Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Joginder Singh And Others v. Roshan Lal And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Oct 12, 2001
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Following an advertisement for bookbinder posts, 528 applications were received, including those of the appellants and respondents. Of these applicants, 323 participated in a practical-cum-interview test conducted on 12 and 13 August 1998. The Departmental Selection Committee prepared a select list, pursuant to which the appellants were appointed. [1]

The Punjab and Haryana High Court quashed the selection, concluding that candidates had not received sufficient time to demonstrate their abilities and that the selection process was a farce. [2][3][4] The resulting appeal was brought before the Supreme Court, which granted leave. [5][2]

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court, exercising jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution, was justified in reviewing and quashing the Selection Committee's process merely because numerous candidates were tested over two days. [6]
  2. Whether the selection could be invalidated despite the Committee being properly constituted, the post being advertised, a lawful and fair process being followed, and no allegation of mala fides or bias being made against any Committee member. [6]

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court found no factual justification for the High Court's conclusion that the selection was a farce or that candidates had been denied a fair opportunity. [6]

It reasoned that a High Court exercising jurisdiction under Article 226 does not act as an appellate authority over a Departmental Selection Committee. Where the committee is properly constituted, the post is advertised, and a lawful process fair to all candidates is followed, the High Court cannot reassess whether the committee conducted the test properly in the absence of allegations of mala fides or bias. [6]

The number of candidates examined over two days did not, by itself, establish unfairness. The Court observed that experienced persons are ordinarily appointed to selection committees and that the time required to assess each candidate may vary. Conducting interviews for Class IV posts over two days therefore did not render the process improper. [6]

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED; HIGH COURT JUDGMENT SET ASIDE. Consequently, the respondents' writ petition stood dismissed. [7]

No order was made as to costs. [8] The direct effect was to restore the selection and appointments that the High Court had quashed. [2][1][7] The opinion stated no broader implications or new precedent beyond applying the limits of Article 226 review to this selection process.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. Leave granted.

2. The challenge in this appeal is the decision of the Punjab and Haryana High Court, which by the impugned judgment had quashed the selection of the learner bookbinder which had been conducted by a duly appointed Selection Committee.

3. The respondents had applied along with a large number of candidates for appointment to the post of bookbinder. The process of selection was that of practical-cum-interview test. On the basis of the advertisement, 528 applications, amongst them of the respondents and the appellants, were received; 323 candidates appeared for the test on two days, namely, 12-8-1998 and 13-8-1998. On the basis of the said test, a select list was prepared by the Departmental Selection Committee, whereupon the appellants were appointed.

4. In the judgment under appeal, the High Court observed:

“in its opinion, fair amount of time should be given to each one of the candidates so that he may be able to show his worth, ability as per his intellect, to the members of the Selection Committee”.

The High Court further observed:

“that it had no hesitation to hold that the process of selection was a farce and the fair chance was never given to the candidates to show their worth”.

5. On the facts on record we see no justification for the High Court to have come to this conclusion. The High Court in exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution is not supposed to act as an Appellate Authority over the decision of the Departmental Selection Committee. If the Committee has been properly constituted, as in this case, and the post is advertised and a selection process known to law which is fair to all, is followed, then the High Court could have no jurisdiction to go into a question whether the Departmental Selection Committee conducted the test properly or not when there is no allegation of mala fides or bias against any member of the Committee. Merely because there were a large number of candidates who appeared on two days, cannot ipso facto lead to the conclusion that the process of selection was a farce and fair chance was not given. Normally, experienced persons are appointed as members of the Selection Committee and how much time should be spent with a candidate would vary from person to person. Merely because only two days were spent in conducting the interviews for the selection of Class IV posts cannot lead to the conclusion that the process of selection was not proper.

6. For the aforesaid reason, we allow this appeal and set aside the judgment of the High Court. As a result thereof, the writ petition filed by the respondents stands dismissed.

7. There shall be no order as to costs.