Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Pramod Buildings And Developers Private Limited v. Shanta Chopra .

Supreme Court Of India
Feb 9, 2011
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent agreed to sell her plot at Greater Kailash, Part I, New Delhi to the appellant-builder for Rs 43,50,000 under an agreement dated 26-10-1988, receiving Rs 9,50,000 as advance. The agreement stipulated that the balance of Rs 34,00,000 had to be paid within 30 days of the vendor notifying receipt of the requisite No-Objection Certificate (NOC) and income-tax clearance; time was expressly of the essence and default would entail forfeiture of the earnest money.

After the respondent unilaterally cancelled the first agreement on 27-02-1989, the parties executed a supplemental agreement dated 02-05-1989 reviving all original terms. The vendor informed the purchaser on 16-05-1989 that both the Form 37-I NOC and Form 34-A clearance had been obtained, obliging the appellant to complete the sale by 19-06-1989 (17-06-1989 and 18-06-1989 being holidays). The appellant did not tender the balance consideration; the respondent terminated the contract on 22-06-1989.

The appellant filed Suit No. 1660 of 1989 before the Delhi High Court seeking specific performance and ancillary reliefs, or, in the alternative, refund of the earnest money with interest. The respondent contested, asserting the appellant’s breach.

After trial, a learned Single Judge dismissed the suit on 08-01-2008, holding the appellant was not ready and willing, but decreed refund of Rs 9,50,000 with 10% interest. A Division Bench affirmed the dismissal on 02-07-2008 with costs of Rs 10,000. The appellant approached the Supreme Court by special leave; the present judgment disposes of that appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant-plaintiff was ready and willing to perform its contractual obligations, thereby entitling it to a decree for specific performance.
  2. Whether, in the circumstances, the appellant was entitled to damages in addition to or in lieu of specific performance.
  3. Whether the respondent’s failure to enter the witness box rendered the evidence adduced on her behalf insufficient, warranting reversal of the concurrent findings.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The respondent failed to provide mutation certificates and up-to-date municipal tax receipts, thereby not making out a marketable title.
  • The appellant’s demand for an affidavit, letter of undertaking, indemnity bond or bank guarantee to confirm clearance of all municipal taxes was reasonable and contractually justified.
  • The vendor’s non-compliance constituted breach; hence the appellant was justified in withholding payment of the balance price until the tax issue was resolved.
  • The respondent did not step into the witness box; evidence by her husband should not suffice to discharge her burden.

Respondent's Arguments

  • A prior suit against the Municipal Corporation (Suit No. 712 of 1976) challenging an arbitrary tax assessment was decreed; no fresh assessment or tax demand existed, making production of tax-paid receipts impossible.
  • Clause 5 of the sale agreement already obligated the vendor to bear all property tax liability up to execution of the sale deed; additional affidavits or guarantees were unnecessary.
  • The respondent attended the Sub-Registrar’s office on 14-06-1989 and 19-06-1989 ready to execute the sale deed upon receipt of Rs 34,00,000, but the appellant insisted on payment of Rs 5,00,000 or clearance of taxes first, demonstrating its own breach.
  • Concurrent findings correctly held that the appellant was not ready and willing, and the respondent’s absence from the witness box did not vitiate the evidence adduced.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Man Kaur (Dead) by LRs v. Hartar Singh Sangha, (2010) 10 SCC 512 Effect of a party not entering the witness box in a suit for specific performance. The appellant relied on the decision, but the Court held that it had no bearing on the present facts and did not disturb the concurrent factual findings.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. Both the Single Judge and the Division Bench found, on appraisal of extensive correspondence and testimony, that the respondent had complied with all contractual obligations, whereas the appellant imposed extra-contractual conditions regarding municipal taxes and therefore failed to tender the balance price by 19-06-1989.

2. Clause 5 of the sale agreement specifically placed liability for property tax on the vendor up to execution; the Court held that this, together with the draft sale deed signed by the respondent, provided adequate security for the appellant, making additional undertakings unnecessary.

3. The appellant’s own notice dated 24-06-1989 acknowledged that it would be unwilling to proceed unless the respondent cleared or secured potential tax dues, corroborating the respondent’s version that the impediment arose solely from the appellant’s demands.

4. In a suit for specific performance, the plaintiff must prove readiness and willingness to perform. The Court affirmed that the appellant’s refusal to pay Rs 34,00,000 at the appointed time demonstrated lack of readiness and willingness, defeating its claim.

5. On the legal objection about the respondent not testifying personally, the Court agreed with the High Court that evidence from her husband, coupled with documentary proof, was sufficient; the precedent cited (Man Kaur) did not mandate reversal.

6. Given the concurrent findings of fact by two lower courts and absence of any substantial question of law, the Supreme Court declined to interfere under Article 136 of the Constitution.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED – The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal, upholding the High Court’s refusal to decree specific performance and maintaining the order for refund of the earnest money with interest.

Implications: The appellant gains only the refund already awarded; the respondent retains the property. The decision reaffirms the principle that a purchaser seeking specific performance must strictly prove continuous readiness and willingness, and that the Supreme Court will not revisit concurrent factual findings absent a substantial question of law. No new precedent was created.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. Leave granted. Heard.

2. The respondent entered into an agreement of sale dated 26-10-1988 agreeing to sell her property to the appellant for a consideration of Rs. 43,50,000 and received Rs. 9,50,000 as advance. The agreement required the sale to be completed by the intending purchaser by paying the full balance consideration of Rs. 34 lakhs within 30 days from the date of issue of a letter/telegram by the intending vendor informing the intending vendee that necessary NOC under Section 269-UL of the Income Tax Act, 1961 and the income tax clearance certificate had been received. The agreement further provided that the time was the essence of the contract and it will not be extendable and if the intending vendee fails to pay the balance of Rs. 34 lakhs, the entire earnest money of Rs. 9.5 lakhs shall stand forfeited.

3. Clause 5 related to property tax and is extracted below:

“5. That any liability whatsoever regarding the plot including the property tax payable in respect of the aforesaid plot shall be paid and be payable by the intending vendor till the sale deed is executed and vacant possession is delivered to the intending vendee.”

4. The respondent cancelled the said agreement by notice dated 27-2-1989. However, subsequently the parties entered into a fresh agreement dated 2-5-1989 under which the cancellation was treated as withdrawn and the respondent undertook to execute the sale deed in terms of the agreement dated 26-10-1988 without any change in its terms. The said agreement recorded that the NOC (in Form 37-I) from the Income Tax Authorities had been received.

5. The agreement dated 2-5-1989 provided that on obtaining the income tax clearance certificate, the vendor should inform the purchaser within one week and within one month thereafter, the sale should be completed by execution of the sale deed and the purchaser should pay the balance amount in the presence of the Sub-Registrar. On 16-5-1989, the respondent informed the appellant that the NOC in Form 37-I and the clearance certificate in Form 34-A have been obtained and, therefore, the appellant should pay the balance consideration of Rs. 34,00,000 within one month from the date of receipt of the said letter and get the sale deed registered.

6. It is not in dispute that in terms of the supplemental agreement dated 2-5-1989, the sale had to be completed by 17-6-1989. It is not disputed that as 17-6-1989 and 18-6-1989 were holidays, the sale had to be completed by 19-6-1989. As the sale was not completed, the respondent alleged that the appellant was in breach and terminated the agreement by notice dated 22-6-1989. This led to the filing of a suit for specific performance (Suit No. 1660 of 1989) by the appellant in the High Court of Delhi.

7. The main reliefs sought in the said plaint are relevant and extracted below:

“(a) For specific performance of the agreement to sell dated 26-10-1988 directing the defendant to execute the sale deed in respect of the plot bearing No. E-47, measuring 300 sq yd, situate in Greater Kailash, Part I, New Delhi and deliver vacant and peaceful possession of the said plot to the plaintiff.
(b) Directing the defendant to pay and discharge all the arrears of property tax due and payable in respect of the said plot till the date of execution of the sale deed and any other liability or encumbrance, if any, in respect of the aforesaid plot prior to the execution of the sale deed and or to get settled the alleged dispute with Municipal Corporation of Delhi, if any, and pay all the property tax dues before the execution of the sale deed.
(c) For recovery of Rs. 1,02,600 as interest for the period from 10-1-1989 till 3-7-1989 on the amount of Rs. 9.5 lakhs and Rs. 45,333 on Rs. 34 lakhs from 13-6-1989 to 2-7-1989 together with interest pendente lite and future @ 24% per annum till the sale deed is executed and Rs. 13.5 lakhs as damages being loss of profits, general and special, thus total amount of Rs. 15 lakhs.”

There was also an alternative prayer for return of the earnest money amount with interest.

8. The respondent contested the suit. She admitted the agreement and the terms thereof. She, however, contended that the appellant committed breach by not tendering the entire balance sale consideration of Rs. 34,00,000 and getting the sale completed by 19-6-1989.

9. Required issues were framed and the parties went to trial and let in oral and documentary evidence. Issues (3) and (4), which are crucial, are extracted below:

“(3) Whether the plaintiff has been still ready and willing to perform its part of the contract, as alleged?
(4) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to damages, if so to what extent?”

10. After considering the pleadings, the evidence and the arguments, a learned Single Judge of the High Court, by judgment dated 8-1-2008, dismissed the suit. He held that the appellant-plaintiff was not ready and willing to perform the contract in terms of the agreement and had failed to tender Rs. 34,00,000 within the stipulated date. However, with reference to the alternative prayer, the Court granted a decree for refund of Rs. 9,50,000 with interest at 10% per annum from the date of payment till the date of repayment. Feeling aggrieved, the appellant filed an intra-court appeal and a Division Bench of the High Court, by the impugned judgment dated 2-7-2008 affirmed the decision of the learned Single Judge and dismissed the appeal with costs of Rs. 10,000. The said judgment is challenged in this appeal by special leave.

11. The suit has been dismissed on the basis of concurrent findings of fact that the appellant was in breach and not the respondent. We may refer to the controversy between the parties.

12. The appellant's case is as under: It is a builder. It agreed to purchase the property for construction of a residential apartment building. The respondent failed to furnish the mutation certificate showing that the property was registered in her name in the records of the Municipal Corporation and failed to produce the up-to-date tax-paid receipts. The appellant therefore demanded that the respondent should give an affidavit and bank guarantee confirming that all municipal taxes had been paid and there were no arrears of municipal taxes. Subsequently, it did not even insist upon the affidavit and required the respondent to give a letter of undertaking and indemnity bond to that effect. The respondent did not comply with the said reasonable demand and refused to clear the tax dues. The respondent was duty-bound to make out a good and satisfactory title and that meant that she had to satisfy the appellant that all municipal taxes had been paid in regard to the property. The respondent failed to discharge this basic obligation and thereby committed breach.

13. The case of the respondent is as under: there was an arbitrary assessment of tax by the municipal authorities in regard to the property and therefore, she had filed a suit (Suit No. 712 of 1976 on the file of the Sub-Judge, First Class, Delhi). The court had decreed the said suit and directed the municipal authorities to make a fresh assessment in the light of its observations. There was no fresh assessment or demand by the Municipal Corporation for payment of tax. Therefore, she could not pay the municipal taxes and produce receipts. She had informed the appellant about the said dispute and had confirmed that in terms of the agreement, if and when the municipal authorities made the final assessment and made a demand in terms of such assessment, she would bear and pay the said taxes up to the date of sale. In this background, the question of her giving any affidavit or other document confirming that all taxes up-to-date were paid did not arise, as the sale agreement itself contained appropriate provision in that behalf. When matters stood thus, though the appellant had secured a demand draft towards the balance price of Rs. 34,00,000 and she was ready to attend the Sub-Registrar's office and execute the sale deed by receiving the said sum, the appellant insisted that she should either pay Rs. 5,00,000 to it towards municipal taxes or clear all municipal taxes due before the sale, as it apprehended that its construction project was likely to be affected. As she was not agreeable to meet the said illegal demand and pay Rs. 5,00,000, the appellant was not ready to proceed with the sale. As the appellant refused to pay the entire balance consideration of Rs. 34,00,000 in terms of the agreement and get the sale completed, she had no alternative but to terminate the contract on 22-6-1989.

14. The following averments in the appellant's notice dated 24-6-1989 (Ext. P-31) prove the version put forth by the respondent:

“You further stated that you would neither make any payment of the property tax and nor you would get your dispute with Municipal Corporation of Delhi settled regarding the assessment, and finalisation of the liability towards the property tax as you were not in any hurry. The Company was then constrained to say that if your dispute remained pending for ten years and you did not make the payment and get your dispute settled, the Corporation would not effect mutation and nor it would sanction the building plans so long as the dispute was pending and/or that the entire arrears of taxes as demanded by it (the Corporation) up-to-date, were paid, which would remit into huge losses to the Company and the Company in that event would be compelled to pay the entire arrears demanded by the Corporation and only thereupon would be able to get the mutation effected and the building plans sanctioned to complete its project, which would cause loss to the Company and the Company would be unnecessarily burdened with the liability which was yours.”

15. The appellant also admitted in the said notice (Ext. P-31) that the respondent had attended the Sub-Registrar's office on 14-6-1989 and 19-6-1989 and had her presence recorded. The averments in the said notice also confirmed the version of the respondent as to what transpired on 19-6-1989, that is, the respondent was not willing to pay any amount until the pending dispute with the Municipal Corporation was decided and the appellant was not willing to buy unless the respondent paid the up-to-date taxes or gave a bank guarantee/security for the likely tax dues.

16. After considering the pleadings and the evidence in detail, the learned Single Judge recorded the following findings on Issues (3) and (4):

“The admitted correspondence between the parties showed that the defendant had in clear-cut words stated that she would be liable for paying the property tax in respect of property as and when determined in future for the period when the property remained under her ownership. If this entire correspondence between the parties and the covenants to this effect in the proposed sale deed were not sufficient to ensure the plaintiff, no affidavit or writing by the defendant would have secured the interest of the plaintiff but, it seems that the plaintiff was adamant in getting a writing from the defendant to the extent mentioned above. I consider that there was no fault of the defendant. The defendant all along was ready and willing to execute the sale deed and it was the plaintiff who because of his adamant behaviour of obtaining an extra writing from the defendant, did not execute the sale deed. This fact is further proved from the fact that the defendant admittedly signed the copies of the sale deed handed over to her. The original sale deed obviously was to be signed before the Sub-Registrar only and she could have signed the original only if the plaintiff had accompanied her to the Sub-Registrar. It is not proved from the evidence of the plaintiff that she had refused to go to the Sub-Registrar's office. Rather the evidence abundantly shows that she had gone to the Sub-Registrar's office and was prepared to appear before the Sub-Registrar and it was the plaintiff who insisted upon additional security from the defendant qua property tax. The plaintiff could have recovered the amount which the plaintiff was made to pay qua the property for period before execution of the sale deed. The sale agreement and proposed sale deed were sufficient security for the plaintiff. The distrust between the plaintiff and the defendant was result of bitterness which crept in between them due to exchange of letters and notices before the execution of the sale deed. In view of the above premise, I therefore, decide both these issues in favour of the defendant and against the plaintiff. The plaintiff is not entitled to a decree of specific performance of agreement to sell.”

This finding of fact that the appellant was in breach has been affirmed in appeal by the Division Bench. As the judgments of the courts below were based upon the said pure finding of fact based on appreciation of evidence, it does not call for interference in exercise of power under Article 136 of the Constitution of India.

17. The only legal issue that was urged by the appellant was that the defendant did not step into the witness box and evidence was given only by her husband and that was insufficient. The said contention was considered and negatived both by the Single Judge and the Division Bench. Reliance was placed on the judgment of this Court in Man Kaur v. Hartar Singh Sangha (2010) 10 SCC 512. The said decision has no bearing on the facts of this case.

18. As rightly held by the High Court, it was for the plaintiff who approached the Court to prove that he was ready and willing to perform the contract. The plaintiff in a suit for specific performance, cannot obviously succeed unless he proved that he was ready and willing to perform the contract. The exhaustive correspondence between the parties clearly discloses the respective stands of the parties. Even the prayer in the plaint shows that the appellant was not ready to pay the entire balance of Rs. 34,00,000 as agreed under the agreement of sale but that the plaintiff insisted upon the appellant to pay the municipal taxes before the sale, as a condition for sale. If the appellant was not willing to pay Rs. 34 lakhs at the time of sale, as specifically agreed under the agreement of sale, the appellant could not claim that it was ready and willing to perform its obligations.

19. As noticed above, after appreciating the entire evidence, the learned Single Judge and the Division Bench of the High Court have recorded a finding that the appellant was not ready and willing and consequently dismissed the suit. We find no reason to interfere with the decision of the High Court. The appeal is, therefore, dismissed.