- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Rohtas Bhankhar And Others v. Union Of India And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
In 1970 the Department of Personnel issued Office Memorandum No. 8/12/69-Estt.(SCT) (“1970 OM”) permitting relaxed qualifying standards for Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe (SC/ST) candidates in departmental competitive and confirmation examinations. The memorandum remained operative for approximately 17 years. On 22-7-1997 Office Memorandum No. 36012/23/96-Estt.(Res) (“1997 OM”) withdrew those relaxations. To give effect to this withdrawal, Regulation 7(3) of the Central Secretariat Service Section Officers' Grade/Stenographers' Grade “B” (Limited Departmental Competitive Examination) Regulations, 1964 was deleted by the Central Secretariat Service Amendment Regulations, 1998 with retrospective effect from 22-7-1997.
Several candidates challenged the withdrawal before the Central Administrative Tribunal, Delhi. The Tribunal relied on S. Vinod Kumar v. Union of India (1996) 6 SCC 580 and upheld the 1997 OM. The unsuccessful candidates filed special leave petitions which were first considered by a two-Judge Bench on 8-10-1999, then by a three-Judge Bench on 2-12-1999 and ultimately referred to a Constitution Bench. The present opinion resolves that reference and the attendant civil appeals.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, in light of Article 16(4-A) and the proviso to Article 335 of the Constitution, the Government can lawfully prescribe relaxed qualifying marks or lower standards of evaluation for SC/ST candidates in departmental promotional examinations.
- Whether the decision in S. Vinod Kumar v. Union of India (1996) 6 SCC 580 correctly states the law after the introduction of Article 16(4-A).
- The legality of the 1997 OM which withdrew relaxed standards and the consequent deletion of Regulation 7(3) from the 1964 Regulations.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| S. Vinod Kumar v. Union of India (1996) 6 SCC 580 | Held that relaxation of qualifying marks in promotion violates Article 335 | Declared per incuriam for not considering Article 16(4-A); expressly overruled |
| Indra Sawhney, 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217 | Majority view that standards cannot be diluted in promotion; laid down 50% ceiling, creamy layer, etc. | Referenced to show the background that Article 16(4-A) was enacted to overcome certain observations |
| Kuldeep Singh (1997) 9 SCC 199 | Upheld relaxation of marks for SC/ST candidates after Article 16(4-A) | Approved as correctly reflecting the constitutional scheme |
| Haridas Parsedia v. Urmila Shakya (2000) 1 SCC 81 | Allowed 10% reduction in passing marks for SC/STs in departmental promotion exams | Noted, but Court observed that Indra Sawhney had not been considered in that decision |
| M. Nagaraj (2006) 8 SCC 212 | Upheld constitutional validity of Articles 16(4-A) & 16(4-B) and the proviso to Article 335; set conditions of backwardness, inadequacy, efficiency | Quoted extensively to demonstrate compatibility of relaxation with constitutional structure |
| R.K. Sabharwal (1995) 2 SCC 745 | Established post-based roster and 50% ceiling principles | Cited via M. Nagaraj to show continuing constitutional requirements |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
1. The Court first identified that S. Vinod Kumar, on which the Tribunal had relied, did not consider Article 16(4-A) (inserted in 1995) and was therefore rendered per incuriam.
2. Article 16(4-A) specifically empowers the State to provide reservation in promotion for SC/ST employees, and the proviso to Article 335 (added in 2000) expressly permits relaxation of qualifying marks or lowering of evaluation standards for such reservation.
3. The Court reviewed the constitutional amendments and the authoritative exposition in M. Nagaraj, confirming that relaxation in promotion is constitutionally valid provided the broader equality structure (50% ceiling, efficiency, etc.) remains intact.
4. Kuldeep Singh was found to be consistent with Article 16(4-A) and therefore correct, while S. Vinod Kumar was inconsistent and incorrect.
5. Because the 1997 OM withdrew relaxations based on the now-disapproved reasoning of S. Vinod Kumar, the memorandum lacked legal validity. The retrospective deletion of Regulation 7(3) equally stood on the same flawed foundation.
6. Given the prolonged litigation and the clear entitlement of the appellants, the Constitution Bench decided the merits instead of sending the case back to a smaller Bench.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The civil appeals are allowed; the Tribunal’s order in O.A. Nos. 499 and 849 of 1998 is set aside; the 1997 Office Memorandum withdrawing relaxed standards is declared illegal. Respondents must revise the results of the 1996 Section Officers/Stenographers (Grade B/Grade I) Limited Departmental Competitive Examination by providing reservation and grant all consequential reliefs. No order as to costs.
Implications: The decision reinstates the validity of relaxed qualifying standards for SC/ST candidates in departmental promotions, clarifies that S. Vinod Kumar is not good law, and affirms Kuldeep Singh as correct precedent. While no new constitutional doctrine is fashioned, the ruling ensures immediate relief to affected candidates and guides future governmental policies on promotions with relaxed standards under Article 16(4-A).
R.M Lodha, C.J— On 23-12-1970, the Department of Personnel issued Office Memorandum being OM No. 8/12/69-Estt.(SCT) (“1970 OM”) relaxing standards in the case of Scheduled Caste/Tribe candidates in departmental competitive examinations and in departmental confirmation examinations. The said OM remained operative for about 17 years until OM No. 36012/23/96-Estt.(Res) dated 22-7-1997 was issued whereby the instructions contained in the 1970 OM were withdrawn. Thereafter by Notification dated 30-11-1998, the Central Secretariat Service Section Officers' Grade/Stenographers' Grade ‘B’ (Limited Departmental Competitive Examination) Regulations, 1964 (for short “the 1964 Regulations”) were amended by the Central Secretariat Service Section Officers' Grade/Stenographers' Grade ‘B’ (Limited Departmental Competitive Examination) Amendment Regulations, 1998 (for short “the 1998 Regulations”). The result of this amendment was that in the 1964 Regulations, Regulation 7 sub-regulation (3) was omitted on and from 22-7-1997. The Explanatory Note appended to the above notification reads as follows:
In compliance with the Supreme Court's judgment in S. Vinod Kumar v. Union of India (1996) 6 SCC 580, the Central Government decided to omit the provisions of Regulation 7(3) of the Central Secretariat Service Section Officers' Grade/Stenographers' Grade ‘B’ (Limited Departmental Competitive Examination) Regulations, 1964 which provides for relaxed qualifying standard in favour of the Scheduled Caste and the Scheduled Tribe candidates to make up the deficiency in the reserved quota which has been rendered legally invalid and unenforceable. This is certified that no one is being adversely affected by giving this amendment retrospective effect.
2. In S. Vinod Kumar (1996) 6 SCC 580, this Court relying upon Indra Sawhney 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217, (1992) 22 ATC 385 held that provision for lower qualifying marks/standard of evaluation was not permissible under Article 16(4) of the Constitution of India in view of Article 335. Though Article 16(4-A) had been brought into the Constitution by the Constitution (Seventy-seventh Amendment) Act, 1995 with effect from 17-6-1995, S. Vinod Kumar (1996) 6 SCC 580 did not take into consideration this constitutional provision. In our view, S. Vinod Kumar (1996) 6 SCC 580 is per incuriam.
3. Moreover, by the Constitution (Eighty-second Amendment) Act, 2000, a proviso has been appended to Article 335 of the Constitution with effect from 8-9-2000. The proviso reads as follow:
“Provided that nothing in this article shall prevent in making of any provision in favour of the members of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes for relaxation in qualifying marks in any examination or lowering the standards of evaluation, for reservation in matters of promotion to any class or classes of services or posts in connection with the affairs of the Union or of a State.”
4. On 8-10-1999, when the special leave petitions, from which these appeals arise, came up for consideration before a two-Judge Bench, the Bench first formulated (2000) 2 SCC 364 the point for consideration in the matter viz. whether it was permissible for the authorities to fix lesser number of qualifying marks for reserved candidates in the matter of “promotion”. The Bench noticed three judgments of this Court: (1) Indra Sawhney 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217, (1992) 22 ATC 385, (2) S. Vinod Kumar (1996) 6 SCC 580, and (3) Kuldeep Singh (1997) 9 SCC 199 and observed that in Kuldeep Singh (1997) 9 SCC 199 the Court did not notice the observations of majority as well as observations of Sawant, J. in Indra Sawhney 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217, (1992) 22 ATC 385, and the matter needed to be heard by a three-Judge Bench.
5. On 2-12-1999, the matter came up before a three-Judge Bench. The Bench on that day reiterated (2000) 2 SCC 366 what was earlier stated by the two-Judge Bench in the order dated 8-10-1999 (2000) 2 SCC 364 that in Kuldeep Singh (1997) 9 SCC 199, the Bench had not referred to the majority decision in Indra Sawhney 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217, (1992) 22 ATC 385. The Bench doubted the correctness of the decision in Kuldeep Singh (1997) 9 SCC 199 and referred the matter to the Constitution Bench. In the reference order, the three-Judge Bench also noted the decision of this Court in Haridas Parsedia v. Urmila Shakya (2000) 1 SCC 81 dated 19-11-1999 wherein it was observed that in the case of departmental promotion examination, which is held exclusively for SCs/STs, there could be reduction to the extent of 10% in the passing marks. As regards Haridas Parsedia (2000) 1 SCC 81, the Bench observed that in that case, the observations of this Court in Indra Sawhney 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217, (1992) 22 ATC 385 wherein it was laid down that there cannot be dilution of standards in matter of promotion were not noticed.
6. It is important to note here that constitutional validity of Article 16(4-A) came up for consideration before the Constitution Bench in M. Nagaraj (2006) 8 SCC 212. In paras 97 to 99 (p. 267) of the Report, the Constitution Bench observed:
“97. As stated above, clause (4-A) of Article 16 is carved out of clause (4) of Article 16. Clause (4-A) provides benefit of reservation in promotion only to SCs and STs. In S. Vinod Kumar v. Union of India (1996) 6 SCC 580 this Court held that relaxation of qualifying marks and standards of evaluation in matters of reservation in promotion was not permissible under Article 16(4) in view of Article 335 of the Constitution. This was also the view in Indra Sawhney 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217, (1992) 22 ATC 385.
98. By the Constitution (Eighty-second Amendment) Act, 2000 a proviso was inserted at the end of Article 335 of the Constitution which reads as under:
‘Provided that nothing in this article shall prevent in making of any provision in favour of the members of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes for relaxation in qualifying marks in any examination or lowering the standards of evaluation, for reservation in matters of promotion to any class or classes of services or posts in connection with the affairs of the Union or of a State.’
99. This proviso was added following the benefit of reservation in promotion conferred upon SCs and STs alone. This proviso was inserted keeping in mind the judgment of this Court in S. Vinod Kumar (1996) 6 SCC 580 which took the view that relaxation in matters of reservation in promotion was not permissible under Article 16(4) in view of the command contained in Article 335. Once a separate category is carved out of clause (4) of Article 16 then that category is being given relaxation in matters of reservation in promotion. The proviso is confined to SCs and STs alone. The said proviso is compatible with the scheme of Article 16(4-A).”
7. The conclusions recorded by the Constitution Bench in M. Nagaraj (2006) 8 SCC 212 are also relevant and they read as under:
“121. The impugned constitutional amendments by which Articles 16(4-A) and 16(4-B) have been inserted flow from Article 16(4). They do not alter the structure of Article 16(4). They retain the controlling factors or the compelling reasons, namely, backwardness and inadequacy of representation which enables the States to provide for reservation keeping in mind the overall efficiency of the State administration under Article 335. These impugned amendments are confined only to SCs and STs. They do not obliterate any of the constitutional requirements, namely, ceiling limit of 50% (quantitative limitation), the concept of creamy layer (qualitative exclusion), the sub-classification between OBCs on one hand and SCs and STs on the other hand as held in Indra Sawhney 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217, (1992) 22 ATC 385, the concept of post-based roster with inbuilt concept of replacement as held in R.K Sabharwal (1995) 2 SCC 745, (1995) 29 ATC 481.
122. We reiterate that the ceiling limit of 50%, the concept of creamy layer and the compelling reasons, namely, backwardness, inadequacy of representation and overall administrative efficiency are all constitutional requirements without which the structure of equality of opportunity in Article 16 would collapse.
123. However, in this case, as stated above, the main issue concerns the ‘extent of reservation’. In this regard the State concerned will have to show in each case the existence of the compelling reasons, namely, backwardness, inadequacy of representation and overall administrative efficiency before making provision for reservation. As stated above, the impugned provision is an enabling provision. The State is not bound to make reservation for SCs/STs in matters of promotions. However, if they wish to exercise their discretion and make such provision, the State has to collect quantifiable data showing backwardness of the class and inadequacy of representation of that class in public employment in addition to compliance with Article 335. It is made clear that even if the State has compelling reasons, as stated above, the State will have to see that its reservation provision does not lead to excessiveness so as to breach the ceiling limit of 50% or obliterate the creamy layer or extend the reservation indefinitely.
124. Subject to the above, we uphold the constitutional validity of the Constitution (Seventy-seventh Amendment) Act, 1995; the Constitution (Eighty-first Amendment) Act, 2000; the Constitution (Eighty-second Amendment) Act, 2000 and the Constitution (Eighty-fifth Amendment) Act, 2001.”
8. We do not think it is necessary for us to deal with the width and scope of Article 16(4-A) any further. Insofar as Kuldeep Singh (1997) 9 SCC 199 is concerned, we find that the matter was decided by this Court having regard to the constitutional provision contained in Article 16(4-A). The view taken by this Court in Kuldeep Singh (1997) 9 SCC 199 is in accord with the constitutional scheme articulated in Article 16(4-A). On the other hand, in S. Vinod Kumar (1996) 6 SCC 580, the Court failed to consider Article 16(4-A). As a matter of fact, Article 16(4-A) was inserted in the Constitution to undo the observations in Indra Sawhney 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217, (1992) 22 ATC 385 that there cannot be a dilution of standards in matters of promotion.
9. We are in respectful agreement with the decision in Kuldeep Singh (1997) 9 SCC 199 and approve the same. Ordinarily, we would have sent the matter to the regular Bench for disposal of the matters but having regard to the nature of controversy and the fact that the Central Administrative Tribunal, Delhi (for short “the Tribunal”) has followed S. Vinod Kumar (1996) 6 SCC 580 which is not good law and resultantly the 1997 OM is also illegal, in our view, the agony of the appellants need not be prolonged as they are entitled to the reliefs.
10. Consequently, the civil appeals are allowed. The impugned order OAs Nos. 499 and 849 of 1998 is set aside. The 1997 OM is declared illegal. The respondents are directed to modify the results in the Section Officers/Stenographers (Grade B/Grade I) Limited Departmental Competitive Examination, 1996 by providing for reservation and extend all consequential reliefs to the appellants, if not granted so far. No costs.
Alert