- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Brij Raj Pershad v. Shantha Devi And Another
(1) The wife filed an application for maintenance against her husband under section 488 cr. P. C. (old). The court after contest, granted rs 30/ - per month. Subsequently applications were filed for enhancement from time to time and the amount was enhanced to rs. 125/. The wife filed an application in m. C. No. 225/87 under section 127 cr. P. C. (new code) for maintenance at the rate of rs. 500/on the file of the addl. Chief metropolitan magistrate, hyderabad. In that application, m. C. No. 320/88 was filed alleging that the court has no jurisdiction as the order was passed by the 4th city magistrate, hyderabad, in m. C. No. 8/61. The addl. Chiaf metropolitan magistrate found that the order of maintenance in m. C. No. 8/6l was not the one passed under the code of 1973 and the court which passed the said order, i. E. , the 4th city magistrate is no longer in existence and the court of the addl. Chief metropolitan magistrate has got jurisdiction. The husband filed the present revision petition challenging that order.
(2) Sri padmanabha reddy contended that the present application filed before the addl. Chief metropolitan magistrate is not maintainable as the addl. Chief metropolitan magistrate is not the "magistrate" contemplated in section 127 cr. P. C. In support of his contention, he relied upon balraj vs. Maliamma. Tn that case, originally maintenance application was filed before the vi metropolitan magistrate in m. C. No. 4/75. That petition was allowed and the husband was ordered to pay maintenance at the rate of rs. 150/ - per month. The wife filed m. C. No. 17/83 again under section 127 cr. P. C. For enhancement of maintenance before the ii metropolitan magistrate, hyderabad. It was in that context that muktadar, j. Has pointed out that the word "magistrate" would mean the magistrate who has passed the first order of maintenance. The word "magistrate" used in sections 125, 126, 127 and 128 was considered. So far as section 128 cr. P. C. Is concerned, the order of maintenance can be executed in any court. If it is a question of enhancement of maintenance as contemplated under section 127 cr. P. C. Is there, the party has to prove the change in the circumstances of any person, receiving under section 125 cr. P. C. A monthly allowance or ordered under the same section to pay a monthly allowance to his wife, child, father, or mother, as the case may be. Sections 125 and 127 cr. P. C. Are interconnected. Unless and until the order has been passed under sec. 125 cr. P. C. Ihe magistrate is not empowered to consider the application under section 127 cr. P. C. Even though it was treated as an independent application. The word used "any other magistrate" in section 125 cr. P. C. Cannot be taken into consideration. Sec. 126 cr. P. C. Contemplated about the jurisdiction of the magistrate.
(3) In the case cited above, the order passed by the vi metropolitan magistrate under section 125 cr. P. C. Was sought to be modified "by filing an application before the ii metropolitan magistrate of the same division. When the original court which passed the order under section 125 cr. P. C. Is in existence, the party, if he wants to seek enhancement, has to file the application for enhancement under section 127 cr. P. C. Before that magistrate only.
(4) Vithal rao vs. Ratnaprabha has considered the effect of filing an application on the same set of facts after an order has been passed. In that context, it has been observed as follows :
"it is true that there is no provision in the code which bars second application under section 488, but when an application under this section has once been heard and decided on merits it would certainly be not proper to allow the parties to agitate the questions which have been once decided, and to take chance of fresh favourable orders either as regards entitlement to maintenance or the quantum of maintenance allowence, when no new substantial facts are alleged and proved".
It was also further held as follows :
"obviously, the effect of alteration in the allowance made under this provision will be to modify the earlier order. As i have indicated above, another magistrate have coextensive jurisdiction would not be able to pass an order w which would have the effect of modifying the earlier order passed by another magistrate. The reliance placed by the learned magistrate upon the provisions of sections 126 and 127 of the code for arriving at the conclusion that second application by the non - applicants is maintainable is obviously erroneous".
(5) On the date when the wife filed an application, the iv city magistrate is not in existence. After the new cr. P. C. Came into force, the courts were re - constituted. When the orginal court is not in existence, we have to find out what is the court that has to try the case under section 125 cr. P. C. If the same court is in existence, the word "magistrate" construed by muktadar. J. Will apply. But when the court is not in existence and when jurisdiction has been conferred in a different court with regard to the trial of cases under section 125 cr. P. C. We have to arrive at the conclusion that the court that is empowered to try the cases under section 125 cr. P. C. Alone is the court that is entitled to consider the application filed under sec. 127 cr. P. C. The notification dated 9 - 4 - 1987 that has been issued confers jurisdiction on the addl. Chief metropolitan magistrate, hyderabad. Ah the metropolitan magistrates are construed to be i class magistrates. They are invested v. Ith the powers to try cases that were being tried by the magistrates. As the notification as such has conferred jurisdiction on the addl. Chief metropolitan magistrate, hyderabad, that court alone is deemed to be the court that has got power or juris diction to try the case filed under section 127 cr. P. C. To make it very clear, as the original court is not in existence and as the present court has been conferred with the trial of cases under section 125 cr. P. C. And as the application, even accordingly to husband, is for enhancement of amou nt, it has to be considered that the newly constituted court will be competent to decide the cases. The addl. Chief. Metropolitan megistrate, hyderabad, in the absence of iv city magistrate who passed the original order, is the competent authority to decide the matter.
(6) In the result, the revision is dismissed.
Alert