Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Kanyakaparameswari Varthakasaogham (Registered) Ganapavaram v. Commissioner Of Endowments

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Mar 30, 1978
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Delivered by Chinnappa Reddy, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant is the Kanyaka Parameswari Varthaka Sangham, Ganapavaram (an association/society of merchants). The sequence of events, as stated in the opinion, is:

  • The Assistant Commissioner of Endowments issued a notice requiring that the building known as the "Sathram" be registered as a charitable institution under Section 38 of the Charitable and Hindu Religious Institutions and Endowments Act.
  • In response, the appellant filed a petition under Section 77 of that Act before the Deputy Commissioner of Endowments (Kakinada) seeking a declaration that the Sathram was not a charitable institution within the meaning of Section 2(4) (as referred to in the opinion) of the Act. The appellant alleged ownership of the building remained with the Sangham, there had been no dedication or divestiture, and that any lodging of travellers was pursuant to a resolution and not a public right.
  • The Deputy Commissioner considered the Sangham's memorandum and byelaws and concluded the building was never endowed or dedicated to the public; he declared the institution not to be a charitable institution.
  • The Commissioner of Endowments and the Assistant Commissioner (who had issued the original notice) filed a suit under Section 78 of the Andhra Pradesh Charitable and Hindu Religious Institutions and Endowments Act seeking to set aside the Deputy Commissioner’s order and asserting that the Sangham and its properties were charitable institutions/endowments under the Act.
  • At trial the District Judge held the suit maintainable and found the Sathram to be a charitable endowment (relying on an asserted gift of the site by the Zamindar). The trial court decreed the suit.
  • The Sangham appealed to the High Court. Jeevan Reddy, J., by judgment dated 27-10-1976, confirmed the decree but on different grounds — holding that the Sangham itself was a charitable institution and that its properties (including the Sathram) were charitable endowments.
  • The Sangham then appealed to this Court under Clause 15 of the Letters Patent. The present opinion is the disposition of that appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Varthaka Sangham (an association of merchants registered under the Societies Registration Act) is a "charitable institution" within the meaning of the Charitable and Hindu Religious Institutions and Endowments Act.
  2. Whether the building known as the "Sathram" is a "charitable endowment" within the meaning of the Act.
  3. Whether the Commissioner and the Assistant Commissioner of Endowments are "persons aggrieved" under Section 78 of the Act and therefore competent to maintain the suit to set aside the Deputy Commissioner’s order.
  4. Whether the order of the Deputy Commissioner under Section 77 was liable to be set aside (i.e., the scope and limits of the suit filed under Section 78 vis-à-vis the original Section 77 proceeding).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Kanyaka Parameswari Varthaka Sangham) — summarized)

  • The Sangham's dominant object and the purpose of formation was to render assistance and advance the commercial interests of its merchant-members; it is akin to a chamber of commerce.
  • Although some charitable objects appear in the memorandum and byelaws, those do not make the Sangham a charitable institution because the dominant object is non-charitable commerce/merchant interests.
  • The Sangham's objects and use of property could be altered (the memorandum/byelaws permit alteration under the Societies Act); there was no irrevocable dedication or divestiture of property to charity.
  • The building (Sathram) remained the absolute property of the Sangham; lodging of wayfarers was provided for convenience and rent was charged after an initial free period — this did not amount to an endowment or dedication for charitable purposes.
  • The Commissioner and Assistant Commissioner of Endowments had suffered no legal injury and were not "person(s) aggrieved" under Section 78; indeed, they were argued to be mere statutory authorities and not proper parties to maintain the suit.

Plaintiffs (Commissioner and Assistant Commissioner of Endowments) — summarized)

  • They sought to set aside the Deputy Commissioner’s order and contended (by their suit) that the 1st defendant (the Sangham) and its properties are charitable institutions or endowments within the purview of the Act. (The opinion records that the Commissioner and Assistant Commissioner instituted a broader suit than the original Section 77 petition.)

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Adi Pheroz Shah v. H.M. Seervai, AIR 1971 S.C. 385 Illustration that the Advocate-General of a State was not a "person aggrieved" under the Advocates Act (Section 37) and thus was incompetent to file an appeal against the disciplinary committee of the State Bar Council. The Court distinguished that decision: it held the position of the Commissioner and Assistant Commissioner (whose statutory functions and duties under the Endowments Act give them a vital role and interest) is "altogether different" from that of the Advocate-General in the cited case; therefore Adi Pheroz Shah did not mandate excluding Commissioners from being "persons aggrieved" under Section 78 of the Endowments Act.
In re Sidebotham (reference to James L.J.) Old exposition that a "person aggrieved" is one who has suffered a legal grievance — someone wrongfully deprived of or affected in a right. The Court observed that such an old exposition is not exhaustive and may not suit modern statutory contexts; the Court preferred a contextual construction and noted later authorities and treatise guidance rather than rigid adherence to that century-old definition.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in distinct steps addressing each central question. The reasoning in the opinion is summarized strictly as contained in the text.

1. Character of the Varthaka Sangham (whether a "charitable institution")

The Court examined the memorandum of association and the byelaws. It noted the Sangham is an association of merchants (eligible members are persons carrying on business) and its prominent objects relate to promoting and protecting commercial interests of the merchant community (representations to authorities, preventing unhealthy competition, arbitration between members, dissemination of business information, collection of sales-tax on behalf of members, lettings of shops, etc.).

The Court recalled the statutory definition of "charitable institution" in the Endowments Act (an establishment formed for a charitable purpose and including specific endowments) and of "charitable purpose" (relief of poverty, education, medical relief, advancement of objects of utility/welfare to the general public or a section thereof). The Court concluded that to be a "charitable institution" the association must be formed for a charitable purpose — that is, the charitable purpose must be the sole or at least the dominant object of formation.

Because the Sangham's dominant purpose was to serve merchant-members and commercial interests, and because charitable objects in the memorandum were ancillary, the mere inclusion of charitable objects did not convert the Sangham into a charitable institution. The Court further highlighted that the Sangham is a society registered under the Societies Registration Act with explicit power to alter its objects (by reference to section 12 of the Societies Act as noted in the byelaws); the capacity to change objects was cited as indicium that the association cannot be a "charitable institution" under the Endowments Act. The Court therefore rejected the High Court's conclusion that the Sangham itself was a charitable institution.

2. Whether the Sathram is a charitable endowment

The Court considered two streams of reasoning used below: (a) Jeevan Reddy, J.'s conclusion that the building was a charitable endowment because the Sangham was held to be a charitable institution; (b) the trial court's view that the site was gifted by the Zamindar of Vuyyuru for a choultry, constituting divestiture and therefore an endowment.

Because this Court had held the Sangham was not a charitable institution, Jeevan Reddy J.'s ground fell away. As to the trial court's reasoning, the Court examined whether a gift of the site by the Zamindar, if it occurred, necessarily produced a charitable endowment. The opinion stated that for an endowment there must be an unequivocal divestiture of ownership and an effective dedication; absent a deed of dedication, long user by the public as of right might give rise to a presumption of dedication, but where the alleged endowment is of recent origin such a presumption is unlikely. The Court found that the evidence did not justify a presumption of dedication and held that it had not been established that the Sathram is a charitable endowment.

3. Whether Commissioner and Assistant Commissioner are "persons aggrieved" able to maintain a suit under Section 78

The Court examined the meaning of "person" (citing Section 3(22) of the Andhra Pradesh General Clauses Act — "'person' shall include any company or association of individuals, whether incorporated or not") and concluded this is an inclusive definition to be construed by context.

The Court then reviewed the Endowments Act's provisions (as described in the opinion): the Commissioner is constituted a corporation sole, has perpetual succession, and many statutory duties are vested in the Commissioner, Deputy Commissioners and Assistant Commissioners (preparing and publishing lists of institutions under Section 6; general superintendence and control under Section 8; power of inspection under Section 12; register institutions under Section 38; various powers to appoint trustees, remove trustees, inspect books, fix budgets, assess contributions, appoint executive officers and punish office-holders, etc.).

Given the wide range of powers and duties and the vital role these officers play in administration and governance of charitable/religious institutions and endowments, the Court reasoned they have a substantial, statutory interest in the proper classification and administration of such institutions. Accordingly, the Commissioner and the Assistant Commissioner were "persons aggrieved" within the meaning of Section 78 and competent to institute a suit to set aside the Deputy Commissioner’s order.

4. Scope and limits of the suit under Section 78 (respecting the earlier Section 77 proceeding)

The Court noted that the petition under Section 77 and the Deputy Commissioner’s order concerned the question whether the building known as "Sathram" was a charitable institution. The suit under Section 78, although pleading it was to set aside the Deputy Commissioner’s order, sought broader relief (a declaration that the Varthaka Sangham itself was a charitable institution). The Court held that it was not permissible for the plaintiffs (Commissioner/Assistant Commissioner) to seek relief in the suit that went beyond the relief sought and granted in the proceeding under Section 77. This constrained the scope of the relief properly open in the Section 78 suit brought to challenge the Section 77 order.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court allowed the appeal (stated in the opinion as "Appeal Allowed") and dismissed the suit. The Court held that:

  • The Varthaka Sangham is not a "charitable institution" within the meaning of the Charitable and Hindu Religious Institutions and Endowments Act — the dominant objective is commercial/merchant interests despite some charitable objects in its memorandum and byelaws.
  • The building known as the "Sathram" has not been established to be a "charitable endowment" — there was insufficient evidence of dedication or unequivocal divestiture of ownership; the trial court's reasoning based on an alleged gift did not establish charitable endowment.
  • The Commissioner and Assistant Commissioner of Endowments are "persons aggrieved" within Section 78 of the Act and thus were competent to institute the suit; however, despite maintainability, the plaintiffs' substantive claim failed on the merits.

Implications / Consequences:

  • Direct effect: The appeal was allowed and the suit (brought by the Commissioner and Assistant Commissioner to set aside the Deputy Commissioner’s order) was dismissed. There was no order as to costs in this Court or in the courts below.
  • Legal clarifications made in the opinion (as stated by the Court): (a) an association formed primarily to advance commercial interests is not converted into a "charitable institution" merely because charitable objects are included among its objects; (b) a charitable endowment requires unequivocal divestiture and dedication (or, in certain cases, long public user as of right) — the absence of a deed of dedication and lack of evidence precludes a finding of endowment; (c) whether a statutory officer is a "person aggrieved" must be determined contextually and public officers with statutory duties and vital administrative roles under a statute may fall within that expression.
  • The Court expressly stated the suit was dismissed for reasons given and made no award of costs; the decree of the courts below was set aside to the extent inconsistent with these conclusions.
Appeal Allowed.
Show all summary ...

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

Chinnappa Reddy, J.

The Kanyaka Parameswari Varthaka Sangham, Ganapavaram is the appellant before us. This appeal under Clause 15 of the letters patent has its roots in a petition filed by the appellant, before the Deputy Commissioner of Endowments, under section 77 of the Charitable and Hindu Religious Institutions and Endowments Act for a declaration that the institution called ‘the Sathram’ at Ganapavaram in West Godavari District run by the appellant-Association was not a charitable institution within the meaning of Section 2 (4) of the Act. The petition under Section 77 was itself necessitated by the fact that the Assistant Commissioner of Endowments bad issued a notice to the appellant to register the Sathram as a Charitable Institution under the provisions of Section 38 of the Charitable and Hindu Religious Institutions and Endowments Act. Alleging that the building known as ‘Sathram’ was constructed by the Appellant-Sangham, a Society registered under the Societies Registration Act, that the ownership of the building was always and continued to be with the Sangham, that there was never any dedication or diverstitute, that though part of the building was used for the purpose of lodging travellers pursuant to a resolution of the Sangham, the public had no right to so use the building, that it was open to the Sangham to divert the building for some other purpose at any time and that the building was not a charitable institution, the appellate sought the declaration already mentioned before the Deputy Commissioner of Endowments, Kakinada. The Assistant Commissioner of Endowments, Eluru was impleaded as a party in the proceedings under section 77 before the Deputy Commissioner of Endowments. The Deputy Commissioner, after considering the memorandum of association of the Sangham and its byelaws. came to the conclusion that the building was never endowed and was never by the public as of right and that merely because a portion of the building was let out for convenience by passengers, it did not become a charitable institution. The Deputy Commissioner, therefore, declared that the institution run by the appellant was not a charitable institution. Purporting to be aggrieved by the decision of the Deputy Commissioner, the Commissioner of Endowments and the Assistant Commissioner of Endowments filed the suit out of which the appeal arises under Section 78 of the Andhra Pradesh Charitable and Hindu Religious Institutions and Endoments Act “to set aside the order of the Deputy Commissioner, Endowments Departmenf, Kakinada passed in O.A No. 50/1969 dated 22-11-1969 on the ground that the 1st defendant and its properties are charitable institutions or endowments coming under the purview of Act 17 of 1966”.

2. It will be noticed at once that white the petition under Section 77 and the order of the Deputy Commissioner concerned themselves with the question whether the building known as ‘Sathram’ was a charitable Institution, the relief sought in the suit, thought mentioning that the suit was to set aside the order of the Deputy Commissioner, was. in fact, of much wider amplitude, involving the appellant-Sangham itself and not merely the Satram run by it. The relief sought was that the Sangam itself should be declared a charitable institution.

3. The suit was resisted by the sangham. It was contended in the written statement that the scheme was established for the benefit of its members primarily to instal the spirit of mutual help among its members, all of whom were to be drawn from the merchant community under its bye-laws. The members had to pay their subscription by way of Rusums which were compulsory exactions and not donations as appeared to have been understood the Sangham mentioned in its bye-laws were secondary in nature. The properties acquired by the Sangham were its exclusive properties and were never dedicated as endowments. The buildings described as Sathram was the absolute property of the Sangham. A part of the Building was used to lodge wayfarers for rent. It was open to the Sangham to alter its bye-laws at any time and divert the purpose even in respect of the portion of the building which was used to lodge wayfarers. Neither the Sangham nor the Sathram was a charitable institution. It was also pleaded in the written statement that the Commissioner of Endowments and the Assistant Commissioner of Endowments were not competent to maintain the suit under section 79 of the Act as they could not be described as aggrieved parties.

4. The two issues on which the suit proceeded to trial were whether the order of the Deputy Commissioner was liable to be set aside and whether the suit as maintainable. The learned District Judge held that the suit maintainable and the Sathram was a charitable endowment within the meaning of Section 2 (3) of the Charitable and Hindu Religious and Institutions Endowments Act. According to the learned District Judge, the sites on which the choultry was constructed had been gifted to the Sangham by the Zamin-daar of Vuyyur for the purpose of construction of the choultry and there could therefore, be no difficulty in concluding that the building was a charitable endowment. He. therefore, decreed the suit.

5. The Sangham preferred an appeal to the High Court, Jeevan Reddy J, by his judgment, dated 27-10-1976 confirmed the decree of the trial court, but he rested his decision on grounds different from those on which the District Judge had rested his judgment. Jeevan Reddy, J., held that the Sangham itself was a charitable institution and that all properties owned by it including the Sathram were necessarily charitable endowments. The Sangham has preferred this appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent,

6. Sri P. Babulu Reddy, learned counsel for the appellant argued that the dominant object of the Varthaka Sangham was to render assistance to its members all of whom were merchants, in various ways. Merely because certain charitable objects were also specified in the Memorandum of Association and the bye-laws of the Sangham it did not follow, on that account alone, that the Sangham was a charitable institution. He pointed out that the objects of the Association could be altered at any lime and the use to which its properties were put could also be changed. No property of the Sangham had even been dedicated nor was there ever any divertitute of ownership or control. Neither the Varthaka Sangham nor the Sathram was a charitable institution or endowment. It was also argued that the Commissioner and the Assistant Commissioner had suffered no legal injury and, therefore, neither of them could property be described as a ‘person aggrieved’ within the meaning of the expression in Section. 78 of the Act. It was argued that they were not even ‘person’, they were mere authorities constituted under the Act.

7. The Appellant-Varthaka Sangham is an association of Merchants, akin to a chamber of commerce. According to the bye-laws the persons who are eligible to be members of the Sangham or Association are persons carrying on business. The Memorandum of Association states that the Association is intended “to create a close union among the business community and other people and to create and develop the economic, rural and business interests”. Amongst the objects of the Association are mentioned various charitable objects, such as the starting of a library for the use of the members and the public, the opening of schools, dispensaries, hospitable, the award of scholarship, helping people who are victims of fire accidents, celebration of anniversaries of great men, etc., There are several non-chari-table objects also mentioned in the Memorandum of Association. They are : “To represent the merchants in their dealings in trade and to help them in making representations regarding the inconvenience in business and to secure the necessary relief required in business”, “to examine the several bills relating to business and to make representation of the amendments necessary to the higher authorities and to the giving proper advice in business dealings to the members”, “to divise the new ways of business either inland or foreign and to create interest in such”, “to see that none of the members of the Association resort to unhealthy competition or black-marketing in their personal business activities and to take necessary steps against anyone who resorts to such things”, “to create and develop unity in business activities and to increase the strength of the Association and educate the members in adopting legal and useful ways for the people and the Government”, “to put the members in the view of all news publications in gazette or in papers regarding business”, and “to see and help in deciding by way of arbitration of all business disputes arising in business dealings amongst the several members of the working committee of their Association”. The Memorandum of Association also provides that in order to carry out the objects of the Association the necessary funds should be obtained by collecting Rusums from members, donations from members, and public and rents for the properties of the Association, etc.

8. The bye-laws of the Association provide that traders and persons carrying on business are eligible to be members of the Association. The working committee of the Association is given the power to admit members on their application and to collect fee for admission. Every member is required to pay a monthly fee called a Rusum calculated on the basis of the monthly sales of the member.

9. Every member is also required to submit a monthly sales statement to the Association. Continuous default for a period of three months entails loss of membership of the Association. There are detailed bye-laws providing for the day to day conduct of the business of the Association. It is provided that the main building of the Association should be given for occupation of way farers. No rent is to be charged for the first three days and thereafter rent is to be charged at the rate of 25 paise per room per day for twelve days and 50 paise per day thereafter. Part of the building may also be let out for purposes of marriage and other functions on payment of rent of Rs. 5/- per day plus current charges. Buildings to be constructed after the formation of the Association are to be let out for reasonable rent. It may be mentioned here that number of shops have been constructed by the Association since its formation and they have been let out to various traders. It is also provided in the bye-laws that the Sales-tax to be paid by the members may be collected from time to time and remitted to the Government by the Association on behalf of the members. Finally it is expressly provided,

“The objects of this Association may be altered or new provisions made in accordance with section 12 of the Societies Act”.

10. It is patent from the Memorandum of the Association and the bye-laws that the Varthaka Sangham is primarily meant to serve the needs to the merchant community and to promote their interests in various ways as set forth in the Memorandum of Association and the bye-laws. For example, the Association is expected to make representations on behalf of the members about their grievances and to try to secure redress. The Association is expected to study the various legislations affecting business and trade and to suggest necessary amendments. The Association is expected to prevent unhealthy competition between its members. The Association is required to diseminate to its members information concerning business. It is required whenever necessary to arbitrate in disputes between the members. It is also expected to collect and pay Sales-Tax on behalf of its members. These are the usual services which any Association of Merchants or Chamber of Commerce may be expected or required to render to its members. The Appellant Varthaka Sangham is thus no more then the usual Association of Merchants formed to secure, advance and promote the commercial interests of the merchant community. It is true that certain charitable objects are also included in the objects of the Appellant-Varthaka Sangham. The inclusion of such charitable objects does not alter the basic character of the Sangham which is that of an ordinary Association of merchants. The Merchant's Association does not thereby become a ‘charitable institution’. A “charitable institution” is defined in the Charitable and Hindu Religious Institutions and Endowments Act as meaning “any establishment, undertaking, organisation or association formed for a charitable purpose and includes a specific endowment”. “Charitable purpose” is defined as including” (a) relief of poverty or distress; (b) education; (c) medical relief; (d) advancement of any other object of utility or welfare to the general public or a section thereof not being an object of exclusively religious nature. “The definition of ‘charitable institution’ shows that the very formation of the Association must be for a charitable purpose in order to make the Association a charitable institution. In other words, the charitable purpose must be the sole or at least the dominate object of the Association before it can be called a charitable institution. An Association formed for other purposes, but amongst whose objects are also some charitable purposes, is not a charitable institution since it is not formed for a charitable purpose. An association of merchants whose dominant purpose is to promote the commercial interests of the merchant community cannot be said to be a charitable institution mereby because the Memorandum of Association also refers to certain charitable purposes amongst its objects. One other circumstance which requires to be noticed is that the Varthaka Sangham is a society registered under the Societies Registration Act and is entitled to change its objects at any time. While a change of the objects of the Sangham may not affect any trust which has already been created the right to change the objects of the Association is clearly indicative of the fact that the Association itself cannot be a ‘charitable institution’ within the meaning of the Charitable and Hindu Religious Institutions and Endowments Act. We are, therefore, not inclined to agree with the conclusion of Jeevan Reddy J., that the Varthaka Sangham is itself a ‘charitable institution’. We would also like to add that the notification issued by the Commissioner under section 6 of the Act and the petition filed by the appellant before the Deputy Commissioner under Section 77 of the Act refer only to the building and not to the Varthaka Sangham. The suit in so far as it sought a declaration that the Varthaka Sangham itself was a charitable institution was clearly wider, in scope, than the proceeding under section 77. Since the suit was one to set aside the order under Section 77, it was not permissible for the plaintiffs to seek relief which went beyond the relief sought and granted in the proceeding under Section 77 of the Act.

11. The next question for consideration is whether the Sathram is a charitable endowment within the meaning of the expression in the Charitable and Hindu Religious Institutions and Endowments Act. Jeevan Reddy J., considered that it was a charitable endowment, because the Sangham itself was a charitable institution. We have held that the Sangham is not a charitable institution. Therefore, that ground falls. The trial court held that the portion of the building which was used for the purpose of accommodating wayfarers was a charitable endowment. The conclusion of the trial court was based on the circumstances that the site on which the building was constructed was gifted to the Varthaka Sangham by the Zamindar of Vuyyuru for the purpose of constructing a choultry. According to the trial court, by making a gift the Zamindar had divested himself of his ownership of the gift and, therefore, the building constructed on the site became a charitable endowment. It is difficult to follow the reasoning of the trial court. Assuming that the Zamindar of Vuyyur had gifted the site to the Varthaka Sangham it did not follow that the building constructed on the site became a charitable endowment. The Varthaka Sangham was the owner of the site and the building. There cannot be an endowment unless there is an unequivocal divestiture of ownership and dedication. In the absence of a deed of dedication, long user by the public as of right may lead to a presumption of such dedication. In the case of an alleged endowment of recent origin, there can be no such presumption. We do not think that the evidence in the case justifies any such presumption. We are of the view that it has not been established that the Sathram is a charitable endowment.

12. The last question for consideration is whether the Commissioner and the Assistant Commissioner of Endowments can be said to be ‘person aggrieved’ by the order of the Deputy Commissioner under Section 77 of the Act so as to be competent to institute a suit under section 78 of the Act. Sri Babulu Reddy would say that the Commissioner and Assistant Commissioner were not ‘persons’ even but mere statutory authorities. Now the word ‘person’ is defined in Section 3(22) of the Andhra Pradesh General Clauses Act as follows:—

“‘person’ shall include any company or association of individuals, whether incorporated or not.”

13. The definition is an inclusive definition, not very helpful, but, useful to show that the expression includes natural as well as artificial persons and must receive an extended connotation. The meaning to be given to the word must naturally depend on the context and there is nothing in the charitable and Hindu Religious Institutions and Endowments Act which compels us to give such a restricted meaning to the expression ‘person’as to exclude from its ambit persons entrusted with statutory duties, Nor are we inclined to accept the submission of Sri Babutu Reddy that the Commissioner and Assistant Commissioner are not ‘persons aggrieved’ because no legal right of their is infringed. Sri Babulu Reddy invited our attention to the decision of the Supreme Court in Adi Pheroz Shah v. H.M Seervai . AIR 1971 S.C 385 where it was held that the Advocate Genera) of a State was not a ‘person aggrieved’ within the meaning of that expression in section 37 of the Advocates Act and, therefore, incompetent to file an appeal against the decision of the disciplinary committee of a State Bar Council. Under the Advocates Act, the entertaining of complaints, the inquiry into them and the punishment to be meted out to the delinquent advocate were all concerns of the Bar Council. The Advocate General was entitled to a hearing if the complaint was not rejected summarily. All that be was expected to do was, to render fair and impartial assistance to the Bar Council, assuming to himself neither the role of a prosecutor nor that of a defence counsel. He was not obliged to appear before the Bar Council unless he desired to be heard. If he appeared or if he did not appear, there was an end of the matter. He could have no agrievance against what ever decision was rendered by the Bar Council, As we shall presently point out the position of a Commissioner and an Assistant Commissioner is altogether different from that of the AdvocateGeneral under the Advocates Act. A reference was made by the Supreme Court to the State by James L.J, lnre Sidebotham2 that ‘a person aggrieved must be a man who has suffered a legal grievance, a man against whom a decision has been pronounced which has wrongfully refused him of something or wrongfully deprived him of something or wrongfully affected bis tide to something”. HidayatuUah C.J, has pointed out that the definition was held in later cases to be not exhaustive and several other features of the phrase were pointed out. We do not think that this century old exposition of the meaning of the expression ‘person aggrieved’ can properly be considered relevant when we are dealing with modern statutes which deal with situations which could have never been contemplated a century back. The proper way to consider the question is indicated in Halsbury's Laws of England, 3rd edition. Volume 25 where referring to the expression ‘person aggrieved’ it was said.,

“the expression is nowhere defined and must be construed by reference to the context of the enactment in which it appears and all the circumstances”.

14. Now, let us examine the provisions of the Andhra Pradesh Charitable and Hindu Religious Institutions and Endowments Act. lt is an Act to consolidate and amend the law relating to the administration and governance of Charitable and Hindu Religious Institutions and Endowments in this Slate of Andhra Pradesh. It applies to all public Charitable Institutions and Endowments other than Wakfs governed by the provisions of the Wakls Act. The expressions ‘charitable endowment’, ‘charitable institution’, charitable purpose’, ‘religious endowment’, ‘religious charity’, ‘mutt’, ‘temple’ are all defined. Provision is made for the appointment of a Commissioner, Deputy Commissioners and Assistant Commissioners. The Commissioner, it is said, shall be a corporation sole and shall have perpectual succession and common seal and may sue or be sued in his corporate name. Section 6 enjoins a duty upon the Commissioner to prepare separately and publish in the prescribed manner a list of all mutts charitable institutions and endowments, religious institutions and endowments with reference to their income. Section 8 of the Act vests in the commissioner the general superintendence and control over the administration of all charitable and Hindu religious institutions and endowments. He is empowered to pass any order which may be deemed necessary to ensure the proper administration of such institutions and endowments. He is empowered to delegate certain func-tions to the Deputy Commissioner and certain other functions to the Assistant Commissioner. Section 12 empowers the Commissioner, Deputy Commissioner and Assistant Commissioner to inspect any charitable or religious institutions or endowment, the properties, records, etc., belonging to such institution to satisfy themselves that the provision of the Act and the rules are duly carried out. The Board of Trustees for Charitable or Religious Institutions or Endowments are required to be appointed by the Government in some cases and by the Commissioner, the Deputy Commissioner and the Assistant Commissioner in certain other cases. The Commissioner, Deputy Commissioner or the Assistant Commissioner, as the case may be, is empowered to require the trustees to furnish for inspection books, accounts, returns, etc., The trustees of all charitable or religious institutions or endowments are required to obey all lawful orders issued under the provisions of the Act by the Commissioner, Deputy Commissioner, Assistant Commissioner, as the case may be. The trustees are required to submit proposals for fixing the Bi???tam to the Commissioner, Deputy Commissioner or Assistant Commissioner, as the case may be. Trustees may be removed or dismissed by the Government in some cases and by the Commi-ssioner, Deputy Commissioner and Assistant Commissioner in certain other cases. The Government and the Commissioner are also empowered to appoint Executive Officers for charitable or religious institutions and endow-ments. The power to punish office holders of institutions and endowments is given to the Commissioner, Deputy Commissioner and Assistant Commissioner. Section 38 requires the trustee of every charitable or religious institution or endowment to make an application for registration to the Assistant Commissioner, If no application is presented for registration, the Commissioner is empowered to have the institution or endowment compulsorily registered. the budget has to be submitted by the trustee to the. Commissioner, Deputy Commissioner or the Assistant Commissioner, as the case may be. Every charitable or religious institution or endowment whose annual income is not less than Rs. 1000/- is liable to pay contribution to the Government. The contribution is required to be assessed by the Commissioner. These are only some of the provisions dealing with the powers and duties of the Commissioner, Deputy Commissioner and Assistant Commissioner under the Andhra Pradesh Charitable and Hindu Religious Institutions and Endowments Act. These provisions indicate the wide range of powers and duties required to be performed by the Commissioner and the Assistant Commissioner. It is evident that they have vital roles to play in the administration of charitable or religious institutions and endowments; they are not mere non-combatant disin terested spectators, ready to offer advice; that are persons charged with the proper adminis-tration of charitable or religious institutions and endowments. The veryapplicability of the provisions of the Act are dependent on the action taken by them. The Commissioner is required to prepare a list of all charitable or religious institutions and endowments while the Assistant Commissioner is required to register all such institutions and endowments. They are, therefore, persons who have a vital interest in any dispute as to the question whether an institution or an endowment is a charitable institution or an endowment, etc., which disputes are required to be decided by the Deputy Commissioner under Section 77 of the Act. In our opinion, having regard to the basic role which the Government and the Assistant Commissioner play in the proper administration of charitable or religious institutions and endowments, they are persons aggrieved’ within the meaning of the expression in section 78 of the Act. We. therefore, hold that that the suit was maintainable at the instance of the Commissioner and the Assistant Commissioner, though, for the reasons already mentioned by us. We allow the appeal and dismiss the suit. There will be no order as to costs either here or in any of the Courts below.

Appeal Allowed.