Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

B. Chandrika v. Santhosh And Another

Supreme Court Of India
Nov 21, 2013
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The first respondent filed a police complaint (Crime No. 302 of 2010, P.S. Mohamma) alleging that the first and second accused had fraudulently collected money from several persons on the promise of securing government jobs. After investigation, the police submitted a refer (closure) report concluding that the alleged cheating had not occurred and that the second accused (wife of A-1) was not involved.

Dissatisfied, the complainant lodged a protest complaint before the Judicial Magistrate, First Class, Cherthalay. On 22-11-2011 the Magistrate took cognizance under Section 190(1)(a) CrPC, registered CC No. 1548 of 2011 for offences under Section 420 read with Section 34 IPC, and issued summons to both accused.

The accused challenged the summons in revision (Criminal Misc. Case No. 1767 of 2012). On 23-11-2012 the High Court of Kerala held that a Magistrate may entertain a protest complaint even after a refer report and dismissed the revision. The present appeal, confined to A-2 (the divorced wife of A-1), was filed before the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Magistrate erred in issuing summons to the second accused after accepting a police refer report that found no material against her.
  2. Whether, on the facts disclosed by the complainant and the investigation, any prima facie case of cheating under Section 420/34 IPC was made out against the second accused.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gopal Vijay Verma v. Bhuneshwar Prasad Sinha (1982) 3 SCC 510 A Magistrate who earlier declined cognizance on a police report is not barred from later taking cognizance upon a complaint. Reaffirmed that the Magistrate’s power to entertain a protest complaint survives even after accepting a final report.
Kishore Kumar Gyanchandani v. G.D. Mehrotra (2011) 15 SCC 513 / AIR 2002 SC 483 Followed the above principle; clarified the scope of Magistrate’s discretion when a protest petition is filed. Cited to support the High Court’s view that the Magistrate could proceed on the protest complaint.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court accepted that, in principle, a Magistrate may take cognizance on a protest petition even after a refer report. However, the Court emphasised that the Magistrate must apply judicial mind to whether the protest complaint itself discloses an offence against each accused.

Reviewing the record, the Court highlighted:

  • The complainant’s own statement acknowledged that money was handed only to the first accused; he neither met nor dealt with the second accused at that time.
  • The police investigation established that the second accused was living separately at Thiruvananthapuram during the relevant period.
  • A decree of divorce dated 25-01-2010 confirmed that the marital relationship between A-1 and A-2 had already been dissolved on the ground of cruelty.

These facts demonstrated absence of any role, common intention, or entrustment of money to the second accused. The Magistrate, while issuing summons, failed to consider this “vital aspect.” Consequently, continuation of proceedings against A-2 amounted to an abuse of process.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED; SUMMONS AGAINST SECOND ACCUSED QUASHED. Proceedings may continue against the first accused.

Implications: The judgment reinforces the requirement that Magistrates must scrutinise the individual involvement of each accused when acting on a protest complaint. No new legal standard was created, but the decision underscores the protective scope of judicial scrutiny against unwarranted prosecution.

Show all summary ...

K.S.P Radhakrishnan, J.— Leave granted. The appellant herein is the second accused in CC No. 1548 of 2011 pending on the file of the Judicial Magistrate, First Class, Cherthalay, which was initiated by the Magistrate on a protest complaint filed by the first respondent herein for the offences punishable under Section 420 read with Section 34 IPC. Summons were issued to the accused persons by the learned Magistrate vide order dated 22-11-2011. That order was challenged in revision before the High Court of Kerala on the ground that the Magistrate was not justified in initiating proceedings after a refer report was submitted by the police, after due enquiry. The High Court, however, dismissed the revision petition vide order dated 23-11-2012 Criminal Misc. Case No. 1767 of 2012 stating that even if a refer report is filed by the police after conducting investigation, the Magistrate has the power to entertain a protest complaint and to issue summons to the accused and proceed in accordance with law. Aggrieved by the same, this appeal has been preferred.

2. This appeal has been preferred by the second accused, a divorced wife of the first accused. The first respondent herein initially filed a complaint against Accused 1 and 2 before Police Station Mohamma which was registered as Crime No. 302 of 2010. The operative portion of the complaint is as follows:

“Accused 1 and 2 with the ambition for immediate profits and the intention to make loss to the complainant, had given the commitment to the complainant in his rental residence house, owned by Kamal Travels, at Aryakara, Thanneermukkam on 13-10-2006 to provide job to his uncle's son, Sajimon, in Aushathi Government Department and taken 1 lakh rupees from the complainant; from Raveendran r/o Illathukalathil House, Kumarakam taken 1 lakh rupees in the commitment to give job to his son Rathish; from Prabhakaran, Puthanparambil House, Kumarakam, and from Arumukam r/o Kalathil House, Udayaperoor taken 50,000 rupees each; and from K.P Prasad r/o Tikarthil, Kothuruthi, taken 25,000 rupees, thereafter the accused persons committed cheating without providing job to these persons.”

3. An FIR was registered and the investigation ordered. The police conducted detailed investigation, relevant portion of the investigation report is as follows:

“After completing the investigation and recording the statement of witnesses stated above, I came to the conclusion that the fact stated above has not occurred. The complainant through Advocate Rajan had made contact with the first accused Ramchandran Unni and given Rs 12,000 for the purpose of taking certified copy of the order passed in Water Authority case, which was decided by the Kerala High Court, wherein the relatives of the complainant were parties in the case for the purpose of permanency in service. After two weeks, Ramchandran Unni had got the certified copies from the High Court and given it to the complainant. Except this, the accused had not collected money from any person. During the period when money was given as stated by the complainant, the second accused was not in the residential house at Muhamma with the first accused because they were separated from each other and started living in the house at Thiruvananthapuram. It is also proved that the first accused had not received any amount from the complainant or any other persons for providing job to the relative of the complainant or any other person. The amount paid, as stated in the complaint, has not been proved by the complainant and others by submitting any reliable documents.”

4. On the basis of the abovementioned report, the police referred the case as not proved. Reference report was submitted to the Judicial Magistrate, First Class, Cherthalay for appropriate action. Later, the respondent claimant filed a protest complaint before the abovementioned court for cancellation of the reference report and for taking cognizance of the case, on which, as already stated, the Magistrate passed an order dated 22-11-2011, which reads as follows:

“Heard the counsel for the petitioner. Perused the evidence adduced and other case records, prima facie case alleged is made out. Hence, case is taken on file as CC No. 154810 for offence under Section 420 and 34 IPC. Issue summons to both the accused. Take steps by 28-1-2012.”

5. The power of the Magistrate to take cognizance of an offence on a complaint or a protest petition on the same or similar allegations even after accepting the final report, cannot be disputed. It is settled law that when a complaint is filed and sent to police under Section 156(3) for investigation and then a protest petition is filed, the Magistrate after accepting the final report of the police under Section 173 and discharging the accused persons has the power to deal with the protest petition. However, the protest petition has to satisfy the ingredients of complaint before the Magistrate takes cognizance under Section 190(1)(a) CrPC.

6. This Court in Gopal Vijay Verma v. Bhuneshwar Prasad Sinha (1982) 3 SCC 510 held that the Magistrate is not debarred from taking cognizance of a complaint merely on the ground that earlier he had declined to take cognizance of police report. The judgment was followed by a three-Judge Bench judgment of this Court in Kishore Kumar Gyanchandani v. G.D Mehrotra (2011) 15 SCC 513, AIR 2002 SC 483.

7. The High Court, in our view, rightly applied the legal principle, but omitted to consider the crucial question as to the involvement of the second accused, the wife of the first accused. In this connection, it is pertinent to refer to the statement of the complainant having been made during the investigation, which reads as follows:

“Thereafter I, Kunjumon and Rajan were gone to Thiruvananthapuram and met his wife then she told that they were separated to each other and she do not know nothing about him. I have given payment to Ramchandran Unni on the words of Rajan and Kunjumon. I do not know where he is now. At the time of paying the amount I have not seen his wife or talked to her. I do not know anything about him so I have given this complaint.”

8. The above statement of the complainant clearly indicates that money was entrusted to the first accused (the husband of A-2) and not to A-2. The complainant has also stated that at the time of paying the amount, the wife was not seen. The police on investigation, noticed that during the period when money was entrusted to the first accused, the second accused was not in the residential house of the first respondent. Investigation revealed that they were separated and the second accused started living at Thiruvananthapuram.

9. The appellant has also produced a copy of decree of divorce dated 25-1-2010 before the Court, which will indicate that the second accused had obtained a decree of divorce against the first accused on the ground of cruelty under Section 13(1)(a) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955. Considering the fact that the second accused had no role, even according to the complainant, there is no reason to prosecute the second accused. In our view, the Magistrate has not considered this vital aspect when the protest petition was considered by him.

10. The Magistrate has to exercise judicial discretion and apply his mind to the contents of the petition. The refer report as well as the statement of the complainant would indicate that no offence has been made out so far as the second accused is concerned since, admittedly, no money was entrusted to her and that the second accused is the divorced wife of the first accused. That being the factual situation, we are inclined to allow the appeal so far as the second accused is concerned and the summons issued against the second accused would stand quashed. However, it is open to the Magistrate to proceed against the first accused.

11. The appeal is allowed, as above.