- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Geomin Minerals And Marketing Private Limited v. State Of Orissa And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The dispute concerns competing applications for prospecting licences (PL) and mining leases (ML) over iron-ore–bearing lands in the State of Orissa. Two sets of areas were made available by State notifications dated 20-8-1991 and 23-8-1991. Geomin Minerals & Marketing (P) Ltd. applied on the first date of availability (29-10-1991) for 186 hectares that later formed part of a larger 2500-hectare tract sought by Posco India (P) Ltd., whose PL application was filed in 2005.
The State Government initially recommended 6204.352 ha in Posco’s favour (19-12-2006). That recommendation was set aside by the Central Government acting as Revisional Authority on 27-9-2007, directing simultaneous consideration of all 203 pending applications. After fresh hearings, the State prepared an inter se merit chart (17-10-2008) and, on 9-1-2009, recommended 2500 ha for Posco under Sections 11(3) and 11(5) of the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 (MMDR Act).
Geomin challenged the impending recommendation by writ petition (WP (C) No. 23 of 2009). On 14-7-2010 the Orissa High Court allowed the writ, held that Geomin had a preferential right, and quashed the State’s recommendation, directing a fresh decision. The State of Orissa, Posco and Geomin filed independent special-leave appeals to the Supreme Court, which were heard together along with interventions by other applicants such as Kudremukh Iron Ore Company.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Geomin’s writ petition before the High Court was premature in view of the Central Government’s yet-to-be-taken decision under the provisos to Sections 5(1) and 11(5) of the MMDR Act.
- Which version of Section 11 of the MMDR Act—pre-amendment (prior to 20-12-1999) or post-amendment—governs the competing claims for preferential right.
- Whether the High Court exceeded its jurisdiction by evaluating the merits of State recommendations and by requiring the recording of “special reasons” afresh.
Arguments of the Parties
Posco India (P) Ltd.
- The State validly recommended Posco under Sections 11(3) and 11(5) after a simultaneous, merit-based comparison ordered by the Revisional Authority.
- All applications are deemed to be of the same date; Posco’s superior experience, investment capacity, FINEX technology and public-interest benefits justified preference.
- Section 11(5) was correctly invoked because Posco’s merits “stand head and shoulders” above others; sophisticated, pollution-reducing technology constitutes the requisite “special reasons”.
- Geomin’s claim of priority fails as its 1991 application was deficient, its corporate character changed in 2007, and any vested right was obliterated by the 1999 amendment.
Geomin Minerals & Marketing (P) Ltd.
- The law applicable on the date of its 1991 application (pre-amended Section 11) confers a preferential right that cannot be curtailed prospectively.
- If the amended Section 11 applies, Section 11(4) (simultaneous consideration) governs and Section 11(5) cannot be used; Sandur Manganese decision supports that position.
- Recommendation in favour of Posco improperly mixed criteria under Sections 11(3) and 11(5) and is therefore not bona fide.
- First-day applicants enjoy priority over Posco, whose application came 14 years later.
State of Orissa
- Followed the Central Government’s 27-9-2007 directive; held exhaustive hearings and prepared a comparative merit chart.
- Posco and Jindal Stainless alone met MoU milestones; Posco clearly the most meritorious in investment, technology and public revenue.
- Geomin’s 1991 application was deficient and effectively revived only in 2007; amended Section 11 therefore applies, erasing any earlier priority.
- High Court usurped Central Government’s statutory role by striking down a mere recommendation.
Kudremukh Iron Ore Company
- State wrongly rejected its applications; the Central Revisional Authority has since set aside that rejection.
- Section 11(5) is inapplicable when applications are considered simultaneously for notified areas; decision must rest solely on Section 11(3) parameters.
- As a public-sector undertaking with prior prospecting expenditure, it is the most suitable allottee.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Bengal Immunity Co. Ltd. v. State of Bihar, AIR 1955 SC 661 | A litigant need not wait for actual injury to seek preventive relief. | Relied on by the High Court (not by the Supreme Court) to hold Geomin’s writ petition was not premature. |
| Sandur Manganese & Iron Ores Ltd. v. State of Karnataka, (2010) 13 SCC 1 | Interpretation of amended Section 11—simultaneous consideration under Section 11(4) and limited scope of Section 11(5). | Cited in arguments by Geomin to contend that Section 11(5) could not override Section 11(4); Court noted the citation but did not finally rule on the applicability at this stage. |
| State of Tamil Nadu v. Hind Stone, (1981) 2 SCC 205 | Statutory provisions in force at the time of consideration, not at application, govern mineral concessions. | Invoked by the State to argue that post-1999 Section 11 applies; Supreme Court acknowledged the precedent while deferring the substantive decision to the Central Government. |
| Monnet Ispat and Energy Ltd. v. Union of India, (2012) 11 SCC 1 | (i) State’s power to reserve areas for public sector; (ii) No vested right to obtain a mining lease. | Quoted by the Supreme Court to underscore that applicants have no fundamental right to a licence and to highlight State ownership aspects. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
1. Prematurity of the Writ: Under Sections 5(1) and 11(5) the State cannot finally grant a PL/ML without prior approval of the Central Government. On 9-1-2009 the State had merely forwarded a recommendation; no Central decision existed. Therefore, judicial interference at that stage was premature and encroached upon the Central Government’s exclusive statutory jurisdiction.
2. High Court’s Evaluation of Merits: The Supreme Court examined the State’s inter se merit chart and concluded that the High Court erred in declaring that “special reasons” were absent; the record showed detailed comparative analysis and reasons in support of Posco.
3. Applicability of Amended vs. Un-amended Section 11: The Court observed that determining which version applies requires factual scrutiny best undertaken by the Central Government when considering prior approval. Hence it refrained from a definitive pronouncement at this juncture.
4. No Vested Right: Relying on Monnet Ispat, the Court reiterated that applicants possess no statutory or fundamental right to a mineral concession; consequently, any preference claim is subject to the statutory scheme and Central approval process.
Holding and Implications
HELD: The Supreme Court set aside the Orissa High Court’s judgment dated 14-7-2010 and remitted the matter to the Central Government to decide, under Section 5(1) MMDR Act, whether to approve the State Government’s 9-1-2009 recommendation.
Implications: The parties must now present their objections to the Central Government, which will evaluate the State’s comparative-merit exercise and decide on prior approval. The Supreme Court made no determination on the substantive merits or on the applicability of pre- or post-1999 Section 11, leaving those questions open. No new legal precedent was set beyond reaffirming that courts should not intervene before the Central Government’s statutory decision.
S.J Mukhopadhaya, J.— Leave granted. These appeals by special leave have been preferred against the order of the Division Bench of Orissa High Court, Cuttack dated 14-7-2010 in Geomin Minerals and Mktg. (P) Ltd. v. State of Orissa WP (C) No. 23 of 2009 whereby the writ petition preferred by Geomin Minerals & Marketing (P) Ltd. was allowed and the recommendation made by the State Government dated 9-1-2009 in favour of Posco India (P) Ltd. was set aside with a direction to the State Government to take a fresh decision in terms of the order dated 27-9-2007 passed by the Revisional Authority in Revision Application File No. 22 (41)/2007-RC-1 by giving Geomin Minerals & Marketing (P) Ltd. the preferential right of consideration. The Division Bench further observed that in the event the State Government decides to invoke the provisions of Section 11(5) of the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 (hereinafter referred to as the “MMDR Act”), “special reasons” for the same in terms of the guidelines dated 24-6-2009 issued by the Ministry of Mines, Government of India be recorded in writing. The State Government was directed to complete the entire exercise within a specified period.
2. The factual matrix of the case is as follows: the availability of two sets of land for fresh grant of lease was notified by the State of Orissa vide Notification dated 20-8-1991 issued under Rule 59(1) of the Mineral Concession Rules, 1960. The first set comprised of 85.60 acres plus 94.47 acres of land in Village Kansar and Village Gokhurang of Balangir District which had earlier been granted on lease in favour of Shri S.K Padhi and Shri B.K Agarwal. These leases were subsequently surrendered to the State Government and were, therefore, available for re-grant. The State Government vide Notification dated 20-8-1991 notified the availability w.e.f 24-10-1991.
3. The second set of land comprised of 283.06 square miles in Horomoto Guali Block, Malangtoli Block, Khandadhar-Pahar in Block Keonjhar and Sundergarh Districts, Taldihi Toda Block, Sundergarh District and Dubna Blocks I and III which was declared to be reserved for public sector corporations vide Notifications dated 5-6-1962 and 6-12-1962.
4. The State Government decided to de-reserve the said mineral-bearing areas and the availability of the said area was notified vide Notification dated 23-8-1991. The date of availability for re-grant was on and from 29-10-1991. The dispute in the case of Geomin's SLP No. 31593 of 2010 is regarding 186 ha of land located in Village Rantha, District Sundergarh. Although, the recommendation made in favour of Posco covers an area of 2500 ha, thus Geomin's interest is limited to a fraction of the land recommended for Posco.
5. Posco had made an application for prospecting licence for an area of 6828.54 ha. Initially a recommendation was made to the Central Government in favour of Posco for an area of 6204.352 ha by the State Government on 19-12-2006. The recommendation was challenged by Kudremukh Iron Ore Company (hereinafter referred to as “the Kudremukh Company”) by means of a writ petition being WP No. 1775 of 2007. The High Court refrained from exercising its discretion since the matter was pending before the Central Government and directed WP (C) No. 1775 of 2007 that representation of Kudremukh Company may be treated as revisional application. The recommendation of the State Government was set aside vide order dated 27-9-2007 by the Revisional Authority as all mineral concession applications were not considered simultaneously and no orders were passed on those applications. It was directed that all pending applications be considered simultaneously and inter se merit be examined and then order be passed as per law after affording an opportunity of hearing to all the applicants. Earlier the Central Government by its Letter dated 16-7-2007 had informed the State Government that the recommendation in favour of Posco could not be processed as the process of hearing in respect of 203 applicants was still not complete. It was noted that the recommendation in favour of Posco was for an area which was partially notified and partially non-notified and, hence, the applications should be considered accordingly as per law.
6. The order passed by the Revisional Authority dated 27-9-2007 was challenged by one Dhananjay Kumar Dagara before the Orissa High Court in a writ petition being WP (C) No. 15315 of 2007. It was challenged on the ground that the directions for simultaneous consideration of all applications affects the preferential rights of the first day applicants under Section 11(2) of the MMDR Act. In the said Writ Petition No. 15315 of 2007, Geomin Minerals & Marketing (P) Ltd. filed an application for intervention. The intervention application was dismissed by the Orissa High Court on 22-2-2008 with the observation that Geomin Minerals & Marketing (P) Ltd. may take independent steps in respect of its grievance. On 2-5-2008 the Orissa High Court by the judgment in Dhananjay Kumar Dagara v. State of Orissa WP (C) No. 15315 of 2007 held that there was no preferential right for the applicant. The High Court thus dismissed the writ petition and upheld the order of the Revisional Authority dated 27-9-2007.
7. Geomin Minerals & Marketing (P) Ltd. filed another writ petition being WP (C) No. 6484 of 2008 praying expeditious disposal of all pending applications for mineral concessions filed by it, based on its right arising from Rule 63-A of the MC Rules. The said writ petition was disposed of on 15-7-2008 WP (C) No. 6484 of 2008 by the Orissa High Court with a direction to the State Government to consider the pending PL/RP applications of Geomin Minerals & Marketing (P) Ltd. preferably within a period of six months without discrimination and in accordance with law.
8. In the meantime, during the pendency of the applications preferred by different persons including Geomin Minerals & Marketing (P) Ltd. for preferential licence (“PL”, for short) and mining licence (“ML”, for short), on 20-12-1999 amendments carried out in Section 11 of the MMDR Act became effective.
9. By the amending Act, the first proviso to Section 11(2) of the MMDR Act was inserted as under:
“11. Preferential right of certain persons.—(1)-(2)***
Provided that where an area is available for grant of reconnaissance permit, prospecting licence or mining lease, as the case may be, and the State Government has invited applications by notification in the Official Gazette for grant of such permit, licence or lease, all the applications received during the period specified in such notification and the applications which had been received prior to the publication of such notification in respect of the lands within such area and had not been disposed of, shall be deemed to have been received on the same day for the purposes of assigning priority under this sub-section:”
The non obstante clause i.e sub-section (4) of Section 11 was renumbered as sub-section (5), and a new sub-section (4) was introduced, which reads as under:
“11. (4) Subject to the provisions of sub-section (1), where the State Government notifies in the Official Gazette an area for grant of reconnaissance permit, prospecting licence or mining lease, as the case may be, all the applications received during the period as specified in such notification, which shall not be less than thirty days, shall be considered simultaneously as if all such applications have been received on the same day and the State Government, after taking into consideration the matters specified in sub-section (3), may grant the reconnaissance permit, prospecting licence or mining lease, as the case may be, to such one of the applicants as it may deem fit.”
10. Pursuant to the order of the Revisional Authority dated 27-9-2007 passed in the case of Kudremukh Company, the State Government issued a notice to Geomin Minerals & Marketing (P) Ltd. under Rule 12(1) of the MC Rules giving them opportunity of being heard. The officials of Geomin Minerals & Marketing (P) Ltd. attended the hearing. Thereafter, by the minutes of the meeting, inter se merits of all applicants was prepared by the State of Orissa on 17-10-2008, but no recommendation was made. Therefore, Geomin Minerals & Marketing (P) Ltd. filed a writ petition being WP (C) No. 23 of 2009 inter alia with the following prayer:
“Order the opposite parties to dispose of all pending applications for mineral concessions filed by the petitioner and set out in the petition in accordance with its vested right to preferential consideration in view of the fact that the petitioner's applications have been filed on the first date of availability and eligibility.
Issue a writ of prohibition or any other appropriate writ, order or direction restraining the opposite parties from considering applications for mineral concessions of later applicants to the petitioner until the applications of the petitioner are first considered and disposed of by according priority or preferential right based on the petitioner being a first day applicant having applied for the mineral concessions concerned set out in the petition on the first date of availability and eligibility.”
11. The writ petition was filed on 5-1-2009 by Geomin Minerals & Marketing (P) Ltd. and just after few days on 9-1-2009, the State Government made impugned recommendation to the Central Government in favour of Posco under Sections 11(3) and (5) of the MMDR Act. The said recommendation was challenged by Geomin Minerals & Marketing (P) Ltd. by filing a petition for amendment.
12. On hearing the parties, the High Court framed the following issues for consideration:
12.1 Whether the writ petition is maintainable due to availability of alternative remedy?
12.2 Whether the writ petition is premature?
12.3 Whether the writ petition is maintainable due to delay and laches?
12.4 Whether the writ petition is barred by res judicata?
12.5 Whether the area in question was earlier reserved or is it a non-reserved area?
12.6 Whether the petitioner has any preferential right under Section 11 of the MMDR Act?
12.7 Whether recommendation made by the State Government under Section 11(5) of the MMDR Act in favour of Posco is valid?
13. In the present case, the second issue (para 12.2) is important as the respondents to the writ petitions raised the question of maintainability on one of the grounds that the application was premature. The said issue was answered by the High Court in a cryptic manner without any reason, as is apparent from its finding which is produced below:
“Issue 2: Whether the writ petition is premature?
This issue is answered in favour of the petitioner as the petitioner has approached this Court at a time when its right to be considered along with Posco has been threatened to be infringed by the action of the State, which, according to the petitioner, is illegal and contrary to the statutory provision. So the petitioner prayed for preferential right under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
Hence the writ petition cannot be said to be premature as the petitioner could not have waited till the harm is caused to him (see Bengal Immunity Co. Ltd. v. State of Bihar AIR 1955 SC 661).”
14. Issues 6 and 7 (paras 12.6 and 12.7) relate to preferential right of Geomin Minerals & Marketing (P) Ltd. under Section 11 of the MMDR Act and validity of recommendation made by the State Government under Section 11(5) of the said Act in favour of Posco. Both the issues were determined by the High Court in favour of Geomin Minerals & Marketing (P) Ltd., and against Posco. Referring to Sections 11(2), (3) and (4) the High Court held that Geomin Minerals & Marketing (P) Ltd. has preferential right for grant of licence and lease and that the recommendation made by the State Government under Section 11(5) in favour of Posco is invalid.
15. The judgment aforesaid has been challenged by Geomin Minerals & Marketing (P) Ltd. by filing an appeal as no specific direction has been given for issuance of licence in its favour. Posco and the Government of Orissa have also challenged the judgment by filing their respective appeals. No separate appeal has been preferred by Kudremukh Company or Jindal Steel and Power Ltd. or any other, but some of them have filed intervention applications and petitions for impleadment. Accordingly, at the time of hearing of the appeals, the respondents and the interveners were heard and, therefore, we allow the applications for intervention and impleadment.
16. The learned counsel for the parties argued in detail for few days but in view of the nature of order we intend to pass it is not necessary to discuss each and every submission except the relevant one, as recorded hereunder.
Stand of Posco India (P) Ltd.
17. Learned counsel Mr K.K Venugopal appearing on behalf of Posco India (P) Ltd. made the following submissions:
17.1 The recommendation in favour of Posco India has been made in accordance with the provisions contained in Sections 11(2), (3) and (5) of the MMDR Act and other relevant provisions of the Mineral Concession Rules, 1960.
17.2 Posco was found to be the most meritorious applicant and hence the State Government by exercising its power under Section 11(5) of the MMDR Act, 1957 has decided to recommend an extent of 2500 ha to the Government of India for prior approval for grant of PL in their favour.
17.3 In the present case, there are at least two reasons as to why there cannot be any claim of priority on the part of Geomin. When the area in question was released from reservation and de-notified on 23-8-1991, no outside date before which applications had to be made had been fixed. The Government of India (Revisional Authority), in exercise of its revisional jurisdiction, vide Order 27-9-2007, had directed the State Government to consider all the pending applications simultaneously. This order was challenged by one Dhananjay Kumar Dagara, and the writ petition was dismissed by the High Court. The decision of the Central Government thus became final. If the applications were to be considered simultaneously, which means as if they were received on the same day, the proviso to Section 11(2) of the Act would apply. Indubitably, in any comparison based on the factors set out in the tabulated statements, Posco would be far ahead of the other applicants, based on its experience, investment, technology used, integrated project, captive use of the iron ore, total employment (direct and indirect) and, above all, public interest. Thus, Section 11(3) of the Act wholly applies in Posco's favour.
17.4 Apart from Section 11(3), the State Government has made the recommendation also under Section 11(5) for the simple reason that Posco stood head and shoulders above the other applicants, in respect of public interest. If the gap between Posco and the other applicants, even in regard to the very considerations specified in Section 11(3) is so vast, then, in such a case, the very same factors, qualitatively and quantitatively, would attract Section 11(5) as well. In any event, in this case, there is one factor which beyond doubt attracts Section 11(5), and that is the sophisticated and advanced finex technology, which not only reduces pollution but is also able to utilise low grade ore to make steel. Section 11(5) would clearly be attracted on this ground alone, and, in whatever manner one approaches the issue, Posco has rightly been recommended by the State Government for grant of the prospecting licence.
17.5 The recommendation dated 9-1-2009 made in favour of Posco falls within the parameters of Sections 11(3) and 11(5) of the MMDR Act. The State Government followed the direction of the Revisional Authority (Central Government) dated 27-9-2007, which was upheld by the High Court and had become final, and simultaneously considered the inter se merits of all the applicants whose PL applications were pending disposal before the State Government. It was after a rigorous exercise of calling all the applicants for personal hearing and to make a presentation that the State Government took the considered view to hold that Posco was the most meritorious applicant.
17.6 Once there was a direction of the Revisional Authority, which was affirmed by the Orissa High Court in Dagara case WP (C) No. 15315 of 2007 (which order attained finality), that the State Government was required to consider all pending applications simultaneously and come to a decision after evaluating the inter se merits of all the applicants. An inter se comparison of multiple applicants for grant of a mineral concession is envisaged only under Section 11(3) of the MMDR Act. This being so, in any inter se comparison [whether pursuant to Section 11(2) or not], the criteria on the basis of which a decision must be taken by the State Government is what is specified in Section 11(3).
17.7 The High Court has failed to point out as to what would amount to “special reasons”. The impugned judgment also does not appreciate that the recommendation in favour of Posco has been made by the State Government keeping in mind the larger interests of the State and its citizens. The basis of this decision was the economic and environmental benefit accruing to the State from Posco's mining methods.
17.8 Posco is a wholly owned subsidiary of M/s Posco, which is a Korean company having more than 25 years' experience in developing minerals in various countries in the world and is the world's second largest steel-maker by market value and Asia's most profitable steel-maker. M/s Posco's operating profit margin is the top in the World Steel Industry, and it is the most competitive steel-maker as per 2010 World Steel Dynamics. According to 2010 World Economic Forum M/s Posco is one amongst the 100 companies to last the next 100 years. Geomin is a company which was incorporated in September 1991, with an authorised share capital of Rs 1,00,000 (Rupees one lakh), obviously only with a view to take advantage of the Notification dated 23-8-1991 issued by the State Government. Geomin did not have any experience of having undertaken any mining activities, and, therefore, cannot be said to have possessed any special knowledge or experience in mining operations. Further, sometime in the year 2007, control of Geomin, through acquisition of a majority of the share of the company, was taken over by one “Navyuga Steel Ltd.” In the submission of the appellant, the experience and/or qualifications of Navyuga Steel Ltd. cannot be used in support of Geomin's application made in the year 1991, since the merit of an applicant for a prospecting licence/mining lease would have to be judged as on the date of the application itself, as otherwise the process of selection would be rendered arbitrary if an applicant is permitted to add to its qualifications after knowing the relative qualifications of other applicants. If this is permitted, such a process of adding to one's qualifications would become never-ending. In any event, if in substance and in effect a totally new entity has been permitted to be brought into existence, by transfer of substantial shares to another company, the original applicant can no more claim priority of its application as its character has undergone a substantial transformation.
17.9 The reliance by Kudremukh Company on Section 11(1) of the Act is wholly erroneous, as (admittedly) no reconnaissance permit was ever granted in its favour. Under Section 11(1) of the MMDR Act, preference can be claimed if an applicant for the grant of a PL has already been granted a reconnaissance permit qua the said area; and the conditions prescribed in the first proviso to Section 11(1) are met. The reconnaissance work stated to have been carried out by the Department of Geology of the State Government, at Kudremukh's expense, also cannot attract Section 11(1) of the Act in its favour. Further, in any event, Kudremukh Company is bound by the aforementioned direction for simultaneous consideration of all applications given by the Central Government, as per the decision of the Revisional Authority, which was upheld by the High Court.
Stand of Geomin Minerals & Marketing (P) Ltd.
18. The learned counsel for Geomin Minerals & Marketing (P) Ltd. made the following submissions:
18.1 A preferential right in the field of mining is an important right. The preferential right conferred under unamended Section 11 up to 1999 cannot be curtailed under amended Section 11. Since Geomin Minerals & Marketing (P) Ltd. applied on 29-10-1991 the law that was applicable on the said date of application i.e unamended Section 11 shall be applicable for consideration of application filed by Geomin Minerals & Marketing (P) Ltd.
18.2 On the other hand if the amended Section 11 is applied, in that event the judgment of this Court in Sandur Manganese & Iron Ores Ltd. v. State of Karnataka (2010) 13 SCC 1 will apply. The consequence will be as follows:
(a) Section 11(4) of the amended Section will apply.
(b) Section 11(5) will not be available.
(c) If amended Section 11(4) applies, then all persons applied on 29-10-1991 will be treated as first applicants. The choice between them will be governed by Section 11(3).
(d) Even if Section 11(5) is applied, special reasons referred to in Section 11(5) cannot be same that of the reasons to be recorded for the purpose of Section 11(3).
In the present case, the exercise which the State Government has done mixes up the matter under Sections 11(3) and 11(5) for recommending the name of M/s Posco India (P) Ltd., therefore it is contrary to the provisions of Section 11 and recommendation in favour of Posco India (P) Ltd. is not bona fide.
18.3 Amended Section 11 is prospective in nature. It is the rule on the date of application that would be applicable and not the rule on the date of consideration. In view of Rule 8(C) of the Mineral Concession Rules it cannot be said that Section 11 will be applicable from the date of consideration. As per the ratio of the judgment in Sandur Manganese & Iron Ores Ltd. v. State of Karnataka (2010) 13 SCC 1 if amended Section 11 is applied then Geomin Minerals & Marketing (P) Ltd. is entitled for benefit of the aforesaid judgment.
18.4 Memorandum of understanding or the arrangements outside the provisions of the MMDR Act cannot be used to trample on the rights of prior or same day applicants. This principle is to be followed irrespective of whether the unamended or amended Section 11 is applied.
18.5 First day applicant enjoys and is entitled to priority over all subsequent days applications including Posco application which was made on 27-9-2005 i.e after about 14 years from the date of the Geomin applications.
Stand of the State of Orissa
19. Mr Rakesh Dwivedi, learned Senior Counsel for the State of Orissa to the facts as noticed above contended as follows:
19.1 Initially a recommendation was made to the Central Government in favour of Posco for an area of 6204.352 ha by the State Government on 19-12-2006. Pursuant to which the Revisional Authority after hearing the matter set aside the recommendation made in favour of Posco and the State Government was directed vide Order dated 27-9-2007 to consider all pending applications simultaneously and to decide inter se merit and then pass an order as per law after affording an opportunity to all the applicants. Earlier the recommendation in favour of Posco was made for an area which was partially notified and partially non-notified and other applications were not considered and hence the matter was remitted back by the Revisional Authority to the State Government.
19.2 The State Government had thereafter granted hearing to all the applicants and had considered the inter se merit of the applicants. An overall holistic consideration and record shows that the Government had an inter se comparison of the applicants as directed by the Central Government and had also made recommendation in favour of Posco by invoking Section 11(5) of the MMDR Act, 1957.
19.3 The case of Geomin had been considered. During the hearing, Geomin stated that it is a joint venture between Navyuga Group and T.P Minerals Group and it wanted to set up one ore-based steel complex of 12 MTPA capacity but at that time their project was under consideration by the high-level clearance authority. The case of Kudremukh Company based on PL No. 1991 dated 17-2-2002 was considered. This Company proposed to invest Rs 100 crores in mines and Rs 5000 crores in industry and its plant was in Mangalore, State of Karnataka. It was proposing some plants in Sundergarh District but there was no definite proposal received by the State. Jindal Steel and Power Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as “JSPL”) had submitted four PL and one ML applications. The PL applications are dated 22-2-2007. They did not submit sufficient documents as required under Rule 22(3)(i) of the MC Rules and legally accepted Geological Prospecting Report for their ML application. This Company is part of Jindal Group and was operating a steel plant at Raigarh, Chhattisgarh. It was considered to be a serious contender for the applied area. Their applied area was 4930.57 ha after clubbing the four PL applications. Out of this only 90 ha are overlapping with the PL application of Posco. Thus, their PL applications cover an area which is overwhelmingly distinct from the area recommended for Posco. Consequently, JSPL had not filed any writ petition nor had applied for impleadment before the High Court. It has chosen to move an intervention application belatedly in the SLP filed by Geomin. This application has not been allowed and it is liable to be rejected. PL Application No. 2122 dated 27-9-2005 for 6828.54 ha filed by Posco India was considered and they were considered to be a front runner and possessing outstanding merit in comparison to all other applicants. They proposed to set up World's first steel plant project using Finex technology which was a next generation eco-friendly process which allows direct use of cheap iron ores fines and non-coking coal as feedstock and has consequently lower emissions as compared to blast furnace. They had assured captive consumption of the mineral at their plant at Paradip which was to be a port-based steel plant. It was likely to create huge employment and generate huge revenue.
19.4 In Part F, Summary, it has been noted that only two companies i.e Posco India Ltd. and Jindal Stripes have achieved the milestones or the eligibility criteria laid down in the MoU for recommendation of raw material linkage to their proposed steel plant. It mentions “as far as relevant merits are concerned in terms of proposed investment, financial resources capability for scientific mining and exploration of ore, it could be safely concluded that M/s Posco India (P) Ltd. stands out as the most meritorious among all the MoU signed applicants and as well as other applicants as narrated above”; it mentions that application of Jindal Stainless was being considered for other areas. The “conclusion” has been drawn and it has been specifically stated in sub-para (c) that Geomin Minerals & Marketing has some merit but they cannot be considered on a par with Posco India. Kudremukh Company was found to be highly meritorious but its merit was not comparable with M/s Posco India taking into account the comprehensive advantage of Posco in terms of revenue and employment generation. In sub-para (f) it was concluded that on account of the ability to carry out scientific exploration and mining, capability to mobilise adequate financial resources for investment, setting up of value addition facilities including 12 MTPA steel plant based on eco-friendly and resource-use-efficient technology which will generate huge revenue and employment, Posco India deserves precedence over all other applicants and it stands out as the most meritorious.
19.5 While considering the extent of area to be recommended, it was noted that Posco had applied for 6828.24 ha in Khandadhar region. Considering all relevant aspects the State Government decided to recommend an area of 4050 ha only in favour of Posco to the Government of India for prior approval for grant of PL. Expressly invoking Section 11(5) of the MMDR Act, 1957 in addition to the inter se comparison of merits, the comparative statement table prepared with the parameters under Section 11(3) in view and with table forms parts of the minutes. The minutes recorded that the applications are to be disposed of in accordance with Sections 11(2) and (3) and relevant provisions of the Mineral Concession Rules. The State Government has complied with the directions of the Central Government and has applied its mind to all the relevant factors and material produced by the various applicants and after making inter se comparison of minutes arrived at a conclusion that Posco was more meritorious from the point of scientific exploration and mining, mobilisation of financial resources, use of eco-friendly and resource-use-efficient technology investments including the steel plant project and generation of employment and revenue. In addition, the State Government has also invoked the provisions of Section 11(5) of the Act.
19.6 Further stand of the State of Orissa is that Geomin's application PL No. 1334 dated 29-10-1991 cannot be considered to be a prior application in view of the following facts: Geomin had made 7 PL applications for different areas to the State Government of Orissa. An area of 186 ha in Village Rantha, District Sundergarh applied vide Application No. 1334 dated 29-10-1991 is overlapping. Thus, the area recommended for Posco includes about 186 ha of area applied for by Geomin.
19.7 The order of the High Court dated 15-7-2008 WP (C) No. 6484 of 2008 had been passed in the context of PL Application No. 1338 in Malantoli Block. This has nothing to do with the area recommended for Posco. After the above High Court order, Geomin made a representation with respect to PL Application No. 1337.
19.8 Geomin's applications, in particular PL No. 1334, all dated 29-10-1991 were made on an individual basis as a private limited company. The nature of business indicated was mining, processing and sale of minerals and mineral products. The affidavit mentions that it is a new company and therefore there are no income tax/sales tax returns or clearance certificates. As regards financial resources the application simply says “sound” and refers to the articles of association. In the experience column Geomin shows no experience and refers to qualified and experienced “people” in the Company. No name or details are given. Geomin does not hold any PL or ML. There is no claim that any Director has any such experience. The application is highly deficient and there is no proposal for setting up any industry based on minerals. After 14 years from the notification under Rule 59 a letter dated 7-9-2004 for sympathetic consideration was made and order dated 15-7-2003 passed by the Central Government (Tribunal) was referred to Geomin, also wrote a letter dated 27-12-2005 requesting that they should be allowed to submit fresh proposal. Earlier on 20-12-2004 AXL also submitted a letter. Thereafter another letter dated 30-12-2006 was written. In this letter for the first time it was proposed that a 0.5 MTPA capacity steel plant in the State of Orissa would be set up through our group company AXL Industries and PLs were required for that purpose. In the aforesaid letters, there is no claim for any preference under Section 11(2). The third letter dated 7-6-2007 refers to the proposal to set up 0.5 MTPA capacity steel plant in Orissa and also offers to consider setting up of the project through Geomin itself or to consider amalgamation of the two companies. Then by a letter dated 6-10-2007 it informed that Geomin has now entered into a partnership with Navyuga Group of Companies who are a large conglomerate with interests in engineering, exports, mining, ports, power, real estate, IT, etc. It further informed that Navyuga Group is planning to set up steel plant in Orissa with 12 MTPA capacity. By the letter it was also informed that Navyuga has already acquired 50% equity stake in Geomin. Therefore the request was made to consider its application “keeping the above in mind”. By the fifth letter dated 13-11-2007 they wished to know the status of Geomin's applications regarding the process of evaluation of applications over Khandadhar Block, District Sundergarh.
19.9 If the provisions operating at the time of the applications are to be considered then Geomin's application would stand rejected in terms of Rule 24(3) of the Mineral Concession Rules, 1960 which was omitted on 7-1-1993. Secondly, Geomin's application was highly deficient and the deficiencies were partially removed which were provided after the notice issued. Moreover, Geomin first placed reliance on 0.5 MTPA steel plant being set up by its group company AXL Industries then offered to set up the said project by itself. Thereafter relied upon 12 MTPA steel plant being set up by Navyuga Group which acquired 50% equity stake was later increased to 70% of the equity share. Application was sought to be considered on this basis. Therefore, Geomin's application is effectively and substantively of October/December 2007.
19.10 Section 11 as amended by Act 38 of 1999 w.e.f 18-12-1999, would apply. The contention of Geomin that the old provisions would apply is incorrect. This matter is not res integra. In State of T.N v. Hind Stone (1981) 2 SCC 205, this Court has decided that the provisions of the Act and Rules as operating at the time of consideration would be applicable.
Stand taken by Kudremukh Company
20. The learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf Kudremukh Company submitted as follows:
20.1 That the State Government vide Letter dated 25-4-2009 has communicated the rejection of the applications of the Company, to the extent of an area of 2130 ha, which was within the recommended area of Posco of 2500 ha. The applications of the Company were rejected on the ground that M/s Posco was the most meritorious of all the applicants. The rejection of the Company's ML/PL application had been challenged before the learned Central Mines Tribunal by filing Revision Applications No. 22(6)/2009-RC-I and Revision Application No. 22(7)/2009-RC-I respectively. The Revisional Authority vide final order dated 23-8-2011, has been pleased to allow the revision applications and set aside the orders dated 25-4-2009 passed by the State Government rejecting the ML and PL applications of the Company.
20.2 The State of Orissa has filed two writ petitions being WP (C) No. 6429 of 2012 and WP (C) No. 6431 of 2012 against Final Orders Nos. 550 of 2011 & 549 of 2011 dated 23-9-2011 passed by the Government of India in Revision Application No. 22(6)/2009-RC-I and Revision Application No. 22(7)/2009-RC-I respectively. The same is pending adjudication before the Orissa High Court. The Company is not aware if M/s Posco has challenged the said order passed by the learned Revisional Authority.
20.3 The recommendation in favour of Posco purportedly under Section 11(5) is not a valid recommendation as per the provisions of the Act. Section 11(5) would have no application in the present case where the applications were being considered simultaneously and the same has to be granted to the applicant who satisfies the criteria under Section 11(3) when compared with the others. The Revisional Authority vide order dated 27-9-2007 had directed to consider all applications “simultaneously”. Therefore, all the applications had to be considered taking into consideration the parameters of Section 11(3). The State Government itself in its recommendation dated 9-1-2009 had stated that the applications were evaluated and taken up for disposal in accordance with Sections 11(2) and (3) of the Act. But ultimately made the purported recommendation in favour of Posco under Section 11(5) of the Act, which is not applicable.
20.4 Section 11(5) would be applicable only if the area is “non-notified” and the State Government for “special reasons” wants to give preference to a later applicant to an application which was received earlier. The “special reasons” need not be other than what have been mentioned in Section 11(3) but may be over and above the reasons mentioned in Section 11(3). Section 11(5) will have no application where applications are considered simultaneously for areas which are notified, which is the present case. The recommendation dated 9-1-2009 made by the State Government is not sustainable.
21. As far as the contention raised by Geomin Minerals claiming priority by virtue of being an earlier applicant are concerned, it was submitted that the said contention no longer holds force after the amendment of Section 11(2) of the Act. As per the amended Section 11(2), all applications which were made during the period of notification and all applications received prior to the publication and had not been disposed of shall be deemed to have been received on the same day for the purpose of assigning priority. Therefore, a prior applicant has no preferential right to be considered over a later applicant. It is submitted that the right, if any, under the pre-amended provisions stands obliterated after the amendment came into force and cannot be construed as a “vested” right.
22. It was further contended that the Court, if it so deems fit may direct the Central Government to consider all applications while deciding grant of prior approval under Section 5(1) of the Act, after giving the parties a right to represent and decide the same taking all factors into consideration that Kudremukh Company is a public sector undertaking and the substantial area of the proposed recommended area was prospected at the cost of Kudremukh Company. The same may be decided uninfluenced by any observations made in the impugned judgment WP (C) No. 23 of 2009 and the recommendation made under Section 11(5).
23. The contentions of Kudremukh Company were summarised as follows:
23.1 Kudremukh Company is a public sector undertaking which is best suited to protect national resources of the country.
23.2 The Company may be allotted at least the portion of the area which was prospected by the Department of Geology at the cost of more than Rs 1 crore.
23.3 Based on the assurances of the State Government at the highest level, the Company has altered its position to its detriment and the Government ought to have granted the PL/ML to the petitioner.
23.4 The Company is more meritorious as compared to others, as it has special knowledge in mining operations, the nature and quality of the technical staff and adequate financial resources, which are the prescribed considerations in Section 11(3) of the Act. As far as the so-called proposed investment in industry based on mines by Posco is concerned, it is still illusory and nothing tangible has been invested on the ground. The Company's merit has also been recognised by the State Government, but it erroneously claimed that Posco is more meritorious on the ground of the so-called proposed steel plant which is yet to take off and the work on the plant has not yet commenced.
24. In the aforesaid factual background and rival contentions made in the appeals, intervention petitions as well as counter-affidavits, the main issue that emerges for consideration is: whether the writ petition was premature and in the case of applicants whether the pre-amended Section 11 or amended Section 11 of the MMDR Act is applicable?
25. Before deciding the aforesaid issues it is relevant to note that the issue relating to competence of the State Government to make reservation and the 1962 Notification issued by the State Government reserving certain areas fell for consideration before this Court in Monnet Ispat and Energy Ltd. v. Union of India (2012) 11 SCC 1. In the said case, this Court held that:
“144. … The authority of the State Government to make reservation of a particular mining area within its territory for its own use is the offspring of ownership; and it is inseparable therefrom unless denied to it expressly by an appropriate law. By the MMDR Act that has not been done by Parliament. Setting aside by a State of land owned by it for its exclusive use and under its dominance and control … is an incident of sovereignty and ownership.”
In the light of aforesaid observation made by this Court in Monnet Ispat and Energy Ltd. v. Union of India (2012) 11 SCC 1 and in view of the relevant facts of the present case, it is to be determined as to whether the writ petition preferred by Geomin was premature.
26. Under Section 5 of the MMDR Act, the State Government cannot grant a reconnaissance permit, prospective licence or mining lease to any person unless previous approval of the Central Government has been obtained. The proviso to Section 5(1) expressly prohibits grant of PL except with previous approval of the Central Government as quoted hereunder. Further, where Section 11(5) is invoked, there also prior approval of the Central Government is also required. The proviso to Section 11(5) prescribes that prior approval of the Central Government shall be obtained “before passing any order under the sub-section”.
27. In the present case the State Government has only made recommendations and has sought approval of the Central Government under the proviso to Section 5(1) and the proviso to Section 11(5) but no final decision has been taken. The State Government can pass final order granting mining licence only if approval is granted by the Central Government under Section 5(1) or Section 11(5) which read as follows:
“5. Restrictions on the grant of prospecting licences or mining leases.—(1) A State Government shall not grant a reconnaissance permit, prospecting licence or mining lease to any person unless such person—
(a) is an Indian national, or a company as defined in sub-section (1) of Section 3 of the Companies Act, 1956 (1 of 1956); and
(b) satisfies such conditions as may be prescribed:
Provided that in respect of any mineral specified in the First Schedule, no reconnaissance permit, prospecting licence or mining lease shall be granted except with the previous approval of the Central Government.
11. (5) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (2), but subject to the provisions of sub-section (1), the State Government may, for any special reasons to be recorded, grant a reconnaissance permit, prospecting licence or a mining lease, as the case may be, to an applicant whose application was received later in preference to an applicant whose application was received earlier:
Provided that in respect of minerals specified in the First Schedule, prior approval of the Central Government shall be obtained before passing any order under this sub-section.”
28. Iron ore is a major mineral specified in Para C of the First Schedule. In matters of such major mineral, even the State Government itself cannot undertake prospective or mining operations without having prior consultation with the Central Government as per Section 4(3) of the Act, and if prospecting licence or mining lease is to be granted to any other person, then previous approval of the Central Government is to be obtained under the proviso to Section 5(1). The consideration of recommendation made by the Central Government for grant of prior approval is an exclusive jurisdiction of the Central Government under the MMDR Act, 1957 and there is no good reason for pre-empting the Central Government from considering the merits of the recommendation.
29. Until the Central Government has passed an order either granting or refusing approval under Section 5(1) and Section 11(5) of the Act, it would not be permissible for any person to file a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India and any such petition if filed would be premature. In the instant case, the High Court committed a grave error of law in proceeding to observe that “special reasons” did not exist on invoking Section 11(5) and that there was no comparison of merits in the record. The record has been shown to this Court and it is apparent that the State Government has tabulated and evaluated the inter se merits and has concluded that Posco is more meritorious. All the applicants were given a hearing. In the circumstances, the High Court's observations are not justified and in fact the High Court appears to have usurped the jurisdiction of the Central Government in proceeding to make these remarks. The scrutiny of the merits was premature and the High Court should have refrained from entering into the merits.
30. The second proviso to Rule 63-A also provides that the disposal of the applications by the State Government in the case of minerals listed in the First Schedule to the Act shall mean either recommendation to the Central Government for grant of mineral concession, and in all other cases disposal shall mean refusal to grant the mineral concession. This is also an indication that the recommendation made by the State Government does not constitute an order as envisaged by Section 30 of the Act.
31. The next issue relates to the application of Section 11 i.e whether the pre-amended Section 11 or post-amended Section 11 shall apply.
32. We have noticed that by the amending Act, first proviso to Section 11(2) was inserted. The pre-amended non obstante clause i.e sub-section (4) of Section 11 was renumbered as sub-section (5) to Section 11 and a new sub-section (4) to Section 11 was introduced by the amending Act. The pre-amended provisions of Sections 11(2), (3) and (4) and the post-amended provisions of Sections 11(2), (3), (4) and (5) read as follows:
Pre-amended provisions of Sections 11(2), (3) and (4) are as follows:
32.1 “11. (2) Subject to the provisions of sub-section (1), where two or more persons have applied for a prospecting licence or a mining lease in respect of the same land, the applicant whose application was received earlier shall have a preferential right for the grant of the licence or lease, as the case may be, over an applicant whose application was received later:
Provided that where any such applications are received on the same day, the State Government, after taking into consideration the matters specified in sub-section (3), may grant the prospecting licence on mining lease, as the case may be, to such one of the applicants as it may deem fit.
(3) The matters referred to in sub-section (2) are the following—
(a) any special knowledge of, or experience in, prospecting operations or mining operations, as the case may be, possessed by the applicant;
(b) the financial resources of the applicant;
(c) the nature and quality of the technical staff employed or to be employed by the applicant;
(d) such other matters as may be prescribed.
(4) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (2) but subject to the provisions of sub-section (1), the State Government may for any special reasons to be recorded and with the previous approval of the Central Government, grant a prospecting licence or a mining lease to an applicant whose application was received later in preference to an applicant whose application was received earlier.”
Post-amended provisions of Sections 11(2), (3), (4) and (5) are as follows:
32.2 “11. (2) Subject to the provisions of sub-section (1), where the State Government has not notified in the Official Gazette the area for grant of reconnaissance permit or prospecting licence or mining lease, as the case may be, and two or more persons have applied for a reconnaissance permit, prospecting licence or a mining lease in respect of any land in such area, the applicant whose application was received earlier, shall have the preferential right to be considered for grant of reconnaissance permit, prospecting licence or mining lease, as the case may be, over the applicant whose application was received later:
Provided that where an area is available for grant of reconnaissance permit, prospecting licence or mining lease, as the case may be, and the State Government has invited applications by notification in the Official Gazette for grant of such permit, licence or lease, all the applications received during the period specified in such notification and the applications which had been received prior to the publication of such notification in respect of the lands within such area and had not been disposed of, shall be deemed to have been received on the same day, for the purposes of assigning priority under this sub-section:
Provided further that where any such applications are received on the same day, the State Government, after taking into consideration the matter specified in sub-section (3), may grant the reconnaissance permit, prospecting licence or mining lease, as the case may be, to such one of the applicants as it may deem fit.
(3) The matters referred to in sub-section (2) are the following—
(a) any special knowledge of, or experience in, reconnaissance operations, prospecting operations or mining operations, as the case may be, possessed by the applicant;
(b) the financial resources of the applicant;
(c) the nature and quality of the technical staff employed or to be employed by the applicant;
(d) the investment which the applicant proposes to make in the mines and in the industry based on the minerals;
(e) such other matters as may be prescribed.
(4) Subject to the provisions of sub-section (1), where the State Government notifies in the Official Gazette an area for grant of reconnaissance permit, prospecting licence or mining lease, as the case may be, all the applications received during the period as specified in such notification, which shall not be less than thirty days, shall be considered simultaneously as if all such applications have been received on the same day and the State Government, after taking into consideration the matters specified in sub-section (3), may grant the reconnaissance permit, prospecting licence or mining lease, as the case may be, to such one of the applicants as it may deem fit.
(5) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (2), but subject to the provisions of sub-section (1), the State Government may, for any special reasons to be recorded, grant a reconnaissance permit, prospecting licence or mining lease, as the case may be, to an applicant whose application was received later in preference to an applicant whose application was received earlier:
Provided that in respect of minerals specified in the First Schedule, prior approval of the Central Government shall be obtained before passing any order under this sub-section.”
33. The State of Orissa and some others have taken the plea that amended Section 11, as amended by Act 38 of 1999 w.e.f 20-12-1999, would apply.
34. According to the State of Orissa the preferential right envisaged in Section 11(1) is considerably distinct from the preference envisaged by Section 11(2). It is only in the case of Section 11(1) where a person has already held a reconnaissance permit or a prospective licence that he gets a preferential right for obtaining a prospecting licence or mining lease. It may be seen that Section 11(5) is subject to the provisions of sub-section (1) and, therefore, the State Government has no authority to give special reasons for overriding the preference. Further, Section 11(5) is notwithstanding Section 11(2), thus the preference under Section 11(2) can be overridden by special reasons.
35. Another distinction is that while Section 11(1) uses the expression “shall have a preferential right for obtaining”, Section 11(2) uses the expression “shall have the preferential right to be considered for grant”. Thus, under Section 11(2), the preferential right is only in relation to consideration. The preference envisaged under Section 11(2) does not mean that the other applicants are not to be considered. It could only mean that if on an inter se consideration, the applicants are on a par, then the prior application may be given a preference.
36. On the other hand the learned counsel for Geomin has submitted that pre-amended Section 11(2) shall be applicable.
37. In State of T.N v. Hind Stone (1981) 2 SCC 205, similar question fell for consideration before this Court. That was a case relating to renewal of lease for mining minerals. The argument was that Rule 9 itself laid down the criteria for grant of renewal of lease and therefore, Rule 8-C should be confined, in considering applications for grant of leases in the first instance. This Court held that an application for the renewal of a lease is, in essence an application for the grant of a lease for a fresh period and, therefore, Rule 8-C is attracted.
38. The amended Section 11(2) is applicable where the State Government has not notified in the Official Gazette the area for grant of reconnaissance permit or prospective licence or mining lease and two or more persons have applied for reconnaissance permit, prospective licence or mining lease in respect of any land in such area, the applicant whose application was received earlier, shall have the preferential right to be considered for grant of reconnaissance permit, prospective licence or mining lease, over the applicant whose application was received later. However, as per the first proviso to Section 11(2) where an area is available for grant of reconnaissance permit, prospecting licence or mining licence, and the State Government has invited applications by notification in the Official Gazette for grant of such permit, licence or lease, all the applications received during the period specified in such notification and the applications which had been received prior to the publication of such notification in respect of the lands within such area and had not been disposed of, shall be deemed to have been received on the same day for the purposes of assigning priority under the said sub-section. Thus under amended proviso to Section 11(2), even those applications received prior to the publication but had not been disposed of, shall be deemed to have been received on the same day for the purpose of assigning priority under the said sub-section.
39. According to us, this is not the stage to decide as to whether in the present case the pre-amended or amended Section 11(2) shall be applicable and thereby priority should be assigned under pre-amended or amended Section 11(2) as the matter has already been considered by the State Government and recommendation is required to be considered by the Central Government under Section 5(1) of the Act.
40. The Central Government is required to go through the relevant facts of each case to determine whether the recommendation is to be approved or not. While deciding the question the Central Government will keep in mind the order which was passed by the Revisional Authority (Central Government) in the case of Dagara on 2-5-2008.
41. It is well settled that no applicant has a statutory or fundamental right to obtain prospecting licence or a mining lease. In this connection one may refer to this Court's decision in Monnet Ispat (2012) 11 SCC 1. Therefore, the High Court before interfering with the recommendation, ought to have looked into the nature of recommendation.
42. In view of the finding as recorded above, we are of the view that the High Court committed a grave error of law in deciding the case on merits and deciding the question of legality of the recommendation made by the State Government. In fact they should have left the matter to the Central Government to pass an appropriate order in accordance with law instead of entertaining a premature writ petition. The State Government by its recommendation having forwarded the tabulated chart showing inter se merit of each applicant, it was not for the High Court to sit in appeal to decide who amongst all is more meritorious and is entitled for preferential right.
43. We, accordingly, set aside the impugned judgment dated 14-7-2010 WP (C) No. 23 of 2009 passed by the Division Bench of the Orissa High Court and remit the matter to the Central Government to consider the question of approval under Section 5(1) taking into consideration the recommendations made by the State Government. While deciding the question it will keep in mind the objections raised by the parties as noticed in the preceding paragraphs. It is expected that the decision will be taken on an early date and shall be communicated to the State Government. The appeals are allowed with the aforesaid observation and direction, but there shall be no order as to costs.
Alert