Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Janata Dal Party v. Indian National Congress And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Jan 21, 2014
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The dispute concerns Premises No. 3, Race Course Road, Bangalore (“A-schedule property”), presently occupied by the political party office of Janata Dal (Secular). The property was originally gifted on 22-4-1949 by Sri C. Rangaswamy to the Bangalore City Congress Committee for construction of “Congress Bhavan”.

A major split in the Indian National Congress in 1969 created two factions: Congress (J) led by Smt. Indira Gandhi and Congress (O) led by Shri S. Nijalingappa. On 11-1-1971 the Election Commission of India (“ECI”) recognised Congress (J) as the legitimate Indian National Congress, a decision affirmed by the Supreme Court in Sadiq Ali v. Election Commission of India (1972) 4 SCC 664.

Congress (O) later merged with the newly formed Janata Party (1977), which took possession of the suit property and granted various leases to third parties. Claiming continued ownership, the Indian National Congress (and its Karnataka unit) filed a civil suit seeking declaration of title, recovery of possession, and mesne profits of Rs 36,000.

The trial court decreed in favour of the plaintiffs; the High Court dismissed Janata Party’s first appeal (RFA No. 2011 of 2005) on 11-10-2013. Janata Dal (Secular), successor to the Janata Party in possession, filed the present Special Leave Petition (SLP) before the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiffs could establish title to the suit property based on the 1949 gift deed, the ECI’s 1971 recognition order, and the Supreme Court judgment in Sadiq Ali.
  2. Whether the suit was barred by limitation and adverse possession under Article 65 of the Limitation Act, 1963.
  3. Whether leases executed by Congress (O) and later the Janata Party in favour of third parties conveyed any valid interest in the property.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner (Janata Dal (Secular))

  • The ECI’s decision and the Supreme Court’s judgment in Sadiq Ali do not confer title or possession; plaintiffs must prove title through independent documents.
  • Possession of Congress (O) and its successor Janata Party had been open and adverse for more than 12 years before the suit, rendering the claim time-barred under Article 65.

Respondents (Indian National Congress & Ors.)

The opinion does not provide a detailed account of the respondents’ arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sadiq Ali v. Election Commission of India (1972) 4 SCC 664 Affirmed ECI’s recognition of Congress (J) as the legitimate Indian National Congress and its entitlement to party name, symbol and assets. Used as persuasive authority to confirm that Congress (O) lost identity and had no rights over the suit property; supported plaintiffs’ title.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court held that the ECI’s 11-1-1971 order and the subsequent judgment in Sadiq Ali are directly relevant to ownership of party properties. These determinations conclusively recognised the Congress led by Indira Gandhi as the rightful successor to pre-split assets, including the suit property.

The Court traced plaintiffs’ title to the registered gift deed of 22-4-1949 and found that Congress (O) never obtained independent title; its later merger into the Janata Party could not create ownership where none existed. Consequently, leases granted by Congress (O) or the Janata Party were void and did not bind the plaintiffs.

On limitation, the Court observed that Janata Party entered possession only in 1977, and Janata Dal (Secular) was impleaded as a defendant on 14-10-2003. Defendants failed to discharge the burden of proving adverse possession; mere possession, even for an extended period, without hostile intent acknowledged by the true owner, is insufficient. Both courts below correctly rejected the plea of limitation, and no substantial question of law arose warranting interference.

Holding and Implications

SLP DISMISSED. The trial court’s decree declaring the plaintiffs’ title, ordering recovery of possession, and directing payment of mesne profits stands affirmed.

Implications: Janata Dal (Secular) must vacate the premises by 31-12-2014 upon filing an undertaking within one month, pay all arrears within three months, and continue paying rent punctually. Failure to comply permits immediate execution of the decree. The decision resolves the dispute between the parties but establishes no new legal precedent beyond reaffirming principles of title tracing and adverse possession.

Show all summary ...

K.S.P Radhakrishnan, J.— We are, in this case, concerned with the ownership and possession of Premises No. 3, Race Course Road, Bangalore, ‘A’ scheduled property, wherein, at present, the political party office of Janata Dal (Secular) is situated. The suit property originally belonged to one Sri C. Rangaswamy, who was the resident of Property No. 54, Hospital Road, Baleput, Bangalore City, executed a registered gift deed dated 22-4-1949 in favour of Bangalore City Congress Committee which was having its Office at No. 142, Cottonpet, Bangalore City, which measured 5330 sq yd. The land was donated by the donor for the purpose of construction of Congress House, wherein the All India Congress Party constructed a building, by name, “Congress Bhavan”, in a portion of the suit property.

2. In the year 1969, there was a split within the Indian National Congress giving rise to two groups, one led by late Smt Indira Gandhi, under the Presidentship of late Shri Jagjivan Ram and the other group led by late Shri S. Nijalingappa. The group led by Jagjivan Ram was then called the “Indian National Congress (J)”, whereas the other group led by Nijalingappa was called as “Indian National Congress (O)”. The split in the Party at the Centre had its own effect in the State of Karnataka as well. The then Mysore Pradesh Congress Party broke up into Congress (J) and Congress (O) corresponding to those groups in the All Indian Congress Committee at the Centre. Each group claimed itself to be the real Indian National Congress. That dispute came up before the Election Commission of India (ECI).

3. ECI, applying the test of majority at the organisational level and the legislative wings, by its order dated 11-1-1971 held that the Congress (J) was the Indian National Congress. The decision of ECI was upheld by this Court in Sadiq Ali v. Election Commission of India (1972) 4 SCC 664. Consequently, the Congress (J) group, formed as the Indian National Congress, came to be recognised as the Indian National Congress for all purposes.

4. The General Elections to the Lok Sabha were held in the year 1977. The Opposition Parties consisting of the Congress (O) group led by Nijalingappa, Lok Dal headed by late Shri Charan Singh, Jana Sangha led by Shri A.B Vajpayee and Congress for Democracy led by Shri Jagjivan Ram, fought elections together as one front under the name of Janata Party. The Congress was defeated in that election. The Janata Party formed the Government at the Centre, but did not last long. In the year 1978, there was a further split within the Congress. The National Convention of the Congress was held at New Delhi on 1-1-1978 and 2-1-1978, in which members of the All India Congress Committee, Members of Parliament, Members of the State Legislatures and Congress candidates participated and they unanimously elected Smt Indira Gandhi as the President, though Shri K. Brahmananda Reddy was also in the fray. ECI was called upon to examine that dispute as well. Later, Shri D. Devaraj Urs succeeded Shri Brahmananda Reddy as the President of that group, which came to be known as Congress (U). However, Indira Gandhi continued to be the leader of the main body which was identified as the Congress (I). The Election Commission allotted separate symbols to the Congress (U) and (I) groups. The election to the Lok Sabha took place in December 1979 and the Congress (I) was voted back to the Lok Sabha.

5. The Election Commission, in the meantime, resolved the dispute pending before it and recognised Indira Gandhi as the President of the Party, known by the name of the Congress (I). It was also held that the group led by D. Devaraj Urs, known by the name of Congress (U), was not the Congress, leaving liberty to that group to approach the Commission for its recognition as a party, taking a different name for itself. D. Devaraj Urs, purporting to be the President of Congress (U), filed a petition for special leave to appeal to this Court against the order of ECI dated 23-7-1981. This Court, after issuing notices to all the parties and hearing the counsel on either side, dismissed the special leave petition on 14-8-1981.

6. We have narrated the above facts to indicate that the suit property, all other properties and funds belonging to or referred to as belonging to the Congress are thus the properties and funds of the first plaintiff herein. Similarly, all properties and funds belonging to or referred to as belonging to the erstwhile Mysore Pradesh Congress Committee or KPCC thus belong to the second plaintiff herein. The ‘A’ schedule property is owned by the second and first plaintiffs herein. The land comprised therein was acquired by the erstwhile Mysore Pradesh Congress Committee, as it was then called, and it constructed the buildings standing in the suit property which was earlier known as Congress Bhavan.

7. We have already indicated that the Janata Party came into possession of the schedule property in question in the year 1977. During the period, the abovementioned property was under the control of the Congress (O) group. Two lease deeds were executed in respect of two portions of the vacant land, vide lease deeds dated 22-1-1971 and 10-4-1971, in favour of the third respondent. After the Janata Party came in possession in the year 1977, the previous Janata Party, a unit of the first defendant, granted lease of a portion of the plaint ‘A’ schedule property in favour of the fourth defendant on 4-8-1981 of which Defendants 5 to 8 are partners, the portion leased is described in the plaint ‘C’ schedule. The Janata Party or the previous Janata Party had no right, title or interest for granting lease of the plaint ‘C’. Defendants 9-12 are stated to be the tenants in portions of the building constructed in ‘A’ schedule property having taken the same on lease from the first defendant.

8. We have indicated that the plaintiffs instituted the present suit seeking a declaration of their title and for possession of the suit property and also sought to recover Rs 36,000 towards past mesne profits. Defendants 1 and 2 filed their written statements on 10-11-1983 contesting the suit, but the factual details were not disputed as such. But, it was pleaded that the decision taken by ECI or the judgment of this Court in Sadiq Ali (1972) 4 SCC 664 would not confer any title, ownership or possession of the suit property on the plaintiffs. According to the defendants, throughout the abovementioned property was in the possession of Congress (O), and after its merger it was in the possession of the Janata Party and at no point of time the plaintiffs were in possession.

9. Further, it was also pleaded that the suit itself was barred by the law of limitation. Defendants 4 to 6 filed a written statement on 31-7-1984 disputing the plaintiffs' right to bring the suit on behalf of the Indian National Congress. They pleaded that the Congress (O) continued to be in possession as the absolute owner of the suit property. Further, it is also stated that the Congress (O) and some other political parties joined together and constituted the Janata Party and the Congress (O) was one of the constituents of the Janata Party, and the property in question became the property of the Janata Party and, since 1977 the Janata Party has been enjoying the suit property and they were having their rights to lease out the property to the other contesting defendants.

10. On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, the trial court framed 24 issues. On behalf of the plaintiffs 5 witnesses were examined and 17 documents were exhibited. On behalf of the defendants 2 witnesses were examined and 18 documents were exhibited. The trial court, after examining the rival contentions and, on facts, came to the conclusion that the Congress (O), which was led by Nijalingappa, lost its identity as the Indian National Congress by virtue of the decision of the Election Commission and as pointed out by this Court in Sadiq Ali case (1972) 4 SCC 664. The trial court also held that this Court recognised the group led by Jagjivan Ram and Indira Gandhi as the Indian National Congress. Consequently, the properties and funds of the Indian National Congress, before its split in 1969, would be of the Congress (J) led by Jagjivan Ram and Indira Gandhi and it would not be the property of the dissident group which was identified as Congress (O). On facts, it was noticed that the Congress (O) was subsequently merged with the Janata Party and, on account of the said merger, the Janata Party would not acquire ownership of the suit schedule property. It was held that since the Janata Party was not the owner of the suit property, it had no right to grant lease in favour of the fourth defendant and grant of such lease by the Janata Party would not bind the plaintiffs. Similarly, it was also held that the grant of lease in ‘C’ schedule property in favour of the third defendant by the President of the Mysore Pradesh Congress Committee, a unit of the Congress (O) Party, was illegal and was not preceded by approval or permission of the Indian National Congress.

11. The trial court also rejected the plea of adverse possession and limitation and held that the plaintiffs have succeeded in establishing their title over the properties in question and, consequently, held that the plaintiff is entitled to recovery of possession and also mesne profits.

12. Aggrieved by the same, the Janata Party filed RFA No. 2011 of 2005 which was heard by a Division Bench of the High Court. The High Court concurred with the findings recorded by the trial court and dismissed the appeal by its judgment dated 11-10-2013 RFA No. 2011 of 2005 against which this SLP has been preferred.

13. Shri Gopal Subramanium, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner, reiterated all the factual contentions raised before the trial court as well as the High Court based on the basis of the written statements filed by the contesting respondents and submitted that neither the decision of ECI nor the judgment of this Court in Sadiq Ali (1972) 4 SCC 664, would confer any title or possession on the plaintiffs over the suit property. The learned Senior Counsel submitted that the plaintiff could succeed in establishing their title and possession only on the basis of independent documents and not on the basis of the decision of ECI or the judgment of this Court in Sadiq Ali (1972) 4 SCC 664.

14. The learned Senior Counsel also submitted that the High Court has erred in noticing that Article 65 of the Limitation Act, 1963, specifies that the limitation for possession of immovable property or any interest therein based on title is 12 years and the time from which the period begins to run is when the possession of the defendant became adverse to the plaintiff. The learned Senior Counsel pointed out that, in the instant case, possession of the defendant and their predecessor-in-title became adverse to that of the plaintiff more than 12 years prior to the filing of the suit and, therefore, the suit was liable to be dismissed solely on the ground of limitation.

15. We have heard the arguments at length and have also gone through the pleadings of the parties as well as the judgments of the courts below. We find it difficult to accept the contention raised by the learned Senior Counsel that the decision of ECI dated 11-1-1971 or the judgment of this Court in Sadiq Ali (1972) 4 SCC 664 would have no bearing, so far as the facts of this case are concerned. The question as to which of the two groups, Congress (J) or Congress (O) (the then Congress Party) should be recognised as the Congress, as already indicated, came before ECI. ECI, after applying the test of majority at the organisational level and the legislative wings, took the view that the Congress (J) group of the Congress came to be recognised as the Congress for all purposes. The order of ECI and this Court clearly indicate that the Congress then led by Indira Gandhi had established rights on the properties in question. The courts below have narrated in detail how the suit property came into the hands of the plaintiffs and how the Congress (O) followed by the Janata Party ceased to have any right over the suit property in question. Since, on facts, it was found that the defendants have no right over the property in question, the various lease deeds executed by them also cannot stand in the eye of the law.

16. We have noticed that the property in question was gifted vide registered gift deed dated 22-4-1949 by Rangaswamy in favour of the Bangalore City Congress Committee. The plaintiffs could successfully trace their title and interest over the suit property towards that gift deed executed in the year 1949, coupled with the various declarations by ECI recognising the petitioner as the real Congress and the judgment of this Court affirming the same.

17. We are also not impressed by the arguments raised by the learned Senior Counsel on the plea of limitation. So far as the Janata Party is concerned, it came into picture only in the year 1977. On facts, it is clearly found that the Congress (O) had no right in the suit property. In the instant case, the Janata Dal (Secular) was impleaded as the defendant only on 14-10-2003 and the disputed property was known as the Congress Bhavan till the formation of the Janata Dal in the year 1977. It is relevant to note that the defendants had never accepted the plaintiffs as the owner of the property. On the contrary, their specific case was that the first defendant was the owner of the property. On facts, it was found that the first defendant had no title over the property in question. Further, the entire burden of proving that the possession is adverse to that of the plaintiffs, is on the defendant. On the other hand, the possession of the suit property was throughout of the Congress (O) and its successor parties and not that of the petitioner herein. It was after the split in the Janata Party and, subsequently before the filing of the suit, the Janata Dal continued to be in possession of the suit property. The plea of limitation and adverse possession was elaborately considered by the courts below and we find no error in the findings recorded by the courts below on that ground as well. Further, no substantive question of law arises for our consideration. The SLP, therefore, lacks merits and is dismissed.

18. Considering the facts that the petitioner is in possession of the property for a considerable long period, we are inclined to grant time up to 31-12-2014 to vacate the premises, for which the petitioner has to prefer an undertaking before this Court within one month from today stating that the petitioner would vacate the premises within the stipulated time and that the petitioner would pay the entire arrears of rent within a period of three months and will continue to pay the rent without any default. If the petitioner commits two consecutive defaults in payment of monthly rent or fails to file the undertaking, the time granted by this Court would not be available and it will be open to the respondents to get the judgment/decree executed.