- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bonagiri Veerabhadra Rao And Others v. The Board Of Revenue, Andhra Pradesh And Others
Legal Opinion Summary — P. Satyanarayana Raju, C.J.
Factual and Procedural Background
This opinion arises from two appeals from a common judgment given by Mr. Justice Basi Reddy in two connected writ petitions. The subject lands (total extent Ac. 42-78 cents) are situated in Komaragiri village in the erstwhile Pithapuram estate.
Procedural history (as recorded in the opinion):
- The Assistant Settlement Officer, Kakinada, suo motu initiated proceedings under section 11(a) of the Andhra Pradesh (Andhra Area) Estates (Abolition and Conversion into Ryotwari) Act, 1948 (the "Abolition Act").
- The 6th respondent objected to the grant of a ryotwari patta in favour of the appellants. The appellants claimed the lands were part of an abandoned tank and that they had acquired occupancy rights by assignment from the landholder.
- The Assistant Settlement Officer held the lands to be tank-bed lands but found assignments had been made long prior to 1908; he directed grant of a conditional ryotwari patta (conditions: cultivate only dry crops in the second crop season and not obstruct supply of water to the ayacut).
- Both the appellants and the Government filed revisions before the Settlement Officer, Masulipatam. The Settlement Officer held the lands to be bed of the tank known as "Raju Cheruvu" and held that no ryotwari patta could be granted. The Director of Settlements confirmed that view.
- The Board of Revenue set aside subordinate orders and remanded to decide whether the lands were ryoti or non-ryoti prior to assignment in 1902. On remand the Settlement Officer, Director of Settlements and the Board of Revenue concluded the lands were tank-bed lands within section 3(16)(a) of the Madras Estates Land Act and that appellants were not entitled to a ryotwari patta under section 11(a) of the Abolition Act.
- The appellants filed writ petitions under Article 226 of the Constitution; Mr. Justice Basi Reddy dismissed them on 19 April 1963. The appellants appealed to this Court; these are the appeals now dismissed by the opinion under summary.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the lands in dispute are tank-bed lands (within the meaning of section 3(16)(a) of the Madras Estates Land Act) or ryoti lands.
- If the lands are tank-bed lands, whether assignment or letting of portions of the tank-bed prior to the Madras Estates Land Act (or prior to 1902/1908 as pleaded) converted them into ryoti lands or gave rise to occupancy (ryot) rights.
- Whether the appellants proved occupancy rights by custom, long usage, prescription or title prior to the Madras Estates Land Act sufficient to entitle them to ryotwari pattas under section 11(a) of the Abolition Act.
- Whether concurrent factual findings of subordinate tribunals as to character of the land are open to challenge in writ jurisdiction under Article 226.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments (as recorded)
- Mr. D. Suryaprakasa Rao for the appellants contended the lands did not form part of a tank-bed until about 1942; the tank was created when the landholder raised bunds and the land was thus converted, and tribunals overlooked important evidence.
- He relied on Exhibit P-10 (a survey plan) which, he argued, did not mention "Raju Cheruvu", suggesting the land was not tank-bed.
- He argued that the appellants (or their predecessors-in-title) had acquired occupancy rights prior to the Madras Estates Land Act by assignment, custom or long usage — citing Venkatanarasimha Naidu v. Dandamudu Kotayya as authority that occupancy rights could arise at common law prior to the Act. He relied on certain documents (sale deed Exhibit P-1 and pattas Exhibits P-2 and P-3) to prove title or long possession.
- He challenged the tribunals' factual inferences and urged deletion of the conditional restriction imposed by the Assistant Settlement Officer (raising only dry crops in the second crop season and not obstructing ayacut supply).
Respondents' / Tribunal Position (as recorded)
- The subordinate authorities, the Director of Settlements and the Board of Revenue treated the documentary evidence (notably Exhibit P-4, the 1903 land register, and Exhibit R-5, the 1915 Record of Rights prepared under the Madras Estates Land Act) as showing the lands to be tank-bed lands let on yearly rent by the zamindar.
- The tribunal relied on the presumption in section 167 of the Madras Estates Land Act that entries in the Records of Rights are prima facie correct, placing the burden on appellants to prove the contrary.
- They also treated the question as essentially one of fact and found, on consideration of the oral and documentary evidence, that the lands were tank-bed lands and that assignment or temporary leases did not convert them into ryoti lands.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Boluswamy v. Venkatadari Appa Rao (1917) 47 I.C. 594 | The term "tank-beds" in section 3(16) of the Madras Estates Land Act refers to cultivable parts of a tank-bed capable of cultivation when the tank is dry; such tank-beds being of a class excluded from ryoti land. | The court cited this authority for the proposition that cultivable tank-beds remain tank-beds (non-ryoti) even when cultivated; it supports the conclusion that assignment or temporary cultivation does not convert tank-bed land into ryoti land. |
| Naganna Naidu v. Pitchayya (1929) L.R. 56 I.A. 346 | Held that tank-bed land leased out by the landholder does not cease to be non-ryoti (i.e., it remains tank-bed and is not converted into ryoti land by lease or assignment). | Referenced to support the proposition that assignments/leases of tank-bed land prior to the Madras Estates Land Act do not alter its character as non-ryoti. |
| Ambalam v. Shanmugha Rajeswara Sethupathi (1934) 66 M.L.J. 338 | Section 20 (preserving landholder's right to lease tank-bed lands) does not mean that tank-beds become converted into ryoti lands by being assigned; approved earlier decision in Boluswamy. | The court relied on this decision as affirming the rule that leasing or assignment by the landholder does not transform tank-beds into ryoti lands. |
| Ramaswami Goundar v. Ramaswami Goundar (1942) 2 M.L.J. 595 | A Division Bench held that small parts of the bed of a tank let out for cultivation when water recedes do not lose their character as tank-beds and do not become ryoti. | The court cited this case to reinforce the proposition that temporary cultivation of exposed parts of tank-beds does not change their legal character to ryoti land. |
| Venkatanarasimha Naidu v. Dandamudu Kotayya (1897) I.L.R. 20 Mad. 299 | Cited as authority for the contention that occupancy rights could, at common law, be acquired before the Madras Estates Land Act by prescription, custom or grant. | The appellants relied on this precedent to support the argument that occupancy rights might arise outside the Act; the court, however, treated the point as assumed for argument but held the appellants failed to prove the requisite title or link in the chain to establish such pre-Act occupancy rights. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court conducted a fact‑based and evidence-led analysis, summarized by discrete steps as follows:
- Documentary evidence review: The court noted Exhibit P-4 (the 1903 land register) recorded the lands as "Raju Cheruvu" under the appropriate column and Exhibit R-5 (the 1915 Record of Rights prepared pursuant to the Madras Estates Land Act) showed the lands as tank-bed lands let out on yearly rent by the zamindar.
- Legal presumption: The court invoked section 167 of the Madras Estates Land Act which presumes entries in the Records of Rights to be prima facie correct; consequently, the appellants bore the burden of proving that the lands were not tank-bed lands.
- Evaluation of competing documents: The court accepted the tribunals' finding on the survey plan (Exhibit P-10) — that the plan recorded drinking-water tanks but not irrigation tanks — and noted that the subordinate authorities had carefully considered the other documents relied upon by the appellants.
- Concurrent factual findings and scope of writ review: Because the question whether the lands are tank-bed or not is essentially a question of fact, and because subordinate tribunals vested with jurisdiction under section 11(a) of the Abolition Act had made concurrent findings that the lands were tank-bed, the court emphasized the limited scope of interference under Article 226 and that such concurrent factual findings are normally not open to challenge.
- Precedent application: The court reviewed relevant case law (Boluswamy, Naganna Naidu, Ambalam, Ramaswami Goundar) establishing that assignment or letting of tank-beds for temporary cultivation does not convert them into ryoti lands. It held that temporary cultivation in the upper reaches or exposed parts does not strip the land of its tank-bed character under section 3(16) of the Madras Estates Land Act.
- On the appellants' claim of pre-Act occupancy rights: The court accepted, for argument's sake, that occupancy rights could be acquired outside the statutory scheme (e.g., by custom or prescription), but found the appellants failed to discharge the burden of proof. The sale deed (Exhibit P-1) did not translate into proven possession because subsequent registers still showed zamindar possession; pattas P-2 and P-3 were produced but the appellants could not trace an unbroken link from the purported earlier purchaser to the present assignees.
- Other evidential points: The court observed that the appellants had pleaded abandonment of the tank (a different case) but failed to establish abandonment. There was also evidence (P.W.2) in prior litigation admitting the tank had an ayacut of 200 acres, supporting the characterization of the lands as tank-bed and the zamindar's treatment of them.
- Conclusion from analysis: Given the documentary record, the presumption in the Record of Rights, the concurrent findings of subordinate authorities, and supporting precedents, the court concluded the tribunals' findings were correct and sustainable.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The court dismissed the appeals. The opinion affirms the subordinate authorities' findings that the lands are tank-bed lands and that the appellants are not entitled to ryotwari pattas under section 11(a) of the Abolition Act. The appeals were dismissed and costs were awarded in the first appeal (Advocate's fee Rs. 100).
Implications:
- Direct effect: The appellants' challenge to the Board of Revenue and subordinate tribunal decisions fails; the lands remain characterized as tank-bed lands and no ryotwari pattas are to be granted to the appellants on the basis advanced in these proceedings.
- On broader legal principle: The court applied established precedents to reaffirm the proposition that assignment or temporary cultivation of parts of tank-beds does not convert such lands into ryoti land. The opinion does not indicate the establishment of any new legal principle beyond the application and reaffirmation of existing case law.
This summary is based exclusively on the provided opinion. No information has been inferred beyond what appears in the text.
P. Satyanarayana Raju, C.J:— These two appeals arise out of a common judgment of our learned brother, Mr. Justice Basi Reddy, in two connected writ petitions. The lands covered by the writ petitions, which are of a total extent of Ac. 42-78 cents, are situated in the village of Komaragiri in the erstwhile Pithapuram estate.
2. The Assistant Settlement Officer, Kakinada, suo motu initiated proceedings under section 11(a) of the Andhra Pradesh (Andhra Area) Estates (Abolition and Conversion into Ryotwari) Act XXVI of 1948 (hereinafter referred to as the Abolition Act). Before that Officer, the 6th respondent, one Devarakonda Subbamma, objected to the grant of a ryotwari patta in favour of the appellants. There the appellants filed a statement contending inter alia that the lands in dispute were part of a tank which was abandoned and that by reason of an assignment made by the landholder, they had acquired occupancy rights and that they were, therefore, entitled to a ryotwari patta. The Assistant Settlement Officer held that the lands in question were tank-bed lands, but that they had beer assigned by the landholder long prior to the year 1908. He directed the grant of a ryotwari patta to the appellants subject to the condition that they would raise only dry crops during the second crop season and do not in any way obstruct the supply of water to the lands under the ayacut of the tank. Against the order of the Assistant Settlement Officer, the appellants as well as the Government filed revisions before the Settlement Officer, Masulipatam, the former contending that the condition should be deleted and the Government objecting to the grant of even the conditional patta. The Settlement Officer, Masulipatam, found that the lands in dispute formed the bed of a tank, known as “Raju Cheruvu.” He held that no ryotwari patta could be granted to the appellants. The Director of Settlements confirmed the order of the Settlement Officer. On a further revision being filed by the appellants, the Board of Revenue set aside the orders of the Subordinate Tribunals and remanded the matter to the Settlement Officer with a direction that he should record a finding whether the lands in question were ryoti or non-ryoti prior to their assignment by the landholder in the year 1902. After remand, the Settlement Officer held an enquiry and on a consideration of the evidence, both oral and documentary, found that the disputed lands are tank-bed lands within the meaning of section 3(16)(a) of the Estates Land Act and that the appellants are not entitled to a ryotwari patta under section 11(a) of the Abolition Act. The Director of Settlements agreed with the finding reached by the Settlement Officer. The Board of Revenue confirmed the finding recorded by the Director of Settlements. The appellants then invoked the jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution to quash the orders of the Board of Revenue and the Subordinate Tribunals. By his judgment, dated the 19th of April, 1963, Mr. Justice Basi Reddy dismissed the writ petitions. Aggrieved by the judgment of the learned Judge, the appellants have preferred these appeals. The arguments before us have ranged over a wide ground, but the ultimate issue in controversy between the parties lies within a narrow compass.
3. It is contended by Mr. D. Suryaiprakasa Rao, learned Counsel for the appellants that the lands in dispute did not form part of a tank-bed till the year 1942, that the tank itself came into existence at or about that time, the landholder having raised bunds on the three sides of what is now known as the “Raju Cheruvu” and that the tribunals which dealt with the matter overlooked important pieces of evidence. The learned Counsel for the appellants and the respondents have given us what, according to them, is the real purport of the documents. The Subordinate Tribunals have considered the nature of these documents and they have reached, and in our opinion rightly, the conclusion that the land in dispute were part of the bed of the tank even before the enactment of the Madras Estates Land Act.
4. As seen from Exhibit P-4, the land register of the year 1903, the lands were classified under column 5 as “Raju Cheruvu”. Under column 11, it was stated that there were temporary leases covering the lands. Under column 10, the source of irrigation for the lands was given as Yeleru and under column 12, it was stated that one Inuganti Venkatarayanam Garu was in possession of the lands on behalf of the Raja. The Record of Rights, Exhibit R-5, prepared in the year 1915 pursuant to the provisions of the Madras Estates Land Act, shows all these lands as tank-bed lands let out on yearly rent by the zamindar who owned the Raju Cheruvu Under section 167 of the Madras Estates Land Act, there is a presumption that the entries in the Records of Rights are prima facie correct. It is, therefore, incumbent upon the appellants to prove that the lands were not tank-bed lands. Mr. D. Suryapakasa Rao, learned Counsel for the appellants, relied upon Exhibit P-10 which is a survey plan of the village and has contended that there is no mention of the “Raju Cheruvu” therein. On a comparison of several survey plans of the six neighbouring villages, the Settlement Officer found that this survey plan Exhibit P-10 only mentioned the drinking water tanks and not irrigation tanks. There were other documents relied upon by the learned Counsel for the appellants, all of which were considered with care by the tribunals. There can be little doubt that the question as to whether the lands in dispute are, tank-bed lands or not, is essentially a question of fact. The tribunals which are vested with the jurisdiction to deal with the grant of Tyotwari pattas under section 11 (a) of the Abolition Act, have concurrently found that the lands are tank-bed lands. This finding is based on a consideration of the relevant evidence and normally, therefore, the finding is not open to challenge under the limited jurisdiction vested in this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution.
5. Assuming that the lands are tank-bed lands, the learned Counsel, Mr. D. Suryaprakasa Rao, has argued that the appellants have acquired occupany rights in the lands in question even before the coming into force of the Madras Estates Land Act by reason of the fact that the lands have been assigned to them by the landholder and they having been in possession of the lands ever since. In Boluswamy v. Venkatadn Appa Rao . 1917 47 I.C 594., a Division Bench of the Madras High Court consisting of Abdur Rahim and Bakewell, JJ., held that in using the expression ‘tank-beds’ in section 3(16) of the Madras Estates Land Act, the Legislature was alluding to such class of tank beds as are cultivable, that is, as are being capable of being cultivated when the tank has become dry or when there is no water in the tank in certain years. In Naganna Naidu v. Pitchayya . 1929 L.R 56 I.A 346, their Lordships of the Privy Council held that tank-bed land which was leased out by the landholder to a tenant did not cease to be non-ryoti. In Ambalam v. Shanmugha Rajeswara Sethupathi . 1934 66 M.L.J 338., a Division Bench of the Madras High Court consisting of Ramesam and Venkatasubba Rao, JJ., held that though section 20 of the Act preserves the right of the landholder to lease the tank bed lands, that does not mean that tank beds by being so assigned become converted into ryoti lands. The learned Judges referred with approval the earlier decision of the Madras High Court in Boluswamy v. Venkatadari Appa Rao. In the cases of Boluswamy v. Venkatadri Appa Rao, and Naganna Naidu v. Pitchayya, the assignment was made prior to the enactment of the Madras Estates Land Act. The definition of ryoti land excludes in terms tank-beds. A land is either ryoti or tank-bed and unless it ceases to possess the character of a tank-bed it cannot be ryoti. A later decision of the Madras High Court in Ramaswami Goundar v. Ramaswami Goundar . 1942 2 M.L.J 595, firmly lays down the same principle. There, a Division Bench of the Madras High Court consisting of Leach, C.J, and Lakshmana Rao, J., held that even though small parts of the bed of the tank which had become exposed when the water recedes in the season, were let out to tenants for cultivation, they did not shed their original character of tank-beds and that they did not become ryoti.
6. We, therefore, hold that the assignment of tank-beds situate in the upper reaches of a tank for purposes of temporary cultivation, will not convert them into ryoti land by reason of such cultivation only and that they still retain their character of tank-beds which are within the purview of section 3(16) of the Madras Estates Land Act.
7. Mr. D. Suryaprakasa Rao, learned Counsel for the appellants, has contended that even so, the predecessors-in-title of the appellants must be held to have acquired occupancy rights in the lands in dispute even before the enactment of the Madras Estates Land Act by reason of custom and long usage. According to him, these-lands were in the possession and cultivation of the appellants' predecessors-in-title even as long ago as the year 1842 and he has referred us to the case of Venkatanarasimha Naidu v. Dandamudu Kotayya . 1897 I.L.R 20 Mad. 299 as supporting his contention that occupancy rights could be acquired before the enactment of the Madras Estates Land Act under the common law of the country. We shall now assume for the purposes of this argument that occupancy rights could be acquired otherwise than under the provisions of the Madras Estates Land Act by grant, custom or prescription. But admittedly, the burden of proving that occupancy rights were acquired by reason of custom and long usage lay upon the appellants. The learned Counsel has relied upon a sale deed, Exhibit P-1. This sale deed shows that certain members of the Thota family purchased the lands. But after the date of the sale deed, we have the land register which still shows that the zamindar himself was in possession of the lands. That apart, we have two documents, Exhibits P-2 and P-3, which are pattas granted by the landholder in favour of the predecessors-in-title of the present appellants. Learned Counsel for the appellants has frankly admitted that the assignees of the lands under the pattas granted under Exhibits P-2 and P-3 are not able to trace their title to the vendee under Exhibit P-1. This essential link not having been established, we are not in a position to hold that the appellants had succeeded in proving that they are the assignees from persons who had acquired occupancy rights by custom and long usage even prior to the enactment of the Madras Estates Land Act. We may also point out that the case pleaded by the appellants in their statement filed before the Assistant Settlement Officer was different and that was that the tank itself was abandoned and that the landholder converted it into ryoti land. The appellants have not succeeded in establishing that the lands in dispute were at any time abandoned and that they were converted into ryoti. There are unimpeachable pieces of evidence which show that even long prior to the enactment of the Madras Estates Land Act, the lands were recorded as lands forming part of the tank-bed. In fact, the landholder himself filed a suit for eviction of the tenants on the ground that they had not acquired occupancy rights and P.W 2 who has been examined on behalf of the appellants in the present proceedings, gave evidence in that suit admitting that the tank had an ayacut of 200 acres under it.
8. We are satisfied that the conclusions reached by the learned Judge affirming the findings reached by the tribunals are correct. These appeals, therefore, fail, and are dismissed with costs in the first of them. Advocate's fee Rs. 100.
9. Appeals dismissed.
Alert