Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Khursid Ahmed Bhat v. Haji Bashir Ahmed Bhat

Jammu and Kashmir High Court
Oct 1, 2009
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent filed a civil original suit in the court of the Principal District Judge, Srinagar, against the appellants seeking reliefs including rendition of accounts for profits from alleged infringement of the respondent's registered trade marks; delivery-up of infringing tools, labels and materials; a decree of perpetual injunction restraining infringement; and other reliefs deemed fit by the court. The respondent claimed to be proprietor of a small scale unit, M/s Haji Bashir Ahmad Bhat and Sons, manufacturing and selling Tobacco and allied products (Naswar), and that its product packaging and marks are registered under the Trade Marks Act, 1999. The respondent alleged that appellants were manufacturing and selling inferior products with marks and packagings deceptively similar to the respondent's, causing loss.

The respondent filed samples of both parties' products and an application for temporary injunction. The trial court initially passed an ex-parte ad-interim order. Appellants applied for vacation of that order; after hearing, the trial court on 10 June 2009 granted the respondent's application and passed a temporary injunction restraining the appellants, until disposal of the main suit, from using the marks "New Mour Marka", "Green Star Brand", and "Green Star Marks". The appellants challenged that interim order in a civil first miscellaneous appeal (the subject of this opinion).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial court was justified in granting the ad-interim/temporary injunction restraining the appellants from using the marks "New Mour Marka", "Green Star Brand", and "Green Star Marks".
  2. Whether the trial court properly considered and recorded the relative strength of the parties' cases and the similarities and dissimilarities between the competing trademarks and packaging before granting interim relief.
  3. Whether the interim injunction granted was within the scope of relief sought in the main suit or beyond it.
  4. Whether the suit was maintainable in Srinagar given that the respondent's trademark registration was stated to be at Delhi (as contended by the appellants).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments (as presented in the opinion)

  • The trial judge failed to consider the appellants' contentions in the application to vacate the ad-interim order.
  • There is no resemblance between the appellants' packets and trade marks and those of the respondent.
  • The suit was not maintainable at Srinagar because the respondent's trade mark registration was in Delhi.
  • The appellants' trademarks are registered with various authorities in the State.
  • The interim relief granted by the trial judge exceeded the relief sought in the main suit and thus was beyond the court's power in the interim order.
  • The respondent, in another suit pending before the Sub Judge Municipal Magistrate Srinagar, appeared as a witness and stated he was not conducting any business; thus he was not entitled to claim any privilege in respect of trademark.
  • Counsel for appellants referred to and relied upon the decision reported at AIR 2000 SC 2114, (1999) 2 SCC 377.

Respondent's Arguments (as presented in the opinion)

  • The trial court's order and reasons for granting the interim injunction are supportable and should be upheld.
  • The trademarks and packaging adopted by the appellants are deceptively similar to the respondent's registered trademarks, and that infringement of a registered trademark justifies an interim injunction.
  • The respondent is a registered user of trade marks described in the opinion as "Star Brand", "More Marka" and "Star Mark", all registered under the Trade Mark Act, 1999.
  • Counsel for the respondent referred to and relied upon judgments reported at AIR 2006 SC 3304, AIR 2008 (NOC) Del 128, and AIR 2007 (NOC) 1988 (Del).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
AIR 2000 SC 2114, (1999) 2 SCC 377 Cited and relied upon by counsel for the appellants (purpose not detailed in the opinion). The opinion records that the appellants' counsel relied on this judgment; the court does not set out or apply specific principles from it in the reasoning reproduced in this opinion.
AIR 2006 SC 3304 Cited and relied upon by counsel for the respondent (purpose not detailed in the opinion). The opinion records that the respondent's counsel relied on this judgment; the court does not expressly discuss or apply its specific principles in the judgment text provided.
AIR 2008 (NOC) Del 128 Cited and relied upon by counsel for the respondent (purpose not detailed in the opinion). Referenced by the respondent's counsel; the opinion does not explain how the court applied or distinguished this authority in its reasoning.
AIR 2007 (NOC) 1988 (Del) Cited and relied upon by counsel for the respondent (purpose not detailed in the opinion). Mentioned by respondent's counsel; the court's written reasoning in the provided text does not explicitly articulate reliance upon or application of this decision.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court reviewed the facts and the trial court's ad-interim order and articulated standards relevant to interim relief in trademark infringement cases, emphasizing a careful, comparative approach. The court's analysis proceeded as follows:

  1. The court acknowledged that in trademark infringement cases the court must consider both the fact of registration under the Trade Marks Act, 1999, and the relative strength of the competing parties' cases. It noted the need to examine similarities and dissimilarities between the trademarks and packaging before reaching a just conclusion on infringement and the genuineness of the grievance (paragraph 9 of the opinion).
  2. The court observed that the reliefs claimed in the main suit authorize the court to pass interim orders restraining the defendant from using the trademarks pending disposal of the suit and specifically held that the interim relief sought was not beyond the reliefs claimed in the main suit (paragraph 10).
  3. Turning to the trial court's order, the appellate court reproduced the relevant passage in which the trial judge found that the addition of words "new or green" did not make the marks different from the registered trademarks and that the applicant had made out a prima facie case of infringement, with balance of convenience and risk of irreparable injury favoring grant of interim relief (paragraphs 14–16).
  4. The appellate court then critically examined the manner in which the trial judge arrived at that prima facie conclusion. It held that the trial judge was duty bound to spell out the relative similarities and dissimilarities of the trademarks and pouches. The court found that the trial judge had not performed the required detailed comparison beyond a brief reference to the words "New or Green" (paragraphs 12, 17).
  5. The court explained that for prima facie findings it is necessary to apply phonetic, visual and ocular tests—i.e., to compare the trademarks closely on these facets—and that the trial judge did not delineate or consider these important aspects in the impugned order (paragraphs 13, 18).
  6. The court also emphasized constitutional considerations: the right to carry on trade, occupation and business under Article 19(1)(g) and the right to livelihood under Article 21. It stated that orders capable of affecting those rights must be passed in strict compliance with the governing law. The opinion cites "0.39 Rl & 2" (as appearing in the text) as authorizing interim orders, but underscores that such orders must align with settled principles (paragraph 14).
  7. Because the trial judge had not sufficiently recorded comparisons and had not assessed relative strengths of the parties' cases in adequate detail, the appellate court concluded that the impugned interim order was legally flawed (paragraphs 17–18).

Holding and Implications

ORDER SET ASIDE

Holding (core ruling): The appellate court set aside the impugned interim order granting temporary injunction. The court directed the trial judge to re-consider the interim injunction application in light of the observations made in the opinion, with hearing of the parties and after conducting the required comparative analysis.

Implications and direct consequences:

  • The trial judge is to re-hear/re-consider the injunction application, addressing the deficiencies identified (in particular, a detailed comparison of trademarks by phonetic, visual and ocular tests and an assessment of the relative strength of the parties' cases).
  • The trial judge was requested to dispose of the injunction application preferably within one month from the date the record is received by him.
  • The registry was directed to send back the record immediately.
  • The appeal was disposed of along with all connected CMPs.

No broader precedent or new legal principle is expressly stated to have been established by the court in this opinion; the decision sets aside the specific interim order and instructs re-consideration in accordance with established comparative and constitutional considerations outlined in the reasoning.

Show all summary ...

1. Respondent instituted civil original suit against appellants in the court of learned Principal District Judge Srinagar in which the following reliefs are claimed:-

"a. A decree for rendition of comprehensive and all accounts for the profits made by the defendants infringing the plaintiffs. 'Registered Trade Marks' stated and submitted above.

b. A decree for delivering (delivery-up) of the infringing tools, instruments, labels, material, seals, marks etc used during and in the course of infringing the plaintiffs 'Registered Trade Mark'.

c. A decree of perpetual injunction restraining the defendants perpetually from infringing the plaintiffs "Registered Trade Marks' by any manner or method.

d. Any other relief which this Hon'ble Court deems fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case be also passed in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants."

2. Respondent claimed to be proprietor of the small scale unit namely M/s Haji Bashir Ahmad Bhat and Sons dealing in manufacturing, processing, pack­ing and sale of Tobacco and allied products (Naswar), with its head office located at Jamalata Srinagar. The respondent claimed that the said SSI Unit is registered with various authorities. The further case of the respondent is that he uses various packings for marketing products and packging of the products are significant because consumers of the products are mostly rustic and illiterate people for whom packing getup, which include colors/marks, is the only guide that leads them to the identification of the product. The further claim of the respondent in the suit is that the appellants have been manufacturing, storing and selling inferior quality products in the market, and Marks/packings have been fraudulently tailor made to be deceptively similar to that of Marks/Pack­ings of respondent, and in process appellants are causing immense damage and loss to the respondent. The respondent's products are registered under the Trade Mark Act, 1999. The respondent has placed the sample of his product along with the samples of the product of the appellants on the suit record. Along with the suit respondent filed an application for temporary injunction, and initially the learned trial Judge passed an ex-parte ad-interim order. Appellants filed an application seeking vacation of the ex-parte order and after hearing of the parties the learned trial Judge vide its order dated 10th June, 2009 allowed the temporary injunction application of the respondent and appellants were temporarily restrained till disposal of the main suit from using the marks "New Mour Marka", "Green Star Brand", and "Green Star Marks" while manufactur­ing and marketing their products. It is this order which is under challenge in this civil first miscellaneous appeal.

3. Heard learned counsel for parties. Considered the matter.

4. Ld counsel for appellants Mr. M.A. Qayoom, submitted that the order under appeal is illegal because the Id. trial Judge has failed to consider the contentions raised by the appellants in the application seeking vacation of the ad-interim order. The Id. counsel further submitted that there is no resemblance between the packets as also the Trade Marks of the products being manufac­tured and sold in the market by the appellants with that of the products manufactured and sold by the respondent. The Id. counsel further submitted that the suit is not maintainable at Srinagar as the respondent has been regis­tered under the Trade Mark Act of 1999 at Delhi. The Id. counsel further submitted that trademark of the appellants are registered with various author­ities in the State. Ld. Counsel also submitted that the interim relief which has been granted by Id. trial Judge is beyond the relief sought for in the main suit and the Id. trial Judge could not pass the order impugned in the appeal. The learned counsel further submitted that the respondent, in the suit instituted by the appellants against him, which suit is pending on the files of Id. Sub Judge Municipal Magistrate Srinagar has appeared as witness wherein he has stated that he is not conducting any business. The Id. counsel would thus submit that the respondent is not entitled to claim any privilege in respect of trademark. The Id. counsel also referred to and relied upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court reported in AIR 2000 SC 2114, (1999) 2 SCC 377.

5. Mr. M.A. Rathore Id. counsel for respondent, however, supported the order and the reasons recorded in the order, impugned in this appeal. The learned counsel was at pains to explain that the trade mark adopted by the appellants are deceptively similar to those of the trademark adopted by the respondent and registered by the competent authority under the trademark Act of 1999. The Id. counsel further submitted, the very fact that the registered trade mark of the respondent has been infringed, a case for issuance of interim injunction is made out. The Id. counsel further submitted that the respondent is registered user of trade mark "Star Brand" "More Marka and "Star Mark" and all these are registered under the provisions of Trade Mark Act of 1999. The Id counsel also referred to and relied upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court reported in AIR 2006 SC 3304, AIR 2008 (NOC) Del 128, AIR 2007 (NOC) 1988 (Del) and submitted that in view of the law laid down in these judgments the appeal merits dismissal.

6. Convictions and concepts of an individual get reflected in his dealings with other creatures inhibiting this universe which include fellow citizens. Relative strength of ones convictions get transformed into his actions and spill-over to his field of activity.

7. A human being may be identified by Mark called "Name" but he is being "known" by his convictions and characteristics which exude from his person­ality. A human being covers vast field of activities on his sojourn on this planet, called "Earth". One such essential activity is dealing with fellow human beings. In the unfathomable field of activity, commerce and trade may be dating back to human history itself.

8. All faiths, philosophies and thoughts visualize a world based on princi­ples of morality and ethics, and simultaneously expect to create surroundings of pristine purity. The trade and commerce is to be carried on, on the funda­mental principles of truth, fairness and honest dealings, which create an aura of distinctive character around a commodity, which one manufactures and sells in the market. The commodity is being "known" by its characteristics which get manifested into trademark with which it is identified in the trade circle by consumers. The good-will earned, and reputation gained, becomes hallmark of, the trademark, of a product. It cannot be allowed to be unscrupulously copied, as fall out and consequence will result in colossal loss to the owner in the field of trade and commerce.

9. In a case of this nature where infringement of trade mark is claimed the court is not only to consider the factum of registration of trade mark with the competent authority under the Trade Marks Act, 1999, but is also to consider the relative strength of the case of competing parties. The court has also to consider the similarities and dissimilarities of the trademarks. When the court considers all these aspects then alone it will come to just and lawful conclusion as to whether there is any infringement of the trademark of the party complaining the same, and court will thus be in position to record a finding as to whether the complaining party has projected a genuine grievance.

10. The relief sought for in the main suit do authorize the court to pass an interim order to restrain the defendant, pending disposal of the suit from using the trademarks. The interim relief sought for is not beyond the relief sought in the main suit.

11. The product involved in this case is "Naswar" which both appellants and respondent are manufacturing and selling to the consumers. The Id. trial judge has passed the order impugned in this appeal after arriving at the conclusion reflected in the order, relevant paragraph thereof is reproduced as under:-

"The addition of words "new or green" to the words used in the registered trademarks does not make marks different from th words in the registered trade marks and are prima facie bound to mislead the consumers.

So viewed, the applicant has made out a prima facie case of infringe­ment of his registered trade marks by the non-applicants by use of the marks appearing in Ahnexure A-7 to the application. The balance of convenience in the circumstances lies in favour of the applicant and against the non-applicants. The applicant is likely to be visited with an irreparable loss and injury making it impossible to compensate the applicant, in case ad-interim relief injunction is not granted in favour of the applicant and against the non-applicant"

12. The Id. trial Judge in order to arrive at such conclusion was duty bound to spell out the relative similarities and also dissimilarities of trade marks and the pouches. It is only after referring to and explaining the similarities and dissimilarities the Id. trial Judge would prima-facie come to conclusion as to whether the trade mark adopted by the appellants is deceptively similar to that of the respondent. The Id. trial Judge has not compared the two trade Marks except making reference to the words "New or Green". This in law would not be sufficient compliance in determining as to whether there has been infringe­ment of trademark. The Id. trial Judge was required to examine the trademarks closely and point out similarities and dissimilarities. The Id. trial Judge has not considered these aspects of the matter. It is only after considering the similarities and dissimilarities of the trademark of the parties in all details that the relative strength of the case of the competing parties could be adjudged even for prima-facie purposes. Mere recording of prima-facie finding of infringement of trademark would not entitle the person having registered trademark to a relief. The relative strength of the case of the competing parties has to be considered and high lighted and thereafter a finding recorded.

13. The court in such type of cases has to put the respective trade marks to phonetical, visual and ocular test. It is on close examination of these facets of case, even for prima facie purposes, that a finding one way or the other way can be recorded. The learned trial Judge has not delineated and considered these important aspects of case in the impugned order.

14. Right to carry on trade, occupation and business is a fundamental right guaranteed under Art. 19 (i) (g) of Constitution. Right to earn livelihood is an important facet of Art. 21. The orders which have the potential of affecting such right cannot be passed, without approaching the problem projected, in strict compliance of the law occupying the field. 0.39 Rl & 2 does authorize court to pass interim orders, but such orders have to be passed in tune with settled principles of law.

15. The order impugned in this backdrop is rendered illegal and is accord­ingly set aside. The Id. trial judge will re-consider the matter in view of the observations made in this judgment and will accordingly pass orders in accor­dance with law after hearing the parties. The Id. trial Judge is requested to dispose of the injunction application preferably within a period of one month from the date the record is received by him. Registry to send back the record immediately. Appeal disposed of along with all connected CMPs.