Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Pravin Gada And Another v. Central Bank Of India And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Sep 18, 2012
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The matter concerns the sale of a property belonging to a defaulting borrower. In 2006 the petitioners — Shri Praveen Gada and Shri Amarnath Singhla — had purportedly purchased the property for Rs 2.5 crores. Central Bank of India, a secured creditor, challenged that transaction. Earlier interim orders of the Supreme Court dated 27-3-2012 (2012) 10 SCC 271 and 5-7-2012 (2012) 10 SCC 274 directed that the property be auctioned through the Debt Recovery Tribunal (DRT) with a reserve price of Rs 3 crores and specific procedural safeguards. Pursuant to those orders:

  • The Recovery Officer issued newspaper advertisements on 20-7-2012.
  • Only the petitioners submitted a bid (Rs 3 crores) within the stipulated seven-day period.
  • On the auction date (7-8-2012) three sealed bids of Rs 3.3 crores each were also received but, following the Court’s directions, were not opened by the Recovery Officer and were forwarded to the Supreme Court.

The present order rules on interlocutory applications seeking further directions in light of these developments.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether bids submitted in sealed envelopes after the seven-day period but before the actual auction could be considered valid.
  2. Whether, owing to alleged deterrence of prospective purchasers and increased market value (claimed at over Rs 10 crores), a fresh auction with revised conditions and a higher reserve price was warranted.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners’ Arguments

  • The sealed bids were not submitted in accordance with the earlier Supreme Court directions and therefore should be disregarded.
  • Consequently, the petitioners’ bid of Rs 3 crores ought to be treated as the highest and accepted.

Central Bank of India’s Arguments

  • The property is presently worth more than Rs 10 crores; the existing reserve price of Rs 3 crores is far below its real value.
  • Prospective purchasers were discouraged because the petitioners had erected a board at the site proclaiming their ownership and did not allow proper inspection.
  • A re-auction with a higher reserve price and clear facilitation of site inspection is necessary to secure the best possible price.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Order of the Supreme Court dated 27-3-2012
(2012) 10 SCC 271
Earlier directions governing the first auction, including reserve price of Rs 3 crores and procedural safeguards. Taken as the baseline; the Court decides to modify several of those directions.
Order of the Supreme Court dated 5-7-2012
(2012) 10 SCC 274
Clarified auction timeline and left upset price to be tested in actual bidding. Further modified to increase reserve price and extend inspection facilities.
Jay Electric Wire Corpn. Employees Union v. Pravin Gada
(2011) 6 Mah LJ 675
Referenced as part of the litigation history underlying the dispute. Cited only to narrate background; no substantive principle extracted.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court opened and examined the three sealed bids (each for Rs 3.3 crores) and noted that they exceeded the petitioners’ offer. It also accepted the Bank’s allegation that the petitioners had erected a board proclaiming ownership, potentially deterring bidders from inspecting the property and depressing bid values.

On these facts the Court concluded that:

  • A competitive, transparent process had not occurred; genuine bidders may have been dissuaded.
  • Achieving the highest possible sale price in a court-supervised auction is paramount; therefore a fresh auction was necessary.

Balancing these considerations, the Court decided to revise earlier directions so as to:

  • Order a re-auction with enhanced transparency (mandatory supervised inspection and removal of the petitioners’ board during inspection).
  • Increase the reserve price from Rs 3 crores to Rs 5 crores, payable upfront as a condition precedent to bidding (except for the petitioners, who could participate without deposit because of their 2006 purchase claim).
  • Require existing sealed-bid offerees to top up their deposits to the new reserve price or forfeit participation.
  • Ensure that the auction results remain subject to final adjudication of the pending Special Leave Petitions (SLPs) by mandating that bid sheets be submitted to the Court in sealed cover.

Holding and Implications

ORDER FOR RE-AUCTION WITH MODIFIED CONDITIONS

The Court directed a fresh auction with a reserve price of Rs 5 crores and detailed procedural safeguards, while maintaining that all directions are provisional and subject to the outcome of the main SLPs. The matter is listed for further hearing on 1-11-2012, and a copy of the present order is to be sent immediately to the Principal District Judge, Mysore.

Implications: The immediate effect is that the earlier auction stands set aside and a new, more stringent auction process will commence. No final rights have been determined; the ultimate disposition awaits final hearing of the SLPs, and no new legal precedent beyond case-specific auction guidelines has been established.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. These are the applications for seeking certain directions in view of the subsequent developments after the order passed on 5-7-2012 (2012) 10 SCC 274. We have heard Mr C.A Sundaram, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners and Mr Mukul Rohatgi and Mr Jaideep Gupta, learned Senior Counsel for Central Bank of India, Respondent 1.

2. Before we advert to the order dated 5-7-2012 (2012) 10 SCC 274, it is necessitous to refer to the order dated 27-3-2012 (2012) 10 SCC 271. In the said order, after referring to the order passed by the High Court in Jay Electric Wire Corpn. Employees Union v. Pravin Gada (2011) 6 Mah LJ 675 and other connected matters, the interim order passed by this Court on 25-11-2011 SLPs (C) Nos. 30894-96 of 2011, recording the contentions of Mr Sundaram, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners and Mr Jaideep Gupta, learned Senior Counsel for Central Bank of India and taking note of the chart produced in respect of the dues of Central Bank of India, Standard Chartered Bank and Workmen through Official Liquidator, this Court passed the following order (2012) 10 SCC 271: (Pravin Gada case (2012) 10 SCC 271)

“5. It is submitted by Mr Gupta that in fitness of things and regard being had to the concept of obtaining the highest price in court sale, having of auction is the warrant and, therefore, auction should be directed to be held. The learned Senior Counsel further submitted that the property is likely to fetch much more amount than that has been deposited by the petitioners.
6. Mr Sundaram, learned Senior Counsel would contend that the sale had been given effect to in the year 2006 on acceptance of Rs 2.5 crores and with the efflux of time if there has been a price rise solely on the said base a public auction should not be directed.
7. Be it noted that at one point of time, a third party had deposited Rs 6 crores to purchase the property but later on he withdrew as the matter was litigated in court.
8. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and regard being had to the totality of the circumstances, we issue the following directions:
(i) The property in question be put to auction by issuing a public advertisement in at least two newspapers one in English and another in Kannada language having wide circulation in the city of Mysore inviting bids for the sale of the property.
(ii) It shall be mentioned in the advertisements that the reserve price is Rs 3 crores and the same shall be deposited before the Recovery Officer of DRT to enable one to participate in the bid.
(iii) Anyone who would not deposit the amount would not be permitted to participate in the auction as speculative bids are to be totally avoided.
(iv) The newspaper publication shall be made within a period of two weeks stipulating that the deposit is a condition precedent for participation in the auction which shall be made before DRT within a week from the date of publication of the advertisement in the newspapers.
(v) The auction shall be held within a period of two weeks from the issuance of the advertisement which shall state the specified time and place for the auction.
(vi) The petitioners without prejudice to the contentions to be raised and dealt with in these special leave petitions shall participate in the bid without the deposit as they have purchased the property in the year 2006.
(vii) The bid shall not be finalised and the bid-sheet shall be produced before this Court in a sealed cover.
9. We reiterate at the cost of repetition that the above arrangements are subject to the result of the final adjudication in these special leave petitions. List the matter after five weeks.”

3. After the said order was passed two interlocutory applications forming Nos. 4-6 of 2012 were filed. This Court, looking at the facts and the contentions raised, passed the following order (2012) 10 SCC 274 on the said applications:

“1. These applications were preferred by the Bank stating that going by the present valuation the property will fetch nearly Rs 10 crores whereas the order stipulates reserved price of only Rs 3 crores. Hence, the Bank has sought modification of the upset price fixed by the Court.
2. The learned counsel for the Bank also submitted that as per the Debts Recovery Tribunal Act the time stipulated for auction is thirty days whereas the order directs to conduct the auction within two weeks. To this extent the respondent seeks modification of that direction also.
3. The learned counsel on the either side submitted that the auction should go on without any delay.
4. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case we are inclined to dispose of these applications directing the Recovery Officer to go on with the auction within the time-limit stipulated in the bid. The question as to whether the upset price has been correctly fixed or not will depend upon the bid amount offered by the bidders in the auction.
5. With the above directions, the IAs are disposed of.”

4. In the present applications it has been asseverated that in compliance with the order dated 5-7-2012 (2012) 10 SCC 274, the Recovery Officer of Debt Recovery Tribunal I, Mumbai, ordered for publication of the notice in two newspapers which was published on 20-7-2012 calling upon the interested parties to give their offer within seven days from the date of publication as directed by this Court vide order dated 27-3-2012 (2012) 10 SCC 271. Pursuant to the publication carried in English and Kannada newspapers no other offer whatsoever was received by the Recovery Officer and till 7th only the offer of the petitioners, namely, Praveen Gada and Amarnath Singhla, was received.

5. When the matter was taken up, order dated 30-8-2012 passed in RP No. 419 of 2003 was brought to our notice. The said order reads as under:

“As per the directions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court vide its orders dated 27-3-2012 (2012) 10 SCC 271 and 5-7-2012 (2012) 10 SCC 274, advertisement was published fixing reserve price at Rs 3 crores.
Only one bid of Shri Pravin Gada and Amarnath Singhla has been received on 7-8-2012 as per public notice. His bid was opened at the scheduled date and time of the auction. He has given offer of Rs 3 crores. As his participation in the auction was without deposit as directed in the above orders, there was no question of his depositing EMD.
Relevant columns of bid sheet were accordingly filled in and signature of the bidder has been obtained. As per the directions, the said bid sheet be submitted to the Hon'ble Supreme Court.
Apart from the above, three offers in closed envelopes were received today, but those are not opened and considered in view of the directions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court as per the aforesaid orders.
On the date of auction the above three closed envelopes containing offers have been received. This being new situation arisen at the time of auction, in my opinion it would be appropriate to bring this fact to the kind notice of the Hon'ble Supreme Court. Hence these three closed envelopes be also submitted to the Hon'ble Supreme Court.
As per the directions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the bid sheet at Ext. 154 be submitted to the Hon'ble Supreme Court in a sealed cover.”

6. The bid sheets were opened before us and we find that an offer amounting to Rs 3,30,00,000 by Kumar Enterprises, Rs 3,30,00,000 by Riddisiddhi Bullions Ltd. and Rs 3,30,00,000 by Krishna Texturisers Pvt. Ltd. were deposited by way of bank drafts on 29-8-2012 and 30-8-2012 respectively.

7. It is submitted by Mr Sundaram, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners that as the said offers were not in accord, the same should not be considered and the petitioners should be treated as the highest bidder in the auction. Mr Rohatgi and Mr Gupta, learned Senior Counsel for Central Bank of India, per contra, submitted that the price of the property as on today is worth more than Rs 10 crores and the reason for the offerees not coming is that the petitioners are in possession and they have put up a board indicating their name and status. It is urged by them that it is one thing to say that the auction is conducted by virtue of the order passed by this Court and the whole thing is subject to the pendency of the lis but it is another thing to see at the entrance that the board is fixed and the people are not allowed to survey the nature and character of the assets. The photographs of the board that have been put up are filed in Court and we have perused the same. Be it noted that the putting up of the said photographs (sic board) is not disputed.

8. Regard being had to the facts and circumstances, we are of the considered opinion that there should be a re-auction and we are inclined to modify the conditions incorporated in the earlier order. Keeping in view the totality of circumstances we issue the following directions:

(i) The property in question be put to auction by issuing a public advertisement within two weeks in at least two newspapers, one in English and another in Kannada language, having wide circulation in the city of Mysore inviting bids for the sale of the property.
(ii) It shall be mentioned in the advertisement that the reserved price is Rs 5 crores and the same shall be deposited by way of bank drafts drawn on a nationalised bank before the Recovery Officer of the DRT to enable one to participate in the bid. The advertisement shall stipulate that the deposit of the reserved price fixed by this Court is a condition precedent for participation in the auction.
(iii) It shall be clearly stated in the advertisement that the property would be available for inspection in presence of the Registrar of civil court or any equivalent officer nominated by the Principal District and Sessions Judge, Mysore, and it is so done to avoid the grievance from any quarter that the property was not available for proper verification. The inspection by any interested party shall be done within one week from the date of advertisement between 11.00 a.m to 3.00 p.m
(iv) During the entire period of inspection the officer concerned deputed by the learned Principal District and Sessions Judge, Mysore shall see to it that the board that has been fixed is removed from the site so that there can be inspection of the plot without any kind of preconceived notion by the perspective bidders.
(v) The aforesaid reserved price shall be deposited before the Recovery Officer of the DRT within ten days from the date of the advertisement. Any one who would not deposit the reserved price within the time-limit, his bid shall not be considered.
(vi) The auction shall be held within a period of two weeks from the date of issuance of the advertisement which shall state the specified time and place for the auction.
(vii) The petitioners without prejudice to the contentions to be raised and dealt with in these special leave petitions shall participate in the auction without the deposit as they have purchased the property in the year 2006.
(viii) The offerees who have already given the bids shall deposit the balance amount to meet the reserved price before the Recovery Officer of the DRT failing which they shall be ineligible to participate in the bid.
(ix) After the submission of the bids there shall be a public auction amongst the eligible offerees to get the maximum price.
(x) The auction shall not be finalised and the bid sheet shall be produced before this Court in a sealed cover for issuance of further directions, if required.

9. We repeat at the cost of repetition that the above arrangements are subject to the result of the final adjudication to the special leave petitions.

10. A copy of the order passed today be sent by fax, email and speed post to the Principal District Judge, Mysore by the Registry of this Court.

11. List the matters on 1-11-2012.