- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kolli Venkata Apparao v. State Bank Of India
Comprehensive Summary of the Provided Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The respondent-plaintiff, State Bank of India, Agricultural Development Branch, Proddatur, filed O.S. No. 64/86, a suit for foreclosure based on a Hypothecation Deed dated 10-4-1974 executed by the first appellant (borrower) with the second appellant as guarantor for Rs. 55,000/-. The plaint referred to demand promissory notes and an extract of statement of account (Ex. A-34). The defendants admitted execution of the hypothecation deed and the promissory notes but resisted the claim on multiple grounds, notably seeking scaling down of interest under the Agricultural Debt Relief Act and asserting limitation as to the guarantor.
At trial, issues were framed and evidence was adduced by both sides (P.W.1 and Exs. A-1 to A-39 for the plaintiff; D.W.1 and Exs. B-1 to B-23 for the first defendant). The trial Court answered all issues in favour of the plaintiff and passed a preliminary decree against the defendants. That decree, as described in the opinion, resulted in a decree for sums aggregating (variously described in the opinion) and included past interest and costs; the defendants (appellants) appealed to the court which delivered the present opinion.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, in the facts and circumstances of the case, the respondent/plaintiff bank was justified in compounding interest with half yearly rests on the agricultural loan?
- Whether charging of interest on incidental/service/other charges debited to the appellants' account from time to time was permissible in law?
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- Compounding of interest with half yearly rests for agricultural advances is illegal, contrary to Reserve Bank of India circulars/directives and the law laid down by the Supreme Court in Corporation Bank v. D.S. Gowda (1994).
- Charging interest on incidental/service charges is not permissible under the terms of the contract (Hypothecation Deed dated 10-4-1974) or under any provision of law.
Respondent's Arguments
- When a borrower defaults, the bank is entitled to compound interest with half yearly rests even in respect of agricultural advances.
- Once incidental charges are debited to the borrower's account they become due from him, and the bank is therefore entitled to charge interest on those amounts.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Corporation Bank v. D.S. Gowda, (1994) 5 SCC 213 (1994 AIR SCW 2721) | The Supreme Court approved the principle that banks are bound to follow Reserve Bank of India circulars/directives prescribing rate and mode of charging interest; banks cannot charge compound interest with quarterly rests on agricultural advances. | The court relied on the approval in this decision to hold that the respondent-bank was bound by RBI directives and therefore unjustified in compounding interest with half yearly rests on an agricultural loan. |
| Krishna Reddy v. Canara Bank, AIR 1985 Kant 228 | High Court principle that if interest charged by banks is not in conformity with RBI-prescribed rate/structure, courts may disallow excess interest; banks cannot charge compound interest with quarterly rests on agricultural advances. | The opinion notes this High Court principle and records that it received the Supreme Court's approval in Corporation Bank's case; it supports the court's conclusion that compounding with half-yearly rests was unlawful. |
| Bank of India v. Karnam Ranga Rao, AIR 1986 Kant 242 | Considers RBI circulars/directives (14-3-1972, 5-10-1974, 13-3-1976, 17-8-1976 and 27-2-1978); holds agricultural advances should not be treated like commercial loans regarding compounding; interest with monthly/quarterly/half-yearly rests discouraged; interest may be charged with yearly rests and may be compounded if the loan/instalment becomes overdue. | The court extracted and relied on the reasoning and the Supreme Court's observations in that case to conclude that compounding interest with half yearly rests on agricultural loans contravened RBI directives and was impermissible; yearly rests were permissible and compounding could occur when overdue. |
| (Unspecified) decision reported at AIR 1983 Kant 143 (First Appeal No. 107/81) | This prior Karnataka decision related to charging interest at 16½% with quarterly rests on a commercial loan (not agricultural); principles from that decision are not the subject of the present opinion's application to agricultural loans. | The court noted that it was not concerned with the principles enunciated in that civil appeal because it pertained to commercial loans; it was referenced for context but not used to justify compounding on agricultural advances. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded by identifying the admitted material facts and the legal standards drawn from authoritative sources:
- It was admitted that Ex. A-34 (statement of account) formed the basis of the suit claim and that interest had been charged in the stated periodic bands (14.5% for 10-4-1975 to 31-12-1977; 11% for 1-1-1978 to 31-12-1979; 12.5% for 1-12-1980 to 25-8-1986) and that these rates applied to agricultural loans.
- The court identified the controlling legal principle: banks are bound to follow RBI circulars/directives regarding rate and mode of charging interest on agricultural loans. It emphasized the Supreme Court's approval of the Karnataka High Court's interpretation (in Corporation Bank v. D.S. Gowda and Krishna Reddy v. Canara Bank) that banks cannot compound interest on agricultural advances with short periodical rests (monthly, quarterly, half-yearly).
- The court examined the Bank of India v. Karnam Ranga Rao line of authority and the RBI circulars extracted therein and recited the reasoning that agricultural borrowers (farmers) typically receive income once a year, making quarterly or half-yearly compounding unsuitable and effectively converting agricultural loans into commercial treatment if permitted.
- Applying those principles, the court concluded that compounding with half-yearly rests (as done by the respondent-bank) contravened RBI directives and the settled jurisprudence; thus the bank was not justified in compounding interest with half-yearly rests. The court recognized that yearly rests (and compounding when an advance/instalment becomes overdue) are consistent with the circulars.
- On the second point, the court noted that Ex. A-34 showed Rs. 6,432.48 debited as service/other charges and that the respondent admitted interest had been charged on those amounts with half-yearly rests. The court found no term in the hypothecation deed nor any legal provision or pleading/evidence establishing the bank's entitlement to charge interest on such service/incidental charges. Because the bank failed to plead and prove entitlement, the court held charging interest on those charges unsustainable in law.
- Balancing these analyses, the court determined that the earlier judgment awarding interest at 14% per annum compounded half-yearly (and charging interest on incidental charges) could not be sustained. It re-decreed the suit amount with the principal and specified past interest rates for specified periods, but required compounding with yearly rests only and included the service/incidental/other charges as a principal sum (Rs. 6,432.48) without sustaining interest thereon.
- Procedural directions were given: parties to file statements of account prepared according to the modified terms within two weeks; Registry to prepare the decree within four weeks after notice to counsel; time for redemption fixed at four months from date of preparation of the decree.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The appeal is allowed to the extent indicated and the decree under appeal is modified.
More specifically, the court held:
- The respondent-bank was not justified in compounding interest with half yearly rests on the agricultural loan; compounding is permissible only with yearly rests (and compounding may occur when the advance/instalment becomes overdue, in line with RBI circulars and the cited jurisprudence).
- Charging interest on service/incidental/other charges debited to the appellants' account was unsustainable because the bank failed to plead or prove any contractual or legal entitlement to charge interest on those charges; the court therefore did not allow interest to be charged on those service/incidental charges (the principal amount of such charges—Rs. 6,432.48—was reflected in the modified decree, but interest on those charges was not sustained).
- The decree was modified to decree Rs. 55,000 together with interest at the specified historical rates for specified periods, compoundable with yearly rests, and service/incidental charges of Rs. 6,432.48 after deducting repayments; and with future interest at 6% per annum on Rs. 55,000 from the date of institution until redemption. The appeal was allowed accordingly and no costs were awarded.
Implications: The decision applies existing Supreme Court and High Court authority and RBI circulars to the facts; it does not purport to establish a new legal principle but enforces the settled rule that short-period compounding (quarterly or half-yearly) is impermissible for agricultural advances and that banks must plead and prove any entitlement to interest on incidental/service charges. The direct effect is to modify the decree in favour of the respondent but restrict the mode and computation of interest and disallow interest on incidental charges.
Administrative Directions (as ordered)
- Both parties to file statements of account prepared as per the modified terms into the Registry within two weeks from the date of the opinion.
- The Registry shall prepare the decree within four weeks thereafter after giving notice to counsel on either side.
- Time for redemption is fixed at four months from the date of preparation of the decree.
Disposition: Appeal allowed to the extent mentioned; decree modified; no costs.
1. The defendants who have suffered a preliminary decree for a sum of Rs. 2,40,070-80 ps. calculated up to 13-4-1993 i.e, Rs. 55,000/- towards principal, Rs. 1,73,693-80 towards interest and Rs. 11,377-00 towards costs in O.S No. 64/86 — a suit for foreclosure filed by the State Bank of India, Agricultural Development Branch, Proddatur, on the file of the Subordinate Judge, Proddatur, are the appellants herein.
2. The suit has been filed on the foot of Hypothecation Deed dt. 10-4-1974 executed by the first appellant as borrower and the second appellant as guarantor for a sum of Rs. 55,000/- together with interest at ½% over the SBI advance rate subject to minimum of 12½% per annum with half yearly rests. The appellants admitted the execution of the deed of hypothecation dt. 10-4-1974 and the demand promissory notes referred to in the plaint. However, they resisted the suit claim on several grounds, the main being that the interest should be scaled down as per the provisions of Agricultural Debt Relief Act (A.P Agriculturists Relief Act) (Act No. 4/38) and the suit is barred by limitation as far as the second appellant, the guarantor, is concerned. Appropriate issues have been framed. Evidence has been let on either side. P.W 1 has been examined and Exs. A-1 to A-39 have been marked on behalf of the plaintiff. The first defendant, who is the first appellant herein, examined himself as D.W 1 and Exs. B-1 to B-23 have been marked on his behalf. On appraisal of the said oral and documentary evidence, the trial Court answered all the issues in favour of the respondent/plaintiff and against the appellants/defendants. Accordingly, a preliminary decree has been passed against the appellants for a sum of Rs. 2,06,803-80 with future interest at 6% per annum on Rs. 55,000/- from the date of the suit till the date of realisation.
2A. Though several grounds have been raised and lengthy written arguments have been submitted, Sri T. Veerabhadrayya, learned counsel for the appellants made only two submissions. His first and principal submission is that compounding of interest with half yearly rests in respect of agricultural advances is illegal, being contrary to the circulars/directives issued by the Reserve Bank of India and the law laid down by the Supreme Court in Corporation Bank v. D.S Gowda, (1994) 5 SCC 213 : 1994 AIR SCW 2721). His second submission, which is rather supplementary to the first, is that charging of interest on incidental charges debited to the appellants's account from time to time is not permissible either under the terms of the contract entered into between the parties or under any provision of law. Sri K. Gopala Krishna Murthy, lerned counsel for the respondent/plaintiff, refutes the first submission on the ground that when a borrower defaults it would be open to the bank to compound interest with half yearly rests even in respect of agricultural advances and the second submission on the ground that once the incidental charges are debited to the borrower's account, they become due from him and therefore the bank is entitled to charge interest thereon.
In view of these rival submissions, the points that emerge for my consideration are:
(1) Whether in the facts and circumstances of the case, the respondent/plaintiff bank is justified in compounding interest with half yearly rests? and
(2) Whether charging of interest on incidental charges debited to the appellants' account from time to time is permissible in law?
3. POINT No. 1: It is admitted by the learned counsel on either side that the suit claim is based on Ex. A-34, an extract of statement of account relating to the suit debt. It is also admitted by them that as per the said statement, interest was charged on the suit debt with half yearly rests at 14.5% for the period from 10-4-1975 to 31-12-1977 at 11% for the period from 1-1-1978 to 31-12-1979 and at 12.5% for the period from 1-12-1980 to 25-8-1986, the date of institution of the suit. Further, they did not dispute the applicability of above stated rates of interest to agricultural loans.
4. The principle that “if it is proved that the interest charged by banks on loans advanced is not in conformity with the rate prescribed by the Reserve Bank then the Court could disallow such excess interest and give relief to the party notwithstanding the provisions of Section 21-A. Banks are bound to follow the directives or circulars issued by the Reserve Bank prescribing the structure of interest to be charged on loans and any interest charged by banks in excess of the prescribed limit would be illegal and void. Banks cannot charge compound interest with quarterly rests on agricultural advances” enunciated by the High Court of Karnataka in Krishna Reddy v. Canara Bank*, AIR 1985 Kant 228 had the approval of the Supreme Court in Corporation Bank's case (supra) in the following terms:
“We are in respectful agreement with the above interpretation placed on Section 21-A of the Banking Regulation Act.”
Thus, there can be no doubt whatsoever that the respondent-bank is bound by the Circulars/directives issued by the Reserve Bank of India regarding the rate and mode of charging interest on loans advanced for agricultural purposes.
5. There is no dispute that regarding agricultural advances the Reserve Bank of India issued Circulars/directives dt. 14-3-1972, 5-10-1974, 13-3-1976, 17-8-1976 and 27-2-1978 which have been extracted in extenso in Bank of India v. Karnam Ranga Rao, AIR 1986 Kant 242. The point for consideration therein was whether the bank can charge compound interest with monthly, quarterly, or half yearly rests on overdue agricultural loans. The facts of that case are: Bank of India filed a suit for recovery of a sum of Rs. 30,564/-, said to be due from defendants 1 and 2 on a loan of Rs. 10,000/- granted to them for raising sugarcane crop. The rate of interest agreed between the parties was 4% above the rate prescribed by the Reserve Bank of India subject to a minimum of 13% with quarterly rests. However, the bank laid the suit, charging interest at the agreed rate with half yearly rests. The defendants while admitting the loan denied their liability to pay interest with quarterly rests on the ground that the loan was sanctioned for agricutlural purpose and the bank has no right to compound interest periodically. One of the issues framed in the suit was whether the plaintiff was not entitled to charge compound interest. The trial Court, having held that the plaintiff would not be entitled to charge compund interest on the loans advanced for agricultural purpose, directed the plaintiff to submit a revised statement of account charging simple interest on the amount due. Accordingly, the plaintiff submitted a revised statement showing Rs. 19,851-66 as the sum due from the defendants. The Court then decreed the suit for the said amount with future interest at 6% payable in two instalments. Aggrieved by the said decree, the bank carried the matter in appeal to the High Court of Karnataka. The appeal was heard by a Division Bench consisting of K. Jagannadha Shetty, Acting Chief Justice, as he then was, and M.S Patil, J., K. Jagannadha Shetty, J. speaking for the Division Bench, on elaborate consideration of the real object and purpose of the circulars/directives dt. 14-3-1972, 5-10-1974, 13-3-1976, 17-8-1976 and 28-2-1978, issued by the Reserve Bank of India, concluded as under:
“The circulars/directives of the Reserve Bank direct that agricultural advances should not be treated on par with the commercial loans in the matter of application of the system of compounding interest. The farmers do not have any regular source of income other than sale proceeds of their crops is an acknowledged fact. They get income generally only once a year. They are, therefore, not in a position to pay interest at usual fixed intervals like monthly, quarterly and half yearly. Banks should not compound interest on current dues. Banks should not also charge interest with monthly, quarterly or half yearly rests on overdue loans. Perhaps, it may not be illegal to charge interest with yearly rests.”
Consequently, the appeal was dismissed. Then, the matter was carried by Bank of India to the Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 544/86. This appeal was heard along with Civil Appeal No. 4214/82 arising out of judgment dt. 22-10-1982 in First Appeal No. 107/81, on the file of the High Court of Karnataka, reported in AIR 1983 Kant 143 and a common judgment was rendered. We are not concerned with the principles enunciated by the Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 4214/82 since it related to charging interest at 16½ with quarterly rests on a loan advanced for commercial purpose. For our purpose, it is sufficient to refer to the following observations of the Supreme Court made in Corporation Bank's Case (supra).
‘Insofar as Civil Appeal No. 544 of 1986 is concerned it relates to the Bank's right to charge compound interest i.e, interest with periodical rests on agricultural advances. We have already referred to the various circulars issued by the Reserve Bank from time to time in exercise of power conferred by Section 21/35-A of the Banking Regulation Act. We have pointed out that the said circulars/directives provide that agricultural advances should not be treated on par with commercial loans insofar as the rate of interest thereon is concerned because the farmers do not have any regular source of income except sale proceeds of their crops which income they get once a year. The question of recovery of interest with quarterly or six-monthly rests from farmers is, therefore, not feasible. The fact that the farmers are fluid at a given point of time every year has to be kept in mind in determining the point of time when they should be expected to repay the loan or pay the instalment/interest on advances. Therefore, to allow the banks to charge interest on quarterly or half yearly rests from farmers would tantamount to virtually compelling them to pay compound interest, since they would not be able to pay the interest except once in a year i.e, when they receive the income from sale proceeds of their crops. The Reserve Bank has shown concern for the farmers by directing all banking institutions to so regulate the recovery of interest as to coincide with the point of time when the farmers are fluid. It has, therefore, been emphasised by the Reserve Bank that interest should be charged once a year to coincide with the point of time when the farmer is fluid and interest on current dues should not be compounded although it may be done when the advance/instalment becomes overdue. Thus according to the circulars/directives, so far as loans for agricultural purposes are concerned, at best interest may be charged with yearly rests and may be compunded if the loan/instalment becomes overdue. In the present case, since interest was charged with six-monthly rests that was clearly in contravention of the Reserve Bank circulars/directives. Compounding of interest on current dues on agricultural advances having been discourage, the Bank was not entitled to charge interest with shorter periodical rests and compound the same. The Bank could add interest outstanding to the principal and compound the interest when the crop loan or term loan becomes overdue having regard to the tenor of the circular dt. 14-3-1972. The High Court was, therefore, fully justified in coming to the conclusion that the Bank was not entitled to charge interest with half yearly rests.”
(Para 23)
In view of the above, there should be no hesitation to conclude that the respondent bank is not justified in compounding interest with half yearly rests. It follows, the contention of the learned counsel for the respondent that when a borrower, who availed agricultural loan, defaults it would be open to the bank to charge compound interest with half yearly rests is totally devoid of substance, for, acceptance of such contention would amount to according permission to the bank to convert agricultural loans into commercial loans the moment the agricultural debtor commits default. None of the circulars/directives of the Reserve Bank of India referred to supra permits the banks to resort to such a course. In this view of the matter, the inevitable conclusion could be that the respondent bank is totally unjustified in compounding interest with half yearly rests, but it would be entitled to compound the same with yearly rests. This point is, accordingly, answered.
6. POINT No. 2: As per Ex. A-34, a sum of Rs. 6432-48 was debited to the appellants' account from time to time towards service of other charges. Learned counsel for the respondent bank admits that interest was charged thereon, as usual, with half yearly rests. However, he is unable to show any provisions of law or term or condition in the Hypothecation Deed, dt. 10-4-1974, which entitles the respondent bank from charging interest on such charges. The plaint as well as the evidence of P.W 1 is silent on this aspect. There can be little doubt that it is for the respondent bank to plead and prove its entitlement to charge interest on service/incidental/other charges too. But, in the case on hand, it has failed to prove the same. In the circumstances, I hold that charging of interest on service/incidental/other charges debited to the appellants' account from time to time is unsustainable in law. This point is, thus, answered.
7. In view of the above conclusions, the judgment under appeal awarding interest at 14% per annum on principal and service/incidental/other charges, compounding with half yearly rests cannot be sustained. Instead, the suit shall stand decreed in favour of the respondent/plaintiff and against the appellants/defendants for a sum of Rs. 55,000/- together with interest thereon at 14.5% per annum from 10-4-1975 to 31-12-1977, at 11% per annum from 1-1-1978 to 30-11 -1980 and at 12.5% per annum from 1-12-1980 to 25-8-1986, the date of institution of the suit, compoundable with yearly rests and service/incidental/other charges of Rs. 6432-48, of course, after deducting the repayments made by the appellants from time to time and future interest at 6% per annum on Rs. 55,000/- from the date of the institution of the suit till the date of redemption. The decree under appeal shall stand, accordingly, modified.
8. The appellants as well as the respondent shall file statement of account prepared as per the above terms into Registry within two weeks from to-day and the Registry shall prepare the decree within four weeks thereafter after giving notice to the counsel on either side. Time for redemption is 4 months from the date of preparation of the decree.
9. In the result, the appeal is allowed to the extent mentioned above. No costs.
Appeal allowed.
Alert