Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ex. Constable Chhote Lal v. Union Of India And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Oct 29, 1999
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, a Police Constable, was dismissed from service without a departmental inquiry under Article 311(2), second proviso, clause (b) of the Constitution of India. His departmental appeal was unsuccessful. He then filed an application before the Central Administrative Tribunal, which was dismissed. A subsequent writ petition before the High Court also failed, prompting this appeal before the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the departmental authority was justified in dispensing with a disciplinary inquiry under Article 311(2), second proviso, clause (b) of the Constitution.
  2. Consequent to the legality of dispensing with the inquiry, whether the order of dismissal could be sustained and, if set aside, what relief—particularly back wages—should be granted.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Although the employer has a constitutional power to dispense with an inquiry, Supreme Court jurisprudence sets conditions precedent for exercising that power.
  • Those conditions were not satisfied in the present case, making the dismissal without inquiry unlawful.

Respondents' Arguments

  • As a serving Police Constable, the appellant could influence potential witnesses, undermining the fairness of any departmental inquiry.
  • On this ground, the authorities reasonably concluded that holding an inquiry would not be fair, justifying its dispensation.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court evaluated the competing submissions in light of its own prior jurisprudence on the limited circumstances that justify dispensing with an inquiry under Article 311(2), second proviso, clause (b). It compared those standards with the reasons advanced by the departmental authorities. Finding that the stated apprehension—that the appellant might influence witnesses—did not meet the threshold set by its earlier case-law, the Court concluded that the conditions precedent for bypassing an inquiry were not met. Accordingly, the dismissal order, having been issued without a legally sustainable inquiry, was invalid.

The Court added that while normally reinstatement following an invalid dismissal would carry a claim to back wages, it declined to award back wages in view of the serious nature of the allegations against the appellant.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED. The dismissal order is set aside. The departmental authority is permitted to initiate and complete a proper inquiry, if it so chooses, in accordance with law. No back wages were awarded. The decision affords relief to the appellant but sets no new precedent, instead reinforcing existing standards governing the dispensation of disciplinary inquiries under Article 311(2), second proviso, clause (b).

Show all summary ...

Order

1. Leave granted.

2. The appellant who was a Constable has been dismissed from service by the departmental authority without holding any inquiry and exercising power under Article 311(2), second proviso, clause (b) of the Constitution of India. Having failed in his attempt to get the order of the departmental authority annulled in appeal, the appellant approached the Central Administrative Tribunal (for short “the Tribunal”) mainly contending that in the facts and circumstances of the present case, dispensation of an inquiry is not justified. The Tribunal having dismissed his application, the appellant approached the High Court by way of a writ petition and the High Court having dismissed his writ petition, the appellant is in appeal before this Court.

3. Mr Yadav, learned counsel appearing for the appellant contends that though the employer has the power to dispense with an inquiry under Article 311(2), second proviso, clause (b) of the Constitution but the conditions precedent for exercising that power have now been indicated in several decisions of this Court and in the present case, those conditions precedent cannot be said to have been satisfied. Mr Choudhary, the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondents, on the other hand, contended that the appellant himself being a Police Constable could have influenced the witnesses who would have come in the departmental inquiry and if on that ground the departmental authorities apprehended that the inquiry would not be reasonable and fair, the conclusion cannot be interfered with.

4. Having examined the rival contentions of the parties and bearing in mind the law laid down by this Court indicating the circumstances under which the inquiry under Article 311(2), second proviso, clause (b) of the Constitution can be dispensed with and applying the same to the facts and circumstances and the reasons advanced by the authorities in arriving at the decision, we have no hesitation to come to the conclusion that the order dispensing with the departmental inquiry is not in accordance with law and necessarily the order of dismissal cannot be sustained. We accordingly set aside the order of dismissal passed against the appellant and permit the departmental authority to hold an inquiry if so desired, in accordance with law and come to the conclusion in the said proceeding.

5. Normally, an order of dismissal on being set aside, the employee can claim back wages, but in this case we are not inclined to grant back wages to the employee concerned, more so, in view of the nature of charges against him.

6. This appeal is accordingly allowed.