- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bharama Parasram Kudhachkar v. State Of Karnataka .
Case Summary: Criminal Appeals Nos. 1487 of 2005, 1135 of 2006, and 739 of 2006
Factual and Procedural Background
Sudhakar (aged 52) and his wife Shilpa (aged 50) ran a stone-and-slab business at 224, Railway Goodshed Road, Belgaum, where they also resided on the first floor. On 10 June 2000 they were dropped home at about 6:00 p.m. after attending a tea party. Around 8:30 p.m., neighbour Parasram (PW-1) and his wife found Shilpa injured at their door; she said that three persons had attacked her and her husband. Both victims were taken first to PW-16’s hospital and then to K.L.E. Hospital; Sudhakar was declared dead on arrival and Shilpa died three days later.
PW-17, Sudhakar’s brother, lodged an FIR under Sections 302 and 397 IPC against unknown persons. During investigation the police lifted fingerprints from a window pane and, after arresting three suspects on 22 June 2000, recovered gold ornaments and blood-stained clothes pursuant to their disclosure statements.
The trial court convicted all three accused under Sections 302/34, 392 and 397 IPC. On appeal, the High Court observed that most eyewitnesses and link witnesses had turned hostile and that the case rested chiefly on recoveries; it dismissed Criminal Appeal No. 1678 of 2002. The Supreme Court granted special leave to appeal in the present matters.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether recovery of gold ornaments, absent prior test identification and in the face of hostile witnesses, could sustain the convictions of Accused Nos. 1 and 2.
- Whether fingerprint evidence against Accused No. 3 was admissible when it was alleged that the procedure under the Identification of Prisoners Act, 1920 had not been followed.
Arguments of the Parties
Counsel for Accused No. 3 — Amit Rama Naik
- Contended that specimen fingerprints were taken without the mandatory magistrate’s order required by the Identification of Prisoners Act, 1920, rendering the fingerprint match inadmissible.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined two categories of evidence:
- Fingerprint evidence (A-3): The defence did not cross-examine the Investigating Officer (PW-28) on the procedure used to obtain specimen fingerprints. The Court therefore presumed regularity and accepted the match between the latent print from the window pane and Accused No. 3.
- Recoveries of ornaments (A-1 & A-2): The mangalsutra, ring and chain were described as “common use” items; they were first produced for identification only during trial, with no prior test identification. Moreover, significant witnesses (PWs 3, 5, 7 and 8) turned hostile, and Shilpa did not name any assailant despite knowing Accused No. 2 from his previous employment. The Court found the recoveries insufficient to prove guilt.
Accordingly, the Court upheld the conviction of Accused No. 3 and found the involvement of Accused Nos. 1 and 2 doubtful.
Holding and Implications
Accused Nos. 1 and 2 ACQUITTED; Accused No. 3 CONVICTION AFFIRMED
• Criminal Appeal No. 1487 of 2005 (Bharama Parasram Kudachkar — A-2) and Criminal Appeal No. 1135 of 2006 (Rama — A-1) were allowed; their convictions were set aside and they were ordered to be released forthwith (A-2’s bail bonds discharged; A-1 to be released unless required in another case).
• Criminal Appeal No. 739 of 2006 (Amit Rama Naik — A-3) was dismissed; he is to be taken into custody immediately to serve the sentence imposed by the trial court.
The decision affects only the parties to the case and sets no new precedent of general application.
Order
1. This judgment will dispose of the three criminal appeals noted above.
2. The facts have been taken from Criminal Appeal No. 1487 of 2005 which is the lead case. They are as under: Sudhakar and his wife Shilpa aged 52 and 50 years respectively both deceased in this matter were running a business in stones and slabs at 224, Railway Goodshed Road, Belgaum. The factory was on the ground floor whereas the couple were residing on the first floor of the premises. On 10-6-2000, the couple attended a tea party in the house of their acquaintance one Parth Deshpande, and after the party was over at about 6.00 p.m PW 6, Mohan Ramnath, who had also attended the party, dropped them off at their residence in his car.
3. As per the prosecution story, at about 8.30 p.m, PW 1, Parasram and his wife heard some knocking on their door and on opening the same they saw Shilpa aforesaid lying on the ground. On enquiry she disclosed that three persons had attacked her husband and her and had caused them severe injuries. On receiving this information, PW 1 and his wife immediately summoned PW 16, Dr Ramesh who had a hospital close by and on his advice they first took Shilpa to his hospital and she and her husband were later shifted to K.L.E Hospital. The doctor pronounced Sudhakar as having been brought dead on arrival whereas Shilpa died three days later while under treatment.
4. PW 1, who was the business manager of the couple, also informed the relatives of the victims including PW 9, the son of the deceased and PW 17, Sudhakar's brother also reached the spot. The latter thereupon lodged a first information report for the offences punishable under Sections 302 and 397 of the Penal Code, 1860 against unknown persons.
5. During the course of the investigation, some fingerprints were lifted from a window pane as per the scientific procedure prescribed. A search was also conducted in the neighbourhood and the accused were ultimately arrested on 22-6-2000 by a police party as they were behaving in a suspicious manner. They were brought to the police station and interrogated by PW 28 to whom they made disclosure statements under Section 27 of the Evidence Act. Pursuant to the disclosure statements, recoveries of gold ornaments alleged to have been taken from the deceased couple as also the bloodstained clothes of the accused were recovered in the presence of PW 24. On the completion of the investigation, the accused were charged for the offences punishable under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC on two counts and under Sections 392 and 397 IPC. They denied their culpability and were accordingly brought to trial.
6. The prosecution produced 29 witnesses in evidence and also a large number of exhibits including the recovered articles on disclosure as also those that had been picked up from the spot. The trial court on an appreciation of the evidence held the accused guilty on all counts and convicted and sentenced them to undergo various terms of imprisonment.
7. The trial court noticed that all the witnesses including PWs 3 and 5 who were the neighbours of the deceased and who were alleged to have seen the accused running away after the crime, had been declared hostile as they had not supported the prosecution. Likewise, PW 7, the jeweller who had been brought by the investigating agency to verify and weigh the ornaments, did not support the prosecution and he too had been declared hostile. Even more significantly PW 8 to whom the stolen ornaments had been allegedly sold backed away from supporting the prosecution. The matter was thereafter taken in appeal to the High Court and the High Court while noticing that the only evidence against the appellants were the recoveries made from them pursuant to their statements under Section 27 of the Evidence Act (as all the other material witnesses referred to above had not supported the prosecution) dismissed Criminal Appeal No. 1678 of 2002 the appeal. It is in this situation that the matter is before us after the grant of special leave.
8. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and have gone through the record carefully with their assistance. Several judgments have also been cited by the learned counsel on which we do not intend to dilate as they are basically on the facts and circumstances of each case.
9. As already noticed the primary evidence against the accused is the recovery of the gold ornaments from them. These are a mangalsutra, a ring and a chain. In addition, a fingerprint of A-3, Amit Rama Naik, the appellant in Criminal Appeal No. 739 of 2006 had also been lifted from a window pane. The learned counsel representing Amit Rama Naik has, accordingly, argued that the specimen fingerprints had not been taken from him in accordance with the procedure prescribed under the Identification of Prisoners Act, 1920 as it was incumbent on the investigating officer to have filed an application before the Magistrate before he could have taken the fingerprints from him. We, accordingly, put it to the learned counsel if the fact as to whether such an order of the Magistrate had been taken or not had been raised in the cross-examination of the investigating officer, PW 28. We have also gone through the evidence of PW 28 and have found that not a single question had been put to him doubting the correctness of the procedure prescribed. We must, therefore, hold that the fingerprint taken from the site had been identified as that of Amit Rama Naik.
10. We must also record that the ornaments recovered were of common use and available to all and sundry and they were produced for identification in court only during the recording of the evidence and no attempt had been made by the police to have them identified at any earlier point of time. It is also significant that A-2 was alleged to have been an ex-employee of the deceased couple. If that had been so, Shilpa would ordinarily have been able to identify him as he had left employment only four years earlier. Admittedly, she did not name any person in her statement immediately after the incident.
11. In this view of the matter, we find that the identification and involvement of A-1 and A-2 i.e Rama, the appellant in Criminal Appeal No. 1135 of 2006 and Bharama Parasram Kudachkar, the appellant in Criminal Appeal No. 1487 of 2005, is doubtful. We, accordingly, allow their appeals and order their acquittal. The bail bonds of A-2 i.e Bharama Parasram Kudachkar shall stand discharged. A-1 i.e Rama is stated to be in jail. He shall be set forth immediately if not required in any other case. The appeal of Amit Rama Naik, the appellant in Criminal Appeal No. 739 of 2006 is dismissed. He is said to be on bail. He shall be taken into custody forthwith to serve out his sentence.
12. The fee of the amicus curiae is fixed at Rs 7000.
Alert