- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Amerika Rai And Others v. State Of Bihar .
Factual and Procedural Background
Six accused were tried for forming an unlawful assembly and, in furtherance of its common object, murdering Shankar Rai the day after his wedding. The altercation stemmed from a dispute between the bride’s and bridegroom’s parties during the marriage festivities in Village Ishupur (District Vaishali, Bihar). On the following morning the accused allegedly assaulted Ram Babu (PW-6, the bride’s brother-in-law). When Shankar Rai intervened, Chulhan Rai (A-3) fired multiple shots at him, while Mithilesh Rai (A-4) shot and seriously injured Dineshwar Rai (PW-7). Sanjay Rai (A-5) and Sipahi Rai (A-6) also fired pistols; Darbesh Rai (A-2) stood with a lathi. Shankar Rai died during treatment; an FIR was lodged the same day (26-6-1995).
The Sessions Court convicted all six under Section 302/149 IPC; A-3 and A-4 were also convicted of Arms Act and other offences. The Patna High Court dismissed the convicts’ appeals. Five of them—Amerika Rai (A-1), Darbesh Rai (A-2), Mithilesh Rai (A-4), Sanjay Rai (A-5) and Sipahi Rai (A-6)—approached the Supreme Court in Criminal Appeals Nos. 1516-1517 of 2004 (Chulhan Rai’s appeal had already been dismissed).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether all appellants, by virtue of Section 149 IPC, could be held vicariously liable for the murder of Shankar Rai and the attempted murder of Dineshwar Rai.
- Whether the specific roles of Amerika Rai (A-1) and Darbesh Rai (A-2)—who allegedly did not themselves fire weapons—were sufficient to brand them members of the unlawful assembly with the requisite common object.
- Whether the absence of recovery of pistols from Sanjay Rai (A-5) and Sipahi Rai (A-6) undermined the prosecution case against them.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- Amerika Rai (A-1) & Darbesh Rai (A-2): Neither used firearms; Amerika only allegedly exhorted, and Darbesh merely stood with a lathi. Hence they were not members of any unlawful assembly with a murderous common object.
- Sanjay Rai (A-5) & Sipahi Rai (A-6): No pistols were recovered during investigation; therefore participation in the firing could not be proved, negating common object or intention.
- Defence witnesses asserted that Chulhan Rai (A-3) had no gun (it was deposited at a gun house) and suggested mutual brick-batting, casting doubt on the prosecution narrative.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court accepted that Shankar Rai’s death was homicidal, supported by eyewitness testimony and medical evidence (Dr. Shradha Nand and Dr. Amarnath Jha). It evaluated liability under Section 149 IPC as follows:
- Principle applied: Mere presence in an unlawful assembly with an “active mind” to achieve the common object suffices for vicarious liability (Section 149 IPC).
- Amerika Rai (A-1): His exhortation to “bring the guns” displayed a guilty mind and active participation, aligning him with the assembly’s common object.
- Mithilesh Rai (A-4), Sanjay Rai (A-5) & Sipahi Rai (A-6): Eyewitnesses unanimously affirmed that all three fired weapons; A-4’s shots caused serious injuries to PW-7. Their conduct proved shared object.
- Darbesh Rai (A-2): Evidence limited to standing with a lathi. The Court found the claim that he instigated firing “an exaggeration”; mere passive presence without overt act or exhortation did not establish common object. Benefit of doubt granted.
- Defence evidence: Testimony about A-3’s gun being deposited and alleged brick-bat exchange failed to dislodge prosecution evidence; right of private defence was neither pleaded nor sustainable given the aggressors’ use of firearms.
Holding and Implications
Holding: Appeals of Amerika Rai (A-1), Mithilesh Rai (A-4), Sanjay Rai (A-5) and Sipahi Rai (A-6) are DISMISSED; their convictions and sentences stand. Appeal of Darbesh Rai (A-2) is ALLOWED; he is acquitted and ordered to be released forthwith. Amerika Rai’s bail is cancelled and he must surrender to serve the remaining sentence.
Implications: The judgment re-affirms the breadth of vicarious liability under Section 149 IPC, clarifying that exhortation and active presence during armed assault suffice for conviction, while passive presence with no overt act may warrant acquittal. No new precedent was set, but the decision underscores evidentiary thresholds for attributing common object in group offences.
V.S Sirpurkar, J.— This judgment will dispose of Criminal Appeals Nos. 1516 and 1517 of 2004. Five accused persons have filed these appeals, they being Amerika Rai (original Accused 1), Darbesh Rai (original Accused 2), Mithilesh Rai (original Accused 4), Sanjay Rai (original Accused 5) and Sipahi Rai (original Accused 6). The appeal of Chulhan Rai (original Accused 3) is already dismissed.
2. Six accused persons came to be tried for having formed themselves into an unlawful assembly and as a common object of that unlawful assembly, having committed murder of one Shankar Rai. Some of the accused persons were also charged with the offences under the Arms Act. All the accused persons were convicted for the offence punishable under Section 302 read with Section 149 of the Penal Code, 1860 (IPC), while Chulhan Rai (A-3) was convicted for substantive offence punishable under Section 302 and for offence punishable under Section 27 of the Arms Act. Again, Mithilesh Rai (A-4) was also convicted for the offence punishable under Section 307 IPC in addition to the offences punishable under Section 27 of the Arms Act and Section 302 read with Section 149 IPC. He was booked for that offence on the allegation that he had fired at and injured one Dineshwar Rai (PW 7). The appeals of all the accused persons were dismissed by the Patna High Court and that is how the accused persons are before us in the present appeals.
3. The prosecution story is in a short conspectus. This is a cruel murder of a young bridegroom Shankar Rai who was married only a day before. He was put to death virtually without any reason. As per the prosecution story, his marriage was held at Village Ishupur, Police Station Lalganj, District Vaishali. All the accused persons appear to be either relations or neighbours of deceased Shankar Rai. They all had joined the bridegroom party and were present at the time of marriage. It is alleged that at the time of function of “Dwarpuja”, there was some altercation in between the members of bride party on the one side and bridegroom's on the other. It is alleged that the brother of the informant, Dineshwar Rai was assaulted by the members of the bride party and in retaliation, the informant also attacked some members of the bride side. Further, when one of the accused persons Sanjay Rai (A-5) was going back to the janvasa (the place where the bridegroom's party stays during the marriage), he was assaulted by some boys of the village. However, the marriage was solemnised.
4. The party of the bridegroom returned to their village along with the bride, and along with them, the brother-in-law of the bride accompanied as per the custom. On the next day, at about 11 o'clock in the morning, when the said brother-in-law, namely, Ram Babu (PW 6) was going for rest after taking meals, the accused persons, namely, Amerika Rai (A-1), Darbesh Rai (A-2), Chulhan Rai (A-3), Mithilesh Rai (A-4), Sanjay Rai (A-5) and Sipahi Rai (A-6) assaulted him with fists and slaps. When this was objected to, a quarrel ensued. At that very time, Amerika Rai (A-1) exhorted and as a result, Chulhan Rai (A-3) brought a licensed gun and fired 6-7 rounds at Shankar Rai. He fell down injured. In the meantime, Mithilesh Rai (A-4) fired 3-4 rounds from his gun causing injury to Dineshwar Rai (PW 7) who was none else but the brother of Shankar Rai (deceased). He suffered injuries to his hand, abdomen and thigh. At this time, Sanjay Rai (A-5) and Sipahi Rai (A-6) also opened fire from their pistols. Darbesh Rai (A-2) was present with a lathi.
5. Injured Shankar Rai was removed to State Dispensary, Parsa, where he died during his treatment. Dineshwar Rai (PW 7) was also treated. The incident, having taken place in the broad daylight, was witnessed by a number of persons including the villagers. Dineshwar Rai (PW 7) reported the matter on 26-6-1995 at 4.15 p.m to the officer-in-charge of Dariyapur Police Station. This was done in the State Dispensary. FIR was drawn up by Dariyapur Police Station vide Case No. 76 of 1995 and the offences were registered under Sections 302, 307, 324 read with Section 34 IPC and Section 27 of the Arms Act. The charge-sheet was filed and the matter was committed to sessions. All the accused abjured their guilt.
6. In support of the prosecution, as many as 12 witnesses were examined including the eyewitnesses, the police witnesses and the doctors. Some of the witnesses like Dineshwar Rai (PW 7) who was an injured witness, Ram Babu (PW 6), Dhaneshwar Rai (PW 1), Sheo Nath Rai (PW 2), Ramesh Rai (PW 3) and Ram Bhawan Rai (PW 4) supported the prosecution version. However, some other witnesses like Wakil Rai, Virendra Rai and Dina Pandit did not support the prosecution. Relying on their evidence, the trial court firstly came to the conclusion that the accused persons formed themselves into an unlawful assembly and indiscriminately fired at Shankar Rai (deceased) and Dineshwar Rai (PW 7) and caused murder of Shankar Rai and attempted to murder Dineshwar Rai (PW 7). However, it is only Mithilesh Rai (A-4) who is booked for the offence punishable under Section 307 IPC on the ground that he was the only person who fired at Dineshwar Rai (PW 7) and injured him seriously. The trial court has also discussed the whole medical evidence as well as the evidence of the eyewitnesses and convicted all the accused persons. The appeals of the accused persons before the High Court failed and that is how the matter is before us.
7. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the accused persons firstly urged that the role of Amerika Rai (A-1) and Darbesh Rai (A-2), as attributed to them by the prosecution witnesses, itself suggests that these two accused persons did not use any firearms. The learned counsel further urged that Amerika Rai (A-1) was merely standing and at the most, it could be said that he exhorted for bringing the guns; however, even that could not be said in respect of Darbesh Rai (A-2) who was merely standing at the door with a lathi. The learned counsel were at pains to point out, by reference to evidence, that Darbesh Rai (A-2) did not in any manner either assault the deceased or take part in the whole affair. The learned counsel, therefore, urged that at least insofar as Amerika Rai (A-1) and Darbesh Rai (A-2) are concerned, they could not be said to be the members of the unlawful assembly.
8. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of Sanjay Rai (A-5) and Sipahi Rai (A-6) pointed out that though it was suggested that these two accused persons fired with their pistols, those pistols are nowhere to be found in the whole investigation, as nothing was recovered from these two accused persons. The learned counsel, therefore, urged that it will be difficult to say that these two persons either shared the common intention or had the common object. It was pointed out that Sanjay Rai (A-5) and Sipahi Rai (A-6) were not even related to Amerika Rai (A-1) and his family or deceased Shankar Rai and his family.
9. There can be no dispute that Shankar Rai died a homicidal death. As many as five eyewitnesses whose presence was most natural on the spot, have supported the prosecution version regarding the deadly attack on Shankar Rai, as also the firing at his brother Dineshwar Rai (PW 7). The evidence of the two doctors being Dr. Shradha Nand (PW 8) and Dr. Amarnath Jha (PW 10), who conducted the autopsy is sufficient to hold that Shankar Rai died an almost instantaneous death because of indiscriminate firing at him by Chulhan Rai (A-3). It has already been stated earlier that appeal of Chulhan Rai (A-3) is already dismissed. Deceased Shankar Rai had suffered as many as 8 injuries, all attributable to the gunshot injuries, so also the injuries suffered by Dineshwar Rai (PW 7) were found to be dangerous to his life, though he ultimately survived. The question, however, is whether all the accused persons could be booked with the aid of Section 149 IPC on the ground that they were the members of the unlawful assembly having the common object.
10. There can be no dispute that the presence of the accused persons on the spot was well established by the five eyewitnesses named above. All the five eyewitnesses who supported the prosecution have in one voice deposed to the presence of all these accused persons and the acts performed by them. Dineshwar Rai (PW 7), Dhaneshwar Rai (PW 1), Ram Bhawan Rai (PW 4), Ram Babu (PW 6), Sheo Nath Rai (PW 2) and Ramesh Rai (PW 3) are unanimous on the question that Amerika Rai (A-1) had ordered to bring the guns. As many as four witnesses being Dineshwar Rai (PW 7), Dhaneshwar Rai (PW 1), Ram Bhawan Rai (PW 4) and Ram Babu (PW 6) spoke about Darbesh Rai (A-2) standing holding a stick. All these four witnesses also suggested that he was instigating.
11. Insofar as Mithilesh Rai (A-4) is concerned, all the witnesses are unanimous that he fired 3-4 rounds with his gun and caused injury to Dineshwar Rai (PW 7), so also all the witnesses are absolutely unanimous in respect of Sanjay Rai (A-5) and Sipahi Rai (A-6) to the effect that they were firing with the pistols in their hand. Sheo Nath Rai (PW 2) and Ramesh Rai (PW 3) also went to the extent of saying that these two accused persons fired 2-3 rounds of shots though no injury was caused by those gunshots. Therefore, there can be no doubt that all these accused persons, who were staying in the nearby house of the deceased, had attacked the deceased and his brother Dineshwar Rai (PW 7). There was a definite background to this attack which related to the altercation in between the bride's party and the bridegroom's party at the time of marriage and accused Sanjay Rai having been beaten.
12. It has come in the evidence of the witnesses like Dineshwar Rai (PW 7) and Ram Babu (PW 7) that there was an unpleasant incident of altercation in between the bride's party and bridegroom's party at the time of Dwarpuja. It has also come in the evidence that Sanjay Rai (A-5), when he was returning back from the bridegroom's place on cycle, was beaten. Therefore, it appears that the accused persons had carried a grudge and seeing Ram Babu (PW 6), the brother-in-law of Shankar Rai's bride, there was an instantaneous reaction on their part. It has come in the evidence that Ram Babu (PW 6) was slapped and fisted when he had finished his meals and was going for rest. The presence of Ram Babu (PW 6) acted as a flash point; perhaps it reminded the accused persons and more particularly, Sanjay Rai (A-5), of the insult meted out to them and then the idea of taking revenge emerged. What happened is that deceased Shankar Rai seeing that his wife's relation was being slapped and fisted by the accused persons, had resisted the attempt on the part of the accused persons and that ultimately proved to be a raison d'être of his death. Therefore, there is no doubt in our mind that this was undoubtedly done with a common object of teaching lesson to deceased Shankar Rai who had taken—as was expected—side of Ram Babu (PW 6), the brother-in-law of his bride. What is liable to be seen is as to whether there was any active participation and the presence of all the accused persons was with an active mind in furtherance of their common object.
13. The law of vicarious liability under Section 149 IPC is crystal clear that even the presence in the unlawful assembly, but with an active mind, to achieve the common object makes such a person vicariously liable for the acts of the unlawful assembly. In that light, when the evidence is examined, it is obvious that Amerika Rai (A-1) who was the elder in the family and father of Darbesh Rai (A-2), Mithilesh Rai (A-4) and Chulhan Rai (A-3), instead of acting in a responsible manner and preventing any unpleasant incident, exhorted the accused persons to bring the gun. The guns are normally not brought for making a show. The exhortation to bring the gun definitely speaks about the guilty mind of Amerika Rai (A-1), so also the use of guns by Mithilesh Rai (A-4), Sanjay Rai (A-5) and Sipahi Rai (A-6) is very clear that they also had guilty mind. Mithilesh Rai (A-4) went to the extent of injuring Dineshwar Rai (PW 7). Therefore, even their presence and part played by them was obviously pointing towards the common object of committing murder of Shankar Rai. Unfortunately, Shankar Rai became the victim of the circumstances. The accused persons had nothing to do with Shankar Rai. Their main ire was directed at Ram Babu (PW 6). But, perhaps because Shankar Rai took side of Ram Babu (PW 6), he became the victim of circumstances and had to pay with his own life. Therefore, at least insofar as these persons are concerned, their presence and their active participation would make them guilty under Section 149 IPC, though the author of the injury to Shankar Rai was Chulhan Rai (A-3) whose appeal has already been dismissed.
14. However, that cannot be said about Darbesh Rai (A-2). He had been given the role of standing at the door of his house with a lathi. We feel that the evidence of the eyewitnesses that he was instigating the other accused persons to fire, appears to be an exaggeration. He would not have kept on standing there holding a lathi had he shared the intention and the common object of committing murder of Shankar Rai. In our opinion, the role of Darbesh Rai (A-2), as attributed to by the eyewitnesses, should not make him vicariously liable. We, therefore, grant benefit of doubt to Darbesh Rai (A-2) and acquit him.
15. It was tried to be suggested, relying on the defence witnesses, namely, Ajit Kumar Singh (DW 1) and Ram Dhani Chaudhary (DW 2), that Chulhan Rai (A-3) did not have any gun, as his gun was deposited in Singh Gun House. This argument is already rejected by the trial and appellate courts and we also endorse the finding. Insofar as Ram Dhani Chaudhary (DW 2) is concerned, he stated that there was a distance of 250 ft in between the house of Chulhan Rai (A-3) and deceased Shankar Rai and there was a pond in between their houses. He also found brickbats in front of the house of the deceased and Chulhan Rai (A-3). Thereby it was suggested that there was exchange of brickbats between the parties. That may be so. However, there is evidence that when Ram Babu (PW 6) was going for rest after the meals, he was actually fisted and slapped by Amerika Rai (A-1), Darbesh Rai (A-2), Chulhan Rai (A-3), Mithilesh Rai (A-4), Sanjay Rai (A-5) and Sipahi Rai (A-6). When this was informed to Shankar Rai, Shankar Rai came and made enquiry from Chulhan Rai (A-3) and then when there was exchange of abuses, the brickbatting started between the parties.
16. The evidence of Ram Dhani Chaudhary (DW 2), SDPO, does not in any manner shake the prosecution case. It was not as if the defence came up with a plea of right of private defence of person and property and indeed they could not have done so as they were the aggressor party using guns. We have considered the defence evidence also at the instance of both the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the defence and we do not find that this evidence would in any manner help the prosecution.
17. In short, there can be no dispute about the formation of unlawful assembly and its common object. We, therefore, dismiss all the appeals excepting that of Darbesh Rai (A-2) who has been granted the benefit of doubt. He shall be acquitted. All the accused persons are, therefore, held guilty and their appeals are dismissed excepting that of Darbesh Rai (A-2) whose appeal is accepted and who is directed to be released forthwith unless required in any other matter. His bail bonds are discharged. It is reported that Accused 1, Amerika Rai is on bail. He shall be taken into custody immediately for serving out rest of the sentence. His bail bonds are cancelled.
Alert