Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Durga Seed Farm v. Raj Kumari Chadha .

Supreme Court Of India
Jan 19, 1995
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent obtained an allotment of the premises from the Chandigarh Administration under a lease designated for showroom use. The appellant occupied the premises as a tenant. The respondent initiated eviction proceedings alleging that the appellant had erected an unauthorised shed, installed heavy machinery, and otherwise altered the structure in a manner that damaged the building and violated the terms of the allotment. The courts below ordered eviction. The present opinion is the Supreme Court’s decision on the appellant-tenant’s appeal against that eviction order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant-tenant’s alterations and change of user constituted a breach of the lease conditions sufficient to warrant eviction.
  2. Whether the risk of resumption of the property by the Chandigarh Administration under clauses 16 and 17 of the allotment terms justified upholding the eviction order.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent’s Arguments

  • The appellant constructed a shed supported by heavy iron angles and girders, placing undue load on walls not meant for that purpose.
  • The shed and installation of machines caused material damage to the building and impaired its value and utility.
  • The alterations amounted to an unauthorised change of user from showroom-cum-office to semi-industrial activity, exposing the property to possible resumption by the Chandigarh Administration.

Appellant’s Arguments

  • The tenant is entitled to make temporary additions and alterations; the shed is only a temporary structure.
  • The plot is classified as semi-industrial, and installation of a 15-HP motor and machines is permissible.
  • No damage has been caused that could justify resumption or eviction; the respondent’s allegations of impairment are denied.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court focused on clauses 16 and 17 of the allotment terms, which restrict use of the site to the purpose for which it was leased and permit cancellation and resumption upon breach. It held that continuation of the appellant’s alterations and user would expose the respondent to the “peril of resumption” by the Chandigarh Administration. Given this exposure, the Court found it unnecessary to examine in detail the lower courts’ factual findings on whether the alterations materially impaired the building. The statutory and contractual framework alone justified eviction. Accordingly, the Court affirmed the eviction order.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed; Eviction Upheld.

The appellant must:

  • Vacate and hand over possession by 31-12-1995, subject to filing an undertaking within four weeks.
  • Pay outstanding arrears of Rs 2,28,500 by demand draft on or before 28-02-1995.
  • Pay damages for use and occupation at Rs 4,500 per month, with specific deadlines for past and future months.
  • Face immediate eviction if any payment schedule is violated.

The decision resolves the dispute between the parties but sets no new legal precedent, as it turns on the particular lease conditions and agreed terms between the counsel.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. We have heard Mr M.L Verma, learned Senior Counsel for the appellant and Mr R.F Nariman, learned Senior Counsel for the respondent. From the terms of the allotment of the property in favour of the respondent by Chandigarh Administration, it is clear that the allotment under a lease was as a showroom. In seeking to evict the appellant from the premises the respondent alleged as under:

“The additions and alterations on account of the construction of this shed have caused damage to the building and this construction has materially impaired the value and utility of the building. The building can be resumed also by the Estate Officer on account of this unauthorised construction. It is likely that on account of this unauthorised construction, the Estate Officer may demolish the shed at any time, which can cause great damage to the building because the enforcement staff whenever demolishes a building, they demolish it in such hopeless manner that it may cause a great damage to the other parts of the building. The shed is supported by big and heavy iron rod angles and girders etc. The load of the whole shed has been put upon the walls which are not meant for this purpose. That the respondent has also caused a great damage to the building. The respondent has got affixed some machines in the building. On account of putting up of the machines, it has also caused damage to the building. These machines have been put by the respondent without the written consent of the petitioner. The premises were taken on rent by the respondent for showroom-cum-office purpose and it was never the intention of the parties to use the premises for affixing the machines. This amounts to change of user also.”

2. In answer to this the appellant urges that:

“The tenant is entitled to make additions and alterations which are temporary in nature. The plot is a semi-industrial plot on which the construction has been made by the landlord and every lessee is entitled to install a motor of 15 HP. That the tenant has not done anything which impairs the value and utility of the building. Neither the building could be resumed on account of any temporary alterations and those made by the lessee. The shed is only a temporary arrangement made by the lessee.
Para 3 of the petition is incorrect and denied to the extent that the lessee-respondent has caused any damage to the building. Being a semi-industrial plot and pursuant to the verbal terms of the lease, the respondent lessee has put up some machines which are permissible under the terms of the plot to the landlord.”

3. On this premise, if the matter is proceeded with, it is clear that the allottee (respondent) will be exposed to the peril of resumption by the Chandigarh Administration by reason of clauses 16 and 17 of the terms of allotment. Those clauses are extracted below:

“16. The site and the building erected thereon shall be used only for the purpose of general for which it has been leased.
17. In the event of default, breach or non-compliance of any of the conditions of lease, the lease may be cancelled and the site resumed and the whole/part amount paid to Government, towards the premium/rent of the site may be forfeited to Government. After the cancellation of lease, it shall be the responsibility of the lessee to remove the malba/structure, if any, within such reasonable period as may be prescribed by the Estate Officer not exceeding 3 months from the date of cancellation of lease, failing which the Estate Officer shall be competent to remove the malba or to proceed to auction the site along with the building thereon and after deducting the market price of the site make over the proceeds of the auction to the lessee. In case of any dispute arising out of the determination of the amount to be paid to the lessee following the auction of site and building thereon, the Chief Administrator shall act as the sole arbitrator and his decision shall be final and binding on the parties.”

4. Once we approach the matter this way, we do not think we need to get bogged down by the findings in judgments of the courts below whether the appellant-tenant had caused such acts as likely to impair material value or utility of the building or rental land.

5. From the above, it is clear that the eviction ordered against the appellant could be upheld. Thus, we see no merits in this appeal, which is dismissed with no costs.

6. Both the learned counsel agreed to the following:

1. That the appellant-tenant will have time till 31-12-1995 to hand over vacant possession. The same is subject to filing of usual undertaking within four weeks from today in this Court.
2. Admittedly, the appellant issued cheques/money orders towards rent at the rate of Rs 4500 per mensem. Money orders have been refused and cheques have not been encashed by the respondent-landlady. As on today, for the period commencing from August 1990 to December 1994, admittedly, there is outstanding arrear of Rs 2,28,500. This amount shall be paid by means of a demand draft drawn on any nationalised bank on or before 28-2-1995, by the appellant to the respondent.
3. As regards the damages for use and occupation, it is determined at the rate of Rs 4500 per mensem. The damages for the months of January and February 1995 shall be paid on or before 15-3-1995 by means of demand draft drawn in favour of the respondent by the appellant. Thereafter commencing from 1-3-1995 the damages for use and occupation @ Rs 4500 per mensem shall be paid by the appellant in favour of the respondent on or before 15th of each succeeding English calendar month.
4. That in default of payment of any one of the above, the tenant shall be liable to be evicted forthwith and time granted till 31-12-1995 cannot be availed of.