- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sudhir Kumar v. State Of Punjab .
Factual and Procedural Background
Kamlesh Rani married Sudhir Kumar on 28 July 1989. Soon after, Sudhir Kumar, his parents, and sisters allegedly harassed her for insufficient dowry, demanding a scooter for Sudhir and a gold ring each for his sisters. The harassment continued despite assurances from Kamlesh Rani’s family that they would try to meet the demands.
On 30 November 1989 Kamlesh Rani was found dead with 95% burn injuries in the bathroom of her matrimonial home. A First Information Report was lodged by her brother Bhim Sain, leading to an investigation and the filing of a challan against five family members.
The Sessions Court charged all five accused under Sections 302/149 and in the alternative Section 304-B of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). After trial, only Sudhir Kumar and his mother Kaushalya Devi were convicted under Section 304-B IPC and sentenced to seven years’ rigorous imprisonment; the father and two sisters were acquitted. On appeal, the High Court acquitted Kaushalya Devi as well, leaving Sudhir Kumar as the sole convicted person. Sudhir Kumar then approached the Supreme Court by special leave, resulting in the present decision.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, in view of the acquittal of four co-accused, the statutory presumption of dowry death under Section 113-B of the Evidence Act stood rebutted, entitling Sudhir Kumar to acquittal on the principle of parity.
- Whether the evidence on record was sufficient to sustain Sudhir Kumar’s conviction under Section 304-B IPC.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The acquittal of four out of five accused demonstrates that the prosecution evidence is unreliable, thereby rebutting the presumption under Section 113-B of the Evidence Act.
- On parity with the acquitted co-accused, Sudhir Kumar is also entitled to an acquittal.
State's Arguments
- Primary evidence, particularly from PWs 2, 3, and 4, directly implicates Sudhir Kumar in dowry demands and threats shortly before the death.
- The statutory presumption remains unrebutted because the appellant failed to offer credible evidence dispelling it.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court observed that:
- The testimonies of PW 2 (Ramji Das), PW 3 (Tej Ram), and PW 4 (Sat Paul) consistently established that Sudhir Kumar made persistent dowry demands and issued threats to the deceased.
- Medical evidence confirmed 95% burn injuries, situating the death within the statutory parameters of “dowry death.”
- Under Section 113-B of the Evidence Act, a presumption of dowry death arises when a woman dies unnaturally within seven years of marriage coupled with prior dowry harassment; the marriage in question was only four months old.
- Although four co-accused were acquitted, the Court distinguished Sudhir Kumar’s role as the principal harasser and threat-maker, finding the evidence against him “primary” and weighty.
- The appellant offered only a bare denial and an epilepsy-related explanation, which the Court found insufficient to dispel the statutory presumption.
Holding and Implications
Appeal Dismissed. The conviction of Sudhir Kumar under Section 304-B IPC and the sentence of seven years’ rigorous imprisonment are affirmed.
Implications: The decision reinforces the operation of the statutory presumption under Section 113-B of the Evidence Act even when some co-accused are acquitted, provided credible evidence exists against the principal accused. No new legal precedent was articulated beyond this application of established principles.
Order
1. The prosecution story is as under: Kamlesh Rani, the deceased, daughter of PW 3, Tej Ram was married to Sudhir Kumar, the appellant herein, on 28-7-1989 at Maur Mandi, District Bhatinda. At the time of marriage, ornaments and cash befitting the status of the families, were given in dowry. A month after the marriage, however, the appellant and his parents, Angoori Lal and Kaushalya Devi and sisters, Neelam Kumari and Urmila Devi started maltreating Kamlesh Rani for having brought insufficient dowry. Sudhir Kumar also demanded a scooter for himself and a gold ring each for his sisters Neelam and Urmila.
2. The demand was duly conveyed by Kamlesh Rani to her parents at Maur Mandi. Tej Ram promised to fulfil the demand on which Kamlesh Rani returned to her matrimonial home and was immediately questioned by her mother-in-law as to the scooter and the gold rings. Bhim Sain, brother of Kamlesh Rani, however, told them that the family was not in a position to fulfil the demand on account of financial difficulties. He, however, returned to Maur Mandi after leaving Kamlesh Rani in the matrimonial home.
3. About 10 days prior to the incident Ramji Das, PW 2, Tej Ram's younger brother, came to Maur Mandi and told Tej Ram that the accused had given slaps to Kamlesh Rani in his presence on which he had promised that the demand for a scooter and gold rings would be fulfilled within a few days. Sudhir Kumar also came to Maur Mandi and once again reiterated the demands to his father-in-law failing which he threatened dire consequences for Kamlesh Rani.
4. On 30-11-1989, Bhim Sain went to the house of the accused and found the outer gate shut. On persistent ringing of the bell, Angoori Lal came out but moved away and when Bhim Sain entered the house he noticed Kamlesh Rani's dead body lying in the latrine. Bhim Sain immediately came to the house of his uncle Ramji Das, PW 2 and the two then went to the police station where the former lodged the report, Ext. PD on the basis of which an FIR was registered. Sub-Inspector Santokh Singh thereupon reached the place of incident and made the necessary inquiries.
5. On completion of the investigation a challan was duly presented against Angoori Lal, Kaushalya Devi and Neelam and Urmila for an offence punishable under Sections 302/34 IPC and the matter was brought for trial to the Court of Session. The Court of Session, however, charged the accused under Sections 302/149 IPC read with Section 304-B IPC in the alternative.
6. The prosecution in support of its case relied on the evidence of PW 1, Dr. S.S Malik who had performed the post-mortem on the dead body, the three primary witnesses PW 2 Ramji Das, PW 3 Tej Ram and PW 4, Sat Paul, also an uncle of the deceased, in addition to the formal evidence of Santokh Singh, the IO. The statements of the accused were thereafter recorded under Section 313 CrPC and they denied the allegations simpliciter. Sudhir Kumar, however, took up an additional plea:
“I am innocent. I have been falsely involved. This occurrence has taken place before noontime and at that time myself and my father Angoori Lal were present at our medical store while my sister Neelam Kumari was teaching at a private school and Urmila was at her in-laws' house. I was suffering from epilepsy and used to be treated by Dr. Sohan Lal Grover and other senior doctors before and after marriage and due to the effect of the drugs I was unable to perform the sexual intercourse and for that reason my wife used to remain under depression. After the occurrence we were summoned from the shop. I never maltreated or demanded dowry from the parents of the deceased.”
7. The prosecution also produced some evidence in defence. The trial court on an appreciation of the evidence convicted the appellant and Kaushalya Devi, his mother under Section 304-B IPC and sentenced them to RI of seven years. Angoori Lal, Urmila and Neelam were, however, acquitted. An appeal was thereafter taken to the High Court, which, in its judgment dated 7-4-2003, which has been impugned in the present proceedings, allowed the appeal of Kaushalya Devi as well. This appeal by way of special leave is, therefore, confined only to Sudhir Kumar, the husband of the deceased.
8. We have heard Mr A. Sharan, the learned Senior Counsel for the appellant and Mr Kuldip Singh, the learned counsel for the State of Punjab. We find that the prosecution story is fully proved by the evidence of PW 2 Ramji Das, the uncle of the deceased; PW 3 Tej Ram, her father and PW 4 Sat Paul, another uncle of the deceased. The medical evidence shows that the deceased had suffered 95% burn injuries and the dead body had been found in the bathroom of the house. Keeping in view the fact that the presumption under Section 113-B of the Evidence Act has to be raised in such matters, it is for the defence to dispel the presumption.
9. We find that the trial court and the High Court have gone through the evidence and given the benefit of doubt to three of the accused while maintaining the conviction only against one i.e the husband of the deceased. We also see from the evidence that the marriage had been performed on 28-7-1987 and death had occurred on 30-11-1987, that is, just four months after the marriage.
10*. Mr Sharan, the learned counsel for the appellant has, however, submitted that in the light of the fact that the prosecution story had been disbelieved with respect to four of the five accused, the presumption under Section 113-B of the Evidence Act had been rebutted and as such the appellant was entitled to acquittal on parity with the other accused.
11. It is true that four of the five accused have been acquitted but we find that primary evidence is against Sudhir Kumar, the appellant herein. A reading of the evidence shows that it was the appellant who had, just a few days before the incident, visited the house of his father-in-law and threatened Kamlesh Rani with dire consequences if his demand for a scooter and two gold rings was not fulfilled and Bhim Sain, the brother of the deceased had told him that his father Tej Ram was not in a position to meet the demands on account of financial difficulties. A few days later Ramji Das (PW 2) too had visited Kamlesh Rani's in-laws' home and had also informed Tej Ram thereafter that the appellant had been found beating his wife at that time and had once again threatened that if the demands were not satisfied Kamlesh Rani would pay dearly for it.
12*. It is true, as contended by Mr Sharan, that in a case where the prosecution evidence has been discarded with respect to four of the five accused, the presumption under Section 113-B could to some extent be said to be dispelled, but on an overview we find that the primary role and the weight of the evidence has been on the appellant herein. We, accordingly, find no merit in this appeal. Dismissed.
Alert