Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Bolla Ajay Babu v. Nalla Manikyamma

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Oct 9, 2009
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

These two civil revision petitions (CRP Nos. 3523 and 4356 of 2009) challenge the order dated 23.7.2009 passed by the II-Additional Junior Civil Judge, Warangal, in interlocutory applications IA Nos. 808 and 809 of 2009 within OS No. 285 of 2002. The suit was filed by the petitioner as plaintiff seeking perpetual injunction. At the stage of further evidence on behalf of the petitioner, two interlocutory applications were filed: IA No. 808 under Order VII Rule 14(3) CPC seeking leave to admit additional documents, and IA No. 809 under Order XVIII Rule 17 CPC seeking to reopen the case and recall PW1 to mark those documents. Both applications were dismissed by the trial court, which found that the documents were not obtained by the petitioner and there was no reference to them in the pleadings.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner can be granted leave under Order VII Rule 14(3) CPC to admit additional documents not originally obtained by the petitioner but certified copies, when there is no reference to such documents in the pleadings.
  2. Whether the absence of reference to the documents in the plaint precludes the petitioner from seeking leave to produce those documents at a belated stage of the suit.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The dismissal of the applications was unwarranted, as the mere fact that the documents were not obtained by the petitioner does not justify rejection.
  • The documents are certified copies, and under Order VII Rule 14(3) CPC, the court ought to have granted leave to admit them.
  • Relied on the judgment in Omprakash Gupta and others v. Government of A.P. and others, 2005 (2) ALD (NOC 98), to support the contention that certified copies can be admitted.

Respondent's Arguments

  • There is no reference to the documents in the plaint, and without such reference, the petitioner cannot seek leave at a belated stage to produce the documents.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Omprakash Gupta and others v. Government of A.P. and others, 2005 (2) ALD (NOC 98) Certified copies of documents can be received in evidence if referred to in the plaint and their authenticity is undisputed. The Court noted that this precedent was distinguishable because in the present case, the documents were not referred to in the plaint, and thus it did not assist the petitioner.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the grounds on which the trial court dismissed IA No. 808 of 2009. It found that the first ground—that the petitioner did not obtain the certified copies but a third party did—was not a valid reason to reject the application. However, the second ground—that there was no reference to the documents in the pleadings—was a valid and sufficient reason to refuse leave to admit the documents at a belated stage. The court emphasized that without any reference to the documents in the pleadings, the petitioner could not seek leave to produce them when the suit was already at the stage of further evidence. The court further distinguished the precedent relied upon by the petitioner on the basis that in that case the documents were referred to in the plaint, which was not so here. Consequently, the court found no illegality in the impugned orders and declined to interfere under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.

Holding and Implications

The civil revision petitions are dismissed.

The direct effect of this decision is the affirmation of the trial court's rejection of the interlocutory applications seeking to admit additional documents not referred to in the pleadings. No costs were imposed. The opinion does not establish any new precedent beyond the application of established principles regarding admission of evidence and pleadings.

Show all summary ...

JUDGEMENT :-

1 Crp Nos.3523 and 4356 of 2009 are filed against the order dated 23.7.2009 passed in IA Nos.808 and 809 of 2009 respectively in OS No.285 of 2002 by the learned II -Additional Junior civil Judge, Warangal.

2 Since these two revision petitions arise out of the same suit, against the orders passed in two interlocutory applications, they are heard together and being disposed of by this common order.

3 The petitioner is the plaintiff and the respondent is the defendant in the suit, which is filed seeking perpetual injunction. The suit is corning up for further evidence on behalf of the petitioner/ plaintiff. At that stage, the petitioner filed two interlocutory applications in IA Nos.808 and 809 of 2009. IA No.808 of 2009 was filed under Order VII Rule 14 (3) CPC seeking leave of the Court to receive some additional documents in evidence and IA No.809 of 2009 was filed under order XVIII Rule 17 CPC to reopen the case and recall PW1 for the purpose of marking the documents, which are sought to be received in IA No.808 of 2009. The Court below, by the impugned orders, dismissed both the applications. In the order passed in LA.808 of 2009, the court below by recording a finding that the documents filed by the petitioner are not obtained by him and that there is no reference in the pleadings about the documents, dismissed the said application. Consequently. IA No.809 of 2009 was also dismissed.

4 It is submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioner that there was no reason for rejecting the applications filed by the petitioner and that merely because the documents, which are sought to be received as additional evidence by granting leave, were not obtained by the petitioner, it is no ground to reject the applications. It is submitted that inasmuch as the documents are certified copies, the Court below ought to have granted leave in view of the provision under Order VII Rule 14 (3) CPC. In support of his contentions, the learned counsel placed reliance on the judgment in omprakash Gupta and others V/s. Government of A. P. and others, 2005 (2)ALD (NOC 98 ).

5 The learned Counsel for the respondent submits that there is no reference to these documents in the plaint at all and that in the absence of any such reference, the petitioner cannot seek leave, at the belated stage, so as to produce the said documents.

6 I have perused the copy of the impugned order passed by the Court below in IA No.808 of 2009. The Court below rejected the said application on two grounds that (i) the certified copies of the documents were not obtained by the petitioner and that they were obtained by a third party and (ii)there is no reference to the documents in the pleadings, which are sought to be received. So far as ground No,l is concerned, it is not necessary that the petitioner should only obtain the certified copies of the documents and it is no ground at all to reject the application, but the Court below was right in holding that the documents cannot be received in evidence by granting leave in the absence of any reference about the same in the pleadings. This Court is also of the opinion that in the absence of any reference to the documents, which are sought to be received, in the pleadings, the petitioner cannot seek leave of the Court to receive such documents, at the belated stage, when the suit is coming up for further evidence on the side of the plaintiff. Further the judgment relied on by the learned counsel for the petitioner is also of no help to the petitioner as in the said judgment, the documents, which were sought to be marked, were referred to in the plaint. In the said judgment, it was held that certified copies can be received when they are referred to in the plaint and their authenticity is not disputed. In any event, having regard to the findings recorded by the Court below for rejection of the applications, I do not find any illegality in the orders impugned so as to interfere with the same in exercise of powers under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.

7 The civil revision petitions are devoid of merits and are, accordingly, dismissed. No order as to costs.