Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mohammed Ibrahim Sahib And Others v. Land Acquisition Officer, Bhimavaram .

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Aug 27, 1957
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — Bhimasankaram, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

These civil revision petitions arise from land acquisition proceedings for a college at Bhimavaram, West Godavari District. Certain appeals arising from a reference made by the Land Acquisition Officer to the Subordinate Court, Narasapur were disposed of on 21 February 1957. In that same judgment the Subordinate Judge also dealt with four interlocutory applications (one unnumbered) presented by persons who had not applied to the Collector for a reference under S.18 of the Land Acquisition Act.

Two civil revision petitions are before the High Court challenging orders of the lower court on interlocutory applications:

  • C.R.P. No. 238 of 1952 — against the order on I.A. No. 896 of 1950 (filed by Mohammad Ibrahim Sahib, who claimed a 2/9ths share in some plots). The petitioner had not sought a reference under S.18; he filed an interlocutory application asking either that the Court enquire as if he had filed objections or that the matter be sent back to the Land Acquisition Officer for fresh disposal.
  • C.R.P. No. 239 of 1952 — against the order on I.A. No. 1074 of 1950 (filed by three petitioners). One petitioner, Mohammad Mahaboob Ali, was not a party to the Collector's award and had separately moved (I.A. No. 1059 of 1950) to be added as a party under Order 1, Rule 10, CPC; both interlocutory applications were dismissed by the lower court.

Petitioners in these revisions fall into two groups: (a) persons who were parties to the Collector's award but did not apply for a reference under S.18, and (b) persons who were not parties to the award and claim they received no notice of the acquisition until court deposit notices were issued. Additional connected applications (e.g., for admission of documents: C.M.P. No. 5100 of 1957; and for impleading petitioners: C.M.P. No. 1418/52) were also dealt with in the judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a person who was a party to the Collector's award but did not apply to the Collector under S.18 can, by intervening in a reference obtained by another person, require the Court to consider or grant enhanced compensation for that person's own share.
  2. Whether a person who was not made a party to the Collector's award and who claims to have received no notice of the award can intervene in a reference obtained by other persons and seek higher compensation in those proceedings.
  3. Whether a document or petition submitted to the Land Acquisition Officer (for example Ex. A-26) can be treated as a valid application under S.18 on behalf of legal representatives of a deceased person, thereby entitling them to intervention in a pending reference.
  4. Whether the Court (invoking S.53 of the Act and Order 1, Rule 10 CPC) can implead persons and grant them reliefs (such as higher compensation) that are not available under the statutory scheme of the Land Acquisition Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • Persons interested in the land who are dissatisfied with the Collector's award may intervene in a reference obtained by another person and raise objections that, if successful, would benefit them — this contention relied on Ss. 19(1)(b), 20(b) and 21 of the Land Acquisition Act and the fact that the statute requires notice to "persons interested".
  • Those who were not present or represented before the Collector claimed that they only became aware of the award when the Court issued notices to take money lying in deposit, and therefore could not reasonably be expected to have sought a reference earlier; they relied on S.18(2)(b) and an interpretation that the six-month period runs from their knowledge of the award.
  • The second petitioner in I.A. No. 1074 argued that petition Ex. A-26 (a representation asking for compensation at a stated rate) should be treated as an application for a reference on behalf of legal representatives of a deceased co-sharer (Abdul Khadar), and thus the Collector should be deemed to have erroneously declined to make a reference.
  • Relying on S.53 of the Act (incorporation of CPC provisions), petitioners argued that the Court had power under Order 1, Rule 10 CPC to add persons and grant them enhanced compensation in the reference proceedings.

The opinion does not contain a detailed, separately-labelled exposition of the respondents' or the Collector's arguments; the court's counter-analysis and reasoning are recorded in the judgment itself.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Narayana v. Annapurnamma, ILR 1941 Mad 753 (AIR 1941 Mad 660) The Court has no jurisdiction to grant enhanced compensation in respect of a person who made no objection and obtained no reference under S.18; the court can only deal with the objection referred to it. The court relied on this authority to support its conclusion that co-owners who did not apply under S.18 cannot raise fresh objections in a reference obtained by another and obtain enhanced compensation.
Abu Bakar v. Peary Mohan Mokerjee, ILR 34 Cal 451 A party who raises no objection to the apportionment of compensation by the Collector must be taken to have accepted the award; under Ss. 18, 20 and 21 the Court is confined to the objection referred to it. Quoted within Narayana and relied upon by the court as an established authority for the limitation of the court's jurisdiction to matters actually referred under S.18.
Pramathanath Mallik v. Secretary of State, ILR 57 Cal 1148; AIR 1930 PC 64 The Privy Council: the jurisdiction of the courts under the Land Acquisition Act is a special one and is strictly limited to specific objections referred to the Court. The court cited this to underscore that the statutory jurisdiction is narrow and arises only when a specific objection has been taken to the Collector's award.
Seshachelam v. District Collector, Guntur, 1955-1 Andh WR 912 (AIR 1957 Andh Pra 687) Interprets "within six months from the date of the Collector's award" (S.18) as meaning within six months from the date of the would-be applicant's knowledge of the passing of the award. The court noted this decision (without finally deciding its correctness) to show that persons who claim they only later became aware of the award could, on that view, have sought a reference within six months of their knowledge; the view was used to show that non-parties had potential remedies under S.18.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeds from a textual reading of S.18–S.21 of the Land Acquisition Act. The court begins by identifying the statutory trigger for the special jurisdiction of the court: an application in writing by a person interested to the Collector asking that the matter be referred (S.18). A mandatory time limit for making such application is established by S.18(2).

The court examined the meaning and function of S.19 and S.20. S.19 requires the Collector, when making a reference, to give the Court certain particulars, including the names of persons he thinks interested; that statement is "for the information of the Court" so it may issue notices under S.20. S.20 directs the Court to serve notice on the applicant and on "persons interested in the objection." The Court read these provisions together and concluded that the statutory notice requirement is directed to persons who are interested in the specific objection referred, not to every person who generally desires a greater award.

On that basis the court rejected the petitioners' contention that any person interested in the land may intervene in a reference obtained by another and press for higher compensation for his own share. The court reasoned that:

  • The statute contemplates an application and fixes a time limit; failure to apply within that time results in the loss of the statutory right to question the award by reference under S.18.
  • The reference statement furnished by the Collector lists persons "whom the Collector has reason to think interested" to enable the Court to choose who should be served with notice in relation to the particular objection. This does not mean that all persons who would like higher compensation get to institute new grievances in the reference.
  • The phrase "persons interested in the objection" primarily covers those likely to be adversely affected by the success of the specific objection (for example, a person whose apportionment is challenged), not all co-owners generally.
  • A person who accepted the Collector's award cannot afterwards ask the Court to alter it simply because another applicant obtained a reference; only those who have not accepted the award and who have asked for a reference under S.18 can press their objections in that forum.

The court applied these principles to both groups of petitioners:

  • Persons who were parties to the award but did not make an S.18 application: the court held they could not have the award altered in their favour in a reference obtained by another.
  • Persons who were not parties to the award and claim they received no notice: the court held they stood on no better footing. S.18 permits an application whether or not the person was present or represented, and, on the authority cited (Seshachelam), the six-month period may be measured from knowledge of the award. If a person truly had no notice, their remedy exists outside the reference procedure (e.g., by suit in a civil court or by seeking relief under Art. 226). But they cannot intervene in a reference obtained by others to ventilate their own fresh objections.

On the special submission that Ex. A-26 (a representation to the Land Acquisition Officer asking a higher rate) was a valid S.18 application on behalf of legal representatives of a deceased co-sharer, the court found that Ex. A-26 only sought a particular rate of compensation and did not request a reference to the Court. The award was dated 8-1-1950 while Ex. A-26 was dated 23-9-1948; in any event the document could not be treated as an S.18 application. If the Collector had neglected a statutory duty to refer, the correct remedy would be to seek mandamus to compel the Collector — the Court seized of a reference cannot itself treat a non-existent reference as though it had been made.

Finally, the court addressed the contention based on S.53 (application of CPC provisions) and Order 1, Rule 10 CPC. While the court accepted that courts can, in proper cases, exercise joinder powers under O.1, R.10 CPC, it held that such procedural powers do not permit the Court to grant substantive reliefs (such as enhanced compensation) that the Land Acquisition Act does not empower the Court to grant in the absence of a proper S.18 reference.

Holding and Implications

Core Holding: The civil revision petitions fail. The Court held that persons who did not apply to the Collector under S.18 cannot, by intervening in another person's reference, obtain review or enhancement of the Collector's award in respect of their own shares. Persons who were not parties to the award and claim lack of notice likewise cannot intervene in a reference obtained by others to litigate new objections in that forum; their remedies lie elsewhere or by seeking a reference timely under S.18.

Disposition: DISMISSED — The civil revision petitions are dismissed with costs. Advocates' fee assessed at Rs. 75 in each case. The connected application for admission of additional documents (C.M.P. No. 5100 of 1957) was dismissed as unnecessary in view of the dismissal of C.R.P. No. 238 of 1952. The petition to dispense with printing of those documents required no order. C.M.P. No. 1418 of 1952 (to implead petitioners in the unnumbered interlocutory application) was dismissed for the reasons given.

Consequences / Implications:

  • The judgment enforces the statutory scheme under Ss. 18–21: the court's special jurisdiction arises only upon a proper S.18 referral and is limited to objections so referred.
  • Persons who have accepted the Collector's award and did not apply under S.18 cannot obtain alteration of their apportionment or enhanced compensation by intervening in a reference obtained by others.
  • Non-parties who claim lack of notice may have remedies outside the reference (suit or constitutional remedy) or could have sought a reference under S.18 within the period allowed (as interpreted in cited authority), but they cannot intervene in another person's reference to raise distinct grievances.
  • The Court will not use procedural joinder powers under CPC to grant substantive reliefs that the Land Acquisition Act does not permit in the absence of a valid reference under S.18.

No novel legal principle was laid down by this judgment; the court relied on established authorities and applied them to the facts to determine the limits of the special jurisdiction created by the Land Acquisition Act.


End of summary. This HTML document is prepared strictly on the basis of the provided text of the judgment and does not introduce facts or inferences beyond that text.

Show all summary ...

Judgement

BHIMASANKARAM, J. :-

These civil revision petitions arise out of proceedings for the acquisition of some plots of land for the use of a college in Bhimavaram, West Godavari District. We disposed of on the 21st of February, 1957 certain appeals arising out of a reference made to the Sub-Court, Narasepur by the Land Acquisition Officer concerned with that acquisition. In the same judgment whereby he disposed of the reference, the learned Subordinate Judge also dealt with four interlocutory applications, one of them unnumbered, presented by certain persons who had not sought a reference from the Collector to the Court under S. 18 of the Land Acquisition Act.

The two civil revision petitions now before us are directed against the orders of the lower court on two of these interlocutory applications. C. R. P. No. 238 of 1952 is against the order in I. A. No. 896 of 1950 and C. R. P. No. 239 of 1952 is against the order in I. A. No. 1074 of 1950. Both these interlocutory applications purported to be made in O. P. No. 4 of 1950 which was how the reference above mentioned was registered and numbered.

In C. R. P. No. 238 of 1952 the petitioner has also filed an application for the admission of some documents as additional evidence C. M. P. No. 5100 of 1957. This and the connected petition (to dispense with the printing of documents sought to be admitted as additional evidence) will be dealt with towards the end of this judgment.

2. I. A. No. 896 of 1950 was filed by one Mohammad Ibrahim Sahib who claims a 2/9ths share in certain of the plots acquired. He is the brother of Mohammad Osman Saheb the claimant in I. A. No. 888 of 1950. I A No. 888 of 1950 was one of the several petitions filed by the claimants for enhanced compensation.

Osman Sahebs claim also was referred to the court. The 1st petitioner in Civil Revision Petition No. 238 of 1952 before us however did not seek and obtain a reference to the court of his claim for higher compensation. When the reference was pending before the Sub-Court, Narasapur, he filed I. A. No. 896 of 1950 and his prayer in that petition was in these terms:

"................... that the matter may be enquired into as (if) this petitioner had filed objections or the matter may be sent back to the Land Acquisition Officer for fresh disposal if necessary"
.

3. These alternative prayers were based upon the following allegations : He did not receive a notice either under S. 9 or S. 12 of the Land Acquisition Act and became aware for the first time of the acquisition proceedings only

"after the receipt of a notice from this Honble Court to take the money lying in deposit after producing the necessary record of title."

According to him as the matter was pending before the Court by the application put in by his brother, a co-owner with the petitioner and as he was a person interested in the objections filed by his brother, the Court was competent under the circumstances to grant either of the prayers. The other petitioners in the Civil Revision Petition who were four in number are the sisters of the petitioner and his brother Osman Saheb and each lays claim to a ninth share in the same items.

In the lower court they were the petitioners in the unnumbered interlocutory application and they have now joined their brother Ibrahim Saheb in the above Civil Revision Petition. In the unnumbered petition they prayed for a relief similar to that asked for by their brother Ibrahim Saheb in I. A. No. 896 of 1950. As they were not parties to the award, objection was taken by the office in the lower Court to registering their application as an interlocutory application in the original petition and it was returned.

But they represented the application with a prayer that it may be heard along with the connected petitions. Now in this court they have filed C. M. P. 1418/52 to add them as petitioners in C. R. P. No. 238 of 1952.

4The facts leading up to Civil Revision Petition No. 239 of 1952 may also be briefly stated. It is directed as already noticed against the order of the lower court on I. A. No. 1074 of 1950. That was filed by three petitioners. The second of those petitioners Mohammad Mahaboob Ali was not a party to the award and he also filed a separate application which was numbered as I. A. No. 1059 of 1950 to add him as a party to the award under O. 1, R. 10, C. P. C. Both the applications were dismissed by the lower court.

There is no separate civil revision petition before us against the order on I. A. No. 1059 of 1950 although the grounds which were urged in support of I. A. No. 1059 of 1950 by the petitioner in that petition have also been urged before us in this civil revision petition.

5The above narrative discloses that the petitioners in the civil revision petitions fall into two groups - those who were parties to the award made by the Land Acquisition Officer and those who were not. Both the groups nevertheless claim that they are entitled under the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act to have their claim for higher compensation considered by the Court seized of the reference made by the Land Acquisition Officer at the instance of their co-owners.

In the case of the second petitioner in I. A. No. 1074 of 1950, another special argument is raised in support of his right to intervene in the proceedings and ask for higher compensation which will be separately considered.

6. We shall first deal with the case of persons who were parties to the award but nevertheless made no application to the Collector seeking a reference to Court. In order to appreciate the argument of the learned counsel for the petitioners, it is necessary to read Ss. 18, 19, 20 and 21 (omitting some immaterial portions in S. 19) which run as follows):

"18. (1) Any person interested who has not accepted the award may, by written application to the Collector, require that the matter may be referred by the Collector for the determination of the Court, whether his objection to the measurement of the land, the amount of the compensation, the persons to whom it is payable, or the apportionment of the compensation among the persons interested.

"(2) The application shall state the grounds on which objections to the award is taken:

Provided that every such application shall be made,-

(a) if the person making it was present or represented before the Collector at the time when he made his award, within six weeks from the date of the Collectors award;

(b) In other case, within six weeks of the receipt of the notice from the Collector under S. 12, sub-s. (2), or within six months from the date of the Collectors award, whichever period shall first expire.

19. (1) In making the reference, the Collector shall state for the information of the Court, in writing under his hand-

(a) *** ***

(b) the names of the persons whom he has reason to think interested in such land;

(c) the amount awarded for damages and paid or tendered under Ss. 5 and 17, or either of them, and the amount of compensation awarded under S. II; and

(d) *** ***

(2) To the said statement shall be attached a schedule giving the particulars of the notices served upon, and of the statements in writing made or delivered by the parties interested respectively.

20. The Court shall thereupon cause a notice specifying the day on which the Court will proceed to determine the objection, and directing their appearance before the court on that day, to be served on the following persons, namely:-

(a) the applicant;

(b) all persons interested in the objection, except such (if any) of them as have consented without protest to receive payment of the compensation awarded; and

(c) if the objection is in regard to the area of the land or to the amount of the compensation, the Collector.

21. The scope of the inquiry in every such proceeding shall be restricted to a consideration of the interests of the persons affected by the objection."

7A plain reading of these sections shows that a special jurisdiction is conferred upon the Court by these Sections and it arises out of an application made to the Collector by any person interested who has not accepted the award made by that officer. There can be no reference except at the instance of such a person unless it be a reference of a dispute under S. 30 of the Act with which we are not now concerned.

The argument for the petitioners however is that any person interested in such land who is not satisfied with the award may intervene in a reference obtained by some other person and may raise an objection to the award, the success of which would benefit him. This argument is based upon the language of Ss. 19 (1) (b), 20 (b) and 21 of the Act.

It is argued that the Statute directs notice to be given to persons interested in such land and that the object of the provision is to enable them to participate in those proceedings and assert their own claims if they are so inclined. The argument is sought to be reinforced by the provision as to notice under S. 20 to "all persons interested in the objection" and by the reference in S. 21 to "a consideration of the interests of the persons affected by" such objection.

We are unable to accede to this contention. In the first place, it is to be noticed that there is a provision for an application to be made and a time limited for its presentation. A person not making the application within the time limited is to be deemed to have lost the right to question the award. In the second place, the Collector is to state the particulars mentioned in S. 19 "for the information of the Court", i. e., the names of the persons "whom the Collector has reason to think interested in such land" are given in order to enable the Court to issue the notice prescribed by S. 20.

It will choose from among them the persons to whom notice is to be served having regard to the nature of the objection. It is conceivable that there may be persons interested in such land but not interested in the objection raised by the applicant. If, for instance, there are several owners of the melwaram in the land and the objection relates only to apportionment of the compensation among them, then notice need not go to the owner or the owners of the kudiwaram.

The latter are persons interested in the land but not interested in the objection. The "persons interested in the objection" would therefore seem to cover primarily persons who are likely to be adversely affected by the success of the objection. For instance, when the objection is in regard to the area of the land or the amount of the compensation, the Collector would be interested, because it might, in either case, involve enhancement of the amount awarded by him.

The phrase "interested in the objection" does not therefore appear to us to cover "persons interested in the success of the objection". Even if it does, it cannot cover the case of persons who could have made a similar objection on their own behalf. Where a person claims a higher compensation for the land of which he is a co-owner, he may claim it either for his own share or for the whole of the land. A manager of the joint family may make such a claim on behalf of the joint family of which he is the manager.

A partner of a firm may make it on its behalf. But where the owner of a specific share claims a higher compensation for his own share, the owner of another share cannot be said to be interested in the objection raised by the applicant to the amount of compensation awarded in respect of the applicants share.

8.Now in the light of the foregoing discussion, it seems to us that S. 21 has not the effect of enlarging the scope of the enquiry to "a consideration of the interests of" all possible persons who would like higher compensation to be awarded to them. Any co-owner who has not filed an application under S. 18 cannot, in the circumstances, be described as a person who has not accepted the award and a person who has accepted the award cannot ask for its alteration though at the instance of any person who has not accepted it he may be brought before the court for the proper determination of all the objections raised by the applicant.

If a person is apportioned by the Collector a specific amount of the compensation awarded and the applicant before the Collector questions that apportionment as too high then the former is a necessary party to the proceedings before the Court because no order can be passed in favour of the applicant without having before the court the party who is likely to be affected by the success of the objection.

9.In our view, therefore, the mere fact that a person is brought before the Court as a non-applicant party does not entitle him to ventilate his own grievances against the award when he himself has not filed an application to the Collector for a reference under S. 18 of the Act.

10. A similar view of the effect of these sections is to be found expressed in the decision in Narayana v. Annapurnamma, ILR 1941 Mad 753 : (AIR 1941 Mad 660) (A), and the decisions referred to therein. In that case, the appellant who was the owner of the kudiwaram in the land acquired was awarded a much higher amount than was awarded to the melwaramdar. The melwaramdar herself did not seek a reference under S. 18.

But on a reference made at the instance of the kudiwaramdar, the court below awarded an enhanced amount to her. The learned Judges pointed out that the Court had no jurisdiction to do so when she had made no objection to the award and had not asked for and obtained areference to the court. In the course of their judgment, they made the following observations:

"The point appears to us to admit of no doubt. It was decided so long ago as 1907 in Abu Bakar v. Peary Mohan Mokerjee, ILR 34 Cal 451 (B) that (i) a party who raises no objection to the apportionment of the compensation made by the Collector must be taken to have accepted the award in that respect and (ii) that under Ss. 18, 20 and 21 of the Act all that the Court can deal with is the objection which has been referred to it, and it cannot go into a question raised for the first time by a party who had not referred any question or any objection to it under S. 18 of the Act."

11. Reference may also be made to the decision of the Privy Council in Pramathanath Mallik v. Secretary of State, ILR 57 Cal 1148 at P. 1152 : (AIR 1930 PC 64 at p. 65) (C), in which their Lordships observed as follows:

"Their Lordships have no doubt that the jurisdiction of the Courts under this Act is aspecial one and is strictly limited by the terms of these Sections. It only arises when a specific objection has been taken to the Collectors award, and it is confined to a consideration of that objection."

12. The learned counsel for the petitioners has referred us also to the definition of the expression "person interested" in S. 3 (b) of the Act which is as follows:

"3. (b) the expression person interested includes all persons claiming an interest in compensation to be made on account of the acquisition of land under this Act, and a person shall be deemed to be interested in land if he is interested in an easement affecting the land."

13. But this definition does not throw any light upon the present discussion because we are not dealing with the expression "person interested" as such. Nor are we concerned with the content of the phrase "person interested in such land."

14. The foregoing discussion therefore leads to the conclusion that so far as the present petitioners who were parties to the award are concerned, they cannot ask the court to grant a higher amount of compensation in respect of their share of the land than the Collector had given them.

15. We shall now deal With the petitioners who were not parties to the award who claim to have received no notice of the acquisition proceedings until they were served with notice by the court to receive their share of the compensation, presumably after a deposit made by the Collector under S. 31 of the Act.

It appears to us that the position of this group stands on no better footing than that of the first group. The courts jurisdiction under the above sections depends, as we have already stated, upon a reference to be made by the Collector. It makes no difference to the jurisdiction of the court to entertain an objection that the person raising the objection could not have asked for a reference by the Collector on the ground that he had no notice of the award.

Section 18 provides for a reference being asked by any person interested whether he was present or represented before the Collector or not. Even a person not present or represented before the Collector and therefore not in receipt of the notice from the Collector under S. 12 (2) might ask for a reference under Cl. (b) of sub-s. (2) of S. 18 within six months from the date of the Collectors order.

It has been held by a learned Judge of this Court in Seshachelam v District Collector Guntur, 1955-1 Andh WR 912 : (AIR 1957 Andh Pra 687) (D), that the words "within six months from the date of the Collectors award mean within six months from the date of the would-be applicants knowledge of the passing of the award. If that view is right and we are not called upon in this case to decide its correctness - then these petitioners could have asked the Collector for a reference under S. 18 within six months of their having come to know of the award.

If, again, they had no notice of the land I acquisition proceedings at all from the beginning to the end, that is to say, if their lands had been taken and the amount of compensation determined without reference to them, then all the proceedings so taken without the knowledge of the persons interested would be ineffective against them and they may seek their remedy in the ordinary courts of law. They might obtain redress by instituting a suit in a Civil Court or by praying in aid the powers of this court under Art 226 of the Constitution. They cannot intervene in proceedings pending before a Conn on a reference obtained by other persons interested.

16. We shall now deal with a special argument on behalf of the second petitioner in I. A. No. 1074 of 1950. He claims to be interested as a co-sharer in a total extent of 51 cents of land - 47 cents bearing R. S No. 447/ 9 and 4 cents bearing R. S. No 447/10. This property originally belonged to one Md. Ismail Saheb and after his death, at a division of his properties among his heirs, these two items fell to the share of one of them Abdul Khadar by name who died a minor and without issues in 1949.

The three petitioners in the interlocutory application are the mother and two of the brothers, who had purchased share of the other brother also. It appears that the second petitioner on behalf of all of them filed a petition marked as Ex. A-26.before the Land Acquisition Officer which runs as follows.

"Our house site situate within the area of the college has been asked for the purpose of the college. We have no sites elsewhere. The site for purchase elsewhere costs Rs. 300/- per cent. We therefore pray that our difficulties may be appreciated."

17. It is argued that this petition should be treated as an application for a reference made by the 2nd petitioner on behalf of all the petitioners in their right as legal representatives of Abdul Khadar Saheb who was a party to the award, that the Collector must be deemed to have erroneously declined to make the reference and that in the circumstances the Court may allow the petitioners to intervene in the proceedings. There are insurmountable objections to the course suggested. In the first place Ex. A-26 cannot be treated as an application for a reference.

All that it can, at the most, be said to seek is the grant of compensation at the rate of Rs. 300/- per cent. The request for this relief is addressed to the Land Acquisition Officer, and is presumably designed to induce him to grant that amount in his award. There is no request for a reference of the award to the Court. The award Ex. B-34 it may be noticed is dated 8-1-1950 while this petition Ex. A-26 is dated 23-9-1948.

It cannot therefore be treated as an application by a person not accepting the award. Even otherwise, assuming that the Collector did not make a reference under S. 18 of the Act in contravention of his statutory duty, then the proper remedy would be to seek a mandamus for the enforcement of that statutory obligation. The civil court seized of the matter under S. 18, as already stated, is a court with a special jurisdiction and cannot direct a reference to itself, nor proceed on the footing that a reference has been made when it ought to have been made but was not. There is no substance therefore in this contention urged on behalf of the second petitioner in C. R. P. No. 239 of 1952.

18. The learned counsel for the petitioners has also argued that as under S. 53 of the Act the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure apply to all proceedings before the Court under this Act, the Court has power to implead parties to the Land Acquisition Proceedings before it under O. 1. R. 10, C. P. C. It is therefore urged that the Court may add persons interested and award a higher compensation to them.

We have no doubt that in a proper case and for certain purposes the powers vested in a court under O. 1, R. 10, C. P. C, could be exercised, but that does not. in our opinion, enable the court to add parties to grant them reliefs which the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act do not enable it to grant.

19. In the result, the civil revision petitions fail and are dismissed with costs. Advocates fee Rs. 75/- in each case.

20. In view of the dismissal of C. R. P. No. 238 of 1952. it is unnecessary to go into the merits of the claim, to substantiate which the additional documents are sought to be filed in this revision petition. C. M. P No. 5100 of 1957 is therefore dismissed. The other petition is a mere formal petition to dispense with the printing of documents sought to be admitted as additional evidence and no orders are necessary thereon.

There is also C. M. P. No. 1418 of 1952 filed to implead the petitioners in the unnumbered Interlocutory application as parties to C. R. P. No. 238 of 1952. For the reasons already given, they cannot be impleaded for the purpose for which they seek to be impleaded. This petition is dismissed.

Petition dismissed.