Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Rajendra Yadav v. State Of Madhya Pradesh And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Feb 13, 2013
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, Head Constable Rajendra Prasad Yadav, was stationed at Police Station Rahatgarh, District Sagar, Madhya Pradesh. A complaint by one Kundan Rajak alleged that the appellant, together with ASI Lakhan Tiwari and Constable Arjun Pathak, accepted Rs 3000 to avoid implicating certain accused persons in Crime No. 4 of 2002 (registered under Sections 341, 294, 323, 506 Part II and 34 IPC). A departmental charge-sheet dated 6-5-2002 was issued by the Superintendent of Police, Sagar, framing two charges: (1) negligence in duty and (2) misconduct by accepting the bribe.

An inquiry conducted by the Additional Superintendent of Police concluded that Charge 2 was “not proved” against the appellant for want of direct evidence, though it recorded his “tacit approval.” Despite this, the Superintendent of Police disagreed with the inquiry officer, issued a supplementary charge-sheet, and the Deputy Inspector General of Police ultimately dismissed the appellant from service. Constable Arjun Pathak, found to have actually demanded and received the money, was given the lesser punishment of compulsory retirement and was later reinstated with reduction of increment for one year. ASI Lakhan Tiwari was demoted for three years.

The appellant’s statutory appeal to the Inspector General of Police was dismissed on 9-12-2004. His writ petition before the Single Judge of the Madhya Pradesh High Court (decided 3-5-2007) and the subsequent writ appeal before the Division Bench (decided 6-9-2011) were also dismissed. The present appeal before the Supreme Court arose from that Division Bench decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the punishment of dismissal imposed on the appellant was grossly disproportionate to his proven involvement in the incident.
  2. Whether imposing a harsher punishment on the appellant than on co-delinquent Arjun Pathak, who played the primary role in demanding and receiving the bribe, violated the constitutional principle of equality under Article 14.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Both charges were not fully proved; therefore dismissal was unwarranted and disproportionate.
  • Evidence showed it was Constable Arjun Pathak who demanded and accepted the bribe; the appellant’s role was at most passive.
  • Imposing a lighter punishment on Pathak while dismissing the appellant was arbitrary and discriminatory, offending the parity principle recognised in Anand Regl. Coop. Oil Seedsgrowers' Union Ltd. v. Shaileshkumar Harshadbhai Shah (2006) 6 SCC 548.

Respondent State's Arguments

  • The High Court orders disclosed no legal error warranting interference.
  • The appellant, as a member of a disciplined force, bore responsibility; his tacit approval of the bribe could not be ignored.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
DG of Police v. G. Dasayan (1998) 2 SCC 407 Parity in punishment among co-delinquents; differential treatment may violate Article 14. Used to demonstrate that imposing a harsher penalty on a lesser-involved employee is impermissible.
Anand Regl. Coop. Oil Seedsgrowers' Union Ltd. v. Shaileshkumar Harshadbhai Shah (2006) 6 SCC 548 Employees guilty of identical misconduct are entitled to equal treatment in disciplinary outcomes. Relied upon to justify aligning the appellant’s penalty with the lighter punishment given to Arjun Pathak.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court scrutinised the departmental inquiry records and confirmed that Constable Arjun Pathak, not the appellant, demanded and received the bribe. While the appellant’s “tacit approval” was noted, his role was undeniably less culpable than Pathak’s.

Applying the doctrine of equality, the Court held that co-delinquents involved in the same incident must receive proportionate punishment. Citing DG of Police v. G. Dasayan and Shaileshkumar Harshadbhai Shah, the Court reasoned that awarding a lighter sanction to the principal offender (Pathak) and a harsher one to the appellant contravened Article 14. The disciplinary authority’s decision was therefore arbitrary and unsustainable.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed. The order dismissing the appellant from service is set aside. He is to be reinstated forthwith from the date on which Arjun Pathak was reinstated and is entitled to all consequential benefits accorded to Pathak. No order as to costs.

Implications: The judgment reinforces the principle that disciplinary authorities must maintain parity and proportionality in punishments among co-delinquents. A harsher sanction on a less-culpable participant, when the main offender receives a lighter penalty, will be struck down as violative of Article 14, but the ruling sets no new substantive precedent beyond this reaffirmation.

Show all summary ...

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

K.S.P Radhakrishnan, J.— Leave granted. The appellant, a police constable, while he was working in Police Station Rahatgarh, District Sagar along with ASI, Lakhan Tiwari and Head Constable, Jagdish Prasad Tiwari is stated to have received an amount of Rs 3000 for not implicating certain persons involved in Crime No. 4 of 2002 charged under Sections 341, 294, 323, 506 Part II and 34 IPC. A complaint to that effect was filed by one Kundan Rajak, a resident of Village Sothia, PS Rahatgarh. Acting on that complaint, the appellant was charge-sheeted, along with two others, vide proceedings dated 6-5-2002 by the Superintendent of Police, Sagar.

2. The following are the charges levelled against the appellant:

(1) He demonstrated gross negligence and lack of interest in discharge of his duty by not implicating all the persons involved in the crime.
(2) He demonstrated misconduct by accepting Rs 3000 from the complainant Kundan Rajak for lodging a report in the police station.

The appellant filed a detailed reply to the charge-sheet by his letter dated Nil and denied all the allegations.

3. A detailed inquiry was conducted through the Additional Superintendent of Police, Sagar against the appellant and other two persons, ASI Lakhan Tiwari and HC Jagdish Prasad Tiwari. During the course of the inquiry, the charge against Lakhan Tiwari was found not proved, but his role was found to be doubtful. So far as appellant Rajendra Prasad Yadav is concerned, it was held that one of the charges could not be proved for want of evidence. The inquiry report dated 8-9-2004, so far as the appellant is concerned, states as follows:

“Against Delinquent 2, HC No. 1104 Rajendra Prasad, one of the charges imputed could not be proved for want of evidence. During the course of departmental enquiry, the inquiry officer has noted that Charge 2 was also not proved from the statement of the prosecution witness and documents of the prosecution but one cannot deny the participation of the delinquent and his tacit approval.”

4. The Superintendent of Police, Sagar, however, vide his proceedings dated 26-3-2004, disagreed with the remarks of the inquiry officer and held that Charge 2 as against the appellant was found to be proved. Consequently, a supplementary charge-sheet was also given to the appellant. Later, a final order was passed by the Deputy Inspector General of Police, Sagar stating as follows:

“With respect to the delinquent HC No. 1104 Rajendra Yadav, the inquiry officer has stated vide his said letter that the delinquent HC was present in the police station during the report of Crime No. 4 of 2002. As per the evidence, the money was demanded by Constable Arjun Pathak. The report has been recorded by HC No. 1104 Rajendra Yadav whereas Rs 3000 was paid to Constable Arjun Pathak. Therefore, with regard to receiving money, the participation of HC Rajendra Yadav and his tacit approval are proved with respect to Charge 2. At the same time, he could not exercise his control over his subordinate. The money was demanded by Arjun Pathak and upon receipt of the money by Arjun Pathak, HC No. 1104 Rajendra Yadav lodged the report. Therefore, I am in disagreement with the view of the inquiry officer given in the inquiry report of the departmental enquiry that the charge is not proved against the delinquent HC Rajendra Prasad Yadav. As per the remark of the inquiry officer, the abovementioned Charge 2 imputed against HC No. 1104 Rajendra Prasad is found to be proved.”

5. On the basis of the above finding, Lakhan Tiwari was demoted for three years from the post of ASI to Head Constable. But the appellant and Jagdish Prasad Tiwari were dismissed from service. Aggrieved by the same, the appellant preferred an appeal before the Inspector General of Police (appellate authority), who dismissed the appeal vide his order dated 9-12-2004. The appellant then filed Writ Petition No. 10696 of 2007 before the High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Jabalpur Bench, which was dismissed by the learned Single Judge by his order dated 3-5-2007, against which Writ Appeal No. 11 of 2007 was also preferred, which was also dismissed by the Division Bench vide its impugned judgment dated 6-9-2011.

6. Mr Rakesh Khanna, learned counsel appearing for the appellant, submitted that since both the charges levelled against the appellant were not proved fully, the respondent Department was not justified in dismissing him from the service, which is grossly disproportionate to the gravity of the offence. Further, it was pointed out that there is nothing on the record to show that the appellant had demanded or accepted the alleged sum of Rs 3000 and it was proved in the inquiry that it was Constable Arjun Pathak who had demanded the abovementioned amount and he was, even though inflicted with the punishment of compulsory retirement, was later reinstated by imposing punishment of reduction of increment with cumulative effect for one year. The inquiry has clearly established that it was Arjun Pathak who had demanded and accepted the illegal gratification from the complainant, but he has been given a lighter punishment while the appellant was imposed a harsher punishment, which is clearly arbitrary and discriminatory. The learned counsel placed considerable reliance on the judgment of this Court in Anand Regl. Coop. Oil Seedsgrowers' Union Ltd. v. Shaileshkumar Harshadbhai Shah (2006) 6 SCC 548 and claimed parity, if not fully exonerated.

7. Shri Arjun Garg, learned counsel appearing for the respondent State, submitted that there is no illegality in the views expressed by the learned Single Judge and the Division Bench calling for any interference. Further, it was pointed out that since the appellant, being a member of a disciplined force, should not have involved in such an incident and his tacit approval could not be brushed aside because it had taken place in his presence.

8. We have gone through the inquiry report placed before us in respect of the appellant as well as Constable Arjun Pathak. The inquiry clearly reveals the role of Arjun Pathak. It was Arjun Pathak who had demanded and received the money, though the tacit approval of the appellant was proved in the inquiry. The charge levelled against Arjun Pathak was more serious than the one charged against the appellant. Both the appellants and other two persons as well as Arjun Pathak were involved in the same incident. After having found that Arjun Pathak had a more serious role and, in fact, it was he who had demanded and received the money, he was inflicted comparatively a lighter punishment. At the same time, the appellant who had played a passive role was inflicted with a more serious punishment of dismissal from service which, in our view, cannot be sustained.

9. The doctrine of equality applies to all who are equally placed; even among persons who are found guilty. The persons who have been found guilty can also claim equality of treatment, if they can establish discrimination while imposing punishment when all of them are involved in the same incident. Parity among co-delinquents has also to be maintained when punishment is being imposed. Punishment should not be disproportionate while comparing the involvement of co-delinquents who are parties to the same transaction or incident. The disciplinary authority cannot impose punishment which is disproportionate i.e lesser punishment for serious offences and stringent punishment for lesser offences.

10. The principle stated above is seen applied in a few judgments of this Court. The earliest one is DG of Police v. G. Dasayan (1998) 2 SCC 407 wherein one Dasayan, a police constable, along with two other constables and one Head Constable were charged for the same acts of misconduct. The disciplinary authority exonerated two other constables, but imposed the punishment of dismissal from service on Dasayan and that of compulsory retirement on the Head Constable. This Court, in order to meet the ends of justice, substituted the order of compulsory retirement in place of the order of dismissal from service on Dasayan, applying the principle of parity in punishment among co-delinquents. This Court held that it may, otherwise, violate Article 14 of the Constitution of India.

11. In Shaileshkumar Harshadbhai Shah case (2006) 6 SCC 548 the workman was dismissed from service for proved misconduct. However, few other workmen, against whom there were identical allegations, were allowed to avail of the benefit of voluntary retirement scheme. In such circumstances, this Court directed that the workman also be treated on the same footing and be given the benefit of voluntary retirement from service from the month on which the others were given the benefit.

12. We are of the view that the principle laid down in the abovementioned judgments would also apply to the facts of the present case. We have already indicated that the action of the disciplinary authority imposing a comparatively lighter punishment on the co-delinquent Arjun Pathak and at the same time, harsher punishment on the appellant cannot be permitted in law, since they were all involved in the same incident. Consequently, we are inclined to allow the appeal by setting aside the punishment of dismissal from service imposed on the appellant and order that he be reinstated in service forthwith. The appellant is, therefore, to be reinstated from the date on which Arjun Pathak was reinstated and be given all consequential benefits as were given to Arjun Pathak. Ordered accordingly. However, there will be no order as to costs.