- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Nanjegowda And Another v. Gangamma And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
Plaintiff 1 Gangamma (widow of late Honnanna), Plaintiff 2 Vanajakshi (their daughter) and Plaintiff 3 Nagesha (their son) sued for a declaration of title and recovery of possession over a 50 ft × 15 ft parcel of land, together with a 15 ft × 12 ft house situate in Survey No. 70/19, Kamakshipalya, Yeshwanthapur Hobli, Bangalore North Taluk, Karnataka. The property had originally been purchased by one Ramakrishna on 13-12-1978 and sold to Honnanna on 5-6-1980.
Defendants 1 and 3—Nanjegowda and his wife Jayamma—had been granted a general power of attorney over the property by Honnanna on 22-7-1985. That authority lapsed upon his death on 13-7-1986. The defendants, however, asserted proprietary rights based on (i) an agreement of sale dated 27-11-1982, (ii) an alleged delivery of possession, and (iii) an irrevocable power of attorney and affidavit executed on 14-7-1985, citing a governmental ban on registration of conveyances at the time.
The trial court framed issues that included whether Defendants 1 and 3 had acquired title after Honnanna’s death. After assessing evidence, it found that the defendants failed to prove execution of a valid sale agreement or delivery of possession, and decreed the suit for the plaintiffs. The High Court dismissed the defendants’ first appeal and affirmed the decree. Defendants 1 and 3 then came before the Supreme Court by special leave.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Defendants 1 and 3 obtained valid title or protectable rights in the suit property under the alleged agreement of sale dated 27-11-1982, read with the irrevocable power of attorney and affidavit dated 14-7-1985.
- Whether the conditions for the doctrine of part-performance under Section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 were satisfied so as to bar the plaintiffs’ claim for recovery of possession.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants’ (Defendants 1 & 3) Arguments
- Contended that Honnanna executed an agreement of sale (Exh. D-1) on 27-11-1982 and handed over possession to Defendant 3, Jayamma.
- Submitted that, due to a contemporaneous ban on property registrations, an irrevocable power of attorney and sworn affidavit (both dated 14-7-1985) were executed to perfect the transaction.
- Invoked Section 53-A TPA, arguing that delivery of possession in part-performance barred the plaintiffs from asserting any contrary title.
Respondents’ (Plaintiffs) Arguments
- Denied that possession was ever delivered to the defendants pursuant to the alleged agreement of sale.
- Pointed out that both the trial court and the High Court, on appreciation of evidence, found the defendants’ plea of possession to be unfounded.
- Argued that, in the absence of actual possession, a fundamental requirement for invoking Section 53-A was missing, rendering the defence inapplicable.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court reproduced Section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act and itemised its four cumulative pre-conditions:
- a written contract signed by the transferor,
- transferee’s possession of the property,
- acts in furtherance of the contract by the transferee, and
- performance or readiness to perform the transferee’s part of the contract.
The Court focused on the second requirement—actual possession by the transferee. It examined:
- The recital in the agreement of sale (27-11-1982) that possession had purportedly been delivered.
- The language of the general power of attorney dated 22-7-1985 in which Honnanna explicitly stated that the property was “in my possession,” authorising Jayamma merely to “look after and manage” it.
This documentary inconsistency convinced the Court that possession never passed to the defendants. Consequently, the crucial element for the defence of part-performance was absent. Because Section 53-A could not be invoked without satisfaction of all its requirements, the defendants’ claim failed. The Court found no error in the concurrent factual findings of the trial and High Courts.
Holding and Implications
Appeal Dismissed. The decree in favour of the plaintiffs stands affirmed; parties to bear their own costs.
Implications: The decision reiterates that actual delivery of possession is indispensable for invoking the shield of part-performance under Section 53-A TPA. The ruling affects only the parties to the suit and does not lay down a new precedent beyond reaffirming statutory requirements.
C.K Prasad, J.— Defendant 1, Nanjegowda and his wife Defendant 3, Jayamma are before us by special leave against the judgment and decree of affirmance.
2. Plaintiff 1, Gangamma is the wife of late Honnanna. Plaintiff 2, Vanajakshi is the daughter of Plaintiff 1, whereas Plaintiff 3, Nagesha and Defendant 2, Manjunatha are her sons. The plaintiffs filed the suit for declaration and possession over an area measuring east to west 50 ft and north to south 15 ft with a house built thereon measuring 15 × 12 ft, appertaining to Survey No. 70/19, situated at Kamakshipalya, Saneguruvanahalli, Yeshwanthapur Hobli, Bangalore North Taluk in the State of Karnataka. According to the plaintiffs, the property originally belonged to one Ramakrishna. He had purchased the same under a registered sale deed dated 13-12-1978. The aforesaid Ramakrishna sold the said property to Honnanna by a registered sale deed dated 5-6-1980.
3. According to the plaintiffs, Honnanna executed the power of attorney in respect of the suit property in favour of Defendants 1 and 3 which came to an end on his death on 13-7-1986. Defendants 1 and 3 (hereinafter referred to as “the defendants”) (the appellants herein) contested the suit. They have not denied that Honnanna had purchased the property on 5-6-1980 from Ramakrishna. However, they claim title over the property on the basis of an agreement to sale dated 27-11-1982. It is further the case of the defendants that there being a ban on registry of the property, an irrevocable power of attorney was executed by Honnanna on 14-7-1985 as also an affidavit of the same date.
4. On the basis of the pleadings of the party, the trial court framed various issues including the issue as to whether Defendants 1 and 3 had acquired title to the property after the death of Honnanna. The trial court on appraisal of evidence, came to the conclusion that the defendants had failed to prove that Honnanna executed an agreement of sale in favour of Defendant 3 Jayamma. The trial court further held that plea of the defendants that Honnanna delivered possession of the scheduled property in the light of the agreement dated 27-11-1982 on the date of agreement is false.
5. In coming to the aforesaid conclusion, the trial court referred to the contents of the general power of attorney which indicated that Honnanna had given the general power of attorney in favour of Jayamma to manage the property. While doing so, the trial court observed as follows:
“48. … what can be made from these recitals is that Honnanna was in possession of the schedule property up to the date of execution of said general power of attorney i.e 22-7-1985. That being so, the contention of Defendants 1 and 3 that Honnanna delivered portion of the schedule property referred to in the agreement of sale dated 27-11-1982 on the alleged date of agreement of sale is found to be false….”
In the light of the aforesaid findings, the trial court decreed the suit and on appeal by the defendants, the High Court had dismissed the appeal and affirmed the judgment and decree of the trial court.
6. Mr Girish Ananthamurthy, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellants submits that Honnanna executed an agreement of sale in favour of Defendant 3 Jayamma and she was put in possession. According to him, after the execution of the agreement of sale, the ban on the registration of the documents was not lifted and accordingly Honnanna executed an irrevocable power of attorney and sworn affidavit, acknowledging possession on 14-7-1985. He draws our attention to the agreement of sale (Ext. D-1) dated 27-11-1982 and the affidavit dated 14-7-1985 (Ext. D-3) and contends that Honnanna having delivered the possession of the property, notwithstanding the fact that sale deed has not been executed and registered, the defendants shall have right over the property. In this connection, our attention has been drawn to Section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”). On this ground alone, according to the learned counsel, the courts below ought to have dismissed the suit.
7. Mr S.N Bhat, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent-plaintiffs, however, contends that the plea put forth by the defendants that they were handed over the possession of the property in part-performance of the contract is unfounded on fact and hence Section 53-A of the Act is not even remotely attracted. He points out that the findings recorded by the trial court, as affirmed by the High Court that possession was not delivered to the defendants is on appraisal of evidence which does not call for interference in this appeal.
8. We have bestowed our consideration to the rival submissions. Section 53-A of the Act which is relevant for the purpose reads as follows:
“53-A. Part-performance.—Where any person contracts to transfer for consideration any immovable property by writing signed by him or on his behalf from which the terms necessary to constitute the transfer can be ascertained with reasonable certainty,
and the transferee has, in part-performance of the contract, taken possession of the property or any part thereof, or the transferee, being already in possession, continues in possession in part-performance of the contract and has done some act in furtherance of the contract,
and the transferee has performed or is willing to perform his part of the contract,
then, notwithstanding that, where there is an instrument of transfer, that the transfer has not been completed in the manner prescribed therefor by the law for the time being in force, the transferor or any person claiming under him shall be debarred from enforcing against the transferee and persons claiming under him any right in respect of the property of which the transferee has taken or continued in possession, other than a right expressly provided by the terms of the contract:
Provided that nothing in this section shall affect the rights of a transferee for consideration who has no notice of the contract or of the part-performance thereof.”
9. From a plain reading of the aforesaid provision, it is evident that a party can take shelter behind this provision only when the following conditions are fulfilled. They are:
(i) The contract should have been in writing signed by or on behalf of the transferor;
(ii) The transferee should have got possession of the immovable property covered by the contract;
(iii) The transferee should have done some act in furtherance of the contract; and
(iv) The transferee has either performed his part of the contract or is willing to perform his part of the contract.
A party can take advantage of this provision only when it satisfies all the conditions aforesaid. All the postulates are sine qua non and a party cannot derive benefit by fulfilling one or more conditions.
10. Bearing in mind the aforesaid principle, we, now, proceed to consider as to whether the defendants have satisfied all the requirements. Had they got possession of the immovable property covered by the contract necessary for invocation of Section 53-A of the Act?
11. Agreement of sale dated 27-11-1982 recites that Honnanna had delivered the possession of property to Defendant 3 Jayamma. According to the defendants, there had been a ban on the registration of documents, hence Honnanna executed an irrevocable power of attorney on 14-7-1985. The contents of the general power of attorney show that the property at that particular time was in possession of Honnanna, the transferor. This would be evident from the following recital in the power of attorney:
“The vacant site as mentioned in the schedule below which is in my possession acquired through the registered sale deed dated 5-5-1980 registered in the Office of the Sub-Registrar, Bangalore North Taluk, in Book 1, Vol. 3236, pp. 210-30, No. 1363, I have hereby given the power in favour of you to look after and manage completely on my behalf as I am unable to manage for inevitable reasons.”
(underlining is ours)
12. Had Defendant 3 Jayamma got possession of the property in pursuance of the agreement of sale dated 27-11-1982, there was no occasion for Honnanna to recite in clear terms that he was in possession of the property. In view of the aforesaid, we are of the opinion that the finding recorded by the trial court as affirmed by the High Court that the defendants did not get possession of the property after execution of the sale deed is on correct appreciation of facts, which do not call for interference in this appeal. In view of this finding, in our opinion, the provision of Section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act is not attracted and the defendants cannot take advantage of that.
13. In the result, we do not find any merit in this appeal which is dismissed accordingly but without any order as to the costs.
Alert