Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Kashi Vishwanath v. State Of Karnataka .

Supreme Court Of India
Jul 3, 2013
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant (Accused 1) was tried along with his mother (Accused 2) and one Lakshmi (Accused 3) for offences under Sections 498-A and 302 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code. The prosecution alleged that on 14 January 2000 the appellant and Lakshmi poured kerosene on the appellant’s wife, Neelamma, and set her ablaze while the appellant’s mother stood by. Neelamma suffered extensive burns and died on 18 January 2000. Three written dying declarations were recorded during her hospitalisation.

The First Additional Sessions Judge, Dharwad (Sessions Case No. 119 of 2000) convicted the appellant and Lakshmi, sentencing each to one year’s rigorous imprisonment and a fine of ₹1,000 for the Section 498-A charge and life imprisonment plus a ₹2,000 fine for the murder charge. The mother-in-law was acquitted.

On appeal, the High Court of Karnataka (Criminal Appeal No. 347 of 2001, judgment dated 27 July 2004) affirmed the appellant’s conviction and sentence but acquitted the mother-in-law. The appellant then filed the present appeal before the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant’s conviction for murder and cruelty could be sustained when the prosecution evidence consisted mainly of three dying declarations that were allegedly inconsistent and recorded in a language the deceased did not understand.
  2. Whether, in the absence of eyewitnesses and with hostile independent witnesses, the prosecution proved the charges beyond reasonable doubt.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • The four written records (including the MLC entry) labelled as dying declarations were mutually contradictory, rendering them unreliable.
  • Oral statements allegedly made to relatives should be disregarded given the inconsistencies in the formal declarations.
  • The deceased spoke only Telugu, yet the declarations were recorded in Kannada without any evidence of translation, undermining their authenticity.
  • Cited Mehiboobsab Abbasabi Nadaf v. State of Karnataka to emphasise that inconsistent dying declarations cannot form the sole basis of conviction.

State’s Arguments

  • The MLC entry (Ext. P-18) was not a dying declaration; the genuine declarations were Exts. P-12, P-22 and P-29.
  • Ext. P-12 was the earliest declaration, recorded by a magistrate soon after admission, and should be accepted as truthful.
  • Ext. P-29 was recorded after the patient had stabilised for a day, enhancing its reliability.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mehiboobsab Abbasabi Nadaf v. State of Karnataka, (2007) 13 SCC 112 Conviction based on a dying declaration requires that the declaration be voluntary, truthful and consistent; caution is mandated where multiple declarations are inconsistent. The Supreme Court invoked this principle to scrutinise the three declarations, holding that their contradictions and language issues precluded safe reliance on them.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court noted the complete absence of eyewitnesses and the hostility of neighbouring witnesses. Consequently, the prosecution’s case rested almost entirely on three dying declarations (Exts. P-12, P-22 and P-29).

  • Internal contradictions: Each declaration presented a different sequence of events—ranging from the deceased pouring kerosene on herself at her husband’s instigation to the husband and Lakshmi jointly pouring kerosene and igniting her.
  • Language discrepancy: Evidence indicated the deceased spoke only Telugu, yet the declarations were written in Kannada. The record was silent on who translated or whether the statements were read back in Telugu, creating doubt about their accuracy.
  • Physical capacity to sign: The first declaration bore the deceased’s thumb impression, whereas the latter two noted she could not sign because her hands were burnt, casting further doubt on the integrity of the documents.
  • Medical testimony: One doctor acknowledged that 90–95 % burns had been sustained and sedatives administered, raising questions about the victim’s mental fitness when later statements were recorded.

Applying the cautionary principle from Mehiboobsab Abbasabi Nadaf, the Court found that the inconsistencies and procedural irregularities undermined the reliability of all three declarations. Because the prosecution offered no other convincing evidence, it failed to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt. Both the trial court and the High Court were therefore held to have erred.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED; CONVICTION AND SENTENCE SET ASIDE.

The appellant is to be released forthwith. The decision provides relief solely to the appellant and does not establish a new legal doctrine, but it reinforces the existing requirement that courts exercise great caution before convicting on the basis of multiple, inconsistent dying declarations, especially where language and procedural safeguards are in question.

Show all summary ...

S.J Mukhopadhaya, J.— The appellant, who is Accused 1, by this appeal has challenged the judgment dated 27-7-2004 in Kashi Vishwanath v. State of Karnataka Criminal Appeal No. 347 of 2001 passed by the Division Bench of the High Court of Karnataka at Bangalore whereby the High Court affirmed the conviction and sentenced imposed by the trial court under Sections 498-A and 302 read with Section 34 IPC. So far as Accused 2 is concerned, the High Court acquitted her of all the charges levelled against her.

2. The appellant along with other accused faced charges punishable under Sections 498-A and 302 read with Section 34 IPC. The First Additional Sessions Judge, Dharwad, sitting at Hubli by his judgment dated 1-2-2001 in Sessions Case No. 119 of 2000, acquitted Accused 2 under Section 235(1) CrPC of the offences under Sections 498-A and 302 IPC but convicted Accused 1 and 3 under Section 235(2) CrPC for the offences under Sections 498-A and 302 read with Section 34 IPC. They were sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for one year by each and to pay a fine of Rs 1000 by each, in default to undergo further rigorous imprisonment for one month, for the offence under Section 498-A IPC. They were sentenced to undergo life imprisonment and to pay a fine of Rs 2000 by each, in default, to undergo rigorous imprisonment for three months by each for the offence under Section 302 IPC.

3. In appeal, the High Court by its judgment dated 27-7-2004 Criminal Appeal No. 347 of 2001 allowed the appeal in part. The judgment of conviction and sentence passed by the Sessions Judge as against Accused 1 (the first appellant before the High Court) for the offence under Sections 498-A and 302 read with Section 34 IPC was confirmed giving rise to this appeal and as against Accused 2 (the second appellant before the High Court), she was acquitted of all the charges levelled against her.

4. The case of the prosecution, in brief, as unfurled before the trial court is as follows: the deceased, Neelamma (alias Leelamma) got married to the appellant herein 13 years prior to the incident. The date of the incident is 14-1-2000. From the wedlock, they have two sons and a daughter and they were all living at Mantur Road, Ambedkar Colony, Hubli.

5. According to the prosecution, the relationship between the husband and wife was cordial till two years prior to the incident. The disruptions started in the family on account of the appellant developing intimacy with one Lakshmi, who was Accused 3 and was the second appellant before the High Court. In this regard, in spite of intervention of the family members of the parental house of the deceased and persistent resistance of the deceased, the said affair of intimacy continued. There used to be bickering and quarrels between the husband and wife in this regard. Though Accused 2, the mother of the appellant was living with them, she never tried to patch up the differences between the husband and wife. Ultimately, on 14-1-2000 at about 10.00 a.m in the matrimonial home of the deceased, Accused 1 and 3 doused deceased Neelamma and set her ablaze while Accused 2 was watching outside. On the same day in the afternoon, she was shifted to KMC Hospital, Hubli and on admission, the hospital authorities intimated the police who came into picture at about 9.30-10.00 p.m in the night. Prior to that, the Taluka Executive Magistrate, PW 10, recorded her statement as per Ext. P-12. One more statement, Ext. P-22, dying declaration, came to be recorded by Rayappa, Police Sub-Inspector (PW 23), in the form of complaint in the presence of Dr Bhimappa (PW 22) and during the course of treatment, deceased Neelamma succumbed to burns on 18-1-2000 at about 6.15 p.m On 15-1-2000, at about 5.30 p.m, Ashok (PW 24), the investigating officer recorded the dying declaration, Ext. P-29 in the presence of Dr Komal Prasad (PW 25). On the basis of Ext. P-22, investigation of the case commenced as against Accused 1 to 3. The kith and kin of the deceased were examined as Pullayya (PW 5), maternal uncle; Eliya (PW 6), father; Grasamma (PW 7), maternal aunt; Padmavathi (PW 8), mother and Prabhudas (PW 9), uncle of the deceased. The purpose of examining these witnesses was to establish harassment, motive and oral dying declaration implicating Accused 1 to 3. The independent witnesses, who were the neighbours of the appellant i.e Mansuresh (PW 11), Savakka (PW 13), Kanechanamma (PW 14), M. Saloman (PW 15) and Perumal (PW 16) were also examined. Unfortunately, none of them have supported the case of the prosecution.

6. Ext. P-1 is the spot mahazar drawn in the kitchen of the matrimonial home of the deceased where burnt clothes, burnt gunny bag, matchbox, matchstick, a kerosene stove and a kerosene can were found. PW 2 and PW 3 were examined to support the contents of Ext. P-2 to Ext. P-6, mahazars seizing caste certificate and marriage certificate revealing the relationship and the case of the deceased and Accused 1 and 2. Ext. P-3 is the recovery of bedsheet alleged to have been used by Accused 2 to extinguish the fire. Letters i.e Ext. P-8 and Ext. P-9 alleged to have been written by the appellant to the wife and parents-in-law, Ext. P-5 is the seizure mahazar of letters (Exts. P-10 to P-11) alleged to have been written by the deceased to her parents, aunt and uncle and lastly Ext. P-6 is the seizure mahazar of photographs of the deceased revealing the burns. Peshalal (PW 4) was examined to speak the inquest over the dead body as per Ext. P-7 but turned hostile. Prabhakar (PW 21) also turned hostile. Dr Radha (PW 17) was the doctor at the casualty ward in KMC Hospital who entered the details in MLC register and the relevant document is at Ext. P-18. Dr Jagadish (PW 18) conducted autopsy on the dead body and issued Ext. P-19, the post-mortem report opining that the death of the deceased Neelamma was due to septicaemia as a result of burns. Ext. P-20 is the sketch drawn by PW 19. Dr Bhimappa (PW 22) is the Head of Department of the Burns Ward in whose presence Rayappa (PW 23), PSI, Bendigeri PS, Hubli recorded the complaint as per Ext. P-22 on 14-1-2000 and sent FIR to the court.

7. As noticed above, the learned Sessions Court based on the oral and documentary evidence held Accused 1 and 3 guilty of the offence punishable under Sections 498-A and 302 read with Section 34 IPC. Accused 2, mother-in-law of the deceased was acquitted of all the charges levelled against her.

8. The learned counsel for the appellant contended that the prosecution absolutely failed to establish any of the charges, much less, the charge under Section 302 IPC in view of four dying declarations brought on record which are contrary to each other. It was further contended that the oral declarations made before the kith and kin of the deceased are not at all important or relevant in the light of the four dying declarations. According to the learned counsel, the contents of Ext. P-18, Ext. P-12, Ext. P-22 and Ext. P-29, if looked into carefully, would indicate the purpose of so many dying declarations coming into existence i.e only to ensure that all the accused are somehow roped in. The learned counsel for the appellant placed reliance on the decisions of this Court in Mehiboobsab Abbasabi Nadaf v. State of Karnataka (2007) 13 SCC 112 which will be referred to in this judgment at the appropriate stage.

9. In reply, the learned counsel for the State submitted that Ext. P-18 was not a dying declaration but the entries in the MLC register were made immediately on the admission of the patient to the hospital. Ext. P-12 was the actual dying declaration recorded by the Taluka Executive Magistrate (PW 10). Ext. P-22 was a complaint recorded by Rayappa, PSI (PW 23), in the presence of Dr Bhimappa (PW 22) and further investigation was taken up. Therefore, the contents of Ext. P-12, according to the counsel for the State have to be taken into consideration which is the earliest dying declaration. He further contended that Ext. P-29 is more reliable because after treatment for almost a day, when the patient was physically and mentally fit, the same came to be recorded.

10. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant also raised doubt relating to contents of Ext. P-12, Ext. P-22 and Ext. P-29, the three dying declarations which were originally recorded in Kannada. According to the learned counsel for the appellant, the deceased had no knowledge of Kannada language and could speak only Telugu.

11. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties at length and gone through the entire material placed before us.

12. The kith and kin of the deceased who were examined are: Pullayya (PW 5) maternal uncle; Eliya (PW 6), father; Gracemma (PW 7), maternal aunt, Padmavathi (PW 8), mother and Prabhudas (PW 9), uncle of the deceased. Their deposition corroborates the case of the prosecution that one or two years prior to the death of the deceased, everything seemed to be cordial between the husband and wife (the deceased). After the appellant joined the railway services on compassionate ground after the death of his father, the bickering and quarrel commenced because of him developing intimacy with a co-worker by name Lakshmi who was the third accused. Exts. P-8 to P-11 are inland letters produced by the uncle and father of the deceased, PW 5 and PW 6 and the letters pertaining to the year 1995 written by the deceased which say that except some harassment and ill-treatment, there was no serious harassment to the deceased at the hands of her husband and mother-in-law of the deceased. The letter written in the year 1999 would only indicate that on account of the appellant developing intimacy with Lakshmi, he ill-treated and harassed her to the maximum extent possible. Accused 2 mother-in-law was only a spectator. This was her complaint or depression recorded in her letters written to the kith and kin.

13. When we look into the statement of independent witnesses produced by the prosecution, who are neighbours of the appellant i.e Mansuresh (PW 11), Savakka (PW 13), Kanechanamma (PW 14), M. Saloman (PW 15) and Perumal (PW 16), we find that none of them have supported the case of the prosecution.

14. In this case, we have noted that there is no eyewitness to the incident in question. The prosecution primarily relies on three dying declarations, Ext. P-12, Ext. P-22 and Ext. P-29. In support of those exhibits the prosecution relied on the statements of the Tahsildar, Hubli (PW 10) and Dhanjaya Kumar, PG student (PW 20) present at the time of arrival of Maharudrappa, Tahsildar (PW 10) at the Burns Ward. Dr Radha (PW 17) who examined the deceased; Dr Jagdish (PW 18), who was working as medical officer on 14-1-2000 and conducted the post-mortem; Dr Bhimappa (PW 22), in whose presence Ext. P-22 was recorded; Rayappa (PW 23), PSI, Bendigeri Police Station, Crime Branch, Hubli who recorded the dying declaration (Ext. P-22) and registered the case; Dr Komal Prasad (PW 25), in whose presence Ext. P-29 was recorded, etc.

15. In Mehiboobsab Abbasabi Nadaf v. State of Karnataka (2007) 13 SCC 112 having noticed multiple dying declarations this Court held:

“7. Conviction can indisputably be based on a dying declaration. But, before it can be acted upon, the same must be held to have been rendered voluntarily and truthfully. Consistency in the dying declaration is the relevant factor for placing full reliance thereupon. In this case, the deceased herself had taken contradictory and inconsistent stand in different dying declarations. They, therefore, should not be accepted on their face value. Caution, in this behalf, is required to be applied.”

16. We will now examine the contents of three different dying declarations i.e Ext. P-12, Ext. P-22 and Ext. P-29 and the related prosecution witnesses who deposed in support of such dying declarations.

17. Maharudrappa (PW 10), Tahsildar, Hubli recorded the dying declaration, Ext. P-12, at 8.30 p.m on 14-1-2000 in Ward No. 202, the deceased stated that she was conscious to give answer to the questions. She got married with the appellant at the age of 26 years, about 13 years back. She had two sons and one daughter. She was a housewife and her husband was working in the Railways and used to come home once in a week. She was staying at Mantur Road, Ganesh Pet, Hubli. She stated that she had been brought at KMC Hospital, Hubli by her mother-in-law, Smt Polamma by autorickshaw, after she having sustained burn injuries at about 8.30 a.m in her residence. At about 12 p.m she had been admitted there for treatment by her mother-in-law. Her husband had not come to see her after the incident. Her mother-in-law was accompanying her in the hospital. She further stated that her husband (the appellant herein) had illicit relations with one Lakshmi. Every week he used to come home and for one or the other reason, used to fight and beat her ruthlessly. Her mother-in-law used to keep quiet without objecting for such acts of her son. It is stated in Ext. P-12 on the said date (14-1-2000) at about 8.30 a.m, when her children had gone out of the residence, her husband had a fight with her and instigated her to pour kerosene upon her body. She poured the kerosene on her body and her husband further poured kerosene upon her and put on fire with matchbox. At that time her mother-in-law was out of the residence. When the flame was catching her sari and burning her body, her husband had not tried to douse the fire. Neighbouring people rushed to her residence on hearing her screams and doused the fire by pouring water. Thereafter, her mother-in-law had brought her to the hospital by auto and admitted for treatment. Both her husband and Lakshmi are responsible for her condition. At the bottom of Ext. P-12 where thumb impression of the victim is taken it is written “read over and accepted to be correct”.

18. The Tahsildar (PW 10) in his statement stated that while he was working as Tahsildar in Hubli, on 14-1-2000 at 7.25 p.m, he received a requisition from Town Police Station, Hubli, to record the dying declaration of Neelamma, wife of Kashi Vishwanath Murari. He had recorded the dying declaration of the said Neelamma on 14-1-2000 from 8.30 p.m to 9.00 p.m The doctor opined that she was in a condition to give the dying declaration. He put the questions to Neelamma and she answered. After recording it, it was read over to her. Admitting its contents she put her thumb impression on it and the doctor also signed. Dying declaration is marked at Ext. P-12, and the signatures of the witness are marked at Ext. P-12(a).

19. Dr Dhanjaya Kumar (PW 20), who was working as PG student in KMC, Hubli stated that on 14-1-2000 at about 8.30 p.m the Tahsildar, Hubli came to KMC Ward No. 202. He was on duty there. The Tahsildar asked him about the patient's condition. He examined the patient and she was fit to give the statement. The Tahsildar recorded the statement of the injured and he examined again and found her alright. He was present when the Tahsildar recorded the statement of the injured. He had also signed on that statement. The signatures of the witness are marked at Ext. P-12(b) and the certificate of the witness is marked at Ext. P-12(c). In the cross-examination he stated that Dr A.S Bekanalkar, Unit Chief did not give anything in writing asking him to be present and examine the injured lady. The Tahsildar, Hubli did not give requisition in writing with a request to be present there and examine that injured lady. He has not given in writing separately about the fitness condition of injured Neelamma. From 8.00 a.m he was on duty in Ward No. 202 of KMC on 14-1-2000. He had not given treatment to Neelamma but his colleague had given treatment. On Ext. P-12 it is not specifically written that Neelamma was examined twice. He specifically stated that he can understand Kannada language. He does not know Telugu language. Neelamma was talking in Telugu language. He further stated that it is incorrect to suggest that at that time Neelamma was not in fit condition.

20. The second dying declaration is Ext. P-22 recorded by the PSI, Bendigeri PS, Hubli at 9.45 p.m on 14-1-2000. In the said dying declaration, the deceased disclosed her name and address as Neelamma alias Lilamma, w/o Kashi Vishwanath of Mantoor Road, Ambedkar Colony, Hubli. She along with her husband Kashi Vishwanath, mother-in-law Polamma, and her children, Sandya, Prasanna and Naveen were staying at home. Her husband had illicit and immoral relation with one Laxmi, who has been working as sweeper in Railways. Her husband and mother-in-law used to quarrel with her and on 14-1-2000 at about 10.00 a.m her husband started quarrelling with her at the behest of Laxmi and along with Laxmi poured kerosene on her body and put on fire by using matchstick. She further stated that she could not put her signatures since her hand was completely burnt. At the bottom of it, it was mentioned that dying declaration was “read over and accepted to be correct”.

21. Rayappa, PW 23, PSI, Bendigeri PS, Hubli who recorded the dying declaration, Ext. P-22 stated that while he was working as PSI, Bendigeri Crime Branch on 14-1-2000 the Police Inspector gave an order and directed me to go to KMC and record the statement of Neelamma. He went to KMC, Hubli at 9.45 p.m and gave the order to the doctor. The doctor opined that she was in a condition to give the statement. He recorded the statement of Neelamma in the presence of doctor. The statement is Ext. P-22. He has signed on it and the doctor has also signed on Ext. P-22.

22. Dr Bhimappa (PW 22), Medical Officer, District Hospital, Bagalkot stated that on 14-1-2000 he was the medical officer in KMC, Hubli. On 14-1-2000 he was on duty in KMC, Bendigeri Police recorded the statement of the injured. The statement is marked at Ext. P-22. It bears his signatures at Ext. 22(a). The injured was in a position to give statement. Ext. P-22 was recorded in his presence. In cross-examination he accepted that the police officer of Bendigeri Police Station had not given any requisition in writing requesting him to be present while recording such statements. He further accepted that on Ext. P-22 he had not endorsed that Neelamma was in a fit condition to give a statement. He further stated that he was not aware whether Neelamma was talking in Telugu.

23. Padmavathi (PW 8), coolie by occupation, is the mother of Neelamma. She stated that after the marriage of the appellant and her daughter Neelamma, their relationship was good, later the appellant used to complain that Neelamma had not brought any dowry. Neelamma was complaining that she was ill-treated and harassed by the appellant and he was intending to marry another woman. They convened a panchayat and advised the appellant. Even after advice harassment was continued. Her daughter was beaten 2-3 times, and she left her matrimonial home and resided with her mother. The appellant took her back to his house. The appellant was suspecting her daughter. She stated that Pullayya had phoned her about the incident. She along with her husband, son-in-law came to Hubli. When they went to KMC Neelamma was talking properly, when they asked Neelamma she told that Accused 1 (appellant) to Accused 3 closed the door of the house, Accused 3 poured kerosene and Accused 1 set her on fire. Accused 2, mother-in-law was outside the house, closing the door. During her cross-examination, PW 8 specifically stated that Neelamma did not know correct writing in Telugu but she used to write some Telugu. She had some written letters which have been given to the police. She does not know that those letters were written by Neelamma or not.

24. The contents of the third dying declaration, Ext. P-29 were recorded by Bendigeri Police on 15-1-2000 in the presence of Dr Komal Prasad (PW 25), a PG student in KMC, Hubli. In the said dying declaration (Ext. P-29), deceased Neelamma stated that she had been residing at the abovementioned address i.e Mantur Road, Ambedkar Colony, Hubli along with her husband, mother-in-law, Polamma, and three children. She was a housewife. Her husband Vishwanath was working in SNI Division, Railways at present employed at Karat. Often he visited the house. Two days prior i.e Thursday, 13-1-2000, she was confronted and slapped on the right cheek by one Laxmi of Mantur Road, Hanchandra Colony, who had illicit relation with her husband. She returned to her house having decided to inform about the incident to her husband. She had informed her husband about the incident when he came to house at 7.30 p.m on the same day. Then he had scolded and thrashed her by saying that why you had spoken to Laxmi. She kept quiet. Next morning i.e Friday, 14-1-2000 while she was cleaning the utensils, her husband came along with Laxmi, and thrashed her by saying that what can she do if he kept Laxmi in the said house. Then he dragged her inside the house and closed the door. Her mother-in-law also supported her husband and went outside. At that time Laxmi was inside the house. Her husband poured kerosene on her and Laxmi lit the matchstick and threw on her body, due to the flames, fire spread all over her body, she rushed outside the house screaming for help. Then neighbours and workers who were at the site came and doused the fire by wrapping her body with blanket. After being scolded by the neighbours her mother-in-law had taken her to KMC Hospital by auto. The incident took place at around 10.00 a.m She further stated that she had been harassed and tormented quite often by her husband and mother-in-law since one year and Laxmi was responsible for the said incident. She further stated that she could not put her signatures since her hand was burnt. Her children had been to school at the time of the incident. Below the dying declaration it was written that the same was “read over and accepted to be correct”.

25. Dr Komal Prasad (PW 25) in his statement stated that on 15-1-2000 he was on duty in KMC, Hubli. Bendigeri Police Officer had come to KMC on 15-1-2000 and asked his opinion about the fit condition of one Neelamma, the injured to give a statement. He examined her, and stated that she was in a fit condition to give a statement. The police officer recorded her statement in his presence and he had also signed on that statement. The statement is Ext. P-29. The signature of the witness is marked at Ext. P-29(a). The statement was recorded at 5.25 p.m In his cross-examination, he stated that Neelamma had sustained nearly 90% to 95% burn injuries. She was admitted on previous day and it was 1½ day when he gave his opinion. She was given the sedative injection.

26. Dr Radha (PW 17), Assistant Surgeon, KMC, Hubli, in her deposition stated that she was working as medical officer in KMC, Hubli. On 14-1-2000 at 11.45 a.m, she examined one Neelamma, wife of Kashi Vishwanath Murari, who had sustained burn injuries. The history was self-afflicted burns due to a quarrel at home at 11 a.m with her husband. The patient was conscious. On examination she noticed superficial deep burns over the lower part of face, lower half of chest and abdomen. Both the upper limbs and both the lower limbs were also burnt, sparing the face, neck, upper part of chest, parts of back in patches, groin and soles of the feet. She had sustained burn injuries from 70% to 75%. Eyebrows and hair of Neelamma were singed. She was admitted to female surgical ward. The patient was brought by her mother-in-law, namely, Polamma Venkatayya. In her cross-examination she stated that such burn injuries are possible if fire catches the lower end of saree of a woman.

27. We have noticed the three dying declarations (Ext. P-12, Ext. P-22 and Ext. P-29). A comparison of the three dying declarations, in our opinion, shows certain glaring contradictions. In the first dying declaration (Ext. P-12), we have noticed that deceased Neelamma stated that she sustained burn injuries in the early morning at 8.30 a.m, when her children had gone out of the residence, her husband had a fight with her and instigated her to pour kerosene upon her body. She poured the kerosene on her body and her husband had also further poured kerosene upon her and put her on fire with matchbox. While in the second dying declaration (Ext. P-22), Neelamma (the deceased) stated that her husband and mother-in-law used to quarrel with her and on 14-1-2000 at about 10.00 a.m her husband had started fight with her at the behest of Laxmi and along with Laxmi poured kerosene on her body and put on fire by using matchstick. In the third dying declaration (Ext. P-29), Neelamma (the deceased) stated that next morning i.e Friday, 14-1-2000 while she was cleaning the utensils, her husband came along with Laxmi, and thrashed her by saying that what can you do if he kept Laxmi in the said house. Then he dragged her inside the house and closed the door, her mother-in-law also supported her husband and went outside. At that time Laxmi was inside the house. Her husband poured kerosene on her and Laxmi lit the matchstick and threw upon her body, due to the flames, fire spread all over her body, she rushed outside the house screaming for help.

28. In the first dying declaration (Ext. P-12), she (the deceased) stated that her husband instigated her to pour kerosene on her body, therefore, she poured the kerosene on her body and her husband further poured kerosene on her and put on fire using a matchbox. In the second dying declaration (Ext. P-22), she (the deceased) stated that her husband along with Laxmi poured kerosene on her body and put on fire by using matchstick. In the third dying declaration (Ext. P-29), she (the deceased) stated that her husband poured kerosene on her and Laxmi lit the matchstick and threw upon her body.

29. Apart from the contradictions, the credibility of the three dying declarations (Ext. P-12, Ext. P-22 and Ext. P-29) is to be doubted. In the first dying declaration (Ext. P-12) dated 14-1-2000 the thumb impression of the victim has been shown. Whereas in the second dying declaration (Ext. P-22) taken on the same day i.e 14-1-2000 and the third dying declaration (Ext. P-29) given on the next day i.e 15-1-2000, the victim had stated that she had not given her signatures since her hand was completely burnt. Dr Bhimappa (PW 22), who signed Ext. P-22, in his cross-examination stated that he was not aware whether Neelamma (the deceased) was talking in Telugu. Dr Dhanjaya Kumar (PW 20), who signed Ext. P-12, in his cross-examination specifically stated that he can understand Kannada but does not know Telugu language and that Neelamma was talking in Telugu language. Padmavathi (PW 8), mother of the deceased, in her cross-examination stated that Neelamma (the deceased) was not knowing the correct writing in Telugu. But she was writing some Telugu.

30. The prosecution has failed to state as to why three dying declarations were recorded in Kannada, if the deceased Neelamma was talking in Telugu. It has also not been made clear as to who amongst the Tahsildar, PSI or SI or the doctors who had signed Ext. P-12, Ext. P-22 and Ext. P-29 had knowledge of Telugu and translated the same in Kannada for writing dying declarations in those exhibits and that at the bottom of three dying declarations it has not been mentioned that they were read over in Kannada and explained in Telugu and that the deceased understood the contents of the same. The abovementioned facts create doubt in our mind as to the truthfulness of the contents of the dying declarations as the possibility of the deceased being influenced by somebody in making the dying declarations cannot be ruled out.

31. On a careful perusal of the materials on record, we are unable to come to the conclusion that the prosecution in this case has established its case beyond reasonable doubt to base a conviction of the appellant. Hence, we are of the opinion that both the courts below have erred in coming to the contra conclusion.

32. For the reasons stated above, this appeal succeeds and the judgment and conviction recorded by the courts below are set aside. The appeal is allowed. The appellant, who is in jail, is directed to be released forthwith.