- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Majjal v. State Of Haryana .
Factual and Procedural Background
The prosecution case originated from a complaint made by Ramjani (PW 4) at Police Station Punhana against the appellant and others. It was alleged that on the night intervening 30-10-1995 and 31-10-1995, the appellant, along with his sons (Harun, Rajak, Khurshid, and Bhati) and other persons, went to the house of Deen Dar with a common object to kidnap Farida (Deen Dar’s daughter). The assailants were stated to be armed with guns and country-made pistols. When Farida raised cries, several persons arrived and attempted to rescue her; during this, the appellant allegedly fired at Lal Khan (PW 3), Harun allegedly fired at Abdul Karim, and Khurshid allegedly fired at Deen Dar. Roshni was injured with lathis. Mehboob (son of Rojdar) was allegedly abducted by the appellant and his son Khurshid. Abdul Karim died at the spot due to a firearm injury, and Deen Dar was injured, after which the assailants fled.
Based on the information from PW 4, FIR No. 277 was registered under Sections 148, 149, 302, 307, 364, 323, 120-B IPC and Section 25 of the Arms Act. After investigation, a charge-sheet was filed against the appellant. The prosecution examined 16 witnesses (PW 1 to PW 16) and exhibited 29 documents (Exts. P-1 to P-29). No defence evidence was adduced.
The trial court convicted the appellant under Section 302 read with Section 149 IPC and sentenced him to imprisonment for life with a fine of Rs 10,000 (default simple imprisonment for 3 months), and directed payment of Rs 25,000 as compensation to injured Lal Khan. The appellant’s criminal appeal (Criminal Appeal No. 920-DB of 2009) was dismissed by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana by judgment dated 14-2-2012. The present appeal before the Supreme Court arose by grant of special leave.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the High Court, while dismissing a criminal appeal involving a conviction under Section 302 IPC with a life sentence, failed to discharge its duty as a first appellate court by providing only cryptic reasons without proper analysis of the evidence and submissions.
- Whether the High Court’s judgment should be set aside and the criminal appeal remanded for fresh consideration due to inadequate reasoning and lack of demonstrated application of mind.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court focused on the manner in which the High Court disposed of the criminal appeal. It observed that, although the High Court’s judgment set out facts in detail, identified prosecution witnesses and documents, and referred to the trial court’s observations and the arguments of counsel, it ultimately dismissed the appeal “without any proper analysis of the evidence” and in a “summary way,” with the reasoning confined to two short paragraphs.
The Court found such a cryptic disposal unsatisfactory, particularly in a case involving a charge under Section 302 IPC resulting in life imprisonment. It emphasised that the High Court, acting as the court of first appeal, must examine whether the trial court’s assessment of evidence and the conclusion of guilt deserve confirmation. This duty was linked to the curtailment of personal liberty upon conviction, requiring the appellate court to state reasons demonstrating why it accepts the evidence on record.
While clarifying that the High Court need not write an unduly long treatise, the Supreme Court held that a judgment—even if brief—must reflect proper application of mind to vital evidence and important submissions that go to the root of the matter. Since this exercise was not undertaken by the High Court, the Supreme Court concluded that the matter warranted remand for fresh hearing after setting aside the impugned order.
Holding and Implications
SET ASIDE AND REMANDED: The Supreme Court set aside the High Court’s judgment and order dated 14-2-2012 in Criminal Appeal No. 920-DB of 2009 and remanded the appeal to the High Court to be heard afresh and decided in light of the Supreme Court’s observations, as expeditiously as possible (noting the appellant was in jail and stated to be 84 years old).
The direct implication is that the High Court must re-adjudicate the criminal appeal independently and on merits, providing reasoned findings rather than cryptic concurrence. The Supreme Court expressly stated that it had not considered the merits of the case, and therefore the remand did not determine guilt or innocence; it required a fresh appellate evaluation with adequate reasoning. No new precedent was set on the substantive criminal charges on the merits within the provided text.
Order
1. Leave granted. This appeal, by grant of special leave, is directed against the judgment and order dated 14-2-2012 Criminal Appeal No. 920-DB of 2009 passed by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh dismissing Criminal Appeal No. 920-DB of 2009 filed by the appellant.
2. Briefly stated the prosecution case is that the complainant, Ramjani (PW 4) made a complaint with Police Station Punhana against the appellant and others. It was alleged in the complaint that during the night intervening 30-10-1995 and 31-10-1995 the appellant along with his sons, namely, Harun, Rajak, Khurshid and Bhati and other persons arrived at the house of Deen Dar with common object to kidnap Farida, daughter of Deen Dar. The appellant and his associates were armed with guns and country-made pistols. They tried to take away Farida on which she raised cries. Consequently Abdul Karim, son of Deen Dar, Lal Khan (PW 3) and Khurshid, sons of Rojdar, Deen Dar, son of Chand Khan and Roshni arrived at the house of Deen Dar along with the complainant and tried to rescue Farida. At that time the appellant fired a shot at Lal Khan, Harun fired a shot at Abdul Karim and Khurshid fired a shot at Deen Dar. Injuries were caused to Roshni with lathis. Thereafter Mehboob, son of Rojdar came. He was abducted by the appellant and his son Khurshid. Abdul Karim expired at the spot due to firearm injury. Deen Dar also got injured. Thereafter, the assailants fled away from the scene of occurrence.
3. On the basis of the information given by PW 4, FIR No. 277 was registered under Sections 148, 149, 302, 307, 364, 323, 120-B IPC and Section 25 of the Arms Act against the appellant and investigation commenced. On completion of the investigation, charge-sheet was filed against the appellant. The appellant pleaded not guilty to the charges and claimed to be tried. The prosecution, in support of its case, examined as many as 16 witnesses (PW 1 to PW 16). The prosecution exhibited 29 documents (Exts. P-1 to P-29) in evidence. No defence evidence was adduced.
4. Upon perusal of the evidence, the trial court convicted the appellant under Section 302 read with Section 149 IPC and sentenced him to imprisonment for life and to pay a fine of Rs 10,000, in default, to further undergo simple imprisonment for a period of 3 months. The appellant was directed to pay Rs 25,000 as compensation to injured Lal Khan. As already stated, the appeal preferred by the appellant was dismissed by the High Court. Hence, this appeal by special leave.
5. We have heard Shri Dushyant Parashar, learned counsel for the appellant as well as Shri Narender Hooda, Senior Assistant Advocate General for the State.
6. In this case what strikes us is the cryptic nature of the High Court's observations on the merits of the case. The High Court has set out the facts in detail. It has mentioned the names and numbers of the prosecution witnesses. Particulars of all documents produced in the court along with their exhibit numbers have been mentioned. Gist of the trial court's observations and findings are set out in a long paragraph. Then there is a reference to the arguments advanced by the counsel. Thereafter, without any proper analysis of the evidence almost in a summary way the High Court has dismissed the appeal. The High Court's cryptic reasoning is contained in two short paragraphs. We find such disposal of a criminal appeal by the High Court particularly in a case involving charge under Section 302 IPC where the accused is sentenced to life imprisonment unsatisfactory.
7. It was necessary for the High Court to consider whether the trial court's assessment of the evidence and its opinion that the appellant must be convicted deserve to be confirmed. This exercise is necessary because the personal liberty of an accused is curtailed because of the conviction. The High Court must state its reasons why it is accepting the evidence on record. The High Court's concurrence with the trial court's view would be acceptable only if it is supported by reasons. In such appeals it is a court of first appeal. Reasons cannot be cryptic. By this, we do not mean that the High Court is expected to write an unduly long treatise. The judgment may be short but must reflect proper application of mind to vital evidence and important submissions which go to the root of the matter. Since this exercise is not conducted by the High Court, the appeal deserves to be remanded for a fresh hearing after setting aside the impugned order.
8. Hence, we set aside the impugned judgment and order dated 14-2-2012 Criminal Appeal No. 920-DB of 2009 and remand the appeal to the High Court. We request the High Court to hear the appeal afresh and deliver judgment in the light of our above observations as expeditiously as possible as the appellant is in jail and he is stated to be 84 years of age. We make it clear that we have not considered the merits of the case. The appeal shall be disposed of independently and on merits.
9. The appeal is disposed of in the aforestated terms.
Alert