- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
The Jammu And Kashmir Bank v. Nirmala Devi And Ors.
Factual and Procedural Background
The respondents deposited certain sums of money with the appellant Bank for a fixed period of one year. Upon the expiry of the fixed deposit period, the Bank did not repay the amounts when demanded by the respondents. Consequently, the respondents instituted suits against the Bank seeking repayment. The Bank raised the defense of limitation, contending that the limitation period started from the expiry of the fixed deposit term, and since the suits were filed after six years from that date, they were barred by limitation. The respondents argued that limitation should run from the date of demand, and since suits were filed within six years of demand, they were timely. The lower courts ruled in favor of the respondents, prompting the Bank to appeal to this court.
Legal Issues Presented
- What is the correct starting point of the limitation period for suits filed by depositors against a Bank for repayment of fixed deposits: the date of expiry of the fixed deposit term or the date of demand for repayment?
- Whether a fixed deposit after expiry of its term should be treated as a deposit payable on demand under the applicable Limitation Act provisions.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The limitation period should be computed from the date on which the fixed deposit period expired.
- The suits were instituted beyond six years from the date of expiry and are therefore barred by limitation.
- Relied on the Supreme Court decision in K. S. Wani v. New Akot Cotton Ginning and Pressing Co. Ltd, AIR 1958 SC 437, to support that limitation should run from maturity date.
Respondents' Arguments
- The limitation period starts only from the date of demand for repayment of the deposit.
- Since suits were instituted within six years of the demand, they are within the limitation period.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Joachimson v. Swiss Bank Corporation, (1921) 3 KB 110 | Established that demand for repayment is a condition precedent to suing a banker for money deposited; the banker-customer relationship is not an ordinary debtor-creditor relation. | Used to illustrate that a deposit with a banker is payable only upon demand, thus limitation runs from date of demand. |
| Chellappa Chetty v. Subramania Chetty, AIR 1919 Mad 825 | Held that a fixed term deposit can be treated as a deposit payable on demand after expiry of the fixed term. | Followed to support that limitation begins on demand even for fixed deposits after term expiry. |
| Murugappa v. Ramanathan, AIR 1935 Mad 734 | Followed the principle in Chellappa Chetty regarding deposits payable on demand after term expiry. | Reinforced the applicability of Art. 60 of the Indian Limitation Act to fixed deposits after term expiry. |
| Firm Nokhlal Sarju Prasad v. Mt. Bibi Mojihan, AIR 1939 Pat 261 | Applied the same principle of deposits payable on demand post fixed term. | Supported the court’s view on limitation starting from demand for such deposits. |
| K. S. Wani v. New Akot Cotton Ginning and Pressing Co. Ltd, AIR 1958 SC 437 | Held that limitation runs from the date fixed for repayment in a case of a loan (debt) and not a deposit. | Distinguished by the court as not applicable since the transaction there was a loan, not a deposit payable on demand. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court analyzed the nature of the banker-customer relationship and distinguished deposits from ordinary loans. It emphasized that a deposit with a banker is not a straightforward debt payable immediately upon term expiry. Instead, it involves an implied condition that repayment is only due upon demand by the depositor. This principle is supported by authoritative English law, including Joachimson v. Swiss Bank Corporation, and is reflected in Articles 89 and 90 of the State Limitation Act (corresponding to Articles 59 and 60 of the Indian Limitation Act).
The court considered whether a fixed term deposit alters this principle. It concluded that after expiry of the fixed term, the deposit generally becomes payable on demand unless there is a different intention evident from the parties' conduct or banking practice. The court found that the appellant Bank did not notify the depositors upon maturity and allowed the deposits to remain with the Bank for years, consistent with the Bank's own practice of treating time-expired deposits as payable on demand.
Based on evidence from the Bank’s manager, who confirmed that fixed deposits become withdrawable at any time after maturity without a time limit, the court held that the limitation period starts only from the date of demand. The court rejected the Bank’s reliance on K. S. Wani, distinguishing that case as involving a loan transaction, not a deposit.
Holding and Implications
The appeals are dismissed with costs.
The court held that fixed deposits, after the expiry of their fixed term, are to be treated as deposits payable on demand under Article 60 of the Indian Limitation Act. Consequently, the period of limitation for suits for repayment begins only from the date of demand. As the suits were instituted within six years of demand, they are within time and not barred by limitation. This decision directly affects the parties by affirming the respondents’ suits as timely and does not set any new precedent beyond confirming established principles regarding banker-customer deposit relationships and limitation periods.
Gopalakrishnan Nair J.:-
These appeals raise a common question of limitation.
(2) The respondents in the appeals deposited with the appellant Bank certain sums of money for a fixed period of one year. As the Bank did not repay the amounts on demand made by the respondents, suits out of which these appeals arise, were instituted by the respondents against the appellant Bank. The Bank raised the same point of limitation in all the suits which may briefly be set out as follows:
(3) The amounts became payable by the Bank on the dates on which the period of the fixed deposits expired. The period of limitation for the suits has, therefore, to be computed from those dates. As the suits were instituted beyond a period of six years from those dates, the suits are clearly barred by limitation.
(4) The respondents, on the other hand, contend that the starting point of limitation is the date on which demand was made on the Bank for repayment of the amount deposited and as the suits were brought within six years of the date of demand, .the suits are well within time.
(5) The controversy thus turns upon what is the correct starting point of limitation in these cases. If time is to run only from the date of demand, it is conceded that the suits are within time. But if Limitation started from the date when the period fixed for the deposits expired, it is common ground that the suits are out of time.
(6) The courts below found in favour of the respondents and decreed the suits. The appellant Bank has therefore come up in appeal to this court.
(7) The relation between the parties is admittedly one of Banker and customer and the transaction is one of deposit of money with a banker by a customer. A deposit with a banker is not a loan, pure and simple. Unlike an ordinary debtor, a banker has not to find out his creditor for re-payment of the debt. Nor is a depositor with a Bank entitled to demand re-payment at any time and at any place as an ordinary creditor is entitled to. Furthermore, whereas in the case of a loan simpliciter repayable on demand the starting point of limitation is the date when the loan is paid, in the case of a deposit with a Bank, time will begin to run only when a demand is made by the depositer for repayment of the amount deposited. This distinction has to be kept in mind in applying Arts. 89 and 90 of the State Limitation Act which correspond to Arts. 59 and 60 of the Indian Limitation Act (Act IX of 1908).
In the case of money lent under an agreement that it shall be repayable on demand, there is a present debt, and the debt which constitutes the .cause of action arises instantly on the loan. The words "on demand" when used in connection with .an ordinary loan, do not really mean that the amount will become payable only when its re-payment is demanded. On the other hand, the same words when used in connection with a deposit really mean what they say, that is, the deposit is to be paid only when a demand for it is made. In other words, the words "on demand" when employed in connection with an ordinary debt, have to be understood in the technical sense in which they are used in English law with reference to a promise to pay a debt.
But in the case of a deposit with a Banker actual demand for re-payment is an implied term of the contract between the Banker and the customer. This position has been authoritatively pointed out in Joachimson v. Swiss Bank Corporation, (1921) 3 KB 110. The question there was whether the customer of a bank can sue the banker for the balance standing to the credit of his current account without making .a previous demand on the banker for payment. That was a concurrent decision of three Judges of the Court of Appeal. Banks L. J. pointed out that it could not be an ordinary relation of a creditor and debtor and that there must be quite a good number of super-added obligations governing the relation between a banker and a customer. It was pointed out that a demand for payment by the customer was a condition precedent to the bringing of an action against the banker for the money.
(8) In Vol. 20 of Halsbury's Laws of England (2nd Ed) at page 610 the law is stated thus:
"If money is paid int3 a bunk on deposit account the statute does not run against an action to recover it until demand is made for its return. Similarly, in the case of money on current account, the statute does not run, in the absence of special contract or waiver, until after demand for payment as a demand either by the issue of a writ or otherwise, is an essential ingredient in the cause of action against the banker for money lent."
(9) Article 90 of the State Limitation Act (Art.; 60 of the Indian Limitation Act) recognizes the implied condition as to demand which is inherent in the relation of a banker with whom money is deposited and a customer who makes the deposit. A condition as to demand on the part of a depositor customer is necessarily implied in the transaction of deposit with a banker depositee. This undoubtedly is the position in the case of an ordinary deposit. But is the position different in the case of a deposit for a fixed term? Decision; on this point have not been uniform. But there appears to be good reason for holding that the essential character of the deposit as a deposit need not necessarily change even if it be for a fixed term. It need not necessarily become an ordinary debt payable instantly on the expiry of the fixed period.
In the large, majority of the cases the question will turn on the intention of the parties as can be gathered from their conduct the surrounding circumstances and the practice of the particular banker. In a given case it may be reasonable to construe a deposit for a fixed term as amounting to nothing more than an undertaking on the part of the depositor that he will not demand re-payment before the expiry of that term. But after the term expires, the implied condition as to demand will come into force and the banker will then hold the deposit under an implied agreement that it s be payable on demand. A demand by the depitor will then become necessary to render the banker liable for payment.
(10) It is not unoften that monies continue to lie in deposit with bankers for long years alter the expiry of the term fixed in respect of them. In such cases, the banker continues to be the depositee and the parties treat the deposit as one payable on demand. Mere expiry of the term fixed is, therefore, not decisive of the question whether the amount is held in deposit as one payable on demand.
(11) If the practice of a particular banker is to treat a time-expired deposit as an ordinary debt falling under Art. 89 (Art. 59 of the Indian Limitation Act) one would reasonably expect him to find out the creditor-depositor and repay the amount. He would at least issue a notice to the depositor informing him that the period of the deposit has expired and that money is due to him. The absence of any such intimation to the depositor will be a circumstance indicating the intention of the banker to treat the amount as a deposit payable on demand, after the expiry of the period fixed. And if we find the depositor also allowing the money to be held by the banker for long years after the expiry of the term: fixed, the intention on his part to treat the deposit as one payable on demand can legitimately be inferred.
In the instant case, the appellant-Bank did not issue any intimation to the depositors that the monies have become payable to them, and the depositors have allowed the banker to continue to hold the amounts in deposit for several years after their term expired. What is even more important in the present case is the practice of the appellant-Bank as spoken to by its Manager, Mr. Dutta. He deposed in clear terms that a fixed deposit after the expiry of its term becomes "a deposit withdrawable at any time".
He added that even after 25 to 50 years from the date of the expiry of the term originally fixed, a depositor is entitled to the return of the deposit by the Bank. Fie unequivocally admitted that there is no time-limit for withdrawal of such deposits. The only consequence which the depositor would incur is that interest will cease to accrue after the date of the maturity of the deposit. The evidence of the Manager of the appellant-Bank makes it abundantly clear that according to the practice of the bank a time-expired deposit becomes a deposit payable on demand.
(12) The conclusion is, therefore, inescapable that in the present cases the appellant-Bank held the amounts as deposits payable on demand, after the term fixed in respect of them expired. It follows that the cases fall under Art. 90 of the State Limitation Act (corresponding to Art. 60 of the Indian Limitation Act) and the period of limitation will begin to run only from the date of the demand by the respondents depositors.
(13) That a deposit for a term can, after the expiry of the term be treated as a deposit payable on demand falling under Art. 60 of the Indian Limitation Act, has been laid down by a Division Bench of the Madras High Court in Chellappa Chetty v. SubramaniaChetty, AIR 1919 Mad 825. This decision was followed by another Division Bench of the same Court in Murugappa v. Ramanathan AIR 1935 Mad 734 which was followed by a single Judge of the Patna High Court in Firm Nokhlal Sarju Prasad v. Mt. Bibi Mojihan, AIR 1939 Pat 261.
(14) Considering the practice of the appellant Bank and the intention of the parties as can be gathered from their conduct and the surrounding circumstances, we are clearly of opinion that there an implied agreement between the appellant Bank and the respondents-customers that after the expiry of the fixed terms the deposits were to be yield by the bank as deposits payable on demand. We are, therefore, clearly of the view that the article of the limitation act applicable to the case on hand is Art. 60 of the Indian Limitation Act (Art. 90 of the State Limitation Act) and that the suits are consequently within time.
(15) The appellant's learned counsel placed considerable reliance on a decision of the Supreme Court in K. S. Wani v. New Akot Cotton Ginning and Pressing Co. Ltd, AIR 1958 SC 437 in support of his contention that limitation should be held to run from the dates of the maturity of the deposits. We have carefully gone through that decision and have come to the conclusion that it is not applicable to the present case. The transaction in that case was one of debt, pure and simple, and not of deposit. Further, there was no agreement, express or implied, in that case, to hold the amounts as deposits payable on demand, after the expiry of the term originally fixed.
In the circumstances Art. 60 of the Indian Limitation Act could not apply to that case. That was an appeal from the judgment, of the Nagpur High Court reported in K. S Wani v. New Akot Cotton iGinning and Pressing Co. Ltd., AIR 1951 Nag 255, which shows that the transaction between the parties was not one of deposit as contemplated by Art. 60 of .the Indian Limitation Act, but was only one of ordinary borrowing in respect of which the period of limitation began to run from the date fixed for repayment of the debt.
(16) In view of the foregoing, the appeals fail and are dismissed with costs.
(17) J. N. WAZIR C. J.: I agree.
D.H.Z. Appeals dismissed.
Alert