- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Prahlad Singh And Others v. State Of Madhya Pradesh .
Factual and Procedural Background
On 30-9-1996, while the deceased Ganeshram, his relative Annilal (PW-2) and his son Chandan Singh (PW-5) prepared to cross the Narmada River by boat, five accused emerged from nearby bushes. Rammilan Lodhi and Babulal Lodhi carried shotguns, while Prahlad, Hukum and Dullam were armed with lathis. After exhortations by the latter three, Rammilan fired, killing Ganeshram instantly; Babulal’s shot severely injured Annilal. Chandan Singh alerted family members and lodged an FIR at Police Station Narsinghpur approximately two hours later. Investigators recovered Rammilan’s muzzle-loading shotgun and ammunition pursuant to his disclosure.
The Sessions Court convicted all five accused under Sections 302 and 307 read with Section 149 IPC, imposing concurrent sentences. On appeal, the Madhya Pradesh High Court upheld the convictions; during that pendency Babulal died. Following grant of special leave, the Supreme Court heard the consolidated criminal appeals that form the subject of this order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the conviction of Prahlad, Hukum and Dullam—who allegedly only exhorted the shooters and inflicted no injuries—could be sustained on the basis of the prosecution evidence.
- Whether the testimony of the solitary eyewitness Chandan Singh (PW-5) and supporting circumstances were sufficient to affirm the conviction of Rammilan for murder and attempted murder.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants Prahlad, Dullam and Hukum
- Contended that with Annilal (PW-2) having turned hostile, the prosecution case rested solely on Chandan Singh’s testimony, which required full credibility before sustaining conviction.
- Emphasised there was no evidence that these appellants used their lathis or caused any injury, negating active participation.
- Highlighted that the alleged election rivalry motive had dissipated, as the rival candidate had withdrawn his nomination.
Appellant Rammilan
- Relied on defence witness Sita Ram (DW-1), the river-crossing contractor, who stated he saw none of the accused at the scene and was merely informed of an incident by Annilal.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court found Chandan Singh (PW-5) “wholly reliable,” noting the FIR was lodged within two hours at a station 20 km away, demonstrating spontaneity and confirming his presence. Saheb Singh’s (PW-6) account of arranging transport for the injured corroborated Chandan Singh’s narrative, and even the hostile witness Annilal admitted their presence. Medical findings matched the eyewitness version.
The Court accepted that the shotguns carried by Rammilan and the deceased Babulal could cause the pellet injuries described; disputes over firing distance were discounted because the weapons and ammunition were of “uncertain make and quality,” rendering standard pellet-spread formulas unreliable and insufficient to discredit credible eyewitness testimony.
As to Prahlad, Hukum and Dullam, the Court observed they only possessed lathis and never used them. Their alleged role was limited to exhortation. Given potential animosity between parties and absence of direct physical participation, the Court held that “the possibility that these three accused have been roped in on account of animosity cannot be ruled out,” granting them the benefit of doubt.
Holding and Implications
Appeal of Rammilan (Criminal Appeal No. 1180 of 2008 dismissed; conviction and sentence affirmed.
Appeals of Prahlad, Dullam and Hukum (Criminal Appeal Nos. 146-147 of 2008 allowed; convictions set aside and they are to be released forthwith if not required in any other case).
Implications: The decision directly frees three appellants while maintaining the conviction of the principal shooter. The Court’s analysis does not establish new precedent but reiterates the importance of credible eyewitness testimony and the cautious extension of vicarious liability where physical participation is absent.
Order
1. This order will dispose of all the above appeals as they arise from a common judgment.
2. The facts of the case are as under: at 12.50 p.m on 30-9-1996 as the deceased Ganeshram accompanied by his relative Annilal (PW 2) and his son Chandan Singh (PW 5) were about to cross Narmada River on a boat, the five accused, Rammilan Lodhi and Babulal Lodhi, both armed with shotguns, and Dullam, Hukum and Prahlad armed with lathis came out of a bush. On seeing Ganeshram and the others Prahlad, Hukum and Dullam exhorted Rammilan and Babulal to fire at Ganeshram. On this exhortation Rammilan first fired a shot at Ganeshram which hit him on the abdominal area killing him instantaneously and a shot fired by Babulal caused a severe injury on the head of Annilal (PW 2).
3. Chandan Singh (PW 5) who was behind them at some distance answering the call of nature witnessed the entire incident. He rushed to the spot and first removed the injured Annilal (PW 2) to the village and thereafter conveyed the information about the incident to PW 6, Saheb Singh, his brother. He also arranged for a tractor on which Annilal was carried to the hospital at Narsinghpur about 20 km away and the first information report was lodged in Police Station Narsinghpur at about 2.30 p.m The investigating officer thereafter reached the place of incident and made the necessary inquiries and also sent the dead body for its post-mortem examination. The post-mortem examination revealed a large number of pellet injuries on the person of the deceased. Rammilan was also arrested and on his disclosure statement under Section 27 of the Evidence Act a muzzle-loading shotgun was seized along with pellets, gunpowder and brass metal caps.
4. During the course of the trial Annilal (PW 2) did not support the prosecution as he was equally related to the complainant as well as the accused party. The prosecution accordingly relied on the statements of PW 5 Chandan Singh and PW 6 Saheb Singh, as also the medical evidence. The trial court however found that the evidence of PW 2 partly supported the other evidence inasmuch that he had admitted his presence and that of Chandan Singh at the time of the incident. The trial court also noted that as the charge against the accused was under Sections 302, 307, 148 and 149 IPC, all the accused (notwithstanding the fact that they had not fired either at the injured or the deceased) were liable to be roped in on a charge of murder. The trial court accordingly convicted all the accused under Sections 302 and 307 read with Section 149 and sentenced them to undergo several terms of imprisonment; all the sentences to run concurrently.
5. An appeal was thereafter taken by the accused to the High Court and during the pendency of the appeal Babulal, one of the main accused is said to have died. The High Court vide its judgment dated 11-9-2007 which has been impugned before us dismissed the appeal on facts and findings similar to ones recorded by the trial court. It is in this background that the matter is before us and after grant of leave has been heard by us today.
6. Mr Shiv Sagar Tiwari, the learned counsel for the appellants Prahlad, Dullam and Hukum in Crl. As. Nos. 146-47 of 2008 at the very outset pointed out that Annilal (PW 2) having disowned the prosecution story, the entire story hinged on the statement of PW 5 and that as there was no evidence to suggest that the appellants had caused any injury to either of the victims although they were armed with lathis, clearly ruled out their participation. He has also urged that the fact that the parties appeared to be at loggerheads on account of election rivalries was said to be the reason for murder but as per the statement of Saheb Singh (PW 6), the election dispute was between Gendalal, the father of Rammilan and the deceased but he had subsequently withdrawn his nomination form, and as such the dispute no longer existed. He has also pointed out that it is by now well settled that in the case of a solitary witness the evidence of that witness had to be wholly credible before the conviction could be recorded thereunder.
7. Dr V.P Appan, the learned counsel representing Rammilan, the appellant in Crl. A. No. 1800 of 2008, has in addition referred to the defence evidence of Sita Ram (DW 1), the contractor at the river crossing who testified that he had not seen any of the accused and only Annilal had been present and he had told him that some incident had taken place.
8. We have considered the arguments advanced by the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record. We must emphasise that the evidence of Chandan Singh (PW 5) is wholly reliable. The first information report had been recorded in the police station 20 km away within 2 hours of the incident. The very spontaneity of the FIR indicates that Chandan Singh had been present at the murder site. Likewise, Saheb Singh (PW 6) who had arranged the tractor to take Annilal to the police station clearly supports the view that Chandan Singh had been present at the site and the two had carried the injured to the hospital. Annilal too supported the prosecution to the extent that he admitted the presence of PW 5 at the time of incident. The medical evidence also supports the eyewitnesses account.
9. It is the admitted case that Babulal and Rammilan were both armed with muzzle-loading .12 bore shotguns which could have caused the injuries found on the person of the deceased as well as on Annilal (PW 2). Some arguments had been occasioned before the courts below with regard to the distance from which shots had been fired. The courts have found that the shots had been fired from a short distance. We must however emphasise that where the weapon and ammunition used is of uncertain make and quality, the normal pellet pattern based on standard weapons and ammunition, cannot be applied with accuracy. The distance from which the shots have been fired cannot therefore have the effect of dislodging a credible eyewitness account in such a case.
10. The appellants Prahlad, Hukum Singh and Dullam were armed with lathis which had not been used by them in any manner and the only allegation against them is that they had exhorted their co-accused to fire at the opposite party. We are, therefore, of the opinion that the possibility that these three accused have been roped in on account of animosity cannot be ruled out and we must give them the benefit of doubt on that score.
11. The appeal of Rammilan i.e Crl. A. No. 1180 of 2008 is dismissed whereas Crl. As. Nos. 146-47 of 2008 are allowed. The appellant-accused Prahlad, Dullam and Hukum are said to be in custody. They shall be released forthwith if not required in connection with any other case.
12. Fee of the amicus curiae is fixed at Rs 7000.
Alert