Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Saraladevi And Others v. Divisional Manager, ...

Supreme Court Of India
Aug 20, 2014
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

On 28-1-2009 the deceased, Vasanthan, suffered fatal injuries when a motor vehicle (Registration No. TN 23 AF 0048) struck the rear of his motorcycle. A criminal case (CC No. 55 of 2009) ended in the driver’s acquittal on 31-5-2010. The dependants—the widow, two daughters and a bed-ridden mother—filed MCOP No. 138 of 2009 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Vellore, seeking ₹45,00,000 under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.

MACT found the driver negligent, fixed the deceased’s annual income at ₹6,09,708, applied a multiplier of 8 and awarded a total of ₹37,33,248 with 7.5 % interest. The insurer, Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Co. Ltd., appealed to the Madras High Court, which re-assessed the evidence, attributed 25 % contributory negligence to the deceased, altered deductions, applied a different methodology, and reduced compensation to ₹15,84,750 with the same rate of interest (judgment dated 12-9-2012).

The claimants appealed to the Supreme Court challenging the reduction.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Madras High Court was justified in holding that the deceased was 25 % contributorily negligent despite the evidence of the eye-witnesses on record.
  2. Whether the High Court erred in adopting a split-multiplier method and in fixing the multiplier contrary to Sarla Verma v. DTC (2009) 6 SCC 121.
  3. Whether the deduction of one-third towards the deceased’s personal expenses, instead of one-fourth, was legally sustainable.
  4. Whether the substantial reduction of compensation from ₹37,33,248 to ₹15,84,750 was warranted in law.
  5. Whether the heads of loss of consortium, loss of estate, and interest were computed in accordance with binding precedent.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • No evidence supported a finding of contributory negligence; the eye-witness testimony exonerated the deceased.
  • The High Court mis-applied Sarla Verma by deducting one-third for personal expenses and by splitting the multiplier.
  • Amounts awarded for consortium, estate, and interest were contrary to decisions in Rajesh v. Rajbir Singh (2013) 9 SCC 54 and MCD v. Uphaar Tragedy Victims Assn. (2011) 14 SCC 481.
  • The drastic reduction in compensation was therefore unjustified and required restoration of the Tribunal’s award.

Respondent Insurance Company’s Arguments

  • Before MACT it contended that the accident was caused by the deceased’s own negligent riding and denied liability.
  • On appeal to the High Court it maintained that the Tribunal’s award was excessive and sought its modification.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sarla Verma v. DTC (2009) 6 SCC 121 Standard multipliers and percentage deductions for personal expenses of deceased earners. Supreme Court held the correct multiplier was 8 (age 58) and deduction should be one-fourth, criticising the High Court for deviating.
Jiju Kuruvila v. Kunjujamma Mohan (2013) 9 SCC 166 Requirement of evidentiary basis before attributing contributory negligence. Court found the High Court’s 25 % contributory negligence finding unsupported and therefore erroneous.
Kerala SRTC v. Susamma Thomas (1994) 2 SCC 176 Adoption of appropriate multiplier method for loss of dependency. Relied upon to reaffirm the Tribunal’s use of multiplier 8.
Rajesh v. Rajbir Singh (2013) 9 SCC 54 Quantum payable for loss of consortium and loss of estate. Used to demonstrate that the High Court awarded inadequate amounts under these heads.
MCD v. Uphaar Tragedy Victims Assn. (2011) 14 SCC 481 Rate of interest on compensation awards (9 % p.a.). Cited to claim higher interest, though the Court ultimately balanced interest against tax deduction considerations.
Trilok Chandra (1996) 4 SCC 362
(referred within Sarla Verma)
Unit method for personal-expense deduction (historical reference). Mentioned in the quoted extract; not directly applied beyond illustrating evolution of standard deductions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court found that the High Court misapplied binding precedent in three principal ways:

  • Contributory Negligence: Citing Jiju Kuruvila, the Court held there was no evidential support for attributing 25 % fault to the deceased; the High Court’s finding was therefore a legal error.
  • Multiplier and Personal-Expense Deduction: Under Sarla Verma and Susamma Thomas, the correct multiplier for a 58-year-old is 8, and with four dependants only one-fourth of income should be deducted. The High Court wrongly applied a split multiplier and one-third deduction.
  • Non-pecuniary Heads and Interest: Referring to Rajesh v. Rajbir Singh and Uphaar Tragedy cases, the Court observed that the High Court awarded amounts below the prevailing standards and maintained an interest rate already lower than 9 %. The Court decided that restoring the Tribunal’s award coupled with 7.5 % interest was fair, noting that the reduced interest rate offset the need for a separate income-tax deduction.

Consequently, the Tribunal’s original computation—loss of dependency ₹36,58,248 plus conventional sums totalling ₹75,000—was reinstated, leading to an aggregate of ₹37,33,248.

Holding and Implications

The Supreme Court set aside the Madras High Court judgment of 12-9-2012 and restored the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal’s award of ₹37,33,248 with interest at 7.5 % per annum from the date of petition until payment.

Immediate effect: The insurer must pay or deposit the restored amount within six weeks, minus sums already deposited, to be apportioned as per the Tribunal’s directions.

Broader implications: The decision re-affirms the benchmarks in Sarla Verma for multiplier selection and personal-expense deductions, underscores the need for concrete evidence before inferring contributory negligence, and signals adherence to earlier rulings on non-pecuniary damages and interest rates without establishing new legal principles.

Show all summary ...

V. Gopala Gowda, J.— This appeal has been filed by the appellants being aggrieved by the judgment dated 12-9-2012 passed in Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Saraladevi (2012) 7 MLJ 410 by the High Court of Madras whereby the High Court reduced the compensation awarded at Rs 37,33,248 by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal and re-determined at Rs 15,84,750.

2. The necessary relevant facts are stated hereunder to appreciate the case of the appellants with a view and to ascertain whether the appellants are entitled for the enhancement of compensation as prayed in this appeal. The deceased met with an accident on 28-1-2009 on account of rash and negligent driving of the motor vehicle bearing Registration No. TN 23 AF 0048, which hit the back side of the deceased's motorcycle. The deceased sustained grievous injuries and succumbed to the same. A post-mortem was conducted on 29-1-2009 and inspection report was filed in CC No. 55 of 2009 before the Court of Judicial Magistrate II, Walajahpet by the Inspector of Police against the driver of the offending vehicle. The prosecution has failed to prove the case against the driver beyond reasonable doubt, therefore, the learned Judicial Magistrate had acquitted the driver of the vehicle from the charge framed against him vide order dated 31-5-2010.

3. The appellants—the widow, two daughters and bed-ridden aged mother of the deceased Vasanthan approached the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Vellore (for short “MACT”) by filing claim petition under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short “the Act”) claiming compensation of Rs 45,00,000 on account of death of their sole breadearner, against the owner as well as the insurer of the vehicle. The said claim petition was registered as MCOP No. 138 of 2009.

4. The Insurance Company filed its counter-statement stating that the accident occurred only due to the negligent riding of the two-wheeler by the deceased Vasanthan and that they are not liable to pay the compensation amount as claimed by the appellants.

5. MACT has conducted an enquiry by giving an opportunity to the parties to adduce evidence in support of their respective claim. Three witnesses (PW 1 to PW 3) were examined on behalf of the appellants and the exhibits were marked as Exts. P-1 to P-15. On behalf of the respondents two witnesses RW 1 and RW 2 were examined and exhibits were marked as Exts. R-1 and R-2. The Tribunal on appreciation of pleadings and legal evidence on record came to the right conclusion and held that the accident occurred due to the negligence of the driver of the offending vehicle. Thereafter, on the basis of legal evidence on record MACT determined the quantum of compensation. For this purpose, the Tribunal has taken the monthly salary of the deceased at Rs 50,809, as per the salary certificate Ext. P-7. Therefore, his annual income was fixed at Rs 6,09,708. The deceased was aged 58 years at the time of the accident and the Tribunal has taken the multiplier as 8. Therefore, the total loss of income of the deceased would be Rs 48,77,664. ¼th of this amount i.e Rs 12,19,416 was deducted towards his personal expenses as his dependents are four in number. Hence, the loss of dependency of the appellants was calculated at Rs 36,58,248. For funeral expenses, a sum of Rs 5000 was awarded. For loss of estate Rs 10,000 and for loss of consortium to the first appellant, a sum of Rs 10,000 was granted. For loss of love and affection, a sum of Rs 50,000 was granted to the appellants. Thus, the Tribunal has assessed the total compensation under different heads as mentioned above and passed an award for a sum of Rs 37,33,248 to the appellants with interest @ 7.5% from the date of petition i.e 8-6-2009 and further directed the Insurance Company to pay the said amount by indemnifying the owner of the vehicle as the same was insured with it.

6. The insurer i.e the Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Co. Ltd. had challenged the correctness of the Award passed by the Tribunal in favour of the appellants by filing an appeal before the High Court of Judicature of Madras seeking for the modification of the compensation awarded in favour of the appellants by the Tribunal contending that the same is excessive, urging various grounds in support of its appeal.

7. The High Court, after examining the facts, evidence and circumstances of the case, has held that as per the judgment in Sarla Verma v. DTC (2009) 6 SCC 121 the correct multiplier between the age group of 56-60 should have been 9 since the deceased was 58 years at the time of his death. Further, the High Court held that if the actual salary of Rs 50,809 is taken into consideration, the annual loss of income of the deceased works out to Rs 6,09,708 and 10% of the amount is liable to be deducted towards income tax deduction. 10% in the sum of Rs 6,09,708 comes to Rs 60,970.80 and the same can be rounded off to Rs 61,000. If so, the balance amount works out to Rs 5,48,708 (Rs 6,09,708 minus Rs 61,000), rounded off to Rs 5,49,000 as the annual income of the deceased. Hence, annual loss of income could be fixed at Rs 5,49,000. For the first two years, the loss of income would be Rs 10,98,000 (Rs 5,49,000 × 2 years). For the balance 7 years, only 50% annual income has to be taken into consideration as notional income, which comes to Rs 19,21,500 (Rs 2,74,500 × 7 years). Therefore, the total loss of income works out to Rs 30,19,500. Further, the High Court was of the opinion that ⅓rd amount is liable to be deducted towards personal expenses of the deceased. If this amount is deducted out of the annual income of the deceased, the balance amount works out to Rs 20,13,000 which amounts to a total loss of dependency (Rs 30,19,500 minus Rs 10,06,500).

8. The High Court further held that there is contributory negligence on the part of the deceased which was assessed at 25% which amount would be Rs 5,03,250. When this amount was deducted out of Rs 20,13,000, the High Court held that the legal heirs of the deceased are entitled to Rs 15,09,750 towards loss of dependency.

9. Thus, the High Court reduced the total compensation and awarded under the following heads:

Loss of dependency Rs 15,09,750 Funeral expenses Rs 5000 Loss of estate Rs 10,000 Loss of consortium Rs 10,000 Loss of love and affection Rs 50,000 Total: Rs 15,84,750

Thus, the High Court while partly allowing the civil miscellaneous appeal of the Insurance Company, directed it to deposit the abovesaid amount with an interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum from the date of the petition, within a period of six weeks before the Tribunal after deducting the amount already deposited.

10. Aggrieved by the impugned judgment and final order dated 12-9-2012 (2012) 7 MLJ 410 passed by the High Court, the appellants filed this appeal before this Court urging various tenable grounds, namely, as to whether the High Court was justified in holding that there is a contributory negligence on the part of the deceased contrary to the evidence of the eyewitness; whether the High Court was justified in fixing the ratio of contributory negligence as 25% on the part of the deceased on the basis of an erroneous finding; whether the High Court was justified in reducing the amount awarded by the Tribunal from Rs 37,33,248 to Rs 15,84,750 and lastly, whether the High Court was justified in deducting ⅓rd amount towards personal expenses of the deceased contrary to the law laid down by this Court in various judgments?

11. In our considered view, the High Court has erred in not considering the principles laid down in Sarla Verma (2009) 6 SCC 121 insofar as deduction of ¼th of the monthly income of the deceased to arrive at the multiplicand and reducing the compensation by adopting the split up multiplier. Further, recording the finding of contributory negligence on the part of the deceased in the absence of evidence on record in this regard rendered the finding erroneous in law and error in law as the same is contrary to the decision of this Court in Jiju Kuruvila v. Kunjujamma Mohan (2013) 9 SCC 166. At the time of death, Vasanthan was 58 years old and was earning a salary of Rs 50,809 per month i.e Rs 6,09,708 annually. By applying the appropriate multiplier of 8 as laid down under Kerala SRTC v. Susamma Thomas (1994) 2 SCC 176, AIR 1994 SC 1631, the loss of dependency comes to Rs 48,77,664.

12. Further, deduction towards personal expenses of the deceased out of the annual income would be ¼th as held by this Court in Sarla Verma (2009) 6 SCC 121, the relevant portion of the judgment reads thus:

“30. Though in some cases the deduction to be made towards personal and living expenses is calculated on the basis of units indicated in Trilok Chandra (1996) 4 SCC 362, the general practice is to apply standardised deductions. Having considered several subsequent decisions of this Court, we are of the view that where the deceased was married, the deduction towards personal and living expenses of the deceased, should be one-third (⅓rd) where the number of dependent family members is 2 to 3, one-fourth (¼th) where the number of dependent family members is 4 to 6, and one-fifth (⅕th) where the number of dependent family members exceeds six.”

The High Court failed to follow the above judgment and committed an error in law in deducting ⅓rd amount towards personal expenses of the deceased. Therefore, as per the above judgment the deduction ought to be ¼th only as correctly calculated by the Tribunal. Thus, after deducting ¼th i.e Rs 12,19,416 towards personal expenses; the loss of dependency would be Rs 36,58,248. Further, we affirm the sum granted by the Tribunal as Rs 5000 for funeral expenses, under the head of loss of estate at Rs 10,000, loss of consortium at Rs 10,000 and Rs 50,000 for loss of love and affection of the deceased.

13. Further, the High Court has erred in not following the decision of Rajesh v. Rajbir Singh (2013) 9 SCC 54 by awarding only Rs 10,000 for loss of consortium, instead of Rs 1,00,000. Towards loss of estate, the High Court awarded Rs 10,000 instead of Rs 1,00,000. Therefore, to this extent there is loss caused to the appellants in not being compensated correctly under different heads such as, loss of consortium, loss of estate, and loss of love and affection. Further, as per MCD v. Uphaar Tragedy Victims Assn. (2011) 14 SCC 481, the appellants are entitled for 9% interest per annum on the compensation awarded from the date of filing of the application till the date of payment. Thus, there will be a difference of 1.5% interest amount payable on the total compensation awarded by both the Tribunal and the High Court as they have awarded at 7.5% interest. Therefore, if the less awarded difference of interest amount @ 1.5% by both the Tribunal and the High Court is taken into consideration on the total compensation awarded in favour of the appellants, it would take care of the amount that was required to be deducted towards income tax out of the gross salary of the deceased for determining the compensation under the heading of loss of dependency.

14. Since the High Court has erred in not correctly awarding compensation under the above heads and having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case, we affirm the award of the Tribunal and the same is restored. Therefore, the determination of compensation under the loss of dependency under other heads as indicated in the following paragraph is perfectly legal and valid as the said compensation is just and reasonable keeping in view the monthly income at Rs 50,809 as per the documentary evidence (Ext. P-7), the salary certificate.

15. In the result, the impugned judgment and order (2012) 7 MLJ 410 of the High Court is liable to be set aside and accordingly set aside and the award of the Tribunal is affirmed. Therefore, the appellants shall be entitled to compensation under the following heads:

Loss of dependency Rs 36,58,248 Funeral expenses Rs 5000 Loss of love and affection Rs 50,000 Loss of estate Rs 10,000 Loss of consortium Rs 10,000 Total: Rs 37,33,248

Thus, the total compensation payable to the appellants/claimants will be Rs 37,33,248 with interest @ 7.5% per annum from the date of filing of the application till the date of payment. The apportionment of the compensation in favour of the appellants is as per the award of the Tribunal.

16. Accordingly, we allow this appeal in the above terms. The respondent Insurance Company shall either pay the compensation by way of demand draft/drafts in favour of the appellants or deposit the same with interest as awarded by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal within six weeks from the date of receipt of the copy of this judgment, after deducting the amount already deposited.