Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Municipal Corporation Gwalior v. Kishan Swaroop .

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Sep 16, 1964
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of Opinion — Municipal Corporation Gwalior v. Kishan Swaroop (Bhargava, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Municipal Corporation Gwalior appealed against an order of the Municipal Magistrate (first class), Gwalior, which had acquitted the respondent, Kishan Swaroop, of an offence under Section 7(1) read with Section 16(1) of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act (7 of 1954).

The facts, as recorded in the opinion, are: on 10-5-1960 at about 7 A.M., Shri Radhey Shyam Sharma, Food Inspector of the Municipal Corporation Gwalior, purchased 3/4 seer of milk from the respondent for 36 paise. The milk was divided into three portions and placed into three separate phials: one given to the accused, one sent to the Public Analyst for analysis (sent on 17-5-1960, analysed apparently on 19-5-1960), and one retained for production in Court. The Public Analyst's report indicated milk fat 2.9%, non-fatty solids 7.39%, and "added water" 17.8%.

The Magistrate placed little reliance on the Public Analyst's report and acquitted the respondent. The present appeal challenges that acquittal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the milk should be deemed adulterated within the meaning of Section 2(i) of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act on the basis of the Public Analyst's reported composition (fat, non-fatty solids and added water).
  2. Whether non-compliance with the requirements for addition of preservative under Rule 20 of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Rules (formalin at two drops per ounce) or the directory nature of Rule 19 affects the admissibility or weight of the Public Analyst's report.
  3. Whether the prosecution's delay (including delay in challan and in securing re-analysis under Section 13(2)) prejudiced the accused's statutory right to have a part of the sample sent to the Director of the Central Food Laboratory and thereby affects the evidentiary value of the Public Analyst's report.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The milk should be deemed adulterated under Section 2(i) because its quality and purity were below the prescribed standard and the Public Analyst found added water.
  • The fact that formalin was added in the proportion of one drop per ounce (instead of two drops per ounce required by Rule 20) is not material because (a) Rule 19 (authorising addition of preservative) is directory and not mandatory, and (b) the milk was examined by the Public Analyst only after 8 days, implying the preservative requirement was not fatal to the report's weight when delay is considered.
  • Under Rule 44(b) the respondent could not sell the milk found to contain added water and should therefore be convicted on that ground alone.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The prosecution was launched with inordinate delay (challan delayed until 21-9-1961 and overall delay about 16 months), which deprived the accused of the statutory right under Section 13(2) to have a part of the sample sent to the Director of the Central Food Laboratory for independent testing.
  • Because of the delay and inadequate preservation of the sample (formalin added in only half the quantity required by Rule 20 and no evidence of refrigeration or ice), the Public Analyst's report cannot be given weight, and the accused's right to challenge that report was effectively denied.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Prem Das v. State, AIR 1961 All 590 (Full Bench) Principle that a sample of milk will be deemed adulterated if milk fat or non-fatty solids are less than the prescribed minimum (Appendix F Rule A.11.01.02: buffalo milk min. fat 5.0% and non-fatty solids 9%). The court relied on this authority to show that the reported fat (2.9%) and non-fatty solids (7.39%) were below prescribed minima; had the Public Analyst's report been legally acceptable, conviction would have followed. The decision supports the threshold-based assessment of adulteration.
Dattappa v. Secretary, Municipal Committee, Buldhana, AIR 1951 Nag 191 Delay in analysis and absence of proof about manner/conditions of sending samples detracts from the evidentiary value of the analyst's certificate. The court expressly agreed with this authority and applied it to find that the delayed analysis (analysis performed about a week or more after sampling without proof of preservation) reduced the value of the Public Analyst's certificate.
Bakewell v. Davis, 1894-1 QB 296 Principle guiding the proper scope and reporting obligations of analysts — analysts should give clear findings enabling the court to form its own opinion on adulteration and permissible water content. Cited to support the court's admonition that Public Analysts must state clear, usable data (not vague generalities) so courts can apply the legal test for adulteration; the court used it as part of its general guidance.
Newby v. Sims, 1894-1 QB 478 Same general principle as Bakewell: requirement that analyst's report be sufficiently precise for the court to determine adulteration. Cited for the same purpose of emphasising the need for clear analytical reporting by Public Analysts so that courts can assess permissible water and composition.
Fortune v. Hanson, 1896-1 QB 202 Reinforces the requirement that the analyst's findings must enable the court to determine whether the article was adulterated; relates to proper treatment of added water in milk. Cited as additional authority underscoring that added water must be quantified and that the court must decide whether the sample exceeded permissible water content based on data.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded through multiple analytical steps, applying statutory provisions and rules to the facts recorded.

  1. Nature of Rules 19 and 20: The court distinguished Rule 19 (a general authorisation to add a preservative when taking samples) from Rule 20 (a specific prescription for milk samples requiring formalin at the proportion of 2 drops per ounce). The court held Rule 20's specific requirement could not be treated as satisfied where only one drop per ounce had been added. Because the prescribed quantity under Rule 20 was not complied with, the court found no basis to hold that the preservative was adequate to prevent disintegration or compositional change in the milk sample.
  2. Weight of the Public Analyst's Report: The court emphasised that the report under Section 13(1) could carry weight only if mandatory requirements (including Rule 20) were fulfilled. Given the inadequate preservative and absence of evidence of refrigeration or ice, the court concluded the Public Analyst's certificate could not be relied upon in full.
  3. Specificity of Analyst's Findings: The court criticised the Public Analyst's statement that the sample "contained 17.8 per cent of added water" as improper because the report did not indicate the total quantity of water found or present sufficient data from which added water could be deduced (e.g., only reporting percentages without contextualised calculations). The court considered such a statement of added water to be of no value unless supported by explicit analytical data; however, it held that the figures for milk fat and non-fatty solids in the report could otherwise be acted upon.
  4. Application of Precedent (Prem Das): The court relied on the Full Bench decision in Prem Das v. State to state the legal proposition that milk is to be deemed adulterated if its fats or non-fatty solids fall below prescribed minima. It observed that, on the face of the analyst's figures (fat 2.9%, non-fatty solids 7.39% against prescribed minima for buffalo milk of fat 5.0% and non-fatty solids 9%), the milk's quantity and purity were below the standard.
  5. Prejudice from Delay and Section 13(2) Right: The court placed significant weight on the prosecution's delay in launching proceedings (about 16 months) and noted that Section 13(2) grants the accused the right, after institution of prosecution, to apply for part of the sample to be sent to the Director of the Central Food Laboratory for re-analysis. Because the prosecution's delay deprived the accused of a meaningful opportunity to have the Public Analyst's report tested in the prescribed manner, the report's evidentiary value was diminished. The attempted re-analysis (sample sent to the Director of the Jivajee Industrial Research Laboratory) failed because curd formation precluded analysis; the report from that Directorate on record is dated 18-12-1962.
  6. Delay in Analysis: The court agreed with the principle in Dattappa that analysis performed significantly after sampling, without proof of preservation or conditions of transit, detracts from the certificate's value. The court noted the rapid change in milk composition unless pasteurised or preserved under refrigeration; thus timely analysis or proof of preservation is essential.
  7. Guidance on Analyst's Duties: The court admonished Public Analysts to avoid vague generalities and to present findings clearly and with sufficient data so that courts can form their own opinion about adulteration — citing older English authorities (Bakewell, Newby, Fortune) and Prem Das as supportive of this approach.
  8. Conclusion of Analysis: Balancing the analyst's reported numerical results against the procedural and preservational defects (insufficient formalin, delayed analysis, delayed prosecution preventing statutory re-test), the court concluded that the Public Analyst's report could not be given sufficient weight to overturn the Magistrate's finding of not proven. The court accepted the Magistrate's reasons for rejecting the report and upholding the acquittal.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is dismissed and the order of acquittal passed by the lower court is maintained (Appeal dismissed; acquittal maintained.).

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The respondent's acquittal is affirmed and the appellant's challenge fails.
  • Evidentiary consequence: The opinion underscores that a Public Analyst's certificate will be given weight only when mandatory procedural and preservational requirements (e.g., Rule 20 for milk samples) are complied with and when the accused has not been prejudiced by delay depriving him of his statutory right under Section 13(2) to seek re-analysis.
  • Guidance (non-declaratory): The court urged clarity and precision in analytical reports so that courts can determine adulteration from the data provided. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal doctrine but applies existing statutory rules and precedents to the facts; no new precedent was declared beyond the application of authorities cited.

This summary is limited to the content and reasoning expressly contained in the provided opinion.

Show all summary ...

Bhargava, J.

1. This is an appeal by the Municipal Corporation Gwalior against the order of the Municipal Magistrate, first class, Gwalior, acquitting the respondent Kishan Swaroop of the offence under Section 7(1) read with Section 16(1) of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act (7 of 1954) (hereinafter called the Act).

2. Briefly stated the facts arc that Shri Radhey Shyam Sharma, Food Inspector of the Municipal Corporation Gwalior purchased 3/4 seer of milk from the respondent on 10-5-1960 at about 7 A. M. for 36 paise. The milk purchased was divided into 3 portions and samples were taken in three separate phials. One of the phials was given to the accused, the other was sent to the Public Analyst for analysis on 17-5-60 and the third was preserved for production in Court. The Public Analyst analysed the sample of milk apparently on 19-5-1960. In his opinion the sample contained fat 2.9 per cent non-fatty solids 7.39 per cent and added water 17.8 per cent. It was not challenged that the milk was buffalo milk and under Rule A. 11.01.03 it is to be presumed that where the milk is sold or offered for sale without any indication as to whether it was derived from cow, buffalo, goat or sheep, the standard prescribed for buffalo milk shall apply.

3. The oral evidence in the case is not of much importance. The case for the prosecution mainly hinges on the report of the Public Analyst. The learned Magistrate concluded that it was not established by the prosecution that the said milk was adulterated. He emphasised that the said milk was analysed by the Public Analyst after more than 8 days of the samples being taken, that only one drop of formalin was added per ounce of milk of instead of two drops per ounce as required under Rule 20 of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Rules; that as the preservative added was much below the proportion of 2 drops to one wince of the sample, it could not be held that the preservative had the effect of preserving the sample; that there was no evidence that the sample sent for analysis was kept and sent to the Public Analyst under refrigeration or having been kept under ice; and that the report of the Public Analyst only mentioned the percentage of added water without mentioning the quantity of water detected in the sample. Consequently, no reliance was placed upon the report of the Public Analyst, and the learned Magistrate found that the report of the Public Analyst did not prove the respondent's guilt.

4. The first contention raised by the learned counsel for the appellant is that the milk in question should have been deemed to be adulterated within the meaning of Section 2(i) of the Act because its quality and purity were found to be below the prescribed standard and because in addition it was found to contain added water by the Public Analyst. The learned counsel urged that the mere fact that formalin was added in the proportion of one drop to one ounce of the sample of milk instead of the requisite proportion of two drops to one ounce of the sample was not material, firstly for the reason that the addition of preservative according to Rule 19 of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Rules was merely directory and not mandatory and secondly for the reason that the milk in question was examined by the Public Analyst only after 8 days of the date of the purchase of milk by the Food Inspector.

5. In our opinion, the contentions advanced by the learned counsel cannot be accepted. Rule 19 on which reliance is placed is a general rule authorising any person taking a sample of any food for the purpose of analysis to add a preservative as may be prescribed from time to time to the sample for the purpose of maintaining it in a condition suitable for analysis. Rule 20 is a specific rule for using the preservative in case of sample of any milk (including skimmed and separated milk) cream and gur in liquid or saniliquid form. This rule expressly provides that the liquid commonly known as "formalin", that is to say, a liquid containing about 40 per cent formaldehyde in acquous solution in that proportion of 2 drops to an ounce has to be added. As admittedly the requirement of this rule was not satisfied and the quantity of formalin added to the sample of milk in question was only half of the strength prescribed by Rule 20, in our opinion, there is no basis to hold that the preservative added was adequate to prevent disintegration or damage in composition of the milk. We are also clear in our mind that the report given by the Public Analyst under sub-section (1) of Section 13 of the Act could carry weight only if it was shown that the mandatory requirements of Rule 20 were fulfilled. As that has not been shown in the instant case we are of the view that the finding of the learned Magistrate on this point must be accepted as correct.

6. It was next contended by the learned counsel for the appellant that under Rule 44(b) of the Rules the respondent could not sell the milk in question because it was found to contain added water by the Public Analyst, and he deserved to be convicted of the offence charged on this short ground alone. Again, we are unable to agree. We fully agree with the learned Magistrate that the Public Analyst should not in his report have said that the milk contained quantity of added water. The proper course for him to adopt was to write down the resuit of his analysis and show how much water was contained in the milk. His statement to the effect that the milk contained 17.8 per pent of added water is of no value unless it was indicated as to what was the total quantity of water which was found by him in the milk, or it could be gathered from the contents of fat and non-fatty solids indicated by him that the milk must have been adulterated by the use of water. The certificate, therefore, was, in our opinion, bad in respect of the statement that the milk sample contained 17.8 per cent of added water. But we have no hesitation to say that on the basis of the quantity of the non-fatty solids and milk fat which has been indicated in the report of the Public Analyst could otherwise be acted upon.

7. The view that we are taking finds support from the Full Bench decision of the Allahabad High Court in Prem Das v. State, AIR 1961 All 590. In that Case their Lordships have enunciated the proposition that a sample of milk will be deemed to be adulterated if the milk fats are less than the prescribed minimum or the non-fatty solids are less than the prescribed minimum. In Appendix F Rule A. 11.01.02 it is prescribed that buffalo milk shall contain not less than 5.0 per cent of milk fat and not less than 9 per cent of the milk solids, other than milk fat. In the instant case, milk fat found by the Public Analyst was only 2.9 per cent and non-fatty solids were 7.39 per cent, and thus the quantity and purity of the milk was definitely below the prescribed standard, Thus, if the report of the Public Analyst were legally acceptable we would have not hesitated in convicting the accused, but we are presently going to show that apart from the question of formalin not having been added to in adequate quantity there is another serious hurdle in the way of the prosecution, because this case was challaned with great delay on 21-9-01 and due to this delay the accused-respondent lost his valuable right to challenge the report of the Public Analyst in the manner prescribed by Section 13(2) of the Act.

8. Section 13(2) envisages that after the institution of the prosecution under this Act, the accused vendor or the complainant may on payment of prescribed fee make an application to the Court for sending a part of the sample mentioned in Sub- Clause (1) or Sub-clause (3) of Clause (c) of Sub-section (1) of Section 11 to the Director of the Central Food Laboratory for a certificate and on receipt of the application the Court shall first ascertain that the mark and seal and fastenings as provided in Clause (b) of Sub-section (1) are intact, and may then despatch a part of the sample under its own seal to the Director of the Central Food Laboratory, who shall thereupon send a certificate to the Court in the prescribed form within one month from the date of the receipt of the sample specifying the result of his analysis. In clause (3) of section 13, it is further provided that the certificate issued by the Director of the Central Food Laboratory under Sub-section (2) shall supersede the report given by. the Public Analyst given under Sub-section (1). In the instant case on the request of the accused-respondent the sample bottle produced in Court by the prosecution was sent to the Director Jivajee Industrial Research Laboratory, Gwalior. But as the curd formation in the sample had already taken place the analysis of the same could not be carried out. The report received from the Directorate of the Research Laboratory is dated 18-12-1962 on record. The learned counsel for the respondent has contended, and, in our opinion, rightly that as the prosecution in the present case was launched after a delay of about 16 months the accused was deprived of exercising his valuable right in getting the report of the Public Analyst tested in the manner contemplated by Section 13, and as his valuable right was denied to the accused for no fault of his, but wholly due to the inordinate laches of the prosecution no weight could be given to the report of the Public Analyst.

9. It is significant that under Section 13(2) the accused gets the right to ask for the examination of the sample by the Director of Central Food Laboratory only after the institution of the prosecution. We are surprised that the appellant should have delayed the prosecution of the respondent for such a long time. Adulteration of food is a crime against society and general interests of the public demand that all such prosecutions should be launched with great despatch so that really guilty persons may not escape punishment. But as in the instant case there can be no doubt that the accused has been prejudiced by the delay of the prosecution we have no option, but to give weight to the contention raised on behalf of the respondent.

10. The learned Magistrate has also stressed that examination of the milk sample by the Public Analyst which was done on 19-5-1960 after 9 days of the incident seriously affected the value of the certificate of the Analyst. Almost in similar circumstances it was observed by Mudholkar J. (as he then was) in Dattappa v. Secretary, Municipal Committee, Buldhana, AIR ]951 Nag 191:

"Bearing in mind that the milk was analysed by the analyst a week after absence of proof of manner in which the samples were sent and the conditions in which the milk was when the samples were received by him detracts from the value of the certificate."

We are in respectful agreement with the said observation. It cannot he disputed that the composition of milk undergoes a rapid change unless the milk is either pasturised or unless it is sent under refrigeration. To obviate the possibilities of these changes it is bsolutely necessary to get the samples examined by the Public Analyst at the earliest possible time and if there is some delay it is also necessary for the prosecution to establish that the milk was preserved in the interval under ice or under refrigeration.

11. The learned counsel tor the appellant urged that the learned Magistrate was in error in relying on the decision in AIR 1951 Nag 191, where it was held that when milk was analysed by the Analyst almost a week after the samples were taken the absence of proof of the manner in which the samples were sent and the conditions in which the milk was when the samples were received by him detracted from the value of the certificate. He tried to distinguish the case by saying that in the year 1950 when that case was decided use of formalin as a preservative was not resorted to and, therefore, the point of delay emphasised in that case cannot serve as a proper basis in those cases where formalin was added to the samples. In our opinion, the argument does not help the appellant for the simple reason that the preservative added in the present case was much below the prescribed quantity under Rule 20, and, therefore, cannot be accepted to be sufficient to prevent its disintegration or changes in its composition.

12. Before we part with the case, we consider it fit to observe that it is high time that the Public Analyst should clearly understand the scope of his duties and confine himself to do what lies within the scope of his duty. If there is adulteration in any degree it is not for the Public Analyst to indulge in vague generalities, nor should he be content merely by expressing his opinion. In such cases he should set out his findings with such clearness that the Court may be able upon the data he gives to form its own opinion as to whether, the article was or was not adulterated. This opinion has been expressed in numerous cases (see Bakewell v. Davis, 1894-1 QB 296, Newby v. Sims, 1894-1 QB 478, Fortune v. Hanson, 1896-1 QB 202 and AIR 1961 All 590 (FB)). All these authorities emphasise that it is the function of the Court to determine in accordance with the law what is maximum quantity of water permissible in unadulterated milk and to decide then whether the sample contained more than that quantity or not. The milk in its natural state contains a large quantity of water. Added water in unadulterated milk merely results in a mixture and does not result in producing a compound having characteristics different from those of its ingredients. Adulteration by adding water can properly be judged by correctly noting the quantity of water found in the milk and the quantity of facts and non-fatty solids.

13. In the view that we take little value can be attached to the report of the Public Analyst on which reliance is placed on behalf of the appellant, For the reasons stated above, we, therefore, maintain the order of acquittal passed by the lower Court. The appeal fails and is dismissed.