- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Union Of India And Others v. Anil Kumar Sarkar .
Factual and Procedural Background
The respondent, Anil Kumar Sarkar, entered Northern Railways as a Junior Clerk on 4 November 1977 and rose to the position of Senior Assistant Financial Adviser (T-1). A Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) held on 26–27 February 2002 recommended him for substantive promotion to Group-A (Junior Scale) of the Indian Railways Accounts Service (IRAS) and placed his name in an extended select panel.
Subsequently, allegations of irregularities committed in 1994-1995 while passing suppliers’ bills led to:
- Four departmental charge-sheets issued between 13 August 2003 and 5 November 2003, and four disciplinary enquiries at Delhi, Kolkata and Guwahati.
- Eleven CBI FIRs in 2004 (later amalgamated into three Special Cases) under the Penal Code, 1860 and the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.
Before any charge-sheet was served, the respondent’s batch-mates were promoted on 21 April 2003. His representations for similar promotion were rejected, prompting OA No. 251/2007 before the Central Administrative Tribunal, Guwahati Bench, which dismissed the application on 21 August 2009. The Gauhati High Court, in WP(C) 744/2010, set aside the Tribunal’s order on 27 April 2010 and directed the Railways to promote the respondent with consequential benefits. The Union of India appealed to the Supreme Court.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, under the Office Memorandum dated 14 September 1992 (paras 2 and 7), the “sealed-cover” procedure could lawfully prevent the respondent’s promotion when, on 21 April 2003, he was neither suspended, charge-sheeted nor facing criminal prosecution.
- Whether the Gauhati High Court erred in ordering promotion despite subsequent disciplinary and criminal proceedings initiated after the DPC’s recommendation.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant (Union of India)
- Para 2 of the 1992 Office Memorandum must be read conjointly with Para 7; once charge-sheets were later issued and enquiries completed, the respondent stood “under cloud,” justifying sealed-cover treatment.
- The High Court incorrectly relied on Para 2 alone and ignored the latter part of Para 7 that bars promotion until disciplinary/criminal proceedings conclude.
- Relied on Union of India v. R.S. Sharma to argue that subsequent initiation of proceedings could still justify withholding promotion.
Respondent (Anil Kumar Sarkar)
- On 21 April 2003, the critical date of his peers’ promotion, he was not under suspension, had not been charge-sheeted, and faced no criminal prosecution; thus none of the conditions in Para 2 existed.
- The sealed-cover procedure could not be invoked retroactively; subsequent charge-sheets (first issued on 13 August 2003) were irrelevant to the earlier promotion exercise.
- Relied on Union of India v. K.V. Jankiraman to contend that disciplinary/criminal proceedings begin only upon issuance of a charge-sheet, and mere investigation cannot bar promotion.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Union of India v. K.V. Jankiraman (1991) 4 SCC 109 | Disciplinary/criminal proceedings are deemed “pending” only after a charge-sheet is issued; sealed-cover procedure applies only thereafter. | Formed the primary basis for affirming that no sealed-cover could be applied on 21 April 2003 because no charge-sheet then existed. |
| Coal India Ltd. v. Saroj Kumar Mishra (2007) 9 SCC 625 | A departmental proceeding is initiated only with issuance of a charge-sheet. | Cited to reinforce Jankiraman’s principle of the starting point of disciplinary proceedings. |
| Coal India Ltd. v. Ananta Saha (2011) 5 SCC 142 | Re-affirmed that disciplinary proceedings commence only when a charge-sheet is issued. | Quoted to further buttress the above principle. |
| UCO Bank v. Rajinder Lal Capoor (2007) 6 SCC 694 | Also supports the proposition that disciplinary proceedings start with a charge-sheet. | Referenced within the Court’s discussion of Ananta Saha to show consistent jurisprudence. |
| Union of India v. R.S. Sharma (2000) 4 SCC 394 | Illustrates circumstances where Jankiraman was distinguished. | Appellant relied on it; Court found the facts distinguishable and held it inapplicable. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court examined the 14 September 1992 Office Memorandum governing promotions where disciplinary or criminal proceedings are pending. Para 2 mandates sealed-cover treatment only where, at the time of consideration, the employee:
- is under suspension,
- has been served a charge-sheet with disciplinary proceedings pending, or
- is facing criminal prosecution.
On 21 April 2003, none of these conditions applied to the respondent—he was not suspended, no charge-sheet had issued, and no prosecution was pending. The first charge-sheet surfaced only on 13 August 2003. Consequently, the DPC’s recommendation had to be implemented without invoking sealed-cover.
Addressing the appellant’s reliance on Para 7, the Court noted that Para 7 treats a candidate as “sealed-cover” only if circumstances in Para 2 arise after the DPC’s recommendation but before actual promotion; however, even in that situation, the pre-condition is that one of the Para 2 events must have occurred, which had not happened by 21 April 2003.
Reaffirming the ratio of K.V. Jankiraman, the Court held that disciplinary or criminal proceedings “commence” only upon issuance of a charge-sheet, and preliminary investigations cannot bar promotion. Later cases (Saroj Kumar Mishra, Ananta Saha, UCO Bank) were cited to underscore this settled law. The Court distinguished R.S. Sharma because, unlike the present facts, the requisite Para 2 conditions existed at the relevant time in that case.
Holding and Implications
Appeal Dismissed. The Supreme Court upheld the Gauhati High Court’s direction to promote the respondent to Group-A (Junior Scale) of IRAS with all consequential benefits, and awarded no costs.
Implications: The decision reiterates that, for promotion purposes, sealed-cover procedure cannot be invoked unless the employee is already suspended, charge-sheeted, or facing prosecution on the critical date. It strengthens the authority of K.V. Jankiraman and clarifies that subsequent initiation of proceedings does not retrospectively justify withholding promotion. The ruling directly affects only the parties and does not create new doctrine, but it reinforces settled principles on promotion and disciplinary proceedings within Indian public employment.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
P. Sathasivam, J.— Delay condoned. Leave granted. This appeal is directed against the judgment and order dated 27-4-2010 passed by the Gauhati High Court at Guwahati in Writ Petition (C) No. 744 of 2010 whereby the Division Bench of the High Court allowed the writ petition filed by the respondent herein and set aside the order dated 21-8-2009 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Guwahati Bench, Guwahati in OA No. 251 of 2007.
Brief facts
2. Anil Kumar Sarkar, the respondent herein, joined the Northern Railways as a Junior Clerk on 4-11-1977. He was promoted to various posts and while he was working as Senior AFA/T-1 in the office of the Financial Adviser and Chief Accounts Officer of Northeast Frontier (NF) Railway at Maligaon, a Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) was convened by the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) on 26-2-2002 and 27-2-2002 to consider eligible Group B officers of the Accounts Department for their substantive promotion to Group A (Junior Scale) of Indian Railways Accounts Service (IRAS) against the vacancies for various zonal railways/production units. In the said DPC, the respondent's name was also considered against the vacancies in NF Railway for the year 2001-2002 and accordingly, his name was placed in the extended select panel.
3. It was alleged by the appellants herein that during the year 1994-1995, while the respondent was working as Assistant Accounts Officer in the Central Stores Accounts (Bills) in the office of the Financial Adviser and Chief Accounts Officer (Open Line), NF Railway, Maligaon, he committed gross misconduct in the matter of checking and passing the bills of various firms involved in manufacturing and supplying of cast iron sleeper plates to NF Railways. For the said acts, four memorandums of charges were issued to the respondent, out of which two were issued on 13-8-2003 and others on 1-9-2003 and 5-11-2003. On the basis of the said memorandums, four departmental proceedings were initiated against the respondent at three different places i.e Delhi, Kolkata and Guwahati, enquiries were completed and show-cause notices were served.
4. Based on the similar charges, in the year 2004, CBI lodged 11 FIRs against the respondent herein on different dates under Sections 120-B/420 of the Penal Code, 1860 and Section 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and accordingly, cases were registered against him. Subsequently, 11 cases were amalgamated into 3 cases being numbered as Special Cases Nos. 59, 60 and 62 of 2004. According to the appellants, on the basis of these charges, the respondent was not promoted to Group A (Junior Scale).
5. By office order dated 21-4-2003, the batchmates of the respondent were promoted. Being aggrieved, the respondent herein filed several representations to the Department for consideration of his case for promotion which were duly rejected. Challenging the non-consideration of his case for promotion, the respondent filed OA No. 251 of 2007 before the Central Administrative Tribunal, Guwahati Bench for a direction to the appellants herein to promote him to Group A (Junior Scale) of IRAS w.e.f 5-3-2002 in terms of the recommendations of the DPC held on 26-2-2002 and 27-2-2002 wherein his name figured in the extended panel list. Vide order dated 21-8-2009, the Tribunal dismissed his application.
6. Challenging the order of the Tribunal, the respondent herein filed a petition being WP (C) No. 744 of 2010 before the Gauhati High Court. The High Court, by impugned order dated 27-4-2010, allowed the petition and set aside the order passed by the Tribunal and directed the appellants herein to issue appropriate order in favour of the respondent herein for promotion with all consequential benefits. Challenging the said order, the Union of India has filed this appeal by way of special leave.
7. Heard Mr Mohan Jain, learned Additional Solicitor General for the Union of India and Mr Rakesh Kumar Singh, learned counsel for the respondent.
Contentions
8. Mr Mohan Jain, learned ASG, after taking us through the Office Memorandum dated 14-9-1992 issued by the Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions, Department of Personnel and Training, submitted that Para 2 of the said memorandum has to be considered along with Para 7 of the same. According to him, the High Court is not justified in considering Para 2 of the memorandum alone. He further submitted that at the relevant time, four charge-sheets were issued to the respondent and enquiries were completed and notices to show cause had already been served upon the respondent.
9. On the other hand, Mr Rakesh Kumar Singh, learned counsel for the respondent submitted that as on the date i.e 21-4-2003, when his juniors were promoted, neither the respondent was under suspension nor any charge-sheet was served upon him and he was not facing any criminal prosecution, hence, there was no impediment in promoting him.
10. We have carefully considered the rival submissions and all the relevant materials including the decision of the Tribunal and the impugned order of the High Court.
Discussion
11. There is no dispute as to the fact that Office Memorandum No. 22011/4/91-Estt(A), Government of India, Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions, Department of Personnel and Training, New Delhi dated 14-9-1992 is applicable to the case on hand. In fact, the learned ASG appearing for the appellants and the learned counsel for the respondent heavily relied on the said memorandum. The relevant paragraphs for our present purpose are Paras 2 and 7 which are reproduced hereunder:
“No. 22011/4/91-Estt(A) Government of India Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions Department of Personnel and Training North Block, New Delhi 110 001 Dated: 14-9-1992 Office Memorandum Subject: Promotion of government servants against whom disciplinary/court proceedings are pending or whose conduct is under investigation. Procedure and guidelines to be allowed. Board's L/No. E (D&A) 88RG6-21 dated 21-9-1988 and 2-7-1990 In supersession of all instructions contained in Board's letters referred to in the margin on the above subject, the procedure and guidelines laid down below shall be followed in the matter of promotion from Group B to Group A and within Group A of Railway Officers against whom disciplinary/court proceedings are pending. 2. Cases of government servants to whom sealed cover procedure will be applicable.—At the time of consideration of the cases of government servants for empanelment details of government servants in the consideration zone for promotion falling under the following categories should be specifically brought to the notice of the Departmental Promotion Committee: (i) Government servants under suspension; (ii) Government servants in respect of whom a charge-sheet has been issued and the disciplinary proceedings are pending; (iii) Government servants in respect of whom prosecution for a criminal charge is pending. *** 7. Sealed cover procedure applicable to officers coming under cloud holding of DPC but before promotion.—A government servant, who is recommended for promotion by the Departmental Promotion Committee but in whose case any of the circumstances mentioned in Para 2 above arise after the recommendations of the DPC are received but before he is actually promoted, will be considered as if his case had been placed in a sealed cover by the DPC. He shall not be promoted until the conclusion of disciplinary case/criminal proceedings and the provisions contained in this letter will be applicable in his case also.”
12. It is not in dispute that the respondent had joined the Northern Railways as a Junior Clerk on 4-11-1977, and got promoted time and again. While he was working as a Group B officer, his case was taken up for promotion to Group A (Junior Scale) of the Indian Railways Accounts Service (IRAS). It is also not in dispute that in the meetings of the DPC conducted on 26-2-2002 and 27-2-2002, the respondent's name was considered and he was placed in the extended select panel. It is further seen that up to 21-4-2003, the date on which the respondent's batchmates were promoted to IRAS, neither any criminal proceedings was initiated against him nor any departmental enquiry was initiated, nor was any charge-sheet served upon him and nor was he placed under suspension. Aggrieved by the non-consideration of his representations for promotion, the respondent filed OA before the Central Administrative Tribunal. The learned counsel for the Railways, by placing reliance on the Office Memorandum dated 14-9-1992, contended before the Tribunal that a government servant who is recommended for promotion by the DPC and in whose case the circumstances mentioned in Para 2 are in existence, he shall not be promoted. Accepting the above stand of the Railways, the Tribunal rejected the petition filed by the respondent herein.
13. Aggrieved by the said decision of the Tribunal, the respondent herein filed a petition before the High Court, wherein, the said memorandum, particularly Para 2, was pressed into service. The High Court, taking note of the conditions prescribed in Para 2 and in the absence of any such condition as on the relevant date i.e 21-4-2003, set aside the order of the Tribunal and directed the Railways to consider the case of the respondent for promotion.
14. As per Para 2 of the said memorandum, at the time of consideration of the government servants for promotion, the following details of government servants in the consideration zone for promotion falling in the categories mentioned should be specifically brought to the notice of the DPC viz. (i) Government servant is under suspension; (ii) Government servant has been served with a charge-sheet and the disciplinary proceedings are pending; and (iii) Government servant is facing prosecution for a criminal charge and the said proceedings are pending. As rightly observed by the High Court, if the above conditions are available, even one of them, then the DPC has to apply the “sealed cover process”. In the case on hand, it is not in dispute that the relevant date is 21-4-2003, when the respondent's batchmates were promoted, admittedly on that date the respondent was not under suspension, no charge-sheet was served upon him nor was he facing any criminal prosecution. In such circumstances, in terms of Para 2 referred to above, the recommendation of the DPC has to be honoured and there is no question of applying “sealed cover process”.
15. Mr Mohan Jain, learned ASG submitted that Para 2 has to be read along with Para 7 of the Office Memorandum dated 14-9-1992. We have already extracted Para 7 of the memorandum which makes it clear that a government servant, who is recommended for promotion by the DPC if any of the circumstances mentioned in Para 2 of the said memorandum arises after the recommendations of the DPC are received, but before he is actually promoted, will be considered as if his case has been placed in a sealed cover by the DPC. After extracting Para 2, we also highlighted the three conditions prescribed therein. Though, the learned ASG has mentioned that four charge-sheets were issued to the respondent, enquires were completed and show-cause notices had already been served on the respondent, on the relevant date, namely, 21-4-2003, when his batchmates were promoted, none of the conditions was in existence in the case of the respondent. Admittedly, the respondent was not placed under suspension, charge-sheet had been issued only on 13-8-2003 i.e nearly after 4 months, no disciplinary proceedings were initiated or were pending as on 21-4-2003. In such circumstances, we are of the view that the High Court is fully justified in issuing the direction based on Para 2 of the memorandum. No doubt, the learned ASG heavily relied on the later part of Para 7 of the memorandum which reads as under:
“He shall not be promoted until the conclusion of disciplinary case/criminal proceedings and the provisions contained in this letter will be applicable in his case also.”
Inasmuch as none of the circumstances was in existence as on 21-4-2003, reliance placed on the later part of Para 7 cannot be accepted or even not be applicable.
16. It is not in dispute that an identical issue was considered by this Court in Union of India v. K.V Jankiraman (1991) 4 SCC 109, (1993) 23 ATC 322. The common questions involved in all those matters were:
“8. … (1) What is the date from which it can be said that disciplinary/criminal proceedings are pending against an employee? (2) What is the course to be adopted when the employee is held guilty in such proceedings if the guilt merits punishment other than that of dismissal? and (3) To what benefits an employee who is completely or partially exonerated is entitled to and from which date?”
Among the three questions, we are concerned about Question 1. As per the rules applicable, the “sealed cover procedure” is adopted when an employee is due for promotion, increment, etc. but disciplinary/criminal proceedings are pending against him at the relevant time and hence, the findings of his entitlement to the benefit are kept in a sealed cover to be opened after the proceedings in question are over.
17. Inasmuch as we are concerned about the first question, the dictum laid down by this Court relating to the said issue is as follows: (K.V Jankiraman case (1991) 4 SCC 109, (1993) 23 ATC 322)
“16. On the first question viz. as to when for the purposes of the sealed cover procedure the disciplinary/criminal proceedings can be said to have commenced, the Full Bench of the Tribunal has held that it is only when a charge memo in a disciplinary proceedings or a charge-sheet in a criminal prosecution is issued to the employee that it can be said that the departmental proceedings/criminal prosecution is initiated against the employee. The sealed cover procedure is to be resorted to only after the charge memo/charge-sheet is issued. The pendency of preliminary investigation prior to that stage will not be sufficient to enable the authorities to adopt the sealed cover procedure. We are in agreement with the Tribunal on this point. The contention advanced by the learned counsel for the appellant authorities that when there are serious allegations and it takes time to collect necessary evidence to prepare and issue charge memo/charge-sheet, it would not be in the interest of the purity of administration to reward the employee with a promotion, increment, etc. does not impress us. The acceptance of this contention would result in injustice to the employees in many cases. As has been the experience so far, the preliminary investigations take an inordinately long time and particularly when they are initiated at the instance of the interested persons, they are kept pending deliberately. Many times they never result in the issue of any charge memo/charge-sheet. If the allegations are serious and the authorities are keen in investigating them, ordinarily it should not take much time to collect the relevant evidence and finalise the charges. What is further, if the charges are that serious, the authorities have the power to suspend the employee under the relevant rules, and the suspension by itself permits a resort to the sealed cover procedure. The authorities thus are not without a remedy.”
In para 17, this Court further held: (K.V Jankiraman case (1991) 4 SCC 109, (1993) 23 ATC 322)
“17. … Conclusion 1 should be read to mean that the promotion, etc. cannot be withheld merely because some disciplinary/criminal proceedings are pending against the employee. To deny the said benefit, they must be at the relevant time pending at the stage when charge memo/charge-sheet has already been issued to the employee.”
After finding so, in the light of the fact that no charge-sheet was served on the respondent employee when the DPC met to consider his promotion, yet the sealed cover procedure was adopted. In such circumstances, this Court held that: (K.V Jankiraman case (1991) 4 SCC 109, (1993) 23 ATC 322)
“32. … The Tribunal has rightly directed the authorities to open the sealed cover and if the respondent was found fit for promotion by the DPC, to give him the promotion from the date his immediate junior Shri M. Raja Rao was promoted pursuant to the order dated 30-4-1986. The Tribunal has also directed the authorities to grant to the respondent all the consequential benefits. … We see no reason to interfere with this order. The appeal, therefore, stands dismissed.”
(emphasis supplied)
18. The principles laid down with reference to similar office memorandum are applicable to the case on hand and the contrary argument raised by the appellant Union of India is liable to be rejected.
19. In Coal India Ltd. v. Saroj Kumar Mishra (2007) 9 SCC 625, AIR 2007 SC 1706 this Court, in AIR para 22, has held that:
“18. A departmental proceeding is ordinarily said to be initiated only when a charge-sheet is issued.”
20. In Coal India Ltd. v. Ananta Saha (2011) 5 SCC 142 this Court held as under:
“27. There can be no quarrel with the settled legal proposition that the disciplinary proceedings commence only when a charge-sheet is issued to the delinquent employee. (Vide Union of India v. K.V Jankiraman (1991) 4 SCC 109, (1993) 23 ATC 322 and UCO Bank v. Rajinder Lal Capoor (2007) 6 SCC 694.)”
21. We also reiterate that the disciplinary proceedings commence only when a charge-sheet is issued. Departmental proceeding is normally said to be initiated only when a charge-sheet is issued.
22. The learned ASG, by drawing our attention to the decision of this Court in Union of India v. R.S Sharma (2000) 4 SCC 394 submitted that in spite of the decision of this Court in Jankiraman case (1991) 4 SCC 109, (1993) 23 ATC 322 in view of Para 7 of the Office Memorandum and in the light of the fact that proceedings were initiated both criminal and departmental, the High Court committed an error by overlooking Para 7 of the sealed cover process and contended that the direction issued by it cannot be sustained. We have carefully gone through the factual position and the ultimate ratio laid down by this Court in R.S Sharma case (2000) 4 SCC 394. Even though in the said decision, this Court has distinguished the decision in Jankiraman case (1991) 4 SCC 109, (1993) 23 ATC 322 and held that the same is not applicable to its case, in the light of the conditions mentioned in Para 2 as well as Para 7 of the Office Memorandum dated 14-9-1992 and of the categorical finding that none of the conditions mentioned therein has been fulfilled, we are of the view that the decision in R.S Sharma case (2000) 4 SCC 394 is not helpful to the case of the appellant.
23. In the light of the above discussion and in view of the factual position as highlighted in the earlier paras, we hold that the ratio laid down in Jankiraman case (1991) 4 SCC 109, (1993) 23 ATC 322 is fully applicable to the case on hand, hence we are in agreement with the ultimate decision of the High Court. Consequently, the appeal filed by the Union of India fails and the same is dismissed. However, there will be no order as to costs.
Alert