Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Gopi Nath Kaul v. State Of Jammu And Kashmir And Another

Jammu and Kashmir High Court
Dec 20, 1956
Smart Summary (Beta)

Case Summary — Opinion by Shahmiri, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, a teacher in the State Education Department (drawing Rs. 176/- in the grade of 80-8-200), filed a writ petition under article 32(2-A) of the Constitution of India read with the Constitution (Application to Jammu and Kashmir) Order, 1954 seeking a writ of mandamus or other appropriate relief. He alleged that although his position in the general seniority list of teachers was No. 7, about twenty juniors were promoted to the Gazetted cadre of Head Masters (scale 200-15-350), and at least ten of those promoted had not crossed the efficiency bar at Rs. 120/- in the scale of 80-8-200. The petitioner claimed these promotions were made on communal and provincial grounds and that he was thereby discriminated against and denied equality before the law and equal protection of the laws and equal opportunity in promotions.

The respondents (State of Jammu and Kashmir and the Director of Education) denied discrimination but admitted that the petitioner had been passed over in recent years while juniors were promoted; they asserted this resulted from considerations of merit, ability and administrative capacity rather than any invidious distinction. The court deferred decision pending the disposal of two similar Full Bench cases (Mohd. Aslam Bach v. V.L. Vishin and Dr. Shanker Nath Ganju v. State of Jammu and Kashmir) which have since been disposed of.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondents violated any statutory rules (including the Kashmir Civil Service Rules and relevant recruitment rules) in promoting the petitioner's juniors to the Gazetted cadre.
  2. Whether the promotions constituted discrimination amounting to denial of equality before the law and equal protection of the laws, including claims of communal or provincial bias.
  3. Whether promotions of persons who had not crossed the efficiency bar (per Cabinet Order No. 1234-C of 1952) were lawful, in light of a subsequent Cabinet Order No. 379-C of 1953 purportedly permitting relaxation by the Minister in charge of Education.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner contended that despite being No. 7 in the seniority list he was passed over while many juniors were promoted to the Gazetted cadre of Head Masters (scale 200-15-350).
  • He alleged the promotions were made on communal and provincial grounds, resulting in discrimination and denial of equality before the law and equal protection.
  • He argued that several promoted juniors had not crossed the efficiency bar at Rs. 120/- in scale 80-8-200, in violation of Cabinet Order No. 1234-C of 1952 (15 November 1952), which stated no person shall be promoted to the higher grade unless he has crossed the efficiency bar in the existing grade.
  • The petitioner maintained his merit and ability were superior to those juniors who had not crossed the efficiency bar and yet were promoted over him.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents denied any communal or provincial discrimination and asserted the petitioner had been passed over because he was not found suitable for promotion on grounds of merit, ability and administrative capacity.
  • They placed three affidavits on record: (a) an affidavit (7 June 1955) stating the Directors of Education were not satisfied with the petitioner's merit and ability and that selections adhered to merit principles; (b) an affidavit (23 August 1955) reiterating the absence of discrimination and unsuitability of the petitioner for Head Master posts; and (c) an affidavit (28 March 1956) stating that in the test/examination and interview held at Srinagar in October 1955 the petitioner secured the 23rd position in order of merit among 35 candidates, and describing the composition of the selection Board.
  • They further contended that Cabinet Order No. 1234-C of 1952 had been modified by Cabinet Order No. 379-C of 1953 (4 April 1953), which vested power to relax the efficiency-bar restriction in the Minister in charge of the Education Department; promotions of persons who had not crossed the efficiency bar therefore resulted from permissible relaxation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mohd. Aslam Bach v. V.L. Vishin, (S) AIR 1957 J & K 8 (A) Affirmation that the appointing authority is the judge of merit and ability; absence of reasons in promotion orders does not necessarily invalidate those orders. The court relied on this Full Bench decision to conclude it could not substitute its judgment for that of the appointing authority and that the mere absence of reasons in promotion orders did not invalidate the respondents' actions.
Dr. Shanker Nath Ganju v. State of Jammu and Kashmir, (S) AIR 1957 J & K 29 (FB) Same principle as above: appointing authority's judgment on merit and ability is primary. The court referenced this Full Bench authority alongside Mohd. Aslam Bach to support the view that selections resting on the appointing authority's assessment of merit cannot be displaced by the court on the facts before it.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded to examine whether statutory rules were violated. It identified and cited Rule 25(a)(1) of the Kashmir Civil Service Rules (General), which mandates that promotions shall be made on grounds of merit and ability (seniority to be considered only where merit and ability are approximately equal). The recruitment rules for category 3 of Class III of the Kashmir Educational Service (Assistant Inspectors of Schools including Head Masters) were noted, including minimum qualifications for direct appointment and transfer, and a rule (page 11) that recruitment by transfer shall be based on merit, ability and previous record, with seniority only in case of equality.

The petitioner had not challenged any specific government order. The court observed that, while it would have been desirable for the appointing authority to assign reasons in the orders by which the petitioner was superseded, the absence of reasons did not in itself invalidate those orders. The court relied on the Full Bench authorities (Mohd. Aslam Bach and Dr. Shanker Nath Ganju) for the principle that the appointing authority is the judge of merit and ability and that the court cannot substitute its judgment for that of the appointing authority.

The court reviewed the respondents' affidavits which stated the petitioner's lack of suitability for promotion, adherence to merit principles, and the results of the test/interview in October 1955 where the petitioner ranked 23rd among 35 candidates. On the issue of the efficiency bar, the court acknowledged the petitioner's contention based on Cabinet Order No. 1234-C of 1952 (which required crossing the efficiency bar before promotion). It then considered the respondents' position that Cabinet Order No. 379-C of 1953 vested the Minister with power to relax that restriction, and that such relaxation had been applied in the cases of certain promoted persons.

Balancing these points, the court recognized the hardship and sympathy due to the petitioner's situation but concluded that the mere relaxation of a Cabinet order (by the Minister under a subsequent Cabinet order) and the resulting disadvantage to the petitioner did not amount to a violation of the statutory rules relied upon by the petitioner nor did it establish a denial of equality or equal protection that the court could remedy. The petitioner failed to demonstrate that any particular order by which he was superseded was legally impugnable under the statutory provisions invoked.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The writ petition is DISMISSED.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The petitioner's challenge is rejected; the promotions already made by the respondents are not set aside by this court. The parties are ordered to bear their own costs.
  • The court emphasized that, although the petitioner’s case deserved special consideration by the Education Department and Government, no new legal precedent was created by this decision on the points of law raised; the court applied existing Full Bench authority and statutory rules to the facts before it.

Outcome recorded in the opinion: "Petition dismissed."

Show all summary ...

Shahmiri, J.:— This is a writ petition under article 32(2-A) of the Constitution of India read with the Constitution (Application to Jammu and Kashmir) Order, 1954 for the issue of a writ of mandamus or any other appropriate writ. The petitioner is a teacher in the State Education Department drawing Rs. 176/- in the grade of 80-8-200. He complains that, though his position in the general seniority list of teachers is at No. 7, as many as twenty juniors to the petitioner were appointed to the next higher cadre in the Gazetted Service of Head Masters in the scale of 200-15-350 and at least ten of these persons had not crossed the efficiency bar at Rs. 120/- in the scale of 80-8-200. He submits that the Education department made these promotions on communal and provincial grounds and that he had been discriminated against and denied equality before the law and the equal protection of the laws and equal opportunity in the matter of promotion.

2. He, therefore, prays that the respondents should be directed that the petitioner should be given the appropriate place he deserves according to his position in the seniority list as it existed on 14th May, 1954 in the Gazetted cadre in the scale of 200-15-350. In the objection filed on behalf of the respondents, namely, the State of Jammu and Kashmir and the Director of Education, it is denied that the petitioner was discriminated against on communal or provincial grounds. It is, however, admitted that during the last few years the petitioner was passed over and his juniors selected for promotion but it was added that it was not on account of any invidious distinction but on account of the fact that he was not found suitable for promotion on grounds of merit and ability including administrative capacity. We have heard lengthy arguments in this case. The decision of this case, however, was deferred as it was considered proper that two similar cases in which similar points were involved and which had been referred to the Full Bench, namely Mohd. Aslam Bach v. V.L Vishin ((S) AIR 1957 J and K 8 (A)) and Dr. Shanker Nath Ganju v. State of Jammu and Kashmir, (S) AIR 1957 J and K 29 (FB) (B) should be heard and decided first. These cases have now been disposed of.

3. The first question that falls for determination in this case is whether any statutory rules have been violated by the respondents. The relevant rules in this connection are as follows:

4. Rule 25(a)(1) of the Kashmir Civil Service Rules (General). It reads:

“25. Promotions, (a) All promotions shall be made by the appointing authority.

(1) Promotions to a service or class or to a selection category or grade in such service or class shall be made on grounds of merit and ability and shall be subject to the passing of any tests that Government may prescribe in this behalf, seniority being considered only where the merit and ability are approximately equal.”

5. Assistant Inspectors of Schools including Head Masters are grouped together as category 3 of Class III of Kashmir Educational Service (vide page 4 of Rules relating to Recruitment to the Gazetted Services Order No. 1328-C of 1939). Appointments to this category of Class III of Kashmir Educational Service can be either direct or by transfer. In the case of direct appointment the minimum qualification is “Degree of M.A with successful course of training in the theory and practice of Education of any recognized University”, and in the case of transfer the minimum requisite qualification is “University Degree with a Training Degree or Diploma and 3 years' experience in teaching work” (vide page 2 of the Rules referred to above).

6. In the same Rules another rule to which reference may be invited is rule (b) at page 11 which provides “Recruitment by transfer shall be made on the basis of merit, ability and the previous record of the Candidate, seniority being considered only in case of equality of merit, ability and excellence of record.”

7. The petitioner has not challenged any specific order of the Government. But it may be assumed that in all orders issued by the Government by which his juniors were promoted to category 3 of Class III of the Kashmir Educational Service and which thus affected him adversely no reason was assigned by the Government why the petitioner was passed over. As observed in the Full Bench case, Mohd's Aslam Bach v. V.L Vishin (A), it would have been, highly desirable that the appointing authority had given in these orders reasons why the petitioner was passed over but the mere absence of these reasons in the orders does not invalidate them. After all as decided in the Full Bench cases, Moh'd Aslam Bach v. V.L Vishin (A) and Dr. Shanker Nath Ganju v. State of Jammu and Kashmir (B), it is the appointing authority which is the judge of merit and ability and this court cannot substitute its judgment for that of the appointing authority. On behalf of the respondents three affidavits have been put in. In the first affidavit dated 7th June 1955 it was stated that the former as well as the present Director of Education were not satisfied with the merit and ability of the petitioner for promotion to the Gazetted cadre and that the principles of merit and ability including administrative capacity were always adhered to in the matter of selection for and appointment to the Gazetted cadre. It was further added that during the last few years the petitioner was passed over and his juniors selected for promotion not on account of any invidious distinction but on account of the fact that he was not found suitable for promotion inspite of the fact that his case was subjected to the same tests as those of others.

8. In the second affidavit dated 23rd August, 1955 it was reiterated that the petitioner was not discriminated against and that in the opinion of the appointing authority he was not found suitable for the post of the Head Master of a High School. In the third affidavit dated 28th March, 1956 it was stated that in the month of October, 1955 the petitioner along with 34 others, appeared in the test examination and in the interview held at Srinagar and secured 23rd position in order of merit and that the members of the Board of this Test Examination consisted of the Director of Education, Deputy Director of Education, Inspectors of Schools of Jammu and Kashmir provinces and the principals of Teachers Training College, S.P College and A.S College, Srinagar.

9. Under these circumstances it is not possible to hold that any statutory rule was violated by the respondents in the case of the petitioner. We, however, consider it necessary to emphasize that it would have been proper if the appointing authority had assigned these reasons in the different orders by which the petitioner was superseded. If these reasons had then been vouchsafed it would have not been necessary for the respondents to explain these supersessions by filing affidavits.

10. It has also been strenuously argued on behalf of the petitioner that the merit and ability of the petitioner was certainly superior to those of his juniors who had not crossed the efficiency bar at Rs. 120/- in the scale of 80-8-200 to which the petitioner also belonged. In support of this contention the petitioner has drawn our attention to the Cabinet Order No. 1234-C of 1952 dated 15th November, 1952 in which it has been stated that no person shall be promoted to the higher grade unless he has crossed the efficiency bar in the existing grade.

11. It is urged that in so far as the persons who had not crossed the efficiency bar had been promoted to the higher grade in the Gazetted cadre over the head of the petitioner this Cabinet order had been violated and the petitioner had been discriminated against. There appears to be some force in this argument urged on behalf of the petitioner. But on behalf of the respondent it is urged that this Cabinet Order was later modified by another Cabinet Order No. 379-C of 1953 dated 4th April 1953 by which the power for relaxing the Cabinet order for crossing the efficiency bar in various grades was vested in the Minister in charge of the Education Department.

12. It is, therefore, apparent that in promoting the persons who had not crossed the efficiency bar to the Gazetted cadre the Cabinet had relaxed the restrictions contained in their order No. 1234-C of 1952 dated 15th November, 1952 in favour of those persons. We cannot help feeling that this relaxation in such circumstances does inflict hardship on the petitioner and we sympathise with him. But with all this we cannot hold that disregarding the restrictions contained in the Cabinet Order referred to above and which could be relaxed by the Minister in charge of Education under another Cabinet Order and which have been relaxed in the case of certain persons to the disadvantage of the petitioner give a right to the petitioner to seek protection from this Court on the ground that he has been denied equality before the law or the equal protection of the laws. The petitioner has not been able to show that any order by which he has been superseded can be impugned on the ground that it infringes any of the statutory rules indicated above. After careful consideration of all the circumstances set forth above we dismiss this writ petition but we would like to add that the case of the petitioner deserves special consideration of the Education Department and the Government. In the circumstances of the case we leave the parties to bear their own costs.

R.G.D

13. Petition dismissed.