- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State Of Uttarakhand And Another v. Umakant Joshi .
Factual and Procedural Background
Respondent 1, Umakant Joshi, entered Uttar Pradesh government service in 1984 as Manager (Marketing) after litigation over his original appointment. Between 1987 and 1999 he received several adverse annual-confidential-report (ACR) entries and, after four departmental inquiries, was punished in 1999 with reduction to the minimum of the pay-scale. In 2000 the State of Uttaranchal (now Uttarakhand) was carved out of Uttar Pradesh and Joshi, together with other officers, was provisionally and later finally allotted to the new State.
Joshi’s punishment was withdrawn by the Government of Uttarakhand on 17-1-2005 and the adverse ACR entry for 1995-1996 was expunged on 11-8-2005. He then sought retrospective promotion to Class I (General Manager) with effect from 16-11-1989—the date on which juniors such as Shri R.K. Khare had been promoted by the erstwhile State of Uttar Pradesh. When administrative representations failed, he filed Writ Petition No. 324 of 2008 in the Uttarakhand High Court, which granted the relief on 6-4-2010, directing his promotion from 16-11-1989 and consequential consideration for higher posts.
The State of Uttarakhand, its Director of Industries, and two affected officers (Appellants 1 and 2) appealed to the Supreme Court, challenging the High Court’s order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Uttarakhand High Court had jurisdiction to direct retrospective promotion of Respondent 1 to a date (16-11-1989) prior to the creation of the State of Uttarakhand.
- Whether, in the absence of the State of Uttar Pradesh as a party, such a direction could validly be issued affecting its earlier promotion orders.
- Whether the High Court could, in exercise of Article 226, mandate promotion ignoring service-record blemishes that existed on the relevant date.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants’ Arguments (State of Uttarakhand, Director of Industries, Sudhir Chandra Nautiyal & Surendra Singh Rawat)
- The writ petition was barred by laches; Respondent 1 approached the court almost two decades after the claimed date of promotion.
- Necessary parties (especially the State of Uttar Pradesh and affected seniors) were not impleaded, rendering the petition non-maintainable.
- The Uttarakhand High Court lacked territorial and subject-matter jurisdiction to order a promotion effective before the State’s formation (9-11-2000).
- Under Article 226, a court should rarely direct promotions; no exceptional circumstances existed here.
- Respondent 1’s reliance on Shri R.K. Khare and Shri S.C. Chandola was misplaced because their service situations differed and they belonged to Uttar Pradesh cadre at the relevant time.
Respondent 1’s Arguments
- Once the 1999 punishment and adverse ACR entries were withdrawn, no impediment remained to consider his promotion retrospectively.
- His juniors, including Shri R.K. Khare (promoted on 16-11-1989) and officers promoted on 22-1-2001, had already received the benefit; denial to him violated parity and fairness.
- The State of Uttarakhand had itself promoted similarly placed officers (e.g., Shri S.C. Chandola) with retrospective effect, demonstrating jurisdiction and precedent for such relief.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court noted that, at the time promotions were granted in 1989, Respondent 1’s record contained adverse ACRs and a subsisting punishment; hence he was legitimately not considered then. Although those blemishes were later removed (2005), any reconsideration for 1989 promotion lay within the exclusive authority of the State of Uttar Pradesh, the employer at that time.
The Court emphasised that the State of Uttarakhand—and by extension its High Court—came into existence only on 9-11-2000. Therefore, the Uttarakhand High Court could not adjudicate or issue mandamus relating to service matters governed by Uttar Pradesh before that date, especially without making Uttar Pradesh a party. It characterised the High Court’s action as a “jurisdictional error”.
The Court also observed that counsel for Uttarakhand had failed to draw the High Court’s attention to this jurisdictional limitation, which led to the erroneous order. While acknowledging that withdrawal of punishment entitled Respondent 1 to fresh consideration, the Court clarified that such consideration must occur before the competent forum—potentially the Allahabad High Court—rather than Uttarakhand courts.
Holding and Implications
Appeals Allowed; High Court order dated 6-4-2010 set aside; Writ Petition No. 324 of 2008 dismissed.
Immediate Effect: Respondent 1’s retrospective promotion stands annulled. He may, however, pursue remedies before the Allahabad High Court, as the Supreme Court expressly refrained from deciding the merits of his entitlement or the validity of the 2005 order withdrawing punishment.
Broader Implications: The judgment reinforces jurisdictional boundaries for successor-state High Courts in service matters predating state reorganisation; no new substantive service-law precedent was established.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
G.S Singhvi, J.— Whether the Uttarakhand High Court could ordain promotion of Respondent 1, Umakant Joshi to the post of General Manager with effect from 16-11-1989 i.e prior to formation of the State of Uttaranchal (now known as “the State of Uttarakhand”) with the direction that he shall be considered for promotion to the higher posts with effect from the dates persons junior to him were promoted is the question which arises for consideration in these appeals, one of which has been filed by the State of Uttarakhand and the Director of Industries, Dehradun and the other two have been filed by Sudhir Chandra Nautiyal (hereinafter described as “Appellant 1”) and Surendra Singh Rawat (hereinafter described as “Appellant 2”) respectively, against the order dated 6-4-2010 WP (SB) No. 324 of 2008 passed by the Division Bench of that High Court in Writ Petition No. 324 of 2008.
The service profile of Appellant 1
2. On being selected by the Uttar Pradesh Public Service Commission (for short “the Commission”), Appellant 1 was appointed to Class I post in the Industries Department of the Government of Uttar Pradesh with effect from 7-2-1994. After formation of the State of Uttaranchal, in terms of Section 3 of the Uttar Pradesh Reorganisation Act, 2000 (for short “the Act”), the Central Government issued an Order dated 20-12-2000 under Section 73 thereof and tentatively allotted Appellant 1 along with large number of other officers/employees of the State of Uttar Pradesh including Respondent 1 to the new State of Uttaranchal. They were finally allotted to the new State vide Order dated 17-5-2006. Appellant 1 was promoted as the Joint Director of Industries on ad hoc basis in the State of Uttarakhand with effect from 17-1-2004. He was regularly promoted on that post on 23-7-2007. After two years, he was promoted as the Additional Director, Industries.
The service profile of Appellant 2
3. Appellant 2 was appointed in the U.P Industries (Subordinate) Service in 1979. He opted for Hill Sub-Cadre formed by the State of Uttar Pradesh in 1992. His name was included in the separate seniority list of the officers of that cadre and on formation of the State of Uttaranchal, he was treated as an employee of the new State. Appellant 2 was promoted to the U.P Industries Class I service in 1996. He was further promoted to the post of Deputy Director/General Manager (Grade I) with effect from 19-1-2004.
The service profile of Respondent 1
4. In response to an advertisement issued by the Commission in 1981 for recruitment to Class II posts in the pay scales of Rs 550-1200 and Rs 450-900, Respondent 1 applied for the post of Manager (Marketing) in the pay scale of Rs 550-1200. He was selected by the Commission for that post but was offered appointment on the lower post of Manager, Handloom in the pay scale of Rs 450-900.
5. After joining the service, Respondent 1 filed Writ Petition No. 9728 of 1986 in the Allahabad High Court and prayed for issuance of a mandamus for his appointment on the post for which he had applied. In compliance with an interim order passed by the High Court on 2-3-1987, Respondent 1 was appointed as the Manager (Marketing) with effect from the date of initial appointment i.e 23-4-1984. The writ petition was finally allowed by the High Court vide order dated 1-12-1995 WP No. 9728 of 1986 and a direction was issued to the State Government to give consequential benefits to Respondent 1. Thereafter, seniority of Respondent 1 was fixed among Class II officers at Serial No. 48-A.
6. While he was working as the Manager (Marketing) in the Directorate of Industries, Uttar Pradesh, Respondent 1 earned adverse remarks in the annual confidential reports for the years 1987-1988, 1988-1989, 1989-1990 and 1991-1992. Four departmental enquiries were also initiated against Respondent 1 between July 1996 and March 1997. These inquiries culminated in the issuance of order dated 23-1-1999 whereby punishment of reduction to the minimum of the pay scale was imposed on Respondent 1. As a sequel to this, an adverse entry was made in the annual confidential report of Respondent 1 for the year 1995-1996 casting reflection on his integrity.
7. Respondent 1 submitted representation dated 14-1-2000 to the State Government for reconsideration/review of the order of punishment. He also filed a writ petition in the Allahabad High Court for quashing the order of punishment. While the representation and the writ petition filed by Respondent 1 were pending consideration, Parliament enacted the Act and the Central Government allotted the services of Respondent 1 to the new State. Thereafter, Respondent 1 made representation dated 23-12-2000 to the Government of the new State for review of the order of punishment.
8. The Allahabad High Court transferred the pending writ petition to the High Court of Uttaranchal (now Uttarakhand), which disposed of the same by relegating Respondent 1 to the alternative remedy of filing an application before the State Public Services Tribunal (for short “the Tribunal”).
9. During the pendency of the matter before the Tribunal, the Government of Uttarakhand considered the representations made by Respondent 1 and proposed that the punishment order may be withdrawn. The Governor of Uttarakhand approved the proposal. Thereafter, the State Government issued an Order dated 17-1-2005, which was described as an office memorandum for withdrawal of the order of punishment.
10. The relevant portion of that order is extracted below:
“Office Memorandum
After due consideration of the representations dated 14-1-2000 and 23-12-2000 submitted by Sh. Uma Kant Joshi against the punishment given vide Office Memorandum No. 4482/181-81(R)/96 dated 23-1-1999 by the Secretary, Small-Scale Industry, Government of U.P to Sh. Uma Kant Joshi, the then Manager (Marketing and Economic Survey), District Industry Centre, Kotdwar, Pauri Garhwal, present in charge General Manager, District Industry Centre, Udhamsingh Nagar, the Governor hereby accords approval to withdraw the said punishment order dated 23-1-1999 upon its merit.
sd/-
Sanjeev Chopra,
Secretary”
11. After about 7 months, the State Government issued an Order dated 11-8-2005 and expunged the adverse entry recorded in the annual confidential report of Respondent 1 for the year 1995-1996.
12. The Tribunal took cognizance of the aforementioned two orders and disposed of the petition filed by Respondent 1 as infructuous. Soon thereafter, he submitted a representation to the Government of Uttar Pradesh for promotion to the post of Deputy Director/General Manager, Industries with effect from 16-11-1989 i.e the date on which persons junior to him were promoted. The same was forwarded to the Government of Uttarakhand, which issued an Order dated 11-10-2006 and promoted Respondent 1 to Class I post. However, his prayer for retrospective promotion was not entertained.
13. After about 2 years, Respondent 1 filed Writ Petition No. 324 of 2008 and prayed for issuance of a direction to the respondents (State of Uttarakhand and Director, Directorate of Industries) to give him the benefit of the timescale and the selection grade respectively with effect from the date of completion of 8 years' and 14 years' service and notional promotion to Class I post from 1989. In support of his claim, Respondent 1 relied upon the orders passed in favour of Shri R.K Khare, who was promoted to Class I post with effect from 16-11-1989. He also relied upon the Orders dated 22-1-2001 passed by the Governments of the States of Uttar Pradesh and Uttarakhand whereby large number of officers including Shri S.C Chandola, who were senior to Shri R.K Khare were promoted to Class I posts with effect from 16-11-1989.
14. In the reply-affidavit filed on behalf of the State of Uttarakhand and the Director of Industries, an objection was taken to the maintainability of the writ petition on the ground of non-impleadment of the State of Uttar Pradesh as the party-respondent. On merits, it was pleaded that Respondent 1 cannot claim parity with Shri R.K Khare because the latter was not allotted to the State of Uttarakhand. As regards Shri S.C Chandola, it was averred that he was appointed on a Class II post on 16-9-1976 and was assigned seniority at Serial No. 16, whereas Respondent 1 was appointed on 23-4-1984 and his seniority was fixed at Serial No. 49. It was further averred that at the time of allotment to the State of Uttarakhand, Shri S.C Chandola was holding Class I post in the pay scale of Rs 10,000-15,200, whereas Respondent 1 was holding a post in the pay scale of Rs 8000-13,500.
15. The Division Bench of the High Court took cognizance of the Orders dated 17-1-2005 and 11-8-2005 and held that once the order of punishment was withdrawn and there was no adverse material in the record of Respondent 1, he was entitled to be promoted to Class I post with effect from the date his junior Shri R.K Khare was promoted. The Division Bench accordingly directed that Respondent 1 be promoted to the post of General Manager with effect from 16-11-1989 and his case be considered for promotion to the higher posts from the dates persons junior to him were promoted.
16. Before proceeding further, we may notice some other facts which have bearing on the decision of these appeals.
17. In exercise of the powers conferred upon it by Rules 18 and 39 to 41 of the Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1930, the Government of United Province had made the United Provinces Industries Service Class I Rules, 1937 for regulating appointment to the posts of Director/Deputy Director, Member, Harcourt Butler Technological Institute, Heads of Sections of Harcourt Butler Technological Institute and Glass Technologist.
18. After Independence, the Governor of Uttar Pradesh made the Uttar Pradesh Industries Service Rules, 1993 (for short “the 1993 Rules”) for regulating recruitment on various posts which were categorised in two groups i.e Group ‘A’ and Group ‘B’. Prior to this, the Government of Uttar Pradesh had issued G.O dated 4-2-1989 in terms of which only those members in the feeder cadre were treated eligible for promotion who had completed 7 years' service as on 1st July. By another G.O issued on 31-3-1993, the State Government decided that timescale shall be granted to an employee on completion of 8 years' satisfactory service.
19. By virtue of Section 3 of the Act, the new State of Uttaranchal was formed. Sections 73 and 74 of the Act, which relate to the services other than All India Services read as under:
“73. Provisions relating to other services.—(1) Every person who immediately before the appointed day is serving in connection with the affairs of the existing State of Uttar Pradesh shall, on and from that day provisionally continue to serve in connection with the affairs of the State of Uttar Pradesh unless he is required, by general or special order of the Central Government to serve provisionally in connection with the affairs of the State of Uttaranchal:
Provided that every direction under this sub-section issued after the expiry of a period of one year from the appointed day shall be issued with the consultation of the Governments of the successor States.
(2) As soon as may be after the appointed day, the Central Government shall, by general or special order, determine the successor State to which every person referred to in sub-section (1) shall be finally allotted for service and the date with effect from which such allotment shall take effect or be deemed to have taken effect.
(3) Every person who is finally allotted under the provisions of sub-section (2) to a successor State shall, if he is not already serving therein be made available for serving in the successor State from such date as may be agreed upon between the Governments concerned or in default of such agreement, as may be determined by the Central Government.
74. Other provisions relating to services.—(1) Nothing in this section or in Section 73 shall be deemed to affect on or after the appointed day, the operation of the provisions of Chapter I of Part XIV of the Constitution in relation to determination of the conditions of service of persons serving in connection with the affairs of the Union or any State:
Provided that the conditions of service applicable immediately before the appointed day in the case of any person deemed to have been allocated to the State of Uttar Pradesh or to the State of Uttaranchal under Section 73 shall not be varied to his disadvantage except with the previous approval of the Central Government.
(2) All services prior to the appointed day rendered by a person—
(a) if he is deemed to have been allocated to any State under Section 73, shall be deemed to have been rendered in connection with the affairs of that State;
(b) if he is deemed to have been allocated to the Union in connection with the administration of the Uttaranchal, shall be deemed to have been rendered in connection with the affairs of the Union,
for the purposes of the rules regulating his conditions of service.
(3) The provisions of Section 73, shall not apply in relation to members of any All India Service.”
20. On 7-11-2002, adoption and modification orders were issued in relation to the Uttar Pradesh Industries Service Rules, 1993 and the Uttar Pradesh Industries (Senior Group ‘A’) Service Rules, 1991.
21. On the recommendations of the Commission, Shri R.K Khare was appointed as the Survey Officer in the pay scale of Rs 450-950 with effect from 27-12-1974. He was appointed as the Assistant Development Officer (Small Engineering Industries) with effect from 3-11-1976 in the pay scale of Rs 550-1200 on ad hoc basis. Subsequently, the State Government issued G.O dated 11-10-1977 and conveyed sanction of the Governor to the appointment of Shri R.K Khare as the Assistant Development Officer (SEI). On 22-3-1980, he was appointed as ad hoc Class I officer in the pay scale of Rs 800-1450. The ad hoc appointment of Shri R.K Khare was regularised with effect from 16-11-1989 under the Uttar Pradesh Regularisation of Ad hoc Appointments (on Posts within Purview of Public Service Commission) Rules, 1988.
22. By an Order dated 22-1-2001, the Government of Uttar Pradesh promoted 19 Class II officers, who were senior to Shri R.K Khare to Class I posts on notional basis with effect from 16-11-1989.
23. S/Shri J.L Gupta and Subodh Markandeya, learned Senior Counsel appearing for Appellants 1 and 2 and Ms Rachana Srivastava, learned counsel appearing for the State of Uttarakhand argued that the impugned order WP (SB) No. 324 of 2008 is liable to be set aside because while granting relief to Respondent 1, the High Court completely ignored that he was guilty of laches and that the persons who were going to be adversely affected by retrospective promotion of Respondent 1 had not been impleaded as party-respondents. The learned counsel further argued that the Uttarakhand High Court did not have the jurisdiction to direct promotion of Respondent 1 to Class I post with effect from a date prior to formation of the new State and even the Allahabad High Court could not have issued a mandamus for promotion of Respondent 1 dehors his service record.
24. The learned counsel emphasised that in exercise of the power under Article 226 of the Constitution, the High Court cannot, except in exceptional circumstances, issue direction for promotion of an officer/official and the case of Respondent 1 did not fall in that category. Ms Srivastava pointed out that even though Shri R.K Khare was junior to Respondent 1 in the seniority list of Class II officers, his promotion to Class I post with effect from 16-11-1989 did not give a cause to Respondent 1 to seek intervention of the Uttarakhand High Court for promotion with effect from that date because till then, he continued to be an employee of the State of Uttar Pradesh.
25. Shri Pramod Swarup, learned Senior Counsel appearing for Respondent 1 defended the directions given by the High Court and argued that once the order of punishment was withdrawn and the remarks recorded in the annual confidential report of Respondent 1 casting adverse reflection on his integrity were expunged, he became entitled to be considered for promotion to Class I post with effect from the date persons junior to him, namely, Shri R.K Khare and others were promoted. The learned Senior Counsel emphasised that after having issued Order dated 22-1-2001 for promotion of Shri S.C Chandola to Class I post with effect from 16-11-1989, it is not open to the Government of Uttarakhand to contend that the High Court did not have the jurisdiction to issue direction for retrospective promotion of Respondent 1.
26. We have considered the respective submissions. It is not in dispute that at the time of promotion of Class II officers including Shri R.K Khare to Class I posts with effect from 16-11-1989 by the Government of Uttar Pradesh, the case of Respondent 1 was not considered because of the adverse remarks recorded in his annual confidential report and the punishment imposed vide Order dated 23-1-1999. Once the order of punishment was set aside, Respondent 1 became entitled to be considered for promotion to Class I post with effect from 16-11-1989. That exercise could have been undertaken only by the Government of Uttar Pradesh and not by the State of Uttaranchal (now the State of Uttarakhand), which was formed on 9-11-2000.
27. Therefore, the High Court of Uttarakhand, which too came into existence with effect from 9-11-2000 did not have the jurisdiction to entertain the writ petition filed by Respondent 1 for issue of a mandamus to the State Government to promote him to Class I post with effect from 16-11-1989, more so because the issues raised in the writ petition involved examination of the legality of the decision taken by the Government of Uttar Pradesh to promote Shri R.K Khare with effect from 16-11-1989 and other officers, who were promoted to Class I post vide Order dated 22-1-2001 with retrospective effect.
28. It appears to us that the counsel, who appeared on behalf of the State of Uttarakhand and the Director of Industries did not draw the attention of the High Court that it was not competent to issue direction for promotion of Respondent 1 with effect from a date prior to formation of the new State, and that too, without hearing the State of Uttar Pradesh and this is the reason why the High Court did not examine the issue of its jurisdiction to entertain the prayer made by Respondent 1.
29. In view of the above, we hold that the writ petition filed by Respondent 1 in 2008 in the Uttarakhand High Court claiming retrospective promotion to Class I post with effect from 16-11-1989 was misconceived and the High Court committed jurisdictional error by issuing direction for his promotion to the post of General Manager with effect from 16-11-1989 and for consideration of his case for promotion to the higher posts with effect from the date of promotion of his so-called juniors.
30. In the result, the appeals are allowed, the impugned order WP (SB) No. 324 of 2008 is set aside and the writ petition filed by Respondent 1 is dismissed.
31. However, it is made clear that this Court has not expressed any opinion on the merits of the entitlement of Respondent 1 to claim promotion to Class I post with retrospective effect and, if so advised, he may avail appropriate remedy by filing a petition in the Allahabad High Court. It is also made clear that we have not expressed any opinion on the legality or otherwise of the Order dated 17-1-2005 issued by the Government of Uttarakhand withdrawing the order of punishment passed against Respondent 1 and the writ petition, if any, pending before the Uttarakhand High Court against that order shall be decided without being influenced by the proceedings in these appeals.
Alert