- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Dr. K. Ashok Kumar v. University Of Health Sciences And Others
Case Summary: K. Ashok Kumar v. University of Health Sciences (Division Bench)
Factual and Procedural Background
This writ petition concerns admission to the lone super-speciality seat in D.M. (Neurology) for the year 1986–87. The seat had earlier been the subject of prior litigation: Dr. Fazal Ghafoor, who stood first in the entrance test, was denied admission on the ground that he was not a "local candidate" for the institution (Nizam's Institute of Medical Sciences / Osmania Medical College) under the Andhra Pradesh Educational Institutions (Regulation of Admissions) Order, 1974 issued under Article 371-D. Dr. Ghafoor's writ petition (No. 7137/87) was dismissed by a single judge on 27-8-1987 and a subsequent writ appeal (W.A. No. 1172/87) before the same division bench was dismissed on 18-1-1988.
After those decisions, the same seat was subsequently granted to the 5th respondent, Dr. Venkata Sai Prabhakar (who stood second in the entrance test). The petitioner, Dr. K. Ashok Kumar (who stood eighth but was the highest-ranked local candidate of the Telangana local area among those eligible), challenged that admission on the ground that the seat is situated in an institution located in the Telangana local area and therefore must be reserved for local candidates of Telangana under Rule 5 of the Presidential Order. The writ petition was referred to the same bench that decided the earlier appeal; the division bench heard the petition and delivered the judgment summarized here.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the lone D.M. (Neurology) seat at Osmania Medical College (situated in the Telangana local area) is reserved exclusively for local candidates of the Telangana local area under Rule 5 of the Presidential Order (A.P. Educational Institutions (Regulation of Admissions) Order, 1974).
- Whether the proviso to sub-rule (2) of Rule 5 (which provides that there shall be at least one unreserved seat) should be read to mean that where only one seat exists in a course at an institution, that single seat is to be treated as unreserved.
- Whether, because only one seat in the entire State exists for that super-speciality, the seat should be treated as effectively "state-wide" (and therefore allocated among local candidates from all three local areas under Rule 6) or otherwise be available to local candidates across the State.
- Whether paragraph 11 of G.O. P. No. 646 (10-7-1979) and related clarifications (concerning eligibility for the 15% unreserved seats) make the lone seat available to categories of persons beyond local candidates (i.e., whether the seat is to be treated as an "unreserved" seat for the categories listed in that paragraph).
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments (Dr. K. Ashok Kumar)
- The seat is provided in Osmania Medical College, which is situated in the Telangana local area and affiliated to Osmania University; therefore Rule 5 (reservation for local candidates of the local area where the institution is situated) applies.
- The 5th respondent is not a local candidate of the Telangana local area (he is local to the Andhra local area) and hence was not eligible for admission to the seat reserved for Telangana local candidates.
- Among Telangana local candidates, the petitioner secured the highest rank and should be admitted to the seat.
Respondents' Arguments (University of Health Sciences and Others)
- The university contends that because only one seat in that super-speciality exists in the entire State, it cannot be confined to Telangana local area candidates and must be made available to local candidates from all three local areas (effectively treating it as state-wide for that course).
- The university also argued that the proviso to sub-rule (2) of Rule 5 (which says there shall be at least one unreserved seat) requires that the lone seat be treated as unreserved.
- The respondents referred to paragraph 11 of G.O. P. No. 646 (10-7-1979) and argued that categories listed there (including local candidates and others meeting specified residency/employment criteria) are eligible for unreserved seats and that the seat should be considered available to those categories.
- The Director of Nizam's Institute of Medical Sciences filed a counter-affidavit stating he did not know the circumstances in which the seat, earlier notified at NIMS, came to be transferred to Osmania Medical College.
- The 5th respondent, though served, did not appear or was not represented at the hearing before the division bench.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Writ Appeal No. 1172/87 (Division Bench judgment dated 18-1-1988) | Confirmed that the seat (located in Nizam's Institute of Medical Sciences / institution situated in Telangana area) is governed by the Presidential Order and reserved for local candidates of that local area; rejected arguments that the seat is state-wide or unreserved under the proviso to Rule 5. | The court relied on and reiterated the reasoning in that earlier judgment; it rejected the university's contentions here for the same reasons and refused to depart from that decision. |
| Single Judge decision in Writ Petition No. 7137/87 (P.A. Choudary, J., dismissed 27-8-1987) | Held that Dr. Fazal Ghafoor was not a local candidate and that denying him admission was correct; rejected estoppel and Article 14 challenges. | The division bench noted and adopted the single judge's findings as affirmed by the division bench on appeal; it treated that earlier outcome as supporting the conclusion that local reservation applied to the seat. |
| State of Andhra Pradesh v. K. Narayan (bench decision cited) | Addressed interpretation of the provision (in pari materia rules / G.O.P. paragraph 11) concerning availability of the 15% unreserved seats and whether they are available only to State residents. | The division bench stated the principle in that decision relates to many seats and the 15% unreserved pool and observed that its principle has no application to the present facts (a reserved single seat under Rule 5). The court declined to express any opinion on its correctness here because the paragraph relied on is not attracted. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's analysis proceeded in carefully defined statutory and textual steps, applying the Presidential Order (A.P. Educational Institutions (Regulation of Admissions) Order, 1974) and related government clarifications to the facts:
- The court began with Article 371-D and the Presidential Order, explaining that the President may specify local areas and provide reservation and preference in admissions for persons who have resided or studied in such local areas. The Order's rules (notably Rules 2–6, 8 and 9) govern definitions and reservation schemes.
- The court set out the definitions: Rule 2 defines "local area," "local candidate," and "state-wide educational institution" and Rule 3 divides the State into three local areas (Andhra, Telangana, Rayalaseema). Rule 4 sets criteria for local candidates (not disputed for present purposes).
- Rule 5 provides that 85% of available seats in institutions (other than state-wide universities/institutions) situated in a local area are to be reserved in favour of local candidates of that local area. Where only one seat is involved, that seat falls within Rule 5's reservation if the institution is not a state-wide institution.
- The court observed that Osmania Medical College is affiliated to Osmania University, is subject to State control, and is situated in Telangana local area. The neurology department is not listed in the Schedule as a state-wide educational institution (unlike certain other departments such as neuro-surgery). The respondents' counsel conceded that neurology differs from neurosurgery. Thus Rule 5, not Rule 6, applies.
-
The court addressed the university's contention that the proviso to sub-rule (2) of Rule 5 (providing that there shall be at least one unreserved seat) means a single available seat should be treated as unreserved. The court rejected this reading:
- The proviso is to sub-rule (2) (which deals with rounding up fractions when determining numbers of reserved seats) and not to sub-rule (1) (which creates the 85% local reservation). The proviso ensures that when fractions are rounded up, at least one seat remains unreserved—it was not intended to convert an entire course's sole seat into an unreserved seat.
- The division bench had previously rejected the same argument in W.A. No. 1172/87 and saw no reason to depart from that decision.
- The court rejected the university's argument that, because only one seat in the State existed for that super-speciality, it should be treated as reserved for local candidates of all three local areas collectively. The court reasoned that the Presidential Order identifies three distinct local areas; the term "local area" always refers to one of those parts. Only where an institution or department is declared state-wide under the schedule does Rule 6 (allocation among all three local areas in the 42:36:22 ratio) apply. Absent such declaration, an institution situated in a local area remains subject to Rule 5.
- The court also considered the university's reliance on paragraph 11 of G.O. P. No. 646 (10-7-1979), which lists categories eligible for the 15% unreserved seats. The court held that paragraph 11 is a clarification about who may be treated as eligible to apply for the 15% unreserved seats; it does not create a category "non-locals" in the Presidential Order nor change the fact that Rule 5 reserves 85% of seats for local candidates when Rule 5 applies. Since the seat in question is not an unreserved seat, paragraph 11 is inapplicable.
- Applying these legal conclusions to the facts, the court determined that the seat at Osmania Medical College in D.M. (Neurology) was reserved for local candidates of the Telangana local area and that the 5th respondent (a local candidate in Andhra local area) was not eligible for that seat.
Holding and Implications
Core Holding:
The writ petition is allowed. The 5th respondent was and is not eligible for admission to the only D.M. (Neurology) seat in Osmania Medical College; only local candidates of the Telangana local area are eligible for that seat.
Consequential directions and immediate implications:
- The respondents are directed to verify which Telangana local-area candidate secured the highest ranking and admit that candidate forthwith to the seat. The respondents must take action in terms of this direction within five days of receipt of a copy of the order (given that classes had already commenced about a month earlier).
- There shall be no order as to costs.
- The court reaffirmed that Rule 5 governs seats provided by institutions that are not declared state-wide; Rule 6 (allocation among all three local areas) applies only to state-wide universities or state-wide educational institutions specified in the schedule to the Presidential Order.
- Broader administrative suggestion: The court observed that where only one seat in a particular super-speciality exists in the entire State, it may be appropriate for authorities to consider declaring that department (for future years) as a state-wide educational institution so that Rule 6 allocation can apply; the court suggested the authorities consider amending the schedule to the Presidential Order if they are so satisfied.
Note: This summary is compiled strictly from the text of the provided opinion. No information beyond the opinion has been added or inferred.
(1) The controversy in the present writ petition is about the same seat in a super - speciality in medicine which is the subject matter of the judgment of a division bench of this court in w. A. No. 1172/1987 dated 18 - 1 - 1988. The contention of the respondent - university then was that a person from outside the state was a non - local and, therefore, not entitled to claim the only seat in d. M. (neurology) was upheld. Thereafter, the same seat has been given to a candidate who is not a local candidate with reference to the area where the institution is located now, the stand of the university is that it is not reserved for local candidate of the area. It is not in dispute that cl. (5) of the presidential order will apply to this case. To avoid further litigation and delay, particularly when the classes have started one month ago, i consider it appropriate that this writ petition be considered and decided by the same bench consisting of jeevan reddy, j, and panduranga rao, j. , which decided the earlier case. Place the papers before the hon'ble the chief justice for posting of the writ petition as early as possible. Pursuant to the above order of reference this petition came on lor hearing before the division bench on 9 - 8 - 1988 and the court delivered the following.
(2) This writ petition relates to admission to a lone seat in super speciality, d. M. (neurology) , in osmania medical college for the year 1986 - 87. Earlier there was a writ petition and writ appeal with respect to this verv seat, and the ntain complaint in this writ petition is that the judgment in the earlier case is not being applied and followed by the respondents.
(3) For the year 1986 - 87 applications were called for, for admission into super specialities, including d. M. (neurology). The only seat in this super speciality was then notified as available in nizam's institute of medical sciences. In the entrance test conducted frr this super speciality, a number of persons appeared, among who one dr. Fazal ghafoor stood first. The 5th respondent in the writ petition, dr. Venkata sai prabhakar, stood second, and the petitioner herein, dr. K. Ashok kumar, secured the 8th rank. In the normal course, dr. Fazal ghafoor ought to have been given admission; but, he was denied admission on the ground that he was not a 'local candidate' and, therefore, ineligible for admission in view of the a. P. Educational institutions (regulation of admissions) order, 1974, issued by the president of india under clauses (1) and (2) of article 371 - d of the constitution. Dr. Ghafoor wab bom in kerala and had obtained hrs m. B. B. S. , degree from a college in kerala. However, he obtained his post graduate degree, i. E. , m. D. (general medicine) from osmania medical college in 1986. Inasmuch as dr. Ghafoor did not satisfy any of the c riteria prescribed in rule 4 of the said older, defining "local candidate", he was denied admission, whereupon he approached this court by way of writ petition no. 7137/87. It was heard by p. A. Choudary, j. And dismissed on 27 - 8 - 1987. The learned judge held that the petitioner. Dr. Ghafoor, is not a local candidate and, therefore, admission was rightly denied to him. The learned judge also repelled the argument of dr. Ghafoor that inasmuch as he was allowed to appear for the entrance test and was also called for interview in pursuance thereof, the respondents were estopped from denying admission to him on the ground of not heing a local candidate. The learned judge also rejected the contention thai reserving the only seat for local candidates offends art. 14. 11 was pointed out by the learned judge that the said reservation is not under art. 15 (4) of the constitution, but was made under the presidential order issued under art. 371 - d and is, therefore, beyond challenge. A writ appeal, being w. A. No. 1172/87, was filed by dr. Ghafoor against the decision of the learned single judge, which had come up before this very bench. We dismissed the writ appeal confirming the opinion of the learned judge on all the three grounds. In the said writ appeal, however, counsel tor the appellant had raised certain new grounds, not urged before the learned single judge. Though we said that the grounds not urged before the learned single judge cannot be allowed to be raised in writ appeal, yet i'or the sake of completeness we dealt with those conte ntions. They were : (i) since there is only one seat in d. M. (neurology) in the entire state, located in an institute situated in hyderabad, it must be treated as a state - wide seat. The argument was based upon the proviso to rule 6 of the presidential order, 1974. This argument was rejected and it was held that inasmuch as nizam's institute of medical sciences is situated in telangana area, the presidential order, 1974 applies to it, and hence only a local candidate can be admitted to the said seat. (ii) by virtue of the proviso to rule 5 of the presidential order, the only seat in the said super speciality must be deemed to be an 'unreserved' seat. In other words, the argument was that the said seat should not be reserved for local candidates but must be available for both 'local' and 'non - local' candidates. This argument also was rejected holding that the said proviso does not say, and cannot be construed as saying that the said seat is not reserved for local candidates. (iii) the nizam's institute of medical sciences, affiliated to the university of health sciences, must be treated to be state - wide educational institution. This argument too was rejected with reference to the schedule to the preside ntial order.
(4) The judgment 1 in writ appeal was tendered on 18 - 1 - 1988. Indeed, the very entrance test for admission to this scut was hold in march 1987, and interviews hold on 9 - 5 - 1987.
(5) After the disposal of the writ appco aforesaid, the authorities admitted the 5th respondent: to the said se - t. As stated hereinbefore, the 5th respondent stood second in the entrance test. He was admitted sometime in may/june, 1988. The petitioner says, he came to know of the same in the first week of jline, 1988 and immediately he approached this court by way of this writ petition. The writ petition came up before waghray, j. Who, by his order dated 28 - 7 - 1988, directed ihut this writ petition be heard by a bench, and if possible by this particular bench, inasmuch as this bench had earlier disposed of writ appeal no. 1172/87 riled by dr. Ghafoor. It was observed that inasmuch as classes have already begun in the month of may 1988, this writ petition has to he heard without any loss of time. Accordingly, the hon'ble chief justice has constituted this beach to hear this writ petition.
(6) The main and the only contention of 'he petitioner is that, inasmuch as this seat is in the osmania medical college, afliliatecl to osmania university, situated in teiangana local area of the state, only a local candidate of the telangana local area can be admitted to this seat. The 5th respondent who has been given admission is not a loeal candidate in telanguna loeal area; he is a local candidate in andhra local area and, therefore, ineligible for the said seat. Among the loeal candidates in teiangana local area, the petitioner secured the highest rank and must, therefore, be admitted to it.
(7) The above contention is opposed by the 1st respondent, university of health sciences, saying that since the said seat is the only seat available in the said super speciality in the entire state, it cannot be conlined to loeal candidates of teiangana local area, and must be held available for the local candidates of all the three local areas in the s'. Ate. This is the main contention raised in the counter - affidavit filed by the registrar of the university. The director of the nizam's institute of medical sciences has also filed a separate counter - affidavit, affirming the same stamp. In fact, the said counter - affidavit was filed merely to say that he does not know in what circumstances the seat, which was previously notified as available in nizam's institute of medical sciences, came to be transferred to osmania medical college. Though the 5th respondent has been served, he is not represented before us.
(8) Article 371 - d of the constitution is a special provision applicable to the state of andhra pradesh alone. It empowers the president to make an order providing - having regard to the requirements of the state as a whole. For equitable opportunities and facilities for the people belonging to different parts of the stale in the matter of public employment, and education. He is empowered to make different provisions for various parts of the state for the said purpose. The president is empowered to specify any part, or parts of the state which shall be regarded as local area for purposes of admission to any university in the state, or to any other educational institution which is subject to the control of the central government. The president is also empowered to specify the extent to which, the manner in which, and the conditions subject to which preference or reservation shall be given or made, in the matter of admission to any such university or other educational institution, to or in favour of candidates who have resided or studied for any period specified in the order, in the local area in respect of such cadres, university or other educational institution, as the case may be; the president, accordingly, issued the a. P. Educational institutions (regulation of admissions) order, 1974.
(9) Rule 2 of the order defines various expressions, including "local area", "local candidates", "state - wide educational institution" and " statewide university" in clauses (b) , (c) , (e) , and (f) respectively, in the following words :
" (b) 'local area' in respect of any university or other educational institution, means the local area specified in paragraph 3 of this order for the purposes of admission to such university or other educational institution ; (c) 'local candidate' in relation to any local area, means a candidate who qualifies under paragraph 4 of this order as a local candidate in relation to such local area ; (e1' 'state - wide educational institution' means an educational institution or a department of an educational institution specified in the schedule to tnis order ; (f) 'state - wide university' means the andhra pradesh agricultural university constituted under the andhra pradesh agricultural university act, 1963 (andhra pradesh act 24 of 1963) , or the jawaharlal nehru technological university constituted under the jawaharlal nehru technological university act, 1972 (andhra pradesh act 16 of 1972)".
(10) Rule 3 divides the state into three local - areas which may, for the sake of convenience, be referred to as "andhra", "telangana" and
"rayalaseema" areas, respectively. Rule 3 reads thus : 3. Local area : (1) the part of the state comprising the districts of srikakulam, visakhapatnam, west godavari, east godavari, krishna, guntur and prakasam shall be regarded as the local area for the purposes of admission to the andhra university, (the nagarjuna university) and to any other educational institution (other than a state - wide university or state - wide educational institution) which is subject to the couliol of the state government situated in that part. (2) the part of the state comprising the districts of adilabad, hyderabad, karimnagar, khammum, mahbubnagar, medak, nalgonda, nizamabad and warangal shall be regarded as the local area for the purposes of admission to the osmania university, (the kakatiya university) and to any other educational institution (other than a state - wide university or statewide educational institution) which is subject to the control of the state government and is situated in that part. (3) the part of the state comprising the districts of anantapur, cuddapah, kurnool, chittoor, and nellore shall be regarded as the local area for the purposes of admission to sri venkaleswara university and to any other educational institution (other than a state - wide university or state - wide educational institution) which is subject to the control of the state government and is situated in that part".
(11) Rule 4 defines "local candidates". A person will be a local candidate in relation to a local area, if he satisfies the requirements mentioned either in sub - rule (i) , or sub - rule (2) of the said rule. It is unnecessary to refer to the criteria mentioned in rule 4, since in the case before us, it is not disputed that while the petitioner is a local candidate in telangana local - area, the 5th respondent is not a local candidate in telangana local area, but that he is a local - candidate in andhra local area.
(12) Rule 5 reserves 85% of seats in each course of study university or any other educational institution (other than a state - wide university or statewide educational institution) , situated in any local area, in favour of the local candidates of that local area. Rule 5 reads thus :
"5. Reservation in non - state - wide universities and educational institutions : (1) admissions to eighty - five per cent of the available seats in every course of study provided - by the andhra university, the nagarjuna university the osmania university, the kakatiya university or sri venkateswani university or by any other educational institution (other than a state - wide university or a statewide educational institution) which is subject to the control of the state government shall be reserved in favour of the local candidates in relation to the local area in respect of such university or other educational institution. (2) while determining under sub - paragraph (i) the number of seats to be reserved in favour of local candidates any fraction of a seat shall be counted as one : provided that there shah be at least one unreserved seat".
(13) Rule 6 deals with reservation in state - wide universities and state - wide educational institutions. State - wide universities and state - wide educational institutions are specified in rule 2 (f) and the schedule to the [1]k. Ashok kumar vs. University of health sciences (jeevan reddy, j) [d. B. J order. In these universities/institutions, admissions to 85% of the available scats in every course of study are reserved in favour of, and allocated among the local candidates from andhra, telangana, and rayalaseema local areas in the ratio of 42: 36: 22 respectively. It would be appropriate to set out rule 6 as well. It reads thus :
"6. Reservation in state - wide universities and state - wide educational institutions : (1) admissions to eighty five per cent of the available seats in every course of study provided by a state - wide university or a statewide educational institution shall be reserved in favour ot and allocated among the local candidates in relation to the (local areas specified in sub - paragraph (1) , sub - paragraph (2) and subparagraph (3) of paragrah 3, in the ratio of 42: 36: 22 respectively) : provided that this sub - paragraph shall not apply in relation to any course of study in which the total number of available seats does not exceed three. (2) while determining under sub - paragraph (i) the number of seats to be reserved in favour of the local candidates, any fraction of a seat shall be counted as one : provided that there shall be at least one unreserved seat."
(14) Rule 9 gives overriding effect to the provisions of the order over any other statute, ordinance, rule. Regulation or other order in respect of admissions to any university, or to any other educational institution subject to the control of the state government.
(15) Rule 8 says that the president may, by order, require the state government to give such directions as may be necessary or expedient for the purpose of giving effect to the presidential order, to any university or to any other educational institution subject to its control, and that the directions so issued shall be binding upon such university/institution.
(16) For a proper and effective implementation of the presidential order, the government of andhra pradesh has been issuing instructions from time to time explaining and elucidating the provisions of the presidential order, for the guidance of the persons and authorities concerned. The last and comprehensive one in this behalf is g. O. P. No. 646, dated 10 - 7 - 1979. Since paragraph 11 of this g. O. Is relied upon by the respondents, we think it appropriate to set out the said paragraph it reads :
"as clarifications were being sought on the question as to who should be considered eligible to apply as candidates belonging to the state of andhra pradesh for the purpose of admission to courses of studies offered by the educational institutions, subject to the control of the state government, against the 15% of the available seats kept un - reserved in terms of the andhra pradesh educational institutions (regulation of admissions) order, 1974, the government after careful consideration have directed that the following categories of candidates may be treated as eligible to apply for admissions to educational institutions in the state, subject to the control of the stale government, as candidates belonging to the state of andhra pradesh against the 15% of the available seates left unreserved in terms of the presidential order : (i) all local candidates defined in the presidential order. (ii) candidates who have resided in the state for a total period of ten years excluding periods of study outside the state ; or either of whose parents have resided in the state for a total period of ten years excluding periods of employment outside the state. (iii) candidates who are children of parents who are in the employment of this state or central government, public sector corporations, local bodies, universities and other similar quasi - public institutions within the state ; and (iv) candidates who are spouses of those in the employment of this state or central government, public sector corporations, local bodies, universities and educational institutions recognised by the government, a university or other competent authority and similar other quasi - government institutions within the state".
(17) The government of andhra pradesh has also issued rules, called
"andhra pradesh (regulation of admissions to super specialities in the medical colleges') rules, 1983", contained in g. O. Ms. No. 740, dated 22 - 11 - 1983. They are statutory rules issued under section 15 of the a. P. Educational institutions (regulation of admissions and prohibition of capitation fees) act, 1983. These rules, it is admitted, have no relevance in this behalf. We have relerred to them just to clarify that they have no application to the admissions concerned herein.
(18) Osmania medical college, in which the said seat in super speciality is provided, is affiliated to osmania university. Osmania medical college is an institution subject to the control of the state government, and is situated in telangana local area. Telangana local area is regarded as 'local area' for purposes of admission to osmania university. Neither the osmania university, is declared as a statewide university, nor is the osmania medical college declared a state - wide educational institution under the schedule to the presidential order. Indeed, item 3 of the schedule specifies "dental, neuro - surgery public health, radio diagnosis and radio therapy departments of the osmania medical college, hyderabad", as state - wide educational institutions. But neurology department in osmania medical college is not so specified as a state - wide educational institution. It is admitted before us by the counsel for respondents 1 and 3 that the department of neurology is different from the department of neuro - surgery. It, therefore, follows that the scat in question is reserved in favour of local candidates of the telangana local area, by virtue of rule 5. Rule 5, which we have already set out herein before, says that admissions to [1] k. Ashok kumar vs. University of health sciences (jeevim reddy, j) [d. B. ] 85% of the available seats in every course of study provided bv the severil universales m the state, or by any other educational institution under the control of the state government "shall be reserved in favour of the local candidates in relation to the local area in respect of such university or other educational institution". Since there is only one seat, it has to be reserved for local candidates of the concerned local area.
(19) It is, howeve, contended by the learned counsel for the 1st respondent - university that by virtue of the proviso to sub - rule (2) of rule 5, this loan seat should be treated as not reserved for local candidates under rule 5. It is contended that inasmuch as the proviso says that there should be at least one unreserved seat it must be held that where only one seat is available in a particular ceurse. It his is ur reserved. We are unable to accede to this contention, which contention we have already rejected in writ appeal no. 1172/87. 1 firstly, we do not think that such a contention is open to the 1st respondent - university, inasmuch as the 1st respondent - university had denied admission to dr. Ghafoor relying upon this very r. O, dr. Ghafoor who had stood first, in the entrance test, was denied admission to this sea! on the ground that he is not a local candidate. The university cannot, therefore now contend that the said seat is not reserved under rule 5 and must be treated as an unreserved seal by virtue of the proviso to sub - rule (2) of rule 5, secondlly even on merits we are of the opinion that the contention is unsound. The proviso to sub - rule (2) cannot be torn out of context and read as an independent provision, it must he read and unlestood in its context sub - rule (1) of rule 5 says that out of the available seats, 85% shoald be reserved in favour of local candidates the local area concerned. Sub - rale (2) says that while determining the number o" seats to 'be reserved in favour of local candidats under sun - rule (1) , any fraction of a seat shall be counted as one. To his, the proviso is added saying that there must at least be one unreserved seat. The proviso is a proviso to sub - rule (2) , and not a proviso to sub - rule (1). It, therefore, only means. That while rounding of the fraction to one. Under sub - rule (2) , it must be ensured that at least one seat is unreserved, i. E. , available to non - local candidates. The proviso cannot, therefore, be read as saying that where only one seat is available in a particular course of stady, if should be treated as unreserved. This is the view expressed by us in our judgment in w. A. No. 1172/87. 1 and we see no reason to depart from it.
(20) It is then contended by the learned counsel for the 1st respondent that, since only one seat is available in this super speciality in the entire state, it must be deemed as having been reserved for the local condidates of three local areas put together. In other words, the argument is that the said seat must be deemed as reserved for residenis of this state. It is on this ground that the 1st respondent seeks to justify the denial of admission to dr. Ghafoor on the previous occasion and granting of admission to the 5th respondent, who is a local candidate of andhra local area. We find this argument totally untenable and misplaced. The presidential order. Specifies three local areas, which we have referred to as 'andhra' 'telangana' and 'rayalaseema' local areas, respectively. The expression 'local area' has only one meaning; it means any of the three local areas. There is no such thing, nor any such local area specified as 'andhra pradesh'. In other words the 'state of andhra pradesh' is not notified as a local area for any purpose. Similarly, a person is a local candidate' only with respect to a particular local area. If he is not a local candidate with reference to that local area, he is a non - local condidate with reference to that local area. Put in different words the concept of local candidate is relevant vis - a - vis a local area only. In such a situation, to say that the seat in osmania medical college - which is affiliated to osmania university - is reserved for local candidates of all the three local areas, put together, is something which is not borne out by any provision of the presidential order. Only where a university or institution is declared as a state - wide university or state - wide educational institution, is the admission to a course of study in such university/institution allocated as between the local candidates of all the three local areas in a particular proportion, referred to hereinbefore. May be that in such a situation, if there is only one seat in a particular course of study in a state - wide university, or slate - wide educational institution, it may be treated as reserved for local candidates of three local areas put together. In such a situation, it may be that all the local candidates of the local three areas shall be treated as one unit and considered as such for the seat. But, where the seat in question is available in an educational institution, affiliated to a non - state - wide university, or where an educational institution is not declared as a state - wide edxicational institution, the course suggested by the 1st respondent cannot be applied, or adopted. Applying or adoping the said course would, in effect mean that the said department in osmania medical college, or the university medical college, or the osmania university, as the case may be is regarded as a state - wide educational institution, or statewide univeisity, as the case may be. Inasmuch as neither the said department, nor the said college, nor the said university have been declared as state - wide educational institution or state - wide university, the courss suggested by the 1st respondent is not permissible. In other words, rule 6 cannot be applied to such a situation; it is only rule 5 that governs and applies. Once it is so it must be deemed that the said seat is reserved in favour of local candidates of telangana local area, and that the local candidates of other local aieas are not eligible for admission thereto.
(21) It was then urged by the counsel for the 1st respondent that the said lone seat must be deemed to be reserved for "non - locals", and the expression "non - locals" must be understood as specified in paragraph 11 of g. O. P. No. 646, dated 10 - 7 - 1979. It is pointed out that according to paragraph 10 of the said g. O. , the persons specified under four sub - claus thereunder are eligible for admission to unreserved course, i. E. , 15% of the available seats. We have set out paragraph 11 of this g. O. Hereinbefore: and we do not think it necessary to reproduce the same over again here. In our opinion, the said argument is again misplaced. Firstly, there is no such expression as "non - locals"; the presidential order does not define or use this expression. It provide for reservation of 85% scats for local candidates : the remaining seats arc not reserved, 'unreserved'. The presidential order does not provide any reservation in favour of the residents of this state as such, nor does it provide for any reservation in favour of 'non - locals'. Secondly, para 11 of g. O. P. No. 646 merely clarifies that the persons mentioned under the four sub - clauses therein "may be treated as eligible to apply" for the said seats. According to the said paragraph, local candidates and persons belonging to three other categories specified therein are also eligible to apply for the said 15% seats. We are not sure whether the said paragraph can be read as saying that the 15% seats are available only for the four categories of persons mentioned in the said paragraph, or as saying that persons not belonging to the said four categories are not eligible to be considered for those seats. The said paragraph appears more in the nature of a clarification saying that the said persons, including local candidates, are equally eligible for being considered agninst the said 15% seats. Be that as it may we do not think it necessary to say anything more in view of the fact that the seat in question is not an 'un - reserved' seat. If so, paragraph 11 is not at all attracted.
(22) Reliance is placed in this behalf on the decision of a bench of this court in state of andhra pradesh vs. K. Narayan. That case related to admission to medical colleges in andhra pradesh, where a large number of seats were available, and 15% of the seats were specified as not reserved. In the light of rule 7 (9) of the said rules which is in pari materia with paragraph 11 of g. O. P. No. 646 - the bench held th. It the said 15% unreserved seats must be deemed to be available only to the residents of this state, and that non - resident candidates (non - residents of this state) are not entitled to admission to seats in medical colleges in this state inasmuch as the said paragraph is not at all attracted to the facts of this case, as pointed out above, it is unnecessary for us to express any opinion about the correctness or otherwise of the said decision. Suffice it to say that the principle of the said decision has no application herein.
(23) For the above reasons, the writ petition is allowed, and it is declared that the 5th respondent is and was not eligible for admission to the only seat in d. M. (neurology in osmania medical college. Only the local candidates of telangana local area are eligible to be admitted to the same. The respondents shall forthwith verify as to which candidate among the local candidates of telangana local area has secured the highest ranking, and admit him forthwith to the said seat. Action shall be taken in terms of this direction within five days of the receipt of a copy of this order, since the classes have already commenced about a month ago.
(24) Theie shall be no order as to costs.
(25) Before parting with this case, we think it appropriate to observe that where in a particular super speciality course only one seat is available in the entire state, i. E. , in all the three local areas put together, it would be appropriate to declare such department in that particluar college as a state - wide educational institution, as has already been done in respect of certain departments. We have referred hereinbefore to the fact that "dental - neuro surgery, public health, radio diagnosis and radio therapy departments" in osmania medical college, hyderabad, were declared as slate - wide educational institutions. It is not known as to why the neurology department was not similarly declared. The authorities may consider whether such a course should not be adopted even in respect of neurology department for the future years, and if satisfied, take steps towards amendment of the schedule to the presidential order.
Alert