Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Union Territory, Chandigarh And Others v. Gurcharan Singh And Another

Supreme Court Of India
Nov 1, 2013
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent, Gurcharan Singh, an ex-serviceman who served the Indian Army as a Combatant Clerk until 31-1-1990, was appointed on 15-4-1990 as a Clerk in the Chandigarh Transport Undertaking on a post reserved for ex-servicemen. His initial pay was fixed by order dated 2-9-1992.

An audit objection raised after his retirement in 1997 revealed that the 1992 fixation ignored the Central Civil Services (Fixation of Pay of Re-employed Pensioners) Orders, 1986 (“the 1986 Orders”). The employer therefore issued a fresh order on 13-10-1998 re-fixing his pay downward.

Singh’s representations failed, leading him to file OA No. 975.CH/2000 before the Central Administrative Tribunal, which dismissed the application on 4-1-2002. The Punjab & Haryana High Court, however, allowed his writ petition on 20-3-2008 ((2008) 6 SLR 240), quashing the 1998 re-fixation order. The present appeal by the Union Territory of Chandigarh and others challenges that High Court judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondent’s pay had been correctly re-fixed on 13-10-1998 in accordance with the 1986 Orders, particularly Order 4.
  2. Whether the High Court erred in setting aside the Tribunal’s decision and restoring the higher pay fixed in 1992.
  3. Whether amounts over-paid to the respondent pursuant to the erroneous 1992 fixation could be recovered by the employer.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments (Union Territory of Chandigarh & Ors.)

  • The 1986 Orders consolidate all earlier circulars on pay fixation for re-employed pensioners and were binding at the time of respondent’s appointment.
  • Order 4(a) mandates that a re-employed pensioner draw pay only in the scale of the re-employed post without protection of earlier military pay; Order 4(d)(i) requires complete ignoring of pension for those below commissioned rank.
  • The respondent had expressly opted for fixation at the minimum of the clerk’s scale in an option form dated 18-7-1990; the 1992 fixation mistakenly granted increments for military service contrary to the option and the Orders.
  • The Tribunal therefore rightly upheld the 1998 re-fixation, and the High Court failed to consider the option form and applicable rules.

Respondent’s Arguments (Gurcharan Singh)

  • He was unaware of any option form; the employer never furnished a copy.
  • The 1992 fixation was valid and should not have been disturbed six years later to his prejudice.
  • Even if the 1998 re-fixation is upheld, recovery of alleged over-payments would be inequitable and should be barred.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court examined the original option form dated 18-7-1990 and the text of Order 4 of the 1986 Orders. It found that:

  • The respondent had unequivocally chosen pay fixation at the minimum of the clerk’s scale, consistent with Order 4(a).
  • Because he continued to receive an army pension without any deduction, principles of “dual benefit” prohibited counting his past military service again for civilian increments.
  • The 1992 order erroneously granted him a higher scale by crediting military increments, contrary to Order 4.
  • The Tribunal correctly treated the 1998 order as a rectification of a patent mistake; the High Court failed to appreciate these statutory provisions and documentary evidence.
  • Equitable considerations cannot override a statutory mandate; therefore, any excess payments made under the invalid 1992 fixation are recoverable, subject to final settlement of accounts which could also reveal sums payable to the respondent.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED; HIGH COURT JUDGMENT SET ASIDE. The order of the Central Administrative Tribunal upholding the pay-fixation dated 13-10-1998 is restored.

Implications: The respondent’s salary will stand re-fixed at the minimum of the clerk’s scale from the outset, and any over-payment attributable to the 1992 error is liable to be recovered (or any short-payment to be made good) upon settlement of accounts. The decision applies established rules on pay fixation for re-employed pensioners and does not create new precedent but reaffirms strict adherence to the 1986 Orders.

Show all summary ...

Anil R. Dave, J.— Leave granted. Being aggrieved by the judgment delivered in Gurcharan Singh v. Union of India (2008) 6 SLR 240 (P&H) dated 20-3-2008 by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh, this appeal has been filed by the employer Union Territory of Chandigarh and others.

2. The facts giving rise to the present litigation in a nutshell are as under: the respondent was appointed as a Clerk by the appellant Chandigarh Transport Undertaking on the quota reserved for ex-servicemen. The respondent had rendered his services to the Indian Army as a Combatant Clerk up to 31-1-1990, till the date when he was discharged from the Indian Army.

3. Upon his appointment as a Clerk under an office order dated 2-9-1992, his pay had been fixed and he was paid his salary accordingly. Only when he retired in 1997, it was brought to the notice of the employer, on getting an audit query, that his salary had been wrongly fixed under the order dated 2-9-1992. The mistake committed in pay fixation had been rectified by an order dated 13-10-1998.

4. Being aggrieved by the refixation of his pay, the respondent had made several representations but as no change was effected by the appellant employer in the pay so refixed, the respondent had approached the Central Administrative Tribunal (hereinafter referred to as “the Tribunal”) by filing Original Application No. 975.CH/2000. The said OA had been dismissed by the Tribunal by an order dated 4-1-2002. Being aggrieved by the order rejecting the aforestated OA, the respondent employee had approached the High Court by filing the aforestated petition which has been allowed by an order dated 20-3-2008 (2008) 6 SLR 240 (P&H) and being aggrieved by the said order and judgment, this appeal has been filed by the employer.

5. The learned counsel for the appellant had explained the circumstances in which the appellant was constrained to refix the pay of the respondent so as to rectify the mistake committed while passing the pay fixation order dated 2-9-1992. The learned counsel had taken us through the relevant regulations with regard to pay fixation of re-employed pensioners and had taken us through the provisions of the Central Civil Services (Fixation of pay of Re-employed Pensioners) Orders, 1986 (hereinafter referred to as “the Orders”) under which pay of the respondent ought to have been fixed.

6. The learned counsel for the appellant had submitted that there were several different notifications and orders in relation to the pay fixation of re-employed pensioners, including ex-servicemen. So as to see that all the orders are available at one place, the orders had been compiled and notified in 1986 so that pay of the re-employed pensioners can be fixed only upon looking at the provisions of the compilation of the Orders instead of looking at several different orders or notifications which had been issued from time to time. Thus, according to the learned counsel, a comprehensive compilation of all the relevant orders, which had been issued from time to time and which were operative in 1996 was duly considered for the purpose of refixation of the pay of the respondent.

7. As the respondent had been given appointment on 15-4-1990 as a Clerk on a post reserved for the ex-servicemen, the provisions of the Orders were to be looked into for the purpose of pay fixation of the respondent. The learned counsel had further submitted that while fixing the pay on 2-9-1992, the appellant did not look into the certain provisions of the Orders and an option exercised by the respondent in relation to his pay fixation and therefore, incorrect pay had been fixed under the order dated 2-9-1992. By virtue of the said pay fixation, the respondent was given benefit of his past services rendered to the Indian Army and accordingly, he was also given increments which he would have got in the Indian Army. As a result thereof, the respondent's pay was fixed in a higher scale than what he ought to have been allowed. As a matter of fact, as per the provisions of Order 4 of the Orders, the respondent could not have been given the benefit of his earlier services in the process of fixing his pay.

8. Order 4 of the Orders, being relevant for the purpose, has been reproduced hereinbelow:

“4. Fixation of pay of re-employed pensioners.—(a) Re-employed pensioners shall be allowed to drawn pay only in prescribed scales of pay for the posts in which they are re-employed. No protection of the scales of pay of the post held by them prior to retirement shall be given.
(b) (i) In all cases where the pension is fully ignored, the initial pay on re-employment shall be fixed at the minimum of the scale of pay of the re-employed post.
(ii) In cases where the entire pension and pensionary benefits are not ignored for pay fixation, the initial pay on re-employment shall be fixed at the same stage as the last pay drawn before retirement. If there is no such stage in the re-employed post, the pay shall be fixed at the stage below that pay. If the maximum of the pay scale in which a pensioner is re-employed is less than the last pay drawn by him before retirement, his initial pay shall be fixed at the maximum of the scale of the re-employed post. Similarly, if the minimum of the scale of the pay in which a pensioner is re-employed is more than the last pay drawn by him before retirement his initial pay shall be fixed at the minimum of the scale of pay of the re-employed post. However, in all these cases, non-ignorable part of the pension and pension equivalent of retirement benefits shall be reduced from the pay so fixed.
(c) The re-employed pensioner will in addition to pay as fixed under para (b) above shall be permitted to drawn separately and pension sanctioned to him and to retain any other form of retirement benefits.
(d) In the case of persons retiring before attaining the age of 55 years and who are re-employed, pension (including pension equivalent of gratuity and other forms of retirement benefits) shall be ignored for initial pay fixation to the following extent:
(i) In the case of ex-servicemen who held posts below commissioned officer rank in the Defence Forces and in the case of civilians who held posts below Group A posts at the time of their retirement, the entire pension and pension equivalent of retirement benefits shall be ignored.
(ii) In the case of service officers belonging to the Defence Forces and Civilian Pensioners who held Group A posts at the time of their retirement, the first Rs 500 of the pension and pension equivalent of retirement benefits shall be ignored.”

9. The respondent had been given an option whereby he had opted for the minimum scale of pay, which was paid to the Clerk and therefore, his pay had been rightly fixed as per the option read with Order 4(a) of the Rules. The learned counsel had further submitted that while allowing the writ petition, the High Court had not considered the aforestated facts at all. The High Court did not look into the fact that an option had been given to the respondent-employee and his pay had been fixed only as per the option exercised by him and as per the provisions of Order 4 of the Orders. It had, therefore, been submitted that the view taken by the Tribunal, confirming refixation of pay was correct and the High Court ought not to have disturbed the same by allowing the writ petition. It was, therefore, submitted that the order dated 20-3-2008 (2008) 6 SLR 240 (P&H) of the High Court should be quashed by allowing the appeal.

10. On the other hand, the learned counsel appearing for the respondent employee had at the first instance submitted that the respondent was not having a copy of the option and he was not aware about the option so exercised. He had submitted that the pay had rightly been fixed by the order dated 2-9-1992 and it ought not to have been refixed to the prejudice of the employee after six years. He had, therefore, submitted that the view taken by the High Court was correct. He had further submitted that perhaps the respondent might have to make some payment to the appellant employer as according to the employer, the respondent had been paid more salary on account of incorrect pay fixation. He had also submitted that recovering the salary so paid would be unjust and therefore, in any case, nothing should be recovered from the respondent employee.

11. Upon hearing the learned counsel and upon perusal of the option form dated 18-7-1990, in our opinion, the High Court was in error while allowing the petition because it is clearly revealed from the option form that the respondent had agreed to get his pay fixed as per the minimum of pay in the pay-scale of the Clerk, the post to which he had been re-employed. It is pertinent to note that the respondent has been getting regular pension from the Indian Army for his past services rendered to the Indian Army. As per the provisions of the Orders and as per the option exercised by the respondent, service rendered by the respondent to the Indian Army cannot be taken into account for the purposes of his pay fixation as the respondent would be getting his pension and there would not be any deduction from his pension or his salary on account of the pension received by him from the Indian Army. If nothing has been deducted from the pension of the respondent upon being re-employed and as the respondent would continue to get his pension and other benefits from the Army for his past services, in our opinion, the High Court was not right while permitting the respondent to get his higher pay fixed by taking into account the services rendered by the respondent to the Indian Army. Even from sound common sense, it can be seen that for the past service rendered to the Indian Army, the respondent is getting pension and other perquisites which a retired or discharged soldier is entitled to even after being re-employed. The respondent would, therefore, not have any right to get any further advantage in the nature of higher salary or a higher pay scale, especially when nothing from his salary was being deducted on account of his getting pension or perquisites from the earlier employer.

12. In view of the aforestated position, in our opinion, the Tribunal was absolutely right in coming to the conclusion that the pay fixation under the order dated 13-10-1998 was correct because a mistake was committed in the earlier pay fixation under the order dated 2-9-1992.

13. Though a submission had been made on behalf of the respondent that no amount should be recovered from the salary paid to the respondent, the said submission cannot be accepted because if any amount had been paid due to mistake, the mistake must be rectified and the amount so paid in pursuance of the mistake must be recovered. It might also happen that the employer might have to pay some amount to the respondent as a result of some mistake and in such an event, even the appellant might have to pay to the respondent. Be that as it may, upon settlement of the account, whatever amount has to be paid to the respondent employee or to the appellant employer shall be paid and the account shall be adjusted accordingly.

14. For the aforestated reasons, we are of the view that the High Court was not correct in allowing the writ petition. We quash and set aside the order passed by the High Court so as to restore the order passed by the Tribunal and give effect to the pay fixation order dated 13-10-1998. The appeal stands disposed of as allowed with no order as to costs.