- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Tahir Nazir v. State Of J&K & Ors.
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The post in question is Range Officer Grade-I (Forest). The applicable recruitment rules are the Jammu and Kashmir Forest Service (Gazetted) Recruitment Rules of 1970 (as amended by SRO 3 dated 05.01.1994), which prescribe the qualification for the post as "B.Sc. (Forestry) or its equivalent from any University recognized by Indian Council of Agriculture and Research." The Schedule (Class V, Category C, Grade 825-1240) also specifies B.Sc. (Forestry) or its equivalent and a method of recruitment.
The Public Service Commission issued an advertisement calling for applications consistent with the above qualification. The petitioners held a general graduation degree with Forestry as one subject (B.Sc. with Forestry as one subject) and also held M.Sc. (Forestry). Because they did not possess a B.Sc. (Forestry) degree (a complete course in Forestry), they were excluded from the selection process and filed a writ petition seeking quashment of the Advertisement dated 08.09.2010 and a direction permitting their participation in the selection on the basis of their qualifications (B.Sc. with Forestry as a subject and M.Sc. (Forestry)).
On 24.11.2010 the Court directed the respondents-Public Service Commission to permit the petitioners to take the examination at their own risk and responsibility. The respondents filed objections/reply affidavit. During the writ petition, the Commission produced results; petitioner no. 3 qualified for interview and was ordered to be subjected to interview with the qualification issue left open for final determination. The matter proceeded on written submissions and authorities cited by both sides.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a candidate who holds a B.Sc. degree with Forestry as one subject (but not a full B.Sc. (Forestry) course) and an M.Sc. (Forestry) qualifies as being possessed of the prescribed eligibility qualification "B.Sc. (Forestry) or its equivalent" under the Rules of 1970 and the Advertisement for the post of Range Officer Grade-I (Forest).
- Whether a superior qualification (M.Sc. (Forestry)) can be treated as equivalent to, or deemed to include, the specific qualification prescribed (B.Sc. (Forestry)), thereby making the petitioners eligible.
- To what extent the Court may, in interpreting recruitment rules or advertisement qualifications, substitute its view for that of the rule-making/appointing authority or declare alternative qualifications to be acceptable.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The petitioners asserted they possess a B.Sc. degree with Forestry as one of the subjects and also hold M.Sc. (Forestry), and therefore are eligible under the Rules/Advertisement.
- They contended that possessing a higher qualification (M.Sc.) should not make them ineligible and that denying them participation would be unfair and discriminatory, invoking equality concerns under Article 16 of the Constitution of India (as referenced by their counsel).
- They relied on judgments (including S. Gurmeet Singh & ors., Mehmooda Bano & ors., Mohd. Riazul Usman Gani, Satpal Sharma, Surinder Singh Jamwal) to support the contention that candidates with higher qualifications in the same discipline should be considered eligible where the prescribed qualification is a minimum.
- They pointed to an instance (referred in supplementary affidavit) where, they alleged, a similarly qualified candidate was recommended/appointed, arguing they should not be discriminated against vis-à-vis that candidate.
Respondents (J&K Public Service Commission) Arguments
- The Commission argued the petitioners are ineligible because the Rules of 1970 and the Advertisement specifically prescribe B.Sc. (Forestry) (or its equivalent) and the petitioners do not hold that prescribed specific degree.
- They submitted that equivalence of academic/technical degrees is a matter for expert bodies and the Court should not itself determine equivalence; determination of equivalence falls within the domain of the rule-making/appointing authority.
- Counsel for respondents relied on multiple authorities (including P.M. Latha, K. Manjusree, Sheikh Muzaffar Rashid, Bashir Ahmad Mantoo) and argued the petition should be dismissed.
- The Commission noted that the petitioners had been permitted to participate by interim order, but their substantive eligibility remained governed by the Rules/Advertisement.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| S. Gurmeet Singh & ors. v. State and others, 2008 (1) JKJ 68 (HC) | Illustrates that where a rule prescribes a minimum qualification (Diploma), higher qualifications (Degree) in the same discipline may be treated as acceptable; selection authority had provided marks for higher qualification. | The Court distinguished this authority on facts, noting that in the present case B.Sc. (Forestry) is a specific/only qualification prescribed (not a minimum), so the reasoning in Gurmeet Singh did not apply. |
| Mehmooda Bano & ors. v. State of J&K & ors. (SWP No.112/2012) | Concerns a post where minimum qualification (10+2 with Diploma) was prescribed and candidates with higher qualifications (B.Sc. Nursing) were treated as eligible. | The Court treated Mehmooda Bano as distinguishable because that case involved a minimum qualification rather than a specific/only qualification as in the present case. |
| Mohd. Riazul Usman Gani and others v. District and Sessions Judge, Nagpur, AIR 2000 SC 919 | Held that the phrase "not lower than" prescribes a minimum qualification (Std IV), making candidates with higher education also eligible. | The Court held this precedent inapplicable because in the present matter B.Sc. (Forestry) is the only prescribed qualification, not a minimum; thus petitioners could not rely on Riazul Usman Gani. |
| Satpal Sharma v. State of J&K & ors, 2008 (1) JKJ 77 (HC) | On the right of a selected candidate to be considered only for the post for which he applied and not for another post. | The Court noted this precedent was not applicable to the present facts. |
| Surinder Singh Jamwal and another v. State of J&K & ors, 2010 (2) JKJ 527 (HC) | Dealt with claim for equal pay for equal work (different factual matrix). | The Court observed this case was not factually similar and therefore not applicable. |
| P.M. Latha and another v. State of Kerala and others, (2003) 3 SCC 541 | Affirms that fixing eligibility qualifications is part of recruitment policy of the State; holding that B.Ed. was not equivalent to T.T.C. for certain teacher posts. | The Court relied on this principle to support the position that the rule-making authority can prescribe specific qualifications and that courts should not treat other qualifications as automatically equivalent. |
| K. Manjusree v. State of Andhra Pradesh, 2008 (3) SCC 512 | Cited by respondents' counsel in support of their submissions regarding qualifications/selection (as part of authorities relied upon). | The Court noted that respondents relied on this authority as part of their submission that petition ought to be dismissed; the opinion does not further apply or distinguish it in detail. |
| Sheikh Muzaffar Rashid v. High Court of J&K & ors, 2010 (1) SLJ 308 / 2010 (1) JKJ HC-148 | Cited by respondents' counsel among authorities supporting dismissal and limitations on court intervention in equivalence issues. | The Court recorded that respondents' counsel relied upon this authority; the judgment is part of the respondents' cited support for dismissal but not specifically analyzed in text. |
| Bashir Ahmad Mantoo v. State of J&K, 2009 (2) JKJ HC-86 : 2011 (1) SLJ 196 | Cited by respondents' counsel among supporting authorities for dismissal. | The Court noted the citation by respondents; the opinion does not elaborate further on its particular application. |
| Ab. Qayoom v. M. A. Chesti and ors., 2009 (Suppl.) JKJ 222 (HC) | Explains the delineation of functions of the three organs of State (Legislature, Executive, Judiciary) and cautions against any organ transgressing its domain. | The Court relied on this reasoning to emphasize the limits of judicial power, explaining why courts cannot themselves legislate or rewrite recruitment rules. |
| Farooq Ahmad Nengroo v. State of J&K and others, 2012 (3) JKJ HC-382 | Affirms the doctrine of separation of functions among the three organs of the State and the limited role of courts in interpreting (not making) law. | The Court cited this decision to reinforce the principle that courts must interpret laws but not assume functions of the legislature or executive by rewriting qualifications. |
| Yash Bhashin v. State and others, 2012 (3) JKJ HC-685 | Reiterates constitutional delineation of functions and the court's role to interpret laws and resolve disputes rather than legislate. | The Court relied on this authority as part of the broader exposition on the respective roles of State organs and to justify restraint in substituting qualifications. |
| Jyoti K.K. and others v. Kerala Public Service Commission and others, JT 2002 (Suppl. KD 85 HC | Interprets a statutory provision (Rule 10(1)(II) of Kerala Rules) that recognized certain executive orders/standing orders as establishing equivalence — enabling higher qualifications which presuppose lower ones to be sufficient. | The Court distinguished this authority because there is no equivalent provision in the Jammu & Kashmir Rules, and because B.Sc. (Forestry) is a complete course whereas the petitioners had only B.Sc. with Forestry as one subject. |
| Ajay Kumar Uttam (reported in 2010 (2) JKJ 757 (HC)) | Addressed situations where a "minimum qualification" was prescribed and higher qualifications were therefore treated as acceptable. | The Court treated Ajay Kumar Uttam (and cases that follow its reasoning) as distinguishable because the present case involves a specific/only qualification rather than a minimumqualification. |
| Ashok Kumar Sharma and others v. Chander Shekhar and another, (1997) 4 SCC 18 (cited in text) | Holds that an advertisement/notification calling for applications is a representation to the public and the authority issuing it is bound by that representation; the authority cannot act contrary to it. | The Court applied this principle to conclude the selection/appointing authority is bound by the qualification prescribed under the Rules and the Advertisement and cannot accept qualifications not prescribed therein. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded by first identifying the exact language of the statutory Rules (Rules of 1970) and the Advertisement: both prescribe "B.Sc. (Forestry) or its equivalent from any University recognized by the Indian Council of Agricultural Research" as the qualification for Range Officer Grade-I.
The Court evaluated whether the petitioners' qualifications (B.Sc. with Forestry as one subject; and M.Sc. (Forestry)) amounted to the prescribed qualification in the Rules/Advertisement. The Court emphasized several legal and practical principles to guide its analysis:
- Separation of functions: The Court reiterated authoritative statements (from prior Division Bench decisions) about the delineation of roles among the legislature, executive and judiciary — in particular, that courts interpret law but must not legislate or rewrite statutory qualifications which are within the rule-making authority's domain.
- Specific vs. minimum qualification: The Court contrasted situations where a rule prescribes a minimum qualification (in which case higher qualifications in the same discipline may be acceptable) with the present case where a specific/only qualification (B.Sc. (Forestry)) is prescribed. The Court held that where only a specific qualification is prescribed, one cannot import a broader meaning to include other degrees.
- No presumption that higher degree presupposes lower specific degree: The Court explained that while sometimes a higher degree may presuppose acquisition of a lower degree in the same discipline, that presumption is not universally applicable. In modern academic structures a candidate may attain an M.Sc. in a discipline without having undergone the full lower-course equivalent (B.Sc. (Forestry)) as a discrete, full course. Specifically, the Court found that a B.Sc. with Forestry as one subject is not the same as B.Sc. (Forestry), a distinct full course.
- Limits of judicial determination of equivalence: The Court accepted the respondents' submission that equivalence of academic/technical degrees is essentially within the competence of expert/bodies or the rule-making authority; the Court should not expand eligibility by judicial fiat where Rules prescribe specific qualifications.
- Consistency and non-discrimination concerns: The Court observed that declaring petitioners eligible while other M.Sc. holders who did not respond to the advertisement would be disadvantaged could lead to inequitable outcomes and discrimination; the Court also noted that petitioners formed a distinct class from those expressly eligible under the Rules and Advertisement.
Applying these principles to the facts, the Court concluded:
- The petitioners' B.Sc. degree with Forestry as one subject does not equal the prescribed B.Sc. (Forestry) (a full course in Forestry) and therefore does not meet the explicit eligibility requirement.
- Possession of an M.Sc. (Forestry) does not permit a presumption that the petitioner also holds B.Sc. (Forestry); the M.Sc. might have been obtained without the petitioners having completed the full B.Sc. (Forestry) course.
- Because the Rules and the Advertisement prescribed a specific/only qualification, authorities and the Court cannot treat superior qualifications as substituting for that specific qualification in the absence of a statutory provision or rule that treats the prescribed qualification as a minimum.
- Authoritative precedents that permit higher qualifications to be treated as acceptable apply in situations where the statutory language or rules prescribe a minimum qualification or where there is an explicit provision recognizing equivalence. The Court found those precedents distinguishable on facts or inapplicable to the present Rule wording.
- Given these conclusions, the petitioners were not eligible under the Rules/Advertisement and the petition could not succeed. The Court also recorded that no finding on the broader question of "minimum qualification" could be recorded in this case (paragraph 30).
Holding and Implications
Holding: For the reasons set out in the opinion, the Court concluded that the petitioners were not possessed of the specific eligibility qualification prescribed by the Rules of 1970 and the Advertisement and therefore are ineligible to be considered for appointment to the post of Range Officer Grade-I (Forest).
Core Ruling: The petition is DISMISSED.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The petitioners remain ineligible under the Rules/Advertisement. The interim permission to participate in the selection process was without prejudice to the question of eligibility, which has now been finally determined against the petitioners.
- On the role of courts: The decision underscores that courts must interpret recruitment rules and advertisements but must not themselves rewrite, amend or expand the eligibility qualifications set by the rule-making authority or the Employer; equivalence determinations are generally within the province of the competent rule-making or expert bodies unless statutory language or applicable precedent dictates otherwise.
- On precedent-setting: The Court distinguished and applied prior authorities according to the factual and textual differences; it did not create a novel rule expanding eligibility beyond what the Rules and Advertisement prescribed. No finding was made on the separate question of "minimum qualification" generally, as that issue was not the subject of determination in this case.
Note: Sections and summaries above are drawn exclusively from the provided opinion text. Where the opinion did not supply further factual detail (for example, the precise facts relating to the other candidate mentioned in the petitioners' supplementary affidavit), this summary does not speculate and reflects only the material contained in the opinion.
1. For the post of Range Officer Grade-I the prescribed qualification in terms of Jammu and Kashmir Forest Service (Gazetted) Recruitment Rules of 1970 (for short Rules of 1970) as amended by SRO 3 dated 05.01.1994 is B.Sc. (Forestry) or its equivalent from any University recognized by Indian Council of Agriculture and Research. 2. Class V of the Schedule appended to the Rule of 1970 provides the qualification and mode of recruitment to the post of Range Officer which is reproduced as under: Class V Category C Grade 825-1240 (pre-revised) Designation Range Officer Qualification for direct recruitment B. Sc Forestry or its equivalent from any University recognized by the Indian council of Agricultural Research. Method of recruitment (1) 30% by direct recruitment from amongst the persons having passed Rangers qualifying examination (written and viva voce) to be held by the J&K Public Service Commission. 3. This is the qualification which has been notified in the Advertisement Notice whereunder applications were called from eligible candidates for seeking consideration for being selected and appointed on the post of Range Officer Grade-I (Forest). Admittedly, the petitioners are possessed of qualification of graduation with Forestry as one of the subjects and are also possessed of qualification of M.Sc. (Forestry). The petitioners responded to the notification issued by J&K Public Service Commission and for the reason that the petitioners were not possessed of B. Sc. (Forestry) qualification were excluded from selection process which constrained them to file the writ petition wherein they sought quashment of the Notification dated 08.09.2010 and prayed for issuance of direction to the respondents to permit them to participate in the selection process on the basis of their qualification, viz., B. Sc. Degree with (Forestry) as one of the subjects and M. Sc (Forestry) Degree. 4. The Court on 24.11.2010 directed the respondents-Public Service Commission to permit the petitioners to take the examination at their own risk and responsibility. The respondents-Public Service Commission filed reply affidavit/objections. Initially, petitioner no. 1 filed supplementary affidavit and at later point of time petitioner no. 3 filed supplementary affidavit and at later point of time petitioner no. 3 filed supplementary affidavit. During the pendency of the writ petition, the Court directed the respondents-Public Service Commission to produce the result of the petitioners before the Court. Petitioner no. 3 was found to have qualified for interview. Petitioner no. 3 was ordered to be subjected to interview for assessing his merit and suitability. The Court, however, qualified the order by providing that by directing the respondents-Public Service Commission to call petitioner no. 3 for interview would not confer any special status on him and final result will depend upon the determination of the issue of eligibility. 5. Mr. C. M. Koul, learned counsel for the petitioner(s) submitted that the petitioner(s) is not only possessed of academic qualification of B. Sc. with (Forestry) as one of the subjects but is also possessed of degree of M. Sc. in (Forestry) and as such, is eligible in terms of the Rules and the Advertisement No tice. Learned counsel further submitted that the petitioner(s) being possessed of the higher qualification than the prescribed qualification, in fairness and in equity, he cannot be declared to be ineligible, thus, depriving him to seek consideration for being selected and appointed on the post of Range Officer Grade-I as such act would mean violating the Constitutional Guarantee available to him under Article 16 of the Constitution of India. Learned counsel, while referring to his supplementary affidavit, submitted that in identical circumstances, another candidate was not only recommended by the Public Service Commission but was appointed by the competent authority on the post of Range Officer Grade-I. Learned counsel submitted that the petitioner(s) cannot be subjected to discrimination by not giving him same treatment which has been given to other similarly circumstanced persons. Learned counsel, in support of his contentions, referred to and relied upon the judgments of this Court in cases S. Gurmeet Singh & ors. v. State and others reported in 2008 (1) JKJ 68 HC, Mehmooda Bano & ors. v. State of J&K & ors. (SWP No. 112/2012 Decided on 19.09.2012), Mohd. Riazul Usman Gani and others v. District and Sessions Judge, Nagpur and others reported in AIR 2000 SC 919, Satpal Sharma v. State of J&K & ors 2008 (1) JKJ 77 (HC) and Surinder Singh Jamwal and another v. State of J&K & ors, 2010 (2) JKJ 527 (HC). 6. Mr. D. C. Raina, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondents-Public Service Commission, submitted that the petitioner(s) is ineligible in view of the qualification prescribed by the Rules of 1970 and the Advertisement Notice. Learned counsel further submitted that the petitioners were permitted to participate in the selection process in pursuance to the interim orders passed by the Court. Learned counsel also submitted that equivalence of qualifications cannot be determined by the Court and it falls within the domain of the expert bodies to return a finding to the equivalence of academic/technical degrees. Learned counsel, in support of his contentions, referred to the cases titled P.M. Latha and another v. State of Kerala and others, 2003(3) SCC 541, K. Manjusree v. State of Andhra Pradesh 2008 (3) SCC 512, Sheikh Muzaffar Rashid v. High Court of J&K & ors. 2010 (1) SLJ 308:2010 (1) JKJ HC-148, Bashir Ahmad Mantoo v. State of J&K 2009 (2) JKJ HC-86 : 2011 (1) SLJ 196 and submitted that the petition deserves to be dismissed. 7. In order to settle the controversy raised in this petition it becomes necessary to look at the functions and duties to be discharged by the three principal organs of the State created by the Constitution. The Division Bench of this Court in case titled Ab. Qayoom v. M. A. Chesti and ors. reported in 2009 (Suppl.) JKJ 222 (HC) has explained the functions of three organs of the State in the following manner: "16. The people of this country have given to themselves the Constitution, which Constitution in its legal and philosophical scheme has clearly and specifically delineated the frontiers of three important organs of the State viz, executive, legislature and judiciary. Every organ of the State is charged with definite duty by and under the Constitution, and every organ is duty bound to obediently and faithfully follow the mandate of the Constitution to secure the purpose and goals underlying Constitution. 17. The judiciary in the three organs of the State with the advancement of time has assumed perceptible importance in the affairs of State. This organ of the State is charged with sacred duty to preserve and protect the basic structure and basic features of the Constitution. The institution of judiciary is performing delicate duty of doing the balancing act between different organs of the State. Our constitution on the one side is loaded with fundamental rights available to an individual and on the other side is founded on the bed-rock of achieving the goals of maintaining and preserving the rule of law. The arbitrary, mala fide and unjust exercise of power by Executive organ of the State is frowned upon by constitutional courts and such actions are struck down in exercise of its Constitutional powers. Our Constitution has made our country sovereign, democratic and republic State and any assault by any authority to undermine the basic features of the Constitution are to be repelled with full vigor and complete force. 18. The three organs of the State, being principal pillars of our democratic set up have to respect each other by working within defined boundaries. Any effort to transcend the Constitutional barriers will have the affect of destroying the basic structure of the Constitution and the mutual collision may result in subverting the very Constitution itself. The three organs of the state are thus, duty bound to exhibit extreme caution, care and restrain in the exercise of their power and authority. The three organs of the State in our constitutional scheme cannot afford to tread the path of collision as consequences thereof can be catastrophic. The executive is duty bound to follow the directions, orders and judgments of the court of law. Any streak of Executive authority's defiance may usher the state into an an archical situation." (emphasis supplied) 8. The Division Bench of this Court in case Farooq Ahmad Ncngroo v. State of J&K and others 2012 (3) JKJ HC-382 (LPA no. 125/2012 Decided on 23.08.2012) has stated as under: "In our constitutional scheme not only jurisdiction but functions of three organs of the State, viz., executive, legislature and judiciary are delineated. Every organ of the State has to maintain diehard discipline in its functioning to ensure that it does not transgress its limits and usurp the powers and functions of one or other organ of the State. These organs of the State are like the creature of nature viz stars/planets, and have to strictly tread the path which has been delineated for them. Any deviation from natural course would result in collision of these organs of the nature and the consequences would be catastrophic. Likewise in democratic state like ours in which functioning of different organs of the State is regulated by the Constitution, any effort to breach the frontiers of other organs of the State would definitely have catastrophic effect on the body politic. The duty of the courts of law is to ensure that the other organs of the State function in accordance with the mandate contained in the Constitution and other laws. Further duty of the courts is to interpret the laws made by legislature as also the subordinate legislations. Under the guise of the interpreting laws, the courts cannot, however, assume unto themselves the functions of the legislature and start writing Statutes/laws, which certainly, is the function of the legislature. The function of Constitutional Courts is to interpret laws and in the first place construe them in a. manner which would save them from rigour of provision of constitution." (emphasis supplied) 9. Likewise, a Division Bench of this Court in case Yash Bhashin v. State and others 2012 (3) JKJ HC-685 (WPPIL no. 20/2011 Decided on 10.09.2012) has reiterated the aforementioned view of the Court as under: "We the people of India" have given to ourselves the Constituent, from the bosom of which are born three principal organs of the State viz., Legislature, Executive and Judiciary. In view of the mandate contained in the Constitution, all the three organs of the State have to function within the frontiers delineated by the Constitution itself. The legislature has to legislate the laws and the executive, which is answerable to the legislature, has to implement the said laws. Amongst others, the principal and fundamental functions of the Courts are to interpret the laws and resolve the disputes between the litigating parties, which disputes are brought before them." 10. To be clear on facts, it requires to be reiterated that the qualification prescribed by the Rules of 1970 as also by the Advertisement Notice for the post of Range Officer Grade-I (Forest) is B.Sc. (Forestry) or equivalent from any University recognized by the Indian Council of Agricultural Research. This is the qualification prescribed by the Statutory Rules and Advertisement Notice for the post of Range Officer Grade-I. 11. Enacting laws and Rule making falls within the province of the Legislative wing of the State. The employer, after taking into consideration all the aspects of a particular post provide for the qualification which a candidate must possess for seeking consideration for being selected and appointed on the particular post. The fixing of eligibility qualification which includes academic/technical qualification, certainly fall within the domain of the employer. The Constitutional Courts have powers to test the action of the State and authorities on the touch stone of law. One of the important jobs of the Constitutional Courts is to interpret the laws which include the Rules made by the competent authority. However, under the guise of interpretation of laws, the Courts cannot step into the shoes of the Legislature/Executive and substitute its own views by replacing the view of the other organs of the State and legislate law. The Courts can, however, declare the law to be unconstitutional and unenforceable. The Courts can fill the gaps occurring "between the law as it is and the laws that may be." The Courts can also bridge the gaps to make a law meaningful and purposeful. The courts, however, definitely cannot themselves provide for eligibility qualification for making a candidate eligible for a particular post that being domain of Rule making authority and not that of courts. 12. It is in the aforementioned backdrop the issue raised in this petition would require to be determined. 13. The petitioner(s) is possessed of B. Sc. Degree with (Forestry) as one of the subjects and is also possessed of M.Sc. Degree in (Forestry). These degrees, admittedly, are not the qualifications prescribed by the Rules of 1970 and the Advertisement Notice. The B. Sc. (Forestry) in itself is a complete course. Had the B.Sc. with (Forestry) as one subject been equivalent to that of B. Sc (Forestry) then the Rule making authority in its wisdom would have definitely provided 'B.Sc. with (Forestry) as one subject' also as eligibility qualification for the post of Range Officer Grade-I. Being possessed of B. Sc. with (Forestry) as one of the subjects, it cannot be said that the petitioner(s) is possessed of the degree of B.Sc. (Forestry). The petitioner(s) thus is not possessed of the eligibility qualification as prescribed by the Rules of 1970 and the Advertisement Notice for the post of Range Officer Grade-I. 14. It would next require to be ascertained as to whether the petitioner(s) can still be declared to be eligible candidate as he is possessed of M. Sc. degree in (Forestry). In most of the cases, a candidate who is possessed of superior/higher degree in a particular discipline may enable the Court to stretch its wings of interpretation by presuming that the candidate is possessed of the inferior degree as well. This type of presumption, however, cannot be of universal application. In present times, there are number of courses in which a candidate may possess superior/higher qualification without having attained the inferior qualification in the same discipline. Take the example of the case of petitioner(s). The B.Sc. degree with one subject as Forestry makes him eligible for attaining the superior/higher degree of M.Sc. in Forestry notwithstanding the fact that he is not possessed of the degree of B.Sc. (Forestry). In his case, thus, there is no scope of presuming that he is possessed of lower degree of B. Sc. (Forestry). So it is to be presumed that he is not possessed of degree of B. Sc. (Forestry), a full-fledged course in the discipline of (Forestry). 15. In the aforementioned backdrop, the petitioner(s) though possessed of superior/higher degree of M. Sc. (Forestry), in contradistinction, thereto is not possessed of inferior degree of B. Sc. (Forestry) but is having B. Sc. degree with (Forestry) as one of the subjects. The petitioner(s) in the facts of this case though is possessed of superior/higher degree with M. Sc. (Forestry), is definitely not possessed of the prescribed eligibility qualification of B.Sc. (Forestry). The petitioner(s) thus is ineligible for seeking consideration for being selected and appointed as Range Officer Grade-I. 16. In Mohd. Riazul Usman Gani's case (supra), for the post of Peon educational qualification was prescribed as not lower than a pass in the Examination of Standard IV in the Regional Language." In making the selection, the Advisory Committee constituted under the Recruitment Rules had laid four criteria for shortlisting of the candidates. One of the criteria laid was that 'applications of those candidates possessing minimum educational qualification of passing IVth Vernacular standard and/or educated upto passing of VIIth Standard only should be considered for the interview to the posts of peons and those who have studied above VIIth vernacular standard may not take proper interest in the work of peons and, therefore, should not be called for interview. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in view of the Rule position held that this criteria was illegal as the Rules had provided educational qualification for peons as "not lower than a pass in the Examination of Standard IV in the Regional Language," which, otherwise, would mean that all candidates who were possessed of Standard IV educational qualification or above would be eligible. The expression 'not lower' would mean that pass in the Examination of Standard IV in the Regional Language was the minimum educational qualification prescribed. The candidates who were possessed of educational qualification above Standard IV were also eligible for seeking consideration for being selected and appointed on the post of Peons. 17. This judgment on facts is not applicable to the case on hand inasmuch as in view of the Rules of 1970 and the eligibility clause of the Advertisement Notice, B. Sc. (Forestry) is not the minimum qualification prescribed but the 'only' eligibility qualification prescribed by the Rules and Advertisement Notice. The petitioner(s) thus cannot derive benefit from Mohd. Riazul Usman Gani's case. 18. In Gurmeet Singh and others case, at paragraph 10 of the judgment, the qualification prescribed was Diploma in Automobile Engineering which was on the basis of Recruitment Rules held to be minimum qualification for the post of Motor Vehicles Inspector and the candidates who were possessed of Degree in Automobile Engineering/Mechanical Engineering were held to be eligible for the reason that the Diploma in Automobile Engineering/Mechanical Engineering was not the 'only' qualification but was the minimum qualification. It was provided that once minimum qualification is prescribed for filling up of the post any candidates in the same discipline possessed of superior/higher qualification would also be eligible for seeking consideration for being selected and appointed on the post. The selection authority had provided marks for the higher qualification also which further goes to show that though minimum qualification of Diploma was prescribed and candidates having higher qualifications were also eligible as additional marks were eanviarked for higher qualifications. 19. This case also on facts is distinguishable from the case on hand. In this case, this Court relied upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in case titled Jyoti K.K. and others v. Kerala Public Service Commission and others, reported in JT 2002 (Suppl. KD 85 HC. The judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Jyoti K.K. has turned on the interpretation of Rule 10(1)(II) of the Kerala Rules which provided as under: "Notwithstanding anything contained in these rules or in the special rules, the qualifications recognized by executive orders or standing orders of government as equivalent to a qualification specified for a post in the special rules and such of those higher qualifications which presuppose the acquisition of the lower qualification prescribed for the post shall also be sufficient for the post" 20. The case on facts is distinguishable from the case on hand on twin grounds viz., (a) there is no similar Rule as that of Rule 10(a)(II) and (b) B.Sc. (Forestry) is a complete course in itself whereas petitioner(s) has obtained degree of graduation with Forestry as one of the subjects which acquisition of the qualification made him eligible to seek admission in M.Sc. (Forestry). In the facts of this case, it cannot be, thus, presupposed that by holding the Degree of M.Sc. (Forestry) the petitioner(s) is possessed of the degree of B.Sc. (Forestry) as well. 21. Surinder Singh Jamwal's case, on facts, is not similar to the case on hand. In that case, the petitioner sought relief of equal pay for equal work. 22. Similarly, Satpal Sharma's case is not applicable to the facts of the present case as in that case it was ruled that a selected candidate has a right to be considered only for the post for which he had applied and not for another post. 23. In Mehmooda Bano and others case, post of Junior Grade Nurse was advertised. Internal page 6 of the judgment would show that the minimum qualification prescribed was 10+2 or above qualification with Diploma in Nursing from recognized Institution for direct recruitment. Challenge was thrown to the selection of some of the candidates who were possessed of the qualification of B. Sc. Nursing. The writ petition aforementioned was filed challenging the said selection on the ground that the qualification prescribed was 10+2 or above with Diploma in Nursing from recognized Institution for direct recruitment. The Court, while relying on Ajay Kumar Uttam's case ruled against the petitioners and dismissed the writ petition. In Ajay Kumar Uttam's case, which is reported in 2010(2) JKJ 757 (HC) the minimum qualification prescribed for the post of Drawing Instructor with three years Diploma/two years Draftsmanship in any Branch of Engineering. The Court, while relying on Jyoti K. K.'s case, rejected the contention of the writ petitioners that the selected candidates were not eligible as they were possessed of the qualification of Bachelor of Engineering which was not the prescribed qualification or equivalent to the prescribed qualification. In this case also it was the minimum qualification which was prescribed for the post of Drawing Instructor. The candidates who were possessed of the superior/higher qualification in the same discipline/branch in view of the expression 'minimum qualification' were held eligible for seeking consideration for being selected and appointed on the post of Drawing Instructor. In this case, the 'minimum qualification' and not the 'specific' qualification was prescribed. 24. This case also is distinguishable with the case on hand as the "only and specific" qualification prescribed is B. Sc. (Forestry). 25. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in P.M. Latha and another v. State of Kerala and others, (2003) 3 SCC 541 upheld the judgment of the High Court of Kerala to the extent it had ruled that the prescribed qualification for the post of lower primary/upper primary teachers in the Government schools of State of Kerala was Teachers Training Certificate and not B. Ed. qualification. The B. Ed. qualification was not treated as higher qualification than Teachers Training Certificate. It was also ruled that fixing of the eligibility qualification for a post belong to the recruitment policy of the State. The B. Ed. candidates were, thus, held to be not eligible. 26. The Rule making authority has prescribed "specific" qualification viz., B. Sc. (Forestry) for making recruitment to the post of Range Officer Grade-I. This is not the "minimum qualification" prescribed. This Court cannot rewrite the Recruitment Rules. If M. Sc. (Forestry) in the facts of this case is held to be one of the prescribed qualifications for the post of Range Officer Grade-I then it would tantamount to legislating the law which is not the function of the Court. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in case titled Ashok Kumar Sharma and others v. Chander Shekhar and another 2010 (5) JKJ SC-679: (1997) 4 SCC 18 at paragraph 6 has held that "an Advertisement or notification issued/published calling for applications constitutes a representation to the public and the authority issuing it is bound by such representation. It cannot act contrary to it." The selection/appointing authority is, thus, bound by the qualification prescribed under the Rules and the Advertisement Notice and would not be entitled to accept any other qualification, not prescribed by the Rules and Advertisement Notice as eligibility qualification. 27. The similar treatment sought is not acceptable in the facts of this case. The issue raised was not determined by court and facts are not disclosed as to how and for what reasons the person mentioned in supplementary affidavit was appointed. 28. The issue is required to be considered from yet another angle as well. The candidates who are possessed of M. Sc. (Forestry) degree and who on the terms and conditions of the advertisement notice did not respond to it would be subjected to discrimination if the petitioner(s) claim is upheld. It will be inequitable and unfair as well. 29. The petitioners' claim is required to be rejected on yet another ground, viz., they being ineligible on the terms and conditions of the Rules of 1970 and the Advertisement Notice constitute a different and distinct class than those candidates who in terms of Rules of 1970 and on the terms and conditions of Advertisement Notice are eligible. The Court cannot direct the selection authority to give uniform treatment to persons who are not similarly circumstanced. The right of the eligible candidates who form one class in themselves would be seriously jeopardized. 30. The question of "minimum qualification" as prescribed qualification being not issue involved in this case, no finding can be recorded thereon in this case. 31. For the abovestated reasons, this petition is held to be meritless and is, as such, dismissed _____________
Alert