Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Jaswinder Singh And Another v. Santokh Nursing Home And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Jan 16, 2012
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Appellants filed a complaint before the State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Chandigarh, alleging medical negligence by Santokh Nursing Home (Respondent 1), Dr Kuldip Singh (Respondent 2) and Dr Rashmi Jain (Respondent 3). Smt Ravinder Kaur, wife of Appellant 1, underwent surgery for removal of a uterine fibroid and total hysterectomy on 8-6-2004. Two surgical mops were inadvertently left inside her abdomen, leading to further procedures, septicaemia, and ultimately her death after prolonged treatment in other hospitals. The appellants sought compensation of ₹50,00,000.

The State Commission held Respondent 3 grossly negligent and found Respondents 1 and 2 vicariously liable, awarding ₹12,34,414.50 with 6% interest and ₹10,000 costs. On appeal, the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission concurred on negligence but reduced compensation to ₹8,00,000, reasoning that the deceased, being a homemaker, had no proven income. The present Supreme Court matter arises from the appellants’ challenge to that reduction.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the National Commission erred in reducing the compensation awarded by the State Commission from ₹12,34,414.50 to ₹8,00,000.
  2. Whether the absence of a proved monetary income for a homemaker justifies lowering compensation for loss of her services to dependants.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • The National Commission gave no cogent reasons for reducing compensation by ₹4,34,414.50.
  • Personal perceptions about the economic value of a housewife’s services cannot justify diminution of damages.

Respondent 3’s Arguments

  • Reduction was proper because appellants produced no evidence of the deceased’s gainful employment.
  • The State Commission wrongly applied a multiplier of 13 given the deceased’s age of 50 years.

Respondents 1 and 2’s Arguments

  • The nursing home’s insurer (Respondent 4) has already paid ₹5,00,000.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Martin F. D'Souza v. Mohd. Ishfaq, (2009) 3 SCC 1 Affirms liability for medical negligence where foreign objects are left inside patient after surgery. Referenced by the National Commission (and noted by the Supreme Court) to support the finding that Respondent 3 was negligent in leaving mops inside the patient.
Arun Kumar Agrawal v. National Insurance Co. Ltd., (2010) 9 SCC 218 Recognises the economic value of gratuitous services rendered by a homemaker and permits compensation to dependants for their loss. Supreme Court applied this ratio to hold that the National Commission erred in undervaluing the deceased homemaker’s services, thereby unjustifiably reducing compensation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court observed that the National Commission’s reduction was premised solely on the deceased being a homemaker, without considering established legal recognition of the economic value of such services. Relying on Arun Kumar Agrawal, the Court emphasised that household work and care provided by a wife/mother are invaluable and that monetary compensation must reflect this loss to dependants.

The Court noted that the National Commission accepted the finding of gross negligence against Respondent 3 yet assumed, without supporting analysis, that the State Commission’s compensation was excessive. Such assumption, the Supreme Court held, constituted a “serious error”. Consequently, it reinstated the original award, affirming that homemakers’ contributions warrant adequate pecuniary assessment just like remunerative employment.

Holding and Implications

Appeals ALLOWED; National Commission’s order set aside; State Commission’s award of ₹12,34,414.50 with 6% interest restored.

Respondents 1 and 2 must pay the balance compensation with interest within three months. The decision reinforces the principle that courts must account for the economic value of homemakers’ services when calculating compensation and cautions lower fora against arbitrary reductions lacking substantive reasoning. It does not create new precedent but applies and affirms existing Supreme Court jurisprudence on valuing non-monetary domestic contributions.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. Leave granted. The appellants are aggrieved by the order First Appeal No. 506 of 2005 of the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (for short “the National Commission”) whereby the appeals filed by Respondents 1, 2, 3 and the insurance company were partly allowed and the compensation awarded by the State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Union Territory, Chandigarh (for short “the State Commission”) was reduced from Rs 12,34,414.50 to Rs 8,00,000.

2. The appellants filed a complaint under Section 17 of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 alleging medical negligence and deficiency in service on the part of the respondents resulting in the death of Smt Ravinder Kaur (wife of Appellant 1). They pleaded that Smt Ravinder Kaur was admitted in Santokh Nursing Home (Respondent 1) on 8-6-2004 for removal of fibroid from her uterus as well as for total hysterectomy; that she was operated upon by Dr Rashmi Jain (Respondent 3) and was discharged from the nursing home on 13-6-2004; that on a subsequent visit to the nursing home, ultrasound was done on her abdomen and it was discovered that two mops/gauges measuring 13½″ × 9½″ were left in her abdominal cavity. Thereupon, Dr Kuldip Singh (Respondent 2) performed a colostomy in the intestine. On 6-9-2004 Smt Ravinder Kaur was admitted in PGI, Chandigarh for removal of mops/gauges. On 13-10-2004 she was admitted in Fortis Heart Care and Multispecialty Hospital, Mohali and after one month she died due to septicaemia inside her abdomen. The appellants claimed total compensation of Rs 50,00,000.

3. The respondents contested the complaint and denied the allegation of medical negligence.

4. After considering the pleadings of the parties and evidence produced by them, the State Commission concluded that Respondent 3 was guilty of gross negligence and she was liable to compensate the appellants. Respondents 1 and 2 were also held vicariously liable. Accordingly, the complaint filed by the appellants was allowed and Respondents 1, 2, 3 and the insurance company were directed to pay compensation of Rs 12,34,414.50 with interest @ 6% per annum from the date of filing the complaint till actual payment and cost of Rs 10,000.

5. Respondents 1 and 2 as also Respondent 3 and the insurance company appealed against the order of the State Commission. The National Commission concurred with the State Commission that Respondent 3 was guilty of medical negligence. This is evident from para 10 of the impugned order First Appeal No. 506 of 2005, which is extracted below:

“On consideration of the respective pleas and the wavering stand taken by Dr Rashmi Jain at different stages of the complaint, we must conclude that Dr Rashmi Jain has not denied the factum of pieces of swabs/mop having been left inside the abdomen of the deceased at the time of surgical procedure conducted on the patient for removal of the uterine fibroid. Even otherwise there is ample material, in the form of ultrasound report and the subsequent treatment/surgical procedure the patient underwent to show that a foreign body, like a mop was left inside the abdomen of the deceased at the time of surgery conducted by Dr Rashmi Jain. It is true that in such a surgical procedure, the surgeon is assisted by other doctor and paramedical staff like nurses, etc. who also owe a duty to count the mops used during the surgical procedure to ensure that all the mops/swabs so used had been retrieved before the operated organ is sutured. However, the surgeon cannot abjure of his/her overall responsibility even in that behalf and cannot be allowed to take the plea that it was not his/her concern to ensure that no mop/swab was left in the abdomen. The pieces of mop/swab left inside the abdomen of the patient had led to infection and septicaemia which ultimately led to her death despite the best possible treatment the patient could be given in other upgraded hospital. The State Commission was, therefore, fully justified in holding the nursing home as well as Dr Rashmi Jain guilty of negligence and deficiency in service in giving the medical treatment to the deceased. The said finding is based on correct appreciation of evidence and material placed on record and calls for no interference from this Commission. This finding also finds some support from the recent judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Martin F. D'Souza v. Mohd. Ishfaq (2009) 3 SCC 1, (2009) 1 CPJ 32.”

6. The National Commission then considered the question whether the compensation awarded by the State Commission was excessive, took cognizance of the assertion made before it that the deceased was not generating any income by practising any occupation for gain and she was merely a homemaker and reduced the amount of compensation to Rs 8,00,000.

7. Shri Himanshu Gupta, learned counsel for the appellants argued that the impugned order First Appeal No. 506 of 2005 is liable to be set aside because the National Commission has not assigned cogent reasons for reducing the amount of compensation by Rs 4,34,414.50. The learned counsel submitted that the particular perception entertained by the members of the National Commission about the value of the services rendered by a housewife could not be made basis for reducing the amount of compensation awarded by the State Commission.

8. Shri Rajiv Kataria, learned counsel appearing for Respondent 3 argued that the National Commission did not commit any error by reducing the amount of compensation because the appellants did not produce any evidence to show that the deceased was gainfully employed. He further argued that the State Commission committed grave error by applying the multiplier of 13 ignoring that the deceased was fifty years old at the time of surgery and death.

9. The learned counsel for Respondents 1 and 2 submitted that the hospital was insured with Respondent 4 and the insurance company has already paid a sum of Rs 5,00,000.

10. We have considered the submissions of the learned counsel and carefully perused the record.

11. In our view, the National Commission committed serious error by reducing the amount of compensation by assuming that the award made by the State Commission was on higher side. The mere fact that the deceased was a homemaker was not sufficient to deny adequate compensation to the appellants in lieu of the services rendered by her — see Arun Kumar Agrawal v. National Insurance Co. Ltd. (2010) 9 SCC 218 In that case, this Court considered the question whether compensation could be awarded keeping in view the gratuitous services rendered by a housewife, referred to several precedents including some judgments of the English courts and held:

“26. In India the courts have recognised that the contribution made by the wife to the house is invaluable and cannot be computed in terms of money. The gratuitous services rendered by the wife with true love and affection to the children and her husband and managing the household affairs cannot be equated with the services rendered by others. A wife/mother does not work by the clock. She is in the constant attendance of the family throughout the day and night unless she is employed and is required to attend the employer's work for particular hours. She takes care of all the requirements of the husband and children including cooking of food, washing of clothes, etc. She teaches small children and provides invaluable guidance to them for their future life. A housekeeper or maidservant can do the household work, such as cooking food, washing clothes and utensils, keeping the house clean, etc., but she can never be a substitute for a wife/mother who renders selfless service to her husband and children.
27. It is not possible to quantify any amount in lieu of the services rendered by the wife/mother to the family i.e the husband and children. However, for the purpose of award of compensation to the dependants, some pecuniary estimate has to be made of the services of the housewife/mother. In that context, the term ‘services’ is required to be given a broad meaning and must be construed by taking into account the loss of personal care and attention given by the deceased to her children as a mother and to her husband as a wife. They are entitled to adequate compensation in lieu of the loss of gratuitous services rendered by the deceased. The amount payable to the dependants cannot be diminished on the ground that some close relation like a grandmother may volunteer to render some of the services to the family which the deceased was giving earlier.”

12. By applying the ratio of the aforesaid judgment in Arun Kumar case (2010) 9 SCC 218 to the facts of this case, we hold that the National Commission committed grave error by reducing the amount of compensation determined by the State Commission.

13. In the result, the appeals are allowed, the impugned order First Appeal No. 506 of 2005 is set aside and the one passed by the State Commission is restored. Respondents 1 and 2 are directed to pay to the appellants the balance amount of compensation with interest @ 6% per annum from the date of filing of complaint. The needful must be done within a period of three months from today.