Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sri Ram Builders v. State Of Madhya Pradesh And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Apr 25, 2014
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Indore Development Authority (IDA) leased 10 acres of land at Vijay Nagar, Indore, to the Madhya Pradesh Road Transport Corporation (MPRTC) on 2 November 1981 for 30 years, handing over possession on 22 January 1982 for construction of a bus-stand. In 2001 the State Cabinet permitted MPRTC to exploit such lands commercially under a Build-Own-Operate-Transfer (BOT) scheme to meet its liabilities. After an open tender, the appellant, Shri Ram Builders, emerged as the highest bidder; an agreement with MPRTC was executed on 4 February 2004, and substantial premium and consultancy amounts were paid.

Various permissions followed, but the Municipal Corporation withheld sanction owing to pending litigation. On 5 August 2005 the Madhya Pradesh High Court (WP 636/2005) directed MPRTC to hand over possession to the appellant upon payment of the balance premium, which the appellant duly deposited. MPRTC’s SLP against that order was dismissed in limine on 7 October 2005.

MPRTC nevertheless gave possession of the plot to the Transport Department for an RTO office, prompting contempt proceedings in which status quo was ordered. IDA then cancelled MPRTC’s lease on 2 November 2007 for violation of conditions. MPRTC challenged the cancellation (WP 6770/2007); the High Court, without notice to the appellant, referred the dispute to the State Chief Secretary. In a meeting of 4 March 2009 the Chief Secretary revoked IDA’s cancellation but also decided (i) that IDA would take back the land, and (ii) that all money received from the appellant would be refunded with interest.

The appellant assailed clauses (III)–(V) of the Chief Secretary’s decision in WP 2937/2009. On 27 September 2012 the High Court declined interference, directed refund with 9% interest, and relegated the appellant to civil remedies. Contempt and review petitions were closed accordingly. The present civil appeal challenges that judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court’s mandamus dated 5 August 2005 directing delivery of possession to the appellant survived subsequent events, including IDA’s cancellation of the lease and the Chief Secretary’s order of 4 March 2009.
  2. Whether the 30-year lease to MPRTC had expired by efflux of time on 21 January 2012, or could be deemed to continue/renew so as to sustain the appellant’s BOT rights.
  3. Whether writ jurisdiction under Article 226 could be invoked to compel specific performance of a commercial contract between private builder and a State corporation, or whether the appellant must pursue ordinary civil remedies.
  4. Scope and effect of a non-speaking dismissal of an SLP on the doctrine of merger and on the maintainability of review/recall applications in the High Court.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Shri Ram Builders)

  • Lease cancellation stood revoked by the Chief Secretary (clauses I & II); hence MPRTC’s obligations and the High Court’s 2005 directions revived.
  • Failure to challenge WP 6770/2007 was irrelevant; that order contained no adjudication on merits and merely mandated a decision by the Chief Secretary.
  • Review applications after dismissal of SLP were an abuse of process (citing Meghmala v. G. Narasimha Reddy).
  • Lease term should be counted from execution of the formal deed on 26 May 2004; alternatively, renewal was automatic under Clause 1, independent of State consent.
  • Doctrine of “self-induced frustration” prevents respondents from pleading impossibility based on their own decision to wind up MPRTC.
  • On equity and contractual rights, MPRTC must hand over possession and allow construction.

Indore Development Authority (Respondent 5)

  • No privity of contract existed with the appellant; any relief lies in a civil suit.
  • Lease commenced on 22 January 1982 and expired on 21 January 2012; renewal required fresh consent of both IDA and the State, which was neither sought nor granted.
  • MPRTC, as lessee, had no authority to create third-party commercial rights; BOT contract exceeded lease terms.
  • High Court’s 2005 order is not final—IDA was not a party, State recall applications are pending, and dismissal of SLP in limine causes no merger (citing Kunhayammed and Gangadhara Palo).
  • Court should decline interference in purely contractual/economic matters (citing Rajasthan Housing Board and Ramchandra Murarilal Bhattad).

M.P. Road Transport Corporation & State Authorities (Respondents 2–4)

The opinion does not set out their detailed independent submissions; their stance is reflected in IDA’s and the State’s positions.

Table of Precedents Cited

PrecedentRule or Principle Cited ForApplication by the Court
Meghmala v. G. Narasimha Reddy (2010) 8 SCC 383Abuse of process; maintainability of review after SLP dismissalReferenced by appellant to show recall applications were not maintainable.
DDA v. Durga Chand Kaushish (1973) 2 SCC 825Principles for construction of deeds—ascertain intention from disposition clauseCited to support appellant’s contention on lease commencement/interpretation.
Ramkishorelal v. Kamalnarayan (AIR 1963 SC 890)Same as above—construction of grantsRelied on by appellant for deed interpretation.
Sahebzada Mohammad Kamgarh Shah v. Jagdish Chandra Deo Dhabal Deb (AIR 1960 SC 953)Construction of deeds against grantorRelied on by appellant.
Provash Chandra Dalui v. Biswanath Banerjee 1989 Supp (1) SCC 487Effect of subsequent lease deed superseding earlier agreementUsed to argue renewal clause in agreement to lease was overridden.
State of U.P. v. Lalji Tandon (2004) 1 SCC 1Renewal and extension clauses distinguishedCited by appellant on lease renewal.
Boothalinga Agencies v. V.T.C. Poriaswami Nadar AIR 1969 SC 110Self-induced frustration cannot discharge contractAppellant invoked to resist frustration defence.
Hardesh Ores (P) Ltd. v. Hede & Co. (2007) 5 SCC 614Difference between “extension” and “renewal” of leasesRelied on by IDA to show renewal not automatic.
Kunhayammed v. State of Kerala (2000) 6 SCC 359Dismissal of SLP without reasons—no mergerAdopted by Court to hold 2005 High Court order did not merge with Supreme Court dismissal.
Gangadhara Palo v. Revenue Divl. Officer (2011) 4 SCC 602Same principle as KunhayammedReaffirmed absence of merger.
Tata Cellular v. Union of India (1994) 6 SCC 651Limits of judicial review in contractual mattersFormed basis for Court’s refusal to grant specific performance in writ.
Noble Resources Ltd. v. State of Orissa (2006) 10 SCC 236Specific performance ordinarily not granted in writ jurisdictionCited indirectly through Ramchandra Murarilal Bhattad.
Ramchandra Murarilal Bhattad v. State of Maharashtra (2007) 2 SCC 588Courts shouldn’t grant specific performance under Article 226 when damages sufficeRelied on to relegate appellant to civil suit.
Rajasthan Housing Board v. G.S. Investments (2007) 1 SCC 477Article 226 discretion should further public interestUsed to justify High Court’s refusal to intervene.
Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. v. State of Bihar (1986) 4 SCC 146Effect of non-speaking dismissal of SLPCited within discussion on merger doctrine.
Maritime National Fish Ltd. v. Ocean Trawlers Ltd. (1935 AC 524)Concept of self-induced frustrationDiscussed and distinguished.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court first addressed the effect of the Supreme Court’s 2005 non-speaking dismissal of MPRTC’s SLP. Applying Kunhayammed and Gangadhara Palo, it held that the High Court’s 5 August 2005 mandamus did not merge with the Supreme Court order and could be revisited.

It then observed that material events occurred after that mandamus: IDA’s lease cancellation (2 Nov 2007), the High Court’s referral to the Chief Secretary (11 Dec 2007), and the Chief Secretary’s composite decision (4 Mar 2009). The appellant accepted the referral, made representations, and only challenged parts of the Chief Secretary’s order; hence it could not now contest that authority’s jurisdiction.

On the lease question, the Court found:

  • Possession was delivered on 22 Jan 1982; under Rule 40 the lease period began then.
  • The maximum initial term expired on 21 Jan 2012; no application for renewal had been filed.
  • Clause 5(E) required IDA and State consent for renewal; such consent was absent, negating any automatic extension.

The Court rejected the appellant’s construction-of-deed arguments, found no privity of contract between the appellant and IDA, and held that MPRTC could not create third-party commercial rights beyond the lease. It further held that alleged frustration resulted from statutory events and lease expiry, not merely self-induced acts.

Invoking Tata Cellular, Ramchandra Murarilal Bhattad, and Rajasthan Housing Board, the bench stressed the limited scope of judicial review in commercial contracts. Specific performance or damages required a civil suit; writ jurisdiction was inappropriate.

Holding and Implications

Civil appeals dismissed.

The Supreme Court affirmed the High Court’s refusal to issue mandamus for specific performance and endorsed relegating the appellant to ordinary civil remedies. The decision leaves the appellant to claim damages or seek contractual relief in a civil court; it sets no new precedent but reiterates existing principles on merger, lease renewal, frustration, and the limits of judicial review in contractual matters.

Show all summary ...

Surinder Singh Nijjar, J.— Leave granted.

2. Civil Appeal No. 4896 of 2014 arising out of SLP (C) No. 35001 of 2012 impugning the judgment of the M.P High Court at Jabalpur rendered in Shri Ram Builders v. State of M.P WP No. 2937 of 2009 The writ petition has been disposed of along with Review Application MCC No. 99 of 2009 and MCC No. 893 of 2008 as well as Contempt Petition No. 469 of 2008. The writ petition has been disposed of with certain directions, whereas the aforesaid contempt petition and the two review petitions have been disposed of in view of the order passed in Shri Ram Builders v. State of M.P WP No. 2937 of 2009

3. The relevant facts leading to the filing of the aforesaid SLP are as follows: In 1979, Respondent 2, Madhya Pradesh Road Transport Corpn. (hereinafter referred to as “M.P RTC”) proposed to construct a bus-stand at Vijay Nagar, Indore. To this end, an agreement for lease dated 2-11-1981 was entered into between the Transport Corporation and Respondent 5, Indore Development Authority (hereinafter referred to as “IDA”), by which the land belonging to IDA, admeasuring 10 acres situated at Vijay Nagar, Indore (hereinafter referred to as “the proposed site”) was agreed to be allotted to the Transport Corporation, initially, for 30 years. In pursuance of the lease agreement, possession of the proposed site was handed over to M.P RTC.

4. The Council of Ministers, State of Madhya Pradesh, vide order dated 8-11-2001, authorised the Transport Corporation to construct a commercial complex on the land owned by it or allotted to it on lease, under a Build, Own-Operate and Transfer (BOT) Scheme through open tenders. The revenue generated from the said project(s) was to be used to discharge the liability of M.P RTC.

5. On 13-4-2003, a notice inviting bids for selection of a developer under the BOT Scheme was issued and published in the leading newspapers. In response to this notice, a total number of ten applications were received, and out of those ten applications, five were found to have satisfied the eligibility criteria. The appellant was placed at Sl. No. 1 in the list of the candidates satisfying the eligibility criteria. Thereafter, a Special Committee was constituted for the scrutiny of tenders received for construction of the bus-stand/commercial premises under the BOT Scheme. On 3-7-2003, the Special Committee recommended that since the premium amount offered by the bidders was less, further negotiations be held with all the qualified bidders. Accordingly, the Special Committee held negotiations with the qualified bidders on 7-7-2003, wherein the appellant's bid for the BOT Scheme was found to be the highest.

6. M.P RTC, after scrutiny of the financial bid and the proposal submitted by the appellant for the BOT Scheme, approved its bid vide acceptance letter dated 3-10-2003. In the acceptance letter, the appellant was directed to deposit 25% amount of the total premium amount of rupees one crore sixteen lakh thirty-seven thousand seven hundred and fifty (Rs 1,16,37,750) within 15 days of the issuance of the acceptance letter. Accordingly, the appellant deposited the first instalment of Rs 1,16,37,750. The appellant also has to pay a further sum of Rs 7,33,320 demanded by M.P RTC as consultancy fees.

7. In pursuance of the acceptance letter, an agreement dated 4-2-2004 was entered into between the appellant and M.P RTC. This agreement inter alia provided that the tender document with scope of work general conditions, special conditions, general specifications, list of brands and offer price bid shall form part of the agreement.

8. M.P RTC issued a work order dated 16-3-2004 to the appellant for demolishing the existing structure on the land; to be replaced by the commercial complex. On 11-5-2004, the State Government issued a notification, in exercise of powers under Sections 35(2) and 35(3) of the Madhya Pradesh Nagar Tatha Gram Nivesh Adhiniyam, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as “the Adhiniyam”), by which out of 10 acres of land at Vijay Nagar which had been earmarked for the bus-stand (proposed site), 3.59 acres of land was permitted to be used for commercial purposes.

9. On 14-5-2004, the appellant requested M.P RTC to hand over the possession of the proposed site, so that the structure existing thereon could be demolished and new bus-stand-cum-commercial complex could be constructed, in accordance with the terms and conditions of the tender/agreement.

10. On 27-5-2004, a lease deed was executed in favour of M.P RTC by IDA upon payment of Rs 24,27,052 by the appellant. This payment was made by the appellant in order to let the Transport Corporation pay its arrears to IDA. Subsequently on 24-6-2004, IDA gave a no-objection certificate (NOC) to M.P RTC for the proposed BOT project. Also, the Deputy Director, Town and Country Planning granted approval to M.P RTC for the construction of the bus-stand and commercial complex.

11. On 28-6-2004, Writ Petition No. 801 of 2004 came to be filed by one Suresh Seth, before the Indore Bench of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh, assailing the Notification dated 11-5-2004. By this notification, as observed earlier, reservation of land use of 3.59 acres was changed by the State Government. The High Court, vide order dated 9-9-2004, sought reports from the State Government as well as M.P RTC and IDA. In their respective reports, the State Government, M.P RTC and IDA stated that the said BOT project was in public interest and justified the Notification dated 11-5-2004. Meanwhile on 6-1-2005, the Joint Director, Town and Country Planning sanctioned the detailed site plan of proposed BOT project. The appellant also applied to Municipal Corporation, Indore for sanction of the building plan, but the same was not granted on the ground that Writ Petition No. 801 of 2004 was pending before the High Court.

12. On 23-2-2005, IDA issued a certificate indicating therein that in respect of the proposed BOT project, premium as well as 15 years' lease rent had already been deposited. On the basis of the above, IDA indicated that there shall be no objection, if the land in question is mortgaged with any bank, financial institution or the Government.

13. In the meanwhile, there was a move by the State Government for closure of M.P RTC. In this context, the Government of India granted no-objection to the State Government on 23-3-2005, subject to the condition that the State Government shall ensure and be fully responsible for ensuring compliance with any existing/future order(s) passed by various courts, including tribunals, in any/all matters relating to M.P RTC.

14. The appellant filed Writ Petition No. 636 of 2005 in the High Court seeking a direction to M.P RTC to immediately hand over possession of the land in question to the appellant and grant permission to demolish the existing structure. On 5-8-2005 WP No. 636 of 2005, Writ Petition No. 636 of 2005 was disposed of by the High Court with the following directions:

(i) That the petitioner shall deposit the entire balance amount within a period of one month along with interest @ 18% per annum, w.e.f July 2004 when the second instalment became due.
(ii) Upon depositing the entire amount the respondent shall hand over the vacant possession to the petitioner, within two weeks, with a permission, to demolish the structure as per the agreement. The respondent shall also pursue the matter with the Municipal Corporation to hand over all parts of the premises, which are in their occupation.
(iii) The respondent shall deposit the map for sanction before the competent authorities immediately, if not submitted, so far. In case the map has already been submitted the respondent shall give the authority to the petitioner, to pursue the matter before the competent authorities for obtaining the permission and shall extend all the assistance for the purpose of obtaining permission.
(iv) After taking possession, the petitioner shall construct and hand over the construction property to the respondent as per the terms of the tender notice/agreement.
(v) The competent authorities shall consider the application of the respondent for permission and shall grant the permission in accordance with law.

The appellant deposited Rs 2,95,03,752 towards premium and a further sum of Rs 27,53,536 towards interest to M.P RTC, in terms of the aforesaid order. Thereafter, again, the appellant requested the respondents herein to hand over the possession of the proposed site to the appellant. A notice was issued by the appellant to M.P RTC dated 12-9-2005, requesting to hand over possession of the land, in terms of the directions of the High Court dated 5-8-2005 WP No. 636 of 2005.

15. At that stage, the Principal Secretary, Transport Department, Respondent 2 herein, recorded a note dated 15-9-2005, questioning the justification for constructing bus-stand and observed that the construction was not in public interest, particularly when a decision had been taken by the State Government to wind up M.P RTC. Soon thereafter, M.P RTC filed Special Leave Petition No. 20038 of 2005 before this Court challenging the order dated 5-8-2005 WP No. 636 of 2005 passed by the High Court. This SLP was dismissed by this Court vide order dated 7-10-2005 SLP (C) 20038 of 2005, (2014) 14 SCC 102 (F3).

16. Possession of the proposed site still not having been delivered, the appellant filed Contempt Petition No. 466 of 2005 (renumbered as Contempt Petition No. 469 of 2008) before the High Court of Madhya Pradesh. In this contempt petition, the appellant moved an application for injunction on 11-11-2005 (IA No. 1060 of 2005) restraining M.P RTC from handing over the possession of the proposed site to the State Government for establishing the regional transport office. The High Court on 14-11-2005, directed M.P RTC to maintain status quo and not to hand over the possession of the proposed site or to create any third-party interest. In spite of the aforesaid order, the possession of the proposed site was handed over by M.P RTC to the Transport Department on 16-11-2005, for opening the RTO. A test centre for driving licences has been established on the land meant for the commercial complex.

17. In the meantime, the State of Madhya Pradesh moved an application, MCC No. 1072 of 2005, before the High Court, seeking recall of the order dated 5-8-2005 passed in Shree Ram Builders v. M.P RTC WP No. 636 of 2005. M.P RTC also filed MCC No. 5 of 2006, seeking identical relief i.e recall of order dated 5-8-2005 WP No. 636 of 2005. It was claimed that a decision had been taken by the M.P State Government to wind up M.P RTC. On 23-3-2005, M.P RTC had been issued a notice of demand for recovery of Rs 2387 crores as tax dues. The property earmarked for the commercial complex, was one of the properties seized by the State authorities on 19-7-2005. Since the possession was already taken by the State, no direction for delivery of possession to the appellant could have been issued on 5-8-2005 WP No. 636 of 2005. These facts could not be placed before the High Court, as the State was not impleaded as a party in Writ Petition No. 636 of 2005.

18. Thereafter, the appellant moved IA No. 7064 of 2006 in the contempt petition before the High Court to implead the Transport Department, Respondent 2 herein, as a respondent in the contempt petition. This IA was allowed by the High Court by order dated 6-10-2006. During the course of hearing of this contempt petition, the appellant moved another IA No. 6906 of 2007, seeking a direction to the respondents to place on record the following:

“1. (a) On what date and by which inward number the order of the Government directing the RTO, Indore to attach the M.P RTC property at Indore was received by RTO, Indore pursuant to which the so-called attachment dated 9-7-2005 was made?
(b) On what date, by which letter number, and under what dispatch number the fact of attachment and acquisition of property/land was sent by RTO, Indore to the State Government (original letters, original dispatch register). And on what date, by which inward number, this information was received?”

According to the appellant, the respondents could not furnish the said information to the Court, despite having sought a number of opportunities in that regard.

19. Meanwhile on 2-11-2007, IDA cancelled the lease of M.P RTC for violation of the lease terms by running the RTO. Cancellation of the lease was challenged by M.P RTC through Writ Petition No. 6770 of 2007 in the High Court of Madhya Pradesh. On 11-12-2007 WP No. 6770 of 2007, the High Court without issuing notice to the appellant, who was impleaded as Respondent 3, disposed of the writ petition with the following observations:

“When two instrumentalities of the State, such as in the present case, choose to bring their disputes in open court, the loss is of the general public. The public confidence in the credibility of the State Government and its various wings/functionaries and its instrumentalities comes at stake.
In these circumstances, I do not find that this Court should continue with the proceedings in the present petition. I deem it appropriate to request the Chief Secretary, State of Madhya Pradesh, to take up the matter at his level and after holding a meeting with the Principal Secretary, Transport Department, Principal Secretary, Housing and Environment Department and the Managing Director of the M.P Road Transport Corpn. Ltd. take such further action, as may be deemed appropriate, in the facts and circumstances of the case. However, the Chief Secretary shall ensure that the officers of the State Government and various other instrumentalities of the State Government are not allowed to bring out their inter se disputes in public in future.”
(emphasis supplied)

20. On 17-11-2008, the Central Government, Department of Transport and Highways informed the State Government of Madhya Pradesh that the request for permission for closure of M.P RTC under the provisions of the Road Transport Corporation Act, for which earlier no-objection had been given, was being declined keeping in view the decision of Ministry of Labour and Employment, and that it would now have to continue its current operations.

21. The appellant submitted representation dated 20-2-2009, wherein attention of the Chief Secretary was drawn to the pendency of the review petitions filed by the State of Madhya Pradesh and M.P RTC; and the contempt petition filed by the appellant and the order passed therein, whereby status quo was ordered to be maintained.

22. In spite of the aforesaid representation, Respondent 1 held the meeting on 4-3-2009 as directed by the High Court, wherein it was inter alia decided as under:

“(I) Order dated 2-11-2007 and notice dated 30-6-2007 for cancellation of lease of the land in question of the Transport Corporation by IDA be cancelled.
(II) RTO be ordered for releasing the land by the Transport Department for attachment.
(III) The M.P Road Transport Corporation shall hand over land in question to IDA.
(IV) The amount which has been received by the Transport Corporation from Shri Ram Builders shall be returned along with interest to Shri Ram Builders.
(V) Decision with respect to further use and management of the land shall be taken by IDA.”

23. Aggrieved by Clauses (III), (IV) and (V) of the aforesaid decision, the appellant preferred Writ Petition No. 2937 of 2009 before the High Court of Madhya Pradesh. It was inter alia contended that the directions in the aforesaid clauses were in violation of order dated 5-8-2005 WP No. 636 of 2005 of the High Court and in violation of the principles of natural justice.

24. The High Court disposed of the writ petition on 27-9-2012 WP No. 2937 of 2009 with the following observations:

“15. The order dated 5-8-2005 passed in Shree Ram Builders v. M.P RTC WP No. 636 of 2005 directing the corporation to deliver possession of site to the petitioner cannot be implemented after the lease deed was cancelled by IDA. It is this cancellation which became the subject-matter of Writ Petition No. 6770 of 2007 and the writ petition was decided vide order dated 11-12-2007 WP No. 6770 of 2007 by another Single Judge Bench directing the Chief Secretary for resolving the dispute.
As already mentioned above, the petitioner did not challenge the order dated 11-12-2007 WP No. 6770 of 2007 and submitted a detailed representation dated 20-2-2009 to the Chief Secretary. The impugned decision taken by the Chief Secretary is in pursuance of the directions given by the High Court in Writ Petition No. 6770 of 2007 in which the petitioner was also a party. There is, thus, no violation of the principles of natural justice.
The decision reached by the Chief Secretary directs that the entire amount paid by the petitioner be returned to it with interest. The decision does not fix the rate of interest but we feel that 9% will be the proper interest having regard to all the circumstances. In view of the direction to return the amount with interest, as decided by us, there would be apparently no loss to the petitioner. The respondents are directed to return the amount with interest within four months from today. If the petitioner still feels that there has been a breach of contract, it can pursue the remedy of specific performance or damages before a competent civil court.
We, therefore, decline to interfere with the decision of the Chief Secretary except fixing the rate of interest, as indicated above.”

25. In view of the aforesaid directions, the High Court also disposed of Contempt Petition No. 469 of 2008, review applications MCC No. 99 of 2009 and MCC No. 893 of 2008 without any further directions.

26. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties.

27. Mr R.F Nariman and Mr P.S Patwalia, learned Senior Counsel, appearing for the appellant submitted that the reasoning adopted by the High Court in para 15 of the impugned judgment WP No. 2937 of 2009, which has been reproduced above, was not even supported by the respondents:

27.1 The first reason given by the High Court is that the order dated 5-8-2005 in Shree Ram Builders v. M.P RTC WP No. 636 of 2005 cannot be implemented after cancellation of lease deed by IDA. This, according to the learned Senior Counsel, is without any basis as by the order dated 4-3-2009, the Chief Secretary had cancelled the order of cancellation of the lease deed. Therefore, the order dated 2-11-2007 having been nullified, the lease in favour of M.P RTC revived. This would also revive the obligation of M.P RTC to carry out the agreement with the appellant.

27.2 The second reason given by the High Court, according to Mr Nariman and Mr Patwalia is that the order dated 11-12-2007 passed in M.P RTC v. Indore Development Authority WP No. 6770 of 2007 was not challenged by the appellant, cannot be supported in law. It is pointed out by the learned Senior Counsel that the aforesaid writ petition was filed by M.P RTC challenging the order of cancelling the deed in its favour by IDA. The appellant was not at all involved in the aforesaid lis. In any event, the High Court had not passed any order on merits. It had merely left it for the Chief Secretary to decide the issue. Therefore, no cause had arisen to the appellant to challenge the order dated 11-12-2007 WP No. 6770 of 2007. It is further pointed out that the Chief Secretary in fact decided the substance of the writ petition. Substance of the grievance raised in the writ petition was decided in favour of M.P RTC by setting aside the order of cancellation of the lease by IDA. It is pointed out by the learned Senior Counsel that IDA has not challenged the order of the Chief Secretary cancelling the direction of IDA with regard to the cancellation of the lease.

28. The learned Senior Counsel further submitted that the Chief Secretary was expected to take a decision in accordance with law i.e in accordance with the order of the High Court that has become final and binding and not contrary to that. Furthermore, the order of the Chief Secretary on Directions (III), (IV) and (V), which affect the rights of the appellant was challenged in the writ petition in which the impugned judgment WP No. 2937 of 2009 has been passed. According to the appellant, Directions (I) and (II) were correct and, therefore, there were no occasion to challenge the same. Directions (III), (IV) and (V) are contrary to Directions (I) and (II) and were beyond the scope of the controversy raised in Writ Petition No. 6770 of 2007, which had been referred to the Chief Secretary by the High Court. The order of the Secretary has been passed without issuing any notice to the appellant, even though in the writ petition, the appellant was impleaded as Respondent 3. It is pointed out by the learned Senior Counsel that by way of abundant caution, the appellant has challenged the order dated 11-12-2007, passed in M.P RTC v. Indore Development Authority WP No. 6770 of 2007 in SLP (C) No. 36887 of 2012.

29. Next it was submitted by the learned Senior Counsel that the actions of Madhya Pradesh Road Transport Corpn. (Respondent 3) are in gross contempt of the orders dated 5-8-2005 WP No. 636 of 2005, which have not been purged till date. The aforesaid order has become final after the dismissal of SLP (C) No. 20038 of 2005 on 7-10-2005 SLP (C) 20038 of 2005, (2014) 14 SCC 102 (F3). It is submitted that the review petition MCC No. 99 of 2009 filed on 2-1-2006 after dismissal of the aforesaid SLP on 7-10-2005 SLP (C) 20038 of 2005, (2014) 14 SCC 102 (F3) is an abuse of process and not maintainable. In support of this submission, the learned Senior Counsel relies on Meghmala v. G. Narasimha Reddy (2010) 8 SCC 383 (paras 25 and 26). Similarly, the review petition MCC No. 893 of 2008 is not maintainable for the same reason. In any event, the review petition was not decided on merits, which was disposed of in view of the impugned order passed in the writ petition with regard to the cancellation of the lease.

30. Thereafter, very detailed submissions have been made on the construction of the lease deed. However, it must be noticed here that the manner in which these submissions have been advanced before us bear no resemblance to the manner in which these submissions were made before the High Court.

31. Mr R.F Nariman has also submitted that the term of lease has to be understood to have commenced from 26-5-2004, when IDA executed a formal lease in favour of M.P RTC. Further, the learned Senior Counsel submitted that the possession of the site in terms of the lease cannot be held to be given on 22-1-1982, when the agreement to lease was executed. It was further submitted that where a literal reading of the lease leads to an absurdity, the court has the power to read it reasonably. Such a reasonable reading, according to Mr Nariman, would support the aforesaid submission i.e the lease commences from 26-5-2004. In this context, the learned Senior Counsel relies upon the following cases: DDA v. Durga Chand Kaushish (1973) 2 SCC 825; Ramkishorelal v. Kamalnarayan AIR 1963 SC 890, 1963 Supp (2) SCR 417 and Sahebzada Mohammad Kamgarh Shah v. Jagdish Chandra Deo Dhabal Deb AIR 1960 SC 953, (1960) 3 SCR 604. These cases reiterate the well-established principles of law relating to the construction of deeds, which are as follows: first, that the intention of the parties to a grant must be ascertained first and foremost from the disposition clause. Second, clear disposition by an earlier clause will not be allowed to be cut down by a later clause; and third, that a deed, being a grantor's document, has to be interpreted strictly against him and in favour of the grantee.

32. Mr Nariman also submitted that the respondents cannot rely upon Clause 5(E) of the agreement to lease, after the execution of the lease deed. Substantiating this, it was submitted that the renewal clause in the agreement to lease stood superseded by the express terms of the lease deed dated 26-5-2004. In this context, he relied upon Provash Chandra Dalui v. Biswanath Banerjee 1989 Supp (1) SCC 487 and State of U.P v. Lalji Tandon (2004) 1 SCC 1.

33. Further, according to Mr Nariman, the terms of the agreement to lease cannot be relied upon when a specific provision has been provided in the lease deed itself, which provides for extension of the lease. Clause 1 of the lease enables IDA to extend the lease for which neither the renewal nor permission of the State Government is necessary.

34. The argument of the respondents that the agreement of M.P RTC with the appellant has been frustrated was sought to be countered by Mr Nariman. It was submitted that self-induced frustration cannot be a basis to frustrate a valid agreement. In this context, it was contended that the submission of the respondents that M.P RTC is being wound up is not tenable since such winding up is the result of an act of the party itself. Reliance was placed upon Boothalinga Agencies v. V.T.C Poriaswami Nadar AIR 1969 SC 110, (1969) 1 SCR 65 at p. 79, wherein it was inter alia held that: (AIR p. 118, para 14)

“14. … The doctrine of frustration of contract cannot apply where the event which is alleged to have frustrated the contract arises from the act or election of a party.”

It was also contended that commercial exigencies can never lead to frustration. Reliance was placed upon Pollock and Mulla, 14th Edn., pp. 887-89.

35. Mr Nariman also submitted that the submission of IDA that the appellant has no privity of contract with the petitioner is not correct. Further, the submission of IDA that the agreement to lease was only for a bus-stand and no permission was granted by IDA to M.P RTC for constructing a commercial project has been submitted to be incorrect by Mr Nariman. Another factual submission advanced by the appellant is that the submission of the respondents that M.P RTC is being wound up is not correct. Lastly, Mr Nariman contended that on the balance of equity, M.P RTC ought to be directed to comply with the directions of the High Court contained in the order dated 5-8-2005 WP No. 636 of 2005, and put the appellant in possession of the plot.

36. Mr J.P Cama, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the fifth respondent, Indore Development Authority has submitted that by an agreement dated 2-11-1981, IDA entered into a lease in respect of 10 acres of his property situated in its Scheme No. 54 at Indore in favour of M.P RTC. Possession of the land was handed over on 22-1-1982. The first instalment of the premium and leased rent was deposited on 3-10-1980. The lease was to be for a period of 30 years subject to renewal. The lease was to subsist in the first instance up to 21-1-2012 but was terminated on 2-1-2007 i.e before the expiry of the period of 30 years from the date of possession. M.P RTC had challenged the aforesaid decision in Writ Petition No. 6770 of 2007. Since the appellant had no privity of contract with IDA, it could not have challenged the termination of the lease on 2-7-2007 and did not do so. Since the dispute was between two government organisations, the High Court rightly remitted the matter to the Chief Secretary of the State of Madhya Pradesh for resolution. Even though the appellant was not a party to the aforesaid writ petition filed by M.P RTC, it had submitted a representation on 22-2-2009. The directions issued by the Chief Secretary were challenged in Writ Petition No. 2937 of 2009 in which the impugned judgment WP No. 2937 of 2009 has been passed.

37. The submissions of Mr Cama in brief are:

37.1 That there was no privity of contract between IDA and Shri Ram Builders i.e the appellant. Therefore, the High Court has rightly granted liberty to the appellant to file a civil suit, if so advised.

37.2 The cancellation of the lease by IDA has become final. This has not been challenged by the appellant. Therefore, no mandamus can be issued to IDA, to permit the appellant to construct the bus-stand and commercial-cum-residential complex. Mr Cama further submitted that the lease commences from 22-1-1982 when possession was handed over and expired on 21-1-2012 upon completion of 30 years' period of the lease. It is further submitted that M.P RTC cannot claim automatic renewal of the lease. It would be subject to the consent of IDA and the State Government. No application had been filed for such extension. In any event, the lease has come to an end by the efflux of time.

37.3 Mr Cama further submitted that IDA had given a lease in favour of M.P RTC. Under the said lease, M.P RTC had no authority to create further third-party rights. Wrongly, according to Mr Cama, M.P RTC under the tender conditions/contract entered into with the appellant had given it the right to sell proposed commercial premises, and to collect premium on such allotment from prospective buyers. M.P RTC had only been given NOC for completing the bus-stand and the commercial-cum-residential complex on BOT basis. M.P RTC had no legal right, being a sub-lessee higher than the lessee.

37.4 The next submission of Mr Cama is that M.P RTC has completely wound up its operations; they have sold all their buses. Therefore, it cannot be compelled to get the bus-stand constructed from the appellant.

37.5 Countering the submission of Mr Nariman and Mr Patwalia, he submits that the order of the High Court dated 5-8-2005 WP No. 636 of 2005 directing M.P RTC to hand over the possession to the appellant cannot be relied upon by the appellant, the said order has not become final inasmuch as:

(i) IDA was not a party in the said proceedings;
(ii) The High Court had not decided the matter in relating to lease of IDA;
(iii) The State Government had filed recall application which was pending disposal before the High Court;
(iv) Even M.P RTC filed a recall application wherein they pleaded that the entire order was based on the statement made by their counsel that they are not in a position to pay Shri Ram Builders, however, they made a statement, in recall application that they are now willing to repay Shri Ram and hence prayed for recall of order dated 5-8-2005 WP No. 636 of 2005—which was also pending;
(v) Where SLP is dismissed without giving reasons, there is no merger of the judgment of the High Court with the order of the Supreme Court. Hence judgment of the High Court can be reviewed, even after dismissal of SLP. Reliance was placed upon Gangadhara Palo v. Revenue Divl. Officer (2011) 4 SCC 602.

38. It is submitted that construction of bus terminal on BOT basis was a commercial transaction between M.P RTC and the appellant. Even if the cancellation is not legal, this Court will not interfere in this decision as it was purely contractual in nature. He relies on the judgments of this Court in Rajasthan Housing Board v. G.S Investments (2007) 1 SCC 477 and Ramchandra Murarilal Bhattad v. State of Maharashtra (2007) 2 SCC 588.

39. It is submitted that the argument of the appellant that the lease, which was granted in the first instance for 30 years was intended to continue (automatically) for a further period of 30 years in terms of Clause 1 of the aforesaid lease deed is untenable. Even otherwise the submission cannot be considered as there were no pleadings to this effect either in the original petition or in the grounds of SLP. In any event, according to the respondents, the initial period of the lease was for 30 years. Furthermore, Para/Clause 5(E) of the agreement to lease makes it clear that after termination of the lease period, it can be extended after renewal; that too only with the consent of M.P RTC and IDA and further obtaining sanction of the State Government.

40. According to Mr Cama, two short questions would arise, namely:

40.1 From what date, is the period of 30 years to be counted?

40.2 Whether there is an automatic extension of lease?

41. According to Mr Cama, admittedly possession of the property was given to M.P RTC on 21-1-1982. This premium, as well as the first lease rent had been deposited on 3-10-1980. It is also an admitted position that the lease rent for the entire period of 1982 onwards has in fact been paid by deposit of premium plus 15 years' lease rent. It is reiterated by Mr Cama that admitted date of actual possession by the lessor is 22-1-1982. Therefore, the first period of lease expired by efflux of time on 21-1-2012. With regard to the renewal of the lease, it is submitted that even such renewal is on specific sanction of IDA and the State Government. He submits that the concept of extension of the lease is distinguishable from the concept of renewal. In support of this submission, Mr Cama relies on Hardesh Ores (P) Ltd. v. Hede and Co. (2007) 5 SCC 614 (pp. 627 and 628). He submitted that the agreement of lease used both words “extension” and “renewal” but “extension” is always made subject to renewal. Mr Cama further pointed out that order dated 5-8-2005 WP No. 636 of 2005 has not become final and binding on all parties on the dismissal of SLP filed by M.P RTC. The aforesaid SLP was dismissed in limine. Therefore, the judgment of the High Court cannot be said to have merged with the order of this Court. In support of the submission, Mr Cama relies on Kunhayammed v. State of Kerala (2000) 6 SCC 359 and Gangadhara Palo v. Revenue Divl. Officer (2011) 4 SCC 602 (Para 7).

42. With regard to the submission relating to the order passed by the Chief Secretary, Mr Cama submits that the appellant has to either accept or challenge the order in toto. If the complete order is accepted, the termination of the lease is set aside, the property would return to IDA with compensation to the appellant. In the event, the order is completely set aside, the termination of the lease remains in force and the property returns to IDA. In either case, the land returns to IDA. Mr Cama submits that the order passed by the Chief Secretary is a comprehensive order and cannot be permitted to be challenged in a truncated manner.

43. We have considered the submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties.

44. Before we proceed to examine the submissions made by Mr Nariman, it would be appropriate to cull out the bare essential facts for the determination of the controversy herein. A lease deed dated 2-11-1981 was entered into between M.P RTC and IDA. The possession of the land was handed over to M.P RTC on 22-1-1982. Initially, the lease was taken by M.P RTC for the purpose of a bus-stand. It appears that no final decision was taken till 8-11-2001 when the Council of Ministers of the State Government authorised the construction of a commercial complex on the land under BOT Scheme. A tender notice was issued on 13-4-2002. On 7-7-2003, the bid of the appellant was found to be the highest. The amount as mentioned in Para 6 earlier, was duly paid by the appellant. A separate agreement was entered into between M.P RTC and the appellant on 4-2-2004 which read along with the tender document provided as under:

“The successful promoters/builders will have the right to market the saleable space made available to him on different floors in the commercial complex, collect premium on such allotment from prospective buyers.”

45. On 25-5-2004, M.P RTC deposited the lease rental with IDA. A formal lease was executed on 26-5-2004. As noticed earlier, the lease was for 30 years. The leased land (plot) was to be used only for the bus terminal. It was specifically provided that the plot cannot be divided. The possession of the plot had been received on 22-1-1982. The lease also provided that the Rules published in the gazette on 16-12-1977 shall be binding on the lessee. Rule 40 of the aforesaid Niyam/Rules read as under:

“40. The lessee may take possession of the plot on the date fixed or notified to him for taking over possession of the plot and the lease of the plot shall commence from the date irrespective of the fact whatsoever, possession of the plot has been taken or not and the lessee shall pay all rates and taxes where leviable the owner or the lessee from the date.”

46. On 24-6-2004, IDA gave its no objection for bus terminal-cum-commercial complex to be constructed under the BOT Scheme. On 18-12-2005, the State Government decided to wind up M.P RTC. The proposal of the State Government was not approved by the Ministry of Shipping and Road Transport, Government of India. On 17-11-2008, a letter was issued informing the State Government that the Ministry of Labour had declined to grant permission for closure under Section 25-O of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.

47. On 5-8-2005 WP No. 636 of 2005, directions were issued by the High Court in the writ petition filed by the appellant. SLP filed against these directions was dismissed by this Court on 7-10-2005 SLP (C) 20038 of 2005, (2014) 14 SCC 102 (F3). In the contempt petition filed by the appellant for non-compliance with the directions of the High Court dated 5-8-2005 WP No. 636 of 2005, M.P RTC was restrained from handing over the possession of the property or to create third-party interest/rights.

48. On 2-11-2007, the lease was cancelled by IDA on the ground that M.P RTC had violated the prescribed conditions by handing over the possession to RTO. As noticed earlier, the cancellation of the lease was challenged by M.P RTC, by way of a writ petition, which was disposed of by the High Court on 11-12-2007 WP No. 6770 of 2007 by referring the entire issue to the Chief Secretary. The appellant did not challenge the order dated 2-11-2007 but submitted to the jurisdiction of the Chief Secretary by filing a comprehensive representation. Even in the writ petition in which the impugned order had been passed, the appellant had only challenged Clauses (III), (IV) and (V) of the order of the Chief Secretary.

49. We shall now consider the submissions of Mr Nariman, seriatim. Can the order dated 5-8-2005 WP No. 636 of 2005 be implemented and should the appellant be permitted to go ahead with the construction of the commercial complex-cum-bus-stand? Undoubtedly, the SLP filed by M.P RTC against the order dated 5-8-2005 in Shree Ram Builders v. M.P RTC WP No. 636 of 2005 has been dismissed by this Court, but it was a dismissal in limine without recording any reason. Therefore, the judgment of the High Court cannot be said to have merged with the order of this Court. In Kunhayammed (2000) 6 SCC 359, this Court considered the effect of the dismissal of the SLP in limine. This Court reiterated the ratio laid down by this Court in Indian Oil Corpn. Ltd. v. State of Bihar (1986) 4 SCC 146 which considered the impact of the order dismissing the SLP with the following expression:

“3. … The special leave petition is dismissed.”

50. Considering the aforesaid order of this Court in Indian Oil Corpn. Ltd. (1986) 4 SCC 146, it has been observed as follows:

“6. … the effect of a non-speaking order of dismissal of a special leave petition without anything more indicating the grounds or reasons of its dismissal must, by necessary implication, be taken to be that this Court had decided only that it was not a fit case where special leave should be granted. This conclusion may have been reached by this Court due to several reasons. When the order passed by this Court was not a speaking one, it is not correct to assume that this Court had necessarily decided implicitly all the questions in relation to the merits of the award, which was under challenge before this Court in the special leave petition. A writ proceeding is a wholly different and distinct proceeding. Questions which can be said to have been decided by this Court expressly, implicitly or even constructively while dismissing the special leave petition cannot, of course, be reopened in a subsequent writ proceeding before the High Court. But neither on the principle of res judicata nor on any principle of public policy analogous thereto, would the order of this Court dismissing the special leave petition operate to bar the trial of identical issues in a separate proceeding namely, the writ proceeding before the High Court merely on the basis of an uncertain assumption that the issues must have been decided by this Court at least by implication. It is not correct or safe to extend the principle of res judicata or constructive res judicata to such an extent so as to found it on mere guesswork.
(emphasis supplied)

51. In reiterating the aforesaid observation, this Court in Kunhayammed (2000) 6 SCC 359 observed as follows:

“27. A petition for leave to appeal to this Court may be dismissed by a non-speaking order or by a speaking order. Whatever be the phraseology employed in the order of dismissal, if it is a non-speaking order, i.e, it does not assign reasons for dismissing the special leave petition, it would neither attract the doctrine of merger so as to stand substituted in place of the order put in issue before it nor would it be a declaration of law by the Supreme Court under Article 141 of the Constitution for there is no law which has been declared.”

52. The aforesaid ratio in Kunhayammed (2000) 6 SCC 359 is reiterated by this Court in Gangadhara Palo (2011) 4 SCC 602: (Gangadhara Palo case (2011) 4 SCC 602)

“7. The situation is totally different where a special leave petition is dismissed without giving any reasons whatsoever. It is well settled that special leave under Article 136 of the Constitution of India is a discretionary remedy, and hence a special leave petition can be dismissed for a variety of reasons and not necessarily on merits. We cannot say what was in the mind of the Court while dismissing the special leave petition without giving any reasons. Hence, when a special leave petition is dismissed without giving any reasons, there is no merger of the judgment of the High Court with the order of this Court.”

53. Even though the order of the High Court had not merged with the order passed by this Court in dismissing the SLP, can the appellant be deprived of the benefit of the order passed by the High Court on 5-8-2005 WP No. 636 of 2005?

54. Mr Nariman has submitted that the order passed by the Chief Secretary on 4-3-2009 even though on directions issued by the High Court in M.P RTC v. Indore Development Authority WP No. 6770 of 2007 cannot nullify the directions given by the High Court earlier. The order passed by the Chief Secretary in its executive capacity cannot have the effect of nullifying the order passed by the High Court on 5-8-2005 WP No. 636 of 2005.

55. On first blush, the submission made by Mr Nariman seems to be very attractive, but factually it has to be noticed that much more water has flown under the bridge since the passing of the order dated 5-8-2005 WP No. 636 of 2005. Subsequently, the lease to M.P RTC was cancelled on 2-11-2007 by IDA. The appellant did not challenge the order dated 2-11-2007 passed by IDA. The aforesaid order was challenged by M.P RTC in M.P RTC v. Indore Development Authority WP No. 6770 of 2007. On 11-12-2007, the High Court without issuing notice to the appellant, who was impleaded as Respondent 3, disposed of the writ petition. The High Court noticed that two instrumentalities of the State have chosen to bring their disputes in open court. In such circumstances, the High Court was of the opinion that the entire dispute ought to be decided by the Chief Secretary of the State of Madhya Pradesh by holding meetings between the Principal Secretary of the Transport Department, Principal Secretaries of Housing and Environment Department and the Managing Director of M.P RTC.

56. The appellant accepted the aforesaid order passed by the High Court and submitted a detailed representation before the Chief Secretary on 20-2-2009. The Chief Secretary in the meeting held on 4-3-2009 took a comprehensive decision on all the issues involved in the writ petition with regard to the cancellation of the lease deed in favour of M.P RTC by IDA. The Chief Secretary revoked the order dated 2-11-2007 and notice dated 30-6-2007 cancelling the lease of land in question granted to M.P RTC by IDA. RTO was directed to release the leased land from attachment.

57. It is noteworthy that the appellant has not chosen to challenge the aforesaid two directions. However, as noticed earlier, the appellant challenged the directions issued in Clauses (III), (IV) and (V) in Writ Petition No. 2937 of 2009 in the High Court of Madhya Pradesh. It was, inter alia, contended that the directions in the aforesaid clauses were in violation of the order dated 5-8-2005 WP No. 636 of 2005. It is noteworthy that even in this writ petition, challenging Directions III, IV and V issued by the Chief Secretary, the appellant had not challenged the competence of the Chief Secretary to decide the issues. The appellant cannot now be permitted to state that the aforesaid directions are without jurisdiction. Under the orders of the Chief Secretary dated 4-3-2009, the possession of the land has already been delivered to IDA. Therefore, it would not be possible at this stage to direct that the mandamus granted on 5-8-2005 in Shree Ram Builders v. M.P RTC WP No. 636 of 2005 shall be enforced.

58. In the ultimate analysis, the whole controversy boils down to a breach of contract by M.P RTC entered into with the appellant. The scope of judicial review is very limited in contractual matters even where one of the contracting parties is the State or an instrumentality of the State. The parameters within which power of judicial review can be exercised, has been authoritatively laid down by this Court in a number of cases.

59. In Tata Cellular v. Union of India (1994) 6 SCC 651 this Court upon detailed consideration of the parameters within which judicial review could be exercised, has culled out the following principles:( & 677, paras 70 & 77)

“70. It cannot be denied that the principles of judicial review would apply to the exercise of contractual powers by Government bodies in order to prevent arbitrariness or favouritism. However, it must be clearly stated that there are inherent limitations in exercise of that power of judicial review. The Government is the guardian of the finances of the State. It is expected to protect the financial interest of the State. The right to refuse the lowest or any other tender is always available to the Government. But, the principles laid down in Article 14 of the Constitution have to be kept in view while accepting or refusing a tender. There can be no question of infringement of Article 14 if the Government tries to get the best person or the best quotation. The right to choose cannot be considered to be an arbitrary power. Of course, if the said power is exercised for any collateral purpose the exercise of that power will be struck down.
***
77. The duty of the court is to confine itself to the question of legality. Its concern should be:
(1) whether a decision-making authority exceeded its powers?
(2) committed an error of law,
(3) committed a breach of the rules of natural justice,
(4) reached a decision which no reasonable tribunal would have reached, or
(5) abused its powers.
Therefore, it is not for the court to determine whether a particular policy or particular decision taken in the fulfilment of that policy is fair. It is only concerned with the manner in which those decisions have been taken. The extent of the duty to act fairly will vary from case to case. Shortly put, the grounds upon which an administrative action is subject to control by judicial review can be classified as under:
(i) Illegality: This means the decision-maker must understand correctly the law that regulates his decision-making power and must give effect to it.
(ii) Irrationality, namely, Wednesbury unreasonableness.
(iii) Procedural impropriety.
The above are only the broad grounds but it does not rule out addition of further grounds in course of time.”
(emphasis in original)

60. In our opinion, the case put forward by the appellant would not be covered by the aforesaid ratio of law laid down by this Court. The High Court, in our opinion, has rightly observed that the appellant can seek the appropriate relief by way of a civil suit. The High Court in exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India would not normally grant the relief of specific performance of a contract. This view is supported by Ramchandra Murarilal Bhattad v. State of Maharashtra (2007) 2 SCC 588. This Court relying upon the earlier decision in Noble Resources Ltd. v. State of Orissa (2006) 10 SCC 236 held as under: (Ramchandra Murarilal Bhattad case (2007) 2 SCC 588)

“50. … this Court would not enforce specific performance of contract where damages would be adequate remedy. It was also held that conduct of the parties would also play an important role.
51. The expansive role of courts in exercising its power of judicial review is not in dispute. But as indicated hereinbefore, each case must be decided on its own facts.”

61. At no stage, had the appellant any privity of contract with IDA. M.P RTC entered into a BOT contract with the appellant contrary to the terms and conditions of the lease which provided specifically that the land shall be used for constructing a bus-stand-cum-commercial complex. M.P RTC had no legal right to create any further right in favour of the appellant with regard to the receiving of the premium on the constructed units sold to third party(ies). Even otherwise, the appellant seems to be flogging a dead horse. Admittedly, the possession of the proposed site was delivered to M.P RTC on 22-1-1982. The maximum lease period was for 30 years. By efflux of time the aforesaid lease period expired on 21-1-2012. We do not accept the submission of Mr Nariman that as the entire rent had been paid, M.P RTC would be entitled to automatic renewal of the lease for 90 years. The renewal clause in the lease subsequently provides that the renewal shall be with the consent of IDA. This consent by IDA is not a mere formality. We are, therefore, not inclined to accept the submission of Mr Nariman that the term of the lease has to be understood to have commenced from 26-5-2004.

62. This apart, there is much substance in the submission of Mr Cama that no application has been filed even for this formal renewal by M.P RTC. In any event, M.P RTC would not be in a position to continue with the lease as it is heavily indebted presently, to the tune of Rs 3500 crores. The property of the Corporation has been attached by various creditors. Even the proposed site where the bus-stand-cum-commercial complex was to be constructed is under attachment. The claim made by the appellant is in the nature of damages for breach of contract and/or the relief of specific performance of contract. So far as the breach of contract is concerned, the appellant will have no cause of action against IDA as there is no privity of contract between the parties. So far as the specific performance is concerned, it appears that the entire purpose of the contract has been frustrated by subsequent events.

63. We are also not much impressed by the submission of Mr Nariman that the doctrine of frustration cannot be applied here since it is a “self-induced frustration”. In Boothalinga Agencies AIR 1969 SC 110, (1969) 1 SCR 65 at p. 79 this Court upon comparing and contrasting the English law and the statement of Indian law contained in Section 56 of the Contract Act summed up the legal position with regard to frustration of contract as follows: (AIR pp. 116-17, paras 10 & 13)

“10. The doctrine of frustration of contract is really an aspect or part of the law of discharge of contract by reason of supervening impossibility or illegality of the act agreed to be done and hence comes within the purview of Section 56 of the Indian Contract Act. It should be noticed that Section 56 lays down a rule of positive law and does not leave the matter to be determined according to the intention of the parties.
13. In English law therefore the question of frustration of contract has been treated by courts as a question of construction depending upon the true intention of the parties. In contrast, the statutory provisions contained in Section 56 of the Indian Contract Act lay down a positive rule of law and English authorities cannot therefore be of direct assistance, though they have persuasive value in showing how English courts have approached and decided cases under similar circumstances.”

We fail to see how the aforesaid observations are of any relevance in the facts and circumstances of this case.

64. We are also unable to accept the submission of Mr Nariman that the doctrine of frustration would not apply in the facts of this case as it is a self-induced frustration. The aforesaid expression seems to have been borrowed from certain observations made by the Judicial Committee in Maritime National Fish Ltd. v. Ocean Trawlers Ltd. 1935 AC 524, 1935 All ER Rep 86 (PC)

65. The facts of Ocean Trawlers case 1935 AC 524, 1935 All ER Rep 86 (PC), as narrated in Boothalinga Agencies AIR 1969 SC 110, (1969) 1 SCR 65 at p. 79, would indicate that in that case, the respondents chartered to the appellants a steam trawler fitted with an otter trawl. Both the parties knew at the time of the contract that it was illegal to use an otter trawl without a licence from the Canadian Government. Some months later the appellants applied for licences for five trawlers which they were operating, including the respondent's trawler. They were informed that only three licences would be granted, and were requested to state for which of the three trawlers they would like to have the licences. They named three trawlers other than the respondent's trawler, and then claimed that they would not be bound by the trawler of the respondent as it was frustrated. It was held by the Judicial Committee that the failure of the contract was the result of the appellant's own election, and, therefore, no frustration of the contract. This Court distinguished the aforesaid judgment in Ocean Trawlers case 1935 AC 524, 1935 All ER Rep 86 (PC) and observed as follows: (Boothalinga Agencies case AIR 1969 SC 110, (1969) 1 SCR 65 at p. 79, AIR p. 118, para 14)

“14. … We think the principle of this case applies to the Indian law and the provisions of Section 56 of the Indian Contract Act cannot apply to a case of ‘self-induced frustration’. In other words, the doctrine of frustration of contract cannot apply where the event which is alleged to have frustrated the contract arises from the act or election of a party.”

66. In our opinion, these observations are of no assistance to the appellant as in this case, the lease has come to an end by efflux of time. This apart, M.P RTC is heavily indebted and had sought permission of the State and the Union of India to wind up. Furthermore, there was also a breach of the terms and conditions of the lease on the basis of which it has been terminated in accordance with law.

67. In any event, these are issues which would involve adjudication of disputed questions of fact which can only be suitably adjudicated in the civil suit as directed by the High Court in the impugned judgment WP No. 2937 of 2009. The appellant shall be at liberty to seek its remedies against M.P RTC for breach of contract. Our conclusion that the High Court was right in rejecting the contentions of the appellant herein is also supported by the law laid in Rajasthan Housing Board v. G.S Investments (2007) 1 SCC 477 which was relied upon by Mr Cama. We may notice here the following excerpt:

“20. … the Court should exercise its discretionary power under Article 226 of the Constitution with great care and caution and should exercise it only in furtherance of public interest. The Court should always keep the larger public interest in mind in order to decide whether it should interfere with the decision of the authority.”

68. Also, we are not much impressed by the submission of Mr Nariman that the order passed by the High Court on 11-12-2007 WP No. 6770 of 2007 has been challenged by the companion SLP (C) No. 36887 of 2012. The aforesaid SLP has been filed merely to get over the earlier lapse of not challenging the order of the High Court at the appropriate time. Having submitted to the jurisdiction of the Chief Secretary, it would not be open to the appellant to challenge the order dated 11-12-2007 WP No. 6770 of 2007.

69. For the aforesaid reasons, we see no merit in the appeals. The civil appeals are, therefore, dismissed.