- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Amar Singh And Others v. Lal Singh And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The matter originated from Second Appeal No. 185 of 1966 decided by the Punjab & Haryana High Court on 18-01-1977. The unsuccessful party sought to challenge that decision before the Supreme Court by special leave. During the pendency of the Supreme Court appeal, several key litigants passed away: the first respondent on 05-05-1979, the third respondent on 08-11-1984, and, according to information supplied to the Court, all the appellants as well. No legal representatives were substituted for any of these deceased parties. The first respondent’s defence in the suit was founded on a Will, which the High Court had upheld. These developments framed the procedural posture considered by the Supreme Court.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the appeal could survive after the death of the first respondent, given that the appeal against him had abated and the decree was joint and inseparable among all respondents.
- Whether the failure to substitute legal representatives for other deceased parties (the third respondent and the appellants) mandated abatement of the entire appeal.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court focused exclusively on the procedural question of abatement. It noted that:
- The first respondent died on 05-05-1979, and no steps were taken to bring his legal representatives on record, resulting in abatement of the appeal against him.
- The decree under challenge was joint and inseparable because all respondents claimed entitlement under the same Will that the High Court had upheld.
- When one of several respondents in a joint and inseparable decree is no longer before the Court due to abatement, the appeal cannot proceed against the remaining respondents; the entire matter abates.
- Further deaths of the third respondent and all appellants, without substitution of their legal representatives, reinforced the procedural impossibility of adjudicating the merits.
- Although counsel for the appellants sought to contest the High Court’s findings, the Court held it lacked jurisdiction to entertain substantive arguments once the procedural abatement had occurred.
Holding and Implications
DISMISSED — The appeal was dismissed, with no order as to costs.
Implications: The dismissal is confined to the parties in this litigation and rests solely on procedural grounds of abatement arising from non-substitution of deceased parties. The judgment does not establish a new substantive precedent but underscores the consequence of failing to act promptly to bring legal representatives on record when a decree is joint and inseparable.
Order
1. This appeal by special leave arises from the order of the Punjab & Haryana High Court made in SA No. 185 of 1966 on 18-1-1977. Pending appeal, the first respondent died on 5-5-1979 and the appeal against him stood abated. We are informed that the third respondent also died on 8-11-1984. No steps have been taken. We are further informed that all the appellants too have died but legal representatives have not been brought on record. We need not proceed further except to the extent of the matter on record, namely, the death of the first respondent and abatement qua him. Admittedly, the first respondent died on 5-5-1979. His defence against the suit of the appellant is based upon the Will. The Will now stands upheld by the High Court. Consequently, as all the respondents are jointly entitled to the property covered under the Will, the relief is joint and inseparable. Since the appeal as against the first respondent stood abated, the decree being joint and inseparable, the appeal stands abated as against all the respondents. Consequently, we cannot hear the matter on merits, though Ms Janani, learned counsel for the appellant, sought to canvass the correctness of the finding of the High Court.
2. The appeal is dismissed. No costs.
Alert