Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M. Nadar Kesavan Nadar v. Narayanan Nadar Kunjan Nadar (Dead) By Lrs. .

Supreme Court Of India
Nov 2, 1999
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The litigation concerns 24.5 cents of land. The appellant initially filed OS No. 645 of 1970 seeking declaration, injunction and possession over 1.46 cents. The respondent then instituted OS No. 3 of 1971 for similar reliefs over about 1.60 cents, which encompassed the disputed 24.5-cent parcel. Both suits were tried together.

The trial court held that although the respondents were in physical possession of the 24.5 cents, they had not perfected title by adverse possession because their occupation was not proved to be hostile to the true owner for the requisite 12-year period. Partial reliefs were granted to both sides on other portions of land.

On appeals, the lower appellate court found possession with the respondents for more than 12 years but likewise concluded that hostility and denial of title were not proved. It also observed that the respondents had not even pleaded a prescriptive title in OS No. 3 of 1971.

In second appeal, the High Court reversed these findings, holding that the respondents' possession was adverse, relying particularly on evidence of a demolished wall as indicative of hostile intent. The present appeal challenges that High Court decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondents had perfected title to the disputed 24.5 cents of land by adverse possession.
  2. Whether the High Court, in a second appeal, was justified in re-appraising evidence and overturning concurrent factual findings of the trial court and first appellate court.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court emphasized that both the trial court and the lower appellate court had unequivocally found the respondents failed to prove the essential elements of adverse possession—namely, hostile and open denial of the true owner's title for at least 12 years. These findings placed the burden of proof squarely on the respondents, who did not produce positive evidence to discharge it.

In a second appeal, the High Court’s jurisdiction is confined to substantial questions of law; it cannot revisit concurrent findings of fact unless those findings are shown to be perverse or based on no evidence. The present court noted that the High Court neither identified perversity nor demonstrated lack of evidence. Instead, it re-examined the record and treated the demolition of a wall as decisive proof of hostility, a step the court deemed impermissible.

Because the High Court exceeded its revisional limits and supplanted factual determinations already made by two lower courts, its judgment was held to be legally unsustainable.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED; High Court judgment set aside; order of the lower appellate court restored.

Consequences: The respondents do not obtain title by adverse possession, and the appellant’s rights, as determined by the lower appellate court, stand reinstated. The parties will bear their own costs. The decision reinforces the principle that appellate courts in second appeal cannot disturb concurrent factual findings absent perversity, but it sets no new legal precedent beyond this affirmation.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. The dispute in this appeal pertains to 24.5 cents of land in respect of which a litigation had commenced about 29 years ago.

2. The appellant had filed a suit for declaration, injunction and possession in respect of 1.46 cents of land being OS No. 645 of 1970. Thereafter, the defendant in the said suit filed OS No. 3 of 1971 against the appellant herein. The said suit was also for declaration, injunction and possession in respect of about 1.60 cents of land including therein 24.5 cents of land with which we are concerned in the present case.

3. Both the suits were tried together. The trial court came to the conclusion that insofar as 24.5 cents of land is concerned, which alone is the subject-matter of this appeal, the respondents were in possession of the said 24.5 cents of land but they had not perfected the title by adverse possession inasmuch as there was no evidence to show that their possession was hostile to the real owner and amounted to denial of his title to the property claimed and that it continued for a period of 12 years. It seems that partial relief was granted to both the sides by the trial court but insofar as this parcel of land of 24.5 cents is concerned the claim of title to the same by the respondents on the basis of adverse possession was not accepted.

4. The lower appellate court, on two appeals being filed against the common judgment of the trial court, came to the conclusion that in respect of the parcel of land in dispute, the respondents herein had been in possession for more than 12 years. The lower appellate court however, observed that it had not been established by positive evidence that such possession of the disputed property was hostile to the real owner and in denial of his title. In this connection he noted that the respondents herein, in the suit OS No. 3 of 1971 which was filed had not prayed for declaration of title in respect of this land on the ground of prescription by adverse possession.

5. In second appeal the High Court observed that inasmuch as the lower appellate court had found that the respondents herein had been in possession of this parcel of land for a period of over 12 years, therefore, “assumption of the courts below that there is no evidence of an open, hostile and adverse possession is based on misapprehension of the legal principles”. The High Court noted that the demolition of the wall which had existed on the land in question was an important piece of evidence indicative of the intention of the parties. In view thereof the only inference possible was that the possession of the respondents satisfied the requirements of an adverse possession. The findings of the trial court and the lower appellate court were reversed by the High Court.

6. It appears to us that in second appeal the High Court was in error in examining the evidence and then reversing the finding of the trial court in the lower appellate court by holding that the possession of the respondents satisfied the requirements of adverse possession. Both the trial court and the lower appellate court had, in no uncertain terms, come to the conclusion that the respondents had failed to establish by positive evidence that their possession of the disputed property was hostile to the real owner and in denial of his title. Even if the finding of fact was wrong, in our opinion this finding of fact could not be disturbed specially when the High Court has not come to the conclusion that the same was not perverse nor was based on no evidence. The trial court as well as the lower appellate court have discussed the evidence on the record and then had come to the conclusion that the defence in Suit No. 645 of 1970, namely, the respondents herein, had failed in showing that they had perfected their title by adverse possession. It is to be noted that the issue in this regard placed the burden of proof on the respondents and as they had not led evidence to show that they had perfected that title, their plea had to fail.

7. The High Court in our opinion was therefore not justified in reversing the concurrent finding of fact and for this reason this appeal is allowed by setting aside the impugned order of the High Court and restoring the order of the lower appellate court. Parties will bear their own costs.