Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Radha Mudaliyar v. Special Tahsildar (Land Acquisition), Tamil Nadu Housing Board .

Supreme Court Of India
Oct 8, 2010
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The State of Tamil Nadu issued a notification under Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 on 23-1-1985 to acquire 261.42 acres in Village Kadaperi (Tambaram Taluk) for establishing the Madras Export Processing Zone (MEPZ). The acquisition included 7.06 acres belonging to the lead appellant.

Objections under Section 5-A were considered, a Section 6 declaration followed on 23-4-1986, and Award No. 3/86 was passed on 28-11-1986 fixing compensation at Rs 145 per cent for 64 cents and Rs 110 per cent for 6.42 acres, with separate sums for improvements. Possession was taken on 3-2-1987, and the landowners accepted the award under protest on 4-7-1987 and sought references under Section 18.

The Reference Court (9-12-1988) enhanced compensation to Rs 3600 per cent and raised amounts for trees and a well. On appeal, the High Court of Madras (5-2-2001) reduced the land rate to Rs 2018 per cent after applying a 40 % deduction. The claimants and State both challenged aspects of that decision, leading to the present batch of civil appeals before the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court erred in applying a 40 % deduction and thereby undervaluing the market rate of the acquired lands.
  2. Whether the claimants are entitled to solatium and interest on solatium in accordance with Sections 23 and 34 of the Land Acquisition Act as interpreted in later Supreme Court authority.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • Market price in 1983-1984 was allegedly Rs 7000–8000 per cent, rising to Rs 45,000–50,000 per ground in 1985-1986; thus the award is grossly inadequate.
  • The High Court’s flat 40 % deduction ignored evidence of increasing land values and the relatively developed surroundings (schools, hospital, railway station within 1 km).
  • Solatium and statutory interest were denied contrary to the ruling in Sunder v. Union of India.

Respondent-State’s Arguments

  • Deduction should not be less than 40 % because the sale deeds relied upon are for small plots whereas the acquisition covers a much larger, agricultural tract requiring development.
  • The High Court’s reliance on sale deed Ext. A-4 (Rs 3363 per cent) correctly reflected market conditions without the need for further escalation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Harcharan v. State of Haryana (1982) 3 SCC 408 Comparable sales are the best evidence of market value. Cited to justify reliance on Exts. A-1, A-4, and A-5.
Kantaben Manibhai Amin v. LAO (1989) 4 SCC 662 Comparable and admissible transactions guide valuation. Reinforced the choice of neighbouring sale deeds.
ONGC Ltd. v. Sendhabhai Vastram Patel (2005) 6 SCC 454 Authority for using adjacent awards/transactions. Supported consideration of nearby sales.
Shaji Kuriakose v. Indian Oil Corpn. Ltd. (2001) 7 SCC 650 Five tests for accepting a sale deed as comparable. Applied to hold Exts. A-1, A-4, A-5 satisfy the criteria.
Kanwar Singh v. Union of India (1998) 8 SCC 136 Prefer sale instances closest to Section 4 notification. Used to give Ext. A-1 primacy (three months prior).
Land Acquisition Officer v. Nookala Rajamallu (2003) 12 SCC 334 Deductions for development/wastage where large tracts are acquired. Cited while fixing a 30 % deduction.
K.S. Shivadevamma v. Commissioner & LAO (1996) 2 SCC 62 Extent of deduction depends on stage of development; could be 33 ⅓ %+ Relied on to justify deduction methodology.
Ram Piari v. Collector (LA) (1996) 8 SCC 338 Range of permissible deductions (20–70 %). Formed part of comparative framework.
Chimanlal Hargovinddas v. LAO (1988) 3 SCC 751 Deductions for development when small-plot sales used. Cited in same context.
Hasanali Walimchand v. State of Maharashtra (1998) 2 SCC 388 Deductions despite high potentiality. Supported need for some deduction.
V. Hanumantha Reddy v. LAO (2003) 12 SCC 642 Even proximity to developed land doesn’t obviate development deduction. Affirmed practice of deducting ~1/3.
Charan Dass v. H.P. Housing & Urban Dev. Authority (2010) 13 SCC 398 Market value determined by objective standards, using comparable sales or awards. Quoted for the general valuation framework.
ONGC Ltd. v. Rameshbhai Jivanbhai Patel (2008) 14 SCC 745 Annual time-based escalation (10–15 %). Used to grant 10 % increase for ten-month gap.
Sardar Jogendra Singh v. State of U.P. (2008) 17 SCC 133 Same principle of annual escalation. Supported limited 10 % addition.
Kasturi v. State of Haryana (2003) 1 SCC 354 Where land abuts development, deduction may be as low as 20 %. Cited by claimants; Court ultimately fixed 30 %.
Prem Nath Kapur v. National Fertilizers Corp. (1996) 2 SCC 71 Earlier view on interest on solatium. High Court had relied on it; Supreme Court overruled reliance.
Sunder v. Union of India (2001) 7 SCC 211 Interest is payable on solatium. Followed to award interest on solatium.
Kapur Chand Jain v. State Govt. of H.P. (1999) 2 SCC 89 Earlier reference concerning interest issue. Explained High Court’s earlier hesitation; now superseded.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court reiterated that comparable sale instances are the “safest method” of valuation. It examined three sale deeds (Exts. A-1, A-4, A-5) from the same village:

  • Choice of exemplar: Ext. A-1 (Rs 4000 per cent, executed three months before the Section 4 notification) was preferred because of temporal proximity and genuineness.
  • Time escalation: Following ONGC Patel and Sardar Jogendra Singh, a 10 % annual increase was accepted where necessary, but the Court avoided the Reference Court’s excessive 40 % uplift.
  • Deduction for development: Relying on Nookala Rajamallu, K.S. Shivadevamma and related cases, the Court held that a uniform deduction of approximately one-third (30 %) was appropriate to account for converting small-plot prices to a large, mostly agricultural tract intended for industrial development.
  • Resultant computation: Applying 30 % deduction to the Rs 4000 per cent benchmark produced Rs 2800 per cent as the fair market value—consistent with a cross-check using the adjusted value from Ext. A-4.
  • Statutory benefits: Citing the Constitution Bench in Sunder, the Court held that solatium attracts interest under the proviso to Section 34, overruling the High Court’s contrary view grounded in Prem Nath Kapur.

Holding and Implications

PARTIALLY ALLOWED: Compensation enhanced to Rs 2800 per cent for all appellants, with consequential benefits under Section 23(1-A) and interest on solatium per Section 34. No further enhancement for wells, trees, or other superstructures. Parties to bear their own costs.

Implications are confined to ensuring correct application of comparable-sale methodology, reasonable (not mechanical) deductions, and mandatory payment of interest on solatium. The decision reaffirms existing precedent without creating a new legal test.

Show all summary ...

Swatanter Kumar, J.— Leave granted in SLP (C) No. 9736 of 2004. Application for impleadment in Civil Appeal No. 5616 of 2004 is allowed.

2. By this judgment, we will dispose of the three civil appeals being Civil Appeals Nos. 5616, 5628 and 5732 of 2004 and a civil appeal arising out of Special Leave Petition (C) No. 9736 of 2004 as they arise from a common judgment with somewhat similar facts.

3. For the purposes of brevity and to avoid repetition, we would be referring to the facts in Civil Appeal No. 5616 of 2004. A Notification under Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (for short “the Act”) was issued by the Industries Department of the State of Tamil Nadu on 23-1-1985 to acquire land in the revenue estate of Village Kadaperi, hamlet of Tambaram, Tambaram Taluk within the municipal limits of the city including the land admeasuring 7.06 acres belonging to the appellant. This notification came to be issued in furtherance of the scheme, which was sanctioned by the State Industries Promotion Corporation of Tamil Nadu (Sipcot) on 3-4-1984 and a total of 261.42 acres of land was acquired for setting up the Madras Export Processing Zone (MEPZ). The entire land, including dry and wet lands, was sought to be acquired as a compact block for the project in question.

4. In response to the publication of the notification, the interested persons filed objections in terms of Section 5-A of the Act which were considered by the Land Acquisition Officer (for short “the LAO”) and declaration under Section 6 of the Act was issued on 23-4-1986. After notice to the interested persons/owners, Award No. 3/86 was made and published by the LAO on 28-11-1986. The LAO awarded compensation at the rate of Rs. 145 per cent for an extent of 64 cents and Rs. 110 for 6.42 acres of another kind of land and also awarded compensation at different rates for the superstructures raised by the appellants on their respective lands. The possession of the land was taken on 3-2-1987. The compensation was received by the appellants under protest on 4-7-1987 and they preferred references under Section 18 of the Act.

5. According to the appellants, the market price of the land in question was between Rs. 7000 and Rs. 8000 per cent in the years 1983-1984. In 1985-1986 the land was sold at the rate of Rs. 45,000 to Rs. 50,000 per ground. In this appeal, the appellants had claimed compensation at that rate. They also stated that they had raised nearly 160 coconut trees and dug a big well fitted with electric motor by incurring a cost of Rs. 1.5 lakhs on the land in question. We may notice that various appellants had raised different claims on these grounds. The Collector, as already noticed, had awarded compensation uniformly at the rates mentioned supra while awarding compensation separately for the well, trees, etc.

6. The parties led evidence before the Reference Court and the Reference Court, vide its judgment dated 9-12-1988, enhanced the compensation payable to the claimants to Rs. 3600 per cent as agricultural land by relying upon Exts. A-1, A-4 and A-5. The Reference Court granted the following relief to the claimants:

“(1) The valuation fixed by the lands acquired at Rs. 110 and Rs. 145 per cent, by the Land Acquisition Officer has been raised and a fresh valuation at Rs. 3600 per cent is fixed for the entire area of the acquired lands;
(2) The valuation at Rs. 2675 per coconut tree, fixed by the Land Acquisition Tahsildar is held to be correct and confirmed;
(3) The valuation for the well and the pumpset made by the Land Acquisition Tahsildar at Rs. 44,487 has been enhanced to Rs. 1,76,862 and fixed accordingly;
(4) Further, it is ordered that the claimant should be paid 30% solatium for the above amounts and interest at the rate of 12% from 23-1-1985 to 28-11-1986 and further 9% interest from 3-2-1987 to 2-2-1988. It is ordered that the sum of Rs. 1,88,887.85 fixed as compensation by the Land Acquisition Tahsildar for the land, trees, well and pumpset should be deducted from the above amount. It is further ordered that the claimant is entitled to the interest at the rate of 15% per annum for the difference amount of compensation from 3-2-1988 till date of deposit of the compensation into court.”

7. Aggrieved by the said judgment of the Reference Court, the Government, through the LAO, filed an appeal before the High Court challenging the correctness of the same. The High Court, vide its judgment dated 5-2-2001, declined to accept the reasoning recorded by the Reference Court in its different judgments under appeal and reduced the compensation payable to the claimants at the rate of Rs. 2018 per cent. Thus, the High Court, while partially accepting the appeal of the State, granted the following relief:

“Therefore, considering the fact that the lands under acquisition are not developed at all, whereas, adjoining lands are developed, deduction at the rate of 40% for prescribing the correct value by the learned Judge cannot be held to be erroneous. Therefore, we are of the considered view that the market value of the acquired lands can be determined by adopting the value as per Ext. A-4 i.e Rs. 3363, and after a deduction of 40% towards development charges, the market value will be Rs. 2018 per cent. The claimant is entitled to compensation for the 7.06 acres of acquired lands at this rate i.e Rs. 14,24,708.”

8. Before discussing the merits in these appeals, it needs to be noticed that different sales instances were produced as exhibits in different references. As far as the question of enhancing the compensation awarded to the claimants on account of trees, well and other improvements on the land in question is concerned, we may notice that it is apparent from the record of the case as well as the arguments addressed before this Court that the correctness of the compensation awarded by the Reference Court was hardly questioned before the High Court and even before this Court. As there is no serious challenge to the quantum of compensation awarded on this account, we do not propose to discuss this issue any further. Thus, only two issues have been raised before us, namely:

(a) that the High Court has not appreciated the evidence on record in its correct perspective. The High Court has applied deduction of 40% which, in the facts and circumstances of the case, is not called for. This has resulted in serious prejudice to the interest of the claimants and they have not been awarded the fair market value of their acquired lands; and
(b) they have not been awarded solatium and interest in accordance with law.

Discussion on merits

9. In Civil Appeal No. 5616 of 2004, the claimant is the owner of land admeasuring 7.06 acres in a compact square shape falling in Survey Nos. 16 and 24/1 in the revenue estate of Kadaperi Village. Exts. A-1, A-4 and A-5 are the sales instances from the same village which had been produced by the claimant in support of her claim. Exts. A-2 and A-3 are the valuation reports in relation to the well and the pump on the acquired land. Ext. A-6 is the photocopy of Kadaperi Village map. Exts. A-1, A-4 and A-5 are dated 7-11-1984, 12-3-1984 and 15-6-1984 respectively. The Reference Court appears to have firstly relied upon Ext. A-5 and while assuming that value of the land under this exhibit was Rs. 6000 per cent then proceeded to apply 40% deduction on account of road facilities and the fact that these were the sales instances relating to plots and resultantly awarded Rs. 3600 per cent as the compensation payable to the claimants. Reference was also made to Ext. A-4 where the land had been sold at the rate of Rs. 4545 per cent. The court noticed that the value of the land had been increasing in the area day by day and various facilities such as school, college, hospital and banks were available quite near the acquired land and even a railway station was located within a distance of one kilometre. While taking Ext. A-4 as the basis, the Reference Court erred in adding 40% increase to the reflected value in the sale deed. The error is due to the reasons that actual sale consideration of Ext. A-4 was Rs. 3363 per cent and the intervening period between the date of the sale deed and issuance of notification under Section 4 was not two years as noticed by that court. Though the compensation was determined primarily on the basis of Ext. A-4, the learned Reference Court noticed that the land in Ext. A-5 had been sold at the rate of Rs. 6000 per cent under that document. This impression of the Reference Court is not supported by any evidence on record as under Ext. A-5 the land was, in fact, sold at the rate of Rs. 2180 per cent on 15-6-1984. However, the learned Reference Court computed somewhat similar compensation with reference to the two Exts. A-4 and A-5. It may be noticed that Ext. A-4 is three months prior to the date of execution of Ext. A-5.

10. In the civil appeal arising out of SLP (C) No. 9736 of 2004, the Tahsildar vide Award No. 5 of 1986 dated 29-11-1986 had fixed the compensation at Rs. 145.85 per cent on the basis of Exts. A-2 and A-3 respectively. These documents, as well as Ext. A-4 were considered to be inadmissible by the Reference Court in its order dated 18-11-1990 and rejected as they were neither the original sale deeds nor copies of registered documents. The rejection thereof is not questioned in the present appeals. The court had primarily relied upon Ext. A-1 and awarded the compensation. The High Court, while adopting the reasoning given in its judgment in Civil Appeal No. 5616 of 2004, reduced the compensation relying upon Ext. A-4 in that case and after making 40% deduction awarded the compensation.

11. In the backdrop of the above factual matrix and the judgments of the courts under appeal, this Court imprimis has to examine as to what would be the just and fair market value of the land on the basis of which the compensation payable to the claimants should be determined in terms of Section 23 of the Act.

12. It is a well-settled principle of law that comparable sales instances, subject to their satisfying the basic ingredients of law, are the best piece of evidence to be considered by the court for the purpose of determining the compensation. Even awards and transactions of the adjacent areas have been treated as best evidence which will fall within the zone of consideration by the court. Of course, such instances must be comparable and legally admissible in evidence. In this aspect, we may refer to the judgments of this Court in Harcharan v. State of Haryana (1982) 3 SCC 408; Kantaben Manibhai Amin v. Land Acquisition Officer (1989) 4 SCC 662 and ONGC Ltd. v. Sendhabhai Vastram Patel (2005) 6 SCC 454.

13. Comparable sales instances are the safest method for determining the market value of the acquired land and as laid down in Shaji Kuriakose v. Indian Oil Corpn. Ltd. (2001) 7 SCC 650, it should satisfy the factors, inter alia, (1) the sale must be a genuine transaction; (2) the sale deed must have been executed at the time proximate to the date of issuance of notification under Section 4 of the Act; (3) the land covered by the sale must be in the vicinity of the acquired land; (4) the land covered by the sale must be similar to the acquired land; and (5) size of the plot of the land covered by the sale be comparable to the acquired land. The sales instances should preferably be closest to the date of the notification as then alone it would satisfy the touchstone of the principles contemplated under Section 23 of the Act, as held in Kanwar Singh v. Union of India (1998) 8 SCC 136.

14. In Civil Appeal No. 5616 of 2004, three sales instances were produced and proved by the claimants on the record of the Reference Court. These are Exts. A-1, A-4 and A-5 and their details are as follows:

Exhibit Date of sale deed Area sold Total sale consideration Value per cent A-1 7-11-1984 5 cents Rs. 20,000 Rs. 4000 A-5 15-6-1984 4.13 cents Rs. 9000 Rs. 2180 A-4 12-3-1984 5.5 cents Rs. 18,500 Rs. 3363

15. It needs to be noticed that all these lands are located in the revenue estate of the same village from where the land has been acquired. The land, subject-matter of Ext. A-4 is located in Survey No. 165 and, as apparent from the above table, admeasuring approximately 5.5 cents was sold for a sum of Rs. 18,500 and the rate comes to Rs. 3363 per cent. However, it is in evidence that when this document was presented for registration, the Registrar concerned made an endorsement raising an objection with regard to the sale consideration declared in the sale deed. According to the Registrar, Mark A-5 was the endorsement vide which the parties were directed to pay stamp duty taking the value of the land in question to be Rs. 25,000. The total sale consideration being Rs. 25,000, the rate of the land would come to Rs. 4545 per cent. This document was registered as per endorsement on record on 15-6-1984 while the date of the presentation and execution of the sale deed was 12-3-1984. We would not like to go into the question whether as per Ext. A-4 the sale consideration should be Rs. 18,500 or it should be Rs. 25,000. The question as to what is the effect of enhancement of the sale consideration by the Registrar for the purpose of payment of stamp duty, on the market value of the acquired land while determining the compensation payable to the claimants, need not be examined by us. In this case, the same is specifically kept open. For the purposes of the present case, we would take the value of the land at the rate of Rs. 3363 per cent.

16. Exts. A-1 and A-5 again are the sales instances from the same revenue estate and are quite close to the date of Notification under Section 4, Ext. A-1 is dated 7-11-1984 while Ext. A-5 is dated 15-6-1984. None of the parties to the proceedings have questioned the genuineness, legality or otherwise of these documents and, in fact, as it appears from the record before us there is hardly any objection regarding their admissibility or being read in evidence.

17. Now, let us examine whether Exts. A-1, A-4 and A-5 satisfy the abovestated tests. They were admitted in evidence in accordance with law as they are genuine transactions and are the closest sales instances to the date of the notification as available on record and the land, subject-matter of the transaction, is quite similar to the acquired land and, in fact, it is from the same village. Of course, the area, stated in these sales instances, is comparatively much smaller in size than the acquired land. The sale deed is dated 12-3-1984 while the Notification under Section 4 was issued on 23-1-1985. Thus, there is a difference of nearly ten months between these two dates. The claimants would be entitled to the benefit of increase for this intervening period.

18. The annual increase of 10% to 15% is normally allowed by the court where the record reflects increasing trend in the sale price of the land. This principle is often applied by this Court while determining compensation. Reference can be made to the judgments of this Court in ONGC Ltd. v. Rameshbhai Jivanbhai Patel (2008) 14 SCC 745 and Sardar Jogendra Singh v. State of U.P (2008) 17 SCC 133 We have opted to apply the minimum increase possible because of the short intervening period between the execution of the sale deed and issuance of notification under Section 4. Consequence of the above addition would be that the value of the land in terms of Ext. A-4 as on the date of the notification under Section 4 would be Rs. 3699 per cent rounded off to Rs. 3700 per cent which, when reasonable deduction is applied, would give more or less the same rate of compensation as computed by us on the basis of Ext. A-1.

19. Now, the next question that arises is whether the claimants would be entitled to receive the compensation at this rate or certain element of deduction needs to be applied in the facts and circumstances of the case. The deduction can be applied for different aspects while determining compensation. If the size of the plot is very small and the same has to be taken into consideration for non-availability of other evidence and where the land acquired is a large chunk of land, then it would be advisable to apply some deduction on that score. Reference in this regard may be made to Land Acquisition Officer v. Nookala Rajamallu (2003) 12 SCC 334. In alternative or in addition thereto, deduction can also be applied on account of wastage of land and development charges.

20. In the present case, the land has been acquired, which apparently was an agricultural land at the time of acquisition, to carry out the development scheme for MEPZ sanctioned by Sipcot. The development purpose, being in public interest, is bound to result in utilisation of part of the land for the purposes of roads, by-links, water and electricity lines and other infrastructural amenities of the project. This Court, depending on the facts and circumstances of the case, has taken the view that deduction on account of expenses of development of the sites could vary from 20% to 70% depending on the nature of the land, its situation, the purpose and stage of development as held by this Court in K.S Shivadevamma v. Commissioner and Land Acquisition Officer (1996) 2 SCC 62, Ram Piari v. Collector L.A (1996) 8 SCC 338, Chimanlal Hargovinddas v. Land Acquisition Officer (1988) 3 SCC 751 and Hasanali Walimchand v. State of Maharashtra (1998) 2 SCC 388.

21. In K.S Shivadevamma (1996) 2 SCC 62, this Court held as under:

“10. It is then contended that 53% is not automatic but depends upon the nature of the development and the stage of development. We are inclined to agree with the learned counsel that the extent of deduction depends upon development need in each case. Under the Building Rules 53% of land is required to be left out. This Court has laid as a general rule that for laying the roads and other amenities 33 1/3% is required to be deducted. Where the development has already taken place, appropriate deduction needs to be made. In this case, we do not find that any development had taken place as on that date. When we are determining compensation under Section 23(1), as on the date of notification under Section 4(1), we have to consider the situation of the land development, if already made, and other relevant facts as on that date. No doubt, the land possessed potential value, but no development had taken place as on the date. In view of the obligation on the part of the owner to hand over the land to the City Improvement Trust for roads and for other amenities and his requirement to expend money for laying the roads, water supply mains, electricity, etc., the deduction of 53% and further deduction towards development charges @ 33 1/3%, ordered by the High Court, was not illegal.”

The above view was reiterated in Nookala Rajamallu (2003) 12 SCC 334.

22. On similar lines, this Court in V. Hanumantha Reddy v. Land Acquisition Officer (2003) 12 SCC 642, while considering that the acquired land was adjacent to developed land, held that neither its high potentiality nor its proximity to a developed land can be a ground for not deducting the development charges and that normally 1/3rd deduction could be allowed.

23. We may also notice that the courts would have to apply some guesswork while determining such a question inasmuch as it is not always possible to determine the quantum of compensation with exactitude or arithmetical accuracy. Of course, this permissible guesswork has to be used with great caution and within the determinants of law declared by this Court from time to time.

24. This Court in Charan Dass v. H.P Housing and Urban Development Authority (2010) 13 SCC 398, (2009) 12 Scale 293, held as under:

“19. Section 15 of the Act mandates that in determining the amount of compensation, the Collector shall be guided by the provisions contained in Sections 23 and 24 of the Act. Section 23 provides that in determining the amount of compensation to be awarded for the land acquired under the Act, the Court shall, inter alia, take into consideration the market value of the land at the date of the publication of the notification under Section 4 of the Act. The section contains a list of positive factors and Section 24 has a list of negatives vis-à-vis the land under acquisition to be taken into consideration while determining the amount of compensation.
20. As already noted, the first step being the determination of the market value of the land on the date of publication of notification under sub-section (1) of Section 4 of the Act, one of the principles for determination of the market value of the acquired land would be the price that a willing purchaser would be willing to pay if it is sold in the open market at the time of issue of notification under Section 4 of the Act. But finding direct evidence in this behalf is not an easy task and, therefore, the Court has to take recourse to other known methods for arriving at the market value of the land acquired.
21. One of the preferred and well-accepted methods adopted for ascertaining the market value of the land in acquisition cases is the sale transactions on or about the date of issue of notification under Section 4 of the Act. But here again finding a transaction of sale on or a few days before the said notification is not an easy exercise. In the absence of such evidence contemporaneous transactions in respect of the lands which have similar advantages and disadvantages are considered as a good piece of evidence for determining the market value of the acquired land.
22. It needs little emphasis that the contemporaneous transactions or the comparable sales have to be in respect of lands which are contiguous to the acquired land and are similar in nature and potentiality. Again, in the absence of sale deeds, the judgments and awards passed in respect of acquisition of lands, made in the same village and/or neighbouring villages can be accepted as valid piece of evidence and provide a sound basis to work out the market value of the land after suitable adjustments with regard to positive and negative factors enumerated in Sections 23 and 24 of the Act. Undoubtedly, an element of some guesswork is involved in the entire exercise, yet the authority charged with the duty to award compensation is bound to make an estimate judged by an objective standard.”
(emphasis supplied)

25. Despite the fact that both the Reference Court as well as the High Court have relied upon Exts. A-4 or A-5 or both of them, still they have arrived at drastically different rates of compensation payable to the claimants. While the High Court took the value of Ext. A-4 as Rs. 3363 per cent, without adding any element of increase for the intervening period, it applied deduction at the rate of 40% and awarded compensation at the rate of Rs. 2018 per cent. On the other hand the Reference Court took the total sale consideration of Ext. A-4 as Rs. 25,000 in place of Rs. 18,500 and applied 40% increase while awarding compensation to the claimants. Of course, the Reference Court also applied 40% deduction on account of development charges and taking the gross value at the rate of Rs. 6000 per cent awarded compensation at the rate of Rs. 3600 per cent.

26. In our considered view, both the Reference Court as well as the High Court have fallen in error of law in computing the compensation payable to the claimants. On the one hand, the High Court ignored an important aspect of the case in not awarding enhancement in the value of the land as it had come in evidence that there was increasing trend in the sale price of the land in that area. The documentary evidence of Exts. A-1 and A-4 also shows the increasing trend. On the other hand, the Reference Court fell in error in giving 40% increase for a short intervening period of ten months. Both the High Court as well as the Reference Court had applied the deduction at the rate of 40% but still awarded compensation at antipodal rates.

27. Another reason which we must notice and, in fact, it is not clear to us either from the judgment of the High Court or that of the Reference Court as to why Ext. A-1 has not been taken into consideration by both the courts. In our view, Ext. A-1 is the sale instance from the revenue estate of the same village and is located close to the developed area. The sale deed was executed only three months prior to the date of notification under Section 4 of the Act and also reflected a reasonable value where the land was sold at the rate of Rs. 4000 per cent while as per Ext. A-4, the land was sold at the rate of Rs. 3363 on 12-3-1984, thus, indicating increasing trend in the value of the land. If appropriate increase is given on the basis of Ext. A-4 for the intervening period and deduction at a reasonable rate less than 40% is applied, it will approximately give the same rate of compensation as would be computed with reference to Ext. A-1.

28. Now, let us examine the exact compensation payable to the claimants with reference to Ext. A-1. Genuineness of Ext. A-1 has neither been questioned nor held to be a transaction which was executed only to enhance the value of the acquired land. Ext. A-1 is a comparable piece of evidence which can safely be relied upon by the court while determining the compensation in regard to the acquired land. The learned counsel for the claimants, while relying upon the judgment of this Court in Kasturi v. State of Haryana (2003) 1 SCC 354 contended that the acquired land has great potential and is located adjacent to the developed land and as such the deduction should not be more than 20% on these counts. However, the learned counsel appearing for the respondents relied upon the other judgments already referred by us supra that the deduction should not be less than 40%.

29. Having examined the facts and circumstances of the case and the evidence on record, we are of the considered view that rule of approximately 1/3rd deduction can be fairly applied to the present case. The land certainly has potential and even the sales instances show that the land from the Revenue Estate of the same village was sold as plots and a number of facilities, as indicated above, were available in the vicinity. Examining the cumulative effect of the evidence on record in relation to location, potential and similarity of land, we consider it appropriate that deduction of more than 30% would be prejudicial to the interest of the claimants whose lands have been acquired by the State in exercise of its power of eminent domain. It is a compulsory acquisition and it is expected of the State to be just and fair and award the compensation to the claimants which satisfies the mandate of law contained in the provisions of Section 23 of the Act. Therefore, applying 30% deduction to the value indicated in Ext. A-1 (deduction being made both on account of size of the plot and development charges), the claimants would be entitled to receive compensation at the rate of Rs. 2800 per cent for the acquired land. As in the other appeals, the High Court had only relied upon its judgment which is impugned in Civil Appeal No. 5616 of 2004, therefore, it is not necessary for us to discuss the evidence in those cases in any further detail. The claimants in all these appeals would be entitled to the same rate of compensation.

30. The argument of the appellants is that they have been denied solatium and interest by the High Court while referring to the judgment of this Court in Prem Nath Kapur v. National Fertilizers Corpn. of India Ltd. (1996) 2 SCC 71 It is contended that in view of the law clearly stated by this Court in Sunder v. Union of India (2001) 7 SCC 211, which has been consistently followed by different Benches of this Court, the claimants are entitled to solatium as well as the interest on the awarded amount. We find merit in this contention.

31. The Constitution Bench of this Court in Sunder (2001) 7 SCC 211 had clearly stated that the court has to keep in mind that the compulsory nature of acquisition is to be distinguished from voluntary sale or transfer. In the latter, there is a willing buyer and seller. In the case of acquisition, it is compulsory and deprives the owner of an opportunity to negotiate and bargain the sale price of its land as it will entirely depend on what the Collector or the court determines as the amount of compensation in accordance with the provisions of the Act. The solatium envisaged in sub-section (2) of Section 23 is “in consideration of the compulsory nature of acquisition”. Thus, the solatium is not the same as damages on account of the landowner's disinclination to part with the land acquired. If such compensation as determined in terms of Section 23 of the Act is not paid within one year from the date of taking possession of the land, then in terms of the proviso to Section 34 interest shall stand escalated to 15% per annum from the date of the expiry of the said period of one year on the amount of compensation or part thereof which has not been paid or deposited before the date of such expiry. The Court further held that it is inconceivable that the solatium amount would attract only the escalated rate of interest from the expiry of one year and that there would be no interest on solatium during the preceding period. Hence the person entitled to the compensation awarded is also entitled to get interest on the aggregate amount including solatium.

32. It appears from the impugned judgment that the High Court had relied upon the judgment of this Court in Prem Nath Kapur (1996) 2 SCC 71 and the judgment of this Court in Sunder (2001) 7 SCC 211 came to be pronounced after the judgment of the High Court. While relying upon the law existing at that time, the High Court had declined to grant the interest on solatium but made it subject to the pronouncement in Kapur Chand Jain v. State Govt. of H.P (1999) 2 SCC 89, wherein this Court subsequently made a reference to a larger Bench and the judgment in Sunder (2001) 7 SCC 211 came to be pronounced. In any case there can be no doubt in law that the claimants are entitled to the solatium and the interest thereupon at the rate specified in the proviso to Section 34 of the Act for the relevant period. Even in this regard the judgment of the High Court, therefore, cannot be sustained.

33. For the reasons aforestated we partially allow the appeals of the appellants that the appellant claimants would be entitled to receive compensation at the rate of Rs. 2800 per cent for the acquired land and the consequential benefits of Section 23(1-A). The claimants would also be entitled to get interest on solatium according to the proviso to Section 34 of the Act. As already noted, the claimants have not pressed for any enhancement for the superstructures, namely, well, trees, etc. which, in any case, is hereby rejected.

34. In the facts and circumstances of the cases the parties are left to bear their own costs.