- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Atla Sidda Reddy v. Busi Subba Reddy And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The dispute concerns title to agricultural land in Cuddapah, Andhra Pradesh. In September 1988 the petitioner filed OS No. 735 of 1988 before the Third Additional District Munsif, Cuddapah, seeking a declaration of title and a permanent injunction against Defendant 1. On 29-11-1990 the trial court dismissed the suit, holding that the petitioner’s predecessor had no valid title.
The petitioner successfully appealed in AS No. 113 of 1990; on 26-3-1997 the First Additional District Judge, Cuddapah, decreed the suit in his favour. During that appeal Defendant 1 died, and Respondents 2-4 were substituted as his legal representatives.
The respondents then filed SA No. 656 of 1997 before the Andhra Pradesh High Court. By judgment dated 18-4-2007, a learned Single Judge allowed the second appeal, restoring the trial court’s dismissal of the suit.
The petitioner approached the Supreme Court via special leave petition (SLP). Despite service, the respondents did not enter appearance before the Supreme Court.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the registered sale deed dated 22-5-1968 (Ext. B-2) executed by Lakshmamma in favour of Thondolu Mahaboob Basha extinguished her title, thereby invalidating her later sale deed dated 10-5-1974 (Ext. A-1) through which the petitioner ultimately claims title.
- Consequently, whether the petitioner acquired any valid title to the suit property under his purchase dated 5-3-1984.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court confined itself to examining the concurrent factual findings of the trial court and the High Court. Both courts had treated Ext. B-2—the 1968 registered sale deed—as genuine and anterior to Ext. A-1 (1974). By virtue of Ext. B-2, Lakshmamma had already divested herself of all rights in the property; she therefore lacked capacity to execute Ext. A-1 in favour of Syed Ghouse Bi, from whom the petitioner derived title.
The first appellate court had discounted Lakshmamma’s testimony, but the High Court found her evidence credible and reinstated the trial court’s view. The Supreme Court saw no reason to disturb these factual conclusions, characterising Ext. B-2 as the “crucial document.” Because the petitioner’s chain of title depended on the later, invalid deed, his claim necessarily failed.
Finding no legal error warranting interference under Article 136 of the Constitution, the Court dismissed the SLP.
Holding and Implications
SLP DISMISSED.
The Supreme Court affirmed the High Court’s decision, thereby restoring the original dismissal of the petitioner’s suit. The outcome leaves title with the respondents and denies the petitioner injunctive relief. The judgment turns on factual appreciation of documentary evidence and sets no new legal precedent.
Altamas Kabir, J.— Despite service of notice, the respondents have not appeared to contest the special leave petition which is directed against the judgment and order dated 18-4-2007 passed by the Andhra Pradesh High Court in SA No. 656 of 1997.
2. In September 1988, the petitioner filed OS No. 735 of 1988 in the Court of District Munsif, Cuddapah, inter alia, for declaration of the petitioner's title to the plaint scheduled property and for permanent injunction to restrain Defendant 1 and his men from interfering with the petitioner's peaceful possession therein and enjoyment thereof. The Third Additional District Munsif dismissed the petitioner's suit on 29-11-1990, upon holding that the petitioner had failed to establish the title of his predecessor-in-interest in the suit land.
3. The petitioner preferred an appeal being AS No. 113 of 1990 in the Court of First Additional District Judge, Cuddapah which was allowed on 26-3-1997. The judgment and order of the trial court was set aside and the suit was decreed in favour of the petitioner.
4. It may be indicated that Defendant 1, Koppolu Subba Reddy died during the pendency of the appeal before the First Additional District Judge, Cuddapah and Respondents 2 to 4 herein were brought on record as his legal representatives. The respondents herein filed Second Appeal No. 656 of 1997 in the Andhra Pradesh High Court and the same was allowed by the learned Single Judge on 18-4-2007. The judgment and decree of the First Additional District Judge was set aside and the judgment and decree of the trial court dismissing the petitioner's suit was restored.
5. In order to appreciate the submissions of Mr A. Subbarao, learned advocate, appearing in support of the special leave petition, it is necessary to set out the facts of the case in brief.
6. According to the petitioner, the suit property belonged to Defendant 1 Koppolu Subba Reddy who sold the same to one Pasupula Lakshmamma by a registered deed of sale dated 19-7-1966. Lakshmamma, in her turn, sold the property to one Syed Ghouse Bi alias Chand Begum, a minor represented by her guardian and father Syed Ghouse, by a registered sale deed dated 10-5-1974 and the same was allegedly attested by Defendant 1 himself. Thereafter, Syed Ghouse Bi alias Chand Begum sold the land to the petitioner by a registered deed of sale dated 5-3-1984 and the petitioner is in peaceful possession and enjoyment of the said land in his own right since then.
7. The suit was resisted by the defendant by filing a written statement wherein it was admitted that the suit lands originally belonged to Defendant 1 who sold the same to Lakshmamma, but the said Lakshmamma sold all the lands, except Survey No. 93/6, to one Thondolu Mahaboob Basha, son of Dathagiri by a registered deed of sale dated 22-5-1968. Subsequently, Thondolu Mahaboob Basha sold two portions of the said land, namely, Survey No. 99/6 to an extent of 40 cents out of 52 cents and Survey No. 99/6 to an extent of 47 cents, comprising the suit land, to Pallampalli Pedda Veera Reddy by a registered deed of sale dated 17-5-1982. The defendant thereafter purchased the said two plots of land from the said Pallampalli Pedda Veera Reddy by a registered deed dated 7-11-1985. The defendant, accordingly, was the absolute owner of the said land and he has been in possession and enjoyment of the property since then.
8. In the light of the pleadings of the parties to the suit, the main issue which fell for decision of the trial court was whether the petitioner had acquired title to the suit properties by virtue of the deed of sale dated 5-3-1984 executed in his favour by Syed Ghouse Bi alias Chand Begum in view of the case of the defendant that Lakshmamma had already sold the suit property to one Thondolu Mahaboob Basha by a registered deed of sale dated 22-5-1968 (Ext. B-2). In other words, what the court was called upon to decide was whether Ext. B-2 extinguished Lakshmamma's right in the suit property so that she no longer had any right to execute and register the sale deed dated 10-5-1974 executed in favour of Syed Ghouse Bi alias Chand Begum.
9. The trial court came to the finding that in view of the registered sale deed dated 22-5-1968 executed by Lakshmamma in favour of Thondolu Mahaboob Basha in respect of the suit property, she was no longer competent to execute the subsequent sale deed in respect of the same property in favour of Syed Ghouse Bi alias Chand Begum through whom the petitioner-plaintiff claims title. The trial court thereupon dismissed the suit.
10. The first appellate court, however, chose not to rely on the evidence of Lakshmamma (DW 4), who in her deposition was not certain as to how the sale deed was said to have been executed by her in favour of Thondolu Mahaboob Basha as she neither knew him nor the scribe, who is said to have written the sale deed. The first appellate court held that the testimony of DW 4 Lakshmamma did not inspire confidence and, accordingly, discarded the same as far as the sale deed in favour of Thondolu Mahaboob Basha on 22-5-1968 (Ext. B-2) is concerned and relied on the subsequent sale deed executed in favour of Syed Ghouse Bi alias Chand Begum dated 10-5-1974 (Ext. A-1) and decreed the suit.
11. As indicated hereinbefore, the High Court accepted the evidence of DW 4 Lakshmamma and came to a finding that by virtue of Ext. B-2 she had transferred all her rights, title and interest in the suit properties in favour of Thondolu Mahaboob Basha and having divested her of the title to the suit properties, she was no longer competent to execute a further sale deed in respect of the same property in favour of Syed Ghouse Bi on (sic 10-5-1974) (Ext. A-1). The High Court having accepted the sale deed dated 22-5-1968 in favour of Thondolu Mahaboob Basha as being genuine, it came to the conclusion that since the said document was prior in point of time in relation to the subsequent document executed in favour of Syed Ghouse Bi, the petitioner-plaintiff, who had acquired his title through Syed Ghouse Bi alias Chand Begum, did not acquire any title to the suit properties. On such finding, the High Court reversed the judgment and decree of the first appellate court.
12. The factual aspect having been dealt with in detail by the courts below, ending in the findings of the High Court, we are not inclined to delve into the facts any further. As indicated by the trial court, Ext. B-2 is a crucial document and was admittedly anterior in point of time to Ext. A-1 subsequently executed by DW 4 in favour of Syed Ghouse Bi when she had already divested herself of title to the suit properties. The petitioner did not, therefore, acquire any title to the suit property and the suit was rightly dismissed.
13. Having regard to the above, the submissions advanced on behalf of the petitioner do not warrant any interference with the order of the High Court impugned herein and the same is, accordingly, dismissed but without any order as to costs.
Alert