Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Birappa And Another v. State Of Karnataka .

Supreme Court Of India
Jul 28, 2010
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Gulappa (deceased) was rumored to have murdered Birappa’s father, creating animosity between the two families in Village Koonur, Jamkhandi Taluk. On 8 August 2002 (Amavas day), after offering prayers at Kali Devi Temple, Gulappa was attacked by Birappa (A-1), Kareppa (A-2), and Muttappa (A-3). Witness Kareppa (PW 1) alleged that A-1 inflicted several injuries while A-2 restrained the deceased. PW 1 fled, informed relatives, and searched through the night. The next morning, Gulappa’s nearly decapitated body was found in a sugarcane field. An FIR was lodged at Jharkhandi Police Station at about 2 p.m. on 9 August 2002, and a case under Sections 302/201/109 read with 34 IPC was registered.

A-1 and A-2 were arrested on 10 August 2002; A-3 was later implicated. The trial court convicted A-1 (Birappa) under Section 302 IPC and acquitted A-2 and A-3. On appeal, the High Court upheld A-1’s conviction, reversed A-2’s acquittal, and maintained A-3’s acquittal. The present appeal under Section 380 CrPC was filed before the Supreme Court by A-1 and A-2.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the conviction could be sustained when the prosecution chiefly relied on a single eyewitness (PW 1) whose credibility was questioned.
  2. Whether the delay and circumstances surrounding the lodging of the FIR undermined the prosecution’s case.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • PW 1 was the sole effective witness, and his conduct indicated he had not actually witnessed the crime.
  • The FIR was lodged after an inordinate delay, suggesting fabrication after the body was discovered.
  • No independent corroboration existed; the deceased’s wife (PW 11) retracted her earlier statement and Ramappa (CW 6) was not examined.

State's Arguments

  • PW 1’s conduct was natural and consistent—he informed relatives, searched for the deceased, and promptly lodged the FIR.
  • Any alleged delay in recording the FIR was a mere procedural lapse by the police, not affecting the core prosecution story.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reiterated that where the case rests on a single witness, the testimony must inspire full confidence. It found PW 1’s conduct “clearly unnatural”: although he claimed to witness the attack near a populated area around 6 p.m., he could not detail his search efforts between 6 p.m. and 8 p.m. The Court highlighted discrepancies:

  • PW 1 asserted he reached the police station at 9 a.m., yet the FIR was recorded only at 2 p.m.; delivery of the special report to the Magistrate at 5:55 p.m. (a half-kilometre distance) reinforced suspicions of a delayed FIR.
  • Potential corroborative witnesses failed to support the prosecution: Ramappa (CW 6) was not produced and the deceased’s wife (PW 11) recanted her earlier testimony.

These factors cumulatively led the Court to conclude that PW 1 was “perhaps not an eyewitness” and that the prosecution version was unreliable.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed; Convictions Set Aside. The Supreme Court set aside the High Court’s judgment and ordered the immediate release of the appellants unless required in another case. The ruling affects only the parties involved and does not establish new precedent beyond reinforcing the need for credible single-witness testimony and timely FIR registration.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. This appeal arises out of the following facts: Gulappa, the deceased was the younger brother of Kareppa Gadad (PW 1) and Ramappa Gadad (CW 6). They resided separately in their garden near Village Koonur, Jamkhandi Taluk. About four months prior to August 2002 Kareppa Rangappa Kote, the father of A-1, Birappa, was found dead in a well in Village Koonur and it was not known as to whether it was an accidental death or a murder, but rumour had it that he had been murdered by Gulappa, the deceased in the present matter. This rumour caused a great deal of ill will between Birappa, Appellant 1, and the deceased on which the appellant threatened that he would kill him one day.

2. On 8-8-2002 which happened to be the Amavas day, the deceased went to Kali Devi Temple at about 4.00 p.m to make his offerings and as he came out from the temple and sat down at a nearby tea shop to take tea he was attacked by Birappa, his cousin Kareppa, A-2 and Muttappa, A-3. Muttappa also made an exhortation that as it was Amavas day and a sacrifice had to be offered to the goddess, Gulappa ought to be that sacrifice. This created a fear in the mind of Kareppa (PW 1) and Gulappa and they attempted to escape from the place by rushing towards Hulyal Road. They were however chased by the accused and whereas Kareppa caught hold of the deceased, Birappa caused him several injuries.

3. Kareppa (PW 1) ran for his life and informed his brother Ramappa about the accident and also the wife of Gulappa, Shivakka (PW 11). They also attempted to trace out the whereabouts of Gulappa during the night but remained unsuccessful and it was only at 9.00 a.m the next morning that they found his dead body in the sugarcane field of one Derappa Shivaramatti. They also noticed that his neck has been virtually severed from the body. Kareppa (PW 1) thereafter went to Jharkhandi Police Station and made a statement at about 2.00 p.m before Malakappa Siddappa Malabagi (PW 12) and a case under Section 302, Sections 201 and 109 read with Section 34 IPC was duly registered. The dead body was also dispatched for its post-mortem and was received at the hospital at 5.45 p.m on 9-8-2002.

4. The accused A-1 and A-2 were arrested on 10-8-2002 and on the completion of the investigation they were charged for the offence punishable under Sections 302/201 and 109 read with Section 34 IPC and A-3 for the offences punishable under Section 302 read with Section 109 IPC. The accused pleaded not guilty and were brought to trial.

5. The trial court relying primarily on the evidence of PW 1 as supported by medical evidence and the circumstances of the case convicted Birappa under Section 302 whereas Kareppa, A-2 and A-3 were acquitted on the ground that no overt act had been attributed to them.

6. Two appeals were therefore filed before the High Court. The High Court dismissed the appeal of Birappa and allowed the State appeal qua Appellant 2 Kareppa and also convicted and sentenced him in terms similar to his co-appellant. The acquittal of Muttappa, the third accused, was however maintained. The present appeal has been filed under Section 380 CrPC directly in this Court.

7. Mr Rajesh Mahale, the learned counsel for the appellants has raised several arguments before us. He has pointed out that PW 1 was the only effective witness who had appeared for the prosecution and that it was apparent that he had not witnessed the incident and had been brought in much later and this was the reason why the FIR had been lodged after an inordinate delay. He has also pleaded that some support for the statement of PW 1 could have been found from the contemporaneous evidence of the wife of the deceased, PW 11, but this lady had not supported the prosecution and had disowned her statement made to the police.

8. Mr Sanjay Hegde, the learned counsel for the State has, however, supported the judgment of the High Court and has submitted that there was no reason to doubt the evidence of PW 1 and that his conduct inspired full confidence as he had rushed to the village, informed his brother and the wife of the deceased and had then returned to the place of incident, made a search for his brother the whole night and on discovering the dead body the next morning had lodged the FIR at about 2.00 p.m It has accordingly been urged that there was no delay in lodging of the FIR and on the contrary its very promptitude strengthened the prosecution story.

9. We have considered the arguments advanced by the learned counsel for the appellants and for the State very carefully. It is now well settled that where the prosecution story rests only on a single witness the evidence of such a witness must inspire full confidence. We find, however, that the conduct of PW 1 was clearly unnatural which makes his evidence extremely suspicious. As per the prosecution story he had seen his brother being cut up at about 6.00 p.m at a place half a kilometre away from the village near a temple and in an area which was heavily populated (as Konnur was a large village) and he had rushed home at 6.00 p.m and then returned at 8.00 p.m to look for his brother. PW 1 in his evidence did not utter a single word as to the places he had visited while in search or the inquiries he had made from the neighbourhood which had a chemist shop, a tea shop, a liquor vend and several residential houses in the fields along a very busy road. We are therefore of the opinion that PW 1 was perhaps not an eyewitness and he had lodged the FIR only after the dead body had been discovered. This perhaps explains the delay in the lodging of the FIR.

10. It has come in the evidence of PW 1 that he had rushed to the police station at 9.00 a.m Curiously enough, however, the FIR had been recorded at 2.00 p.m The High Court has glossed over this glaring flaw by observing that it was a mistake on the part of the police officer to have recorded the FIR belatedly. Some justification for this argument could perhaps have been found if the special report had been delivered within a reasonable time. It has however come in the evidence of PW 9, the police constable who had been deputed to deliver the special report to the Magistrate, that the distance between the police station and the Magistrate's residence where he had delivered the special report at 5.55 p.m was only half a kilometre. We therefore find some substance in Mr Mahale's argument that the FIR had indeed been recorded at about 5.30 or 5.45 p.m, that is, at the time when the dead body had been received in the hospital.

11. It is significant also that some corroboration could have been found from the prosecution story had Ramappa (CW 6), the brother of the deceased supported the evidence of PW 1. CW 6 though cited as a witness was not produced as a PW. The wife of the deceased, PW 11 Shivakka supported the prosecution story in the examination-in-chief but when she was called for further cross-examination after a few days she disowned her earlier statements saying:

“I did not come to know as to how my husband died and who have committed the murder of my husband. Kareppa did not inform me as to who have committed the murder of my husband. Nobody informed me that the accused have assaulted my husband.”

It is true that this witness was declared hostile but in the light of the uncertain and shaky evidence we have no option but to treat this as the final blow to the prosecution story.

12. On a cumulative reading of the aforesaid factors, we are of the opinion that the judgment of the High Court cannot be maintained. Accordingly, we allow the appeal, set aside the conviction of the appellants and direct that the appellants, who are in custody, shall be released forthwith if not required in connection with any other case.