Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Rajah Yarlagadda Siv... v. The State Of Andhra ...

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Jul 28, 1959

Chandra Reddy, C.J.:-

(1) The question raised in this petition is whether a tank situate in the midst of private lands of an erstwhile landholder would fall within the comprehension of section 3 (10) of the madras estates land act. It arises in the following circumstances.

(2) The petitioner is the zamindar of devarakota situated in krishna district. The estate was notified under the provisions of section 3 of the madras estates (abolition and conversion into ryotwari) act, 1948 (hereinafter referred to as the act) on 7th september, 1949 and was taken over by the government subsequently. In due course, the petitioner filed an application before the settlement officer under section 12 of the act for the grant of a ryotwari patta in regard to several items of lands claiming them as his private lands. Amongst them is a tank alleged to be in the middle of his private lands. The settlement officer allowed his claim in regard to most of the items but rejected the application in respect of the remaining items including item i, which is the tank in dispute. An appeal preferred to the estates abolition tribunal proved unsuccessful. Thereupon, the aggrieved landholder has invoked the jurisdiction of this court under article 226 of the constitution. The principal point for consideration is whether the petitioner is entitled to a ryotwari patta in regard to the tank. This has to be answered with reference to the provisions of the act. Under section 3 (f) of the act, the moment an estate is notified under section 3 (a) certain consequences follow, namely, the madras estates land act, 1908 and other enactments applicable to estates as such shall be deemed to have been repealed and the entire estate vests in the government. Consequent upon this, the quondam landholder has no right other than those recognised under the enactment by force of clause (g). One of the rights conferred upon a landholder is to claim a ryotwari patta in regard to his private land. Section 12 recites :

"in the case of a zamindari estate, the landholder shall, with effect on and from the notified date be entitled to ryotwari patta in respect of - (a) all lands (including lanka lands) which immediately before the notified date (i) belonged to him as private land within the meaning of section 3, clause 10 (a) , of the estates land act, or (11) stood recorded as his private land in a record prepared under the provisions of chapter xi or chapter xii of the said act, not having been subsequently converted into ryoti land."

(3) We are not concerned with the other provisions of that section, as the controversy in the case centres round the question whether a tank could come within the definition of ' private land ' defined in section 3 (10) of the madras estates land act. We have, therefore, to turn to section 3 (10) of the madras estates land act. This section defines ' pivate land ' thus :

" (a) in the case of an estate within the meaning of sub - clauses (a) , (b) , (c) or (e) of clause 2, means the domain or home farm land of the landholder by whatever designation known such as kambattam, khas, sir, or pannai and includes all land which is proved to have been cultivated as private land by the landholder himself, by his own servants or by hired labour, wrth his own or hired slock, for a continuous period of twelve years immediately before the commencement of this act."

The point for decision is whether a tank answers the definition of ' private land '. In the consideration of this question, clause 16 of that section plays some part. It runs thus :

"ryoti land means cultivable land in an estate other than private land but docs not include (a) beds and bunds of tanks and of supply, drainage, surplus or irrigation channels, (b) threshing floor, cattle - stands, village sites and other lands situated in any estate which arc set apart for the common use of the villagers, (c) lands granted on service tenure cither free of rent or on favourable rates of rent if granted before the passing of this act or free of rent if granted after that date, so long as the service tenure subsists."

(4) Section 12 (a) of the act talks only of the grant of patta in regard to private land falling within the purview of section 3 (10) (a) of the madras estates land act and does not take in those covered by section 3 (16) of that act. In our considered opinion, it is difficult to postulate that a tank could be regarded as a private land notwithstanding its situation in the middle of other lands to which the landholder could claim a ryotwari patta. To satisfy the definition of ' private land ', it should be capable of cultivation. That test could not be complied with in regard to a tank. " that being the position, its being appurtenant to other lands is not decisive of the matter.

(5) Another consideration that is quite pertinent in the context of this enquiry is that immediately after the estate is notified, all enactments that govern ryotwari tenures shall apply to the estate. Under the statute the beds of all tanks, among other things, vest in the government. Section 2 of the madras land encroachment act recites :

" (1) all public roads, streets, lanes and paths, the bridges, ditches, dikes and fences, on or beside the same, the bed of the sea and of harbours and creeks below high water mark and of rivers, streams, canals, lakes and tanks, and all canals and water - courses and all standing and flowing water and all lands, wherever situated, save in so far as the same are the property - (a) of any zamindar, poligar, mittadar, jagirdar, shortriemdar or inamdar or any person claiming through or holding under any of them."

Consequent on the abolition of the estate, the zamindar cannot have any prehensions to any of the properties situate in the estate and the government steps into his shoes in that regard. That being the case, the government becomes the proprietor of the properties enumerated in section 2 of the madras land encroachment act. That apart, when once the estates are notified, the land therein will be treated as ryotwari area. In that position, all the incidents of ryotwari tenure attach to those in the erstwhile estate and therefore are attracted to a patta pertaining to private land.

(6) The counsel for the petitioner places strong reliance on a judgment of a bench of the madras high court in saraswathi bai v. The state of madras, (1956) 2 m. L. J. 595: i. L. R. (1957) mad. 436. It was there ruled that the definition of private land in section 3 (10) (a) did not expressly or even impliedly exclude land which is in use as tank used exclusively to irrigate the cultivated private lands of the landholder and consequently a landholder has a statutory right to obtain ryotwari patta in regard to a tank also. The, learned judges thought that if patta could issue in regard to a private land, the same consideration should apply to a tank which is appurtenant to the land. We are unable to agree with this decision. We do not think that the appurtenance theory will in any way come to the rescue of the landholder. Before a patta could be issued under section 12 (a) , it should be established at least that the land is capable of cultivation, whether directly or indirectly apart from the question whether it was cultivated or not. It could not be posited that a tank could satisfy that test.

(7) Further, the question is not one of exclusion but by express provision such a right should be conferred upon the landholder by the estates land act since the right to a ryotwari patta in the quondam estate is itself a creature of the statute and such right has to be decided with reference to the provisions of the act read in the light of the relevant provisions of the madras estates land act. This principle is recognised by rajagopalan, j. , who was a party to the judgment in saraswathi bai v. The state of madras, in saraswathi bai v. Chairman, estates abolition tribunal, madurai, (1956) 1 m. L. J. 200. The view taken by the learned judge in that case was that :

"obviously thr lands that fell within the scope of scetion 3 (16) (a) or (a) of the estates land act cannot come within the ambit of the provisions of section 12 (a) or section 12 (a) (iii) of the abolition act"
.

This ruling was not noticed by the learned judges who decided saraswathi bai v. The state of madras. Nor have they considered the various aspects arising out of the application of enactments that apply to ryotwari tenures such as the land encroachment act, etc. Moreover, this bench decision was overruled by a full bench of the same court in (writ petition no. 62 of 1956) lakshmipathi nayakar v. The estates abolition tribunal, madurai, since reported in (1959) 2 m. L. J. 254 (f. B.). The learned judges, after taking into account the several aspects of the matter, came to the conclusion that a tank could not fall within the purview of section 3 (10). It is pointed out by them that the position of a tank could not be equated to that of a well or pond in regard to which the landholder could obtain a patta. We are in respectful accord with the principle of this case. It follows that a landholder could not claim a ryotwari patta in regard to a tank. Therefore, the order now impugned in this petition is correct and has to be affirmed. As such, it cannot be removed on certiorari.

(8) In the result, the writ petition is dismissed with costs. Advocate's fee rs. 100. Petition dismissed.