- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mohinder Singh And Others v. State Of Haryana .
Factual and Procedural Background
The State of Haryana issued a notification on 2-12-1982 under Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, proposing to acquire 327.52 acres in Village Patti Jhambra, Shahabad, District Kurukshetra for development of a residential, commercial and industrial urban estate. A follow-up notification under Section 6 was published on 4-7-1984 in respect of 178.62 acres, though only 90.07 acres were ultimately taken possession of.
The Collector’s award dated 16-9-1986 fixed varying compensation rates based on land classification (chahi, abadi plot, gair mumkin and banjar quadim). Dissatisfied landowners sought references under Section 18. On 31-5-1991, the Reference Court awarded a uniform rate of Rs 2,66,400 per acre.
The State’s regular first appeals (for reduction) and the claimants’ appeals (for enhancement) were disposed of by a learned Single Judge who reduced the rate to Rs 1,83,080 per acre. The claimants filed letters patent appeals. A Division Bench increased the rate to Rs 2,19,696 per acre. Both sides came to the Supreme Court: the State to seek further reduction, and the claimants to seek enhancement.
Legal Issues Presented
- What is the reasonable percentage deduction towards development charges to be applied to the market value when determining compensation for the acquired land?
Arguments of the Parties
State of Haryana’s Arguments
- The sale deeds relied on by the claimants involve only small plots and therefore do not reliably indicate the value of the large tract acquired.
- The acquired land was agricultural and undeveloped; consequently, a 50% deduction from the market value—as earlier fixed by the learned Single Judge—is reasonable and ought to be restored.
Claimants’ Arguments
- The land lies within the municipal limits of Shahabad and is surrounded by existing development (educational institutions, cinema hall, cold storage, rice mills, grain market and nursing homes).
- Given its urban location and existing amenities, the deduction for development should not exceed 20%; the 40% cut imposed by the Division Bench is excessive.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Charan Dass v. H.P. Housing and Urban Development Authority (2010) 13 SCC 398 | Deduction for development must reflect the actual situation of the land; a 40% cut is not justified where the land is amidst developed areas with existing amenities. | Relied upon to hold that a 40% deduction was excessive because the acquired land was already within developed municipal limits. |
| Kasturi v. State of Haryana (2003) 1 SCC 354 | A 20% deduction, lower than the typical one-third, can be justified after considering relevant factors. | Used to illustrate that deductions below the standard one-third are acceptable in appropriate circumstances, supporting the court’s view that a 25% cut is reasonable here. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court first evaluated the locational attributes and potential of the acquired land. The Reference Court had found—and the Single Judge accepted—that the land lay within the municipal limits of Shahabad and was surrounded by multiple urban amenities, giving it high development potential. The State produced no contrary evidence to establish that the land was purely agricultural.
In determining the appropriate deduction for development charges, the Court applied the principles from Charan Dass and Kasturi. It agreed with the High Court’s approach of comparing large-scale acquisition with smaller sale instances but concluded that a flat 40% deduction was unjustified given the land’s urban surroundings. Instead, the Reference Court’s 25% (one-fourth) deduction more accurately reflected the minimal development required.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The claimants’ appeals are partly allowed; the Division Bench judgment in LPA No. 310 of 1999 is set aside and the Reference Court’s award—compensation at Rs 2,66,400 per acre with statutory benefits—is restored. The State’s appeals are dismissed. Interlocutory applications to bring legal heirs on record are allowed. No order as to costs.
Implications: The immediate effect is an increase in compensation payable to the landowners. The decision reaffirms that development deductions must correspond to the actual development need of the land and may be lower than the conventional one-third where the land is already situated within developed municipal limits. No new legal precedent beyond this reaffirmation was created.
C. Nagappan, J.— Leave granted. All these appeals are directed against the common judgment dated 11-9-2000 in Mohinder Singh v. State of Haryana LPA No. 310 of 1999 and connected appeals passed by the Division Bench of the High Court for the States of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh.
2. The State of Haryana issued Notification dated 2-12-1982 under Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, intending to acquire 327.52 acres in Village Patti Jhambra, Shahabad in District Kurukshetra for a public purpose, namely, to develop and utilise the land for residential, commercial, industrial area for the urban estate of Shahabad. Section 6 Notification was issued on 4-7-1984 in relation to 178.62 acres, though on actual measurement, the possession of the land taken was found only 90.07 acres. After hearing the objections of the landowners/claimants the Collector by his award dated 16-9-1986 awarded compensation at different rates per acre, classifying the lands as chahi, abadi plot, gair mumkin and banjar quadim. Having not satisfied with the amount awarded, the claimants filed applications for reference under Section 18 of the Act and the Collector referred them to the District Judge, Kurukshetra for determining the value of the lands. The Reference Court after hearing both the parties on the basis of the evidence adduced, awarded uniform compensation at Rs 2,66,400 per acre in his award dated 31-5-1991.
3. Feeling dissatisfied with the said award the State filed regular first appeals seeking reduction in the amount of compensation and the claimants filed independent appeals for enhancement of the compensation. The learned Single Judge of the High Court partly allowed the appeal filed by the State and dismissed the appeals of the claimants and held that the claimants are entitled to get compensation at the rate of Rs 1,83,080 per acre along with solatium and interest and statutory benefits. Feeling aggrieved the claimants preferred letters patent appeals and the Division Bench of the High Court partly allowed the claimants' appeals and modified the award to the extent that claimants are entitled to get compensation at the rate of Rs 2,19,696 per acre along with other benefits as awarded by the Reference Court. Feeling dissatisfied the State preferred the present appeals seeking reduction in the amount of compensation and the claimants preferred separate appeals seeking for enhancement of the compensation.
4. Shri Narender Hooda, learned Additional Advocate General for the State of Haryana submitted that the sale transactions relied on by the claimants related to small plots of land and the sale price of such transactions could not be taken to be an accurate assessment of the valuation of lands which were acquired in bulk and the acquired lands were agricultural in nature and they are not developed and deduction of 50% of the market value done by the learned Single Judge was reasonable and is liable to be restored.
5. Mr Brijender Chahar, learned Senior Advocate who appeared for the claimants submitted that the lands in question fell within the municipal limits of Shahabad and it is in the midst of already developed land and reasonable deduction would be not more than 20% of the assessed value of the land and the cut of 40% imposed by the Division Bench of the High Court was not justified in the circumstances.
6. We carefully considered the submissions and perused the record. The only point for consideration in these appeals is as to what would be the reasonable deduction towards development charges to be made from the market value.
7. With regard to the location and potential of the land, the Reference Court held that the acquired land adjoins the abadi of the township of Shahabad and it is in its municipal limits and it is in evidence that around this land there exist DAV College, Girls High School, cinema hall, cold storage, rice mills, grain market and private nursing homes and all the establishments have sprung up before the acquisition and the acquired land had great potential value for development of residential, commercial and industrial units. The learned Single Judge while referring to the contention of the State that the land in question was recorded as agricultural land has held that the State has produced no evidence to establish the same and on the contrary the testimony of PW 1 on oath that the land lies within the municipal limit of Shahabad remained unrebutted.
8. This Court in the decision in Charan Dass v. H.P Housing and Urban Development Authority (2010) 13 SCC 398 observed that any deduction made should be based on the situation of the land and the need for development and where the acquired land is in the midst of already developed land with amenities of roads, drainage, electricity, etc. then deduction of 40% would not be justified.
9. In Kasturi v. State of Haryana (2003) 1 SCC 354 wherein the question had arisen as to whether the deduction of development charges at the rate of 20% in regard to the acquired lands was justified or not, and after taking the various factors into consideration it was held that a cut of 20% to the development charges which was lower than the normal 1/3rd was understandable and could be justified.
10. In our view, the High Court on the facts of the case was justified in taking into consideration the size of the plots which were exhibited for the purpose of comparison with the size of the plot acquired, but we are unable to uphold the cut of 40% which has been imposed by the High Court since the acquired lands are already within developed municipal limits and the deduction of 1/4th of the market value made by the Reference Court is appropriate and liable to be restored.
11. In the result the appeals preferred by the claimants are partly allowed and the impugned judgment LPA No. 310 of 1999 of the Division Bench of the High Court is set aside and the award passed by the Reference Court is restored. The appeals preferred by the State are dismissed. Interlocutory Applications Nos. 5 and 6 in SLP No. 5191 of 2001 for bringing on record the legal heirs are allowed. No costs.
Alert