Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Jile Singh v. State Of Uttar Pradesh And Another

Supreme Court Of India
Jan 12, 2012
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

On 26-10-2008, Bharat Lal Sharma was murdered. The next morning his father (Respondent 2) lodged a First Information Report (FIR) at Police Station Kosikalan, requesting registration of a case against unknown persons. After investigation, the police filed a charge-sheet naming only Hari Singh as the accused and expressly stating that no case was made out against the present appellant, Jile Singh.

On 2-5-2009 the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Mathura, committed Hari Singh’s case to the Sessions Judge for trial. Dissatisfied with the police report, Respondent 2 filed a private complaint under Section 200 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC) against the appellant and one Jayveer Singh. After recording statements under Section 202 CrPC, the Magistrate issued summons to the appellant on 3-1-2011 under Section 204(1)(b) CrPC.

The appellant challenged this order in criminal revision before the Allahabad High Court, which dismissed the revision on 10-3-2011. The appellant then approached the Supreme Court by way of special leave, leading to the present decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, after committal of the case to the Sessions Court under Section 209 CrPC, the Chief Judicial Magistrate had jurisdiction to summon a new accused on a private complaint under Section 200/204 CrPC.
  2. Whether the proper statutory mechanism for adding a person not charge-sheeted by the police is confined to the Sessions Court’s power under Section 319 CrPC.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The Magistrate lacked jurisdiction to issue summons once the case had been committed to the Sessions Court; only the Sessions Court may add an accused and only under Section 319 CrPC.
  • Relied on Supreme Court precedents in Ranjit Singh v. State of Punjab (1998) and Kishori Singh v. State of Bihar (2004) to support this proposition.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The complainant is entitled to file a private complaint when the police omit an offender, and the Magistrate may take cognizance under Section 200 CrPC.
  • Cited Hareram Satpathy v. Tikaram Agarwala (1978) and Kishan Lal v. Dharmendra Bafna (2009) to contend that filing such a complaint or a protest petition is permissible when some culprits are left out in the police report.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ranjit Singh v. State of Punjab (1998) 7 SCC 149 Sessions Court can add a new accused only after evidence is collected and only through Section 319 CrPC; no power exists to add an accused at a pre-evidence stage. Treated as binding authority; formed the core basis for holding the Magistrate’s summons without jurisdiction.
Kishori Singh v. State of Bihar (2004) 13 SCC 11 Reaffirmed Ranjit Singh; Magistrate cannot issue process against persons omitted from the police charge-sheet after committal. Relied upon to reinforce that addition of an accused must comply with Section 319 CrPC.
Hareram Satpathy v. Tikaram Agarwala (1978) 4 SCC 58 Permits complainant to file a protest or complaint where the police omit a suspect. Distinguished as inapplicable because it did not involve the post-committal stage governed by Section 209 CrPC.
Kishan Lal v. Dharmendra Bafna (2009) 7 SCC 685 Recognises complainant’s right to notice of police report and to file a protest petition. Held not relevant to the jurisdictional question after committal.
Raj Kishore Prasad v. State of Bihar (1996) 4 SCC 495 Discusses circumstances for arraying additional accused. Cited within Kishori Singh; forms part of the analytical chain supporting the decision.
India Carat (P) Ltd. v. State of Karnataka (1989) 2 SCC 132 Principles on taking cognizance when police file a final report. Referenced in conjunction with Kishori Singh; no direct application distinct from main holding.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court held that once a case has been committed to the Sessions Court under Section 209 CrPC, only the Sessions Court has competence to add a new accused, and that competence arises solely under Section 319 CrPC after some evidence is available. The Chief Judicial Magistrate’s issuance of summons under Section 204(1)(b) CrPC therefore exceeded his jurisdiction.

The Court carefully traced the statutory scheme: following committal, the Sessions Court can deal only with the accused sent up under Section 209. The next procedural point at which additional persons may be arraigned is after evidence begins, invoking Section 319. This interpretation had already been definitively settled in Ranjit Singh and reaffirmed in Kishori Singh. Allowing the Magistrate’s order would undermine this framework by enabling the addition of an accused before any evidence is taken.

Decisions cited by the respondents (Hareram Satpathy and Kishan Lal) were found to concern scenarios prior to committal or relating to protest petitions and therefore did not disturb the binding ratio of Ranjit Singh.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed; orders of the High Court (10-3-2011) and the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Mathura (3-1-2011) are set aside.

Immediate Effect: The summons issued to the appellant are quashed; the appellant is removed from the array of accused in the pending Sessions trial.

Future Implications: The Sessions Judge retains the power under Section 319 CrPC to summon the appellant or any other person if evidence during trial justifies such action. No new legal principle was created; the judgment reaffirms the existing precedent on the post-committal jurisdictional divide between Magistrate and Sessions Courts.

Show all summary ...

R.M Lodha, J.— Leave granted. A certain Bharat Lal Sharma was done to death on 26-10-2008. His father (Respondent 2 herein) informed Police Station Kosikalan on the next day i.e 27-10-2008 at 8 a.m that he had received an information in the morning at about 7 a.m that his son Bharat Lal Sharma had been murdered and his dead body was lying in the agricultural field of Ghure, son of Gaisi, “Jat” resident of Tumaura. On receipt of this information, he (Respondent 2 herein) went to the spot and found that the body of his son was lying in blood. His son was killed with some sharp-edged weapon the previous night. He requested the police to register the first information report (FIR) against unknown accused persons and take appropriate action in the matter. On this information, an FIR was registered and investigation commenced.

2. On conclusion of the investigation, the investigating officer submitted a charge-sheet naming one Hari Singh as an accused having committed the murder of Bharat Lal Sharma. On the basis of the material collected by the investigating officer, no case was found out against the present appellant, Jile Singh and the investigating officer concluded that the appellant has been falsely named in the course of investigation.

3. On 2-5-2009, the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Mathura, committed the accused, Hari Singh to the Court of the Sessions Judge, Mathura for trial. It was then that the complainant Respondent 2 herein filed a private complaint under Section 200 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short “the Code”) in the Court of the Judicial Magistrate, Mathura, against the present appellant and one Jayveer Singh for the murder of his son Bharat Lal Sharma.

4. The Chief Judicial Magistrate, Mathura, after recording the statements under Section 202 CrPC, issued summons to the appellant on 3-1-2011. Aggrieved by that order, the appellant filed criminal revision before the Allahabad High Court which came to be dismissed on 10-3-2011. It is from this order that the present appeal, by special leave, has arisen.

5. Mr Manoj Saxena, learned counsel for the appellant, submitted that the issuance of summons by the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Mathura, on a private complaint made by Respondent 2 after committal of accused Hari Singh for the murder of Bharat Lal Sharma to the Sessions Court, was without jurisdiction. He would submit that addition of a new person to the array of the accused in a case pending before the Sessions Court can only be done by that court in exercise of the power under Section 319 CrPC and in no other way. In this regard, he relied upon the decisions of this Court in Ranjit Singh v. State of Punjab (1998) 7 SCC 149 and Kishori Singh v. State of Bihar (2004) 13 SCC 11.

6. Mr Ratnakar Dash, learned Senior Counsel for Respondent 1, State of Uttar Pradesh, and Mr Vikram Patralekh, learned counsel for Respondent 2 complainant, stoutly defended the impugned order. They submitted that the complaint filed by the complainant before the Magistrate was maintainable under Section 200 CrPC since the investigating officer on conclusion of the investigation did not name the appellant as accused although there was material to that effect in the course of investigation.

7. The learned Senior Counsel and the learned counsel for the respondents submitted that if on receipt of a report, the police takes up the investigation of a case and on completion thereof submits a charge-sheet against few persons and leaves the other persons involved in the crime by stating in the report that no case has been made out against such person, it is open to the aggrieved complainant to file a complaint under Section 200 CrPC and the Magistrate is empowered to issue summons. In this regard, they relied upon a decision of this Court in Hareram Satpathy v. Tikaram Agarwala (1978) 4 SCC 58.

8. Mr Ratnakar Dash, learned Senior Counsel for Respondent 1, also referred to another decision of this Court in Kishan Lal v. Dharmendra Bafna (2009) 7 SCC 685 and submitted that if a right has been given to the complainant to be given notice of filing of the police report and to file protest petition, there is no impediment in the law for maintaining a complaint if persons involved in the crime have been left over by the police in the course of the investigation.

9. The present case, in our view, is squarely covered by the law laid down by this Court in Ranjit Singh (1998) 7 SCC 149 and the subsequent decision in Kishori Singh (2004) 13 SCC 11 reiterating the same legal position.

10. In Ranjit Singh (1998) 7 SCC 149, this Court was concerned with the issue whether the Sessions Court can add a new person to the array of the accused in a case pending before it at a stage prior to collecting any evidence. The three-Judge Bench that considered the above issue referred to various provisions of CrPC, namely, Sections 204, 207, 208, 209, 225, 226, 227, 228, 229, 230 and 319 and held as under: (Ranjit Singh case (1998) 7 SCC 149)

“19. So from the stage of committal till the Sessions Court reaches the stage indicated in Section 230 CrPC, that court can deal with only the accused referred to in Section 209 CrPC. There is no intermediary stage till then for the Sessions Court to add any other person to the array of the accused.
20. Thus, once the Sessions Court takes cognizance of the offence pursuant to the committal order, the only other stage when the court is empowered to add any other person to the array of the accused is after reaching evidence collection when powers under Section 319 CrPC can be invoked. We are unable to find any other power for the Sessions Court to permit addition of new person or persons to the array of the accused. Of course it is not necessary for the court to wait until the entire evidence is collected for exercising the said powers.”

11. The above legal position has been reiterated by this Court in a subsequent decision in Kishori Singh (2004) 13 SCC 11. The two-Judge Bench in Kishori Singh (2004) 13 SCC 11 considered some of the provisions of CrPC and earlier decision of this Court in Ranjit Singh (1998) 7 SCC 149 and two other decisions, namely, Raj Kishore Prasad v. State of Bihar (1996) 4 SCC 495 and India Carat (P) Ltd. v. State of Karnataka (1989) 2 SCC 132 and held as under: (Kishori Singh case (2004) 13 SCC 11)

“9. After going through the provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure and the aforesaid two judgments and on examining the order dated 10-6-1997 passed by the Magistrate, we have no hesitation to come to the conclusion that the Magistrate could not have issued process against those persons who may have been named in the FIR as accused persons, but not charge-sheeted in the charge-sheet that was filed by the police under Section 173 CrPC.
10. So far as those persons against whom charge-sheet has not been filed, they can be arrayed as ‘accused persons’ in exercise of powers under Section 319 CrPC when some evidence or materials are brought on record in course of trial or they could also be arrayed as ‘accused persons’ only when a reference is made either by the Magistrate while passing an order of commitment or by the learned Sessions Judge to the High Court and the High Court, on examining the materials, comes to the conclusion that sufficient materials exist against them even though the police might not have filed charge-sheet, as has been explained in the latter three-Judge Bench decision. Neither of the contingencies has arisen in the case in hand.”

12. In the present case, if the order passed by the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Mathura, in issuing summons against the appellant on the complaint filed by Respondent 2 complainant, which has been confirmed by the High Court, is allowed to stand, it would mean addition of the appellant to the array of the accused in a pending case before the Sessions Judge at a stage prior to collecting any evidence by that court. This course is absolutely impermissible in view of the law laid down by a three-Judge Bench of this Court in Ranjit Singh (1998) 7 SCC 149.

13. The stage of Section 209 CrPC having been reached in the case, it was not open to the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Mathura to exercise the power under Section 204(1)(b) CrPC and issue summons to the appellant. The order of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Mathura is totally without jurisdiction. The High Court was clearly in error in not keeping in view the law laid by this Court in Ranjit Singh (1998) 7 SCC 149 followed by a subsequent decision in Kishori Singh (2004) 13 SCC 11 and in upholding the illegal order of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Mathura.

14. The two decisions, namely, Hareram Satpathy (1978) 4 SCC 58 and Kishan Lal (2009) 7 SCC 685 relied upon by the learned Senior Counsel and counsel for the respondents have no application at all to the case in hand.

15. We, accordingly, allow this appeal and set aside the order of the High Court dated 10-3-2011 impugned in this present appeal and the order of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Mathura, dated 3-1-2011.

16. Needless to say that in the course of trial, on the basis of the evidence if it appears to the Sessions Judge that any person not being the accused in the trial has committed the offence and the case is made out for exercise of power under Section 319 CrPC for proceeding against such person, it will be open to the Sessions Judge to proceed accordingly and the present order will not come in the way in exercise of his power under Section 319 CrPC.