Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Kota Sambasiva Rao And Others v. Kota Venkateswarlu And Others

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Mar 19, 1997
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This Letters Patent Appeal arises from a judgment and decree of a learned single Judge in A.S. No. 154 of 1977, which affirmed the decree passed in O.S. No. 203 of 1970 dismissing the plaintiffs' suit (O.S. No. 203 of 1970). The suit was instituted by three plaintiffs (appellants 2 to 4 in the appeal) for partition of joint family immovable properties (plaint A schedule) and the joint family business (plaint B schedule).

The defendants included the plaintiffs' father (defendant No. 3), his five brothers (defendants Nos. 1, 2, 4, 5 and 6), their mother (defendant No. 7) and the firm known as Kota Pullaiah and Sons (defendant No. 8). The business began in the name of Kota Pullaiah and later became a family partnership by documented instruments: Ex. B-41 (1-4-1957), Ex. B-40 (1-11-1958) when a minor was admitted, and Ex. B-42 (11-4-1967) with specified partner shares. A partition deed (Ex. B-44) allotted immovable properties to family members.

The firm was dissolved under Ex. B-109 on 19-4-1970. A fresh partnership (Ex. B-110 / Ex. B-110 dated 22-4-1970) was later constituted excluding Kota Pullaiah. Kota Pullaiah died in 1970. The plaintiffs (sons of defendant No. 3) claimed partition and separate possession of the share attributable to their father. The Trial Judge dismissed the suit, holding that because defendant No. 3's share had been shown in his father's share, the plaintiffs could not independently claim rights and their remedy was to "work out their rights separately." The single Judge affirmed that dismissal. The present appeal challenges that position.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellants (the three sons) are entitled to claim a share in the joint family firm which was dissolved on 19-4-1970 under Ex. B-109.
  2. Whether defendant No. 3 (the first appellant) is entitled to a share in the immovable properties allotted to the share of his father, the late Kota Pullaiah.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments (Sri Chandra Sekhar Rao)

  • A sum of Rs. 37,757.78 (Ex. B-114) stood to the credit of late Kota Pullaiah on the date of dissolution; defendant No. 3's share was included in that credit and therefore he (and his sons) are entitled to his portion of that amount.
  • Under Section 37 of the Partnership Act, when accounts have not been finally settled, an outgoing partner (or his estate) is entitled to a share of subsequent profits attributable to the use of his share of the property or to interest at 6% per annum.
  • Accordingly, defendant No. 3 is entitled to half of the credited amount that relates to his 7 paise share (which was clubbed with Pullaiah's share) and an additional 1/7th of the remaining half. The plaintiffs (as sons) can therefore claim through defendant No. 3.
  • Separately, appellants contended that interest should be calculated at 12% per annum under the partnership deed provisions for share-capital, not at 6% under Section 37.

Respondents' Arguments (Sri T. Veerabhadraiah)

  • The business was conducted as a partnership; the appellants (sons) were not partners and therefore cannot claim a share in the partnership assets.
  • If defendant No. 3 had any claim, he should have filed a suit against his father's estate; that remedy is now barred by limitation.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis focused principally on statutory provisions of the Indian Partnership Act as applied to the undisputed factual matrix in the record. The Court examined whether the partnership assets had been finally settled when the firm was dissolved and whether the continuing/reconstituted partnership had used those assets without a final settlement of accounts with the outgoing partner or his estate.

Key steps of the Court's reasoning:

  1. Application of Section 37 of the Partnership Act: The Court accepted the appellants' core contention that Section 37 applies where a partner dies or ceases to be a partner and surviving partners continue business with firm property without final settlement of accounts. In that situation the outgoing partner or his estate is entitled, at their option, to either (a) a share of profits attributable to the use of his share of the property, or (b) interest at the rate of 6% per annum on his share in the property.
  2. Factual finding on absence of final settlement: The Court found no evidence that separate funds were furnished to create a distinct, non-family firm (i.e., no evidence that the reconstituted partnership had lost the character of the joint family business or had made a final settlement). The credited amount (Ex. B-114) remained in the firm's accounts and was used by the reconstituted partnership. Consequently, the legal proviso in Section 37 applies: the outgoing partner's legal representatives are entitled to one of the options provided.
  3. Rejection of 12% interest claim: The Court rejected the appellants' argument that interest should be calculated at 12% as per the partnership deed. The Court held that Section 48 prescribes how accounts must be finally settled (payments rateably towards advances, capital and residuals), and since such settlement had not taken place, the substantive remedy is governed by Section 37. Therefore, the statutory 6% rate under Section 37 applies; the contractual 12% provision in the deed could not supplant the entitlement under Section 37 where no final settlement had been done.
  4. Quantification under Section 37: The Court proceeded to quantify the share and interest due to defendant No. 3 based on the admitted credited amount of Rs. 37,757.74 (credited on dissolution under Ex. B-109 and continued in the reconstituted firm under Ex. B-110 / Ex. B-110 dated 22-4-1970). The Court allocated a half-share to defendant No. 3 for the 7 paise interest that had been clubbed into Pullaiah's share and an additional 1/7th of the remaining half, then computed interest at 6% for the period 19-4-1970 to 19-4-1997.
  5. Adjustment for non-participating deceased brother and succession: The Court excluded the 1/7th share attributable to a brother (Kota Narayana Rao, the 6th defendant) who died and was not impleaded in the appeal (thus excluding Rs. 8,075.57). The Court also noted that the mother (defendant No. 7) died leaving a registered will; her legatee (respondent No. 2) is liable for the mother's 1/7th share that may be payable to defendant No. 3.
  6. Practical apportionment: To avoid calculation difficulties, the Court, with assistance from counsel, fixed the sums payable by respondents-defendants 1 to 4 (defendants 1, 2, 4 and 5) in specified proportions and directed deposit into the trial Court within three months, failing which execution may follow.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The appeal is allowed to the extent indicated. The Court reversed and set aside the Trial Court's decree and the single Judge's affirmation insofar as they denied relief to defendant No. 3 and his sons. Specifically:

  • Preliminary decree for partition is granted in favour of defendant No. 3 (and accordingly his sons' claim to the extent of their equities) for Items 1 and 2 of plaint A schedule immovable properties — defendant No. 3 is entitled to a 1/7th share in those properties allotted to late Pullaiah.
  • Money decree: A decree for recovery of Rs. 48,453.40 (Rupees Forty Eight Thousand Four Hundred and Fifty Three and Forty paise only) is to be entered in favour of defendant No. 3 against respondents Nos. 1 to 4 (defendants Nos. 1, 2, 4 and 5) in specified proportions:
    • Respondent No. 1 (Kota Venkateswarlu): Rs. 9,690.68
    • Respondent No. 2 (Kota Radhakrishna Murthy): Rs. 19,381.36
    • Respondent No. 3 (Kota Sankara Rao): Rs. 9,690.68
    • Respondent No. 4 (Kota Narasimha Rao): Rs. 9,690.68
  • The respondents' counsel undertook to deposit the sum into the trial Court within three months; in default, defendant No. 3 is entitled to execute the decree.
  • There shall be no order as to costs between the parties.

Implications:

The direct effect of the decision is to (a) confer a preliminary partition decree for specified immovable properties in favour of defendant No. 3 (entitling him to a 1/7th share in the items allotted to Pullaiah), and (b) require specified respondents to pay Rs. 48,453.40 in defined proportions to defendant No. 3 representing his share and interest under Section 37 of the Partnership Act after adjustments noted by the Court. The opinion does not state that it establishes any broader legal precedent beyond applying Sections 37 and 48 of the Partnership Act to the facts of this case; no new legal principle beyond that statutory application is announced.

Appeal allowed.
Show all summary ...

1. This Letters Patent Appeal is from the judgment and decree of a learned single Judge of this Court in A.S No. 154 of 1977 affirming the decree passed in O.S No. 203 of 1970 dismissing the suit O.S No. 203 of 1970 on the file of the Subordinate Judge, Guntur filed by appellants 2 to 4 herein, sons of the first appellant.

2. The suit was instituted by three plaintiffs, appellants 2 to 4 herein, for partition of the joint family properties consisting of immovable properties as mentioned in plaint — A schedule and joint family business (iron, hardware etc.,) as disclosed in plaint — B schedule. As already stated, defendant No. 3 is the father of the three plaintiffs. Defendants Nos. 1, 2, 4, 5 and 6 are brothers of defendant No. 3. Defendant No. 7 is the mother of defendants 1 to 6. The 8th defendant is the firm known by the name of Kota Pullaiah and Sons, Guntur. Kota Pullaiah, the father of defendants 1 to 6, carried on business in iron and hardware and other goods in Guntur originally in his own name and after sons were born to him, he changed the name of his business as Kota Pullaiah and Sons. The joint family business was converted into joint family partnership business on 1-4-1957 under Ex. B-41. As by that time, the 3rd defendant Sambasiva Rao, the father of the plaintiffs was in Government service, he was not shown as a partner. But his share of 1 Anna 3 paise was shown in the share of his father Kota Pullaiah. The total share of Pullaiah was thus 4 Annas 6 paise (3 annas 3 paise +1 anna 3 paise). Defendants 1, 2 and 4, each was given 3 Annas share. As by the date of Ex. B-41 the 6th defendant was a minor, the partnership was reconstituted under Ex. B-40 on 1-11-1958 taking defendant No. 6 also as a partner. Once again under Ex. B-42 on 11-4-1967, the family business was continued as joint family partnership business and the partners were allotted the following shares:

Defendant No. 1 — 22 ps

Defendants Nos. 2 and 4 — 20 ps each

Defendant No. 5 — 17 ps

Defendant No. 6 — 7 ps

Kota Pullaiah — 14 ps

3. Kota Pullaiah, father of the six defendants was given 14 paise share which included the 7 paise share of the 3rd defendant, Sambasiva Rao. But, however, Sambasiva Rao's name was not shown as one of the partners. Under Ex. B-44, the partition deed, A — Schedule properties comprising a residential house in Guntur, was given to defendant No. 1. Shop rooms were given to the other brothers and defendant No. 3, father of the plaintiffs, was allotted a vacant site in Nallapadu admeasuring 1048 square yards, which at that time, was valued at Rs. 500/-. Pullaiah died on 1-5-1970. The partnership was dissolved under Ex. B-109 on 19-4-1970. Subsequently, a fresh partnership came into being consisting of defendants 1, 2, 4, 5 and 6 thus excluding Pullaiah, their father. The plaintiffs as sons of defendant No. 3, sought a decree for partition and separate possession of their share of the properties as the sons of defendant No. 3. The 3rd defendant supported the claim of his sons — the plaintiffs, whereas the paternal uncles of the plaintiffs resisted the suit contending that the business was that of the partnership in which defendant No. 3 not being a partner, the plaintiffs, as sons of defendant No. 3 could not claim any share therein. In the course of evidence, the factual position that defendant No. 3's share was shown in the share of Pullaiah, the father, was established. The learned Trial Judge, had taken the view that as the 3rd defendant alone was entitled to the share in the partnership since his share also was shown in the share of his father, the plaintiffs cannot claim independently any right in the shares of the father and the only remedy open to them was to work out their rights separately. On that view, the learned Judge dismissed the suit. That view was affirmed on appeal by the learned single Judge of this Court.

4. Before us, Sri Chandra Sekhar Rao, learned counsel for the appellants, has contended that in view of the admitted position of defendant No. 3's share having been shown in the share of Pullaiah, his father, on the date of the death of Pullaiah on 19-4-1970, a sum of Rs. 37,757.78 ps was standing to his credit in the accounts as admitted by the defendants in their evidence and marked as Ex. B-114. Out of this amount of Rs. 37,757.78 ps. the 3rd defendant was entitled to half of the share since that included his half share also (7 paise) and after the death of his father, he was entitled along with his five brothers and mother to an additional 1/7th share. Besides this amount, it is not in dispute that Items 1 and 2 of plaint — A schedule property which are immovable properties allotted to the share of Pullaiah, the 3rd defendant is entitled to 177th share.

5. The only question for consideration is whether the appellants are entitled to claim a share in the joint family firm which was dissolved on 19-4-1970 under Ex. B-109 and whether defendant No. 3, the 1st appellant is entitled to a share in the immovable properties allotted to the share of his father late Pullaiah?

6. Arguments are advanced before us by Sri T. Veerabhadraiah, learned counsel for the respondents, contending that since the entire business was run as partnership business, the appellants have no right to claim a share in that business since they were not partners. If at all, defendant No. 3 was entitled to any share, he should have filed a suit for a share in the property of his father who died in 1970 and that right also is foreclosed to him because of the bar of limitation.

7. In opposition to this, Sri Chandra Sekhar Rao, contends that under Section 37 of the Partnership Act, on the date of dissolution of the partnership, in view of the admitted position, defendant No. 3 is entitled to claim a share from out of the amounts standing to the credit of late Pullaiah as the accounts were not settled and the reconstituted partnership firm continued the joint family business with the assets of the earlier firm in which was included the share of Kota Pullaiah.

8. We are inclined to accept the contentions of Sri Chandra Sekhar Rao, in the plaint, it was specifically averred that the joint family business constituted the business of the joint family firm. No evidence whatsoever is found in the record nor our attention is invited to any part of the evidence to show that separate funds were procured for the firm. Pullaiah and Sons, and that the firm had lost the character of joint family business. Section 37 of the Partnership Act, which deals with right of an outoging partner is in the following terms:

37. Right of outgoing partner in certain cases to share subsequent profits:— Where any member of a firm has died or otherwise ceased to be a partner, and the surviving or continuing partners carry on the business of the firm with the property of the firm without any final settlement of accounts as between them and the outgoing partner or his estate, then, in the absence of a contract to the contrary, the outgoing partner or his estate is entitled at the option of himself or his representatives to such share of the profits made since he ceased to be a partner as may be attributable to the use of his share of the property of the firm or to interest at the rate of six per cent per annum on the amount of his share in the property of the firm:

Provided that where by contract between the partners an option is given to surviving or continuing partners to purchase the interest of a deceased or outgoing partner, and that option is duly exercised, the estate of the deceased partner, or the outgoing partner on his estate, as the case may be, is not entitled to any further or other share of profits; but if any partner assuming to act in exercise of the option does not in all material respects comply with the terms thereof, he is liable to account under the foregoing provisions of this section.”

From a reading of the above provision, it is clear that at the time when the firm was dissolved under Ex. B-109, Pullaiah, the outgoing partner was entitled, at his option and after his death his legal representatives for a share of the profits as may be attributed to the use of his share of the property by the continuing firm or to interest at the rate of 6% per annum on the amount of his share in the property of the firm. Either of these two options was open only if there was no final settlement of accounts when the partnership firm was dissolved. This legal position could not be seriously disputed by Sri T. Veerabhadraiah, learned counsel for the respondents. If that be so, it follows that there was no necessity for the third defendant to file a separate suit much less can it be said that the plaintiffs, as the sons of defendant No. 3, cannot claim their shares in the amounts standing to the credit of their grand-father in the accounts of the dissolved firm.

9. Sri M. Chandra Sekhar Rao, learned counsel for the appellants, however, sought to contend that rate of interest at six per cent prescribed under Section 37 of the Indian Partnership Act has no application to the instant case, as the accounts were settled and Rs. 37,757.74 ps was determined as the share of Kota Pullaiah and credited to his account and thereafter the sum was utilised by the firm re-constituted under Ex. B-110 and it is submitted that interest has to be calculated on the aforesaid amount at the rate at which the erstwhile partners had provided for, under the Partnership Deed i.e, at 12% whenever any share-capital was brought in by the partners and not at the rate of 6% as specified in Section 37. We are not inclined to accept the said contention of the learned counsel for the appellants for the reason that the settlement of accounts with the legal representatives was not completed and the distribution did not take place in the manner prescribed under Section 48 of the Partnership Act. Section 48 prescribes the manner in which the accounts have to be settled between the partners. The same is completed only when payments are made to each partner rateably towards advances, on account of capital and residue if any to be divided among the partners in proportions in which they are entitled to share profits.

10. In the instant case, the amount payable to Kota Pullaiah was determined and the same was credited to his account and continued to be utilised by the reconstituted firm of the continuing partners. Section 37 lays down the substantive law relating to the liability of the surviving or continuing partners who without a settlement of accounts with legal representatives of the deceased partner utilise the assets of the partnership for continuing the business. In the circumstances the legal representatives of Kota Pullaiah would have to exercise one of the options available to them under Section 37. As the firm or the reconstituted firm is no longer in existence, the only option available to the legal representatives of Kota Pullaiah including appellant No. 1 (defendant No. 3) would be to claim the share in the amounts which have been credited to Kota Pullaiah and continued to be used by the reconstituted partnership firm with interest thereon at 6% as per Section 37, referred to above. We accordingly reject the contention of learned counsel for the appellants claiming interest at 12% per annum.

11. As regards Items 1 and 2 of plaint — A Schedule properties, it is admitted that since the same were allotted to the share of Pullaiah, defendant No. 3 — the first appellant herein is entitled to 1/7th share and the same, cannot be disputed. The defendant No. 3 is, therefore, entitled to partition of the said properties and for allotment of 1/7th share in items 1 and 2 in plaint — A schedule property which was allotted to late Pullaiah. Accordingly, there shall be a preliminary decree to that extent and the decree and judgment of the Trial Court as also in A.S No. 154 of 1977 are accordingly reversed and set aside to that extent.

12. As regards the share in the firm of Kota Pullaiah and Sons, as already noticed, admittedly a sum of Rs. 37,757.74 ps was credited to the account of Kota Pullaiah on the dissolution of the firm on 19-4-1970 under Ex. B-109. The said amount was not paid to Kota Pullaiah and continued to be utilised by the fresh partnership that was constituted under Ex. B-110, dated 22-4-1970. Accordingly, under Section 37 of the Partnership Act, reference to which has been made above defendant No. 3 would be entitled to a half share therein amounting to Rs. 18,878.87 ps towards the seven paise share which was clubbed with the share of Kota Pullaiah. Defendant No. 3 would also be entitled to an additional 1/7th share in the remaining half of the amount standing to the credit of Late Pullaiah which comes to Rs. 2696.98 ps. The total amount on this account falling to the share of defendant No. 3 would aggregate to Rs. 21,575.85 ps (Rs. 18,878.87 + Rs. 2698.98). The 3rd defendant, as per Section 37 of the Partnership Act, is entitled to 6% interest thereon which works out to Rs. 34,953.12 ps from 19-4-1970 till 19-4-1997. The amount thus defendant No. 3 is entitled towards his share as principal and interest aggregates to Rs. 56,528.97 ps. However, it may be noted here that one of the brothers Kota Narayana Rao, 6th defendant in the suit, died and was not impleaded as a party respondent to L.P.A No. 403 of 1985. Accordingly, the 1/7th share (Rs. 8,075.57 ps) of Kota Narayana Rao who is not party to the appeal or to these proceedings would have to be excluded from the aforesaid amount. Excluding the said 1/7th share of Narayana Rao, the defendant No. 3 would be entitled to a sum of Rs. 48,453.40 ps (Rs. 56,528.97 ps — Rs. 8,075.57 ps). A money decree shall accordingly be passed for the said sum.

13. It may also be noted here as has been brought to our notice by Sri T. Veerabhadraiah, learned counsel for Respondent Nos. 1, 2, 3 and 5 that during the pendency of the proceedings before this Court, the mother of defendant No. 3 i.e, defendant No. 7 died on 29-10-1980 leaving behind a Registered Will and the respondent No. 2 herein, Kota Radha Krishna Murthy, is the legatee under the said Will, who was also taken over the liabilities of his mother. Accordingly, the 1/7th share which the mother would have been liable to pay to the defendant No. 3 would have to be added on to Respondent No. 2 — Kota Radha Krishna Murthy and he shall be liable to pay and discharge the same.

14. To obviate the calculations and difficulty in apportionment, we have considered it appropriate to calculate the same with the assistance of the learned counsel and arrived at the amount that is liable to be paid by the respective defendants to Appellant No. 1 (defendant No. 3) as shown below:

A sum of Rs. 48,453.40 ps shall be payable by respondents Nos. 1 to 4 herein i.e, defendants Nos. 1, 2, 4 and 5 in the following proportions:

Respondent No. 1 — Kota Venkateswarlu — Rs. 9,690.68

Respondent No. 2 — Kota Radhakrishna Murthy —Rs. 19,381.36

Respondent No. 3 — Kota Sankara Rao — Rs. 9,690.68

Respondent No. 4 — Kota Narasimha Rao — Rs, 9,690.68

A money decree in favour of defendant No. 3 is accordingly passed for recovery of the sums payable in the proportions set out above against the respective respondents-defendants. The learned counsel for the respondents has undertaken to deposit the said amount into the trial Court within three months from today. In default, the defendant No. 3 shall be entitled to execute the said decree.

15. In the result, the appeal is allowed reversing the judgment and decree passed in O.S No. 203 of 1970 as affirmed in A.S No. 154 of 1977 and instead, a preliminary decree for partition of items 1 and 2 of plaint A schedule property is hereby passed. The plaintiffs shall, however, work-out their equities from the share that may be allotted to defendant No. 3. Further, a decree for money in a sum of Rs. 48,453.40 ps (Rupees Forty Eight Thousand four hundred and fifty three and forty paise only) shall be passed in favour of defendant No. 3 and against respondents 1 to 4 herein i.e, defendant Nos. 1, 2, 4 and 5, in the proportions indicated above.

16. Having regard to the relationship between the parties, there shall be no order as to costs.

Appeal allowed.