- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Industrial Associates, 3465, Rashtrapati Road, Secunderabad v. Mohammed Hussain
Structured Summary of the Opinion — Civil Revision Petition concerning Order 38 Rule 5 and Order 21 Rule 46
Factual and Procedural Background
The Civil Revision Petition challenges an order that refused to maintain a prohibitory order issued against garnishees in proceedings for attachment before judgment. The opinion sets out the following facts and procedural history:
- The plaintiff (revision petitioner) sued the respondent for recovery of Rs. 6,282-78.
- A prohibitory order was issued restraining five garnishees from making payments to the respondent under Order 21, Rule 46.
- After that prohibitory order was issued, the defendant (respondent) filed a counter-claim disputing the amount and specifically contended that the plaintiff had not placed material before the Court to show that the defendant was likely to leave the jurisdiction or dispose of property so as to evade any eventual decree; the defendant argued that issuance of a prohibitory order before complying with the conditions of Order 38, Rule 5 was illegal.
- The learned Assistant Judge examined the plaintiff's affidavit and held it did not disclose circumstances justifying a prohibitory order (i.e., it did not show the defendant was about to leave the jurisdiction or dispose of property). The Assistant Judge held the conditions of Order 38, Rule 5 had not been fulfilled before issuing a prohibitory order under Order 21, Rule 46, and accordingly dismissed the petition; an earlier ex parte prohibitory order appears to have been withdrawn.
- The plaintiff challenged that decision by way of this revision petition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the court must comply with the procedure under Order 38, Rule 5 (i.e., give notice to the defendant to furnish security or to show cause) before issuing a prohibitory order to a garnishee in a proceeding for attachment before judgment.
- Whether a prohibitory order sought before judgment can be issued under Order 21, Rule 46 without following the requirements of Order 38, Rule 5, or whether a petition for such relief must be treated as one under Order 38, Rule 5 read with Order 21, Rule 46.
- What legal distinction follows if the petition is simpliciter under Order 21, Rule 46 (execution-attachment context) as opposed to a petition under Order 38, Rule 5 read with Order 21, Rule 46 (attachment before judgment context).
Arguments of the Parties
Revision Petitioner (Plaintiff) — Arguments
- The plaintiff's counsel contended that before issuing a prohibitory order under Order 21 (the opinion alternately cites Rule 45 and Rule 46 in places) to a garnishee, it was not necessary to satisfy the conditions of Order 38, Rule 5, and that no notice to the defendant was necessary at that stage.
- The counsel argued that Order 21, Rule 46 is a specific provision relating to attachment of property in the possession of a person who is a debtor of the judgment-debtor and that recourse to Order 38, Rule 5 need not be had when seeking a prohibitory order prior to judgment.
- The petitioner relied upon Imperial Bank v. Bibi Sayeedan (A.I.R. 1960 Patna 132) in support of the contention that Order 21, Rule 46 alone would govern and that no defendant notice was necessary where a prohibitory order before judgment is sought.
Respondent (Defendant) — Arguments
- The defendant contested the claim and specifically argued that the plaintiff had not produced material to show that the defendant was likely to leave the jurisdiction or dispose of property so as to evade any decree; on that basis he contended issuance of a prohibitory order under Order 21, Rule 46 before complying with Order 38, Rule 5 was illegal.
- After receiving a copy of the ex parte prohibitory order (served under Sub-rule (2) of Rule 46 of Order 21), the defendant objected to the issue of a prohibitory order against the garnishee before a show-cause notice had been issued to him under Order 38, Rule 5.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Imperial Bank v. Bibi Sayeedan, (1) A.I.R. 1960 Patna 132 | Demonstrates a case where an application under Order 38, Rule 5 and Section 151 resulted in simultaneous directions: notice to defendants to show cause and a prohibitory order to the garnishee. | The court interpreted the facts of that case as showing that without a notice to the defendant under Order 38, Rule 5 there could not properly have been a prohibitory order to the garnishee pending suit; the ruling does not support dispensing with the Order 38, Rule 5 requirement when attachment before judgment is sought. |
| R.V. Pandaram & Company v. Surajmal, AIR 1964 Madras 49 | Authority that where a third party prefers a claim to property attached in the hands of a garnishee, the claim must be adjudicated under Order 21, Rule 46-E read with Order 38, Rule 5. | The court observed that this authority supports that petitions can be framed under Order 21, Rule 46 read with Order 38, Rule 5 for prohibitory orders against garnishees, though that case did not decide whether the conditions of Order 38, Rule 5 must be strictly complied with before issuing the prohibitory order. |
| Sri Krishna Gupta v. Ram Babu, (3) AIR 1967 Allahabad 136 | Holds that the Court must direct security to be furnished for specified sums and that an attachment does not come into existence unless the full prescribed procedure for making attachment is completed (case under Order 38, Rule 5 and Order 21, Rule 54). | The court noted this ruling but observed it did not address whether a show-cause notice or direction to furnish security should be issued to the defendant before a prohibitory order is made to a garnishee. |
| Bhagavan Dass v. Santhosh Singh, (4) AIR 1958 Punjab & Haryana | States that an attachment before judgment cannot be an attachment in execution of a decree; it only becomes execution after decree and an application to execute it is made. | The court found this ruling of limited help to the specific question under consideration (i.e., whether Order 38, Rule 5 procedure must precede a prohibitory order to a garnishee before judgment). |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's analysis proceeds in a stepwise manner, adhering closely to the statutory scheme and the authorities cited in the opinion:
- The fundamental distinction identified by the court is between:
- a petition that is simpliciter under Order 21, Rule 46 (the attachment provisions ordinarily invoked in execution of a decree), and
- a petition that seeks attachment before judgment under Order 38, Rule 5 read with Order 21, Rule 46 (i.e., a pre-judgment attachment where the plaintiff must show special circumstances such as intent to obstruct or delay execution of a future decree).
- The court examined the effect of Order 38, Rule 5: it enables attachment before judgment when the plaintiff satisfies the court that the defendant, with intent to obstruct or delay execution of any decree that may be passed, is about to dispose of or remove property. When such an application is made under Order 38, Rule 5(1), the court may direct the defendant to furnish security or to appear and show cause why security should not be furnished.
- On the authorities examined (notably Imperial Bank and R.V. Pandaram), the court concluded that where a prohibitory order in relation to monies in the hands of a garnishee is sought before judgment, the petition must effectively be treated as one under Order 38, Rule 5 read with Order 21, Rule 46, thereby invoking the procedural safeguards of Order 38, Rule 5.
- The court emphasised that the presence of Order 38, Rule 8 (which directs that claims to property attached before judgment be adjudicated in the manner provided for claims in execution) likely explains why parties invoke Order 21, Rule 46 pre-judgment, but that does not relieve the applicant from meeting the conditions of Order 38, Rule 5 when the attachment is before judgment.
- While acknowledging that in urgent cases there may be little interval between giving notice to the defendant and issuing a prohibitory order to the garnishee, the court held that as a matter of law a show-cause notice or direction to the defendant to furnish security cannot be dispensed with when the petition is under Order 38, Rule 5 read with Order 21.
- The court clarified the differing procedural consequence: if the application is strictly a petition under Order 21, Rule 46 (i.e., relating to execution-stage attachment), no notice to the judgment-debtor is necessary; but if the application seeks attachment before judgment, the requirements of Order 38, Rule 5 (notice/show-cause/security) must be observed.
- Applying these principles to the present facts, the court accepted the Assistant Judge's finding that the plaintiff's affidavit did not disclose the required circumstances (no allegation that the defendant was likely to obstruct or evade execution). Given that lack of allegation and the procedural requirements for attachment before judgment, the Assistant Judge correctly withdrew the earlier ex parte prohibitory order and dismissed the petition. Consequently, there were no grounds for interference by way of revision.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The revision petition is dismissed with costs.
Implications (as stated in the opinion):
- Where a prohibitory order in relation to monies or property in the hands of a garnishee is sought before judgment, the petition must be treated as one under Order 38, Rule 5 read with Order 21, Rule 46; the procedural requirements of Order 38, Rule 5 (notice to the defendant to show cause or direction to furnish security) cannot be dispensed with as a matter of law.
- If, however, the petition is strictly a petition simpliciter under Order 21, Rule 46 (procedural context of attachment in execution), no notice to the judgment-debtor is necessary under that provision.
- On the facts of this case, because the plaintiff's affidavit did not disclose the necessary circumstances (likelihood of the defendant evading execution), the prohibitory order was correctly refused and the revision court declined to interfere.
- The opinion does not purport to declare a novel or sweeping new precedent beyond applying existing provisions and authorities to the present factual matrix; its ruling enforces the procedural requirement that Order 38, Rule 5's safeguards attend an attachment before judgment seeking a prohibitory order against a garnishee.
This summary is prepared strictly from the contents of the provided opinion without adding facts or inferences not present in the text.
1. The Civil Revision Petition gives rise to the question whether the procedure under Order 38, Rule 5 have to be gone through by the Court before it issues a prohibitory order to a garnishee, in a proceeding before attachment before judgment. The facts leading to the revision petition, briefly stated are these:
2. The plaintiff-petitioner laid a suit for recovery of Rs. 6,282-78 from the respondent. A prohibitory order was issued against five garnishees under Order 21 Rule 46 restraining them from making payments to the respondents of the sums alleged due by them.
3. After the prohibitory order was issued, the defendant-respondent filed a counter inter alia disputing the amount of claim. It was his specific contention that the plaintiff has not placed any material before the Court to show that the defendant is likely to leave the jurisdiction of the Court or that he was about to dispose of any of his movable or immovable property so as to evade the suit claim in the event of decree and therefore the issue of prohibitory order under Order 21, Rule 46 before complying with the conditions of Order 38, Rule 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure is illegal. The learned Assistant Judge held that the affidavit of the petitioner does not disclose any circumstance for the issue of prohibitory orders in the sense that it does not disclose that the defendant was about to leave the jurisdiction of the Court or was disposing of any of his properties. In other words, the learned Assistant Judge has held that the conditions laid down under Order 38, Rule 5 CPC are not fulfilled before a prohibitory order could he issued to the granishee under Order 21, Rule 46 CPC. He thus dismissed the petition. It would also appear that the earlier exparte prohibitory order was withdrawn. It is this order that is now assisted in this revision petition.
4. The contention of the learned Counsel for the petitioner is, that before a prohibitory order under Order 21, Rule 45 CPC could be issued to a granishee, it is not necessary for the plaintiff to fulfil the conditions of Order 38, Rule 5 CPC and, in fact, no notice to the defendant is equally necessary at that stage. Order 21 Rule 46 CPC relates to the attachment of certain properties in the possession of not the judgment-debtor but a person who can be said to be a debtor of the judgment debtor. This is a provision which can be availed of in the course of execution of a decree. Order 38 Rule 5 enables the plaintiff to have the defendant attached before judgment, when the plaintiff satisfies the Court that the defendant with intent to obstruct or delay the execution or any decree that may be passed again him is about to dispose of the whole or any part of his property, or is about to remove the whole or any part of his property from the local limits of the jurisdiction of the Court. When the plaintiff in a suit makes an application under Order 38 Rule 5(1) CPC, the court may direct the defendant either to furnish security or to appear and show cause why he should not furnish security. The question presently is whether the plaintiff could straight away seek a prohibitory order against the garnishee in a petition purporting to be under Order 21, Rule 46 read with Order 38, Rule 5, without any notice by the Court to the defendant to furnish security or to show cause as to why he should not furnish security for the suit claim. We are not presently concerned with any execution proceeding. In the instant case, the prohibitory order was sought to be issued before judgment. What was contended by the learned counsel for the revision petitioner is, that when there is a specific provision under Order 21, Rule 46, recourse need not be had to Order 38 Rule 5 and that the procedure laid down under the latter order need not be followed and as such, there not need be a notice to the defendant either calling upon him to furnish security or to show cause as to why he should not furnish security. In support of his contention that Order 21, Rule 46 would alone govern a case like this, and that no notice to the defendant is necessary where prohibitory order before judgment is sought, reliance is sought to be placed by the learned Counsel for the petitioner on a ruling of the Patna High Court reported in Imperial Bank v. Bibi Sayeedan (1) A.I.R 1960 Patna 132. The following head note, however, does not bring out the ratio decided therein. The Head note reads as follows:
“An order for attachment before judgment can be issued only against the defendant of the suit as provided in Or. 38, Rule 5. A prohibitory order can be issued against a person, who is not a defendant to the suit, under Order 21, R. 46 When there is a specific provision in the Code, no recourse can be had to the inherent powers of the Court under Section 151”.
5. The facts of that case would disclose that in a money suit for recovery of dower debt brought by the widow of one Nadir Ali against his heirs, she made an application under Order 38 Rule 5 and Section 151 CPC and prayed for the issue of an attachment before judgment. The following was the order made by the Judge:
“Issue notice to defendants to show cause why the attachment before judgment sought should not be allowed. This should be done after plaintiff files requisites by 24-11-1949. Meanwhile, a copy of this order and petition may be forwarded to the Agent of the Imperial Bank of India, at Gaya requesting him not to make payment of this money to any party till further orders”.
6. Thus, while making an application under Order 38, Rule 5 and Section 151 CPC, the plaintiff sought a prohibitory order against the Imperial bank of India where Nadir Ali had some Fixed deposit. The Court, while directing a notice to the defendants, also issued a prohibitory order. Thus, the notice to the defendant as well as the prohibitory order against the garnihee were simultaneous. The very facts of that case would disclose that without a notice to the defendant under Order 38, Rule 5, there could not have been a prohibitory order to the garnishee under Order 21, Rule 46 pending the suit. We are not now concerned with the provisions of Order 21, Rule 46-A, B to I relating to the attachment of the monies lying with the garnishee or the claims of third person with regard to the amount so attached.
7. Another provision which can be noticed at this stage is Order 38, Rule 8 CPC, which lays down that any claim preferred to property attached before judgment shall be adjudicated upon in the manner provided for the adjudication of claims to property attached in execution of a decree for the payment of money. Probably, having regard to this provision, Order 21, Rule 46 is being invoked for issue of prohibitory orders against the garnishee even before judgment. But this necessarily involves the fulfilment of the conditions laid down under Order 38, Rule 5. In other words, if a prohibitory order is sought against the garnishee before judgment, the petition is one that is filed under Order 38 Rule 5 read with Order 21, Rule 46. Reference can also be made in this context to a ruling of the Madras High Court reported in R.V Pandaram & Company v. Surajmal (2) AIR 1964 Madras 49. That can be said to be an authority for the proposition that where a third party prefers a claim with regard to the attachment of properties in the hands of a garnishee, that claim has to be decide under the provisions of Order 21, Rule 46-E read with Order 38 Rule 5. It would however emerge from this ruling that a petition could be laid under Order 21, Rule 46 read with Order 38, Rule 5 CPC for a prohibitory order against the garnishee. The question whether the conditions of Or. 38, Rule 5 have to be complied with before a prohibitory order could be issued did not fall consideration in that case. The two rulings which would be referred to thereafter, cited by the learned counsel for the respondent, are also not directly on the point. In Sri Krishna Gupta v. Ram Babu (3) AIR 1967 Allahabad 136 all that is laid down is, that the Court has to issue an order directing security to be furnished for the sums specified and in the same order it may make attachment of property and that no attachment comes into existence unless the whole procedure prescribed by law for making attachment is gone through. That is again a case under Order 38, Rule 5 and Order 21, Rule 54. That does not discuss the point now in issue whether a show-cause notice or direction to furnish security should be issued to the defendant before a prohibitory order is issued to a garnishee. In Bhagavan Dass. v. Santhosh Singh (4) AIR 1958 Punjab and Harayana all that is laid down is, that an attachment before judgment cannot be an attachment in execution of a decree. It can only become an attachment in execution of a decree after the decree has been passed and after an application to execute such a decree has been made. This ruling is not of much help in deciding the point in issue. Even in the light of the ruling of Patna High Court reported in Imperial Bank v. Bibi Sayeedan (supra) relied upon by the learned counsel for the petitioner, it can yet be said that where a prohibitory order with regard to the monies in the hands of a garnishee is sought to be issued, a notice to the defendant as laid down in Order 38, Rule 5 is equally necessary. It might be that having regard in any likelihood of the defendant obstructing or evading the execution of decree, much interval between a notice to the defendant and the issue of a prohibitory order is not desirable. But nevertheless, as a question of law, since that would be a petition under Order 21, Rule 45 read with Order 38, Rule 5, the requirement of a show-cause notice or a direction to the defendant to furnish security cannot be dispensed with. If it is a petition simplicitor under Order 21 Rule 46, the position is, of course, different. In that event, no notice to the judgment debtor is necessary. In the instant case, though an exparte interim prohibitory order appears to have been issued initially, in responsible to a copy of the prohibitory order served under Sub-rule (2) of Rule 46 of Order 21, the defendant raised an objection to the issue of prohibitory order against the garnishee before a show-cause notice was issued to him (the defendant). The learned Assistant Judge on the averments of the petition affidavit, held that there was no allegation that the defendant is likely to obstruct the execution of the decree that would be ultimately passed against him and in this view, he has with-drawn the prohibitory order. The contention of the revision petitioner that at the stage of issue of prohibitory order in a case like this, no notice to the defendant is necessary, is therefore, unacceptable. In the circumstances found by the learned Assistant Judge that their was no likelihood of the defendant evading the payment in the event of any decree against him, the issue of a prohibitory order was rightly refused. There are thus, no grounds to interfere with that order by way of revision. The revision petition is accordingly dismissed with costs.
Alert