- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Veluri Sitarama Sastry And Others v. Isukapalli Sundaramma And Others
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
Two brothers, Veluri Gopalakrishnamurthy and Veluri Seetharama Sastry, filed separate suits (O.S. No. 17 of 1948 and O.S. No. 18 of 1948) in the Court of the Principal Subordinate Judge, Eluru, each seeking partition and separate possession of their respective shares out of property originally belonging to the joint family of their father V. Buchanna Sastry (V.B.S) and his three sons. The subordinate judge tried the suits together and passed a decree concerning certain schedule items.
Krishnamurthy and Seetharama Sastry appealed (A.S. No. 105 of 1953 and A.S. No. 180 of 1953) to the District Court, West Godavari. The Additional District Judge heard those appeals together and held that certain alienations (Exhibits B-20 and B-19) affecting item 9 in the plaint 'B' Schedule (in O.S. No. 17 of 1948) were invalid; he awarded each plaintiff one-eighth share in that item. Second appeals (S.A. Nos. 750 and 751 of 1959) were brought to the High Court; a Division Bench (Chandra Reddy, C.J. and the sitting judge) dismissed those appeals by a common judgment dated 18th November, 1963, confirming the decree as it stood.
During the pronouncement of that Division Bench judgment, counsel for the appellants, Shri T. Veerabhadrayya, orally represented that the share awarded (one-eighth) was incorrect and that the correct share should be one-fourth. The respondent's counsel, Shri P.P. Surya Rao, disputed this representation at that time.
Subsequently, review petitions and related applications were filed: C.M.P. Nos. 11656 and 11657 of 1964 (filed 6 June 1964), S.R. No. 22524 of 1964 (for which delay was excused and later renumbered C.M.P. No. 1147 of 1965), and other procedural C.M.Ps to dispense with certified copies and to amend decree/judgment. The review petitions sought to change the decree to grant each plaintiff one-fourth share (instead of one-eighth) in item 9 of the plaint 'B' Schedule (O.S. No. 17 of 1948) and corresponding item in O.S. No. 18 of 1948.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the judge who was a member of the Division Bench and who continues attached to the Court can hear and decide the review petitions (i.e., jurisdiction under Order 47, rule 5, Civil Procedure Code).
- Whether a review petition under Order 47, rule 1, Civil Procedure Code lies when a petition seeking leave to appeal (S.C.C.M.P / presentation for Supreme Court leave) is presented simultaneously with the review petition — in particular, whether presentation of the S.C.C.M.P amounts to an appeal having been "preferred" for the purpose of Order 47, rule 1.
- Whether the Division Bench's judgment and the underlying lower appellate judgment contained an error apparent on the face of the record (specifically, awarding one-eighth share instead of one-fourth share in a full unit), such that a review under Order 47, rule 1 is justified.
- Whether the failure of counsel for the appellants to press a ground (ground No. 31 in the appeal memo) before the Division Bench constituted abandonment of that ground or merely an oversight that can justify review.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments (counsel: Shri T. Veerabhadrayya)
- The judge sitting singly had jurisdiction to decide the review petitions by virtue of Order 47, rule 5, Civil Procedure Code because he was one of the judges who had been a member of the Division Bench and continued attached to the Court.
- The Division Bench's judgment contained a mistake or error apparent on the face of the record: the lower appellate court had awarded one-eighth share for item 9 in the plaint 'B' Schedule whereas, on the undisputed facts (item 9 being a full unit belonging to the joint family), the correct share for each plaintiff should have been one-fourth.
- The review petitions were properly filed even though an S.C.C.M.P (petition for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court) was presented simultaneously; simultaneous presentation does not preclude filing a review petition because the crucial date for Order 47, rule 1 is the date of filing the review and the appeal must not have already been preferred earlier than that date.
Respondents' Arguments (counsel: Shri P.P. Surya Rao)
- Preliminary objection: a review petition does not lie if, at the time of filing the review petition, an appeal has already been preferred. The presentation of the S.C.C.M.P (petition for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court) amounted to preferring an appeal for the purposes of Order 47, rule 1.
- At the time of pronouncement before the Division Bench, the respondent's counsel disputed the appellants' oral assertion that one-eighth was a mistake and that one-fourth should have been awarded.
- Relied on authorities (such as Venkayya v. Surynaravana and Sabapathi v. V.S. Subraya) to contend that if a question was raised and abandoned at the appellate stage, review jurisdiction should not normally be invoked.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Re Chenna Reddy (Madras High Court practice extract) | The practice that where a Judge who passed the decree continues attached to the Court, that Judge shall hear the review (Order 47, rule 5, C.P.C.). | The court accepted that the judge who had been a member of the Division Bench and continued attached to the Court could hear the review petition sitting singly. |
| Aubhoy Churn Mohunt v. Shamont Lochun Mohunt, 1889 I.L.R. 16 Cal. 788 | Authority approved in the Madras High Court decision extracted in the opinion (used to support the practice stated in re Chenna Reddy). | Cited with approval as supporting the rule that the same judge(s) who heard the appeal should hear the review when they continue attached to the Court. |
| Thungabhadra Industries v. Government of Andhra Pradesh (Tungabhadra Industries, Ltd. v. Government of Andhra Pradesh) | Clarifies that the crucial date for Order 47, rule 1 is the date when the review application is filed; if on that date no appeal has been filed, the court may dispose the review on merits (subject to loss of jurisdiction if the appeal is later decided). | The court relied on this principle to determine that a review petition is maintainable if, on the date of filing, an appeal had not already been preferred; the decision informed the interpretation that simultaneous presentation of appeal papers and review petition may be permissible. |
| Secretary of State v. Hindusthan Cooperative Insurance Society, Ltd. | Dealt with timing issues between filing for leave to appeal and filing a review petition; observations suggesting review should normally be filed before seeking leave, though the exact issue of simultaneous filing did not arise in that case. | The court noted that the case had different factual dates and therefore was not decisive; it observed that the earlier judicial remarks were of a general nature and did not resolve the precise question of simultaneous filing. |
| Rekanti Chinna Govinda Chettiar v. S. Varadappa Chettiar | Held that even absent an error apparent on the face of the record, a mistake of counsel leading to errors in the judgment may justify review. | The court relied on this authority to support the proposition that counsel's oversight (failing to point out the one-eighth/one-fourth mistake) could be analogous to an error apparent and justify review. |
| Gangamma v. Venkanna | Applied Rekanti Chinna Govinda Chettiar to allow review where counsel failed to point out an omission (e.g., hearing without evidence for a defendant). | Followed as an example where review was permitted for counsel's failures; used to support allowing review in the present case for counsel's oversight. |
| Jamna Kuer v. Lal Bahadur (1950 S.C.J. 117) | Illustrates that errors apparent on the face of the record relating to misdescription of claimed items justify review; error can be apparent regardless whether caused by counsel or court. | Quoted to show that an error apparent on the face of the record is a recognized ground for review and that such errors permit the Court to exercise review jurisdiction. |
| Venkayya v. Surynaravana, A.I.R. 1940 Mad. 203 | Holds that where a specific question raised by the plaintiff was abandoned as a result of the plaintiff's pleader's erroneous view, the Court cannot interfere under Order 47, rule 1 in ordinary circumstances. | The court considered this authority but distinguished the present facts, finding that counsel had not abandoned ground No. 31 but had merely forgotten to argue it by oversight. |
| Sabapathi v. V.S. Subraya | Holds that a party who raised a question and then abandoned it on appeal cannot ordinarily re-agitate it by review. | The court noted this authority but concluded on the facts that the appellant's counsel had not abandoned the point; therefore Sabapathi did not bar review here. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded in two broad analytic strands: (A) jurisdiction to hear the review petitions, and (B) whether an error apparent on the face of the record existed that justified review.
(A) Jurisdiction to hear the review petitions
- The court accepted the petitioners' contention that a judge who was one of the members of the Bench which passed the decree and who continues attached to the Court may hear the review petition alone, relying on the express wording of Order 47, rule 5, C.P.C. and the Madras High Court practice extracted in re Chenna Reddy. The judge who was part of the Division Bench satisfied that condition and therefore had jurisdiction to hear the review petitions sitting singly.
- On whether a review petition could be filed where an appeal has been "preferred," the court analyzed the language of Order 47, rule 1, focusing on the critical timing question: the "crucial date" is the date when the application for review is filed. The court relied on Thungabhadra/Tungabhadra authority, which held that if on the filing date of the review no appeal has been filed, the review may be entertained, though jurisdiction may end if the appeal is later decided before the review is disposed.
- The court examined procedural rules governing presentation of appeals to the Supreme Court (Order 16, rule 2 of the Supreme Court Rules and Order 41, rule 1; and the provisions of Order 45 of the C.P.C. concerning petitions for certificates and admission). From those rules the court concluded that presentation of the S.C.C.M.P in the High Court effectively constitutes presentation/preferring of an appeal to the Supreme Court because: (i) presentation in the High Court with grounds and prayer for certificate is the act of presenting the petition for leave; (ii) after the High Court's formalities the appeal, when admitted, places the petitioner in the position of an appellant even before lodging the petition of appeal in the Supreme Court; and (iii) rules permitting withdrawal of appeal by an appellant prior to lodging the petition indicate an appellant exists once the High Court grants certificate/admission.
- On the specific facts, the S.C.C.M.P (petition for leave) and the review petition were presented simultaneously. The court held that simultaneous presentation of the S.C.C.M.P and the review petition did not preclude filing the review petition: the review is valid so long as the appeal has not already been preferred earlier than the time when the review petition was presented. The contention that presentation of the S.C.C.M.P counts as preferring the appeal was accepted in principle, but simultaneous presentation does not bar the review because neither act had been a completed earlier act when the review petition was filed.
(B) Error apparent on the face of the record
- The court examined the factual and schedule descriptions. It noted that many schedule items were half-shares in larger units, but items 9 (and 10) of the plaint 'B' Schedule were full units, not half-units. The lower appellate judge had proceeded under a mistaken impression that every schedule item was a half of a unit, and therefore erroneously described each plaintiff's share as one-eighth in 'B' Schedule rather than one-fourth with respect to full-unit items.
- The court found that, given the undisputed facts (joint family property with each son entitled to one-fourth), the Additional District Judge's award of one-eighth for item 9 was a mistake apparent on the face of the record — a patent arithmetic/description error arising from a wrong assumption about the character of item 9.
- The court considered whether the omission to argue ground No. 31 (which specifically asserted that the lower court should have granted one-fourth) amounted to abandonment. It reviewed authorities (Venkayya, Sabapathi) holding that an abandoned point cannot ordinarily be revived by review. On the facts, however, the court concluded that counsel for the appellants had not abandoned ground No. 31 but had merely forgotten to argue it by oversight. The court relied on Rekanti Chinna Govinda Chettiar, Gangamma and Jamna Kuer authorities to accept that counsel's oversight (or a mistake of counsel) may be analogous to an error apparent on the face of the record and may warrant review.
- Balancing the authorities and the undisputed factual matrix, the court concluded there was a clear error apparent on the face of the record (one-eighth in place of one-fourth) and that review jurisdiction properly lay. The court therefore decided the review petitions on merits and corrected the decree accordingly.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The court allowed the review petitions and corrected the decree. Concretely, the court allowed C.M.P. Nos. 11657 of 1964 and 1147 of 1965 and reviewed the Division Bench judgment dated 18th November, 1963 in S.A. Nos. 750 and 751 of 1959 by granting a decree for partition and separate possession of one-fourth share in the property which is item 9 in the 'B' Schedule in O.S. No. 17 of 1948 (and item 6 in the 'B' Schedule in O.S. No. 18 of 1948).
The court also noted that, in view of the order allowing the two review petitions, counsel did not press certain related C.M.Ps and the court dismissed C.M.P. Nos. 11655 and 11656 of 1964. The court made no order as to costs in these petitions.
Implications: The direct effect is the amendment of the decree to award each petitioner one-fourth share in the identified schedule item(s) and dismissal of two ancillary C.M.Ps; the opinion does not purport to establish a broader new precedent beyond the application of existing rules on review jurisdiction and error apparent on the face of the record as applied to the specific facts.
1. Veluri Gopalakrishnamurthy filed O.S No. 17 of 1948 in the Court of the Principal Subordinate Judge, Eluru, praying for partition of plaint schedule properties and for separate possession of his share. His brother, Veluri Seetharama Sastry, filed O.S No. 18 of 1948 for partition and for separate possession of his share. Each of them asked for share out of joint family property which originally belonged to the joint family of their father, V Buchanna Sastry (V.B.S) and three sons including two plaintiffs. The learned Subordinate Judge tried two suits together and awarded a decree regarding certain items. Krisnamurthy filed A.S No. 105 of 1953 and Seetharama Sastry filed A.S No. 180 of 1953 in the District Court, West Godavari. The learned Additional District Judge, West Godavari, heard the two appeals together and passed a common judgment in which he held ha??? the alienations under two documents (Exhibit B-20 and Exhibit B-19) regarding ???m 9 in the ‘B’ Schedule in O.S No. 17 of 1948 (which is item 6 in plaint ‘B’ Schedule in O.S No. 18 of 1348) were not valid and binding on the plaintiffs and he awarded a decree for partition and for separate possession to each plaintiff of one-eighth share of this item. Seetharama Sastry filed S.A No. 750 of 195??? and Krishnamurthy filed S.A No. 751 of 1959 against the common judgment of the learned Additional District Judge. By common consent, the two appeals were heard together by a Division Bench consisting of Chandra Reddy, C.J and myself. Along with these two appeals, we also heard a memorandum of cross objections which was Med by some defendants contending that the alienations under Exhibits B-2) and B-19 were valid and binding on the plaintiffs S??? C??? Sankara Sastry argued two appeals on behalf of the appelants in great d??? he did not urge before us that the one-eighth share awarded by the le??? Additional District Judge was wrongly awarded instad of one-fourth share ??? was the correct share. I pronounced judgment of the Division Bench sitting singly in my chambers. While I was pronouncing judgment Shri T. Veerabhadrayya, who appeared before me on behalf of the appellant mentioned that the one-eighth share mentioned in the judgment of the learned Additional District Judge was not correct and that he ought to have mentioned one-fourth share. Shri P.P Surya Rao, who appeared for the respondent at that time did not agree with the statement of Shri T. Veerabhadrayya. I completed pronouncing the judgment of the Division Bench on 18th November, 19??/3, dismissing S.A Nos. 750 and 751 of 1959 and also dismissing the Memorandum of cross-objections. Subsequently, Shri T. Veerabhadrayya filed these petitions C.M.P Nos. 11656 and 11657 of 1964 on 6th June 1964. He also filed along with them S.R No. 22524 of 1964 together with a petition (C.M.P No. 11653 of 1964) for excusing delay in filing S.R No. 22524 of 1964. I allowed that petition, Thereupon, S.R No. 22524 of 1964 was numbered as C.M.P No. 1147 of 1965.
2. C.M.P No. 11654 of 1964 was filed to dispense with certified copy of judgment I allowed it. C.M.P No. 11657 of 1964 by Krishnamurthy and C.M.P No. 1147 of 1965 by Seetharama Sastry praying for reviewing the Bench judgment in S.A Nos. 750 and 751 of 1959 by granting decree for partition and separate possession of one-fourth share instead of one-eighth share in item 9 out of plaint ‘B’ Schedule as mentioned in O.S No. 17 of 1948. C.M.P Nos. 11655 and 11656 of 1964 are filed to amend the decree and judgment.
3. Shri T. Veerabhadrayya, the learned Advocate for the petitioners, contends that I, sitting singly, have jurisdiction to pass order on the review petitions. This contention is correct in view of the express wording of Order 47, rule 5, Civil Procedure Code, and the decision of the Madras High Court in Chenna Reddy, In re1. Order 47, rule 5, Civil Procedure Code, runs at follows:—
“Where the Judge or Judges, or any one of the Judges, who passed the decree or made the order, a review of which is applied for, continues or continue attached to the Court at the time when the application for a review is presented…………such Judge or Judges or any of them shall hear the application, and no other Judge or Judges of the Court shall hear the same.”
4. I am the Judge who passed the decree and judgment in S.A Nos. 750 and 751 of 1959 and continue attached to the Court. In re Chenna Reddy, Somayya, J., held according to the invariable practice of the Madras High Court, the application for review has to be heard and decided only by the Judges who heard the appeal or where one of them is absent, by the other Judge sitting alone and that it cannot be heard by another Bench. The learned Judge extracted with approval a passage from Aubhoy Churn Mohunt v. Shamont Lochun Mohunt . 1889 I.L.R 16 Cal. 788..
5. Shri P.P Surya Rao, the learned Advocate for the respondents, has raised a preliminary objection that the Review Petition does not lie as, at the time of its filing, the petitioner has ‘preferred’ appeal. He further contends that the presentation of S.C.C.M.P with prayer for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against the judgment in the Second Appeals amounted to preferring an appeal for purpose of Order 47, rule I, Civil Procedure Code. The S.C.C.M.P concerned was filed on the same day as the Review Petition. Shri T. Veerabhadrayya says that they are both presented simultaneously. This statement stands unchallenged. There is no room to doubt the correctness of that statement.
6. Order 47, rule I, Civil Procedure Code, runs as follows;
7. Any person considering himself aggrieved—
(a) by a decree or order, from which an appeal is allowed, but from which no appeal has been preferred…………………………………….on account of some mistake or error apparent on the face of the record, or for any other sufficient reasons, desires to obtain a review…………………………………may apply for a review”
8. The question is whether ‘no appeal has been preferred’ at the relevant point of time. In Thungabhadra Industries v. Government of Andhra Pradesh, it was observed as follows (at page 1376):
“The crucial date for determining, whether or, not the terms of Order 47, rule 1(1). are satisfied, is the date when the application for review is; filed. If on that date no appeal has been filed is competent for the Court hearing the petition for review to dispose of the application on the merits notwithstanding the pendency of the appeal, subject only to this, that, if before the application for review is finally decided, the appeal itself has been disposed of, the jurisdiction of the Court hearing the Review Petition would come to an end.”
9. Lordships also observed earlier as follows (at page 1376):
“Order 47, rule 1(1) of the Civil Procedure Code permits an application for review being filed ‘from a decree or order from which an appeal is allowed but from which no appeal has been preferred.’ In the present case, it would be seen, on the date when the application for review was filed, the appellant had not filed an appeal to this Court and therefore the terms of Order 47, rule 1(1) did not stand in the way of the petition for review being entertained.”
10. In that case the relevant dates are seen from the following passage in the judgment of the Supreme Court (at page 1376):
“As already seen, the applications for reviewing the order dated 4th September, 1959, refusing the certificate, were filed on 23rd November 1959. During the pendency of these review application, the appellant filed on 30th November, 1959, petitions seeking Special Leave of this Court under Article 136 of the Constitution but those petitions were filed beyond the period of limitation prescribed by the Rules…………… the petitions for Sepecial Leave never legally came on the file of this Court”
11. Apparently, the delay in fling was not excused and the petitions for Special Leave were dismissed as not filed in time. The review applications were disposed of on 6th January, 1961 by the High Court. Their Lordships of the Supreme Court in interpreting the wording of Order 47, rule 1, Civil Procedure Code, indicated that the petition for review would not lie if, on the date on which the application for review was filed, ‘the appellant had not (already) filed an appeal to this Court.’ The word ‘already’ is not found in the above passage but the use of the words ‘had not filed an appeal’ as distinguished from the words ‘did not file an appeal’ indicates that petition for review would lie if ???ing of an appeal had not already been done as a completed, act when the Review Petition was being presented.
12. Shri P.P Surya Rao for the respondents contends that the date of preferring of appeal for the purpose ot Order 47, rule 1, Civil Procedure Code, is the date on which the S.C.C.M.P was presented in this High Court. Sri. T. Veerabhadayya for the petitioners, on the other hand, contends that it is not the date of preferring the appeal but the date on which the petition of appeal is lodged in the Supreme Court under Order 16, rule 2, which should be treated as the date on which the appeal is preferred. Order 16, rule 2, of the Supreme Court Rules. 1950, runs as follows:—
“The appellant shall lodge his petition of appeal within a period of forty-five days from the date of the service of notice of despatch of the record by the Registrar of the Court appealed from………The appellant shall, along with the petition of appeal, lodge sufficient number of copies of the same for service on the respondents ……”
13. Order 41, rule 1, Civil Procedure Code, runs as follows:—
“Every appeal shall be preferred in the form of a Memorandum signed by the appellant or his pleader and presented to the Court or to such officer as it appoints in this behalf.”
14. This indicates that the presentation of the appeal memorandum amounts to preferring the appeal. Order 45, rule 2, Civil Procedure Code, says that whoever desires to appeal to the Supreme Court shall apply by petition to the Court whose decree is complained of (hereafter referred for convenience as High Court). Order 45, rule 3(1), Civil Procedure Code, says that every petition shall state the grounds of appeal and pray for a certificate. Order 45 rule 7 Civil Procedure Code, provides that where the certificate is granted, the petitioner should furnish security etc. Rule 8, Order 45, Civil Procedure Code, provides that where security has been furnished and deposit made to the satisfaction of the Court, the Court shall (a) declare the appeal admitted. It would appear from the above Rules that (i) presentation consists of only the S.C.C.M.P along with the grounds; (ii) such presentation is in the High Court, and (iii) after formalities are fulfilled as required by the rules, the appeal is declared as admitted by the High Court itself. Thus, preservation of S.C.C.M.P in effect amounts to presentation of appeal to the Supreme Court.
15. Order 12, rule 1 of the Supreme Court Rules, says:—
“Subject to any special directions which the Court may give-in any particular case, the provisions of Order 45 of the Code…………….. …..shall apply in relation to appeals preferred under Articles 132(1), 133(1) and 135 of the Constitution.”
16. Rule 2 of Order 12 of the Supreme Court Rules mentions as follows:—
“An appellant who has obtained a certificate from the High Court may, at any time prior to the making of an order admitting the appeal, withdraw the appeal x x x x x x x.”
17. This clearly shows that when the certificate is obtained by a person from the High Court, in effect, an appeal has been admitted and he is an appellant who ??? presented an appeal and is in a position to withdraw the appeal. Order 16, rule 6 mentions as follows:—
“Where an appellant who has not lodged his petition of appeal desires to withdraw his appeal, he shall make an application to that effect to the Registrar x x x x x x”
18. This also clearly indicates that even before lodging of a petitition of appeal as contemplated in rule 2 of Order 16, the person concerned is in the position of an appellant and is in a position to withdraw the appeal. Thus, it is obvious that the appellant already exists on the record even before petition of appeal is lodged to the Supreme Court under Order 16, rule 2 and that the order under Order 45, rule 8, Civil Procedure Code, amounts to admitting the appeal. It follows that the presentation of the S.C.C.M.P itself amounts to presentation of the appeal or preferring the appeal, The contention of Shri P.P Surya Rao in this respect is tenable and I accept it.
19. In the present case the S.C.C.M.P concerned and the Review Petition were presented simultaneously. Shri P.P Surya Rao relies on the decision in The Secretary of State v. Hindusthan Cooperative Insurance Society, Ltd.. In that case, the relevant dates were as follows. On 25th January, 1929, the High Court pronounced judgment. On 22nd April, 1929 the Secretary of State applied for leave to appeal to the Privy Council. On 2nd July, 1929 leave was granted, The Privy Council disposed of the appeal on 20th March, 1931 holding that the appeal did not lie. Review Petition was filed by the Secretary of State on 12th July, 1931. Meanwhile, the Hindusthan Insurance Society also had applied for review on 22nd April, 1929 and had made an application for leave to appeal to the Privy Council on 17th May 1929. The question arose whether there was sufficient cause for the delay by the Secretary of State in filing the review petition. The case was heard by a Division Bench. Ghose, C.J, held that sufficient cause had not been made out for excusing the delay between the date when leave to appeal to the Privy Council was applied tor and the date when the Privy Council pronounced judgment (time between 20th March, 1931 and 12th June, 1931). Mitter, J. also held as follows (at page 177):
“I Would, therefore, rest my decision on the ground that no explanation has been given as to why the review was not filed between the date of judgment and the application for leave to His Majesty-in-Council.”
20. While dealing with the case, Mitter, J., also made an observation as follows (at page 176):
“It appears to me that the scheme of the order relating to review in the Civil Procedure Code is that in those cases in which an appeal lies, the application for review should be filed before the appeal is lodged. In this case, at any rate, the Secretary of State thought that an appeal would lie to His Majesty-in-Council against the order of the High Court……I fail to understand why in the circumstances, the application for review was not made prior to the filing of the application for leave. There seems to be no reasonable excuse for this course.”
21. In that case, the application for leave to appeal to the Privy Council was not tiled on the same date as the date on which the review petition was filed. The question as to whether review petition could be validly filed simultaneously along with a petition for leave to appeal to the Privy Council did not arise and was not decided in that case. Therefore, the observation of Mitter, J., was only of a general nature.
22. The words ‘has been filed’ refer to a completed action. Under Order 47, rule 1, Civil Procedure Code, a petition for review would not lie only when an appeal has already been preferred as mentioned by me. In effect, on the wording of Order 47, rule 1, Civil Procedure Code, a person aggrieved can file a review petition if no appeal has been preferred, that is, if no appeal has already been presented earlier than the time when Review Petition was presented. Therefore, review petition can be validly presented so long as it is not filed after the presentaion of an appeal petition. It is tenable when presented simultaneously with presentation of S.C.C.M.P
23. Shri T. Veerabhadrnyya contends that the decree of this Court in S.A Nos. 750 and 751 of 1959 were passed on account of mistake or error apparent on the face of the record.
24. The learned Additional District Judge mentioned in para. 3 of his judgment as follows:—
“The property acquired by the plaintiff and defendants 1 and 2 under the gift-deed (Exhibit A-11) is shown as ‘A’ Schedule in the plaint, The property belonging to the family consisting of the plaintiff, defendants 1 and 2 and V.B.S (father of plaintiff and defendants 1 and 2) is mentioned as ‘B’ Schedule in the plaint, As I have already stated, Sitaramaswamy (father of V.B.S and paternal grandfather of plaintiffs and defendants 1 and 2) conveyed his undivided half share in the proportion mentioned in Exhibit A-11 to his grandsons viz., the plantiff and defendants 1 and 2 and therefore each of the donees acquired 1/6th share in the plaint ‘A’ Schedule properties by virtue of Exhibit A-11. The plaintiff and defendants 1 and 2 are entitled to 1/8th share each in the plaint ‘B’ Schedule properties.”
25. Beyond doubt or dispute, there was joint family consisting of V.B.S and his three sons and it had joint family property. Each of them was admittedly entitled to one-fourth share of that joint family property. So, each of them was really entitled to one-fourth of each item of joint family property shown in ‘B’ Schedule. The eldest son did not question the alienation within the period of limitation. The two younger sons each filed a suit claiming his share. There were seven items in ‘A’ Schedule in O.S No. 17 of 1948 which I am taking as basis for discussion for the purpose of convenient reference. Each of items 1 to 7 consisted of joint half share in a bigger unit. For example, item 1 is joint half share in S No. 332/2. For convenience in discussion, I shall refer to the whole of S. No. 332/2 as a ‘unit’ so that item 1 is half of the ‘unit’. Similarly, in ‘B’ Schedule in O.S No. 17 of 1948, there were ten items, Of these items 2 to 8 consisted of a joint half share in a bigger unit, But, each of items 9 and 10 was a full unit. Neither of them was described as half share in a bigger unit. The shares which each of the plaintiffs claimed was one-third of each item in ‘A’ Schedule (as it was property which was acquired by gift only by the three brothers—their father (V.B.S) had no share in it) and one-fourth share in each of the items in ‘B’ Schedule As regards each of the items in ‘A’ and ‘B’ Schedules, which was itself half-share of a bigger unit, claim of each of the plaintiffs could be treated as one-sixth share of the respective bigger unit in Schedule ‘A’ and one-eighth share of the bigger unit in Schedule ‘B’. Regarding these items, the learned Additional District Judge would have been right if he had meant and mentioned the share of each plaintiff as one-sixth share and one-eighth share in each of those bigger units concerned and not as one-sixth and one-eighth share in each of those items mentioned in Schedules “A” and ‘B.’ But this mention of one-eighth share was not correct and could not be correct regarding items in ‘B’ Schedule (items 8 and 9) which consisted of whole units and not half share of individual units. The learned Additional District Judge was under a wrong impression that each and every item in each Schedule was half of a unit and he failed to note that item 8 and item 9 were full units. He committed a mistake in describing the share of the plaintiff as one-sixth of each item in ‘A’ Schedule and one-eighth of each item in ‘B’ Schedule instead of as one-third of each item in ‘A’ Schedule and one-fourth of each item in ‘B’ Schedule
26. At the end of para. 10 of his judgment, the learned Additional District Judge held that property which was sold under Exhibit B-20 was joint family property (belonging to V.B.S and his three sons). The same property (concerned in Exhibit B-20) was also concerned in Exhibit B-19. On are basis of these findings, he gave his final finding in para, 53 of his judgment as follows:—
“In the circumstances, I hold that alienations under Exhibit B-20 and Exhibit B-19 item 9 of the Plaint ‘B’ Schedule are not valid and binding on the plaintiffs. Consequently, the suits, have to be decreed for partition and separate possession of 1/18th share of plaintiff in each suit in that item viz., item 9 of the plaint ‘B’ Schedule.”
27. Item 9 of the plaint ‘B’ schedule in O.S No. 17 of 1948 is a full unit and not half of a unit. He obviously committed a mistake in mentioning one-eighth share instead of one-fourth share. Item 9 of ‘B’ Schedule in O.S No. 17 of 1948 was item 6 of ‘B’, Schedule in O.S No. 18 of 1948.
28. In the judgment in the Second Appeals, this Court agreed with the finding of the learned Subordinate Judge that the alienations under Exhibits B-20 and B-19 were not valid and binding on the plaintiff. The abovementioned mistake in the lower appellate Court's judgment was not brought to our notice or argued about, though there were very elaborate arguments adduced before us on other points in great detail by Sri Sankara Sastry, the learned Advocate for the appellants. But, in the appeal memo, there was a ground relating to this. Ground No. 31 in S.A No. 750 of 1959 is as follows:—
“The lower Court ought to have granted a decree for partition and separate possession of ¼th share in item 9 of the plaint ‘B’ Schedule instead of 1/8th share therein even on its findings.”
29. In the appeal memo, in S.A No. 751 of 1959, reference was made to the grounds of appeal in S.A No. 750 of 1959. As this point was not brought to our notice or argued, we dismissed the second appeals and confirmed the decree of the lower appellate Court as they stood. When I was pronouncing judgment, Shri T. Veerabhadrayya, who reprensented the appellants, said that there was an error in the lower appellate Court's judgment by awarding decrees for one-eighth share instead of one-fourth share. At that time, I was pronouncing judgment in my chambers sitting singly but the judgment was of a Division Bench consisting of Chandra Reddy, C.J and myself. Shri P.P Surya Rao for the respondents disputed the contention of Shri T. Veerabhadrayya. In those circumstances, I completed pronouncing the judgment.
30. In Tungabhadra Industries, Ltd. v. Government of Andhra Pradesh, it was observed as follows (at page 1377):
“A review is by no means an appeal in disguise whereby an erroneous decision is reheard and corrected, but lies only for a patent error. We do not consider that this furnishes a suitable occasion for dealing with this difference exhaustively or in any great detail but it would suffice for us to say that where without any elaborate argument one could point to the error and say here is a substantial point of law which stares one in the face, and there could reasonably be no two opinions entertained about, a clear case of error apparent on the face of the record would be made out. No questions of fact were involved in the decision of the High Court in T.R.C Nos. 75 to 77 of 1956. The entire controversy turned on the proper interpretation of rule 18(1) of the Turnover and Assessment Rules and the other pieces of legislation which are referred to by the High Court in its order of February 1956; nor could it be doubted or disputed that these were substantial questions of law. In the circumstances therefore, the submission of the appellant that the order of September, 1959 was vitiated by ‘error apparent’ of the kind envisaged by Order 47, rule 1, Civil Procedure Code, when it stated that ‘no substantial question of law arose’ appears to us to be clearly well founded”
31. In the present case also, there was no need for any elaborate argument to show that ‘one-eighth’ was written as a mistake while ‘one-fourth’ alone could have been meant and ought to have been written as share of the plaintiff on facts relevant to share which were undisputed, If the learned Advocate for the appellants had merely pointed out the undisputed facts during arguments, it would have been sufficent to show that the learned Additional District Judge put one-eighth share as mistake for one fourth share in para 53 of his Judgment. So, I find that there was mistake or error apparent on the face of the record and that the learned Advocate for the appellants, by oversight, forgot to point it out at the time of arguments.
32. In Rekanti Chinna Govinda Chettiar v. S. Varadappa Chettiar, though there was no error apparent on the face of the record, still there was a mistake of Counsel leading to errors in the judgment. It was held that judgment could be reviewed. Patanjali Sasttri, J. (as he then was) observed as follows (at page 18):
“There was of course no mistake or error apparent on the face of the record in this case. If there were, that would obviously be a sufficient ground by itself for a review. But the misapprehension owing to which the learned Counsel for the respondents says he did not urge all his arguments in support of the finding recorded in favour of his clients by the first Court, and the consequent erroneous impression on the part of the learned Subordinate Judge, seem, to my mind, to be analogous enough to an error apparent on the face of the record to be a sufficent reason for review under Order 47, rule 1, Civil Procedure Code.”
33. The learned Judge referred with approval to prior decisions of Rangoon and Madras High Court.
34. In Gangamma v. Venkanna, the above decision of the Madras High Court in Rekanti Chinna Govinda Chettiar v. S. Varadappa Chettiar was followed and it was held that review should be allowed when the Counsel had failed to point out to the appellate Court that the suit had been heard without taking evidence on behalf of the defendant.
35. In Jamna Kuer v. Lal Bahadur . 1950 S.C.J 117 it was observed as follows (at page 132);
“…………..In the result; Mst. Jamna Kuer's appeal was allowed and it was declared that she was entitled to the properties left by Kunj Behari.”
In the concluding portion of the judgment, the learned Judges made a specific declaration to the effect that Jamna Kuer was entitled to 2½ biswas zamindari of village Kaman, the ca??? certificates and the nine shares of the District Co-operative Bank, all entered in the application dated 20th August, 1936 of the applicants under section 4. Encumbered Estates Act. This declaration seems to have been made under some misapprehension as the list filed by the applicants on 20th August, 1936 was not limited to there properties………….. Her claim was not limited to only those properties which had been mentioned by her originally at the foot of her objection petition. It was common ground between the parties that items 3 to 37 in the Gazette Notification of 15th May, 1936 were the property of Kunj Behari and the person who was held to be legal heir was entitled to all those properties……………..
The mistake as to the items of property regarding which Mr. Jamna Kuer had laid claim is apparent on the face of the record…………… Whether the error occurred by reason of the Counsel's mistake or it crept in by reason of an oversight on the part of the Court was not a circumstance which could affect the exercise of jurisdiction of the Court to review its decision……………… A mere look at the trial Court's decision indicates the error apart from anything else.”
36. In the instant case, it was beyond dispute that, if any item of property was held to belong to joint family of V.B.S and his three sons, each of the plaintiffs would be entitled to one-fourth share of that item. So. I find that there is an error apparent on the face of the record.
37. Shri P.P Surya Rao on behalf of the respondents has relied on certain decisions.
38. In Venkayya v. Surynaravana . A.I.R 1940 Mad. 203. it was held by Kunhiraman, J., that, where a specific question involved in an issue that was raised at the instance of the plaintiff has been abandoned as a result of an erroneous view taken by the plaintiff's pleader, Court cannot interfere under Order 47, rule 1, Civil Procedure Code. In this case, I am convinced that Sbri Shankara Sastry did not abandon ground No. 31 in his appeal memo, but only forgot to argue it before us by mere oversight.
39. In Sabapathi v. V.S Subraya, it was held that a party who not only had an opportunity of raising a question, but who did raise it on appeal and on argument abandoned it, cannot, under ordinary circumstances, be allowed to agitate the question under review. As I have already mentioned, on the relevant facts.
40. I hold that Shri Sankara Shastry did not abandon ground No. 31 but only forgot to mention it by oversight.
41. I find that, on the facts of this case, the petitioners' prayers for Review have to be granted.
42. I, therefore, allow C.M.P Nos. 11657 of 1964 and 1147 of 1965, review the judgment dated 18th November, 1963 in S.A Nos. 750 and 751 of 1959 by granting a decree for partition and separate possession of one-fourth share in the property which is item 9 in ‘B’ Schedule in O.S No. 17 of 1948 and item 6 in B Schedule in O.S No. 18 of 1948
43. In view of my order allowing the above two C.M Ps. Sri T. Veerabhadrayya does not press C.M.P Nos. 11655 and 11656 of 1964. I dismiss C.M.P Nos. 11655 and 11656 of 1964. In the circumstances of the case, I make no order as to costs in all these petitions.
44. orders accordengly.
Order 47, rule 1(1)Alert