Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Raghunath Pradhani v. Damodra Mahapatra And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Nov 2, 1978
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Respondent 1 obtained a money decree on 18 August 1962 against Respondent 3 and Respondent 4 (his mother). On 28 June 1963 Respondent 1 commenced execution proceedings and secured an order on 13 July 1963 attaching immovable property belonging to Respondent 3. Because Respondent 3 was a member of a Scheduled Tribe, clause 6 of the Orissa Scheduled Areas Transfer of Immovable Property by Scheduled Tribes Regulation 2 of 1956 and Rule 4 made thereunder required written permission of the competent authority (the Revenue Divisional Officer, Nowrangpur) before any attachment or sale.

While execution was pending, Respondent 3 sought and on 23 October 1963 obtained the RDO’s written permission to sell the property privately for Rs 4,000 to a non-tribal. Acting on that permission, he executed a registered sale deed in favour of the appellant on 2 January 1964.

Nevertheless, Respondent 1 produced a copy of the RDO’s order in the executing court and on 15 May 1964 the property was sold in court auction, where Respondent 2 (son of Respondent 1) purchased it.

On 22 June 1964 the appellant moved the executing court under Order 21 Rules 89 and 90 and Sections 47 and 151 CPC to set aside the auction sale, alleging that both the attachment and the auction sale were void for want of statutory permission and that Respondent 1 had misled the court.

The District Munsif set aside the auction sale; the Subordinate Judge (hearing Civil Misc. Appeal 9 of 1965) affirmed that order. Respondent 1’s second appeal (Misc. Appeal 208 of 1966) before the Orissa High Court succeeded on the ground of constructive res judicata, though the High Court rejected the contention that Respondent 3 was not a Scheduled Tribe member. The present appeal by the private purchaser (appellant) arises from that High Court judgment dated 12 September 1968.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the attachment and subsequent court auction of immovable property belonging to a Scheduled Tribe member are void when effected without prior written permission of the competent authority under Regulation 2 of 1956 and Rule 4 framed thereunder.
  2. Whether the doctrine of constructive res judicata bars the appellant (claiming through the judgment-debtor) from challenging the validity of the auction sale on grounds that were not raised earlier in the execution proceedings.
  3. Whether the auction purchaser (Respondent 2) acquired any valid title in light of the prior private sale to the appellant effected pursuant to the competent authority’s permission.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The attachment and auction sale were void ab initio because they were conducted without obtaining the requisite permission from the RDO as mandated by clause 6 and Rule 4.
  • The decree-holder (Respondent 1) committed fraud on the court by using the RDO’s permission, which had been granted specifically for a private sale to the appellant, to justify a forced sale.
  • Because title had already vested in the appellant through the registered sale deed dated 2 January 1964, the judgment-debtor had no remaining saleable interest capable of being sold in auction.

Respondent 2’s Arguments

  • He was a bona fide purchaser in a court sale conducted after the competent authority had granted permission; hence his title should be protected.

Respondent 1’s Arguments in the High Court

  • Respondent 3 was not a member of a Scheduled Tribe; therefore statutory permission was unnecessary and the attachment and sale were valid.
  • Even if he were a Scheduled Tribe member, any challenge to the attachment should have been raised earlier; the failure to do so barred subsequent objections under constructive res judicata.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. Scheduled Tribe status of Respondent 3. The Court upheld the finding that Respondent 3 was a Scheduled Tribe member. Respondent 1 himself had sought the competent authority’s permission on that premise and could not later contest it. Questions about whether the “Bhotra” community was covered by the Constitution (Scheduled Tribes) Order, 1950 could not be entertained for the first time in second appeal or before the Supreme Court.

2. Invalidity of attachment. Clause 6 of Regulation 2 of 1956 and Rule 4 categorically prohibit attachment or sale of immovable property of a Scheduled Tribe member without prior written permission. The attachment ordered on 13 July 1963 preceded any such permission and was therefore void.

3. Effect of prior private sale. The RDO’s permission dated 23 October 1963 allowed sale of the property for Rs 4,000. Relying on that permission, Respondent 3 sold the property to the appellant on 2 January 1964, transferring full title. Consequently, when the auction took place on 15 May 1964 the judgment-debtor had no subsisting right, title or interest; a court sale can convey only what the judgment-debtor owns, so the auction purchaser acquired nothing.

4. Breach of permission conditions in auction sale. The condition attached by the RDO that the property be sold for Rs 4,000 was violated: the decree amount was about Rs 1,000 and the highest auction bid was Rs 3,000. This independent breach rendered the auction sale invalid.

5. Res judicata not applicable. The basic issue was the validity of the auction sale. Neither the judgment-debtor nor the decree-holder had ever disputed Scheduled Tribe status during execution; both acknowledged the need for permission. Their failure to raise additional objections could not bar the appellant from asserting his superior title.

Holding and Implications

Appeal ALLOWED. The Supreme Court set aside the Orissa High Court’s judgment and restored the order of the Subordinate Judge (Koraput) which had annulled the court auction sale in favour of Respondent 2. No order as to costs.

Implications: The decision reinstates the appellant’s title and confirms that any attachment or sale of immovable property belonging to a Scheduled Tribe member without prior written permission of the competent authority is void. The judgment affects only the parties to the case and does not articulate broader precedent beyond strict enforcement of Regulation 2 of 1956 and its rules.

Show all summary ...

Y.V Chandrachud, C.J— Respondent 1 obtained a money decree on August 18, 1962 against Respondent 3 and his mother Respondent 4. On June 28, 1963 Respondent 1 filed an execution petition for recovering the decretal amount and prayed therein for attachment of the immovable property belonging to Respondent 3. The property was attached by an order passed by the executing court on July 13, 1963. On November 27, 1963 Respondent 1 filed an application in the Executing Court praying that permission be obtained of the Revenue Divisional Officer for sale of the property since Respondent 3 to whom the property belonged was a member of the Scheduled Tribe. The permission was considered necessary by reason of the provisions contained in clause 6 of the “Orissa Scheduled Areas Transfer of Immovable Property by Scheduled Tribes Regulation 2 of 1956”. It provides:

“In execution of money decree against a member of a Scheduled Tribe no right, title or interest held by him in any immovable property within any scheduled area shall be liable to be attached and sold except as and if prescribed.”
Rule 4 made under the aforesaid regulation provides:
“There shall be no attachment or sale of immovable property in execution of a money decree against a member of a Scheduled Tribe within any scheduled area without the written permission of the competent authority. The property at such a sale shall be sold only to a member of a Scheduled Tribe unless otherwise specifically directed in writing by the competent authority.”
The Revenue Divisional Officer, Nowrangpur, was the competent authority for the present purpose.

2. Respondent 3 who was in the meantime negotiating for the private sale of the property moved the RDO, Nowrangpur on June 18, 1963 for permission to sell the property to a non-Scheduled Tribe person. He obtained the requisite permission by an order dated October 23, 1963 for the sale of the property for Rs 4000. On the strength of the aforesaid permission Respondent 3 sold the property to the appellant on January 2, 1964 by a registered deed of sale.

3. A copy of the order passed by the RDO was produced by Respondent 1 in the executing court whereupon, on May 15, 1964 the property was put to sale. Respondent 2, who is the son of Respondent 1 purchased the property in the auction sale.

4. On June 22, 1964 the appellant filed an application under Order 21 Rules 89 and 90 and Sections 47 and 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure praying that the auction sale should be set aside on the ground that the attachment and the auction sale were void since they were effected without obtaining the permission of the competent authority under Orissa Regulation 2 of 1956. The appellant also alleged that the decree-holder had played a fraud on the court by inducing it to put the property to sale on the strength of the order dated October 23, 1963, which was passed by the competent authority at the instance of the appellant.

5. Respondent 2 resisted the appellant's application on the ground that he was a bona fide purchaser in a court sale, that the aforesaid sale was held after the competent authority had granted permission for the sale of the property and that therefore his title to the property was not liable to be displaced at the instance of the appellant.

6. The learned District Munsif who dealt with the matter accepted the contention of the appellant and set aside the auction sale. In Civil Miscellaneous Appeal 9 of 1965 filed by Respondent 1, the Appellate Judge confirmed the order of the District Munsif and dismissed the appeal.

7. Respondent 1 then filed a second appeal in the Orissa High Court, being Miscellaneous Appeal 208 of 1966. Before the High Court Respondent 1 raised two contentions only viz., (1) that the judgment-debtor, Respondent 2, was not a member of the Scheduled Tribe and therefore the attachment and the court sale were not void; and (2) that the judgment-debtors, having failed to take objection to the attachment on the ground that they belonged to a Scheduled Tribe, Were debarred from objecting to the sale of the property on the principle of constructive res judicata.

8. The High Court rejected the first contention relying mainly on the circumstance that Respondent 1, the decree-holder, had accepted the position that Respondent 3 whose property was being put to sale was a member of the Scheduled Tribe. The High Court however accepted the second contention on the ground that neither Respondent 3 nor the appellant had taken any objection in the execution proceedings that since the former had no saleable interest in the property the auction sale could not be held or that the permission given by the RDO did not authorise the sale. Being aggrieved by the judgment of the High Court dated September 12, 1968, the private purchaser from the decree-holder has filed this appeal.

9. We are in agreement with the view of the High Court that it is not open to Respondent 1, the decree-holder, to contend that Respondent 3 whose property was put to sale in the execution proceedings was not a member of the Scheduled Tribe. Respondent 1 filed his execution petition for the purpose of recovering the decretal dues by attachment and sale of the property belonging to one of the judgment-debtors, Respondent 3. Respondent 1 himself asked the executing court to secure the permission of the competent authority for sale of the property on the ground that Respondent 3 whose property was to be put to sale belonged to the Scheduled Tribe. The permission from the competent authority was later obtained by the appellant, with whom Respondent 3 was negotiating for a private sale of his property. The permission which was granted by the RDO, Nowrangpur at the instance of the appellant was produced by Respondent 1 in the execution proceedings as if the permission was granted in his favour for the sale by Respondent 3 of his property. Respondent 1 cannot then be permitted to dispute that Respondent 3 did not belong to a Scheduled Tribe and therefore the permission of the competent authority was not needed to validate the sale.

10. The contention that Respondent 3 did not belong to a Scheduled Tribe was founded solely on the consideration that he belonged to the Bhotra tribe which is not expressly mentioned as one of the Scheduled Tribes in the Schedule to the Constitution (Scheduled Tribes), Order, 1950. It may be assumed that Respondent 3 is a Bhotra. But para 2 of the Scheduled Tribes Order, 1950 provides to the extent material that the Tribes, or parts of, or groups within the Tribes specified in the Schedule to the order shall also be deemed to be Scheduled Tribes. Whether Bhotras fall within any of the subgroups of the Scheduled Tribes enumerated in Part 9 of the Schedule to the 1950 Order is a question which could not have been permitted to be raised for the first time in the second appeal. Much less can it be allowed to be raised before us. This appeal, like the second appeal before the High Court, must therefore be disposed of on the basis that Respondent 3 is a member of the Scheduled Tribe.

11. Upon that footing, the appellant must succeed because after the RDO, Nowrangpur granted permission to sell the property on October 23, 1963, the property was purchased by the appellant from Respondent 3 on January 2, 1964. Prior to that sale the property was undoubtedly attached in execution proceedings on July 13, 1963 but the order of attachment was void, being contrary to the express inhibition contained in clause 6 of Regulation 2 of 1956 read with Rule 4 made thereunder. Both clause 6 and Rule 4 provide that no immovable property belonging to a member of the Scheduled Tribe is liable to be attached or sold except in accordance with the permission granted by the competent authority. Under the registered sale, Ex. 4, executed by Respondent 3 in favour of the appellant, the title to the property vested in the appellant. The appellant having become an owner of the property on account of the aforesaid private sale, Respondent 3 had no saleable interest left in the property which could be put to sale in the court auction. It is elementary that what can be brought to sale in a court sale is the right, title and interest of the judgment-debtor and therefore, the auction purchaser can get nothing more than that right, title and interest. The judgment-debtor not having any saleable interest in the property at all on the date of the auction sale, there was nothing that Respondent 2 could get in the auction sale which was held in execution of the money decree obtained by his father, Respondent 1. The auction sale therefore cannot displace the title of the appellant which is the same thing as saying that as between the title of the appellant and the so-called title of the auction purchaser, the appellant's title must prevail. It must follow that the auction sale is bad and must be set aside.

12. There is an additional reason why the auction sale is not valid. By the permission granted by the RDO, Nowrangpur on October 23, 1963 for sale of the property, one of the conditions imposed on the judgment-debtor was that the property shall be sold for a sum of Rs 4000. In the private sale, the appellant purchased the property for Rs 4000 and therefore the condition of the permission was complied with. But the auction sale was held in satisfaction of the decretal dues which were far less than Rs 4000, the decree itself being in the sum of Rs 1000 odd and the highest bid at the auction being of Rs 3000 only. As the condition imposed by the RDO regarding the price was violated by the auction sale, the auction purchaser cannot get a valid title to the property under that sale.

13. In this view, no question of res judicata can arise because the basic issue in the appeal is as regards the validity of the auction sale in favour of Respondent 2. The appellant claims through the judgment-debtor and neither the latter nor the decree-holder ever disputed that he, the judgment-debtor, was a member of the Scheduled Tribe. On the other hand both of them were conscious of the situation that the property could not be sold without the sanction of the RDO, Nowrangpur. The decree-holder himself apprised the executing Court of that position. The failure, therefore, of the judgment-debtor to raise any particular contention cannot operate as res judicata, actually or constructively, either against him or against the appellant.

14. For these reasons we allow the appeal, set aside the judgment of the High Court and confirm that of the learned Subordinate Judge, Koraput, setting aside the court sale in favour of Respondent 2. There will be no order as to costs.