Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Tsering Narboo v. Tashi Phunchok & Anr.

Jammu and Kashmir High Court
May 26, 2008
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

A civil suit was filed by the appellant before the District Judge, Leh, seeking a declaration that the plaintiff and defendants are co-sharers in joint possession of certain lands situated at Skurbucan, Leh. The appellant also sought a declaration of ownership and possession by adverse possession over a specific land measuring 1 Kanal 4 Marias. Alongside the suit, the appellant filed an application for a temporary injunction restraining the defendant/respondent No.1 from interfering with the possession of this land. The defendants denied the appellant's title and possession claims.

The District Judge, Leh, dismissed the appellant's application for temporary injunction on 11-8-2006, finding no prima facie case. Subsequently, during the pendency of the suit, the defendants filed an application seeking a direction restraining the appellant from interfering with their possession of the same land. The District Judge allowed this application, restraining the appellant from interference and directing the defendant not to change the nature of the property until the suit's final disposal. This order by the District Judge is the subject matter of the present appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial court had the power under Order 39 Rule 1 (a), (b), and (c) of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) to grant an injunction in favor of the defendant restraining the plaintiff from dispossessing the defendant.
  2. Whether the inherent powers under Section 151 CPC can be invoked by the court to grant such injunctions when not maintainable under Order 39 Rule 1 CPC.
  3. Whether a defendant can claim injunction relief in a suit filed by the plaintiff when the cause of action for the defendant arises separately and after the plaintiff’s cause of action.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The application filed by the defendants under Order 39 Rule 1 & 2 CPC was not maintainable because the power to grant injunction under these provisions is limited to preventing wasting, damaging, alienation, sale, or removal of property, and does not extend to staying dispossession by the defendant.
  • Even if the court had power to grant injunction, it could not be on an application filed by the defendant who cannot claim any right arising from the plaintiff’s cause of action.
  • Cited precedents supporting the limited scope of injunctions under Order 39 Rule 1 CPC.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The court has the power to grant injunction to the defendant under Section 151 CPC, even if not under Order 39 Rule 1 (a) and (b).
  • Filing a separate suit by the defendant would cause multiplicity of proceedings and is barred under Section 10 CPC because the issues substantially overlap with the plaintiff’s suit.
  • Cited precedents supporting the use of inherent powers and injunctions in the defendant’s favor.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Suganda Bai Vs Sulu Bai and others, AIR 1975 Karnataka 135 Limitation on grant of injunction under Order 39 Rule 1 CPC Supported appellant’s argument restricting injunction to prevent wasting or alienation only.
Dr. Ashis Ranjan Das Vs Rajendra Nath Mullick, AIR 1982 Cal 529 Scope of injunction under Order 39 Rule 1 CPC Supported appellant’s position on non-maintainability of defendant’s injunction application.
M/s Anand Associates Vs Nagpur Improvement Trust, AIR 2000 SC 3350 Use of inherent powers under Section 151 CPC Respondents cited it to argue court’s power to grant injunction under inherent powers.
Kisan Uchattar Madhyamik Vs IIIrd Addl District Judge, AIR 1989 All 168 Injunction powers and inherent jurisdiction Respondents cited to support inherent power argument.
Vincent and others Vs Aisumma, AIR 1989 Kerala 8 Grant of injunction under inherent powers Respondents cited to support their claim of court’s power under Section 151 CPC.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the provisions of Order 39 Rule 1 (a), (b), and (c) CPC, noting that the power to grant injunction on an application by a party is limited to preventing the wasting, damaging, alienation, or wrongful sale of property. The court emphasized that these provisions restrict injunctions against dispossession to protection of the plaintiff only, and do not empower the court to grant injunctions in favor of the defendant restraining the plaintiff from dispossessing them.

The court further held that the inherent powers under Section 151 CPC cannot be exercised to grant injunctions that are barred under the specific provisions of Order 39 Rule 1 CPC. The inherent power is meant to supplement and not override statutory provisions. Therefore, the court rejected the respondents’ contention that injunction could be granted under Section 151 CPC when not maintainable under Order 39.

Regarding the argument on cause of action, the court found that the cause of action for the plaintiff arose in 2006, whereas the defendant’s cause of action arose in 2007, making them distinct. Hence, the defendant could not claim injunction relief based on the plaintiff’s cause of action. The court also rejected the argument that filing a separate suit by the defendant would amount to multiplicity of proceedings, as the claims and causes of action were different.

Holding and Implications

The court allowed the appeal, set aside the order of the District Judge, Leh, and dismissed the application seeking temporary injunction filed by the defendant.

The direct effect of this decision is that the defendant’s application for injunction restraining the plaintiff from dispossession was held not maintainable and dismissed. The court explicitly stated that this decision does not express any opinion on the merits of the suit pending before the trial court. No new precedent was established beyond the interpretation of the scope of Order 39 Rule 1 CPC and the limitations on inherent powers under Section 151 CPC.

Show all summary ...

1. A civil suit came to be filed by the appellant before the District Judge, Leh seeking declaration to the effect that the plaintiff and the defendants are co-sharers, co-sharers and in joint possession of land comprising in Khasra No. 698, 701,1184,1185,1408, Khewat No. Ill situated at Skurbucan, Leh. Further declaration was sought that the appellant is owner in possession of land measuring 1 Kanal 4 Marias, comprising in Khewat No. Ill, Khasra No. 1410 situate at Skurbuchan, Leh on account of adverse possession claiming against the respondents for over 30 years.

2. Alongwith the suit an application for temporary injunction restraining defendant/respondent No.1 from interfering with the peaceful possession of land under Khewat No. 111, Khasra No. 1410 measuring 1 Kanal 4 Marias was filed.

3. The defendants in their written statement denied the title of the plaintiff over the suit land as a co-sharer on the ground that he was not the son of Late Tundup Namgial. They have also denied the plaintiffs possession over the suit land as claimed by him.

4. The application for seeking temporary injunction against the defen­dants/respondents came to be decided by the learned District Judge, Leh on 11-8-2006. The learned District Judge did not find the petitioner entitled to the relief of injunction on the ground that there was no prima facie case in his favour, except for the averments made by him in the plaint. The plaintiff/petitioner claimed this land as in adverse possession against the defendants.

5. It is important to mention that the application for temporary injunction was confined only to Khasra No. 1410 measuring 1 Kanal 4 Marias. The said application came to be dismissed.

6. During the pendency of the suit the defendants/respondents filed an application against the plaintiff/petitioner seeking a direction against the plain­tiff/petitioner not to interfere with the peaceful possession over the land measuring 1 Kanal 4 Marias comprising in Khasra No. 1410.

7. The said application was allowed by the learned District Judge in which he restrained the petitioner/plaintiff permanently from causing any type of interference in the land measuring 1 Kanal 4 Marias comprised in Survey No. 1410 situated in village Skarbuchan, Leh in cultivating possession of defendant/respondent No.1 till final disposal of the suit. It was also directed that the defendant shall not change the nature of the suit property till the final disposal of the suit. It is this order of the District Judge, Leh which is subject matter of challenge in this appeal.

8. Mr. Raina, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that the application filed by the defendants/respondents before the trial Court under order 39 rule 1 & 2 code of civil procedure was not maintainable for the following reasons:

(i) That under order 39 rule-1 (a) & (b) cpc the power to grant injunction on an application filed by a party in the suit is restricted only for preventing the wasting, damaging, alienation, sale, removal of the property; There is no power vested with the trial Court to order stay of dis-possession of the defendant by the plaintiff in a suit filed by the plaintiff. In other words Mr. Raina states that no application for seeking stay of dispossession by the defendants can be filed under Order 39 Rule 1 (a) (b) (c) of Code of Civil Procedure.

(ii) The second ground is that assuming but not admitting that there is power to grant injunction even then the same cannot be done on the application filed by the defendant as he cannot claim any right on the cause of action of the plaintiff.

9. In support of his arguments Mr. Raina, learned counsel for the petitioner has cited the cases (i) Suganda Bai Vs Sulu Bai and others, AIR 1975 Karnataka 135; and (ii) Dr/Ashis Ranjan Das Vs Rajendra Nath Mullick, AIR 1982 Cal 529

10. On the other hand Mr. L.K. Sharma, learned counsel appearing for the respondents states that the Court has the power to grant injunction to the defendant in a suit filed by the plaintiff, if not under Order 39 Rule 1 (a) (b), but under section 151 CPC. In support of his arguments Mr. Sharma, learned counsel for the respondents cited M/s Anand Associates Vs Nagpur Improve­ment Trust, AIR 2000 SC 3350; Kisan Uchattar Madhyamik Vs Illrd Addl District Judge, AIR 1989 All 168; & Vincent and others Vs Aisumma, AIR 1989 Kerala 8.

11. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record. A bare perusal of order 39 Rule 1 (a), (b) and (c) reveals that the Court has the power to grant an order of injunction under clause (a) on an application filed by a party to the suit, if it is found that the property in dispute is in danger of being wasted, damaged or alienated by any party to the suit or wrongfully sold in execution of a decree. Clause (b) empowers the Court to issue temporary injunction in case the conditions indicated in clause (a) are satisfied. Clause (b) also empowers to grant the order of injunction if the defendant threatens or intends to remove or dispose of his property with a view to defrauding his creditors. It is clear from the conjoint reading of clauses (a) and (b) that power to grant injunction on an application filed by the defendant is restricted to the extent indicated hereinabove and none other. This fact is further corroborated when we examine the clause (b) in totality. It reveals that the power to grant injunction against dispossession can only be revoked by the plaintiff and not by the defendant.

12. The Court can pass an order of injunction in the mandatory form also, if the facts so permit. So from the conjoint reading of the above said provisions it is clear that no order of injunction to restrain the plaintiff to dispossessing the defendant in a suit filed by the plaintiff can be passed. Further the defendant can seek temporary injunction against the plaintiff even without filing counter claim only when the relief claimed arises out of plaintiffs cause of action. The remedy for the defendant in that case may be to file a fresh suit. The other kind of injunction which can be granted under clause (b) of Rule 1 is restricted to dispossession the plaintiff may face from defendant in respect of any property in dispute. Clause (c) also empowers the Court to grant temporary injunction in case the defendant threatens to dispossess the plaintiff or otherwise causes injury to the plaintiff in relation to any property in dispute in the suit.

13. The reading of the provisions mentioned above clearly restricts the Courts power under O.39 R1 (a) (b) and (c) in respect of threat of dispossession to the plaintiff only. If the legislature intended to confer power on the court to grant temporary injunction in favour of the defendants in respect of his dispos­session, same would have been incorporated in the statute. The statute clearly omits this rightly so because while granting order of temporary injunction in a suit filed by the plaintiff seeking protection of property, the defendant cannot seek an order of injunction against dispossession in the said suit.

14. Argument of Mr. L.K. Sharma, learned counsel for the respondents is that even if the power to grant injunction is not traceable under Order 39, the Court has the power under section 151 Civil Procedure Code. I am not in agreement with this proposition. The Court cannot take recourse under section 151CPC on an application which is not maintainable under Order 39 R 1(a) (b) (c). The inherent power can be exercised only to supplement any eventuality which is not covered under Order 39 R 1 (a) (b) (c) and not in derogation of the statute. Granting of an injunction against dispossession of defendant is clearly barred by O.39 Rule (1) ,(b) and (c). O 39 Rule 1 CPC prescribes circumstances in which temporary injunction can be issued. Ordinarily the court is not to use its inherent powers to make necessary orders in the interest of justice. Civil court generally has no inherent jurisdiction if the case is not covered under 0.39 Rule 1 of CPC to issue temporary injunction. Inherent powers are being exercised by the court in very exceptional circumstances for which court lays down no procedure. There is bar under O. 39 to grant temporary injunction against defendant whose possession is threatened by the plaintiff.

15. The next argument of Mr. Raina is that the respondents/defendants cannot claim any right on the cause of action accrued to the plaintiff. According to Mr. Raina, he had filed a suit for declaration claiming to be owner in possession of land measuring 1 Kanal 4 Marias on account of adverse possession claimed over the plaintiff for over 30 years. It is his claim of possession which he wanted to protect by filing an application for temporary injunction. The defendants on the other hand state that they are in possession of the property. It is not in dispute that the petitioner's application for temporary injunction has been dismissed. It is submitted that the cause of action arose to the plaintiff in the year 2006, whereas the cause of action arose to the defendant in the year 2007. Both these causes of action are different. There is no dispute with respect to the dates when the plaintiff initially filed an application for injunction and when the defendant filed the application before the Court below. So admittedly, the defendants could not have filed an application on the cause of action of the plaintiff which arose in 2006.

16. Mr. Sharma, learned counsel for the defendants/respondents states that by filing a separate suit, there will be multiplicity of proceedings. He further submits that the matter in issue is directly and substantially the same as filed by the plaintiff, as such, filing such a suit would be barred under section 10 CPC. This ground is also not tenable because the suit of the plaintiff is that he claims adverse possession against the defendant, whereas the defendant claims relief of injunction against the plaintiff. So this argument is also not sustainable.

17. For the foregoing reasons, I allow this appeal and set aside the order passed by District Judge, Leh and dismiss the application seeking grant of temporary injunction filed by the defendant.

18. Nothing stated hereinabove shall be treated as an expression of opinion on the merits of the suit pending before the trial court.