- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Abdul Kareem Sab v. Gowlivada S. Silar Saheb
Summary of the Judgment
Factual and Procedural Background
The suit before the court was for partition of a 1759/2880 share of a house in Kurnool which originally belonged to one Hassu Bhai. There was an earlier partition suit, O.S. No. 565 of 1931, among the heirs of Hassu Bhai that resulted in a preliminary decree dated 15-12-1931 declaring the shares of the plaintiff and several defendants; no subsequent steps were taken to effect partition under that decree.
The present plaintiffs claimed title to a fractional share under two sale deeds: Ex.A-1 dated 23-9-1938 and Ex.A-3 dated 20-11-1948, said to be from defendants 2 and 3 in O.S. No. 565/1931. The defendant (the appellant) had earlier purchased the share of the plaintiff and others in O.S. No. 565/1931 under Ex.B-1 dated 23-2-1934 and purchased the share of defendant 4 under Ex.B-5 dated 22-7-1945. Under Ex.B-2 dated 25-6-1937 the municipal registry was transferred in the name of the defendant; subsequently on 11-7-1950 the municipal registry was made in the joint names of the plaintiffs and the defendant.
The present suit was instituted on 20-9-1949.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the plaintiff's partition suit was barred by the prior preliminary decree in O.S. No. 565 of 1931 (i.e., whether the present suit is barred by res judicata / preclusion by the earlier partition proceedings).
- Whether the defendant had acquired exclusive title by adverse possession (specifically by virtue of entry in the municipal register on 25-6-1937 and continuous possession for over 12 years) sufficient to extinguish the plaintiffs' title.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's (Defendant's) Arguments
- The suit was not maintainable in view of the earlier partition decree in O.S. No. 565 of 1931 (i.e., the earlier proceedings precluded the present suit).
- The plaintiffs' title had been extinguished because the defendant had asserted exclusive possession and acquired title by adverse possession for over 12 years from 25-6-1937 when his name was entered in the municipal registers.
Plaintiffs' Contentions
- The plaintiffs claimed title to the relevant fractional share under sale deeds Ex.A-1 (23-9-1938) and Ex.A-3 (20-11-1948) from persons who had been defendants in O.S. No. 565/1931 and sought partition accordingly.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Naha v. Veeran, 1942-1 Mad LJ 219; (AIR 1942 Mad 364) | Illustrates that a final decree in a partition proceeding (with allotment and direction to put parties in possession) could bar a separate suit under S.47 Civil P.C. | The court cited this authority to explain that if a final decree had been passed in the prior partition suit, S.47 Civil P.C. might bar a separate suit; however, because only a preliminary decree existed, that principle did not apply here. |
| Ittappan v. Mana Vikrama, ILR 21 Mad 153 | Support for the principle that possession of a co-sharer is, in law, the possession of other co-owners and that mere occupation does not constitute adverse possession without ouster or notice. | The court relied on this authority as part of its conclusion that the defendant's possession was traceable to lawful title as transferee of a co-sharer and did not constitute adverse possession vis-Ă -vis other co-sharers. |
| Lakshmi Narasamma v. Ramabrahmam, 1950-1 Mad LJ 350; (AIR 1950 Mad 680) | Affirms the principle that exclusive occupation by a co-sharer or non-participation in profits does not, by itself, constitute adverse possession; ouster and notice are required. | The court applied this authority to hold that mere entry in the municipal register and occupation by the defendant did not amount to ouster or hostile possession sufficient to establish adverse possession. |
| Mubarak-un-nisa v. Mohammad Razakhan, ILR 46 All 377; (AIR 1924 All 384) | Application of the co-sharer-possession principle to Mohammadan co-sharers—possession by one co-sharer is not adverse to other co-sharers absent ouster. | The court cited this case to reinforce that the defendant, being a transferee of a co-sharer, could not claim adverse possession against other co-sharers without proof of ouster and notice. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
On the question of res judicata and the effect of the prior partition proceedings, the court found that the decree in O.S. No. 565 of 1931 was a preliminary decree that merely declared the shares of the parties; it did not effectuate partition by metes and bounds or change the character of the property from joint to separate. A partition suit in which only a preliminary decree has been passed remains pending and the rights of parties are to be adjusted at the time of a final decree. Consequently, the court held that purchasers of the interests of some co-sharers (the plaintiffs) were entitled to institute a fresh suit for partition against the purchaser of the remaining interests (the defendant). The court noted that if a final decree had been passed and possession/allotment directed, S.47 Civil P.C. could bar a separate suit, but that was not the situation here (citing Naha v. Veeran).
On the adverse possession contention, the court reasoned that by purchasing only the undivided shares of co-sharers the defendant acquired, under S.44, Transfer of Property Act, the transferor's right to joint possession and enjoyment, and the right to enforce partition. The court emphasized the well-settled principle that the possession of one co-sharer is legally the possession of the other co-owners; absent proof of ouster (a denial of the rights of other co-owners with their knowledge), possession by one co-sharer cannot be pleaded as adverse to the others. Mere non-participation in profits or exclusive occupation is insufficient to establish adverse possession. The court applied these principles and the authorities cited to conclude that the defendant's entry in the municipal register in 1937 and subsequent occupation did not amount to ouster or hostile possession; indeed, the defendant's own subsequent purchases (Ex.B-5) showed he did not regard his possession as hostile.
Based on the above analysis, the court concluded that the appellant's contentions on both grounds (res judicata and adverse possession) had no substance.
Holding and Implications
Appeal dismissed.
Direct effect: The second appeal fails and is dismissed with costs; no leave is granted. The court's order permits the plaintiffs (as purchasers of some co-sharers' interests) to pursue partition notwithstanding the prior preliminary decree, and it rejects the defendant's claim of exclusive title by adverse possession. The opinion does not articulate any broader legal change or novel precedent beyond applying established principles concerning preliminary partition decrees and the position of co-sharers regarding possession.
Judgement
Defendant is the appellant. The suit was for partition of 1759/2880 share of a house in Kurnool which originally belonged to one Hassu Bhai. There was a prior suit for partition, O. S. no. 565 of 1931, among the heirs of Hassu Bhai, which resulted in a preliminary decree dated 15-12-1931 declaring the shares of the plaintiff and the several defendants in that suit. No further steps were taken to work out the rights of the parties as declared by the preliminary decree.
The plaintiffs claim title to a fractional share of the house under two sale deeds, Ex.A-1 dated 23-9-1938 and Ex.A-3 dated 20-11-1948, from defendants 2, 3, in O. S. No. 565/1931. The defendant purchased the share of the plaintiff and 5 to 9 in O. S. No. 565 of 1931 under Ex.B-1 dated 23-2-1934 and the share of defendant 4 in that suit under Ex.B-5 dated 22-7-1945.
Under Ex.B-2 dated 25-6-1937 there was a transfer of the municipal registry in the name of the defendant. Subsequently on 11-7-1950 the municipal registry came to be made in the joint names of the plaintiffs and the defendant:
The defence to the plaintiffs suit for partition was two-fold: (1) that the suit was not maintainable in view of the prior decree for partition in O. S. No. 565 of 1931, and (2) that the title of the plaintiffs had been extinguished by the adverse possession of the defendant for over 12 years from 25-6-1937 when his name was entered in the municipal registers. It might be mentioned that the present suit was instituted on 20-9-1949.
2. There is no substance in the contentions of the appellant. The decree in O. S. No. 565 of 1931 merely declared the shares to which the heirs of Hassu Bhai who were parties to that suit, were entitled. The vendors of the plaintiffs were some of the defendants to that suit. An application made in a partition suit after the passing of a preliminary decree, by which the shares of the parties were defined, in order that the proceedings may be continued for the purpose of actually effecting a partition and that a final decree for partition by metes and bounds may be passed, is not governed by Art. 181, Limitation Act.
A partition suit in which a preliminary decree has been passed is still pending suit and the rights of the parties have to be adjusted at the time of the final decree. If it were necessary, I would treat this suit as an application for the passing of a final decree in O. S. No. 565 of 1931.
At the same time, it cannot be doubted that when a preliminary decree declaring a right to partition or the shares of the parties, has not been given effect to by the parties proceeding to partition in accordance with it and the property continues to be jointly held by the co-sharers, their right to partition continues. So long as they continue to be interested in the joint property as co-sharers, it is competent for them to bring a suit for declaration of their right and for partition in case their right to partition is denied or challenged.
In the present case, even though the plaintiff in O. S. No. 565 of 1931 obtained a preliminary decree declaring his share in the common property, the co-sharers, who were the heirs of Hassu Bhai were content to remain as co-sharers without effecting partition of the house. In these circumstances, it is open to plaintiffs as purchasers of the interest of some of the co-sharers, who were defendants in O. S. No. 565 of 1931, to institute the present suit for partition against the defendant, the purchaser of the interest of the remaining co-sharers.
The preliminary decree in the prior suit for partition was in form and substance, merely a declaratory decree pronouncing that the then plaintiff was entitled to a particular share of the house on a general partition being made. Such a decree did not change the character of the property which continued to be a joint estate till an actual partition by metes and bounds. The parties continued to hold the house as before unaffected by the passing of the decree and in the shares to which they were entitled under the Mohammadan law.
I am therefore of opinion that the present suit is not barred by res judicata. The fact that a defendant in a partition suit is, for some purposes, considered to be in the position of a plaintiff, does not mean that even if the defendant does. not want a partition, he should, at his peril, get a separate allotment of his share in the partition suit on pain of losing his rights as a co-sharer if he does not choose to do so.
It might be that a defendant in a partition suit has the liberty given to him to seek a partition and separate allotment of his share but the law does not oblige him to do so. If there had been a final decree in the prior partition suit allotting certain property for the share of the plaintiffs or their vendors and directing them to be put in possession of the property so allotted, then S. 47. Civil P. C. might bar a separate suit and the remedy of the plaintiffs would be to execute the decree for partition. That is not the position in the present case. See Naha v. Veeran 1942-1 Mad LJ 219 : (AIR 1942 Mad 364) (A).
3. The further contention of the appellant that the defendant had acquired an exclusive title to the house by reason of his adverse possession from 1937 is also untenable. In 1934 the defendant purchased the fractional share of the plaintiff in O. S. No. 565 of 1931. On 25-6-1937 he got his name entered in the municipal registry. By his purchase the defendant acquired the undivided share of his vendor and no more.
Under S. 44, Transfer of Property Act, where-one co-owner transfers his share of immovable-property the transferee acquires, as to such share-and so far as it is necessary to give effect to the transfer, the transferors right to joint possession or other common enjoyment of the property and to enforce partition of the same. The possession of the defendant was traceable to a lawful title derived from his vendor, who was himself a co-sharer.
It is well-settled that the possession of one co-sharer is, in law, the possession of his co-owners and unless there is an ouster, that is to say denial of the rights of the other co-owners over the property to their knowledge, the co-owner in possession cannot plead that this possession was adverse to the other co-owners. Mere non-participation in profits of the common property by one co-sharer or exclusive occupation of the property by the other, is not, by itself, sufficient to constitute an adverse possession.
It must be proved that such exclusive possession was in denial of the title of the other co-owners and the latter had notice thereof, either direct or inferable from notorious acts and circumstances. The mere occupation of common property without more, would be referable to be lawful title possessed by the co-owner to use the common property and would not be regarded as an assertion of a hostile title or of a right to hold it as his own separate property.
The authorities on this subject are numerous and I need only refer to three of them. Ittappan v. Mana Vikrama, ILR 21 Mad 153 (B); Lakshmi Narasamma v. Ramabrahmam 1950-1 Mad LJ 350: (AIR 1950 Mad 680) (C). This principle was applied to the case of Mohammadan co-sharers in Mubarak-un-nisa v. Mohammad Razakhan ILR 46 All 377: (AIR 1924 All 384) (D).
4. In the present case, the defendant himself regarded his possession as not being hostile or adverse to the co-sharers of his vendors as might be seen from Ex.B-5 dated 22-7-1945 under which he took a sate of the share of a co-sharer, one of the heirs who was a defendant to O. S. No. 565 of 1931. The inclusion of the name of the defendant in the Municipal Registry in 1937 did not amount to a ouster of the other co-sharers.
5. For these reasons, I am of the opinion that the second appeal fails and must be dismissed with costs. No leave.
Appeal dismissed.
Alert