- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State Of Andhra Pradesh v. M. Narasimha Rao .
Factual and Procedural Background
The respondent, M. Narasimha Rao, and the deceased, T. Subbaiah, were villagers of Veknuru, Andhra Pradesh. Prior animosity existed: two months before the incident PW 1 (elder son of the deceased) was beaten by the respondent, and PW 3 (younger son) retaliated by thrashing the respondent.
On the night of 13–14 September 1995, while PW 3 was away on a pilgrimage, the deceased and PW 2 (his wife) slept in PW 3’s house at his request. Around midnight the respondent, armed with a knife, entered the house, mistook the sleeping deceased for PW 3, and inflicted multiple knife blows. PW 2 witnessed the attack; her cries brought PW 1, who attempted to apprehend the assailant but the respondent escaped.
At 8 a.m. on 14 September 1995 PW 1 reported the incident to the Village Administrative Officer (PW 8), leading to registration of an FIR at Avanigadda Police Station and the respondent’s arrest. He was charged under Sections 449 and 302 IPC.
The trial court relied principally on eyewitness testimony from PW 1 and PW 2, convicted the respondent under Section 302 IPC, and sentenced him to life imprisonment. The High Court, on 18 April 2002, acquitted the respondent, doubting PW 1’s presence, expressing concern over hostile witnesses and perceived delays in filing the FIR and forwarding the special report.
The State appealed to the Supreme Court, which granted leave to examine the acquittal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the High Court erred in discarding the testimony of PW 1 and PW 2 and consequently acquitting the respondent.
- Whether the alleged delay in lodging the FIR and forwarding the special report undermined the prosecution case.
- The scope of Supreme Court interference in an appeal against acquittal when the High Court’s appreciation of evidence is alleged to be perverse.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant (State of Andhra Pradesh)
- PW 1 and PW 2 are credible eyewitnesses; being close relatives does not disqualify their testimony.
- Only family members could reasonably witness a midnight attack inside a house; expecting independent witnesses is unrealistic.
- No real delay exists: PW 2’s statement was recorded at 8 a.m.; the police station was 7 km away, explaining the interval before FIR registration and delivery of the special report.
- Hostility of other witnesses and non-support for extra-judicial confession are immaterial given strong direct evidence.
Respondent (M. Narasimha Rao)
- The Supreme Court should exercise restraint in overturning an acquittal.
- PW 1 was not present during the attack; reliance on him as an eyewitness is unjustified.
- PW 2’s account conflicts with medical evidence; her opportunity to witness the assault is doubtful.
- Delay in FIR and special report indicates fabrication.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court acknowledged the general caution against interfering with acquittals but emphasized its duty to correct grave misappreciation of evidence. The Court found:
- Credibility of PW 1 and PW 2: PW 2 directly observed the attack; PW 1’s house was 25–30 yards away, making it plausible that he reached the scene during the continuing assault, qualifying him as an eyewitness. Cross-examination offered no serious challenge to his presence.
- Corroboration by medical evidence: Post-mortem findings (multiple deep cut injuries to face and neck) aligned with PW 2’s description of a knife attack, reinforcing authenticity.
- Motive and mistaken identity: Prior hostility and the respondent’s shouted admission (“he had killed PW 3 and would now kill PW 1”) supported the prosecution theory that the intended victim was PW 3, establishing motive.
- Delay in FIR and special report: Considering PW 2’s advanced age (75) and trauma, an 8 a.m. statement followed by FIR registration around 10 a.m. at a station 7 km away was reasonable; any delay was both minimal and satisfactorily explained. Delivery of the special report four hours later carried little weight against strong eyewitness testimony.
- Hostile witnesses: The non-support of witnesses to extra-judicial confession or weapon recovery did not erode the consistent and trustworthy direct evidence.
Accordingly, the High Court’s doubts were deemed unfounded and its acquittal “erroneous.”
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeal is allowed; the High Court’s acquittal is set aside. The respondent is convicted under Section 302 IPC and sentenced to life imprisonment with a fine of ₹100 (15 days’ simple imprisonment in default).
Implications: The decision reinstates the trial court’s verdict, reaffirming that credible eyewitness testimony—especially when corroborated by medical evidence—can sustain a conviction despite hostile ancillary witnesses or minor procedural delays. No new legal principle was articulated, but the judgment underscores the Supreme Court’s willingness to overturn acquittals where evaluation of evidence is found to be perverse.
H.S Bedi, J.— This appeal against acquittal at the instance of the State of Andhra Pradesh arises out of the following facts.
2. M. Narasimha Rao, the respondent herein, and the deceased, T. Subbaiah were residents of Village Veknuru. The deceased was married with PW 2 and they had two sons PWs 1 and 3. Some two months prior to the present incident, a quarrel had taken place between the respondent and PW 1 in which PW 1 had suffered a beating. In order to avenge this insult, PW 3 went to the house of the respondent and gave him a sound thrashing.
3*. On 13-9-1995, PW 3 planned to go on a religious journey to Pedakakani and while doing so, he requested his mother PW 2 and his father to sleep in his house while he was away. Accordingly, the deceased and PW 2 went to the house of PW 3 to sleep there that night. At about midnight on the night intervening between 13-9-1995 and 14-9-1995, the respondent-accused reached the house of PW 3 armed with a knife and on seeing a person sleeping on the cot in the verandah, and believing him to be PW 3, attacked him administering several knife-blows. On hearing the commotion, PW 2 who was sleeping on a mat beside her husband's cot, cried out in alarm and also attempted to intervene to save her husband, but the accused pushed her down. In the meanwhile, PW 1 whose house was close by also rushed to the spot and he also witnessed the incident and attempted to catch the accused who, however, managed to run away. The accused thereafter went to the house of his maternal uncle PW 6 who told him to get out of the house.
4. At 8 a.m on 14-9-1995 PW 1 went to the Village Administrative Officer, PW 8 and narrated the incident to him. PW 8 recorded the circumstances in writing and sent the information to Police Station Avanigadda and a formal FIR was registered in the police station. The accused was thereafter arrested and on completion of the investigation, a charge-sheet was filed under Sections 449 and 302 IPC. He pleaded false implication and claimed trial.
5. In support of its case, prosecution examined 13 witnesses in all, the primary witnesses being one PW 1, the elder son of the deceased, who had come to the place of incident during the occurrence after hearing cries of his mother and had also attempted to apprehend him; PW 2, the wife of the deceased and mother of PW 1 and PW 3, the younger brother of PW 1, who had gone on a pilgrimage and was in fact the cause of the attack and PW 8, the Village Administrative Officer, who had recorded the first information report. Certain other witnesses, who are not eyewitnesses, were, however, declared hostile. The prosecution also relied upon various documents such as the post-mortem report and the circumstantial evidence such as the recovery of the murder weapon at the instance of the accused, etc.
6. The trial court relying on the evidence of PW 1 and PW 2, both eyewitnesses, and the closest relatives of the deceased, as corroborated by the statement of PW 3 with regard to the motive convicted the accused. It held that though some of the witnesses had not supported the prosecution story, it was of no consequence as they had no role to play in determining the truthfulness of the eyewitness account of PW 1 and PW 2. The court accordingly held that though PWs 6 and 9 with respect to the extra-judicial confession and the recovery of weapon of murder had not supported the prosecution, this factor would have no effect on the prosecution story.
7**. The court also observed that in the light of the fact that the incident had happened at night and PW 2 was an old woman, 75 years of age, and must have been completely traumatised by the events, the mere fact that the FIR had been lodged at about 10 a.m or the special report had been delivered four hours later, could not detract from the prosecution story.
8. The trial court, accordingly, convicted and sentenced the accused to undergo imprisonment for life under Section 302 IPC but did not record any conviction under Section 449 IPC.
9. An appeal was thereafter taken to the High Court of the State of Andhra Pradesh. The Division Bench by its judgment dated 18-4-2002 reversed the findings of the trial court and acquitted the accused. In doing so, the High Court observed that as some of the witnesses, PWs 4, 5 and 6, who had reached the place of incident soon after the incident, had turned hostile and PW 9, the witness of the extra-judicial confession had also not supported the prosecution, the reliance on the statements of PWs 1 and 2 alone was a matter which needed examination with care. It observed that PW 2 was the wife of the deceased and was an eyewitness but as PW 1 had come to the spot after the occurrence and had not been present at the time of the incident, it appeared that he was not an eyewitness, and the Court had to be extremely careful before recording a verdict of guilt on the basis of the statement of a solitary witness. The Court then held that the incident had happened at about midnight of 13th and 14th September and the FIR had been lodged after 8 hours though the police station was 7 km away from the place of incident and the fact that the special report had been delivered 4 hours later to the Magistrate's Court, which was in the same compound as the police station, was also a belated exercise.
10. The present appeal has been filed by the State of Andhra Pradesh challenging the order of the High Court and after the grant of leave, the matter is before us.
11. The learned counsel for the appellant has, first and foremost, pointed out that there was no reason whatsoever to disbelieve PW 1 and PW 2 as they were eyewitnesses to the incident and also the closest relatives of the deceased. It has been further pointed out that only witnesses, who could be expected at the night in a residential house, would be the immediate members of the family and to look for evidence beyond these witnesses was difficult to accept. It has also been pleaded that there was no delay in lodging the FIR as the statement had been made by PW 2 to the Village Administrative Officer at about 8 a.m and it was his duty to forward the information to the police station and if in doing so, some time had been taken as the police station was 7 km away from the village, there was absolutely no delay in registration of the FIR. It has been further submitted that the delay in the delivery of the special report would become insignificant in the light of the categoric eyewitness evidence.
12. The learned counsel for the respondent-accused has, however, pointed out that the High Court having recorded an acquittal, the reappraisal of the evidence by this Court, was not justified. On merits, it has been pleaded that PW 1 was not an eyewitness and there was absolutely no justification for the trial court to have held otherwise. It has further been pleaded that the evidence of PW 2 was at variance with the medical evidence and the fact that she had not seen the incident was borne by the fact that the FIR had been belatedly recorded and the special report delivered belatedly as well.
13. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and gone through the record.
14. It is true that interference by this Court on a reappraisal of the evidence should not ordinarily be made, particularly in the case of an acquittal appeal but if it is found that the judgment of acquittal recorded by the High Court was not justified on the evidence, it would be a travesty of justice for this Court to ignore this aspect and the circumstances may, thus, warrant that the exercise be performed.
15. We see that the case hinges on the testimony of PW 1 and PW 2. PW 2 was the wife of the deceased and the mother of PW 1. The prosecution story is that PW 3 had gone to a pilgrimage with his family and requested his parents to sleep in his house at night so as to guard the house and the accused, thinking that the person sleeping in the verandah outside the house was PW 3, attacked the deceased with a knife and killed him instantaneously. The fact that there had been ill will between the families of the deceased, particularly PW 1 and PW 3 on the one side, and the accused on the other is clear from the evidence of PWs 1, 2 and 3. It is also significant that the accused while running away had called out that he had killed PW 3 and would now kill PW 1. It is obvious that the intended victim of the attack was PW 3 and he managed to escape as he was not at home and his aged father paid the penalty on the mistaken impression of the accused. In this background, the evidence of PW 1 and PW 3, is completely trustworthy.
16. PW 2 stated that she had been sleeping beside her husband's cot in the verandah when she had heard a noise and had looked up and seen the accused attacking her husband and while she was looking on he had caused some additional injuries as well. It is also her case that her cries had attracted PW 1, whose house was at a distance of 25 to 30 yards from the house of the deceased and who had reached the place during the attack and had also attempted to catch hold the accused but he had pushed him aside and then ran away. For the High Court, therefore, to hold that PW 1 was not an eyewitness is erroneous.
17. We also see that the eyewitness account is fully corroborated by the medical evidence. The doctor, PW 11 who conducted the post-mortem had found several cut injuries on the face and neck of the deceased. They are reproduced hereinbelow:
“A cut injury of 0.5 cm below the nose extending both sides 1 cm below the lobule of both ears, size 30 cm × 5 cm, bone-deep, severing muscles, vessels, nerves and fracturing maxilla and mandible and roots of teeth.
2. A cut injury of 1 cm below upper lip extending up to angle of mandible on left side and up to the angle of mouth on right side, size 15 cm × 5 cm × bone-deep severing muscles, vessels, nerves and fracturing mandible and roots of teeth.
3. A cut injury over chin extending both sides, left side up to sterna mastoid muscle, right side up to the angle of mandible, size 25 cm × 5 cm × bone-deep severing muscles, vessels, nerves, fracturing mandible on right side. Brain and meninges; left caroled (sic carotid) vessels are cut; severed stomach contains partially digested rice.”
18. The violence and intensity of the attack shows that it must have taken place over a couple of minutes and it would not only have enabled PW 1 to reach the place of incident but also PW 2 to have properly identified the accused as he was also a resident of the same village. It is in the statement of PW 1 that his house was adjoining the house of PW 3 and it was, accordingly, possible for him to rush to the scene so as to give him the status of an eyewitness. As a matter of fact, in the cross-examination, there is no serious suggestion that he had reached the place after the incident and after the accused had run away and the broad suggestion is that the deceased had been killed by some unknown person as he had many enemies in the village and the surrounding area.
19. To our mind, therefore, as the eyewitnesses have fully supported the prosecution story, and the fact that the witness of the extra-judicial confession PW 9 or the recovery of the weapon, etc. did not support the prosecution, would not detract from their evidence.
20. We are also of the opinion that there is no delay in the recording of the FIR. It cannot be ignored that PW 2 had witnessed the murder of her husband and that too in a most brutal and blood-curdling manner as the evidence is that the injuries had led to a huge amount of bleeding. PW 2 was a lady of 75 years of age but she had nevertheless given the statement to the Village Administrative Officer at about 8 a.m and the information had been forwarded to the police station. If any delay occurred after 8 a.m it was a matter which was beyond the control of PW 2. In any case, in the light of the fact that information had been conveyed to the police station at 10 a.m of what had happened at 1 or 2 a.m in a remote village 7 km away from the police station, we are of the opinion that there was no delay in the lodging of the FIR and if there was some delay, it stood explained. In the face of unimpeachable evidence the late delivery of the special report by itself would do no great damage to the prosecution story.
21. We, accordingly, allow this appeal, set aside the judgment of the High Court and convict the respondent-accused under Section 302 IPC and sentence him to undergo RI for life and a fine of Rs. 100 and in default of fine to undergo SI for 15 days. The respondent-accused be taken into custody forthwith to serve out his sentence.
Alert